Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
#
+
Judgment Reserved on: 30.07.2026
Judgment delivered on: 12.08.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 12.08.2026
CNR No. DLHC011015202024
RFA(COMM) 39/2025 & CM APPL. 46529/2025
ANUP KOTHIWAL
..... Appellant
versus
SINGHASAN PRASAD
.....Respondent
Advocates who appeared in this case
For the Appellant
:
Ms. Niyati Pathak, Advocate
For the Respondent
:
Mr. Rakesh Mittal, Ms. Yamini Mittal
and Mr. Ajay Harshana, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
JUDGMENT
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J.
1.
The present regular first appeal has been filed under Section 13 of the
Commercial Courts Act, 2015, [„Act of 2015‟] assailing the judgment dated
26.10.2024
[„impugned judgment‟]
passed by the District
Judge
(Commercial Courts)-05, South East District, Saket, in CS DJ NO. 144/2020
titled as Singhasan Prasad v. Anup Kothiwal [„Trial Court‟].
1.1.
Vide impugned judgment the suit filed by the Respondent for the
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
recovery of the amount of Rs. 9,02,686/- has been decreed in favour of the
Respondent along with interest at 10% per annum from the date of filing of
the suit till its realisation, along with the costs of Rs. 20,000/-.
FACTUAL MATRIX
The brief facts as set out in the appeal are as under: 2.
The Appellant engaged the Respondent in June 2017 to carry out
interior renovation work in Appellant‟s flat at M-67 Third Floor, Greater
Kailash-II, New Delhi („flat‟). The scope of work was settled vide e-mail
dated 03.07.2017 which included carpentry, electrical, plumbing, plastering
and painting. It is stated that payments were to be made progressively based
on the work completed.
3.
In July, 2017, Appellant shifted to a rented accommodation to enable
the Respondent to carry out renovation work in the flat. The Respondent
carried out renovation work thereafter until December, 2017. In
November/December, 2017, Appellant shifted back to the flat.
4.
According to the Appellant, the Respondent delayed the work
considerably and ultimately handed over the flat in an incomplete and
defective condition in November-December 2017, despite the agreed
completion date being October 2017. The Respondent raised claims for its
outstanding dues vide e-mail dated 12.12.2017.
5.
It is stated that the Appellant raised the defects in the work through an
e-mail dated 13.03.20181. However, in its reply dated 29.10.20182, the
Refer to printed page no. 147 of the appeal
Refer to printed page no. 149 of the appeal
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
Respondent acknowledged that certain snags may arise after handover and
offered to undertake repairs, while maintaining that the same could not
justify withholding payment.
6.
Thereafter, the Respondent instituted a suit seeking recovery of
principal amount of Rs. 9,02,686/- plus interest, which has been decreed by
the Trial Court in favour of the Respondent. Aggrieved by the said decree,
the Appellant has filed the present appeal for seeking to set aside the
impugned judgment dated 26.10.2024.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES
7.
Ms. Pathak, learned counsel for the Appellant, states that after taking
possession of the flat, the Appellant noticed that the interior work carried out
by the Respondent was incomplete and unprofessional.
7.1.
She states that the existence of defects and snags, in the work
executed by the Appellant, is evident from a conjoint reading of the e-mails
dated 13.03.2018 and 29.10.2018 exchanged between the parties.
7.2.
She states that the Appellant accordingly engaged an Architect on
12.02.2020 to inspect the flat. She states that the Architect has submitted an
estimate of a sum of Rs. 4,13,000/- towards rectification and repair of the
defects in the Appellant‟s work.
7.3.
She states that the learned Trial Court ought to have granted set-off
for this amount of Rs. 4,13,000/- from the principal amount of
Rs. 9,02,686/- found due and payable.
7.4.
Also, she submits that there are inconsistencies in the outstanding
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
amount demanded by the Respondent. In the e-mail dated 13.03.20183, the
Respondent claimed an outstanding amount of approximately Rs. 9.8 lakhs
along with taxes, whereas in the e-mail dated 29.10.2018, a demand of Rs. 8
lakhs were raised, and finally the suit was ultimately instituted for recovery
of Rs. 9,02,686/-.
7.5.
She contends that these inconsistent demands of the alleged
outstanding support the Appellant‟s case that the bills were not prepared in
accordance with the actual measurements at the site.
8.
In reply, Mr. Mittal, learned counsel for the Respondent states that the
measurement sheets were duly filed before the Trial Court and during the
admission/denial of the documents, the said measurement sheets4 have been
admitted by the Appellant.
8.1.
He states that the total bills were duly sent by the Respondent to the
Appellant through e-mail on 12.12.2017. He states that the bills were also
sent on 21.12.2017 to the Appellant‟s Architect Mr. Karan Kapoor, who
responded by e-mail dated 24.12.20175, marked to the Appellant and raised
an objection only with respect to the sum of Rs. 85,000/-.
8.2.
He submits that the total bills for a sum of Rs. 20,72,686/- was raised
by the Respondent upon the Appellant against which an amount of
Rs. 11,70,000/- was duly received from the Appellant. He states that
therefore the suit was filed for recovery of the balance principal amount of
Rs. 9,02,686/-. He states that these bills are based on the measurement
Refer to printed page no. 146 of the appeal
Refer to Ex- PW 1/3
Refer to printed page no 129 of the appeal
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
sheets.
8.3.
As regards the defects, he states that there was a single snag identified
by the parties which was a broken tile. He states that the Respondent had
offered to have the broken tile replaced, however, the parties differed as the
new tile was not available in the same pattern. This led to discord.
9.
In rejoinder, learned counsel for the Appellant submits that the bills
raised by the Respondent do not match with the measurement sheets filed.
She, however, fairly submits that this contention was neither raised in the
written statement nor put to the Respondent‟s witness during crossexamination and was advanced for the first time at the stage of final
arguments, before the learned Trial Court.
9.1.
She further submits that the Appellant does not dispute that some
amount is payable to the Respondent for the work carried out. She, however,
claims a set-off of Rs. 4,13,000/- as estimated by the Architect to be payable
towards rectification and repair of the defective work.
9.2.
She admits that no repair or rectification work has, till date, been
carried out at the flat by the Appellant after moving in NovemberDecember, 2017. In relation to the broken tile, she submits that its
replacement of the tile would require removal and relaying of the flooring of
the entire flat, thereby causing substantial inconvenience and expense to the
Appellant. She submits that the outlet of the drainage of the kitchen is
defective and cannot be restored.
9.3.
She states that the Appellant had genuine concerns regarding the
quality of the work executed by the Respondent.
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
9.4.
She further states that the entire decretal amount has been deposited
with this Court in compliance with the order dated 05.05.2025.
9.5.
Lastly, she submits that the award of interest at the rate of 10% may
be set aside given the genuine disputes between the parties, even if the Court
upholds the grant of principal amount.
ANALYSIS and FINDINGS
10.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused
the record.
11.
The following two issues arise for consideration in the present matter:
“1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree of a sum of
Rs.9,02,686/against defendant, as prayed for? OPP
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for any interest as claimed, if so,
at what rate and for what period? OPP.”
12.
Learned Trial Court has decided the Issue No. 1 in favour of the
Respondent and held that on the basis of the evidence led on record the
Respondent is entitled to recover a principal amount of Rs. 9,02,686/-, being
the outstanding amount due and payable towards the bills raised.
13.
The findings of the learned Trial Court are as under:
“14. Heard. Material perused.
It has not been disputed that defendant has engaged services
of plaintiff for renovation of his house no. M-67, Third Floor,
Greater Kailash-II. It is also not disputed that scope of work was
enhanced after it was initially assigned. The record further reflects
that defendant had engaged Mr. Karan Kapoor, Architect who has
prepared drawings etc. of property which are on record as part of
Ex.PW1/1. It is also not disputed that plaintiff used to correspond
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
with Mr.Karan Kapoor, Architect through email etc.
The plaintiff has filed copies of bills as Mark A and deposed
to the effect that total amount of all bills was Rs.20,72,686/-.
During cross-examination the witness has deposed to the effect that
he has calculated amount of Rs.20,72,686 on the basis of entire
work done and on the basis of entries made in account sheets
prepared in this respect. During lengthy cross-examination of this
witness, it is found that apart from putting mere suggestion that his
claim from defendant is incorrect and wrongly calculated, no
further explanation was called. There is nothing in the crossexamination of this witness which suggest that amount calculated to
the tune of Rs.20,72,686/- for the entire work done is not correct.
Further this witness has also brought on record the
measurement sheet as Ex.PW1/3 qua the complete work done
by plaintiff at the site. The measurement sheet has been
admitted by defendant in the affidavit of admission-denial.
One of the contention of Ld. Counsel for defendant is that
there is contradiction between the claim made by the plaintiff in
email dated 13.03.2018, part of Ex PW1/1 and claim made in the
present suit. In this respect, as pointed out by Ld. Counsel for
defendant, admittedly plaintiff in the email dated 13.03.2018 has
claimed total amount of Rs.21.0 lac and has, inter alia, further
mentioned in said email that he has received Rs.11.20 lac out of the
said amount and balance of Rs.9.80 lac has not been paid, whereas
in the present suit it has been mentioned that plaintiff has carried
out work of Rs.20,72,686/- out of which Rs.11.70 lac has been paid
but remaining sum of Rs.9,02,686/- has not been paid.
Now the question arises whether the said discrepancy
disentitle the plaintiff from the relief claimed in the present suit.
The answer to this query is in negative. First, on the ground that
claim made by plaintiff in the present suit is less than the amount
claimed in email dated 13.03.2018 and further that only on this
ground the plaintiff cannot be denied his legal recoverable amount,
if proved on record. Whether any claim of plaintiff stands proved
on record, or not, would be considered only after appreciation of
remaining evidence.
One of the contention of Ld. Counsel for defendant is that
there was some defect in work done by plaintiff i.e. in the outlet of
drainage of Kitchen, wooden cabinets and that certain tiles in the
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
drawing room and kitchen were damaged due to negligence of
plaintiff. But as matter of fact, the defendant has not taken any
action against the plaintiff on any of such lapses. He has not even
brought on record any notice, if any, issued to plaintiff calling upon
him to carry out necessary repairs or to complete the work etc.
However, the defendant has brought on record certain
photographs that there was certain defects in the work done by
plaintiff. The photographs on record are Ex.DW1/2 and the video
of spot in the pendrive is Ex.DW1/3. From the careful scrutiny of
cross-examination of DW1, it is found that this witness has
submitted to the effect that certain photographs were taken prior to
filing of the suit and certain photographs were taken subsequent of
the suit. However, from careful perusal of photographs Ex.
DW1/2 and video in pendrive Ex.DW1/3, it is found that there
is no substantial damage/defect in said photographs or video for
which the claim of plaintiff can be denied.
Further the defendant has examined DW-2 Mr.Arjun Sara,
Architect and Interior Designer to prove that there were certain
damages/defects in the property, which were not removed by
plaintiff.
In respect to testimony of DW-2 Mr.Arjun Sara, it is
found that during cross-examination of this witness, the fact came
on record that DW-2 is relative of defendant being husband of his
niece. In the examination in chief DW-2 has deposed to the effect
that he was approached by defendant in the month of February
2020 to carry out inspection of the site which he has carried out and
prepared report Ex.DW1/5. This witness has mentioned his address
of Jaipur, Rajasthan. Here the Court failed to understand as to why
the defendant had engaged architect from Jaipur, Rajasthan to carry
out inspection at Delhi. Even otherwise it is prerogative of the party
to engage any architect from anywhere, but there should be some
reason that why a particular architect has been engaged from far
place. Considering the entire facts and circumstances,
particularly the fact that this witness is related to defendant, it
cannot be ruled out that he is an interested witness and no
reliance can be made on his testimony. Moreover, the fact that
there are no substantial defects in the property has already been
held. Under these circumstances the contentions of Ld. Counsel for
defendant in this respect are found to be without any force.
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
One of the contention of Ld. Counsel for defendant is that
defendant is required to incur a sum of Rs.4,13,000/- for getting the
damaged/incomplete work completed. The said estimate has been
calculated by DW-2 in his report Ex.DW1/5. The testimony of
DW-2 has already been discarded as discussed earlier. Moreover, it
has also been found that defendant has not taken any legal action
against plaintiff before filing of the present suit. Even no counterclaim has been filed or set-off of the said amount has been claimed.
Under these circumstances, the plea of defendant in this respect is
found to be without any force.
One of the contention of Ld. Counsel for defendant is that
when plaintiff himself has mentioned in the plaint that he is weak in
English and accounts then how he can claim the exact amount in
this suit. On this aspect it is found that plaintiff has examined his
son as PW-2 who has deposed to the effect that he used to take care
of correspondences through email etc. and accounts of his father, in
respect to work done for defendant. The testimony of PW-2
remained un-controverted in this respect, hence, no good ground is
found to doubt the testimony of this witness and the plea of plaintiff
that his son used to take care of his accounts and other
correspondence with defendant. Therefore, it makes no effect on
the claim of plaintiff, even if, he is weak in English and Accounts.
In the light of above discussion, it is found that the plaintiff
has brought sufficient material on record that he is entitled for sum
of Rs.9,02,686/- from defendant. This issue stands decided in favor
of plaintiff and against defendant.”
[Emphasis supplied]
14.
The Appellant has reiterated the pleas raised by it before the learned
Trial Court. The first plea raised by the Appellant is that the claim of
Rs. 9,02,686/- in the suit is contrary to the demand raised in the e-mail dated
13.03.2018. Leaned Trial Court has already noted in the impugned judgment
that the demand in this suit of Rs. 9,02,686/- is lower than the demand made
in the e-mail dated 13.03.2018 of Rs. 9.8 lakhs plus taxes.
15.
Moreover, we note that the Respondent had duly placed on record all
the invoices (Ex. PW 1/2) raised by it, aggregating to Rs. 20,72,686/- and
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
after giving credit to the Appellant for a sum of Rs. 11,70,000/- already
received, the Respondent claimed the balance amount of Rs. 9,02,686/- only.
The invoices are based on measurement sheets (Ex. PW 1/3). The claim for
the balance sum of Rs. 9,02,686/- is thus founded upon the invoices
prepared based on the measurement sheets placed on record.
16.
The Appellant has been unable to rebut contents the invoices and the
measurement sheets, which constitute the primary basis of the Respondent‟s
claim.
In these circumstances, the alleged inconsistency in the demand raised
through the e-mails dated 13.03.2018 or 29.10.2018 does not persuade us to
interfere with the findings of the learned Trial Court.
17.
The Appellant has contended that it has received an estimate of
Rs. 4,13,000/- from an Architect i.e. DW-2 on 12.02.2020 for getting the
damaged/incomplete work at the flat repaired.
18.
In this regard, we note that the Appellant had examined an Architect
Arjun Sara as its witness DW-2. The learned Trial Court has discussed the
statement of the said witness and considering the close nature of relationship
between the said witness and the Appellant, discarded the testimony of DW2. The learned Trial Court declared that DW-2 is an interested witness being
husband of the Appellant‟s niece.
Moreover, with respect to the claim of Rs. 4,13,000/- the Trial Court
has noted that the Appellant has neither raised a counter-claim nor claimed a
set-off in the written statement for this amount.
19.
We find merit in the said finding of the Trial Court that the said
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
estimate of Rs. 4,13,000/- prepared by the DW-2 would not have any effect
on the claims of the Respondent, as neither has this amount been incurred by
the Appellant nor has any set-off been claimed on this account. Even if a setoff had been claimed, it could not have been granted because admittedly, the
Appellant has not incurred this expenditure.
20.
The interior work was undertaken in 2017, and the Appellant shifted
back to his flat in November/December, 2017. Despite the lapse of nearly
eight [8] years, the Appellant has not incurred the alleged expenditure for
carrying out any alleged rectification work at the flat, till date. Therefore, no
basis exists for permitting deduction of the said amount of Rs. 4,13,000/from the overdue amount of Rs. 9,02,686/-.
21.
Lastly, the Appellant has contended that there were certain snags
which was acknowledged by the Respondent in its e-mail dated 29.10.2018
and therefore it is entitled to set off for the estimate of rectification work to
be carried out. Learned Trial Court after examining the photographs and
videos produced by the Appellant has returned a finding that it does not find
any defect or damage in the flat. Moreover, as noted above the Appellant has
till date not carried out any rectification work in the flat. In these peculiar
facts there is no evidence available on record to quantify the value of the
alleged defective work. Therefore, no ad-hoc deduction can be made from
the principal amount of Rs. 9,02,686/-.
22.
In its grounds of appeal, the Appellant has alleged that it is entitled to
set off of Rs. 85,000/- as objected to by the Architect Karan Kapoor in its email dated 24.12.2017. We however find that at trial, Appellant has not led
evidence to substantiate the deduction of Rs. 85,000/- proposed by the said
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
Architect. In the absence of any evidence justifying the said deduction, the
said sum of Rs. 85,000/- cannot be deducted from the principal amount of
Rs. 9,02,686/-.
23.
Accordingly, we find no infirmity in the findings recorded by the
learned Trial Court in the impugned judgment dated 26.10.2024 awarding
the principal amount of Rs. 9,02,686/-.
24.
Learned Trial Court has awarded interest at 10% from the date of
filing of this suit till its realisation. The Appellant has sought waiver of the
interest liability. We however note that interest has been awarded only for
the pendente lite and future period. No interest has been awarded for the presuit period. In view of the fact that the transaction between the parties is
commercial, the rate of interest awarded by the learned Trial Court is
reasonable and just.
25.
We accordingly find no merit in this appeal.
26.
The appeal stands dismissed. Pending applications are disposed of.
27.
The registry is directed to release the decretal amount deposited with
the Court along with the interest accrued thereon to the Respondent within
two (2) weeks.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
AUGUST 12, 2026/msh/AJ
PRATAP SINGH
23:48:19
RFA(COMM) 39/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review