Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 13.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 07.08.2026
Date of uploading
: 07.08.2026
APHC010722232025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3601]
WRIT PETITION NO: 36841 of 2025
Ankem Suma Harshitha
Vs.
The State Of Andhra Pradesh and Others
...Petitioner
...Respondent(s)
**********
CORAM : SRI JUSTICE RAVI NATH TILHARI
SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR CHINTALAPUDI
DATE
: 7th August 2026
Present:
Advocate for Petitioner:
Advocate for Respondent:
RAMALAKSHMANA REDDY
SANEPALLI
ADDL ADVOCATE GENERAL
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Ravi Nath Tilhari)
Heard Sri Ramalakshmana Reddy Sanepalli, learned counsel for
the petitioner and Sri Kirthi Teja Kondaveeti, learned Government
Pleader, attached to the Office of the learned Additional Advocate
General, appearing for the respondents.
2. The petitioner, wife of the alleged detenu, namely, Ankem Raja,
has filed the present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India for issuance of Writ of Habeas Corpus directing release of the
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
detenu and to set him free by declaring and setting aside the Order of
Preventive Detention.
3. The District Collector/Magistrate passed an Order of Preventive
Detention being Rc.C1(Magl)/126/2025, dated 08.12.2025 under Sections
3 (1) and 3 (2) of A.P. Prevention Dangerous Activities of Bootleggers,
Dacoits, Drug Offenders, Goondas, Immoral Traffic Offenders and Land
Grabbers Act, 1986 (in short ‘Act 1986’). The Order was passed on three
grounds, i.e., three criminal cases, which are;
1) Kovur Police Station: Crime No.160/2025, U/s.271, 272, 273 R/W 3(5) B.N.S.,
dated 09.06.2025;
2) Kovur Police Station: Crime No.246/2025, U/s.127 (2), 140 (3), 308 (5), 115 (2)
r/w.3(5) B.N.S., dated 20.08.2025;
3) Kovur Police Station: Crime No.322/2025, under Sections 420, 386 r/w.34 IPC,
dated 18.11.2025;
The Order recorded that the detenu was ‘Goonda’ under Section 2 (g) of
the Act 1986 and the criminal cases registered against him fell under
Chapter XVII and XXII of the Indian Penal Code (‘IPC’) and VI, XVII, XVIII
and XIX of Bharathiya Nyaya Sanhitha (‘BNS’).
He was habitually
indulging in criminal activities in the manner prejudicial to the public order
and in spite of enforcement of ordinary penal laws, the detenu could not
be prevented from indulging in such brutal activities.
4. After the proceedings of the Advisory Board, the State
Government/1st respondent confirmed the Order of Detention by
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
G.O.Rt.No.211, dated 03.02.2026. Both the Orders are under challenge
in the writ petition.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that,
(i)
The Crime No.160/2025 under Sections 271, 272, 273 r/w. Section 3
(5) BNS 457 of Kovur Police Station under Ground No.1,
corresponding to Sections 267, 268 & 269 IPC do not fall under
Chapter XVII, XVIII or XXII of IPC (corresponding Chapters VI, XVII,
XVIII and XIX of BNS). The detenu is therefore not ‘Goonda’ within
its meaning under Section 2 (g) of the Act 1986. The Investigating
Officer had also issued Section 35 (3) BNS notice to the detenu
(Accused No.2 in the said crime number). He cooperated with the
investigation. The Investigating Officer had filed the charge sheet
and the case was pending for trial.
(ii)
The Crime No.246/2025 under Sections 127 (2), 140 (3) 308 (5), 115
(2) r/w.3 (5) BNS in Ground No.2, related to a dispute with respect to
purchase of a flat in an apartment in which O.S.No.269 of 2023 was
pending between the detenu and the complainant. The complaint
was filed in the year 2024, in which the detenu is Accused No.3. He
was arrested on 20.08.2025 and was enlarged on regular bail on
15.09.2025. The bail order, though referred in the detention order,
but the detaining authority did not consider the conditions of the bail
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
Order. So, the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority is
vitiated for non-consideration of the relevant material.
(iii) The Crime No.322 of 2025, under Sections 420, 386 r/w.34 IPC of
Kovur Police Station in Ground No.3, relates to the incident which
occurred on 18.11.2025 wherein there was dispute of the payment of
some amount relating to some work between the complainant and
Accused No.1 therein and the allegation made against the detenu
(Accused No.3), was that he threatened to kill the complainant. The
detenu was arrested on 23.11.2025. He was sent to the judicial
custody and was granted regular bail.
The District Collector in
Ground No.3 only considered that the detenu was remanded to the
judicial custody, but he did not consider the triple test as laid down in
Champion R. Sangma v. State of Meghalaya1. The satisfaction of
the Detaining Authority is neither the subjective satisfaction nor is
based on relevant considerations.
(iv) The preventive detention could not be used on stale or irrelevant
grounds. There must be a real possibility of future conduct prejudicial
to public order, whereas in the nature of the incidents, even if taken
to be true, at best, it constituted a breach of law and order and not
disturbing the public order.
(2015) 16 SCC 253
The Order of Detention was passed
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
mechanically. The Order of Preventive Detention is illegal. It cannot
be sustained and the detenu is entitled to be set free.
6. Learned Government Pleader referring to the counter affidavit
supported the Order of Preventive Detention and he submitted that,
(i) the District Collector recorded its subjective satisfaction that the
criminal activities in which the detenu was indulged were prejudicial
to the public order and in spite of enforcement of ordinary penal
laws, the detenu could not be prevented from indulging in such
activities. Such satisfaction is based on material on record;
(ii) the detenu falls within the definition of ‘Goonda’ for the offences in
Ground Nos.2 & 3, under Section 2 (g) of the Act 1986, even if the
offences under Ground No.1, may not be falling under Chapter XVI,
XVII & XXII of IPC. So, the preventive detention order has rightly
been passed under the Act 1986.
7. We have considered the aforesaid submissions and perused the
material on record.
8. It is not in dispute that the offences under Sections 271, 272, 273
r/w.3 (5) BNS 457 in Crime No.160 of 2025, Ground No.1, which
correspond to Sections 267, 268 and 269 of IPC, fall in Chapter XV of
IPC and not in Chapter XVI, XVII & XXII of IPC.
9. Section 2 (g) of the Act 1986, defines ‘Goonda’ as follows:
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
“2 (g) "goonda" means a person, who either by himself or as a member of or
leader of a gang, habitually commits, or attempts to commit or abets the
commission of offences punishable under Chapter XVI or Chapter XVII or
Chapter XXII of the Indian Penal Code;”
10. In view of the definition of ‘goonda’, if the offences do not fall
under the Chapters XVI, XVII or XXII of IPC, with respect to those
offences the person cannot be termed as ‘goonda’. However, there is no
dispute that the offences in Ground Nos.2 & 3 are punishable under
Chapter XVI, XVII or XXII of IPC. Though the District Collector in the
Preventive Detention Order has termed the detenu as ‘goonda’ in all the
criminal cases under the Ground Nos.1 to 3, incorrectly, and though the
offences in Ground No.1 do not fall under Chapters XVI, XVII and XXII of
IPC, it cannot be said that the detenu is not ‘Goonda’ under Section 2 (g)
of the Act 1986, in view of the offences in criminal cases in Ground Nos.2
& 3, which falls in Chapter XVI, XVII and XXII of IPC on which no dispute
has been raised by the learned counsel for the petitioner. So, it can also
not be said that an Order of Preventive Detention could not be passed
under Section 3 of the Act 1986 in view of Ground No.1, as the detenu
would be covered within the definition of ‘Goonda’ under Section 2 (g)
with respect to the offences under Sections 2 & 3. But, the Order of
Preventive Detention terming the detenu as ‘Goonda’ in the criminal
cases in Ground Nos.1 to 3 shows the non-application of mind to the
correct factual position, which must have affected his satisfaction
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
recorded for passing the Order of Preventive Detention against the
detenu.
11. In Ground No.2, Crime No.246 of 2025 the incident is primarily
a civil dispute between the detenu and the complainant for which
O.S.No.269 of 2023 is pending. The detenu was enlarged on bail on
15.09.2025.
The Order of Preventive Detention does not show the
consideration of bail orders and in the light thereof, recording any
satisfaction by the Detaining Authority as to why those bail conditions
were not sufficient to restrain the detenu from indulging into any further
activities affecting the public order if he was not detained. Though the
bail order has been referred, but it has only been referred as a fact and it
has only been observed that the detenu is in judicial remand in another
criminal case, Crime No.322 of 2025 under Ground No.3, but there is no
consideration of the bail order to arrive at the subjective satisfaction.
12. In Buddiga Dhana Lakshmi v. State of A.P.2 a Coordinate
Bench of this Court set aside the preventive detention order and released
the detenu observing that while passing the Order of Preventive
Detention, the Detaining Authority has not considered the bail orders
passed in favour of the detenu in other criminal cases. Paragraphs 14 &
15 of Buddiga Dhana Lakshmi (supra) are reproduced as under:
“14. In Ponnada Geetha (supra), a coordinate Bench of this Court has held
that when the detenu was already released on bail in a crime and when it was
2026 SCC OnLine AP 2162
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
made basis for passing the order of preventive detention and when such order of
bail was not placed before the detention authority, it vitiates the order of
preventive detention. Paragraph Nos. (9) to (12) of Ponnada Geetha (supra) read
as under:
“However, as per the settled law, the very fact that the order of bail granted
to the detenu in Crime No. 219 of 2024 of Gopalapatnam Police Station for the
offence under NDPS Act, was not placed before the detaining authority, while
passing the impugned order of detention, by itself, is sufficient to hold that it
vitiates the impugned order of detention. The legal position in this regard is
fairly well settled.
10. The Division Bench of the common High Court for the State of
Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh had an occasion to elaborately deal
with the said legal position in the case of Vasanthu Sumalatha v. State of
Andhra Pradesh 2015 SCC OnLine Hyd 790 : (2016) 1 ALT 738 (DB). At para
44 of the said judgment, it is held as follows:
“44. When a person is enlarged on bail by a competent criminal court, great
caution should be exercised in scrutinizing the validity of an order of preventive
detention, which is based on the very same charge which is to be tried by the
criminal court. (Vijay Narain Singh v. State of Bihar [(1984) 3 SCC 14 : 1984
SCC (Cri) 361]; Jotha Viswanadh v. Chief Secretary, Govt. of A.P. [judgment
in W.P. No. 10018 of 2012, dated 29-6-2012 (APHC) (DB)]. Where the detenu
is released on bail, and is enjoying his freedom under the order of the court, the
order of bail must be placed before the detaining authority, when the order of
detention is passed, to enable him to reach a proper satisfaction. (Rushikesh
Tanaji Bhoite v. State of Maharashtra [(2012) 2 SCC 72 : (2012) 1 SCC (Cri)
693]. If the detaining authority was unaware of the order of bail, the detention
order is rendered invalid as the Court cannot attempt to assess in what manner,
and to what extent, consideration of the order granting bail to the detenu would
have effected the satisfaction of the detaining authority in passing the order of
preventive
detention (Rushikesh
supra); Jotha Viswanadh (44 supra).”
Tanaji
Bhoite (42
supra); Rekha (5
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
11. At para 42 of the said judgment, it is also held by the Division Bench of
the common High Court that it is incumbent that all vital materials are placed
before the detaining authority to enable him to arrive at the subjective
satisfaction as to the necessity for passing an order of detention, as decided
in M. Ahamedkutty v. Union of India ((1990) 2 SCC 1 : 1990 SCC (Cri)
258 and State of U.P. v. Kamal Kishore Saini ((1988) 1 SCC 287 : 1988 SCC
(Cri) 107 (2)). Therefore, it is held that the bail order is a vital material for
consideration and if it is not considered, the satisfaction of the detaining
authority would be impaired.
12. Thus, it is obvious from the analogy and the legal position decided in
the aforesaid judgment of the Division Bench of the common High Court,
which is binding on this Court, that when the detenu was already released on
bail in a crime and when it was made basis for passing the order of preventive
detention and when the said order of bail was not placed before the detaining
authority, it vitiates the impugned order of preventive detention. Therefore, in
view of the law enunciated in the above judgment, as the order of bail is
admittedly not placed before the 2nd respondent when he has passed the
impugned order of preventive detention, the impugned order of preventive
detention is vitiated and, therefore, cannot be sustained.”
15. The aforesaid is the settled position in law. The bail order and the
conditions of bail are relevant material to be considered to arrive at the
satisfaction if the order of detention is yet to be passed.”
13. The Ground No.3 in which by the time the Order of Preventive
Detention was passed the detenu was in judicial custody, as submitted by
the learned Assistant Government Pleader, we find that the detaining
authority has not considered and applied the triple test to arrive at a
subjective satisfaction to pass an Order of Preventive Detention with
respect to the detenu when the detenu is in judicial custody.
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
14. The triple test as laid down in Champion R. Sangma (supra)
are as under vide paragraphs Nos.9 to 11:
“9. Coming to the ground on which we intend to allow this appeal, we may
point out that even if the appellant is in jail in connection with some criminal
case(s) there is no prohibition in law to pass the detention order. Law on this
aspect is well settled and stands crystallised by a plethora of judgments of this
Court. However, a reading of those very judgments also clarifies that there are
certain aspects which have to be borne in mind by the detaining authority and
satisfaction on those aspects is to be arrived at while passing the detention
order.
10. There
are
three
such
factors
which
were
restated
in Kamarunnissa v. Union of India [Kamarunnissa v. Union of India, (1991) 1
SCC 128 : 1991 SCC (Cri) 88] : (SCC pp. 140-41, para 13)
“13. From the catena of decisions referred to above it seems clear to us
that even in the case of a person in custody a detention order can validly be
passed (1) if the authority passing the order is aware of the fact that he is
actually in custody; (2) if he has reason to believe on the basis of reliable
material placed before him (a) that there is a real possibility of his being
released on bail, and (b) that on being so released he would in all
probability indulge in prejudicial activity; and (3) if it is felt essential to
detain him to prevent him from so doing. If the authority passes an order
after recording his satisfaction in this behalf, such an order cannot be struck
down on the ground that the proper course for the authority was to oppose the
bail and if bail is granted notwithstanding such opposition, to question it before
a
higher
court.
What
this
Court
stated
in Ramesh
Yadav [Ramesh
Yadav v. District Magistrate, Etah, (1985) 4 SCC 232 : 1985 SCC (Cri) 514]
was that ordinarily a detention order should not be passed merely to pre-empt or
circumvent enlargement on bail in cases which are essentially criminal in nature
and can be dealt with under the ordinary law. It seems to us well settled that
even in a case where a person is in custody, if the facts and circumstances of the
case so demand, resort can be had to the law of preventive detention. This
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
seems to be quite clear from the case law discussed above and there is no need
to refer to the High Court decisions to which our attention was drawn since they
do not hold otherwise. We, therefore, find it difficult to accept the contention of
the counsel for the petitioners that there was no valid and compelling reason for
passing the impugned orders of detention because the detenus were in custody.”
11. The aforesaid dicta is reiterated in subsequent judgments as well. Some
of which are as under:
(i) T.V. Sravanan v. State [T.V. Sravanan v. State, (2006) 2 SCC 664 :
(2006) 1 SCC (Cri) 593] ,
(ii) K.K. Saravana Babu v. State of T.N. [K.K. Saravana Babu v. State of
T.N., (2008) 9 SCC 89 : (2008) 3 SCC (Cri) 679] ,
(iii) Huidrom Konungjao Singh v. State of Manipur [Huidrom Konungjao
Singh v. State of Manipur, (2012) 7 SCC 181 : (2013) 1 SCC (Cri) 956] .”
15. It is true that a criminal case in which the accused is under
judicial custody can be taken into consideration for passing the Order of
Preventive Detention but at the same time, the Detaining Authority has to
satisfy on the fulfillment of the above said triple test, which are missing in
the present Preventive Detention Order.
16. Further, the detenu was granted bail in Ground No.3 offences,
but there is no consideration of the bail order by the Authority confirming
the detention order.
17. We are satisfied that the Order of Preventive Detention and the
Order of Confirmation cannot be sustained on the aforesaid discussion.
So, there is no need to discuss the other grounds of challenge.
18. The Writ Petition is allowed, setting aside the Order of
Preventive Detention dated 08.12.2025 and the Order of Confirmation
RNT, J & PKC, J
WP. No.36841 of 2025
dated 03.02.2026. The Detenu shall be set at liberty, if he is not required
in any other case. No order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed in
consequence.
______________________
RAVI NATH TILHARI, J
_____________________________________
PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR CHINTALAPUDI, J
Date: 07.08.2026
Dsr
Whether the order is:
Reasoned ‘Yes’
Reportable ‘No’
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review