Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 4062 of 2020
Anita Devi, aged about 50 years, Wife of Late Arvind Kumar Tripathi,
Resident of: Village & P.O- Bishunpur P.S.- Govindpur, DistrictNawada, Bihar.
...
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand.
2. Registrar General, Jharkhand High Court, P.O & P.S: Doranda,
District: Ranchi, State-Jharkhand
3. Basanti Lakra, W/o Late Arvind Kumar Tripathi, R/o: Q No. A/31
Sachiwalay Paryavaran Vibhag, Nepal House, P.O. & P.S.
Doranda, Dist: Ranchi, State-Jharkhand.
...
Respondents
--------HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ PRASAD
--------For the Petitioner:
Mr. Rajeev Kumar, Advocate
Ms Niteshwari Kumari, Advocate
For the State:
Mr Shirsh Mazumdar, A.C. to S.C.-II
For Resp. No.2:
Mr Amit Kumar Das, Advocate
Mr. Shivam Utkarsh Sahay, Advocate
For Resp. No.3:
None
--------14/Dated: 04.11.2026
CORAM:
1.
Heard Ms Niteshwari Kumari, learned A.C. to Mr Rajeev Kumar,
learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr Amit Kumar Das, learned
Senior Advocate, who appears with Mr Shivam Utkarsh Sahay,
learned counsel for the 2nd respondent and Mr Shirsh
Mazumdar, learned A.C. to S.C.-II for the State of Jharkhand.
2.
The petitioner, the first wife of late Arvind Kumar Tripathi,
ex-staff car driver of the High Court, has filed this petition
claiming compassionate appointment for her son, Sri Aalok
Kumar, and payment of the death-cum-retiral dues.
3.
The Registrar General of this Court filed a supplementary
counter affidavit on 02.11.2026, annexing the minutes of the
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
meeting dated 17.09.2026 of the Committee constituted to
consider
compassionate
appointment
matters
in
the
Establishment of the High Court.
4.
On the issue of compassionate appointment, the Committee
interacted with Anita Devi (petitioner), Sri Vishnu Kumar (son of
late Arvind Kumar Tripathi and Anita Devi), Sri Aalok Kumar
(son of late Arvind Kumar Tripathi and Anita Devi), Smt Basanti
Lakra (2nd wife of late Arvind Kumar Tripathi), Sri Aman Anand
(son of late Arvind Kumar Tripathi and Smt Basanti Lakra) and
Ms Anjali Anand (daughter of late Arvind Kumar Tripathi and
Smt Basanti Lakra).
5.
After interacting with all the above-referred persons, the
Committee has made the following recommendations: “In the light of this backdrop, the Committee,
having taken into consideration, the totality of facts
as well as upon perusal of the documents available
on record, the oral submissions of the family
members of Late Arvind Kumar Tripathi before the
Committee
and
the
statutory
provisions
for
appointment on Compassionate Ground, is of the
opinion that Sri Aalok Kumar S/o Late Arvind Kumar
Tripathi, Ex-Staff Car Driver of this Court, who died in
harness on 21.01.2020, appears to be eligible for
appointment
on
compassionate
ground
in
the
Establishment of this Court.
Accordingly, the Committee recommends the
name of Sri Aalok Kumar, S/o Late Arvind Kumar
Tripathi, Ex-Staff Car Driver of this Court, who died in
harness on 21.01.2020 for appointment to the
available vacant post of Peon carrying pay in PayLevel 1 of the 7th PRC Pay-Matrix (corresponding to
the Grade Pay of Rs. 1800/-) under the 6th PRC PayScale; however, this recommendation shall remain
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
subject to the
condition that before
offer
of
appointment is issued in favour of Sri Aalok Kumar,
Sri Kumar shall submit a declaration form, in the
prescribed Form III (in two sets) duly sworn, signed
and affidavited by him before a Notary-Public to the
following effect(i)
that he will invariably take care of the
livelihood of all those dependent and eligible
family members of Late Arvind Kumar Tripathi,
in whose favour, the Succession certificate
dated
31.10.2025
has
been
issued
by
Additional Judicial Commissioner XI, Ranchi
and as per the consent given by him, he shall
also pay Rupees Three Thousand (Rs. 3,000/-)
per month each to both Sri Aman Anand till he
gets a regular employment and to Ms. Anjali
Anand,
till
she
either
gets
any
regular
employment or till she gets re-married;
(ii)
that in case, any complain against him is
received in the Court made by any of the
dependent and eligible family members of Late
Arvind Kumar Tripathi, in whose favour, the
Succession Certificate dated 31.10.2025 has
been
issued
by
Additional
Judicial
Commissioner XI, Ranchi, then the monthly
emoluments (Basic Pay admissible dearness
allowance) that he will be entitled to, shall be
apportioned among such members on pro-rata
basis; and
(iii)
that in case, he denies the apportionment of
his admissible emoluments (Basic Pay +
admissible dearness allowance), as mentioned
above at para (ii), then the Court shall be at
liberty to remove him from service and
consider any other dependent and eligible
family
members
for
appointment
on
compassionate ground in the Establishment of
the Court;
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
As such, taking into consideration, the totality of
facts as well as upon perusal of the documents available
on record and in light of the statutory provisions for
appointment on Compassionate Ground, the liberty to
remove him from service and consider any other
dependent
and
eligible
family
appointment
on
compassionate
members
ground
in
for
the
Establishment of the Court;
As such, taking into consideration, the totality of
facts as well as upon perusal of the documents available
on record and in light of the statutory provisions for
appointment on Compassionate Ground, the Committee
is of the opinion that Sri Aalok Kumar S/o Late Arvind
Kumar Tripathi, Ex-Staff Car Driver of this Court, who
died in harness on 21.01.2020, is eligible to be appointed
on Compassionate Ground in the Establishment of this
Court. Accordingly, the Committee recommends the
name of Sri Aalok Kumar for appointment to the post
of Peon, subject to the condition that the aforesaid
duly notarized Affidavit to the effect that he will look
after all the family members invariably, be filed by
him.”
6.
Insofar as payment of death-cum-retiral benefits and the issue
of compassionate appointment is concerned, paragraphs 11
and 12 of the Registrar General’s affidavit state as follows:“11. That, so far as the claim relating to the death
benefits as well as Family Pension of Late Arvind
Kumar Tripathi is concerned, upon consideration of
the matter and the Succession Certificate submitted
by the Petitioner-Anita Devi, it has been proposed
that the disbursal of amount to be effected in the
following manner(i)
the payment of all benefits payable w.r.t. Late
Arvind Kumar Tripathi, ex-Staff Car Driver of
the Court who died in harness on 21.01.2020
which includes payment of Ex-Gratia amount,
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
G.I.S. amount, G.P.F. amount, Death Gratuity
and Leave encashment amount may be made
in favour of all the eight (08) persons, in equal
shares in whose favour, Sucession Certificate
has been issued by over-riding the nominations
(wherever applicable) made by Late Arvind
Kumar Tripathi during his life-time under the
said schemes;
(ii)
the matter of Family Pension may be decided
as
per
the
provisions
stipulated
under
Jharkhand Pension Rules, 2000 read with CCS
(Pension) Rules 1972 [Rule 54 (8) (iii) and
DoP&PW O.M. 1/16/1996-P& PW dated 27the
November 2012, sub rule 6(ii) of Rule 54 and
sub rule 7(b) & 7 (c) of Rule 54 CCS (Pension)
Rules 1972] which reads as under"If deceased employee is survived by more
than one widow and chidren from both
wedlock, family pension will be shared
equally by first wife being legally wedded
wife along with child from second wedlock
i.e. 50% each. However, second widow will
not have any claim for family pension as
second marriage is null and void and she is
not holding the status of legally wedded
wife.";
[DoP&PW
O.M.
1/16/1996-P&PW
dated 27.11.2012]
"The eligibility of each child sharing
pension along with legally wedded wife will
be considered as per Rule 54 (8) (iii). Their
claim will be considered in the order of their
birth, and the younger of them will not be
eligible for family pension unless the elder
next above him becomes ineligible for the
grant of family pension";
"In the case of an unmarried son
family pension will be payable until he
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
attains the age of twenty-five years or until
he gets married or until he starts earning
his livelihood, whichever is earliest." [sub
rule 6(ii) of rule 54];
"If children from second wedlock
becomes ineligible to receive pension, such
share of the family pension would not get
lapsed but would be payable to legally
wedded wife or her children as the case
may be in full i.e. 100%."[sub rule 7 (b) &
7(c) of Rule 54].
12. That, in view of the aforesaid facts and subsequent
developments,
the
answering
respondent
respectfully states that considering the Succession
Certificate granted by a competent court of law and
produced by the Petitioner and the same having
been considered in accordance with the relevant
policy, rules, guidelines governing the field of
compassionate appointment and proportionment of
death-cum-retiral benefits among the claimants from
both sides, decision has been taken to extend the
benefits to the respective claimants. Now there is no
impediment in extending the benefits to the
respective claimants and the process thereof will
start after the instant Writ Petition is disposed of.”
7.
The learned counsel for the petitioner states that the third
respondent has been duly served in this matter. Further,
learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is
agreeable to the disposal of this petition based upon what is set
out in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the Registrar General’s affidavit
and in terms of the recommendations of the Committee made in
its meeting held on 17.09.2026.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner and the petitioner present in
the Court further state that they will ensure that Sri Aalok Kumar
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
files the necessary affidavits/undertakings and complies with
the undertaking to pay Rs. 3,000/- per month to Sri Aman
Anand until he secures regular employment and further pay
Rs. 3,000/- per month to Ms Anjali Anand until she either
secures regular employment or gets remarried.
9.
Accordingly, we dispose of this petition by directing the
respondents to pay the death-cum-retiral benefits in terms of
what is undertaken in paragraphs 11 and 12 of the Registrar
General’s affidavit dated 02.11.2026. The respondents must
ensure that this payment is made as expeditiously as possible
and in any event within two months from today.
10.
Further, subject to what is set out in the following paragraph, we
direct the respondents to pass suitable orders for the
appointment of Sri Aalok Kumar on a compassionate basis, in
accordance with the terms and conditions set out in the
Committee’s recommendations.
11.
However, one condition of the recommendation is that if any
complaint is received against Sri Aalok Kumar from any
dependent or eligible family member of late Arvind Kumar
Tripathi, then Sri Aalok Kumar’s salary will be apportioned
among such family members on a pro rata basis. Further, if he
refuses to apportion his salary, Sri Aalok Kumar would be liable
to be removed from service and substituted by any other
dependent and eligible family member for appointment on
compassionate grounds in the Establishment of the High Court.
These conditions appear somewhat problematic.
2026:JHHC:32439-DB
12.
If Sri Aalok Kumar fails to pay Rs 3,000/- per month to both
Sri Aman Anand and Ms Anjali Anand, a suitable condition can
be inserted that these amounts would be deducted from his
salary and paid over to Sri Aman Anand and Ms Anjali Anand.
However, the condition that his salary will be equally
apportioned amongst all dependents and family members, and
that his appointment will be substituted by another family
member, does not appear appropriate.
13.
Therefore, subject to the above, necessary appointment orders
must be issued to appoint Sri Aalok Kumar to the vacant post of
Peon, as referred to in the Committee's recommendation. Such
appointment order must be issued to Sri Aalok Kumar within
two months from the date he furnishes the necessary
undertakings and complies with the other prescribed formalities.
14.
This order is made in the presence of the petitioner Smt. Anita
Devi and her son Sri Aalok Kumar, who have expressly
accepted the condition of paying Rs. 3,000/- per month each to
Sri Aman Anand until he gets regular employment, and to Ms
Anjali Anand until she gets regular employment or remarries.
15.
This petition is disposed of in the above terms. No costs.
16.
All concerned must act on an authenticated copy of this order.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Manoj Prasad, J.)
November 04, 2026
N.A.F.R.
APK/VK
Uploaded on 06.11.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review