The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. In view of the aforesaid averments made in the affidavit-inreply, the petition would not survive and is accordingly dismissed as the grievance raised in the petition is not in existence as the authority has already allotted the final plot No.88 as per Form “F” and has removed the super structure existed on 12.0 Mtr TP road in question with regard to the implementation of the town planning scheme No.51. Notice is discharged.”
6. Having regard to the request made by learned Advocate for the petitioners and the order passed by the learned Co-ordinate Bench and the Hon’ble Division Bench, the following directions, in the considered opinion of this Court, would meet with the ends of justice. (i) Special Civil Application Nos. 3278 of 2012 and 3622 of 2012 are disposed of as rejected, on basis of the observations of the learned Coordinate Bench made in the order dated 25.02.2021 in Special Civil Application No. 14607 of 2011. C/SCA/3278/2012 (ii) ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026 Liberty is reserved in favour of the petitioners herein to challenge allotment of final plot so made in favour of the original owner, if there is any such right available to the petitioners and also subject to just exceptions. It is also clarified that this Court has not expressed any opinion with regard to maintainability of such challenge, if made before appropriate forum. (NIKHIL S. KARIEL,J) Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/3278/2012
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3278 of 2012
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 3622 of 2012
==========================================================
ANJALI BIKES -THRO ITS PROPRE ITOR RAJKUMAR R PANDEY
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT THRO PRINCIPAL SECRETARY & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. HARSH D. DESAI(17769) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MR. MILAN. B. DESAI(17768) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MS POOJA CHOUDHARY, AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 1,4
M/S RJ RAWAL ASSOC.(1987) for the Respondent(s) No. 3
MR. ARCHIT P JANI(7304) for the Respondent(s) No. 2
NOTICE SERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 1,3,4
RULE SERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 5,6
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE NIKHIL S. KARIEL
Date : 10/06/2026
COMMON ORAL ORDER
1.
Heard learned Advocate Mr. Kushal Mehta for learned Advocate
Mr. Milan B. Desai for the petitioners, learned AGP Ms. Pooja
Choudhary for the respondent-State and learned Advocate Mr. Gaurang
Vaghela for M/s R. J. Rawal Associates for the respondent No.3 in both
the petitions as well as learned Advocate Ms. Simpal Rathod for learned
Advocate Mr. Nandish Y. Chudgar for the respondent No.2 in Special
Civil Application No. 3622 of 2012.
2.
At the outset, learned Advocate Mr. Gaurang Vaghela on behalf of
the respondent-Corporation draws the attention of this Court to decision
of a learned Co-ordinate Bench of this Court dated 25.02.2021 in Special
C/SCA/3278/2012
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
Civil Application No. 14607 of 2011 and would submit that the issue
raised in the present petitions are covered by the decision of the learned
Co-ordinate Bench. Learned Advocate would submit that the petitioners
therein, were identically situated to the petitioners herein and whereas it
is submitted that except for the name of the petitioners, the shop number
and the suit number, all other aspects remain the same. Learned Advocate
would submit that since the learned Co-ordinate Bench has rejected the
said writ petition vide decision dated 25.02.2021 and since the same
squarely covers the issue raised herein, this Court may reject the present
petitions also.
3.
The above proposition could not be countered by learned Advocate
Mr. Mehta on behalf of the petitioners, more particularly this Court has
perused the petitions as well as the affidavit-in-replies and whereas this
Court is in agreement with learned Advocate Mr. Vaghela that the
petitioners before the learned Co-ordinate Bench were identically situated
to the petitioners herein.
4.
At the same time, learned Advocate Mr. Mehta would draw the
attention of this Court to order dated 29.0.2022 in Letters Patent Appeal
No. 425 of 2022 preferred in Special Civil Application No. 14607 of
2011, i.e. the Letters Patent Appeal against the order dated 25.02.2021
C/SCA/3278/2012
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
passed by the learned Co-ordinate Bench, referred to hereinabove.
Learned Advocate would submit that the Hon’ble Division Bench of this
Court while refusing to interfere with the decision of the learned Coordinate Bench, had reserved liberty in favour of the original petitioners appellants therein to challenge the order of allotment in favour of the
respondent No.5 therein, i.e. the original owner of the land in question.
Learned Advocate, taking a cue from the said order, would request that
similar liberty, as had been reserved in favour of the original petitioners –
appellants before the Hon’ble Division Bench, may be reserved in favour
of the present petitioners.
5.
Considering the submissions made by the learned counsels, more
particularly since it is undisputed that the order dated 25.02.2021 covers
the issue raised in both the writ petitions and also considering the fact that
the order of the Hon’ble Division Bench dated 29.09.2022 confirms the
order of the learned Co-ordinate Bench, relevant portion of the decision
dated 25.02.2021 is required to be reproduced herein below :
“2. The grievance raised in this petition pertains to the allotment
of final plot to the petitioners in the draft town planning scheme
and without giving the possession of the final plots to the
petitioners the possession of the property of the petitioners should
not be taken by the respondents.
3.
It is not in dispute that the town planning scheme No.51,
C/SCA/3278/2012
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
Ahmedabad was sanctioned by the State Government under
Section 65 of the Gujarat Town Planning and Urban Development
Act, 1976 (for short ‘the Act, 1976’) and pursuant there to the
Ahmedabad Municipal Commissioner issued notice under Section
68 of the Act, 1976 read with Rule 33 of the Gujarat Town
Planning and Urban Development Rules, 1979 (for short ‘the Rule,
1979’) in the year 2006. After the draft town planing scheme was
sanctioned by the State Government, the Town Planning Officer
was appointed and the town planning scheme No.51 (Khokhra),
Mhemdabad-East was published. There were civil proceedings
initiated by the petitioners against the Ahmedabad Municipal
Corporation challenging the aforesaid notices issued in the year
2006, however, notices of motion applications were rejected in the
year 2010 in Civil Suit No.47 of 2007 and Civil Suit No.53 of
2007 as the same were not maintainable. The petitioners thereafter
preferred the Appeal from Order No.247 of 2007 and Appeal from
Order No. 248 of 2007 which were dismissed by this Court (Coram
: Hon’ble Mr.Justice Anant S. Dave as he was then) vide judgment
and order dated 3rd August, 2010. The petitioners have therefore
filed this petition.
4.
It is not in dispute that the respondent-Corporation issued
notice under Section 68 of the Act, 1976 and Rule 33 of the Rules,
1979 pursuant to the sanctioned town planning scheme. Therefore,
this petition is not maintainable. Moreover, the Deputy Estate
Officer of the Municipal Corporation has filed an affidavit on 27 th
June, 2012 wherein, following averments are made :
“2. The Answering Respondent being an implementing
authority states that Final Plot no. 88 (Original Plot no.
52/2) is already alotted to its Original owner Shri
Becharbhai Balabhai Bajania as per “F” form and final
award and had removed super structure existed on 12.0 mtr
T.P. Road in question for implementation of T P Scheme no.
51(Khokhra ~Mehmdavad). A copy of the map showing
superstructure removed by the corporation as well as some
of the photographs are annexed hereto and marked as
ANNEXURE ~ “R1",
3. The Answering Respondent states that as provided under
C/SCA/3278/2012
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
section 68 of the T. P. Act, 1976, the eviction proceedings
have been done by the corporation for implementing the TP
Scheme in accordance with the procedure provided under
the act.
4. The Answering Respondent further states that earlier Civil
Suit no. 47 of 2007 filed by the petitioner no. 2 for
declaration and injunction contending that the plaintiff
( Petitioner no. 2) is the owner of suit premises situated at
Ghodasar, near Cadila Bridge, Anmedabad. The Answering
Respondent in the said Civil Suit was directed to consider
the question of Compensation or to allot the area as claimed
by the plaintiff as early as possible. The Answering
Respondent further states that thereafter the petitioner no.2
filed another suit being Civil Suit no. 53 of 2007 and prayed
for declaration and injunction inter-alia contending that the
plaintiff ( Petitioner no. 2) is the owner of the suit premises
situated at Ghodasar, near Cadila Bridge, Ahmedabad. The
Ld. City Civil Court rejected the said suit on the principle of
“resjudicata”, however the earlier order was modified to the
extent that question of compensation shall be decided by the
concerned Town Planning Officer. Copies of the orders are
annexed at page 96 and page no. 102 of the petitioner at
Annexure K and Annexure L respectively.
5. The Answering Respondent further states and submits that
the order passed below exhibit 54 dated 12.07.2010 and
dated 16.04.2010 were challenged by the petitioners by way
of group of Appeal from Order numbers 245 of 2010 to 248
of 2010. It is humbly submitted that this Hon'ble Court upon
hearing the said petitions vide its order dated 03.08.2010
was pleased to reject the said petitions also (A.O.'s). Thus,
there is NO question of compensation and allotment of plot
remains with the petitioners and stands concluded by the
dismissal of petitions.
6. The Answering Respondent further states that petitioners
have filed present petition seeking appropriate writ, order or
direction, directing Respondents to give appropriate final
plots in the same survey numbers having the same
commercial potentiality in lieu of their original plot.
C/SCA/3278/2012
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
7. The Answering Respondent states that the scope of giving
appropriate final plots to the petitioners herein have already
been dealt with by this Hon'ble Court in the Appeal from
order no. 245 of 2010 to Appeal from Order no. 248 of 2010.
Hence, the present petition would be operated as
“resjudicata” and hence the same deserves to be dismissed
and not maintainable. Moreover, the plot is question is
already allotted handed over to the Original owner as above
stated.
8. Since the petitioners could not obtain any relief in the civil
Suits as well as Appeal from Orders, they have preferred
present Petition and have tried to start second round of
litigation on same grounds. ”
5.
In view of the aforesaid averments made in the affidavit-inreply, the petition would not survive and is accordingly dismissed
as the grievance raised in the petition is not in existence as the
authority has already allotted the final plot No.88 as per Form “F”
and has removed the super structure existed on 12.0 Mtr TP road in
question with regard to the implementation of the town planning
scheme No.51. Notice is discharged.”
6.
Having regard to the request made by learned Advocate for the
petitioners and the order passed by the learned Co-ordinate Bench and
the Hon’ble Division Bench, the following directions, in the considered
opinion of this Court, would meet with the ends of justice.
(i)
Special Civil Application Nos. 3278 of 2012 and 3622 of 2012 are
disposed of as rejected, on basis of the observations of the learned Coordinate Bench made in the order dated 25.02.2021 in Special Civil
Application No. 14607 of 2011.
C/SCA/3278/2012
(ii)
ORDER DATED: 10/06/2026
Liberty is reserved in favour of the petitioners herein to challenge
allotment of final plot so made in favour of the original owner, if there is
any such right available to the petitioners and also subject to just
exceptions. It is also clarified that this Court has not expressed any
opinion with regard to maintainability of such challenge, if made before
appropriate forum.
(NIKHIL S. KARIEL,J)
BDSONGARA
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review