Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
Appeal from Order No.503 of 2012
Reliance General Insurance
Company Ltd.
…..Appellant
Vs.
Anil Nath and others
…..Respondents
With
Appeal from Order No.35 of 2013
Anil Nath
…..Appellant
Vs.
Sohan Singh Pundir and others
…..Respondents
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:Mr. Pulak Agarwal with Mr. Bharat Tewari, Advocates for the
appellants.
Mr. Bhagwat Mehra, Advocate for respondent no.2.
Mr. Deepa Rawat, Advocate for respondent no.4.
Mr. Himanshu Pal, Advocate for the formal party.
---------------------------------------------------------------------Hon'ble Pankaj Purohit, J.
These two appeals arise out of a common motor
vehicle accident and common judgment and award passed
by learned Tribunal and involve identical questions of fact
and law. Accordingly, both the appeals are being disposed
of together by this common judgment.
2.
The appeal being AO No.503 of 2012 has been
preferred by the Insurance Company seeking absolution
from liability, whereas AO No.35 of 2013 has been filed
by the claimant seeking enhancement of compensation
awarded by the Tribunal to the tune of ₹1,60,265/-.
3.
These proceedings arose out of a motor
accident claim petition instituted before the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, District Pithoragarh, wherein
the claimant sought compensation for grievous injuries
sustained in a road accident dated 29.06.2009. The
learned Tribunal, after appreciating the pleadings and
evidence on record, decided the claim petition by
judgment and award dated 04.08.2012. The present
narration records the factual background, pleadings of
the parties, issues framed by the Tribunal and the
findings returned thereon.
4.
The brief facts of the case are that on 29th
June 2009 at about 05:00 P.M., the claimant-Anil Nath
was travelling on a motorcycle of his friend as a pillonrider bearing registration no. UK-07-U-9313 near Van
Vibhag Post, Raywala, Dehradun. At the said place, an
Indigo car bearing registration no.UA-09-4848, coming
from the opposite direction, collided with the motorcycle.
As a result of the accident, the claimant sustained
multiple grievous injuries, including severe injuries to his
right hand and other parts of the body. He was initially
taken to Jolly Grant Hospital, Dehradun and thereafter
referred to P.G.I. Chandigarh, where he underwent
prolonged treatment including surgeries. The claimant
asserted that due to the injuries sustained in the
accident, he suffered permanent disability, affecting his
physical capacity and quality of life. Consequently, a
claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 was filed before the Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal seeking compensation.
5.
The
claimant
pleaded
that
the
accident
occurred solely due to the rash and negligent driving of
the Indigo car by its driver. It was specifically averred
that the car was being driven at a high speed and on the
wrong side of the road, resulting in a head-on collision
with the motorcycle. The claimant further pleaded that
he sustained grievous injuries, remained hospitalized for
a long duration, underwent multiple surgical procedures
including amputation of his right hand, and suffered
permanent disability assessed at 80%. It was stated that
the injuries caused immense physical pain, mental agony
and loss of enjoyment of life. The claimant claimed
compensation under various heads including medical
expenses, pain and suffering, loss of amenities and
permanent disability.
6.
The owner of the Indigo car filed his written
statements denying the allegations of rash and negligent
driving. It was pleaded that his vehicle was being driven
carefully and in accordance with traffic rules. According
to him, the accident occurred due to negligence on the
part of the motorcycle rider. It was also pleaded that the
vehicle was duly insured and that the driver possessed a
valid and effective driving licence at the time of the
accident.
7.
The
insurance
company
filed
a
separate
written statement contesting the claim petition. While the
insurance
company
did
not
specifically
deny
the
occurrence of the accident, it disputed its liability to pay
compensation. It was pleaded that the claimant and
other occupants (riders) of the motorcycle were travelling
in violation of statutory provisions. The insurance
company further raised objections regarding the validity
of the driving licence and alleged breach of policy
conditions. The quantum of compensation claimed was
also disputed as excessive and unsupported by reliable
evidence.
8.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties the
Tribunal framed the following issues:
(1). Whether on 29.06.2009 at about 05:00 P.M., at the
place DPO No.1, in front of the Forest Department,
Raywala, District Dehradun, while the claimant Anil
Nath, during the course of his duty, was travelling by
sitting on the pillion seat of motorcycle bearing
registration no. UK-07-U-9313 towards Pithoragarh, the
driver of Indigo car bearing registration no.UA-09-4848,
by driving the vehicle at high speed and negligently from
the opposite side, dashed against the said motorcycle, as
a result of which the claimant sustained injuries?
(2). Whether in causing the aforesaid accident, there was
also negligence on the part of the driver of motorcycle
bearing registration no.UK-07-U-9313, and if so, what
would be its effect?
(3). Whether the vehicle bearing registration no.UA-094848 involved in the aforesaid accident was insured with
respondent no.3-Reliance General Insurance Company
Limited, and whether the vehicle documents and the
driving licence of the driver were valid; if so, what would
be its effect?
(4). Whether the motorcycle bearing registration no.UK07-U-9313 involved in the aforesaid accident was
insured with respondent no.6-The Oriental Insurance
Company Limited, and whether the vehicle documents
and the driving licence of the driver were valid; if so,
what would be its effect?
(5). Whether the claimant is entitled to receive any
compensation if so, from which respondent and to what
extent?
9.
While
deciding
Issue
No.1,
the
Tribunal
considered the oral testimony of the claimant and other
witnesses, along with documentary evidence including
the FIR, site plan, charge-sheet and medical records. The
Tribunal found that the claimant’s version regarding the
manner of the accident remained consistent and credible.
The Tribunal held that the Indigo car bearing registration
no.UA-09-4848 was being driven rashly and negligently
and had come from the opposite direction, colliding with
the motorcycle. The injuries sustained by the claimant
were found to be a direct result of the said collision.
Accordingly, Issue No.1 was decided in favour of the
claimant, holding that the accident occurred due to rash
and negligent driving of the Indigo car.
10.
While dealing with Issue No.2, the Tribunal
examined whether the driver of the motorcycle bearing
registration no.UK-07-U-9313 was also negligent. The
Tribunal took note of the evidence on record, including
statements regarding the number of persons travelling on
the motorcycle at the time of the accident. The Tribunal
recorded that more than the permissible number of
persons were travelling on the motorcycle and that
contradictory statements had been made by the claimant
and witnesses in this regard. But it was recorded by the
learned Tribunal that could not be the cause of accident
always. On this basis, the Tribunal held that there was
no contributory negligence on the part of the motorcycle
rider. Accordingly, Issue No.2 was decided in favour of
the claimant, holding that no contributory negligence was
established against the motor-cyclist.
11.
While
deciding
Issue
No.3,
the
Tribunal
examined the insurance policy, vehicle documents and
driving
licence
relating
to
the
Indigo
car
bearing
registration no.UA-09-4848. The Tribunal found that the
said vehicle was duly insured with Reliance General
Insurance Company Limited on the date of the accident.
The Tribunal further held that the driver of the Indigo car
possessed a valid and effective driving licence and that
the vehicle documents were in order. Accordingly, Issue
No.3 was decided in favour of the claimant, fastening the
liability upon respondent no.3, the insurance company
i.e. Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. of the Indica Car.
12.
While
deciding
Issue
No.4,
the
Tribunal
considered the evidence relating to motorcycle bearing
registration no. UK-07-U-9313, including the insurance
policy and driving licence of the rider. The Tribunal found
that the motorcycle was insured with The Oriental
Insurance Company Limited and that the relevant
documents were valid. Therefore, the issue no.4 was
decided in favour of claimants.
13.
While
deciding
Issue
No.5,
the
Tribunal
assessed the nature of injuries, medical evidence,
disability certificate and expenses proved on record. The
Tribunal accepted that the claimant suffered grievous
injuries including permanent disability, pain and mental
agony.
However,
the
Tribunal
restricted
the
compensation under various heads and awarded a total
compensation of ₹1,60,265/-, together with interest at
the rate of 8% per annum from the date of filing of the
claim petition till realization.
14.
The Tribunal held that the liability to pay the
awarded compensation rested upon respondent no.3, the
appellant insurance company. Accordingly, Issue No.5
was decided partly in favour of the claimant.
15.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties at
length and having carefully perused the record of the
Tribunal, this Court finds that both the appeals arise out
of the same judgment and award dated 04.08.2012
passed
by
the
Motor
Accident
Claims
Tribunal,
Pithoragarh, and therefore deserve to be decided together
by this common judgment.
16.
The principal contention of the Insurance
Company is that the Tribunal erred in fastening liability
upon it, particularly in view of the fact that the claimant
was found to have made false statements before the
Tribunal, suppressed material facts, and attempted to
mislead the Court by producing fabricated bills and by
falsely asserting that only two persons were riding the
motorcycle at the time of the accident.
17.
This Court is unable to accept the said
submission. It is a settled position of law that the liability
of an insurer in a claim under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 can be avoided or restricted only upon
proof of one or more statutory defences enumerated
under Section 149(2) of the Act. The burden to establish
such
defences
Company.
In
squarely
the
lies
present
upon
case,
the
the
Insurance
Tribunal
has
categorically recorded findings that the offending vehicle
(Indica Car No.UA-09-4848) was duly insured with the
appellant Insurance Company on the date of the
accident; the policy was valid and subsisting; no evidence
was led by the insurer to prove that the driver of the
offending vehicle did not possess a valid driving licence or
that there was any breach of policy conditions.
18.
In the absence of proof of any statutory
defence, the Insurance Company cannot be absolved of
its liability merely on account of misconduct or falsehood
on the part of the claimant. The law on this aspect
stands authoritatively settled by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran
Singh & Ors., (2004) 3 SCC 297, wherein it has been held
that unless a defence under Section 149(2) is strictly
proved, the insurer remains statutorily liable to satisfy
the award.The attempt made by the claimant to mislead
the Tribunal, howsoever reprehensible, does not fall
within the scope of statutory defences available to the
insurer. Such conduct may legitimately influence the
quantum of compensation, but it cannot result in
exoneration of the insurer from liability. Accordingly, this
Court finds no legal infirmity in the Tribunal fastening
liability upon the Insurance Company.
19.
The claimant has sought enhancement of
compensation primarily on the ground that he suffered
80% permanent disability, including amputation of the
right hand, and therefore the compensation awarded by
the Tribunal is grossly inadequate. At the outset, it must
be noted that the Tribunal has not disputed the nature or
extent of the injuries suffered by the claimant. The
medical evidence on record clearly establishes that the
claimant suffered grievous injuries resulting in 80%
permanent disability, which stands duly proved by
medical testimony and disability certificate. However, the
determination of “just compensation” does not depend
solely upon the percentage of physical disability. The
correct legal approach has been laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar,
(2011) 1 SCC 343, wherein it has been held that the
Tribunal must assess:
1. the nature of disability,
2. its impact on earning capacity,
3. the avocation of the claimant prior to the
accident,
4. and whether the disability has resulted in loss of
future earning capacity.
20.
Applying the above principles, the Tribunal
has recorded a clear finding that the claimant failed to
establish any loss of future income. The claimant was
working in the P.A.C. department and continued to
receive his salary even after the accident. No evidence
was led to show reduction in pay, loss of service benefits,
or termination from employment.
21.
Thus, the Tribunal rightly declined to award
compensation under the head of loss of future earning
capacity. This Court cannot overlook the serious findings
recorded by the Tribunal regarding the conduct of the
claimant. The Tribunal has meticulously analysed the
evidence and has arrived at the conclusion that- three
persons were riding the motorcycle at the time of the
accident, contrary to the claimant’s assertion that only
two persons were riding; the claimant produced a
caretaker bill of ₹50,000/-, whereas in his own statement
he had earlier claimed to have paid only ₹5,000/- each;
the alleged caretaker bill was unsupported by any
independent evidence and bore only the claimant’s own
signature; false statements were made on oath, and
material facts were suppressed.
22.
The Tribunal has rightly held that such
conduct
disentitles
the
claimant
from
claiming
compensation under exaggerated or unproved heads.
This approach is fully consistent with the observation of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Raj Kumar v.
Ajay Kumar (supra) that the Tribunal must not be a
silent spectator and must actively scrutinise the evidence
to ensure that only “just compensation” is awarded.
23.
examined
That
said,
whether,
misconduct,
the
this
Court
has
notwithstanding
compensation
independently
the
claimant’s
awarded
under
conventional heads warrants marginal interference. The
Tribunal has awarded - ₹40,265/- towards medical
expenses (proved by bills), ₹20,000/- towards attendant
expenses, ₹1,00,000/- towards pain, suffering, and loss
of amenities of life.
24.
Given
the
nature
of
injuries,
prolonged
treatment, amputation, and permanent disability, the
amount of ₹1,00,000/- awarded towards pain, suffering,
and loss of amenities cannot be said to be shockingly low
so as to warrant interference. On the contrary, the
Tribunal has already exercised considerable discretion in
awarding this amount despite the claimant’s lack of
honesty.
25.
Learned counsel for the claimant relied upon
the judgment passed in Rekha Jain v. National Insurance
Co. Ltd., (2013) 8 SCC 389. But in the said case, the
Supreme
Court
enhanced
compensation
where
the
claimant had suffered total loss of career prospects.
However, the said judgment is clearly distinguishable on
facts, as in the present case no loss of livelihood or
income has been established. This Court is therefore of
the considered view that no further enhancement is
legally justified.
26.
In view of the foregoing discussion:
A.
AO No. 503 of 2012, filed by the Insurance
Company, lacks merit and is hereby dismissed, as
no statutory defence under Section 149(2) of the
Motor Vehicles Act has been established.
B.
AO No. 35 of 2013, filed by the claimant for
enhancement of compensation, is also dismissed, as
the
compensation
awarded
by
the
Tribunal
represents just compensation in the facts and
circumstances of the case, and the claimant’s own
conduct
disentitles
him
from
any
further
indulgence. The award dated 04.08.2012 passed by
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, awarding a
total
compensation
interest
as
of
directed,
₹1,60,265/is
hereby
along
with
affirmed.
The
claimant is entitled to receive said compensation of
Rs.1,60,265/- along with interest @ of 8% per
annum accrued thereon, if not already received or
adjusting the amount received by him.
(Pankaj Purohit, J.)
SK
26.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review