Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
- [ 32551
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO: 20711 OF 2016 & 8826 OF 2024
WRIT PETITION NO: 20711 OF 2016
Between:
1. Anumula Buchi Reddy, S/o. Linga Reddy @ Mallaiah, Aged about 45 years,
Occ: Agriculture, R/o. Nelojipalli, H/o.Kudurupaka, Boinpalli Mandal,
Karimnagar District.
2. Anumula Lachi Reddy, S/o. Linga Reddy @ Mallaiah, aged about 48 years,
Occ: Agriculture, Nelojipalli H/o.Kndurupaka, Boinpalli Mandal, Karimnagar
District.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana,, Rep by its Principal Secretary, Department of
lrrigation and Command Area Development, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad,
Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Karimnagar District, At Karimnagar, 3. The Special Deputy Collector,, LA Unit-Vl, SRSP (Sriram Sagar Projects)/
EFC(Flood Flow Cannel)/ Mid Manair Reservoir Project Dr.B.R. Ambedkar
Srujala Sravanthi Projects, LMD Colony, Karinagar District.
4. The Special Collector,, LA, Srirain Sagar Projects, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue a Writ or order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus declaring the action of the Respondents in not considering the proposals
of the Three Men Estimated Committee report Dt.26-1 1-2009 for payment of
compensation to the petitioners for acquiring the houses and structures while
extending the same benefit to other 209 structures and relying on the Agriculture
Finance Corporation Ltd., Hyderabad (AFC) valuation is illegal, arbitrary and liable to
be set aside and consequently direct the respondents to pay the compensation as
per the Three Men Estimation Committee proposals and in accordance with Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparence in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 201 3.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2016(WPMP. NO: 25395 OF 2015)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondent not to evict the petitioners from their Houses bearing No. 2-20, No.2-
35/B and 2-35lA total admeasuring to an extent of 860 sq. yards situated at
Nelojipalli, H/o. Kudurupaka Village, Boinpally Mandal, Karimnagar District, pending
disposal of the writ petition
l.A. NO: 1OF 2O17|WPMP. NO: 6546 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondents to pay the compensation to the petitioners as per AFCL report i.e., Rs.
37,56,6971- for the lands acquired without prejudice to the rights and contentions of
the petitioners raised in WP.No 20711 of 2016.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI P. RAJA SRIPATHI RAO, REPRESENTING
SRI B ARJUN RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: AGP FOR lRRl AND COMM AREA DEV
Counsel for the Respondents No.2 To 4: GP FOR LAND ACQUISITION
WP NO: 8826 OF 2024
Between:
Anumula Buchi Reddy, S/o. Linga Reddy alias Mallaiah, Aged 52 years, Occ.
AgricultUre, R/o Neetojipally Village, Bolnpalli Mandai Rajanna Sircilla
District.
Anumula Lachi Reddy, S/o Linga Reddy alias Mallaiah,
Aged 55 years, Occ,
Asricutture, R/o Neetojipaily vitLge, B"i;p;ili
M;;;;['Ru1"nn, Sircila District
.,.PETITIONERS
AND
1. State of Telangana, Rep.by its Principal Secretary Revenue (Land
Acquisition) Department, Secretariat, Tank Bund Road, Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Rajanna Sircilla Dlstrict, Collectorate Buildings, Sircilla.
3. Land Acquisition Officer and Special Deputy Collector, L.A., Unit- Vll, FFC
and MMR, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar PCSSP, Sircilla, Rajanna Sircilla District.
4. The Executive Engineer, lrrigation Division No.1 of lrrigation Circle-I, lrrigation
and CAD Department, L.M.D Colony, Karimnagar, Karimnagar District.
(Erstwhile Executive Engineer, Division No.4, IFFC-1, Rekurthy Road,
Kothapally, Karimnagar).
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus declaring the lmpugned draft Award vide File No. F 123812012,
Award No. 4512013-14, dated.31l12l2013 for an amount of Rs. 81,34,134/- which is
passed antedated/backdated and fraudulently under the provisions of Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 as illegal, arbitrary, violation of the principles of natural justice,
Article, 14, 21 and 300-4 of the Constitution of lndia and also in violation of principles
of natural justice, procedures and provisions of Act, 30 of 2013, settled principles of
Law and consequently set aside/Quash the draft Award vide File No. F123812012,
Award No. 4512013-14, dated. 31-12-2013 for an amount of Rs. 81,34,134/including all the consequential proceedings initiated if any, with regard to the H.No's.
2-20, 2-3514, 2-35lB situated at Neelojipally Village, Boinpalli Mandal, Rajanna
Sircilla District and consequently direct the Respondents herein to pass a fresh
Award under the provisions of Act, 30 ot 2013 with regard to the H.Nos. 2-2O, 2351A, 2-3518 situated at Neelojipally Village, Boinpalli Mandal, Rajanna Sircilla
District by taking into consideration of the estimations/valuations of structures
furnished by the three Men Committee constituted vide G.O. Rt. No. 917, dated.
26111 12009, lrrigation and CAD Department.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2024
Petition under Section 1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
Award
(Draft Award) vide File No F 123812012'
Award
lmpugned
the
of
operation
the,
passed by the 3rd Respondent herein
is
which
31t12t2l13
dated
No. 45/2013-14,
'1
pending disposal of the above Writ Petition'
under the provisions of Act, of 1894'
l.A. NO:2 OF 2024
in the
'151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
Section
under
Petition
to stay all
petition, the High court may be preased
aftidavit filed in support of the
File No'
lmpugned Award (Draft Award) vide
fu'ther proceedings subsequent to the
F123812012'AwardNo,45t2o13.14'daied.3lll2t20l3,initiatedoryettobeinitiated,
1 of 1894' pending
herein under the provisions of Act'
if any, by the 3rd Respondent
disposal of the above Writ Petition
SRlPATlll-RAO' REPRESENTING
SRI B ARJUN RAO
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI P' RAJA
GP !9L L+ND ACQUISITION
Counsel for the Respondents No'1 To 3:
FOEl[ry AND COMM AREA DEV
Counsel for the Respono"'Ilit'+' ICP
it'"'C.rJr"ae the following: CoMMoN ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF'TELANGANA AT
T{YI)[RATtAI)
'IIIh tIONOURAttI-1, SItl JUST'lCIl N.V.SI-IRAVAN KUMAR
WRIT PETITION Nos.20717 of 201.6 and 8826 of 2024
DATE OF ORDER: 25.08.2026
W.P.No.20711 of 201,6
Between:
Sri. Anurnula Iluchi llcr.1r.l r' ancl Anothcr
" ' Petitioners
AND
Thc State of Tciangana, rcprcscr.rtotl bv its Principal Sccretarv, Department oI
ln'r1;a[ron anrl Con.tr.l.r.tnt] Arca I)rrvclo l.r nre n t,
Sccrctariat 13uilrlin;1s, Saitab.r,-l, I Ii cicrabati .tn11 thrce (()3) olhcrs.
... Respondents
COMMON ORDER:
Heard Sri P.Raja Sripathi Rao, learned Senior counsel representing Sri
B.Arjun Ilao, learner{ counsel for the petitioner, Iearned Government Pleader
for lrrigation and learned Government Pleader for Land Acquisition. As the
pctjtiorlcrs in both the w,rit pctitions aro orlc ancl tho same and they are
a1;1;ricvcrl br lho aclion ol tlrt' rosponrlr'tt[: jtt ttoi p;ri'irt11 thc colt]pcnsaIion
krr accluiring thc houscs.rurl slru.ILlrcs lvhiclr catne unrler thc submergence
of thc Mici-Manair Resen,oir l)rojcct, both [hc rvrit pctitions arc taken up
together for analogous hcaring
W.P.No.20711 of 2016
2.
Facts giving risc to the filirr1,, ol this r,t rit petition are that the 1st
pctitioner clairns to btt lhc ort'ttt'r ol hor-rsc No. 2-20 antl house No.2-35/B antl
ihc 2rrr,l L)e titiolr(rr claitns to bt' tltt' ovvncr of httuso No. 2 35/ A, totallY
aclmeasuring ar1 extent of 860 sq.'",ds at Neelo;ipalli, H/O Koclurupaka
village, Boirrpalli manrlal, Kariurnagar I)istrict. Ihe Lxtcutivc linginccr,
l&C.,\Dof Nlitl \lanair I)ir isi.n 1\'.1 lr(, ( ircli: N. 1, Kt,thapall), Kanr.nnagar
fileil a requisition for acquisition oi lar-rcls, situatecl at Nr.elolipalli, H/O
Kodurupaka villa1lc, Boinpalli rlanrlal, Karirnrrallar clistrict. In pursuance to
the requisition rnacle br tlre 3rtl rosponrlent ancl after r:onducting survey bv
the concerned revenue offrcials, a clraft proposal was submitted under Section
4(1) of the Land Acquisitiorr Act, 1894 for acquisition of 584 houses situated at
Neeiojipallr', I I O. Korlurupaka vrllage, IJornl.allr. rnancial, Karimnagar
disllici, which canrc into thc suLrrncrgcnco of thc Mrtl N,larrair Rescr'oir
Project. The structur('s.f thc Pclitirrncrs r'crc n.rcntior.rccl rn thc saicl draft
t.totilication, antl aftcr. appror a1, thr- Lant{ Acquisition officer issuecl Form-lll
notice under Section 5A of the i-A Act, 1894 for conducting survev on
01.08 2009 and called lor objcctio.s
/ claims bv 01.09.2009. After c.nducting
inquirv, the 3rd respor.rdent submitted clraft declaratiorr under section 6 of the
Lanci Acquisition Acr, or.r 3.1 .12.2009. rhc draft proposals issueci unrler Section
.l(1) and Scction t., o1 tho l.i\ Act u'e r.t aPProverl anrl thc sulrstance
ol tho same
was publishotl in the localiir rrn l().ll l0()8 and (15.i)2.2(X)9 t.csfrccti\.ol\.. l.he
3r'd responclc'rr a.tl sur'c'or irspcctcrl tho l.nd suuctures u,der the
acqulsition to ascertai, fhc rnarket'alue accordrng to its utility. The lands
have been categorisecl as
:
L Dwelling area cor.ered witll sfuctures;
IL Open areas bef orc ancl surt our_rding
the stl.ucturcs
3.
A detailed inquiry was conductecl for assessing the value of the price
of the land and accordingly market value was fixed as Rs.254/- per sq.yd for
the dwelling areas. Further, for about 209 structures existing on the acquired
land which came under the submergence, it was necessitated to constitute a
three-man committee consisting of Executive Engineer (R&B Division),
Assistant Conservator (Forest), and Executive Engineer, DivisionJV, F.F.C"
Circle, Kothapally, Karimnagar to cstimatL. the value of the structures. The
committee also conducted social audit of valuation of estimates of the
structures and submitted report dated 12.06.2013 for each and every house
including petitioners' houses.
4.
The 3rd respondent while agreeing with the estimation value of the
structures in respect of 209 houses, has deferred the petitioners' three houses
and paid the compensation amount. The three-man committee in its report,
estimated the value of the petitioners' houses as Rs.63,43,000/-. However, the
Land Acquisition Officer / 3rd respondent tlid not agree with the three-man
committee estimates on the ground that the value of the structures were
estimated abnormally and referred the matter to the Agriculture Finance
Corporation Limited for re-verification of the estimated value of the three
houses of the petitioners. On such reference, the Senior Engineer of
Agriculture Finance Corporation furnished estimation value of the three
houses fixing the value for structures for Rs.37,56,697/ -. I'he 3rd responclent
relying on the valuation fixed by the Agriculture Finance Corporation
Limited, passecl an awarcl on 31.12.2073. The petitioners submit that they are
verv much in possession ol their houses ancl no compensation was
paid till
date and in view of the enactment of the Right to Fair Compensation
and
Transpalency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act' 2013'
are entitleci for fair antl just comPensation for the lands' houses'
structures
acquirecl for the public Purpose and other benelits as per the
provisions of
Act 30 of 2013 bv taking the three-man estimatiorr committee report
12.06.2013 on par t'ith othcrs. The petitioners thereafter made
dated
representations
on 10.03.2015 ancl 13 03.2015 for payment of compensation' fhe 3rd
responclent having acceptecl the three-man committee valuation
209 stmctures, denied the same and relied on the estimation
teport for
proposals fixed
by the Agriculture Finallce Corporation Lirnited Aggrieved by the same'
the
petitioners filed tire presenL writ petition'
5.
ln the grouncls ulgcd bv the petitioners, it is submitted that the 3rd
respondetrthasnotextendcdtirebenefitofvaluationfixedbythethree-marr
committee, but has extendecl the same to the 209 structures' which
is nothing
but cliscriminatory ancl r.iolation of principles of naburai iustice and that
the
Land Acquisrtion Officcr, though has initiatecl the land acquisition
proceeclings in 2009, has not taken the possession and not paid
compensation, tLrereiore, the acquisition proceedings are deemed to be
under the Act 1 of
.l8tl-1
the
lapsed
and tf the government w,ants to acquire the land, it
has to initiate fresh proposals for acquisition in accordauce with provisions of
tl.re Act, 2013 and tliat the pctitioners are entitled fot fair ancl justifiable
compensation for the house and structur.es acquired for the public purpose in
accordance with Act 30 of 2013
Counter Affidavit of Res pondent No.3
6.
Respondent No.3 filed counter and would submit that the erstwhile
combined State of Andhra Pradesh intended to construct a reservoir across
Manair river in between Kandikatpoor and Manwada villages and declared
project affected zone while noti{ving 12 villages coming fully and 6 villages
coming partially unrler subrnergence in Mid Manair Reservoir vide
C.O.Ms.No.69 I&CAD (MAG Irrigation-11, .A1 department) <late<I 06.04.2006.
For the said purpose an extent of Ac.15998-25 gts of land was requisitioned by
the Irrigation Department, out of which an extent of Ac.75757-26 guntas was
already acquired, awarded, and compensation was paid. Further under
submergence, 7150 structures were notified, out of which for 5648 structures,
awards were passed and compensation was paid till date on priority basis
(falling in seven villages).
7.
lt is further submitted that with regard to Neelojipalli village which is
a fully submergecl village under Mid Manair Reservoir, draft notifications
under Section 4(1) and clraft declaration under Section 6 of the Land
Acquisition Act were issued for acquiring Patta lands, structures in Patta
lands and Abadi lancls. It is further submitterl that the agricultural lands of
the village have been acquired vide consent award to an extent of Ac.3255
guntas and land compensation was paid in the year 2007-08, leaving a balance
of lancl covered by houses / structun:s in thc ',,illage for want of estimations
from the concerned eugrneering departmet-rt. The Executive Engineer, I&CAD
Irrigatron Department, Pedclapalli and his technical staff prepared the
detailed estimates of 58'1 structures/ houses of this Neeloiipalli / Kodurupaka
villago of Boinpaili N{anclal and furnished the estimations to the Special
Deputl, Collector. LA Unit-VIl, Karimnagar. Estimates rvere also served on
the inclividuals inviting objections fron-r the interested parties. Certain
objectrons over valuatiot1s l{eLe received, and in few cases, the individuals
represented that their house estimates have been valuated less and requested
for re-estrmation and sot-ne of the villagers filed complaints that for manv
houses. valuations Werc boostecl ancl dcmanded for re-estimation. 1n orcler to
have claritv and tlausparetlcv, it was clecided to entrust the work to the
Executrve Errgineer', DPEP, Karimnagar, who completed the detailed
estimation rt'ork and Iollvarded the estimations to the Special Deputv
Collector, LA Unit-Vll, LMD Colonl', Karimnagar. It is further submitted that
on the cletailed estimates of structures in Neelojipally village for the second
time also, manv cotnplai:tts ancl several adverse news items were published
in the neruspapers allcgirtg tarnpelirrg, forgelv, and alterations of the
valuation of estimates of the structures. Further, rvhen the officials of the
cortcerned Li\O,1SDC vrsited the villages to verily the estimates, it was
notici.-r1 that the ualuc ol the structutes are abnortnalll' boosted ancl in some
estimates, corrcctions, over''"vriting/ tampering of original types/Iigures of the
estimates ha'e bee^.oticed. similar complaints were made on estimation of
structures in ali the subn'.ergcd
' lages in MMR project. In view of the abor.e
discrepancy, a meeting was held by the Goverrunent on 26.08.2009 and a
decision was taken up for the social audit of the valuation of the estimate of
structures which are coming under the submergence of MMR project.
Thereafter, the Government issued G.O.Rt.No.917, I&CAD (PW.LA-IV R&R)
Department dated 26.-11.2009 and constituted a three-man committee to verify
the structure values under MMII submerged villages, so that any irregularity,
if committed, must be rectified beiore passing the awarcl under Section 11 of
the LA Act, 7894. Accordingly, estimations were sent to the three-man
committee for social auciit of the valuation of estimates of the struchrres of the
said Neelojipalli H/O Kodurupaka village of Boinpalli mandal, which came
into the submergence of the said MMR project.
8.
It is submitted tha! after receipt of the estimation values from the
three-man committee bv thc Spccial Dcpu tl Collcctor, L,A, Karimnagar, the
Xerox copies of the three-man committee estimates were served on the
individuals inviting objections, if any, from the interested parties. On service
of the copies of the estimates prepared by the three-man committee, one J.V.
Muralidhar Rao. President of Kodurupaka village (Boinpalli mandal), filed a
petition stating that the structures/ houses which are covered in the present
petition bearrng house No.2-20, No.2-35/ A and No.2-35/ B estimate values
have been abnormally increased wl-rilc valuating the structures and requested
not to pay the estimated value. Further, on verification of the detailed
estimates booklet for house No.2-20, it was noticetl that the estimates of the
structures were tampcred, and it was also noticcd that the valuation of
u
estimates of structurcs l^'ere altered. Irurther, the tluee-man committee
conducted social audit and corrected the estimation, but have not verified the
structures physicallv. Fttrther, the three-man committce report is also not
clear, and thele :ire corrections, alterations lt is further submjtted that, there
are fouL types of valucs in the leport of the three-r.nan committee, and it is not
clear as to which value should be adopted for payment of compensation.
Furtl-rer, basecl on the l'eport teceived from the three-man committee, the
SDC/'l,AO are paving the compeusation for those structures after being
satisfied with the valrte of the structures and leaving a balance in which the
SDC/i LAO and thc Special Collector was not satisfied with the reports given
b1 thc three-rnan committee, as there is a huge difference between the
amounts proposed bv the three-tnan cornmittee and the physical condition of
the houscs/ strlr c tures on spot, as such, the Director of Vigilance and
Enforcement has lakcn a sllo lrotu case basecl on the complaints and adverse
nelr's items rcported in the newspapers or-r the submerged villages of the
MMR project, inclucling Neelojipalli village. Tl-re Vigilance Department
pointed out irlegularities iu the estimations of the value of structures and
subr.rritted arr alcrt note No.176(12381V&ElE1 12010), dated 30 12 2011 to the
Govcmment, Revenue Department to stop paYments regarding compensation
for the sLructures in the villages r'r'hich are coming under the submergence of
thc N.lirl l\lana;r l-rojcct Irultlrcr', on lhe pht.sical verificatron of the
struc ture/ houses of Neerojipali vilrage, it was revearecr
structures/ houscs, incluclirrg trre three strucfures
that the varue of 26
of the petitioners, were
abnormally boosted by the three-man committee and as per the Government
orders, the entire responsibility goes on the shoulders of the SDC/LAO for
any excess payment and high payment made in the award, as they are the
competent authority to finalise the award and in view of the complaints on
the three-man committee report, the Special Collector, LA, SRSI'], l arnaka,
Hyderabad, bv letter NO.C2/2201/2013, dated 77.71.2073, requested
Government to give permission to entrust the work of valuation of estimates
to M/s Agriculture Finance Corporation, owned by NABARD. It is further
submitted that earlier in Sripada Yellampally Project, and in all other
irrigation projects of many districts, the valuation estimates of the structures
were prepared by the Agriculture Finance Corporation Limited. The
Government, zrlde Memo No.22283ILA-IV&R&R-1/07-6 clated 07.03.2008,
perrnitted the Distnct Collectors to entrust the work of valuation of estimates
to M/s Agriculture Finance Corporation Limited. Further, the Principal
Secretary to Government, I&CAD, AP, had permitted to entrust the valuation
of estimates of high values/low values in which the SDC/LAO is not satisfied
with the report of three-man committee to be re-verified by third-party
verification. Accordingly, re-estimation work of value of structures where the
LAO/SDC is not satisfieri with the rePorts fiivcn bv the three-man committee
was entrusted to Agriculture Finance Corporation in all the submerged
villages of the Micl Manair Project and in the case of Neeloiipalli village,
re-estimation work of 26 structure/ houses was entrusted to Agriculture
FinanceCorpolationl-inritedforre-verificationoftheestimatedvalueofthe
26 structures, inclurl irrg thc petitiorers' three houses
9,
The respondent furthel submits that the Vigilance
report on three-man
committee nf1g1 "'grification of estimates of the structures
and alter
scrutiuizing, the follot'rng observatious were rnade by the
Vigilance
Department:(i)Tlratthecommitteedidnotfollowtl.reguidelinesstipulatedirr
G.O.N{s.No. 291 Irrigation (PW) Departrnent dated 05
08 1982; (ii) That the
Water supply'
committce'Le-cc,tttlt-ttllt.1ct1 10o"i extra towarcls Sanitatron'
Electrification ancl othcr misceilaneous items without ar-ry guidelines
Government; (iii) ThaL the cornmittee randomly decreased
from the
the teak woocl
quantrtv ctc. lt is further submitted that the Vigilance and Enforcernent
Department, bv their' letter No RVEo IKNIEW-1721201'5'/7'
dated 01 03 2016'
caller-l for the inJormation pertaining to the compensation
of the houses in
Neelojipallvl-illaqeofKar.imnagar.distr.ict'TireLAo/SDCsubmittedrecords
totht.VigilarrccDePal-tnlentbrletterNo.F/128/2016,c1ated16.03.2016,and
they are in thc custodv of the Vigilance Department
]0'Itisfurllrersrrbnrittecltl-rattlreSeniorEngineer,AgricultureFinance
Corporation, I-lr tlerabail, iurnishecl the cletailed estirnation
values and the
estimation values preparecl b"v the three-man committee for Rs
63'43'000/ -
was rcduced as per the estimatjon value prepared by the AFC (Agriculture
Finance Coryroratror.r, I lr clr:rabatl) to a tunc of Rs.37,56,69U - and that the
esti,atior-rs p.epared br- the Agriculture l,-inance Corporation, Hvderabad,
was founcl reasonablc, as srrch, the estimation values preparecl bv the
Agriculture Finance Corporation' Flyderabad'
It is further submitted that notices wcre
were taken into consideration'
issued uncler Section 9(1) and 10 of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894' and same
Panchayat inviting claims and objections
were published in the Gram
from the interested persons lt is
inquiry'
further submitted that, during the award
agreed to receive the structure compensation
Finance Corporation ancl requested
the petitioners have not
as estimated by the Agriculture
to adopt the valuation estimates
petitioners have not executed the
by the tfuee-man committee As such' the
agreement in Form-llI antl lV untlcr
Section.l l(2) rea'i witl.r Section 31(2)
the LA Act for passing the consent award
award under Section 11(1) of the LA
under Section 11(1) of ttre LA Act'
prepared
of
and requested to pass general
Act Hence' the award was passed
'1894 on 37 '72 2073 and a notice under
'
Section 12(2) was issuecl to the petitioners
on 06 01 2014 to attend the office of
the Special Deputy Collector' LA' Karimnagar'
to sign on the acquittance rolls
withinaperiodofsevendaystocrec]ittlrecompensationpayabletothemin
their bank account. It is further submitted
turned up to receive the award amount'
that since the Petitioners have not
the amount was kept in the revenue
deposit and would be paid to the Petitioners
as and when they approach
the
Land Acquisition Of(iccr'
11- It is further submittecl that the construction of R&R
progress with all infrastructure and civic
tl-rey will be shiftecl to R&l( colonics'
colonies is under
amenities' and once thev are ready'
anc'l thev are not Permitted
submergence areas- It is further submittccl
to live in the
that sirrcc the possession of the
land lr.as takcn or er anrl haudecl over to thc requisition department, the
subjer t Iarrds '. t'sis r.r'ith thc GovenrncnL lt'itlr all eucumt,rances ancl since the
ar,r'ar,.l has bet,n passccl ancl posscssion has been taken under the Land
Acqu isition r\ct, 1894, thc ;rrovisions of the IiFCTLARR Act, 2013 ale not
appli, .rblt' to tl'l(' :1('t iti('ll('r\' ( d5c.
72. lt is furthcr submrttccl that the petitioners houses/ stluctu res awarcl
was passecl undcl Sectiort 11 (1) of the LA Act on 31.12,2013 duly awarcling
o,6 ancl 15o,i, intcrest from the clatc
of taking over possession, j.e., from
04.01.2()12. It is turthcl subrnittccl that if the petitioners are aggrieved with the
quillrtunl of co rn l.rcr-rsa lion iireil bv the LAOISDC, they can approach the
Civil Court bv liling pctitron before the L.,\O/SDC under the Act for'
enhancement ()l (ompens.)iron. I)rc respondents submit tl-rat the \\,rit petitioll
is clevoid of r.ncrits and evcntuallv pray to dismiss \{.P. No.20711 of 2076.
W.P.No.8826 ot 2024
13.
['he pct itior.rcrs
aggrievcrl bv the inrpugnt'cl draft au'arcl file
No.F,r23Bl2012, .rn,arcl No..l5l2013-14, dated 37.12.2013 for an amount of
Rs.Bl .11,13-1/- (Rupees Lightv one Iakl-rs thirtl four thousand oue hundreci
and lhirtr ic,rrr onlr), x'hich n'as P.rssed an terta tccl/ bac kt{ated fratrclulentlr
unrler the provisions ot thc I-and Acquisition Act, 1894 and also in violation
of tht. procerlurc,s ancl provisions of Act 30 of 20'13 with regard to the
nrocc, (iir)B\ rlrilr.rtt,d It,r. Itouse NoS.2_20.
Neeloiipalli vilJage, Boirrpa[i Mardai,
the facts statecJ irr h'.I,..r"..o.2071i/
2-35/ A,
2-35/B situated at
Rajanna sirci]ra district. In acrdition to
2076, the petitioners woulci subrnit
that
preliminary notification under Section 4(1) ancl Section 6 declaration with
respect to the petitioners' houses were published in AP Cazette vide SRP 039
datecl 19.12.2008 and SRP 058 dated 37.72.2009 (as per award) and the date o{
publication of draft notification and draft declaration under Section 4(1) and 6
of the Land Acquisitior-r Act,.l89-l w'ere reckoned as 29.12.2008 and 05.02.2009
respectively. It is further submitted that the publication of Section 6
declaration in Andhra Prabha newspaper, was published on 28.12.2008,
whereas in the award, it is mentioned that the declaration is published in
State Gazette on 31.12.2009 and was reckoned as 05.02.2009, which are
contradictory in nature and also in violation of Land Acquisition Act, 1894. It
is further submitted that in the instant case, the possession of the lands as
well as structures were taken into possession on 04.01.2012. However, no
opportunity for filing objections to the notification were given, and the
possession of the houses was taken onlv after three years of publishing the
declaration. The petitioners subrnit that their houses were surveYed,
estimated, and valued by the engineering authorities twice at the first
instance, thereaf ter, the State Government/ Irrigation & CAD Department
issued G.O.Rt.No.917 dated 26.17.2009. Basetl on the three-man committee,
the 3rd respondent/LAO passed award and compensation was awarded for
three houses as per the estimates submitted by the three-man committee, and
the said draft award was passetl inclucling Form-[ll under the old Land
Acquisition Act, 1894, and the compensation amount was awarded for three
houses to a tune of Rs.1,29,22,241/- (Rupees One Crore Twenty Nine Lakhs
1+
Trventy Two - rousatrd lwo Flundred arrd Forty Four only), dated
Nil-12-2013. It rs further submitted that the 3rd respondent had also
aclct essed a letter .rlong u'ith lion.n-lll to the Superintending Engineer,
Irrigation, IFFC 1, N'llVlR Circle, Dl-rarur camp, Jagtial, by letter dated
12.01.2014 recluesting to rccommend the case to the Chief Engineer (Projects),
I&( \D [)t'p.rrtnt'nl, l\lD Colonr., Karilrlragar, for issuance of I-OC for atl
amount of Rs.1,29,22,24'l/-. The 4th respondent itr tutn addressed a letter
along rvith staternerlt to tJre Superintending Engineer, IFFC, Circle-1, Dharur
camp, Jagtial, Lrv lcttcr clated 13.03.2014, for issuance of LOC for thc said
amount. Thcrcaiter, thc Superinter-rcling Enginecr also addressed a letter to
the (lhref Engincer on I1.03,201-1 recluesting for issuance of LOC for the said
am()unt. The sard inforrnation lvas obtained bir the petitioners from the 4th
rcsponcleni br vtav ol tiling an application under RTI Act, 2005. The
petitioners also rt'ft't to the various communications between the 3rcl
rcspo:rdent anc{ ll.rc lrrigation Deparhnent, and r,r'ould submit that as per the
saicl corrcspontlcncc, the 3rc{ respoudent has addressed a letter to the
Assistant Par' & Accounts Officcr, lVorks & Projects, Karimnagar, requesting
to jssue author-isrttion for Lanc] Acquisitior-r Paylnenls for an amount of
lr,s.1 ,29,22,211,t- ;rt,r'tainir.rg to the pc'titioners colnperlsation.
The pctitioners
[urther subrnil that though att au,arcl 1""'as passed for an amount of
11s.1
,2t),22,211i-, the 3rc1 resl-ronrlcnt again got estirnated and valuecl the
alro'e.-mc.tioneri thrt,e houses/ s truc tu res w,ithout issuing anv notice to the
pctitioners a.11 r'r'itrr the assistance. of Agricurturar Finance
Corporation
Limited, NABARD, Hyclerabatl, harl reduced the valuation of the house
estimates and passed anotl-rer draft award vide File No.F / 238/ 20-12, Award
No.45/2013-14 dated 37."12.2013 for an amount of Rs.81,34,134l- under the
old Land Acquisition Act, 1894, which was revealed to the petitioners under
the RTI Act, 2005. The petitioners further submit that the 3rd respondent has
passed the second draft award so as to avoid the payment of compensation
under the new Act 30 of 2013, which came into force on 01.01.2014, which is
more beneficial to the land oustees when compared with the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 and that the second award dated 31,.1,2.201,3 passed for
an amount of Rs.81,34,134/- is antedated/ backdated, passed behind the
petitioners' back bv plavrng fraurl. Ihc pL'titioncrs prat' to quash or set aside
the said award dated 37.72.2073 as thev are entitled for payment of
compensation under the provisions of Act 30 o( 20-13.
1,4. Respondent No.3 filerl atlditional counter affidavit dated 02.07.2025
and would submit that notification under Section 4(1) of the Act, 1894 was
issued on 79.72.2008 by the Special Collector, SRSP, Hyderabad vide
proceedings No.D3/3584/ 2008-.1 dated 28i12.2008 and the substance was
published in the locality' on 29.72.2008 and declaration by file
No.D3/3584/ 2008-2 dated 22.12.2009 and the substance in the locality was
published on 05.02.2009. The submissions made in the additional counter are
similar to the submissions made in the counter filed in W.P.No.207"11/2076.1r
is further submitted that the Petitioners, after a lapse of about eleven years
from the date of award, have filed the present writ petition, and thus the
pctrLiolers case ts llit br delat ancl laches and misl ePresenta tion of facts. And
that W.P.No.20777 /201,6 u'ith similar plea in respect of the same subject
f ro l,crl\ is I't'ntlinl.
15. A Repii to acltiitional courlter affidavit u'as filed by the petitioner on
03.07.2025. I hc petr tioncr subrnits tha t the responclent No.3 was silent with
respoct to tht'groultds r.risecl bv the petitioners rvith regard to the passilrg of
the inrpugni'tl cirait .rrvard bv trile No l'/23812012, Aivard No 45/ 2013-1,4
datccl 31.12.2()11, rvhich is a tlratt award passctl in antedated/ backdatecl
uncitrr the I-.rr-rcl AcqLrisrtion Act, 1894. Further, as per Section 11-A of the
Lantl Acqu isition i\ct, 189'1, thc Land Acquisition Officer shall make an
arvarcl undcr Section ll of thc Act, 189'1 w'ithin a pi.riod of two vears from the
datc of pulrlrcatron ol tlte declaration, and if l-ro au'ard is passed within that
puriori, tJ.re crrlire Iarrtl actlursition proceetlirrgs for the saici larrt1 shall lapse. In
thc irlstant c.rse, thc pLrlrlicatiotr of the declaration under Section 6 of the Land
AcqLrisition ,\ct, 189-l ',''as recorclecl on 05.02.2009, and the respondent No 3
or.rgirt to h;rr c passerl .trtat.l ttrttler Sectior-r 11 of the Act, 189'l bv 0'1 02 2011
ar.rc1 tlrat thc' responrlcrrts failed to pass the arvard by 04.02.2017 as such the
lar,d acquisition proccctlings l.rave lapsed thereafter, and without passing an
ar",arcl, the .rr,rthoritics have taken possession of the subiect properties on
0.1.01.2012. Srncc lhe proceedings have lapsecl, the respondent authorities
ougirt to har.. initiatc.l iresir accluisition proceedirrgs in accordance with law.
Tho petitio.e r- furLIr.r quL.stiolrs that when an award was passed on
31 1:'201.r r()r .rn ,r'r)()unt or ns.g1,3{,13r/-, lht: responcrent
No.3 has
addressed a letter to the authorities of Irrigation DePartment on 72.03.20'14
stating that the draft award has been approved by the Special Collector, LA,
SRSP, SSP & JCRGLIP, Tarnaka, to an extent of 860 square yards for an
amount of Rs.7,29,22,2411/ - ar-rd requestcel to recommend the case to the Chief
Engineer, Projects, I&CAD Department, for issuance oI LOC for an amount of
Rs.7,29,22,244
/-. It is further submitted that when respondent No'3 has
passed awarc-l on 31.12.2013 for an amount of Rs.81,34,134/- for the same
subject three houses, the respondent No.3 has again addressed a letter to the
lrrigation Department on 12.03.2014 and 72.06.201'4 seeking to provide an
amount of RsJ,,29,22.244/ - for the PaYment of compensation in respect of the
verv same subject three houses enclosing Form-lll statements. Further, be{ore
passing the award, notices under Section 9(1) and 9(3) of the Act, 1894 were
issued on 16.03.2012 a nd were served on the concerned, but the award shows
that there is no mention of date with regard to the commencement of the
award inquiry ancl conclusion of the said inquiry was shown as Nil-Ni1-2013,
which is onlv a mere exercise on paper, which is void. The Petitionels furthel
submit that the Agriculture liinarnce Corporation [.imitecl has no jurisdiction
for preparation of valuation estimates of the subject houses for the reason that
the subject acquisition is for construction of an irrigation projec! which is a
State Government Project and the Central Covernment has no say in the said
irrigation project. It is further submitted that after passing the award in
respect of the subiect houses, the petitioners were called to receive the
compensation by notice datecl 06.01 2014- For non-receipt of the
c()nlpcnsa trorr., tho ntatter lras been referred to the senior Civil Judge at
Sircilla unllcl Stction 30 of Act 1 of 1894 bv file No F/ 23812072 daled
09.03.2t11t1 ancl tho .t'"r'artl cot r.tprensa tion oI Rs 81,34,134/- was dePosited in
tir(' alro\'('-rncntiorrL'tl c(rurt bV rheque No. 211273, dated 08 03 2018 Further,
tlre petitioncr carr(, to knon' that the reference made on 12.03.2018, vide C.F.
I..\op No. 220 /2018 rr.as returned on 14.05.2018 with celtain office obiections
taken br. thc Senior (-ivil Jutlge at sircitla, anrl thcreafter thc 3rd respondent
has not iaken anr steps to resubmit the same bv complf ing with the
objections bcforc the saicl court. The petitioner further submits that the
rcspontltr-rt No.3 cannot pass a draft award/f;rir award without there being
[unds at hrs clispr-rsai ior the rlisbursement of the same to the landorvuers. lhe
prrtitioncr fulther subrnits that the possessiorl of the subiect property was
taken on 0{.0i.2011 r'r'ithout conducting arvaltl inquiry, without passing an
arr,.rrci, a nti rvitltout pa\ mcltt of compensation, and that the action of the
atrthoritics in taki|S ;rossessiou prior to the co:rclucting of award incluiry and
sLrLrsequc'ntlv passine oi arvard is illegai, arbitrarl', ancl in violation of
plovisiorrr Lrl ,\ct I rrl 1tl9-t arrd r\ct 30 o[ 2013
l(,.
r\n .rd.lilion.ri coulltcr rvas filcd bt' respondent No.3, rciterating lhe
same submis-cions marle iu the counter filecl earlier' Tl-re respondent No.3
frrrtlrer srrhmifs tl.rat 1ro .1$'arLi rvas passecl lor an amottnt of Rs7,29,22,214/',
and therc i5 np apprroval ior the said arvard amount and while referring to the
It'tters atltllt,ssetl fo the iuigatrop authorities and on pcrusal of the OffiCe
reL'ords, a It'*r'r iili.rr [,r one ].v. N4uralidhar
R.r. r,r,as found, filed before the
Special Collector, Hyderabad, alleging that the SDC Shankar Rao had
enhanced the house compensation abnormally to the houses of the petitioners
and that the petitioner Anumula Buchi Reddy was a middleman and a letter
bearing No. C2/3282/2013, dated 07.77.2013 was issued to SDC by Special
Collector, LA, Tarnaka to offer remarks on the complaint and to appoint any
other officer for further inquiry in the rnatter. Meanwhile, the SDC entrusted
the Agriculture Financc Corporation l-imitccl to re-vcrifv the above structures
and submit estimates and on the basis of the estimations furnished by the
Agriculture Finance Corporation Limited, an award was sent for an amount
of Rs.81,34,134/- for approval of Special Collector, Hyderabad, ancl for the
said amount only, the Special Collector, Tarnaka has approved and that
inquiry will be conducted and after approval from the higher authorities, if
any fraud is found, action will be initiatecl against all concerned officers. The
respondent pra)' this Court to uphold the award bearing No.45/2013-14, File
No.F / 238 / 2012, datetl 31.1 2.2013 f or Rs.81,34,134l -.
'1,7. An additional reply affidavit was filed by the petitioner reiterating the
same submissions made in the reply. The petitioner submits that on a perusal
of the letter dated 14.09.2013 filed along with the additional counter afficlavit,
it is shown that there is no signature of ihe said J V. Muralidhar Rao, which
itself speaks that thc saitl lctter is rrot genuine ancl is a false letter. It is further
submitted that two awards in respect of the subject three houses were passed,
one for an award amount of Rs.1.,29,22,244/-by File No.F/23812012, Award
No.Nil/ 2013-14 datecl Nil-12-2013, and another award for an amount of
Rs.tt1,34,134/- bv Irilc No.l-l238/2012,,\w.rrd No.45/2013-14 tlatet{
31.12.2013 anrl that n() irlquirv has been conducted on the officials and officers
sincr: 2013-1-1. arcl evontuallv prat' to allow the lr,:'it Petition
SUBMISSIONS
1u.
The learnecl Scnrol Counsel, Sri Raja Sripathi Ilao appearing for the
petitiuners, rr,ould submit that the rnain grievancc of tht: petitioners is that the
conrpensation .rt,.rrtlctl to petitioners lantl bcing acquirecl untlet' the
irnpugned au ar rl w'as rerlucecl frorn about Rs.7,29,22,214 / - to Rs.81,3.1,134/acqu ired for the' proposecl construction of Mid Mar-rair Rcservoir
/ Irrigation
Projr:ct effectirrg th(,agricultural lands and hotrses situated in various villages,
arrcl the sul-rlect vi1la1lc br nanre Ncelojipalli, H7() Ko.{urupaka village was
nrrtilied as a fullr suL,mergerl r'illage in r.vhich petitioners' houses were
rcquisitionecl at Sl.Nos.179, 19.1 and 192. Pursuant to the requisition of
rL-sp()ndL'r1t \o.1, r't'sPonrlcnt
\o.i issuecl Scction {(1) rrotification published
in AP Gazette No.SI{l'039 datcil 19.12.2008 and cleclaration notification was
issuocl under Sectiorr 6 of Act I of 1894 and publishecl in AP Gazette No.SRP
058 tlatecl j1.12lixlg, ancl the !rotiti()r1crs' houses are rt:flectec1 at Sl.Nos.179,
.19-l
arrd 192. I'ht, possession of the subject houscs was taken on 04.01,2012
Thc (lovernment o.rrliL.r issued C.O.Rt.No.917 constituting a three-rnan
c(\minittL.e iot.corrrluctrrrg social aurlit of valuatirrn estilnates of sttuctures in
n'hi< h the petlti.r.rc.s' houscs wcre also put kr verification by the three-man
c()m'11tt('e, ancr trrc.c.rftor trle corlmittee
sublnittecl a repori to r.espondent
N..3 b_,,, letter ciatocl il.0(r.20i3 recommending'aluation
of House No.2_20 as
2t
Rs.20,64,000 / -, House No.2-35 / A as Rs.21.,29,000/ - and House No.2-35lB as
Rs.21,50,000/- for passing of award and payment of compensation. Learned
Senior Counsel submits that basing on the cstimates furnished bv the
three-man committee, respondent No.3 passed award by File No.F/238/2012,
Award No.Nil/ 20-13-74 dated Nil-12-2013 for the subject three houses
totalling an amount of Rs."1,29,22,244/-, ancl the same was approved bv the
Special Collector, Hyderabad and forwarded to the Superintending Engineer,
Irrigation, Jagtial, who in turn addressed a letter to the Chief Engineer,
Irrigation, Karimnagar seeking release of Rs.7,29,22,244 / - by enclosing
Form-lll.
79. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that similar letters were
addressed by respondent Nos.3 and 4 to the Superintending Engineer,
lrrigation seekir-rg release of Rs.1,,29,22,214/ -. On 11.06.2014, respondent No-3
addressed a Land Acquisition letter to the Assistant Pay & Accounts Officer,
Works & Projects, Karimnagar, requesting to issue authorisation for Land
Acquisition payments for an amount of Rs.7,29,22,2M / -. Learnecl Senior
Counsel further submits that though the award was passed for the subject
three houses, respondent No.3 again got estimatecl the value of the subiect
three houses without issuing anv notice to the petitioners with the help of
Agriculture Finance Corporation, NABARD, IJyderabad, anrl reduced the
valuation of houses estimates and passed another impugned award in an
antedated/backdated manner by File No.F 1238/2072, Award No.45l2013-14
cla tecl 31.12.2013 for an amount of Rs.81,34,134/-
/
under Act 1 of 1894 for the
subject three houst's. Learnetl Senior Counsel n'ould submit that the verr'
same officer, i c., responclct-tt No.3, had passcd two awards - one for
Rs.1.29,22,2411- and anolher antedated/ backdated for Rs.81,34,134/- passed behir-rcl Lhr: back of the petitior-rers for thc subiect three houses and
furthcr subr.nits lhat rvhcn rcspondent No.3 had passecl the impugned award
dated 31.12.2013 fol Rs.81,34,134/-, responde;rt No.3 did not substantiate on
rr.hat Lrasis he .rrltlressetl lcttcrs to thc Irrigatioll Department authorities on
12 ()l 201{ arrcl l2.()6.2014 sct'king to pror,idc an .rnloutlt of Rs7,29,22,2111-
for pal'ment of compeusation in respect of the ven' same subject three houses
by r.nclosing Folm-lll statctnellts. Learncd Senior cortnsel would submit that
in llrt: counter, tro subtnissit)ns lvcre tnacle ot.t thesr: aspects and further'
subrnits that thc ('cntral Govermnent through Ministry of Rural Development
hacl issued Gazottt' Notif rcation No. S.O.3729(E) appoirrting 01.01.2014 as the
datt, on which tht' nerv Act 30 of 2013 came into force and that as per Section
1.t-..\ of tl.re l-anil ,'\ct1u ist tt or.t Act, 1891, tllc responclen: is bouncl to make an
award under Sectron 11 of the Act, 1894 within a period of two years from the
datt of prublication oi cleclaration, and if no art'artl is made n'ithin that period,
thc r:ntire proctcrling tor the acquisition of lant1 shall iapse. Learned Serrior
courrsel rvould submit tl-rat in the instant case, as Per the irnpugned arvart1,
the publicatron of cleclaratiou was recorded as 05.02.2009, then the award
ouglrt t() har r. [rr'r,r.r pass(,(l L]\ 01.02.2011 ancl cven if the latest date oi
pubJitation of rlt'claraIi.rr rs takerr into co.sideration, i.e., 31.122009,
lesfrorlderll No..l ought to har.e passed the award b1
30.12.2011. Learned
Senior counsel would submit that the land acquisition proceedings have
already been lapsed in the instant case, therefore, the question of passing an
award clated 31,.72.2073 is barre,cl in law. I:urthcr, the petitioners have already
filed W.P.No.2O717 /20116 seeking to Pay comPensation as Per the three-man
cornmittee recommendations / proposals dated 72 06 2013' The learned
senior Counsel further draws attention of this Court that in the counter filed
by respondent No.3 in W P.No.20711/ 2076, and would submit that the
counter affidavit is completely silent on the aspect of passing of award by File
No.F/238/2012, Award No Nil/2013-14 dated Nil-12-2013 for
Rs.-1,29,22,244/- for the subject three houses, and is also silent on the
asPect of
Section 11-A of Act 1 o11894. Further, even as Per the impugned award
31.12.2073, the awarcl is passecl onlv for dwelling area
dated
I plinth area of each
house, and no award is passed as on date with regard to the open area
covered lor each house, though the structure, dwelling area / plinth area
and
open area of all three houses are notified in AP Cazette No SRP 058 dated
31.72.2009 and tl-rat the Lantl Acquisrtion Act did l-rot contemplate
passing of a
part award and deferring part of extent, thereby, the impugned award is in
clear violation of Section 11(1) of Act 1 of 1894 Learned Senior Counsel
further draws attention to tllc counter filecl by respondent No 3 stating that
after lapse of about eleven years, the present writ petition is filed and on
the
aspect of lapse, the petitioners relied on the juclgment of the Hon'ble
Apex
Court reported in Urban Improvement Trust v Vidhya Devi & Ots'
(2024
SCC Online SC 3725)
20.
I-earned Scnirrr Counsel further draws attention to the statement
shorvrnll thL. re(luisilr()u ol L()(l uncler thc hcatl ol account and refers to thc
file and date in u'hich c{rait au'ai-d was subrnitted, i.e., File No.F/238/2012
dated Nil-12-2013 lor a draft arvard arnount cl Rs.1,29,22,244/ - signed bv the
Exettrtive Engireer, [)ir ision No..l, IFFC-I. Learned Sr.nior Counsel submits
that the draft notific.rtion uncler Section 4(1) was passed on 19.12.2008 antl
subsLrnce in the localitv vr'as publisl-red on 29.12.2008, and draf t declaration
undcr Scction 6 r.r'.rs passecl on 05.02.2009, and would submit that the date of
pubJication of clrafi r.rotrlicatiorr ancl dlaft cleclaration under Section 4(1) ar-rd 6
ot the I A .\ct rr'erc rcckouetl as 29.12.2008 ancl 05.02.2009 respectively, ar-rcl
the in-rpugned an,arrrl rvas passctl on 37.12.2013 and as per Section I1-A of Act
1 oi 189-1, the arvald \\'as passcd beyond tu,o vears ancL would subrnit that ii
an ;uvard is nr>[ p.rssecl within two years, the entire land acquisition
proceerlings 1aps6.5. 1,-r suppor t of the submissions, relied on the .judgrnent
reportt,rl in 1 99+ (l) r\ I- I 175. Ilc.liance is also placccl orr Abdul Majeed Sahib
r' D(, & Ors ((1997) 1 SCC 297).
21.
[-carned Serriol counscl w,ould further submit that since the subject
lanrls rr'cre takt,rr in posst-.ssior-r on 04.0.1 .2012, t'hich is mentioner-1 in thc
arvarcl rlated 31 .12.2013, the cntire land acquisition concluded beyond the
period of t\\'o vL.ars violating the provisions of Section 11-A ancl eventuallv
prar this Hon'blc c-ourt to all.r.r, both the writ petitions and to sL.t aside the
irnpugrrt'cl clratt .r,' altr dateri .3 r 12.2013 passcd
thc 1'11rv.1n'.''r or Act r of 1gg4, rvith
bY the 3rcl responclent uncrer
consequentiar direction to responde.t
authorities to Pay comPensation
proposals in terms
provisions of the
as per the three-man estimation committee
of Lancl Acquisition Act' 7894 in accordance with the
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Act' 2013'
22. Learned Government Pleader for Land
submits that the
Acquisition would further
draft preliminarl' notification under Section 4(1) of the Land
Acquisition Act, 7894'
locality on 29.12'2008''f
was issued and the substance was published in the
hc draf t dcclaration undcr Section 6 of the Act was
issued and the substance
under Section 5-A
objections by 01
was published in the locality on 05 09'2009 Enquiry
was issued to the interested parties on 01 08 2009 to file
09 2009 An enquir"v into such claims ancl objections
was
scheduleclon02.0g.200gPossessionofthelanc{sweretakenon04.01.2012.
ThelndividualnoticesuntlerSectionsg(1)and9(3)oftheActwereissuedon
award enquirv on 29'03 2072' which was commenced on
L7.O3.2012,fixing the
29.03.201,2 ancl
conclutled on 13 12 2013 and that an award was passed
bearing File No.F/238/2012,
the Act on 3L.12.2073
06.01..201,4 to receive
Award No.45/2013-14, under Section 11(1) of
antl thereafter, notices were issued to the petitioners on
the alt'ard comPensation and when the petitioners did
notturnuPtoleceivetlreawarc]amountorfileaclaimunderSectionlSof
the Act, thereafter,
on 09 03'2018' the matter was referred to the Senior Civil
uncler Section 30 of the
Judge at Sircilla
award amount was deposited
0g.03.2018 and that
Act vicle File No F/238/2012 and the
in Court vide cheque No 211273 dated
as on date, an awarc-l has been passed for Rs'81'34'"134/'
onl\, and thc s.rmc has been dcposited in tl-re jurisdictional Court under the
aw.rrd, and lhc petitionets maY reccivc the satne and for enhancetnent oI
contpensation lllav PtlI sue tl-rcil remedl' before the trial Court
ANA LYS IS AND CONCLUSION:
27. On a perusal ol. the in"vald register, at Serial No.20, it is recorcled that
thc a checluc bearinl', No.211273, dated 08.03.20.18 for Rs 81,34,134/-, along
u.ith enclosures, u'as rcceivetl from tlte Special Deputy Collector on 12/03.
L.A.Unit vll.FCC/ NI\'{RL, Dr.B.ll.Arnbcdkar PCSSP Rajanna Sircilla, further,
it-r t5e rt marks t oiut.t.'ttt, it is recordcci as
"rctut-ltetl". In :he replv afficlavit, tho
petitioners subrnittetl that, rvhetr the matter $'as referrecl b the Senior Civil
Jtrcl;:e for rlcposrt
of corlpensation of Rs.81,3'1,131/ -, tlte Petitioners came to
k,.rv that tlrc lcfcrcttct' r.r1.1rlc or.r 12.03.2018 bv tho Deputv C--ollector in C.F.
LAOP No.220/2018 rvas returncd on 14.05.2018 with office objections taken
br. the Senior C ivrl f Lrrlge, Silcilla. Thereafter, the respondent No.3 has not
takel any stops to resubmit thc same bv complying with the objections before
thc said Cotrrt.
21. On a perusal (rl thc copt of endorsemcr-rt .rr-rd the inrvard register, no
subr.nissions \,vere madt' bv thc learned Covernment Pleader to that extent,
lhc rt-.spon(ler1ts havt' lailed t() compl] u'ith tl.rc tin.relines as stipulatecl under
Section 1'1-A of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Section 11-A of the Land
Acquisitiorr .\ct, 189J, stipyl.ies that the Colleck>r shall rnake an arvard
\^,itirin a pc.rror{ of tr,t.o vcars lrrrl1 11.," date
ot pubiicatirtn of the declaration
and. if such award is not macle, the entire proceedings for acquisition of the
lancl shall lapse. Section 11-A is extracted for reference
"11-A. Period within which an award shall be made. - The
Collector shall make an award under Section 11 within a period of
two years from the date of the publication of the declaration and
if no award is made within that period, the entire proceedings for
the acquisition of the land shall lapse:
Provided that in a case *,here the said declaration has been
published before the commencement of the Land Acquisition
(Amendment) Act,7984, the award shall be macle within a period
of two years from such commencement."
25. In the case on hand, the preliminary notification was issued on
29.72.2008 and the draft declaration was issued under Section 6 of the Act on
05.02.2009. The award was passed on 31..12.2013, which is beyond the
prescribed time period unrier Section 11-A of the Act. It is also pertinent to
note that possession was taken on 04.01.2012 and, though the compensation
was deposited before the trial Court, the same has been returned and
possession for the pctitioners land/structurcs aktne was taken. That apart,
even the compensation amount has been returned on technical reasons as
such the compensation amount was not deposited as on date. Section 16 of
the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, contemplates that the Collector has to pass an
award under Section 11 and take possession of the land. In the case on hand,
even going biu the date of award, i.e.,3-1.12.2013, the respondents have taken
possession of the land on 04.01.2012, thereby violating the provisions of
Section 16 of the Act.
26. l he lJon'ble Suplcrle Court in Abdui Majeed Sahib and Another r,
District Colicctor antl Othcrs, repolted in (1997) 7 S<:C 297, observed that
Section l1-A w:is inh ociuccd lo rnitigate the harrlship of the lanci loscrs. The
reler.ant paragraph is crtractecl for referencc
"6. Seciion 1l-r\ n,as brought on statute by' Arnendntent Act 68 of
1984. It ..r,as notorjous that the State, after publication of
r-le,claration rrnclL.r Sr-ction 6 r.r,cnt on clelaving for 1e.rrs, to pass the
a',r'arcls putLing obstluc[ior.t to tlte or'vnor of thc land for enjoyrnent;
lesultantlr', loss arrrl unduc clisadvantage cnsued to the owner ol'
tl-re lar-rd. To milisate such hardship, Parliament introduced Section
11-A arrcl tli- rocte,.l ihe l.and Acquisition Officer to make the
arvard r.r'ithin t\\'o vc;u's frorn the date oi publication of last of the
steps undel Section 6(2) publishing the declaration under Section 6.
r\s a c(, r-Lsetluencc, lhe Larrcl Acquisitiot-r Ofticer is statutorilv under
an oblil;ation, at the pain of invalidation of the acquisition itself, kr
make the arrard n'ithin t\^'o vears unless it falls rt'ithin one of the
provisos or the I:xplanaLion added thereto. In this case, neither thc
ploviso nor thc Iirplanation stands ath'acted to the facts.
Corrsequentlr, since the l-and Acquisition Officer did not make the
arv.rrd rvithrn t'll o vt'ars from the rlate of thc declaration, vrz.,77-61988, tlrc entire,rcquisitron shall stand lapscc1."
27. [jurtht'r. this (,orr lt 1l'l Madhava Rao Gandhe and Ors. Vs. Land
Acquisition Ofticer, Qrrli Qutubshah Urban Development Authority ln
W.I'\o.14320 ot 199t, N4r\NU/AAP/0330/1994 (1994 (3) 1.l-r 775), dccided
on 1-1.09.199'1, ol-,ser',,ec1 that rvhen the rnandatory requirements under Section
11A of the ,\ct har-e rrot beerr satisfied b.v thc respondents, the rrotification
issuetl urrrlcr Scr'tion -t(l ) ol the r\ct stoocl crtitrgutshed and as an inevitable
corolLarv, tht, inrpugnecl .rrvarcl becomes llon est undcr law. The relevant
paragraph is crtr.rctetl fol lcierencc
'1. \.fs. .\.i' Iakshrtri. thr: lcarnc,rl (_ounsel
aclrnits that r1o,.lr.genc\ clause ir.as int,oked
for tJrc responderrt,
anrl that the enquiry,
under Section 5A of the Act was helcl and then only the draft
declaration under Section 6 of the Act was published. As such,
Section 11A of the Act oPerates. The draft declaration under
Section 6 of the Act was published locally on 9-4-1992. I(eckoning
two years from that date and even excluding 9-4'1992' the Award
ought to have been passed bv 9-4-1'994- But, in the instant case, the
Award was passed on 7 -4-7994 and if it is taken apParently as
such, technically the requirement under Section 11A of the Act is
satisfied. But the very intendment and obiect of the amending Act
68 of 1984 in incorporating Section 11A into the Act was to see that
the compensation is kePt ready at the disposal of the Land
Acquisition Officer while passing the Award so that soon after the
Award is passed, either it is disbursed to the awardees and in case
there is a dispute with regard to the same, refer to a Civil Court
under Section 30 of the Act along with the amount. I cannot
countenance an argument that sincc the Award is passed on 7-41994 even there being no amount with the Land Acquisition
Officer at his disposa.l to disburse the same to the awardees, the
requirement under Section 1l A of the Act is satisfied The
requirement under Section 11A of the Act is a mandatory one and
not a directory and there is no meaning in passing an Award
without there being money readilv available with the Land
Acquisition Of f icer for clisbu rsement. If the monev is not at the
disposal of the Land Acquisition Officer at the time of passing of
the Award, even if the Award is passed, it is only a paper Award
and such a technical satisfaction under Section 11A of the Act is
not contemplated. Section 11A of the Act substantively requires
not only passing of the Award within two years, but also keeping
the amount awarded ready with the Land Acquisition Officer at
the time of passing of the Award for the purpose of disbursement
or deposit as tnentioned above. In the instant case, it is clear from
the counter-affidavit that even as on this date, the Land
Acquisition Officer is not ready' with the compensation awarded
and he is awaiting sanction from the Government for the awarded
amount. In the circumstances, I hold that the rnandatory
requirement under Section 11A of thc Act has not bcen satisfiecl by
the respondent and Section 11A oi the Act operated and the
notification issuecl under Section 4(1) of the Act stood
extinguished- As an inevitable corollary, the impugned Award
tlated 7 -4-1994 became non est under [aw. This order shall not
preclude the respondent from taking steps for issuing fresh
notification under Section 4(1) of the Act and then to proceed
afresh from that stage."
lf
28.
Srnce the tlisprrtcs raisccl in
thcse n,rit petitions pertains to
determinatiorr of cluantum of compensation
recluced fronr Iis.11,29,22,2J4/ _
(Rupees
tht' Agricurtu'ar I:irra,ces C.rporatio.
ansrvercd b' t.c .espo.tlents rvitrr
possible' this Cou,t i^ orercise
'
by the Three Man Committee a,cl
Limitecr, ir-re sarne has not been
subrnerged and further enclui^,
stage,
is not
of this jurisdiction under Article 224
atrjuclicate upon such disputed
0f
questions of fact.
'12 2013 r'as passerr beyond the prescribed
1l-,\ under LA r\ct, 1g9-l anc.l therefore
2tt
to Rs
hundred
variti proof. As sur:rr, at trris beratecl
morc so, *.^e. thc structur.cs ar.c
Further the arvarcl clatecr 3.r
ar-rcl Fortl' Four only)
one lakhs thirty four thousand one
anrl thirt'foLrr orrrl') r'r'hich was crecided
(lo.stitutior ol Irrtria c'runot
submitted by the petitioners was
One Crore Twentv Nine Lakhs
l r.t entr, ['rvo ll11p,;6,1..1 ].w.o [Junrirecj
Rs.81,3-1,1 -1{/ - (Rupres5 Eighty
the
sectio.
unsustainable in law.
In trrt- backcr"p rr thc facts antr circ
u r.ns t.r nces
and refer.ring to the
abo.e;ucliciai
antr cor.rsicrering that the lanrl
has alreadl, been
'recccrcr.rts
acquir.ed and posscssion has
Lreen takerr on 04.01.2012,
the artarcj clated
11 .12.2017 is hcr.,br st,t
rsic.lc a.cl t^e Writ petrti.n
Nos. 20711 oi 2016 and
8826 d 2021arc. allorr.erl.
30.
The r.espondcnts arc tlirectecl
to iltitiate proceedings
pr()visi()ns o1'thc sairl Ilight
,Acquisition, Ilchalrrlitatron
lo Irair Compensation
anri Ilcse.ttlement
tltr, cr.rtirc e\cl.c ls(, as,..\frcditiousl\
as pe55jblg
under the
arld Transparencv in
Ar.t, 2013 atresh
Land
and complete
With tlre above tlirections, Writ Petition Nos 20711 o1201'6 and 8826 of
2024 are accordingly tiisposed of. There shall be no order
as to costs
Miscellaneous Petitions, if any are pending' shall stand
closecl
Sd/- S. MALLIKARJUNA RAO
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principal Secretary, Department of lrrigation and Command Area
Development, State of Telangana, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad,
Hyderabad.
2. The District Collector, Karimnagar District' At Karimnagar, 3. The Special Deputy Collector,, LA Unit-Vl, SRSP (Sriram Sagar Projects)/
EFC(ilood Flow Cannel)/ Mid Manair Reservoir Project Dr.B.R. Ambedkar
Srujala Sravanthi Projects, LMD Colony, Karinagar District
4. The Special Collector, LA, Srirain Sagar Projects, Hyderabad
5. The Principal secretary Revenue (Land Acquisition) Department, state of
Telangana, Secretariat, Tank Bund Road, Hyderabad'
6. The District collector, Rajanna sircilla District, collectorate Buildings,Sircilla.
7. Land Acquisition Officer and Special Deputy Collector, L A , Unit. Vll, FFC
and MMR, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar PCSSP, Sircilla, Rajanna Sircilla District'
8. The Executive Engineer, lrrigation Division No.1 of lrrigation circle-|, lrrigation
andCADDepartment,L.M.DColony,Karimnagar,KarimnagarDistrict'
(ErstwhileExecutiveEngineer'DivisionNo4,lFFC-l,RekurthyRoad'
KothaPallY, Karimnagar).
9. One CC to SRl. B ARJUN RAO, Advocate [OPUC]
l0.TwoCCstoGPFoRLANDACQUlSlTloN,HighCourtfortheStateof
Telangana, at HYderabad [OUT]
11. Two CCs to GP FOR lRRl AND COMM AREA DEV, High court for the state
ofTelangana, at HYderabad [OUT]
,A I
t2.two CD Copies
DAN
HIGH COURT
CC TODAY
DATED: 2510812026
5 1AT E o F
rY
:l
o
\o
COMMON ORDER
WP.No.20711 of 2016 & 8826 OF 2024
DISPOSING OF THE BOTH WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
A /l
r"7i
Ii ib
'tt
(
stP flfs
..:_
1'_'
J':
li
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review