Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
"
$%& $ '
()
&$
"
#$
%%$
(
*
!!
&
'
"
(
!)
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
)
)
)
!)
)
)
* +
%
))
+
))
)
"
# +
%
&
'
!
(
,
-2-
!
+
%/ %
!
'
$+
!
!
)
"
%/
%%%
)
!!
$
(
.
% $
!
'
(
$ 2
'
(
!
'
-
)
%
% $
$%/ $ %
%' ( %
' ('33(' (' ('$( ! )
!
!
"
)
1% %
!
)
+
( 2
!
! "
!
"
"
536 789393:; 36 <3=8> ?;>8@
BDB@3E
?@BE65B
B;539B
%
BDB3;69 958 789393:;8@ BAA?68>
:
HC
8A93:;
:
+ 3;
:
1%
@3G8
65:E
)B=BH?@BD3
BDB@
:=3A8
1 B;>
@ I
8A93:;
+ :<
5B@B93CB
9: F?B65 958 7@:A88>3;D6
% $ B@363;D :?9 :<
7?;365BH=8 ?;>8@ 68A93:;6 $%/
$
)
$ %
$ :<
7=
%
)
@8D3698@8>
<:@ 958 :<<8;A86
%' (
%
%/
B;>
8A93:;
-3-
' ('33(' (' ('$( :< )
:< @=
369 B;>
@867:;>8;9
:
66369B;9
%%% 78;>3;D :; 958 <3=8
8663:;6 "?>D8 )B=BH?@BD3
BH@3>D8>
:
# :=3A8 :;
A9
<BA96 :<
AB68
B@8
95B9
=:>D8> 958 A:G7=B3;9 H8<:@8 @867:;>8;9
+
%
%
8A9?@8@
B==8D3;D 95B9 658 36 I:@E3;D B6
3;
5B@B;BHB6BJB
;3J8@639C
3>CB;BDB@ )B=BH?@BD3 B;> IB6 B77:3;98> B6 B
?78@J36:@
<:@
)B@;B9BEB
?95:@39C <:@ 958 @8A@?39G8;9 :< !
8KBG3;B93:;
KBG3;B93:;
A:;>?A98>
HC
36 <?@958@ B==8D8> 95B9 :; 958 >B98 :< 8KBG3;B93:; 3 8
+%
%
B9 BH:?9
IB6 D:3;D :; 958
% BG
87?9C
I58; 958 8KBG3;B93:;
3@8A9:@ :< )
ABG8 B=:;D I395
:=3A8 9: 958 8KBG3;B93:; A8;98@ B;> 9BE8; A?69:>C :< :;8
@3G?@93 BAA?68>
:
B;> 9BE8; 53G :?963>8 958
B== <:@ 3;98@@:DB93:; B;> @8A:J8@8>
KBG
=?89::95 >8J3A8 <@:G
53G
;
8;F?3@C
GHB@8865#BAA?68>
:
@8J8B=8>
IB6
95B9
63993;D
H@:958@
:?963>8
8KBG3;B93:; A8;98@ 3; 958 AB@ B;> B;6I8@3;D 958 F?8693:;6
-4-
B;> <?@958@ @8J8B=8> 95B9 :;8
B93= BAA?68>
:
B;>
:958@6 B@8 58=73;D 53G 3; 958 8KBG3;B93:; 9: ?68 958
=?89::95 >8J3A8 9: I@398 958 8KBG3;B93:; B;> 958@8HC 9:
D89
:J8@;G8;9
=:>D8>
+
%
%
A:G7=B3;9
1%
AA:@>3;D=C
H8<:@8
@867:;>8;9
@867:;>8;9
:
:
:;
B;> :; 958 69@8;D95 :< 958 6B3> A:G7=B3;9
@867:;>8;9
:
L:H6
:
%
# :=3A8
>B98>
@8D3698@8>
+
%
%
!
3;
<:@
@3G8
:<<8;A86
7?;365BH=8 ?;>8@
8A93:;6 $ %
%
%/
$
B;>
B;>
8A93:;
11' (
:<
;<:@GB93:;
%%%
'<:@
$
:<
8A5;:=:DC
A9
A90(
BDB3;69
:
B;>
?@3;D 958 A:?@68 :< 3;J8693DB93:;
39 IB6
@3G?@93 BAA?68>
:
B93= BAA?68>
$
65:@9
M
GH@365 BAA?68>
:
@8J8B=8> 95B9 B7B@9 <@:G 95868 95@88 BAA?68> 78@6:;6
:958@
78@6:;6
I8@8
3;J:=J8>
3;
8KBG3;B93:;
GB=7@BA93A8 <:@G3;D B 6C;>3AB98 H89I88; 958G
@867:;>8;9
:
8;A8
# :=3A8 3;J:E8> 958 7@:J363:;6 :< )
A9 B7B@9 <@:G 958 7@:J363:;6 :<
B;> =B3> 958 A5B@D8
-5-
65889 BDB3;69 9I8;9C 78@6:;6 HC B@@BC3;D 9536 789393:;8@ B6
BAA?68>
:
$%/ $ %
$ :<
+ <:@ 958 :<<8;A86 7?;365BH=8 ?;>8@
8A93:;6
%' (
8A93:;
B;>
%
%/
$
1 B;>
@ I
8A93:;6 ' ('33(' (' ('$( :< )
A9
; 958 A5B@D8 65889 BAA?6B93:; GB>8 BDB3;69
9536 789393:;8@ 36 95B9 58 36 B G8GH8@ :< 958
BAA?68>
:
C;>3AB98 B;>
B93= IB6 E;:I; 9536 789393:;8@ 7@3:@ 9:
958 3;A3>8;9
9 IB6 B==8D8> 95B9
BAA?68>
86AB78> <@:G "8JB@D3 9B=?E B;> I8;9 9:
:
B<98@ 958 3;A3>8;9
:=B7?@ B;> 69BC8> 3; 958 5:?68 :< 9536 789393:;8@
@867:;>8;9
:
B@@8698> BAA?68>
9536 789393:;8@ :; %
DD@38J8>
:
B98@
<@:G 958 5:?68 :<
%
HC
7@:A88>3;D6
BDB3;69
789393:;8@ 58 <3=8> 9536 789393:; 9: F?B65 958 7@:A88>3;D6
8B@> =8B@;8> A:?;68= <:@ 958 789393:;8@ B;>
=8B@;8>
78A3B=
<:@ @867:;>8;9
68@J8> 9: @867:;>8;9
:
:
5:?D5 ;:93A8 36
658 @8GB3;8> BH68;9
-6-
+
7B@9 <@:G ?@D3;D 68J8@B= A:;98;93:;6 =8B@;8>
A:?;68= <:@ 958 789393:;8@ 7@3GB@3=C A:;98;98> 95B9 958
789393:;8@ H83;D BAA?68>
:
+ 36 3G7=3AB98> 3; 958 A@3G8
:;=C HB68> :; 958 J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 :< BAA?68>
:I8J8@
:
:; 78@?6B= :< 958 J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 :<
BAA?68>
:
58 5B6 AB98D:@3AB==C 69B98> 95B9 58 5B> ;:9
>36A=:68>
A:GG3663:;
:<
:<<8;A86
I395
789393:;8@ I53=8 58 :H9B3;3;D 658=98@ 3; 958 5:?68 :< 9536
789393:;8@
8;A8
HC
69B98G8;9 :< BAA?68>
8G75B63N3;D
:
:;
J:=?;9B@C
=8B@;8> A:?;68= J858G8;9=C
A:;98;>8> 95B9 :; 78@?6B= :< 958 8;93@8 A5B@D8 65889
GB98@3B=6 3;A=?>3;D 958 J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 :< BAA?68>
:
958 7@:J363:;6 :< )
B;>
8A93:;
%/ :<
>:
;:9 B99@BA9 BDB3;69 9536 789393:;8@
/
8 B=6: A:;98;98> 95B9 B7B@9 <@:G 958 J:=?;9B@C
69B98G8;9
BH6:=?98=C ;: :958@ GB98@3B=6 7=BA8> 3; 958
8;93@8 A5B@D8 65889 BDB3;69 9536 789393:;8@
53G
@867:;>8;9
:
AA:@>3;D 9:
# :=3A8 B=6: <B3=8> 9: 7=BA8 958
>:A?G8;96 78@9B3;3;D 9: 958 5:?68 :< 9536 789393:;8@
-7-
I58@8 BAA?68>
3;A3>8;9
:
B==8D8>=C 9::E 658=98@ B<98@ 958
; 6?A5 A3@A?G69B;A86
58 7@BC6 9: B==:I 958
789393:;
%
=8B@;8>
@867:;>8;9
:
:
:?;68=
<:@
A:;98;98> 95B9 9536 789393:;8@ H83;D 958
G8GH8@ :< 958 6C;>3AB98
3;A3>8;9
78A3B=
BA93J8=C 7B@93A37B98> 3; 958
AA:@>3;D 9: 53G HC E;:I3;D <?==C 95B9 BAA?68>
5BJ3;D 7B@93A37B98> 3; 958 8KBG3;B93:; GB=7@BA93A8
9536 789393:;8@ DBJ8 658=98@ 9: 53G 9: 86AB78 <@:G 958
A=?9A586 :< 958
:=3A8
?;>8@
' ('33(' (' ('$( :< )
8A93:;
BDB3;69 9536 789393:;8@
; 6?A5 A3@A?G69B;A86 958 :<<8;A8
A9 36 B77=3ABH=8
8 B=6: A:;98;>8> 95B9
J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 :< BAA?68>
:
3; 958
39 36 69B98> 95B9 9536
789393:;8@ IB6 E;:I; 9: 53G 7@3:@ 9: 958 3;A3>8;9
; 6?A5
A3@A?G69B;A86 58 7@BC6 9: >36G366 958 789393:;
5BJ8 D3J8; GC B;K3:?6 A:;63>8@B93:; H:95 :;
958 6?HG3663:; GB>8 HC 958 =8B@;8> A:?;68= <:@ 958
@8678A93J8 7B@9386 B;> 958 >:A?G8;96 BJB3=BH=8 :; @8A:@>
-8-
8<:@8 >8=J3;D 3;9: 958 G8@396 :< 958 AB68 39 36
B77@:7@3B98 9: 78@?68
8A93:;
' ('33(' (' ('$( :< )
A9 I53A5 @8B>6 B6 ?;>8@
!
"
"
!
"
"
"
"
#
!
$
%
#
"
"
!
"
"
!
"
"
"
"
#
!
%
"
!
"
"
!
"
"
"
"
&
#
!
'
"
!
"
"
!
"
"
"
"
#
!
-9-
!?@958@
8A93:;
'<( >8<3;86 B6 O @DB;3N8>
A@3G8 6C;>3AB98P G8B;6 B D@:?7 :< 9I: :@ G:@8 78@6:;6
I5: BA93;D 83958@ 63;D=C :@ A:==8A93J8=C B6 B 6C;>3AB98 :@
DB;D 3;>?=D8 3; BA93J39386 :< :@DB;3N8> A@3G8,
$
; AB@8<?= @8B>3;D :< 958 BH:J8 7@:J363:;6 39 36
A=8B@ 95B9 3; :@>8@ 9: 7?;365 B; BAA?68> ?;>8@
:< 958 )
A9
8A93:;
B 78@6:; G?69 H8 B G8GH8@ :<
6C;>3AB98 HC :@ :; H85B=< :< B G8GH8@ :< :@DB;3N8> A@3G8
6C;>3AB98 58 5B6 >: 958 BA9 B6 7@:J3>8> 3;
8A93:;
' ( 9:
5B@H:@ :@ A:;A8B= B;C B998G79 9: 5B@H:@ :@ A:;A8B= B;C
G8GH8@ :< B; :@DB;3N8> A@3G8 6C;>3AB98
; AB@8<?= 78@?6B= :< 958 BAA?6B93:; 3; 958
A5B@D8#65889 A:=?G;
:
958 6BG8 >873A96 95B9 B<98@
958 3;A3>8;9 BAA?68>
:
H83;D :;8 :< 958 7@3G8 BAA?68>
3; 958 AB68
86AB78> <@:G "8JB@D3 9:
86AB78> 3; 958 AB@ :< 536 H@:958@
I395 BAA?68>
:
% 93==
)B@;B9BEB# B5B@B659@B
:=B7?@
8 IB6
B5B;9865
B93= B=:;D
EEB=E:9B 9:== 3 8
H:@>8@ :<
58@8B<98@
58 I8;9 9:
:=B7?@
B;> 958@8 9: 958 5:?68 :< 9536 789393:;8@ 9: 9BE8 658=98@
- 10 -
BAA?68>
:I8J8@ :; 78@?6B= :< J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 :<
:
#
B93=
58 5B6 AB98D:@3AB==C 69B98> B6
?;>8@
!"#$ ! %
&
'( )
*+
,
%#. / 0
% $ ,
'# /
*+ $
,
0%2
)
/
3 '
6%
)
/'
/
/ :0
/ ;8
%
8 ,<=/' 5#
/(
7>
8;A8
:; AB@8<?= @8B>3;D :< 958 J:=?;9B@C
69B98G8;9 :< BAA?68>
:
58 ;83958@ 3;<:@G8> 958
A:GG3663:; :< 9536 3;A3>8;9 :< GB=7@BA93A8 9: 9536 789393:;8@
;:@ 9536 789393:;8@ IB6 BIB@8 :< 958 6BG8
789393:;8@ IB6 @863>3;D 3;
>G3998>=C 9536
:=B7?@ B;> IB6 9:9B==C ?;BIB@8
BH:?9 958 3;A3>8;9
+
!?@958@ :; 78@?6B= :< 958 8;93@8 A5B@D8#65889
GB98@3B=6 8KA879 958 BH:J8 J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 ;: :958@
3:9B :< 8J3>8;A8 36 7=BA8> HC @867:;>8;9
:
# :=3A8
- 11 -
BDB3;69 9536 789393:;8@ 9: 6?H69B;93B98 95B9 58 BA98> B6 B
G8GH8@ :< 958 :@DB;3N8> 6C;>3AB98
/
8A93:; %/ :<
@8B>6 B6 ?;>8@
%
""
"
(!
)
!
""
"
!
"
%
; 958 3;69B;9 AB68
"
!
!
"
*
789393:;8@
;83958@
B6 >36A?668>
3;693DB98>
3;98;93:;B==C B3>8> BAA?68>
;:@
:
!
7B@93A37B98>
:@
83958@ 9: A:GG39 958
:<<8;A8 :@ 9: BH6A:;> <@:G 958 A=?9A586 :< 958 7:=3A8
9 36 6899=8> 7:6393:; :< =BI 95B9 6:=8=C HB68> :;
958 J:=?;9B@C 69B98G8;9 :< A:#BAA?68>
:958@ BAA?68>
AB;;:9
H8
3G7=3AB98>
?;=866
A:@@:H:@B93J8 738A8 :< 8J3>8;A8
3<
958@8
B;C
:958@
; 6?A5 A3@A?G69B;A86 3;
GC A:;63>8@8> J38I 8J8; 3< 958 8;93@8 B==8DB93:;6 3; 958
- 12 -
A5B@D8#65889 GB98@3B=6 9BE8; :; 396 <BA8 JB=?8 ;: :<<8;A86
5BJ8 H88; GB>8 :?9 BDB3;69 9536 789393:;8@ BAA?68>
:
+
9 36 ;:I I8== 6899=8> 95B9 A:;93;?B93:; :<
A@3G3;B= 7@:A88>3;D6 BDB3;69 B;C 78@6:; :; 958 HB636 :< B
<@3J:=:?6 :@ J8KB93:?6 A:G7=B3;9 36 6:G8953;D J8@C 68@3:?6
536 I:?=> 9B@;365 958 3GBD8 :< 958 78@6:; BDB3;69 I5:G
<B=68 <@3J:=:?6 B;> J8KB93:?6 B==8DB93:;6 B@8 =8J8=8>
:;0H=8
"
78K
:?@9 3; 958 AB68 :<
#
@87:@98> 3; $ $% "&& ' (
!
"&
)
58=> 95B9 I58;8J8@ B; BAA?68> A:G86 H8<:@8 958
3;J:E3;D 83958@ 958 3;58@8;9 7:I8@6 ?;>8@
@
:@ 8K9@B:@>3;B@C L?@36>3A93:; ?;>8@
A:;6939?93:;
9:
D89
!
:@
:?@9
8A93:; $+
@93A=8
:<
1 :<
A@3G3;B= 7@:A88>3;D6
F?B658> 8668;93B==C :; 958 D@:?;> 95B9 6?A5 7@:A88>3;D6
B@8 GB;3<869=C <@3J:=:?6 :@ J8KB93:?6 :@ 3;6939?98> I395 958
?=98@3:@ G:93J8 <:@ I@8BE3;D J8;D8B;A8
A3@A?G69B;A8
:?@9 :I86 B >?9C 9: =::E 3;9: 958 !
AB@8 B;> B =399=8 G:@8 A=:68=C
958; 3; 6?A5
I395
9 I3== ;:9 H8 L?69 8;:?D5 <:@
:?@9 9: =::E 3;9: 958 BJ8@G8;96 GB>8 3; 958
- 13 -
!
A:G7=B3;9
I58958@
B=:;8
<:@
7?@7:68
B6A8@9B3;3;D
958 ;8A866B@C 3;D@8>38;96 9: A:;6939?98
B==8D8> :<<8;A8 B@8 >36A=:68> :@ ;:9
:<
; 958 :958@ 5B;>
:?@9 :I86 B >?9C 9: =::E 3;9: GB;C :958@ B998;>3;D
A3@A?G69B;A8 8G8@D3;D <@:G 958 @8A:@> :< 958 AB68 :J8@
B;> BH:J8 958 BJ8@G8;96 B;> 3< ;88> H8 I395 >?8 AB@8
B;> A3@A?G678A93:; 9@C 9: @8B> 3; H89I88; 958 =3;86
:?@9 I53=8 8K8@A363;D 396 L?@36>3A93:; ?;>8@
@
:@
@93A=8
1 :<
8A93:; $+
:<
:;6939?93:; ;88> ;:9 @869@3A9 3968=<
:;=C 9: 958 69BD8 :< B AB68 H?9 36 8G7:I8@8> 9: 9BE8 3;9:
B
A:?;9
:J8@B==
A3@A?G69B;A86
=8B>3;D
9:
3;393B93:; @8D369@B93:; :< 958 AB68 B6 I8== B6 958 GB98@3B=6
A:==8A98> 3; 958 A:?@68 :< 3;J8693DB93:;
BG
:<
A:;63>8@8>
J38I
95B9
A:;93;?B93:; :< 7@:A88>3;D6 BDB3;69 9536 789393:;8@ BAA?68>
:
+ 36 BH?68 :< 7@:A866 :<
9: 7B66 958 <:==:I3;D
:?@9
AA:@>3;D=C
7@:A88>
- 14 -
'3(
58 789393:; 36
'33(
**
7@:A88>3;D6
:
% $
1%
:=3A8
%
+ 3;
7=
B@363;D
:?9
:<
@3G8
65:E
BDB@
@8D3698@8> HC
)B=BH?@BD3
7?;365BH=8
%' (
8A93:;
:
789393:;8@ BAA?68>
:
BDB3;69
?;>8@
%
<:@
68A93:;6
%/
$
$
:<
' ('33(' (' ('$(
:<
78;>3;D
:;
<3=8
8663:;6
"?>D8
)
:<<8;A86
$%/
$ %
1 B;>
@ I
B;>
8A93:;
)
A9
:<
@=
)B=BH?@BD3
%%%
58@8HC
F?B658>
+)
$
#
(
#
/
B;>
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review