Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:930
Serial No. 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC(CRP) No. 4 of 2024
Date of Decision: 21.10.2024
Shri Antariksh Kalita
S/o Shri. Pradip Kalita
R/o College Road No. 1
Padumoni, Sarupathar,
Golaghat, Assam-785601
:::::
Applicant
:::::
Respondents
-Vs1.
The Deputy Commissioner,
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
2.
Sri. Ranabir Choudhury, Advocate
S/o (L) Rajendra Kumar Choudhury,
Plot No. 249, R.R. Colony,
P.O. Rynjah, East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. Sr. GA for R 1.
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. for R 2.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:930
in press:
Yes/No
ORDER
1.
In a pending matter before this Court wherein, Shri Ranabir
Choudhury, the respondent No. 2 herein had preferred a revision petition
being aggrieved by an order dated 17.12.2014, passed by the Meghalaya
Board of Revenue in MBR/RA No. 2 of 2013. In such revision petition,
Smti. Prabhashini Dutta was also impleaded as respondent No. 1 with
the Deputy Commissioner (Revenue), East Khasi Hills District, Shillong
as the respondent No. 2.
2.
The revision petition numbered as CRP. No. 2 of 2015 has
proceeded in its usual course, when this Court was informed of the death
of Smti. Prabhashini Dutta. On submission made by the learned Sr.
counsel for the petitioner that since, no relief is sought for as against the
deceased respondent No. 1 (in the main revision petition), this Court on
prayer made, vide order dated 25.07.2023, had accordingly struck off the
name of the deceased respondent No. 1 from the proceedings.
3.
However, Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has sought
for leave to file an appropriate application in order to bring the legal heir
and representatives of the deceased respondent No. 1 in place of the
2024:MLHC:930
deceased respondent No. 1 so as to contest the proceedings before this
Court. Such prayer being allowed, an application registered as MC(CRP)
No. 4 of 2024 was accordingly filed, the same being taken up herewith
for consideration.
4.
Heard Ms. P. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the applicant,
who has submitted that this Court vide order dated 25.07.2023 had
struck off the name of the respondent No. 1 in the main petition on her
death. However, since the time of her death on 22.02.2019, her son
Bishwanath Dutta was pursuing the proceedings in the matter. But, he
too expired on 13.01.2024 and due to the communication gap between
the parties and the counsels, necessary steps for substitution of the
deceased respondent No.1 could not be done so.
5.
The learned counsel has further submitted that since the legal
heir of the deceased Prabhashini Dutta has also expired, the remaining
legal heirs have now issued necessary no objection to allow the present
applicant to be impleaded in the case as party respondent in substitution
of the original deceased respondent.
6.
Under the circumstances as is evident in the case herein, the
learned counsel has submitted that the applicant has now approached
2024:MLHC:930
this Court with this instant application made under Order 1 Rule 10 (2)
of the Code of Civil Procedure for impleadment of the applicant as a
party herein.
7.
In support of this contention, the learned counsel has referred
to the case of Puran Singh & Ors v. State of Punjab & Ors reported in
AIR 1996 (SC), 1092 para 10 which reads as follows.
“10. As such even if it is held that Order 22 of the Code is
not applicable to writ proceedings or writ appeals, it does
not mean that the petitioner or the appellant in such writ
petition or writ appeal can ignore the death of the
respondent if the right to pursue remedy even after death of
the respondent survives…”
8.
Per contra, Mr. K. Paul, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the
respondent No. 2 herein, who is the petitioner in the main revision
petition, while opposing the contention of the applicant has submitted
that the prayer in this application would show that the applicant has
sought for being impleaded as a party respondent in the main
proceedings and additionally, for the order dated 25.07.2023 to be
vacated. However, the applicant has failed to submit pleadings as to why
he should be impleaded and also as to how he is a necessary party to the
proceedings.
2024:MLHC:930
9.
Taking this Court to the order dated 25.07.2023, the learned
Sr. counsel has submitted that by such order, this Court has rightly struck
off the name of the deceased respondent No.1 (in the main revision
petition) from the proceedings since in the order impugned by the
respondent No. 2 herein, that is, the order dated 17.12.2013 passed by
the Meghalaya Board of Revenue, no substantive right of the deceased
respondent No. 1 was infringed, the impugned order being negatively
directed only against the respondent No. 2 herein. Therefore, being the
complainant who has initiated the said proceedings culminating in the
passing of the said impugned order, the applicant herein has not been
able to state as to how his rights have been affected. Without any
pleadings as to how the passing of the said order dated 25.07.2023 has
caused prejudice to him, the applicant having asserted that this is not an
application seeking substitution of the deceased respondent No. 1, this
application is liable to be dismissed as not maintainable.
10.
The learned Sr. counsel has again submitted that the prayer of
the applicant to be impleaded as a party to these proceedings relying on
the provision of Order 1 Rule 10 (2) CPC, has no basis as he is not at all
involved in the lis between the parties since its inception, he could
2024:MLHC:930
therefore not be considered as a proper or necessary party. If he could
assert any right at all, it can only be on behalf of the deceased
respondent and that too, by way of substitution for which he has to
approach this Court under the relevant provision of the Code of Civil
Procedure, particularly, under Order XXII Rule 4.
11.
This Court on consideration of the submission made, is
aware that the instant application is two-fold in its approach, the first
being the prayer for impleadment of the applicant herein as a necessary
party in the revision and the second, being the recall of the order dated
25.07.2023, wherein the name of the deceased respondent No. 1 therein
was struck off from the proceedings, thus, not necessitating any legal
heir to be substituted in her place.
12.
A perusal of the petition under consideration, would show
that the applicant has asserted that he is the Attorney Holder and
grandson of Late Prabhashini Dutta, the deceased respondent No. 1 in
the main revision petition. Thereafter, the date of death of the said
deceased respondent No. 1 was given as 22.02.2019. Again, the
applicant has further stated that after the death of the deceased
respondent No. 1, her son who was the Attorney Holder had been
2024:MLHC:930
pursuing the case of the parties. However, he too has since expired on
13.01.2024.
13.
It is the further submission of the applicant that there was a
communication gap between the parties and the counsels resulting in this
Court passing the order dated 25.07.2023, where effectively, the name of
the deceased respondent No. 1 was struck off from these proceedings.
The applicant went on to state that now, the legal heirs of the deceased
respondent No. 1 have executed respective power of attorney in his
favour to pursue this matter, and as such, this application is now filed
with a prayer to implead the applicant as party respondent and also for
the order dated 25.07.2023 to be vacated.
14.
At the outset, the learned counsel for the applicant has
maintained that this is an application seeking impleadment in terms of
the provision of Order I Rule 10 (2) of the Code of Civil Procedure and
is not an application for substitution in place of the deceased respondent.
15.
It may not be out of place to reproduce the provision cited by
the learned counsel that is, Order 1 Rule 10 (2) which reads as follows:
“ORDER 1
PARTIES TO SUITS
2024:MLHC:930
10(2). Court may strike out or add parties. – The Court
may at any stage of the proceedings, either upon or without the
application of either party, and on such terms as may appear to the
Court to be just, order that the name of any party improperly
joined, whether as plaintiff or defendant, be struck out, and that
the name of any person who ought to have been joined, whether
as plaintiffs or defendant, or whose presence before the Court may
be necessary in order to enable the Court effectually and
completely to adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved
in the suit, be added.”
16.
There are a number of interpretations as to who is a proper
and necessary party who is required to be impleaded or struck off from a
proceeding before the Court. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Vidur Impex and Traders Private Limited & Ors v. Tosh Apartments
Private Limited & Ors reported in (2012) 8 SCC 384 at para 41.1, 41.2,
41.3 and 41.4 has observed as follows:
“41.1. The Court can, at any stage of the proceedings,
either on an application made by the parties or otherwise,
direct impleadment of any person as party, who ought to
have been joined as plaintiff or defendant or whose
presence before the court is necessary for effective and
complete adjudication of the issues involved in the suit.
41.2. A necessary party is the person who ought to be
joined as party to the suit and in whose absence an
effective decree cannot be passed by the court.
41.3. A proper party is a person whose presence would
enable the court to completely, effectively and properly
adjudicate upon all matters and issues, though he may not
be a person in favour of or against whom a decree is to be
made.
2024:MLHC:930
41.4. If a person is not found to be a proper or necessary
party, the court does not have the jurisdiction to order his
impleadment against the wishes of the plaintiff.”
17.
The learned counsel for the applicant in course of her
argument, had stressed on the fact that the applicant being the legal
representative as well as the legal heir of the deceased respondent, he is
accordingly the best person to step into the shoes of such deceased
respondent, and as such, if not impleaded in these proceedings, the rights
of the deceased respondent would stand extinguish without due
procedure of law. It is therefore necessary that the said order dated
25.07.2023 be vacated.
18.
It is not understood as to how the applicant can intervene in
the lis between the parties since apart from a bare assertion that he is the
legal heir of the deceased respondent deriving his authority on the
strength of the said power of attorney executed by the so called legal
heirs of the said deceased respondent, this fact not having been
established, since it would stand to reason that the legal heirs of the
deceased ought to have appeared before this Court as principal legal
representatives of the said deceased and thereafter, in order to pursue the
matter, they would then authorized the applicant herein to represent
2024:MLHC:930
them. This process has never been followed, and as such, the applicant
has not been able to prove his bonafide as far as his right and interest in
the matter under consideration is concerned.
19.
Even so, since the applicant claiming to be the legal heir of
the deceased respondent and therefore, is the best person to pursue the
matter, the approach before this Court ought not to have been under the
provision of Order 1 Rule 10 (2) CPC, but should have been one under
Order XXII Rule 4 (1) which reads as follows:
“ORDER XXII
DEATH, MARRIAGE AND INSOLVENCY OF PARTIES
4. Procedure in case of death of one of several defendants or of
sole defendant. – (1) Where one of two or more defendants dies and the
right to sue does not survive against the surviving defendant or
defendants alone, or a sole defendant or sole surviving defendant dies
and the right to sue survives, the Court, on an application made in that
behalf, shall cause the legal representative of the deceased defendant to
be made a party and shall proceed with the suit.”
20.
However, the factual aspect of the matter is that the deceased
respondent had expired on 22.02.2019, the matter is said to have been
diligently pursued by her son Late Bishwanath Dutta, who was still alive
in the year 2019. Upon the death of the deceased respondent, an
application by her legal representatives to be made a party and to
proceed in the proceedings ought to have been filed, however, there is
2024:MLHC:930
nothing on record to show that Bishwanath Dutta has ever entered these
proceedings to succeed his deceased mother, the deceased respondent
No. 1. In view thereof, the provision of Order XXII Rule 4 (3) which
provides for a limitation period, being the prescribed period of three
years from the date of death of the party to enable an application for
substitution in place of the deceased plaintiff or defendant to be filed,
would certainly apply to the case of the parties herein, the same being
found wanting.
21.
Since the applicant has not pressed for substitution in place
of the deceased respondent, but has insisted on being impleaded as a
proper and necessary party, no credence or good grounds or even legal
grounds being shown to convince this Court to allow such prayer, the
prayer in this regard cannot be entertained in the form and manner in
which it was presented.
22.
Again, as to the prayer to vacate the order dated 25.07.2023,
as has been argued by the learned Sr. counsel for the respondent No. 2
herein, the applicant has not been able to point out the reasons as to why
the said order is to be vacated, vis-à-vis, the infirmity or illegality
thereof, this Court has no basis to allow the prayer in this regard. It may
2024:MLHC:930
be reminded that the said order was passed on the prayer of the
petitioner therein, who is the dominus litis and the same was passed on a
prima facie observation made by this Court on the assumption that no
relief is sought for or claimed as against the deceased respondent No. 1.
In view of the provision under Order XXII Rule 4, it is incumbent upon
the plaintiff/petitioner to bring the legal heirs or representatives of a
deceased defendant/respondent on record, it would be open to the parties
to agitate this issue before the proper forum.
23.
The authorities cited by the learned counsel for the applicant
would not be applicable to the case in hand, and as such, no detailed
discussion is necessary to be made in this regard.
24.
Mr. S. Sengupta, learned Addl. Sr. GA appearing for the State
respondent No. 1 has submitted that no argument will be advanced on
behalf of the said respondent.
25.
In view of the above observations, this Court finds that the
applicant has not been able to make out a case either for impleadment as
party respondent in the related proceedings or for vacation of the said
order dated 25.07.2023. This application is therefore dismissed as
devoid of merits.
2024:MLHC:930
26.
Application disposed of.
Judge
DARIKORDOR NARY
Date: 2024.10.21 18:07:06 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review