Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 05th February, 2026
Pronounced on: 16th June, 2026
+
RFA 648/2024
ANJU DHAWAN
W/o Shri Vikram Dhawan,
R/o Tower 2-1701, M3M, Merlin,
Gurugram-122101.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. S.C. Anand Advocate.
versus
M/S. AITHENT TECHNOLOGIES PVT. LTD.
Through its Chief Executive Officer,
A-186, Okhla Industrial Area, Phase-I,
New Delhi-110020.
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Venancio D'Costa and Ms. Gauri
Goel, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order
XLI of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as
"CPC") has been preferred by the Appellant/Plaintiff, Anju Dhawan,
assailing the Judgment and Decree dated 09.04.2024, whereby the Suit for
Recovery of Rs.9,09,593/- filed by the Appellant/Plaintiff has been
dismissed, by the learned Additional District Judge-10, Delhi.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
2.
The Appellant/Plaintiff instituted the CS DJ No.13442/2016 for
recovery of Rs.9,09,593/- (principal sum of Rs.3,10,500/- on account of
deferred salary and compensation bonus, Rs.4,05,498/- on account of
gratuity, leave encashment and other terminal dues, and interest of
Rs.1,93,595/-).
3.
Briefly stated, the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff was that she joined
the services of the Respondent Company on 01.10.1993 and continued in
employment till 22.07.2004. At the time of her resignation, she was serving
as Senior Member, Consulting Staff of the Company and was drawing a
gross monthly salary of Rs.83,333/-.
4.
During the financial year 2002-2003, the Respondent Company faced
financial difficulties on account of substantial investments in infrastructure
and delayed payments from its overseas affiliated entities. Consequently, in
March 2002, the Defendant Company decided to defer a portion of the
salaries payable to employees drawing salaries above Rs.12,000/- per
month, for the financial year 2002–2003 on a graded scale of 15%, 20%,
25% and 30% depending upon the salary range. The employees were also
promised one month's salary, as bonus compensation, to offset the financial
hardship occasioned by the deferment of salaries. The deferred salary was to
be paid on 01.04.2003.
5.
The deferment was implemented on a graded scale, and since her
gross salary in March 2002 was Rs.67,500/- per month, 30% of her gross
salary amounting to Rs.20,250/- per month, was deferred from April, 2002
till March, 2003. The deferred component aggregating to Rs.2,43,000/-, was
agreed to be paid on 01.04.2003.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
6.
The Appellant/Plaintiff further asserted that, as per the policy of
deferment, she was also entitled to Rs.67,500/- i.e. one month's salary, as
bonus compensation. Hence, a total amount of Rs.3,10,500/- was due and
payable to the Plaintiff, as on 01.04.2003.
7.
Appellant/Plaintiff stated that during an Open-House Meeting held on
09.08.2002, the Management announced restoration of salaries of certain
employees i.e. lowest salary group of Rs.12,000/- to Rs.20,000/- per month,
with effect from 01.10.2002, and assured that the cases of other employees
would also be reviewed and their deferred salaries, would be released.
8.
As per the Appellant/Plaintiff, the said announcement had been made
with the approval of the CEO of the Defendant Company, who had sent an
e-mail dated 09.07.2002 to Mr. Raju Ahluwalia, with copies to Mr. Ajay
Malik and Mr. Sunil Vadehra regarding the preponement of the decision to
restore salaries to the earlier levels.
9.
While the original salary of the Appellant/Plaintiff of Rs.67,500/-
stood restored w.e.f. 01.04.2003, the management sought more time to pay
the arrears of the deferred salary along with the compensation bonus. The
Plaintiff has also relied upon a communication dated 01.04.2005, issued by
the CEO of the Respondent Company assuring clearance of her dues by
31.05.2005. However, payment of the deferred salary and compensation
bonus, continued to be postponed, despite repeated requests.
10.
The Appellant/Plaintiff further stated that at the time of her
separation, she was entitled to Car Rental of Rs.4,258/-, other
reimbursements of Rs.19,476/-, Gratuity of Rs.3,05,250/- and Leave
Encashment of Rs.81,694/-, while the Respondent being entitled to deduct
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
notice period pay of Rs.5,180/-. The said terminal dues, aggregating to
Rs.4,05,498/-, which became due on 23.07.2004.
11.
Despite subsequent communications sent by the Plaintiff asking about
her dues, including her letter dated 07.09.2005, the Respondent Company
failed to release the claimed amount. The Respondent Company offered a
cheque of Rs.3,96,860/- after deduction of tax of Rs.8,638/-, however,
refused to disclose the details and insisted upon a receipt of full and final
settlement, which was not acceptable to the Appellant/Plaintiff.
12.
The Appellant thus, instituted the present Suit seeking recovery of
Rs.9,09,593/- inclusive of interest (Rs.3,10,500/- towards deferred salary
and compensation bonus due on 01.04.2003, Rs.4,05,498/- towards
terminal dues comprising gratuity, leave encashment, car rental and other
reimbursements due on 23.07.2004, and interest of Rs.1,93,595/-).
13.
The Defendant/Respondent Company in its Written Statement,
raised a preliminary objection regarding territorial jurisdiction, as the
Appellant had been employed at the Gurgaon Office of the defendant
Company.
14.
On merits, it was contended that there was no deferment of salary and
that the salary structure of employees had merely been restructured, in
view of prevailing business circumstances.
15.
The Respondent Company denied that any Agreement existed
whereby the reduced portion of salary was to be repaid, at a future date. It
was further asserted that the Appellant/Plaintiff herself was part of the
Management team which had participated in the decision-making process
relating to restructuring of salaries.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
16.
The Respondent Company admitted that one month's salary had been
discussed as a "loyalty incentive", but asserted that the same was neither a
contractual commitment nor a legally enforceable obligation, and that any
such payment was contingent upon the Company achieving profitability.
17.
The Respondent Company further asserted that a Letter dated
01.04.2002 had been issued to the Appellant/Plaintiff communicating the
restructuring of remuneration, which letter had been signed and accepted by
the Appellant/Plaintiff, without any contemporaneous protest.
18.
The Respondent Company further denied that any amount remained
due and payable to the Appellant/Plaintiff, at the time of cessation of her
employment and prayed for dismissal of the Suit.
19.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial Court
framed the following Issues, on 05.10.2011:
i. “Whether this Court has no territorial jurisdiction to try and entertain
the suit? Onus on parties as per their pleadings.
ii. Whether suit is not maintainable in view of preliminary objections
no.2 and 3 of written statement? OPD
iii. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to amount claimed in the suit? OPP
iv. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any interest and if so at what rate
and for which period? OPP
v. Relief."
20.
The Appellant/Plaintiff examined herself as PW-1 and tendered her
affidavit Ex. PW-1/A. She relied upon the experience certificate dated
28.07.2004 Ex. P-1, the monthly salary certificate dated 28.07.2004 Ex. P-2,
the offer letter dated 12.07.2004 from M/s Fidelity Information Systems
Company India Pvt. Ltd. Ex. PW-1/1, the salary revision letter dated
30.06.2007 Ex. PW-1/2, her salary slips for the period March 2002 to May
2004 marked as Ex. P-3 to Ex. P-9 and Ex. P-11 to Ex. P-20, the Form-16
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
issued by the Defendant for the Assessment Years 2002-03 to 2005-06
marked as Ex. PW-1/3 to Ex. PW-1/6, the letter dated 01.04.2005 issued by
the CEO of the Respondent Company Ex. P-10, her own letter dated
07.09.2005 Ex. PW-1/7, and the postal receipts Mark PW-1/A.
21.
PW-2, Shri Sunil Vadehra, former Director and Head of India
Operations of the Respondent Company, who deposed about the e-mail
dated 09.07.2002 and connected correspondence Ex. PW-2/1 (coll).
22.
DW-1, Shri Banty Bisht, Manager (HR) of the Defendant Company,
who proved the copy of the Minute Book Ex. DW-1/A. The deposed about
the defence as stated in the Written Statement.
23.
The learned ADJ, upon appreciation of the evidence led by the
parties, concluded that the Appellant/Plaintiff had failed to establish any
contractual arrangement, whereby the reduced component of salary was to
be repaid at a later date or that one month's salary was contractually payable
as bonus. Consequently, the Suit was dismissed vide Judgment and
Decree dated 09.04.2024.
24.
Aggrieved by the said Judgment and Decree dated 09.04.2024, the
present Appeal has been preferred by the Appellant/Plaintiff.
25.
The grounds of challenge primarily are that the learned ADJ erred in
dismissing the Suit despite the documentary record, particularly the e-mail
dated 09.07.2002 Ex. PW-2/1, consistently employing the terminology
"deferred salary", establishing that the salary reduction during the financial
year 2002-2003 was a deferment and not restructuring.
26.
It is further submitted that the impugned Judgment is self-
contradictory inasmuch as the learned ADJ has placed reliance upon the
decisions in Dale & Carrington Invt. (P) Ltd. v. P.K. Prathapan, (2005) 1
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
SCC 212 : 2004 SCC OnLine SC 1067, and Mukesh Hans v. Uma Bhasin,
2010 SCC OnLine Del 2776, to underscore the importance of a Board
Resolution, while overlooking that admittedly no Board Resolution exists
authorising the salary reduction either as a deferment or as a restructuring;
that the said decisions pertain to internal disputes amongst shareholders and
personal liability of Directors and were inapplicable to the facts in hand. In
the present case, the communication dated 01.04.2005 Ex. P-10 issued by
the CEO of the Respondent Company, established the case of the
Appellant/Plaintiff.
27.
It is also stated that the learned ADJ failed to address the issue of
interest on the terminal dues of Rs.3,96,860/-, which had accrued on
23.07.2004 which were paid only during the pendency of the Suit, in three
instalments, the last being paid on 05.10.2011, accepted without prejudice;
and that a balance sum of Rs.9,838/- remained unpaid.
28.
The Appellant has accordingly, prayed that the impugned Judgment
and Decree dated 09.04.2024 be set aside and the Suit be decreed.
29.
The Respondent, in its Short Note of Submissions, has contended
that the salary reduction during the Financial Year 2002-2003 was a
restructuring of remuneration, necessitated by the financial constraints faced
by the Company in the aftermath of the events of 11.09.2001, and was not a
deferment of salary. This is evident from the communication dated
01.04.2002 Ex. D-1 itself, which referred to restructuring as an "interim
measure", it did not contain any promise for repayment on a future date.
30.
It is further submitted that the Appellant, who continued in service
even after restoration of salary w.e.f. 01.04.2003, did not raise any
contemporaneous claim for the alleged arrears. The reliance has been placed
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
upon the Judgment dated 06.08.2018 passed by Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in M/s Aithent Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Archana Verma (RFA
608/2014), wherein claims arising out of the salary restructuring exercise
were dismissed, which Judgment has attained finality.
Submissions heard and Record perused.
31.
It is the case of the Plaintiff/Appellant, Ms. Anju Dhawan, that she
joined the Defendant Company, as Senior Member, Consulting Staff on
01.10.1993 and continued in service until 22.07.2004, when she tendered her
resignation, which was duly accepted by the Defendant Company.
32.
She further deposed that at the time of her separation, she was
drawing a gross monthly salary of Rs.83,333/-, as recorded in the Salary
Certificate dated 28.07.2004 Ex. P-2, issued by the Defendant. The factum
of her employment for the period 01.10.1993 to 22.07.2004 is further
confirmed by the Experience Certificate dated 28.07.2004 Ex. P-1, which
records that the Appellant "has left the services of our organisation on her
own accord." The Plaintiff further deposed that prior to the events giving
rise to the present dispute, she was drawing a gross monthly salary of
Rs.67,500/-, comprising Basic of Rs.37,500/-, House Rent Allowance of
Rs.18,750/- and reimbursements aggregating to Rs.11,250/-, as is borne out
by the Salary Slip for March 2002 Ex. P-3. These facts are admitted by the
Defendant Company.
33.
The entire controversy in the present case, centres around the
reduction of the Plaintiff's salary during Financial Year 01.04.2002 till
31.03.2003. It is an admitted position that with effect from 01.04.2002, the
Plaintiff's Basic and House Rent Allowance components were reduced from
Rs.56,250/- per month to Rs.36,000/- per month, and continued until
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
31.03.2003. It is further undisputed that with effect from 01.04.2003, her
Basic and House Rent Allowance components, were restored. Thus, there
was an admitted reduction of Rs.20,250/- per month in the Plaintiff's salary
for one year i.e. the period from 01.04.2002 to 31.03.2003, aggregating to
Rs.2,43,000/-.
34.
The circumstances leading to reduction in salary for Financial Year
2002-03, were explained by the Plaintiff in her testimony and corroborated
by PW-2 Sh. Sunil Vadehra, then Director and Head of India Operations of
the Defendant Company. It was stated that the Defendant Company faced a
severe liquidity crunch on account of substantial investment in infrastructure
during the year 2001, accentuated by delay in receipt of payments from its
affiliated entities namely Velos, Canyon Blue and Zero to N.
35.
Towards the end of March, 2002, discussions were held within the
senior management of the Defendant Company, comprising Mr. N. Venu
Gopal (CEO), Mr. H.R. Ahluwalia (Vice President – HR), Mr. Sunil
Vadehra (Director and Head of India Operations), Mr. Sanjay Verma (Vice
President – Technology) and Mr. Rajeeva Gupta (Associate Vice President –
Technology). It was thereafter, decided that an Open House Meeting of all
employees be convened to share the prevailing situation and seek their
cooperation.
36.
The proposed measure involved deferment of a portion of the
employees' salaries on a graded scale for a period of up to twelve months. It
was represented that upon expiry of the said period, the salaries would be
restored to their original levels. The management also promised a special
bonus equivalent to one month's salary to each employee.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
37.
As per the Plaintiff, under the aforesaid arrangement, the Defendant
Company agreed with employees drawing a gross salary above Rs.12,000/per month to defer a portion of their salary for Financial Year 2002-2003,
till April 2003. The deferred portion of the salary was determined on a
graded scale, namely 15%, 20%, 25% and 30% for employees drawing gross
monthly salaries in the ranges of Rs.12,000/- to Rs.20,000/-, Rs.20,000/- to
Rs.30,000/-, Rs.30,000/- to Rs.60,000/- and above Rs.60,000/- respectively.
38.
Consequently, the amount of deferred salary attributable to the
Plaintiff for Financial Year 2002-2003, on the 30% slab, was Rs.2,43,000/-.
Upon adding the promised bonus equivalent to one month's salary of
Rs.67,500/-, the Plaintiff claimed that a total sum of Rs.3,10,500/- became
due and payable to her, which was not paid by the Defendant Company.
39.
The Defendant Company, on the other hand, contended that the
arrangement was not one of deferment of salary and that no promise had
been made to pay the reduced salary amount with effect from 01.04.2003 to
the employees. In fact, owing to the financial difficulties being faced by the
Company, the salaries of employees were restructured for a period of one
year. It was, therefore, asserted that there was no question of any deferred
salary becoming payable to the Plaintiff or any other employee.
40.
The first significant document is Letter dated 01.04.2002 Ex. D-1,
issued by the Defendant Company to the Appellant/Plaintiff at the very
inception of the disputed arrangement. The said document is the only
contemporaneous communication addressed individually to the Appellant by
the Defendant Company, about the salary reduction, and is admittedly
signed by the Appellant in acknowledgement of acceptance. The same is
reproduced as under:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
41.
Significantly, the said document characterises the modification of
remuneration as a "re-structure" and as an "interim measure", and is
completely silent on any deferment of salary or on any obligation
undertaken by the Defendant Company to repay the reduced component of
salary at a future date. The Plaintiff has admittedly signed the said document
and has admitted her signatures on the Letter, in her cross-examination,
conceding that she did not give any objections regarding Ex. D-1 to the
Defendant Company in writing. There is no recital of conditional acceptance
on the face of the document.
42.
The admissions made by the Plaintiff further reveal that there was no
formal written Agreement, Board Resolution or other contemporaneous
document, recording any obligation on the part of the Defendant Company
to repay the reduced salary at a future date.
The Plaintiff specifically
conceded in her cross-examination that at the time of restructuring, no
objection in writing was given by her to the Company; that during her entire
period of service she never gave any Letter regarding restructuring of her
salary; that there was no written letter given by the Defendant Company
regarding payment of the restructured/deferred salary; and that she could not
produce any document regarding the deferred salary having been paid to any
other employee.
43.
The Plaintiff has placed reliance upon the e-mail dated 09.07.2002
Ex. PW-2/1, addressed by the CEO of the Defendant Company to the Vice
President HR, which uses the terminology "deferred salary". However, the
said e-mail is an internal management communication, not addressed to or
signed by the Appellant. The only document communicated to and signed by
the Appellant on the subject of the salary reduction is Ex. D-1, which
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
characterises the arrangement as a "re-structure". Internal management
correspondence, cannot displace the express terms of the written contract
between the parties.
44.
The e-mail dated 09.07.2002 contemplated partial reversal of the
deferment decision, only for the lowest salary slab. For the higher slabs to
which the Appellant belonged, it stated that the cases "would be reviewed at
the end of the next quarter and implemented gradually" language of future
contemplation rather than of present commitment. No subsequent
communication crystallised the said contemplation, into a binding
obligation.
45.
Another aspect which is of immense importance, is that the Plaintiff
continued in service of the Defendant Company for over fifteen months,
after the alleged date of accrual of the deferred salary on 01.04.2003, and
ultimately resigned on 22.07.2004. The Experience Certificate Ex. P-1
records that she left the services "on her own accord." If it was indeed a case
of deferment, there is no reason why she would not have protested, insisted
or claimed her outstanding dues at the time of her resignation, particularly
since the alleged due date of 01.04.2003 had passed well over a year earlier.
46.
The conduct of the Plaintiff, in not claiming any outstanding dues at
the time of her resignation, and her filing of the Suit only on 01.04.2006,
also lends support to the conclusion that it was not a formally agreed policy
of the Defendant Company, to pay the deferred salary.
47.
The Appellant/Plaintiff has also placed reliance upon the letter dated
01.04.2005 Ex. P-10, wherein the CEO of the Respondent Company stated
that he remained committed to clear the dues of the Appellant/Plaintiff. The
same is reproduced as under:
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
48.
However, the said communication neither quantifies the alleged dues
nor identifies their nature. There is no reference to the reduced salary for
Financial Year 2002-2003, no mention of any compensation bonus and no
recital that the salary reduction was merely a deferment to be repaid at a
future date.
49.
It is not disputed that there were discussions regarding payment of a
one month's salary bonus to employees. However, the Appellant/Plaintiff
has failed to place on record any material to establish that the said bonus
crystallised into a binding contractual obligation. The consistent stand of the
Respondent has been that the same was contemplated only as an incentive
and not as a legal commitment. In the absence of any document or other
cogent evidence demonstrating that the bonus became payable as a matter of
right, the claim towards compensation bonus cannot be sustained.
50.
The Plaintiff has relied upon the aforesaid two communications, but
from these, there is no admission of there being any deferment of salary or
the entitlement of the Plaintiff for the same.
51.
The learned Trial Court has carefully appreciated the evidence
brought on record and has rightly concluded that while reduction of salary
during the relevant period stands admitted, the Appellant/Plaintiff failed to
establish that such reduction merely constituted a deferment creating a
legally enforceable obligation to repay the amount at a later date.
52.
Significantly, during the pendency of the Suit, the Respondent
admitted its liability towards the terminal dues of the Appellant/Plaintiff on
account of gratuity, leave encashment and connected dues, and vide Order
dated 12.01.2011 was directed to pay a sum of Rs.3,96,860/- (being
Rs.4,05,498/- less statutory tax deduction of Rs.8,638/-). The said amount
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
was paid in three instalments, namely, Rs.1,50,000/- on 29.03.2011,
Rs.1,50,000/- on 06.07.2011 and Rs.96,860/- on 05.10.2011, and was
accepted by the Appellant/Plaintiff. The said terminal dues, accordingly, no
longer survive as a live dispute in the present Appeal, and the claim now
pressed in the Appeal, is confined to interest on the said paid amount
53.
The Appellant has, in the present Appeal, pressed a claim for interest
at 12% per annum on the said sum of Rs.3,96,860/- from the date of accrual
on 23.07.2004 till the respective dates of payment, on the strength of the
assurance contained in the letter dated 01.04.2005 Ex. P-10.
54.
The said claim cannot be sustained for the simple reason that the
Appellant had been offered this amount, and the Respondent Company had
offered a cheque of Rs.3,96,860/- after deduction of tax of Rs.8,638/-, in
September, 2005. However, the appellant herself had declined to accept it.
55.
The Plaintiff's claim of a balance unpaid sum of Rs.9,838/- on account
of Provident Fund, Leave Encashment and connected dues is equally
untenable. The Appellant has not placed on record any computation
establishing the said balance. The Respondent has paid Rs.3,96,860/- in
satisfaction of admitted terminal dues of Rs.4,05,498/-, the differential of
Rs.8,638/- representing the statutory tax deduction at source. No further
amount stands established on the record.
56.
The terminal dues of Rs.4,05,498/- having stood satisfied by payment
of Rs.3,96,860/- to the Appellant, during the pendency of the Suit (after
statutory deduction of tax of Rs.8,638/-), and the claims on account of
interest on the said paid amount, and the alleged balance sum of Rs.9,838/-,
having been found to be unsustainable for the reasons recorded hereinabove,
no further direction is called for on this account.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
57.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby, dismissed
along with pending Applications.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 16, 2026/R
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
18:14:22
RFA 648/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review