Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision :07.01.2026
W.P.(C) 11894/2024 CM APPL. 4324/2025
ANIL PARMAR
.....Petitioner
Through:
Mr. Abhay Kumar Bhargava, Mr.
Satyaarth Sinha, Ms. Shradha Mewati
and Mr. Ajinkya Dhalwade, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr. Vedansh Anand, SPC with Mr.
Kush Garg, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA. (ORAL)
1.
The present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has
been filed by the petitioner seeking benefits of disability pension and
quashing of the order dated 29.01.2024 (‘impugned order’) issued by the IG
(ADM) FHQ BSF, New Delhi.
Factual Matrix
2.
The relevant facts in brief as set out in the petition are as under:
2.1.
The petitioner was working as a Constable at STC BSF Kharkan
Camp, Hoshiarpur, Punjab. On 02.10.2016, the petitioner and his wife met
with an accident while going to Civil Hospital, Hoshiarpur, Punjab on his
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
personal Activa Scooter due to the negligence and sudden opening of the
door of Celerio Car (Maruti Suzuki) of one Sh. Ravinder Singh. As a
consequence, the petitioner along with his wife collided with the opened
door of the car, lost their balance and fell down on the road. They were run
over by a civil truck, which was coming from behind. Afterwards, the
petitioner and his wife were rushed to Civil Hospital, Hoshiarpur, where the
Petitioner was diagnosed as a case of Road Traffic Accident (‘RTA’, for
short) with head injury as well as with fracture SOH left leg, fracture Tibia
Right, degloving injury of right foot and leg and foot with fracture D11D12, L2-L3 with paraplegia, fracture 3rd metataersal left. The petitioner and
his wife were further referred to PGI Chandigarh due to their critical
condition.
2.2.
Furthermore, on 06.10.2016 wife of the petitioner passed away.
Thereafter, on 07.10.2016 considering the seriousness of injury of the
petitioner, he was further shifted to Medanta Hospital Gurgaon. That while
being admitted in Medanta Hospital Gurgaon, on 08.10.2016 the petitioner
underwent surgery in which his right lower limb was amputated. That
despite surgery, the condition of the petitioner did not improve and again on
12.10.2016 he underwent debridement of right above knee amputated stump
along with percutaneous D10-11 AND L3-L4 fixation with rod and screws
was done. Thereafter on 30.12.2016, the petitioner underwent transnasal
trans-sphenoidal excision of pituitary tumor and was discharged on
02.01.2017. That petitioner was again admitted to Medanta Hospital
Gurgaon due to complaints regarding sore sacral region grade 3 and was
later on discharged on 06.03.2017 after preliminary treatment.
2.3.
The Court of Inquiry vide proceeding dated 15.04.2017 was of the
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
opinion that injury of the petitioner is attributable to bona fide government
service and all financial benefits should be provided to the petitioner. The
said opinion reads as under: “ OPINION OF THE COURT
After going through all the relevant witnesses and evidences produced,
this court of the opinion that:No 021099896 CT Anil Parmar along with his wife (Late Smt Sunita
Devi) met with an accident on 02-10-2016 while they were going to
Civil Hospital, Hoshiarpur for her treatment as she had been referred
to Civil Hospital, Hoshiarpur by CMO (SAG), STC BSF, Kharkan
Camp CT Anil Parmer had duly obtained outpass through proper
channel from his Coy Cdr for proceeding to Hoshiarpur.
No 021099896 CT Anil Parmar had no control over the circumstances
under which the accident happened due to sudden opening of the door
of Celerio car (No PB-17-AQ-1617) by the driver which was already
halting on the road. Resultantly, the Honda Activa (two wheeler vehicle
bearing registration number PB-07-R-2242) on which CT Anil Parmar
and his wife were travelling struck with the door of the car after which
they fell down on the road and were run over by a Civil truck (Tipper)
No PB-32-L-9872 coming on the road from behind. The accident
happened due to sheer negligence of the driver of Celerio car (No PB07-AQ-1617).
No 021099896 CT Anil Parmar, being on bona fide government duty,
may be extended all the necessary financial benefits admissible to him
under such cases. The injuries sustained hy the individual are
attributable to government service.
Further, medical category of No 021099896 CT Anil Parmar may be
assessed upon his arrival in this institution after recuperation.”
2.4.
The Inspector General, STC BSF, Kharkan Camp, Distt Hoshiarpur
(Punjab) vide order dated 02.05.2017 agreed with the findings of the Court
of Inquiry and opined that the injury sustained by the petitioner was
attributable to government service, as the petitioner was on bonafide
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
government duty. It directed that all financial benefits should be provided to
the petitioner as per BSF Rules, 1969 (‘BSF Rules’, for short). The order
dated 02.05.2017 is reproduced hereinbelow: -
2.5.
A disability certificate dated 11.10.2017 was issued by the Disability
Medical Board, Civil Hospital, Bhiwani, Haryana, whereby the petitioner
was declared a case of 100% permanent disability.
2.6.
The petitioner appeared before the Medical Board on 13.07.2022,
which awarded him a Medical Category of ‘S1H1A5P5E1’ and declared his
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
case of 100% permanent disability. Furthermore, the Medical Board opined
that the disability of the petitioner was attributed to bona-fide government
duty. The Medical Board further opined that the petitioner is not fit for
rehabilitation in force and was declared as unfit for service.
A medical certificate dated 13.07.2022 was also issued during the
course of medical board proceeding, whereby the petitioner was considered
unfit for service due to ‘Post Traumatic Paraplegia with above Knee
Amputation of Right Lower Limb with Left Foot 3rd Ray Amputation with
Fracture D12, L1, L2 with Fracture Right Transverse Process of L1/L2 with
Fracture Left Transverse Process of L3/L4 and Bladder Involvement’.
2.7.
The decision to retire the petitioner from duty due to physical
unfitness in accordance with Rule 25 of the BSF Rules, 1969 was
communicated to the petitioner by the respondents, vide a notice dated
14.09.2022.
2.8.
The petitioner retired from services on grounds of permanent
disability w.e.f., 10.11.2022 vide an order dated 05.11.2022 issued by the
respondents on the ground that the petitioner was placed in Medical
Category of ‘S1H1A5P5E1’ with 100% permanent disability and was
considered unfit for service by the Medical Board under the provisions of
Rule 25 of BSF Rules ,1969 along with pensionary benefit.
2.9.
The petitioner applied for disability pension after his retirement but
the same was rejected by the respondents vide impugned order dated
29.01.2024 on the ground that petitioner was not injured while performing
any official task or government duty.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioner
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner states that the relevant provision is
Rule 3-A of CCS (Extraordinary Pension) Rules, 1939 (‘CCS (EOP) Rules,
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
1939’, for short). The said rule read as under: “3-A. Disablement/Death - (1)(a) Disablement shall be accepted as
due to Government service, provided that it is certified that it is due to
wound, injury or disease which –
(i) is attributable to Government service, or
(ii) existed before or arose during Government service and has
been and remains aggravated thereby.
(b) Death shall be accepted as due to Government service provided it
is certified that it was due to or hastened by(i) a wound, injury or disease which was attributable to
Government service, or
(ii) the aggravation by Government service of a wound, injury
or disease which existed before or arose during Government
service.
(2) There shall be a casual connection between(a) disablement and Government service; and
(b) death and Government service, for attributability or
aggravation to be conceded Guidelines in this regard are given
in the Appendix which shall be treated as part and parcel of
these Rules.
G.I., M.HA., (Dept. of Personnel & A.R.), O.M. No. F. 23
(9)-EV (A)/79, dated the 28th November, 1980.- Clarification.It will be seen from the new (revised) Forms "C", "D" and "E"
that these forms of medical certificates have been so designed
that they would indicate whether the entitlement criteria laid
down in new Rule 3-A have been satisfied or not, and,
therefore, normally, no other separate certificates in that behalf
maybe necessary. It is essential for the Administrative Officer
as well as the Audit Officer (PAO) concerned to satisfy
themselves that the death/disability is, in fact, attributable to or
aggravated by the Government service which alone makes in
E.O.P. Award admissible and for that purpose, it is essential
for both of these authorities to satisfy themselves in that behalf
and certify the nexus and causal connection between
disablement and Government service or between death and
Government service (as the case may be), in any particular
case, as laid down in the new Rule 3-A on the. basis of the
medical and other documents regarding the case. If a
Government servant had died in such circumstances and that a
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
medical report could not be secured, even then, the nexus and
the causal connection between death and Government service
has to be established before conceding acceptance of death due
to Government service.
(3) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules, the
degree of default or contributory negligence on the part of a
Government servant may be taken into consideration in making
an award under these rules in favour of such Government
servant, but, shall not be taken into account where such award
is made in favour of the family of such Government servant.”
3.1.
He states that for entitlement of disability pension, the officer is
required to show that the disablement is due to an injury, which is
attributable to the government service or it arose during government service
and has been aggravated thereby.
3.2.
He states that the Medical Board in its opinion dated 13.07.2022 has
opined that the petitioner has sustained injuries due to RTA while on
bonafide duty at Kharkhan Camp, which eventually led to his disability.
Thus, there is a casual connection between the government service and the
disability.
3.3.
He states that the impugned order dated 29.01.2024 has been passed
by the respondents without giving any due consideration to the Medical
Board proceeding held on 13.07.2022 and the medical certificate dated
13.07.2022. He relies upon the judgment of the coordinate Bench of this
Court in Rajinder Mani v. UOI and Ors.1
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
4.
In reply, learned counsel for the respondents’ states that the petitioner
on the fateful day on 02.10.2016 was not ‘on duty’. He states that for being
eligible for pension the injury ought to have been sustained when
2019:DHC:1499-DB
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
performing an official task or a task, failure to do which would constitute an
offence. He refers to para 4(b) of the Guidelines for Conceding
Attributability of Disablement or Death to Government Service as applicable
to CCS (EOP) Rules, 1939.
4.1.
He states that indisputably when the petitioner suffered the injury
leading to his disability in a road accident, he was in government service but
not on government official duty or task assigned to him by the BSF.
4.2.
He states that the investigation before the Court of Inquiry, its opinion
dated 15.04.2017, the order of the Inspector General dated 02.05.2017 and
the Medical Board opinion dated 13.07.2022 are a matter of record. He
states that there is no dispute that the petitioner suffered 100% disability due
to the road accident, however, no direct corelation between disablement and
duty could be established.
4.3.
He states that as per G.I., MHA [Dept. of Pers. & AR] O.M. No.
F.23(9)-EV(A)/79 dated 28.11.1980 being a clarification on Rule 3-A of
CCS (EOP) Rules, 1939, it is essential for the Administrative Officer as well
as the Audit Officer concerned to satisfy themselves that disability is infact
attribution or aggravated by the government service, which alone makes an
EOP award admissible. He states that it is for these authorities to satisfy
themselves in this behalf and certify the nexus and casual connection
between disablement and government service on the basis of the medical
and other documents in the case. He states that the finding of the Court of
Inquiry and the Medical Board alone is not sufficient for grant of EOP
benefits.
Findings and Analysis
5.
We have heard the learned counsels for the parties and perused the
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
record.
6.
It is a matter of fact that the permanent disability of the petitioner is
not in dispute; the moot question is whether the said permanent disability of
the petitioner is attributable or aggravated by the service.
7.
The Court of Inquiry in its proceeding dated 15.04.2017 has held in
favour of the petitioner and determined that the injury of the petitioner is
attributable to bonafide government service and all the benefits should be
provided to him.
8.
The Court of Inquiry was held in pursuance to Rule 174(b) of BSF
Rules, which reads as under:
“174. Courts of Inquiry when to be Held.- (1) A court of inquiry may
be held to investigate into any disciplinary matter or any other matter
of importance.
(2) In addition to a Court of Inquiry required to be held under
section 62, a court of inquiry shall be held in the following cases:…
(b) All injuries sustained by persons subject to the Act
which are likely to cause full or partial disability. The court
shall in such case determine whether such injuries were
attributable to service or not.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
9.
Inspector General, STC BSF, Kharkan Camp vide his order dated
02.05.2017 agreed with the opinion of the Court of Inquiry and opined that
the injury sustained by the petitioner was attributable to government service,
as the petitioner was on bonafide duty. The order further directed that all
financial benefits should be provided to the petitioner as per BSF Rules. The
said order was passed by the Inspector General in pursuance to Rule 175 of
BSF Rules, which reads as under:
“175. Action on the Proceedings of a Court of Inquiry.The proceedings of a court of inquiry shall be submitted by
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
the presiding officer to the officer or authority who ordered
the court. Such officer or authority on receiving the
proceedings may either pass final orders on the
proceedings himself, if he is empowered to do so, or refer
them to a superior authority.”
10.
The aforesaid order dated 02.05.2017 has attained finality and was
implemented as all financial benefits were extended to the petitioner.
11.
The Medical Board vide its proceedings dated 13.07.2022 has
unequivocally certified that the disability of petitioner was attributed to
bonafide government duty. The relevant portion of the report reads as under:
In fact, the Medical Board has recorded the then present condition of the
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
petitioner, which reads as under:
“(ii) What is the Govt. Servant's present condition: - At present,
Individual has Post-traumatic paraplegia with above knee amputation
right lower limb (02.10.2016) and no bowel & bladder control. He is
totally bed ridden.”
12.
The aforesaid report of the Medical Board was duly accepted by the
respondents and a notice for retirement was issued to the petitioner on
14.09.2022 and subsequently the petitioner was boarded out on 10.11.2022.
The findings of the said report thus attained finality qua the respondents.
13.
In view of the aforesaid findings the conditions of Rule 3-A of the
CCS (EOP) Rules, 1939 for entitlement of disability pension to the
petitioner stand satisfied. The aforesaid reports and order show that the
respondents conceded that the petitioner has suffered an injury which is
attributable to the government service.
14.
Rule 3-A read with Rule 13(4) of the CCS (EOP) Rules, 1939
contemplate that before the Government accepts the claim for disability
pension, it shall call for a medical report and a report of the accounts officer.
In the facts of this case, no report of the accounts officer has been
placed on record and the medical report relied upon is dated 13.07.2022 as
referred to above.
15.
The petitioner has placed on record the impugned order dated
29.01.2024, issued by the respondents, which refers to a comment of PAD2
BSF, which has not agreed to the request for grant of disability pension on
the ground that there is no direct corelation between disablement and duty.
The order also refers to the advice of MHA (R&WD) dated 21.12.2023,
which similarly opines that it ‘appears’ that the petitioner was not injured
Payment and Accounts Division
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
during performance of any official task or government duty. The
respondents have sought to defend the aforesaid impugned order by
contending that petitioner was not on duty at the relevant time when the
accident occurred.
16.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the impugned order dated
29.01.2024 is liable to be set aside as it is in complete contradiction to the
findings of the Court of Inquiry’s order dated 15.04.2017 passed by the
competent authority and the Medical Board’s opinion dated 13.07.2022,
which have categorically held that the injuries suffered by the petitioner on
the fateful day of 02.10.2016 are attributable to Government service and
which further held that the petitioner was on bona fide government duty.
17.
The Court of Inquiry was held specifically for determining this
specific aspect as a fact finding under Rule 174(b) of BSF Rules and the
order of the competent authority under Rule 175 of BSF Rules accepting the
said report for this very purpose forms the basis of extension of financial
benefits to the petitioner at the relevant time.
The denial of the disability pension by now disputing that the
petitioner was not on bonafide government duty is inherently contradictory
to the actions already taken by the respondents in favour of the petitioner
past since 2017; and the respondents cannot be heard to take a different
stand only for the purpose of denying disability pension.
No cogent reasons have been furnished by the PAD, BSF or the
Government in the impugned order dated 29.01.2024 for recommending
contrary to the aforementioned orders and findings of the competent
authority as well as the Medical Board. The impugned order does not make
any reference to the aforesaid orders and findings and therefore cannot be
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
sustained and is thus liable to be set aside.
18.
In view of the aforesaid, the impugned order dated 29.01.2024 is
hereby set aside. The respondents are directed to grant the benefits of
disability pension to the petitioner under Rule 3 and Rule 3-A of the CCS
(EOP) Rules, 1939 along with 9% interest from the date of his release i.e.
10.11.2022.
19.
With the aforesaid directions, this petition stands allowed and
disposed of. Pending applications, if any, stands disposed of.
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
JANUARY 7, 2026/rr/hp/MG
Signed By:MAHIMA
SHARMA
12:24
W.P.(C) 11894/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review