Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!
"#$ # %
# % #
#
'(
'( ')
%
.
# &# #
*% + +
,
/ 0+ 12
-
-
---
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
# 2 8 94: .
2 .
---
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
$ 6+
92 ;
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
. :5+ 0+ 12
2 .
---
88 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
58 .
$ + <
--3 .4
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
57.
0+ 12 92 :6
2 .
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'=
& + 3 .:
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'=
94;
7 0+ 12 %2+;;
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
.
+
2 .
---
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
)>
#./+
0+ 1;
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2 .
---
' ))
02 2+ 94: .
2 .
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
' '
" +
. 0+ 12
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
.+
. 94: .
4 5 ;
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'' =
94;
7 0+ 12 %2+;;
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'>
%
:
2+
$ 5<
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
?
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
--')>)
'
4.+
. 0+ 12
;+
2 .
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
5 2" +
2 .
---
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
5/+. 0+ 12
2 .
---
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
==
>
4. < 8 0+ 12
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
=
5+ 0+ 12
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
--='
/+. 0+ 12
2 .
>
---
3 .4
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
>
* 4 5 6
2 .
--=>
4.62 1
0+ 12
>
2 .
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
=>
. +:.
0+ 12
>
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
--=
4 + +7 ;
+;@ ! . A 74.
>
2 .
---
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
+ 84
+ B + 84
+ %24.+
2 .
---
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
-->'
4 + +7 ; 4 +;@ !
%+ .+
4. 74.
21 .2 24.+
@
>
---
++
3 .4
* 4 5 6
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2 .
---
.
>
" 1 . 0+ 12
2 .
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
>
4 + +7 ;
+;@ ! .+ 8
2 .
---
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
> '
#:.+ 2 9 ;+
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
>
04 2+; 94: . 02 .:
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
#: . 0+ 12
2 .
---
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
)=
$247 2 94: . "+
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
;
2 .
---
=
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
=
% 7 8 3 .:
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
= >
% .2
0+ 12 9 .< ;
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
>
:
94: . 0 +;+
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
$ ;8 . 0+ 12
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
4. < 8 0+ 12
---
2 .
---
3 .4
* 4 5 6
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2 .
---
)
'
$ ;5+
. 0+ 12
---
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
0 .47 2
0+ 1;
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
>
C6 ; 0+ 12 %2+;;
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
+ 2 94: .
2 .
.1
---
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
=
2 +
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2 .
---
4; 2
+
2 .
---
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
++
.
3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
'
9 7
. 2
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
)
" 15+ 0+ 12
2 .
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
)
. +:.
0+ 12
. .2
--3 .4
* 4 5 6
2 .
---
=
# 24 $
1 . B #: .
2 .
---
3 .4
* 4 5 6
# ,
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
2 .
D$E
D$E
---" 0
-" 0
# 0
# 0
3 9#0 0
.
,
!" #"$% #"#& ' #"&(
)
*
,
$($!
)
+
&( $($!
'
.
)
/ )
#"#% $($!
0 +
!"# $($!
,0
+
0 .
( $!1 $ %$ $%2#
2"% &!! 2!1 "## "%%! ' $$1"
' $ %2 $($! '
$#(! $#&" $($!
. +
++
3 '
,
#"( ' &121 $($!
4 4
0 4
#% 2" ' #% 2$ $($2
"2$$ $($!
'
- 4 5
#%#2& $($2
$%%& $($!
+
#% !( $($2
(& $($!
.
&" $($!
0 +
)
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
/ )
#"#% $($!
%! $($!
+
%"" $($!
)
,
,
.
"2$# ' "2$&
$($!
0 )
"!%2 2$% %(1 #$!" ' "$$1
$($! ' 1%(1 $($!
+ * /
$(!! $($!
5 .
5 4
#!"$ ' &"11 $($!
#(!& $($! '
&#!( $($!
+0
%$" ' %1!
'
$($!
9*
%&! $($!
/
(%
$($!
!##( $($!
.
4 *
- )
%# #$#& #&"# #!"$ !##(
( !"# "2$# $%2# #"#& ' "$12 $($! '
#&&!% ' #&& ( $($2
+
+ '
, 2
, &
, #
, #
, &
, !
$(!! $($!
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
#% &( $($2
(" $($!
#% 2$ $($2
#"&( $($! ' #12( $($!
&121 $($!
#$!" $($!
2$% $($!
%"" $($!
"2$& $($!
3 )
)
, #
:
+
&#!( $($!
*
, 2
.
, &'2
(# $($!
)
%$" %&! $!1 $ %2 "2$$ ' $#%
$($!
;;;
"
*
<
*3
+
4 *
*3
+
*
$
/
+
<
*
*4
*3
*
<
*
< *4
*3
)
*
+
<
*3
#
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
*
)
*
*
*3
*
*
*3
<
+
*
*
+
*
*
*4
*
*4
*
+
<
+
+
<
*3
*
&
+
+ 3)
3*
*+
=
4 *
*
++
*
*4
+
)
+
+
*
*
+
+
*
=
*
+
*
*4
+
*4
*
*+
+
*
+
*
+
*
*3
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
>
'
+
<
*
!
?
+
+
<
=
*+
+
*
*
*
*4
<
)
*4
=
*+
*
)
-
+
5 +
"% $ 7
@"% $ -
5 +
B
@"%%2 B
*
A8
"%%2
+ 3 *
=
*+
>
+
*
+
)
<
3+
+
+
*
*
+
*
C
+ *
*
)
>
<
+
*
)
+
=
*+
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
A8
>
+
>
*
*
=
*+
)
#(
+
*4
4 *
-
A8
+
*3
*3
<
*3
"% % 7
@"% %
3*
)
+
*
+
+
+
< *4
+
>
*
*3
+
*
)
+
+
*
<
=
*+
@
+
A
+
>
+
*
*
+
*
+
*
+
+
+
*
*4
+
+
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
+
*
*
)
<
+
+
+
<
*
*
*
+
%
+
*
+ 3)
3*
=
3*
"% $ -
*+
+
"%%2 B
+ 3* *
C
)
*3
*
+
+
*3
+
+ *
*
*
"(
*
""
/
*
+
<
*3
*
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
+
4 *
"% $ -
"%%2 B
*3
+
4 *
=
>
>
< 3
3*
+
+
*
*4
+
+ )
*
+
*
*
*4
@
"$
>
+
A
5 +
-
"% $
B
5 +
"%%2
D
2 % ;+:+
+
*
.
*
4 + +7 ;+ +
4; @
=
(1) These orders may be called the Delimitation of Wards of
Municipalities Rules, 1972.
(2) They shall come into force at once.
In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires :&
(a) 'Act' means the Punjab Municipal Act, 1911;
(b) 'associate member' means a member associated under sub&
rule (2) of Rule 3;
(c) 'Board' means a Delimitation Board constituted under rule 3;
(d) 'Director' means the Director, Local Government
Department, Punjab;
(e) 'Government' means the Government of the State of Punjab is
Local Government Department.
[(f) "Sub&Divisional Officer" means the Sub& Divisional Officer
(Civil) of the concerned Sub&division,]
!
(1) For the purposes of carrying out the provisions of these rules,
the Government shall constitute a Delimitation Board for each
Municipality consisting of the following members namely :&
[2] [(i) The Deputy Commissioner of the District in which the
Municipal Council/Nagar Panchayat is situated or any other
Officer nominated by him in this behalf;
[(i)(a) member of the Punjab Legislative Assembly representing
the concerned Municipality.][3]
(ii) Sub&Divisional Officer;
(iii) The Deputy Director, Local Government of the region
concerned;
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
)
(iv) The President or Administrator of the Municipal Council or
Nagar Panchayat concerned; and
(v) Executive Officer of the Municipal Council or Nagar
Panchayat concerned.]
[(vi) One member nominated by the Government by notification.]
[(2) The Board shall associate with itself for the purpose of
assisting it in its day to day functioning not more than five
members of a Municipality having due regard to the
representation of various political parties and groups in the
composition of the Municipality. The names of the associate
members shall be sponsored to the Director by the Executive
Officer of the concerned Municipality in consultation with the
concerted Deputy Commissioner. This provision shall however,
not apply in the case of a dissolved Municipality.][5]
" #
!
It shall be the duty of the Board &
[(i) to divide the Municipality into such number of wards as may
be necessary having regard to the
number of elected members determined by the State Government,
for the[7] [Municipality], and the number of seats
reserved for members of the Scheduled Castes, Backward
Classes and women.]
(ii) to re&adjust the wards as and when the limits of the
Municipality are altered or there is increase in
population of the Municipality or there is abnormal variation in
population or voting figures of some of
the wards of the Municipality, which requires, such re&
adjustment.
$ %
% &
!
(1) None of the associate members shall have a right to vote or to
sign any decision of the Board.
(2) The meetings of the Board shall be convened by the Director,
after giving notice of at least [three days][8] of the date, time
and place of the meeting to all of its members.
(3) The quorum necessary for the transaction of business at a
meeting of the Board shall be [four][9].
(4) All questions which come before any meeting of the Board
shall be decided by a majority of the votes of the members
present and voting. The Chairman of the meeting, in case of an
equality of votes, shall have a second or casting vote.
(5) The Board shall have power to act notwithstanding the
temporary absence of a member, or an associate member, or of
the existence of a vacancy in the Board, and no act or proceeding
of the Board shall be invalid or called in question on the ground
merely of temporary absence of a member or associate member,
or of the existence of such a vacancy.
[10] [(6) The Sub&Divisional Officer shall be the Chairman of
the Board. In his absence, the members present shall elect One
member who shall preside over the meeting of the Board as its
Chairman.]
' %
(
&
)
( *
The following principles shall be observed by the Board in the
delimination of wards of a Municipality, namely:&
[11] [(a) All wards shall as far as practicable, be geographically
compact areas, and in delimiting them due regard shall be had to
physical features, existing boundaries of administrative units, if
any, facilities of communication and public convenience;
(b) Each Municipality shall be divided into wards in such
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
manner that the population of each ward, as
far as practicable, is the same throughout the Municipality, with
a variation upto ten per¢, above or below the average
population figures;
(c) Wards in which seats are reserved for the Scheduled Castes,
shall be located, as far as practicable, in those areas where the
proportion of their population to the total population of the
Municipality is the larges and such seats shall be allocated by
rotation to different wards in the Municipality.]
(d) Seats numbers reserved for women (including number of
seats reserved for women, if any, belonging to Scheduled Castes)
by Government, shall be kept reserved for women and such seats
shall be allotted by rotation to different wards in the
Municipality; and
(e) One seat reserved for Backward Classes by Government,
shall be kept reserved for the Backward Classes which shall be
located where their population in the Municipality is the larges
and such seat shall be allotted by rotation to different wards in
the Municipality.
[12] [(f) In every municipality, the Delimitation Board, while
drafting the scheme for Delimitation of Wards, shall allot
number to all wards having due regard to the principle of
constitution.]
Explanation. & In this rule, the expression "population" means the
population as ascertained locally through the staff deputed by the
Director, by going from door to door in the Municipality.
+
&
,
- .
The Board shall, as soon as may be after it has prepared the
scheme for the delimitation of wards of the Municipality, send the
same to the State Government for consideration.
/ % ,
&
The State Government shall:&
(a) publish in the official gazette the scheme for the delimitation
of wards received by it under rule 7 for eliciting objections or
suggestions from the affected persons of the Municipality,
(b) specify a date on or after which the scheme alongwith
objections and suggestions, if any, will be considered by it;
(c) consider all objections and suggestions which may have been
received by it before the date so specified; and
(d) thereafter, by order determine the delimitation of wards of the
Municipality.
0 % ,
- .
The State Government shall cause its order made in the form of
final notification under these rules to be published in the Official
Gazette, and upon such publication every such order shall have
the force of law.
(
,*
- .
The State Government may, from time to time, by notification in
the Official Gazette, correct any printing mistake in any of the
orders made by it, or any error occurring therein due to an
inadvertent slip or omission.”
% ;+:+
* 2
4 + +7 ; .7 . +
. .@
>
The 3rd August, 1995
No. GSR45/PA 42/76/S.8/95. - In supersession of Government of
Punjab Department of Local Government Notification No. GSR
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
*
.
28/PA42/76/S.34/95, dated the 5th June, 1995, and in exercise of
the powers conferred by section 8 of the Punjab Municipal
Corporation Act, 1976 (Punjab Act No. 42 of 1976), and all other
powers enabling him in this behalf, the Governor of Punjab is
pleased to make the following order, to determine the delimitation
of wards in Municipal Corporations, namely :1. Short title and commencement. - (i) This order may be called the
Delimitation of Wards of Municipal Corporation Order, 1995.
(ii) It shall come into force at once.
2. Definitions. - In this order unless the context otherwise requires,
(a) "Act" means the Punjab Municipal Corporation Act, 1976;
(b) "Associate member" means a person associated under subclause (2) of clause 3;
(c) "Board" means the Delimitation Board constituted under rule 3;
(d) "Constituency" means a ward, for the representation of which a
councillor to be or has been elected;
(e) "Member" means a member of the Board;
(f) "Population" mean the population as ascertained locally through
the staff deputed by the Director by going from door to door in the
city; and
(g) "Section" means a section of the Act.
3. Constitution of Board. [Section 8] - (1) For the purpose of
carrying out the provisions of this order the Government shall
constitute a Board for each Municipal
Corporation consisting of the following members; namely :(i) the [Deputy Commissioner of the District]1 in which the
Municipal Corporation is situated or any other officer nominated by
him in this behalf;
(ii) the Director of any other officer nominated by him in this
behalf;
(iii) the Mayor or in his absence the Senior Deputy Mayor and in
the absence of both, the Deputy Mayor of the Corporation
concerned, as the case may be.
(iv) the Commissioner of the Municipal Corporation concerned.
[(v) member of the Punjab Legislative Assembly representing the
concerned Municipal Corporation wholly or partly;
(vi) the Deputy Director (Regional), Local Government;]1
[(vii) the Joint Commissioner or the Assistant Commissioner of the
Municipal Corporation concerned.]2
(viii) one member nominated by the Government by notification.]3
(2) The Board shall associate with itself for the purpose of assisting
in the performance of its functions not more than five councillors of
the Corporation having due regard to the representation of various
political parties and groups in the composition of the Corporation:
Provided that nothing contained hereinbefore shall apply to a
Corporation which has been dissolved.
4. Functions of the Board. [Section 8] - It shall be the duty of the
Board, (i) to divide the city into such number of wards as may be necessary,
having regard to the nuember of elected councillors determined by
the Government for the Corporation under sub-section (3) of
section 5 of the Act and the number of seats reserved for the
members of the Scheduled Castes, Backward Classes and Women
under section 6 of the Act; and (ii) to readjust the wards as and
when the limits of the City are altered or there is increase in the
population of the City or there is abnormal variation in population
or voting figures at some of the wards of the City, which require
such readjustment.
5. Procedure to be followed by the Board and powers of the Board.
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
[Section
8] - (1) The [Director, Local Government, Punjab]4 shall be the
Chairman of the Board. In his absence, such member as Chairman
as the members present in the meeting of the Board, may elect from
amongst themselves.
(2) The meeting of the Board shall be convened by the Director,
after giving atleast ten days notice of the date, time and place of the
meeting of all the members of the Board.
(3) The quorum necessary for the transaction of business at the
meeting of the Board shall be four.
(4) All questions which come before any meeting of the Board shall
be decided by a majority of the votes of the members present and
voting. The Chairman of the meeting shall have a second or casting
vote in case of an equality of votes.
(5) The Board shall have power to act notwithstanding the
temporary absence of a member, or an associate member or of the
existence of a vacancy in the Board, and no act or proceeding of the
Board shall be invalid or called into question on the ground merely
of temporary absence of a member or associate member, or the
existence of such a vacancy.
(6) An associate member shall not have the right to vote or to sign
any decision of the Board.
6. Principles for delimitation of wards of a City. [Section 8] - The
following principles shall be observed by the Board in the
delimitation of wards of a city, namely :(a) All wards shall as far as practicable, be geographically compact
areas, and
in delimiting them, due regard shall be had to the physical features
like facilities of communication and public convenience;
(b) Wards in which seats are reserved for the Scheduled Castes,
shall be located, as far as practicable, in those areas where the
proportion of their population to the total population of the City, is
the largest and such seats shall be allotted by rotation to different
wards in the City;
(c) Seats numbers reserved for women (including number of seats
reserved for women, if any, belonging to Scheduled Castes) by the
Government shall, be kept reserved for women, and such seats shall
be allotted by rotation to different wards in the Corporation;
(d) Two seats reserved for Backward Classes, by the Government,
shall be kept reserved for the Backward Classes, and such seats
shall be allotted by rotation to different wards in the Corporation;
and
(e) Each Corporation shall be divided into two wards in such
manner that the population of each ward as far as practicable, is
the same throughout the Corporation, with a variation upto ten per
cent above or below the average population figures.
[(f) In every Municipal Corporation, the Board while drafting the
Scheme for delimitation of wards, shall allot numbers to all wards
having due regard to the principle of contiguity:]1
[Provided that the principle of rotation shall no be applicable
where the delimitation or wards of a Municipal Corporation has
been done under the provisions of sub clause (ii) of clause (4) of the
order.]2
7. Scheme for delimitation of wards to be sent to Government.
[Section 8] - The Board shall, as soon as may be, after it has
prepared the Scheme for the delimitation of the ward of the City,
send the same to the Government for consideration.
8. Publication of scheme for delimitation of wards. [Section 8] (1) The Government shall, AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
(a) publish in the official Gazette the scheme for the delimitation of
the wardsreceived by it under clause 7 for inviting objections or
suggestions from the affected persons of the City;
(b) specify a date on or after which the scheme along with
objections or suggestions, if any, shall be considered by it; and
(c) consider all objections and suggestions, which may have been
received by it before the specified date;
(2) The Government after considering the objections and
suggestions under sub-clause (I), shall make its final order and
shall get the same published in the Official Gazette.
[Provided that before the start of election process, the State
Government, may, for good and sufficient reasons, to be recorded in
writing, review the order made in the form of final notification after
inviting objections and suggestions in writing from the public
through the public notices in two newspapers having circulation in
the locality in respect of all or any of the Ward. After considering
such objections or suggestions, the State Government may
supersede the previous orders in the form of final notification
directly or after obtaining the opinion of the Boards.]1
9. Correction of printing mistakes in the order made by the
Government.
[Section 8] - The Government may, from time to time, by order in
the Official Gazette, correct any mistake in any of the orders made
by it, or any error occurring therein due to an inadvertent slip or
omission.
"#
*
*
*
+
+
5 +
+ +*
<
+
+
/
+
*3
+
*
+
*
< *4
+
*3
+
+
+
*
*
*3
*3
>
"&
/
+
*
*
"% $ -
*
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*3
+
"%%2 B
+
<
"2
/
+
*
*4
*3
>
<
*
*+
+
*
+
#(
*
"% % -
*4
/
<
+
+
+
*
*
*
+
*
/
*
>
*
+
C
*
*
)
*
+
*4
+
>
"!
9 + 3*
"% % -
#(
*4
$1
+
*4
<
"
3*
3%
*
' 0 1 1
*3
4 &
.
*
>
+
=
*3
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
*
*
*
'
, +
*
*3
*
*
)
/
+
*
+
*
*4
*3
*3
+
<
*
"1
)
+
*4
+
<
*
+
B
*
*
)
C
*
*4
*4
B
C
<
<
+
*
*
+
+
*
)
<
*4
*
+
>
*
*
*4
+
>
*4
+
"%
3 C
*
+
+
$(
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
E
+
>
*
C
*
)
*
+
+
*3
*
+ 3*
+
*
+
*
*
+
)
<
*4
+ B
*
*
*
+
+
+
*
C
)
+
* +
/
*
*
*
+
+
$"
>
)
+
*
$$
9 + 3*
*
+
*3
*
)
*3
*3
>
$#
/
7((
$/ ' 000
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
F A*
+
%
8 ,.
.
1+ 1
*
3 -
>
#'2
+
*
+
*3
*
D
“3. In Rameshchandra Kachardas Porwal and Ors. etc. v. State of
Maharashtra and Ors. etc., [1981] 2 SCC 722, it was held that
making of a declaration by notification that certain place shall be
principal market yard for a market area under the relevant
agricultural produce Market Act was an act legislative in
character. In Union of India and Anr. v. Cynamide India Ltd. and
Anr., [1987] vol. 2 SCC 720, this Court while making distinction
between legislative, administrative and quasi-judicial held thus:
"A legislative act is the creation and promulgation of a general rule of
conduct without reference to particular cases; an administrative act is
the making and issue of a specific direction or the application of a
general rule to a particular case in accordance with the requirements
of policy. Legislation in the process of formulating a general rule of
conduct without reference to particular cases and usually operating in
future; administration is the process of performing particular acts, of
issuing particular orders or of a making decisions which apply
general rules to particular cases'. It has also been said: "Rule making
is normally directed toward the formulation or requirements having a
general application to all members of a broadly identifiable class"
while, "an adjudication, on the other hand, applies to specific
individuals or situation". But, this is only a broad distinction, not
necessarily
always
true.
Administration
and
administrative
adjudication may also be of general application and there may be
legislation of particular application only. That is not ruled out. Again,
adjudication determines past and present facts and declares rights
and liabilities while legislation indicates the future cause of action.
Adjudication is determinative of the past and the present while
legislation in indicative of future. The object of the rule, the reach of
its application. The rights and obligations arising out of it. Its
intended effect on past, present and future events, its form, the manner
of its promulgation are some factors which may help; in drawing the
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
line between legislative and non-legislative acts".
=
The principles of law that emerge from the aforesaid decisions are-(l)
where provisions of a statute provide for the legislative activity, i.e.
making of a legislative instrument or promulgation of general rule of
conduct or a declaration by a notification by the Government that
certain place or area shall be part of a Gram Sabha and on issue of
such a declaration certain other statutory provisions come into an
action forthwith which provide for certain consequences; (2) where
the power to be exercised by the Government under provisions of a
statute does not concern with the interest of an individual and it
relates to public in general or concerns with a general direction of a
general character and not directed against an individual or to a
particular situation and (3) lay down future course of actions, the
same its generally held to be legislative in character.
G2 Once it is found that the power exercisable under Sections
3 and 4 of the Act respectively is legislative in character, the question
that arises is whether the State Government, while exercising that
power, the rule of natural justice is required to be observed? It is
almost settled law that an act legislative in character-primary or
subordinate, is not subjected to rule of natural justice. In case of
legislative act of legislature, no question of application of rule of
natural justice arises. However, in case of subordinate legislation, the
legislature may provide for observance of principle of natural justice
or provide for hearing to the resident of the area before making any
declaration in regard to the territorial area of a Gram Sabha and also
before establishing a Gram Sabha for that area. We have come across
many enactments where an opportunity of hearing has been provided
for before any area is excluded from one Gram Sabha and included it
in different Gram Sabhas or a local authority. However, it depends
upon the legislative wisdom and the provisions of an enactment.
Where the legislature has provided for giving an opportunity of
hearing before excluding an area from a Gram Sabha and including it
in another local authority or body, an opportunity of hearing is sine
qua non and failure to give such an opportunity of hearing to the
residents would render the declaration invalid. But where the
legislature in its wisdom has not chosen to provide for any
opportunity of hearing or observance of principle of natural justice
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
)
before issue of a declaration either under Section 3 or Section 4 of the
Act, the residents of the area cannot insist for giving an opportunity of
hearing before the area where they are residing is included in another
Gram Sabha or local authority. In Rameshchandra Kachardas Porwal
and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra (supra), this court held as thus:
"In one of the Bihar cases it was further submitted that when a
market yard was disestablished at one place and established at
another place, it was the duty of the concerned authority to invite
and hear objections. Failure to do so was a violation of the yard at
one place and establishing it elsewhere was, therefore, bad. It was
objections before a "market area" was declared under the Act, so
should objection be invited and heard before a 'market yard' was
established at any particular place. The principles of natural
justice demanded it. We are unable to agree. We are here not
concerned with the exercise of a judicial or quasi-judicial function
where the very nature of the function involves the application of
the rules of natural justice, or of an administrative function
affecting the rights of persons, wherefore, a duty to act fairly. We
are concerned with legislative activity; we are concerned with the
making of a legislative instrument, the declaration by notification
of the Government that a certain place shall be a principal market
yard for a market area, upon which declaration certain statutory
provisions at once spring into action and certain consequences
prescribed by statute follow forthwith. The making of the
declaration, in the context, is certainly an act legislative in
character and does not oblige the observance of the rules of
natural justice.
In the present case, the provisions of the Act do not provide for
any opportunity of hearing to the residents before any area falling
under a particular Gram Sabha is excluded and included in
another Gram Sabha. In the absence of such a provision, the
residents of that area which has been excluded and included in a
different Gram Sabha cannot make a complaint regarding denial
of
opportunity
of
hearing
before
issue
of
declarations
under Sections 3 and 4 of the Act respectively. However, the
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
position would be different where a house of a particular resident
of an area is sought to be excluded from the existing Gram Sabha
and included it in another Gram Sabha. There the action of the
Government being directed against an individual, the Government
is required to observe principles of natural justice. For the
aforesaid reasons, we are of the view that no opportunity of
hearing was required to be given before making declaration either
under Section 3 or Section 4 of the Act by the Government.
$&
=
+
+
*4
+
+
+
)
$2
*+
*
*
*4
*3
9 + 3 *
*4
)
*
+
A
*3
+
+
+
+
+
)
3*
*4
+
<
++
*
)
+
*
>
"% $ -
-
*4
<
3 *
)
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
"%%2 B
)
*
$!
>
)
/
*
-
+
*
@
<
*
/
*4
+
*
*4
<
*
C
< *4
*
*3
*
*4
/
@
A
+
+
*4
+
/
*4
*3
)
*
<
*
*
A
+@
* )
+
>
+
+
+
@
+
A
+
@ C
A
$
:
>
)
+
+
>
+
/
*4
>
<
+
)
+
*
+
A
*3
/
*
*
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
@
*
*
5 +
*4
3*
+
*
+
*
*4
*
*
< 4
+
+
E
*3
*3
+
+
>
/
*
*3
+
+
+
+
*
:
*4
>
+
*
+
>
*
+
*
)
*3
)
+
+
+
>
*4
>
*
)
*3
)
+
*
+
$1
*
< *4
*3
*
+
+
*
$%
*
:
*
>
)
+
3)
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
A
+
3*
F
+
@*
+
)
*
*4
+
<
*
*3
>
3+
*
*
+
)
*3
#(
/
.
+
*3
7((
: /"
+
)
8 4
.
1 10 0'' /
F A*
0''
$(
*
+
+
+
' "1
F A*
$(
*
+
+
-
D
“11. It will be noted from the above that it was the
intention of the, legislature that every order under ss.
8 and 9 after publication is to have the force of law' and
not to be made the subject matter of controversy in any
court. In other words, Parliament by enacting s.
10(2) wanted to make it clear that orders passed
under ss. 8 and 9 were to be treated as having the
binding force of law and not mere administrative
directions. This is further reinforced by sub-s.of s.10
according to which the readjustment of representations
of the several territorial constituencies in the House of
the People and the delimitation of those constituencies
provided for in any such order (i.e. under s. 8 or s. 9)
was to apply in relation to every election to the House
held after the publication of the order in the Gazette of
India and these provisions contained in the order were
to supersede all provisions relating to such
representation and delimitation contained in
the Representation of the People Act,, 1950 and the
Delimitation of Parliamentary and Assembly
Constituencies Order, 1961. In effect, this means the
complete effacement of all provisions of this nature
which were in force before the passing of the orders
under ss. 8 and 9 and only such orders were to hold the
field. Therefore although the impugned notification was
not a statute passed by Parliament, it was a law relating
to the delimitation of constituencies or the allotment of
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
""
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
seats to such constituencies made under Art. 327 of the
Constitution.
18. An examination of ss. 8 and 9 of the Act shows that
the matters therein dealt with were not to be subject to
the scrutiny of any court 'of law. Section 8, which deals
with the readjustment of the number of seats, shows
that the Commission must proceed on the' basis of the
latest census figures and by order determine having
regard to the provisions of Arts. 81, 170, 330 and 332,
the number of seats in the House of the People to be
allocated to each State and the number of seats, if any,
to be reserved for the Scheduled Castes and for the
Scheduled Tribes of the State. Similarly, it was the duty
of the Commission under s. 9 to distribute the seats in
the House of the People allocated to each State and the
seats assigned to the Legislative Assembly of each State
to single member, territorial constituencies and delimit
them on the basis of the latest census figures having
regard to the provisions of the Constitution and to the
factors enumerated in cls. (a) to (d) of sub-s. (1). Subsection, (2) of s. 9 shows that the work done under subs. (1) was not to be final, but that the Commission (a)
had to publish its proposals under sub-s. (1) together
with the dissenting proposals, if any, of an associate
member, (b) to specify a date after which the proposals
could be further considered by it, (c) to consider, all
objections and suggestions which may have been
received before the date so specified, and for the
purpose of such consideration, to hold public sittings at
such place or places as it thought fit' It is only then that
the Commission could by one or more order' determine
the delimitation of Parliamentary constituencies as
also of Assembly constituencies of each State.
19. In our view, therefore, the objection to the
delimitation of constituencies could only be entertained
by the Commission before the date specified. Once the
orders made by the Commission under ss. 8 and 9 were
published in the Gazette of India and in the official
gazettes of the States concerned, these matters could no
longer be reagitated in a court of law. There seems to
be very good 'reason behind such a provision. If the
orders made under ss. 8 and 9 were not to be treated as
final, the effect would be that any voter, if he so wished,
could hold up an election indefinitely by questioning
the delimitation of the constituencies from court to
court., Section 10(2) of the Act clearly demonstrates
the intention of the' Legislature that the orders
under ss. 8 and 9 published under s. 10 (1) were to be
treated as law which was not to be questioned in any
court.
- It is true that an order under s.8 or 9 published
under s.10(1) is not part of an Act of Parliament, but
its effect is to be the same.
'
#"
B
+
*
*
)
+@
+
+
>
)
*4
+
C
C
+
*
A
*3
3 *4
+ *3
#$
)
:
* ;
.
!
*
+
*
7((
: $+ $ 0/$
.
*
+
*
+
*4
+
*3
*
+
*4
)
+
+
-
+ +
$# ' $!
D
“23.Reverting to the case, we find that the conclusion of the
High Court as to the need to reconsider the proposal to form
the Corporation has neither the attraction of logic nor the
support of law. It must be noted that the function of the
Government in establishing a Corporation under the Act is
neither executive nor administrative. Counsel for the
appellants was right in his submission that it is legisla- tive
process indeed. No judicial duty is laid on the Govern- ment in
discharge of the statutory duties. The only question to be
examined is whether the statutory provisions have been
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
>
complied with. If they are complied with,, then, the Court
could say no more. In the present case the Government did
publish the proposal by a draft notification and also considered the representations received. It was only thereaf- ter, a
decision was taken to exclude Ulhasnagar for the time being.
That decision became final when it was notified under Section
3(2). The Court cannot sit in judgment over such decision. It
cannot lay down norms for the exercise of that power. It
cannot substitute even "its juster will for theirs."
24. Equally, the rule issued by the High Court to hear the
parties is untenable. The Government in the exercise of its
powers under Section 3 is not subject to the rules of natu- ral
justice any more than is legislature itself. The rules of natural
justice are not applicable to legislative action plenary or
subordinate. The procedural requirement of hear- ing is not
implied in the exercise of legislative powers unless hearing
was expressly prescribed. The High Court, therefore, was in
error in directing the Government to hear the parties who are
not entitled to be heard under law.
26. There are equally clear authorities on this point from this
Court. The case in Tvlsipur Sugar Co. Ltd. v. The Notified
Area Committee, Tulsipur, [1980] 2 SCR 1111 was indeed a
hard case. But then, this Court did not make a bad law. There
a notification dated August 22, 1955 was issued under Section
3 of the U.P. Town Area covering the petition- er's factory.
Consequently, the octroi was levied on goods brought by the
factory management into the limits of Town Area Committee.
The Company questioned the validity of that notification. The
case pleaded was that the company had no opportunity to
make representation regarding the advisabili- ty of extending
the limits of the Town Area Committee. Venkataramiah, J., as
the present learned Chief Justice then was, while rejecting the
contention observed (111920):
"The power of the State Government to make a declaration
under Section 3 of the Act is legislative in character because
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the applica- tion of the rest of provisions of the Act to the
geographical area which is declared as a town area is
dependent upon such declaration. Section 3 of the Act is in the
nature of a conditional legislation. Dealing with the nature of
functions of a non-judicial authori- ty, Prof. S.A. De Smith in
Judicial Review of Administrative Action (third edition)
observes at page 163: "However, the analytical classification of a function may be a conclusive factor in excluding
the operation of the audi alteram partem rule. It is generally
assumed that in English law the making of a subordi- nate
legislative instrument need not be pre- ceded by notice or
hearing unless the parent Act so provides."
##
*4
<
*
+
+ *
*
*
<
)
*4
*3
+
+ @
+
)
A
*3
<
+
+
<
>
+
#&
:
+
+ 3 *
*
+
*4
>
*3
*3
<
+
3% 1 "0 11/
!
.
*
8.
1+ 11/,
-
+
#
+
G37 Petitioners in all these petitions seem to be
political workers who may be associated with one or
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
%
8 ,
=
the other political parties. No material has been
placed on record to indicate that any right of the
petitioners is infringed in any manner. The only right
of a citizen in the matter of election is to exercise
franchise according to his/her free will and choice.
This right of the petitioners remains intact irrespective
of the fact whether there are lesser number of
representatives or more. In some of the petitions, the
grievance of the petitioners is that they are interested
to contest election in a particular ward which has
either been reserved or de&reserved. These are the
individual rights which cannot have precedence over
the larger public interest of holding elections to
democratic institutions which alone can strengthen the
democracy. Since we have observed that there have
been aberrations in applying the constitutional
provisions in the right spirit in some of the
Municipalities, the reservation and allocation of
reserved wards have not been properly done. We hope
and believe that the State Government shall redress to
such complaints and adopt all resuscitative measures
at least for future elections to these democratic
bodies.”
#2
*
*
+
* )
+
*
#!
+
+
+
*4
*3
*3
+
/
*
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
)
*
+
+
*
)
*3
)
*4
*3 *
+
+
#
*
=
+
*
*+
+
*
)
+ 3*
+
3*
*
*3
*3
+
+
+
+
*
/
*
+
+
+
<
*
+
>
*
#1
E
+
*3
+
+
+
+
*4
+
*
*
<
+
+ 3*
>
*
+
< *4
+
*
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
+
*4
+
+
*4
<
*
*3
)
+
*3
)
>
*4
*3
*
*4
3*
#%
+
=
*
*
*+
*4
*
)
-
3% +$"/ 1
*
*
.
*3
+
%
8 ,
+ 1 1 "
&(
9 + 3 *
+
*
+
3%
<
1 "
%
8 ,
+
'"0 1
+ *
>
+
*
+
+
)
+
>
&"
:
(
+
*
*
F A*
>
+
)
* >
+
(
+
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
*3
F A*
+
,
'
/
+
*
*3
)
(
+
*
)
*4
+
*
+
*
+
-
$%
D
(
G29. In the above endeavour, it is apparent on a reading
of the draft rules, whereafters on consideration of the
apposite objections, the impugned notification(s) became
issued, that the exercise of limitation was taint free nor it
breached the Rules (supra). In sequel, the undertakings of
the well purpose of makings the de&limitation exercise,
thus for takings into account the apposite demographic
increases
in
the
wards
concerned,
rather
for
concomitantly the reservation system becoming drawn, as
has been drawn, but has also been achieved. Naturally
also therebys, prima facie, there appears to be no
exclusion of voters in the voters list, even after the
completion of the de&limitation exercise, especially, when
no tangible evidence in respect of the relevant exclusions
has been put forth as such. Even if such a grievance is put
forth, therebys, it was to be ventilated before and also was
to be decided rather only by the Election Tribunal
concerned, who on receiving such a motion, with
averments thereins, that on account of inapt exclusions of
the eligible voters, from the voters list, thus may have
proceeded to declare the election to be vitiated, the same
being materially affected therebys.”
30. However, the said grievance is stated to be neither put
forth before the Election Tribunal concerned, through an
election petition being cast therebefore, nor has been
stated to be under consideration before the State Election
Tribunal. Resultantly therebys, the completed de&
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
'
limitation exercise, as done, but on the basis of a census,
thus as a necessary precursor of the de&limitation of the
wards taking place, but when naturally also becomes the
hinge for the creation of a reservation roster for
endowing
the
apposite
representations
to
the
category(ies), whose population size so deserves. In
sequel, the de&limitation exercise, as undertaken but
cannot be faulted on any score, especially, when the
election programme has been announced, election
programme whereof, is un&interfereable in terms of the
expostulations of law made in the verdicts (supra).
Importantly also, when there is no grievance that in
pursuance to the de&limitation exercise, their being any
evident deprivation of the rights of exercising franchise
vis&a&vis any of the voters, therebys, also the de&limitation
exercise cannot be faulted.”
&$
F
)
+
*
>
+
*3
+
+
*
<
*4
<
&#
*
+
=
>
*3
F A*
&&
)
+
9 + 3*
*3
+
F A*
+
*3
3*
*3
+
(
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
*
+
* >
*
*3
+
*3
'
F A*
+
*
+
* +
*
)
*
&2
:
+ 3 *
(
*3
>
*3
)
3% 11/
%
. 5
>
1 1
'
1 1
+
$!
+
(
2 %
4 )
+
(
*
*
+*
*
+
*
+
C
>
+
*
:
3 +
*
*
$
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
+
3 +
2 %
*
(
$2 $!
D
G25. Keeping in view, the aforesaid ratio of law laid
down by the Hon’ble Apex Court and followed by the
Full Bench of this Court, we are of the considered
opinion that both the writ petitions are not maintainable
'
in as much as election process has commenced vide
Notifications dated 27.11.2020 and 1.12.2020 issued by
the State Election Commission notifying the programme
holding the general/bye elections of the Municipal
Corporations, Municipal Councils and Nagar
Panchayats. As reproduced above, the date for
preparation of electoral rolls is upto 9.12.2020, draft of
publication of electoral rolls is by 10.12.2020, last date
for filing claims and objections and disposal of the same
are 16.12.2020 and 23.12.2020 respectively. Final
publication of electoral rolls is on 5.1.2021. Intervention
of this Court, in exercise of writ jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution at this stage, which may
even remotely suggest the stalling of elections, is
improper. The object and purport of introduction of
Chapter IX&A in the Constitution of India by the 74th
Constitutional Amendment 1992 was/is to facilitate the
conduct of elections without putting any hindrance and
taboo which is the fundamental requirement of
democracy. Election to the local bodies is the grass root
of democracy which is a process by which much
decision&making authority is shifted to the lowest
geographic and social levels. Any action of the Court or
any individual which may, by any means, hamper or
obstruct the democratic process is anti thesis to the
spirit of these constitutional provisions.
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
26. The principles of natural justice are not embodied
rules and they cannot be imprisoned within the strait&
jacket of a rigid formula. The requirements of natural
justice depend on the circumstances of each case, the
nature of the enquiry, the rules under which the official
respondents are acting, the subject matter being dealt
with and so forth. In the present case, scheme and policy
for delimitation of wards has been framed under the
statute, right to file objections and suggestions has been
given to the residents of the Municipal areas. After
consideration of the objections, final notification has
been made. In this view of the matter, principles of
natural justice would not require personal hearing to be
given especially when all relevant circumstances were
taken into consideration before issuing final notification
of delimitation of wards.
27. In such matters, the scope of judicial review is very
limited. Judicial review of administrative action is
intended to prevent arbitrariness, irrationality,
unreasonableness, bias and mala fides. Its purpose is to
check whether choice or decision is made “lawfully”
and not to check whether choice or decision is “sound”.
We
find
no
arbitrariness,
irrationality,
unreasonableness, bias and mala fide in the action of the
''
respondents. This court will not interfere with the action
of the respondents and the letters/final notifications
impugned in both the writ petitions.”
&!
+*
*
*
+
*3
)
+
*
+
(
+
+
*
C
(
(
+
>
+
+
)
+
*4
@
A*
&
B
+
*
)
*
<
+
+
)
*
+
+
* >
+
*
+
+
+
+
*
+
&1
9 + 3 *
@
<
+
@
A
+
+
<
+
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
*
'>
* 3
+
B
*
+*
*
+
*
+
C
>
>
*
*
*
+
+
C
3 /
>
*
C
+
*
C
+
*
*3
+
*
)
E
+
F
+
&%
+
+
+
+
*
+
+
+ 3*
*
+
>
+
*
)
+
+
+
"%%2 B
2(
*
+
+
>
+
=
>
*4
$% "$ $($2
#" "$ $($2
+
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
>
)
+
+
+
*
*3
'
*4
<
2"
*+
+
/
78 ,
+
+
+
+
*4
+
&1
*
*4
,
*
B
+
*
*
*3
*4
+
*4
/
C
+
+
"%%2 B
2$
E
+
*3
$($!
>
*
*3
*3
*
+
+
+
"% $ -
+ 3*
5 +
*
5 +
+
*
+
*
+
*
*
?
)
+
+
*
+
*
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
C
+
*
'=
++
+
+
)
*
+
+
"% $ 2#
:
+ +*
*
*+
5 +
+ +*
*
2&
9 + 3 *
*
+ +*
*3
+
*
*3 5
+
>
++
+ +*
5 +
:
++
*
++
:
+
*3
+
+
)
+
*
3 *
++
*
>
:
*
*
*
B
+
*
)
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
*
*
')
2!
+ 3 *
*
,
#%!
#% &( #% 2" #% 2$ #% !( ' #%#2&
,
#"$% #"#& #"&( &$&$ (" (# (& ' (
+
*
*
$($!
B
+
*
$($2
*
F
+
<
+
>
+
4 *>
<
B
+
*3
+
*4
*3
<
*
+
*
+
9 + 3 *
*
*4
*3
<
*
*
+
+
3 C
*3
+
B
+
*4
*
<
>
+
C
3 *
+
, 3
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
+
*
*3
*
*
*
*
+
+
'
*
+
,
*
>
, 3
+
, 3
"" *4
*
*4
*4
*
+
>
, 3
2%
,
+
!(
/
*
!"
*
+
*
>
*3
+
<
*3
*
+
+
4 *
#" "$ $($2
!"
+
!$
*
# 0
# 0
" %
3 9#0 0
" %
. 2
aarti
+
@
AARTI SHARMA
2026.04.01 10:32
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Whether speaking/reasoned :Yes
Whether reportable :
Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review