Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. 445 of 2026
Reserved on: 18.09.2026
Date of decision: 28.09.2026
____________________________________________________
Anil Kumar
...Petitioner.
Versus
State of H.P. & others
...Respondents.
Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner:
Ms. Devyani Sharma, Senior
Advocate with Ms. Srishti Negi,
Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Diwakar Dev Sharma, Additional
Advocate General.
__________________________________________________
Romesh Verma, Judge
The instant petition arises out of the judgment dated
30.03.2026 passed by learned District Judge, Una, District Una,
H.P., whereby the appeal filed by the plaintiff/petitioner was
dismissed and the order dated 16.12.2024 passed by learned
Civil Judge, Court No. II, Una, District Una, H.P. was affirmed,
whereby the application filed by the plaintiff under Order 39
Rules 1 and 2 CPC was dismissed.
2.
The facts as emerge in the present case are that the
plaintiff/petitioner filed a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction
against the respondents/defendants restraining defendants No.
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
1 and 2, i.e., State of H.P. and Block Development Officer, from
sanctioning and releasing the grant-in-aid for the proposed
cremation ground in favour of defendant No. 3, and restraining
defendant No. 3 personally or through its agents and servants
from constructing the proposed cremation ground over the land
bearing Khasra No. 6830.
3.
As per the case set up by the plaintiff, he is an
inhabitant, proprietor and right holder of Village Badhera, Tehsil
Haroli, District Una, H.P. He is joint owner in possession of land
bearing Khasra No. 6826, comprised in Khata No. 2112 min,
Khatauni No. 2552 min, measuring 17 Kanals 14 Marlas(2), and
land measuring 02 Kanals 19 Marlas, Khewat No. 2110 min,
Khatauni No. 2550 min, Khasra No. 6848, as per Jamabandi for
the year 2014-15, situated in Mohal Badhera, Tehsil Haroli,
District Una, H.P.
4.
As per the case of the plaintiff, civil litigation between
the Gram Panchayat and one of the affected and interested
persons, namely Amrit Lal, cropped up in the Civil Court in the
form of Civil Suit No. 64 of 2003, titled Amrit Lal versus Gram
Panchayat, decided on 09.04.2007, and Civil Appeal No. 49 of
2007 was decided on 31.01.2008 by the learned District Judge,
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
Una. In the said litigation, the question involved was that the
Gram Panchayat should be stopped from constructing a
cremation ground near the abadi area. As per the case of the
plaintiff, the then Pradhan of the Gram Panchayat compromised
with the plaintiff Amrit Lal on 30.01.2008 and it was agreed upon
that as and when alternative land is made available, the
cremation ground will be established there. Pursuant thereto,
one Sh. Manohar Singh, son of Sh. Hakam Singh, vide gift deed
No. 1565 of 2014 dated 25.11.2014, gifted land measuring 1
Kanal bearing Khasra No. 7370 to the Panchayati Raj
Department, Himachal Pradesh, through Gram Panchayat
Lower Badhera for the construction of a 'Shamshan Ghat', which
has been mutated in the revenue record vide mutation No. 8590
dated 20.12.2014.
5.
The plaintiff alleged that Gram Panchayat Lower
Badhera (Defendant No. 3) had constructed a 'Shamshan Ghat'
over the land bearing Khasra No. 7370, for which the plaintiff
and others had no objection since this 'Shamshan Ghat' is a
proper, appropriate and adequate place for the cremation of
dead bodies, being located outside the abadi area. The plaintiff
is a family person and he has a huge family who are living in the
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
abadi over the land of Khasra Nos. 6826 and 6848, which is
adjoining to the land of Khasra No. 6830.
6.
As per the plaintiff, the abadi of the plaintiff is situated
over the land of Khasra Nos. 6826 and 6848 adjoining the land
of Khasra No. 6830. Defendant No. 3 having its political
allegiance to one political party, whereas the plaintiff and others
having their allegiance to another political party, therefore,
defendant No. 3 threatened to construct another 'Shamshan
Ghat' over Khasra No. 6830 and passed a resolution and sent it
to defendant Nos. 1 and 2 for approval, and defendant No. 1 is
threatening to sanction the grant for the proposed construction
of the 'Shamshan Ghat' over the land of Khasra No. 6830, which
is adjoining to a thickly populated area.
7.
As per the case of the plaintiff, since these acts amount
to an invasion of the civil rights of the plaintiff and other
inhabitants of the village, as the proposed 'Shamshan Ghat' is
amidst the abadies of the vicinity and abuts the holdings/abadies
of the plaintiff and other inhabitants, therefore, the same shall
not be for the benefit of the plaintiff and other co-villagers. As
such, the plaintiff filed a suit for permanent injunction restraining
defendants No. 1 and 2 from sanctioning and releasing the
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
grant-in-aid for the proposed 'Shamshan Ghat' in favour of
defendant No. 3, and restraining defendant No. 3, personally
and through its agents and servants, from constructing the
proposed 'Shamshan Ghat' over the land of Khasra No. 6830,
measuring 00-16 Marlas, comprised in Khewat No. 1074,
Khatauni No. 1231, as per Jamabandi for the year 2004-05,
situated in Mohal Badhera, Tehsil Haroli, District Una, H.P.
8.
The suit was resisted by defendant No. 3 by filing a
written statement in which preliminary objections with regard to
cause of action, maintainability, locus standi, suppression of
material facts/not approaching the Court with clean hands,
estoppel, and the suit being barred by Section 11 of the CPC
etc. were raised. On merits, all the averments made in the plaint
were refuted and denied.
9.
Though the institution of Civil Suit No. 64 of 2003, titled
Amrit Lal vs. Gram Panchayat, and the appeal filed against the
said judgment were not denied, as a matter of record and it was
submitted in the written statement that the cremation ground is
already existing in Khasra No. 6830 and it is used for cremation
of dead bodies since long by the inhabitants of the locality of the
village. Previously there was no abadi near the cremation
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
ground bearing Khasra No. 6830 and the abadies were
constructed by the villagers later on, which are also far away
from Khasra No. 6830. Since the similar controversy stands
decided in Civil Suit No. 64 of 2003 decided on 09.04.2007, the
suit is barred under Section 11 CPC.
10.
In defence, it was stated by defendant No. 3 that the
aforesaid land bearing Khasra No. 7370 is about 3 kilometres
away from Khasra No. 6830, and the said Khasra No. 7370 is
jointly owned and possessed by co-sharers along with the Gram
Panchayat, situated near the boundary of village Saloh. Village
Badhera is a big village in length and width and there are other
cremation grounds ('Shamshan Ghat's) including this 'Shamshan
Ghat' being used and existing in Khasra No. 6830. The
cremation ground which is existing over Khasra No. 7370 has
been constructed in an abadi which is about 3 kilometres away
from 'Shamshan Ghat' existing in Khasra No. 6830, and the
said 'Shamshan Ghat' in Khasra No. 7370 is not approachable
to the inhabitants of the locality and people residing in the area
of Khasra No. 6830. As per the defendant, no new cremation
ground is being constructed in Khasra No. 6830, but an
improvement has to be made to the old existing 'Shamshan
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
Ghat' by constructing a boundary wall, cremation sheds, sitting
benches etc., and providing water facilities to the general public
at large as well as for the safety and security of the people and
agricultural land of the adjoining field owners. It is submitted that
the cremation ground ('Shamshan Ghat') is lying open and the
dead bodies are cremated and funeral rites are performed in the
open space, due to which there remains an apprehension of fire
spreading and causing damage to the crops, and to make
development of the area, the Government has sanctioned an
amount of Rs. 14,45,000/- for the improvement of 'Shamshan
Ghat' for raising a boundary wall, cremation sheds, providing
water facility, sitting benches etc., for the safety and facility of
the general public. Dead bodies have been cremated there for
the last 25-30 years, and even during COVID-19 dead bodies
were cremated there, and there is no other cremation ground
near the locality for cremation of dead bodies. Therefore, it was
prayed that the suit filed by the plaintiff being without any merit
deserves to be dismissed.
11.
Along with the suit, the plaintiff/petitioner filed an
application under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 read with Section 151
of the CPC with the prayer that defendants/respondents be
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
restrained from releasing the grant-in-aid for the proposed
'Shamshan Ghat' in favour of defendant No. 3, and defendant
No. 3 be restrained personally or through its agents & servants
from constructing the proposed 'Shamshan Ghat' over the land
comprised in Khasra No. 6830.
12.
The application was duly resisted by the defendants
and it was prayed that the application being without any merit
deserves to be dismissed.
13.
The learned Civil Judge, Court No. 2, Una, District
Una, H.P., vide its order dated 16.12.2024 dismissed the
application filed by the plaintiff/petitioner.
14.
Feeling aggrieved, plaintiff approached the learned
District Judge, Una, District Una, H.P., by invoking the
provisions under Order 43 Rule 1 of the CPC on 06.01.2025.
The learned First Appellate Court vide its judgment dated
30.03.2026
dismissed
the
appeal
preferred
by
the
plaintiff/petitioner.
15.
Feeling dissatisfied, plaintiff/petitioner has approached
this Court by instituting the present petition invoking the
provisions under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
16.
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
It is contended by Ms. Devyani Sharma, learned Senior
Counsel, assisted by Ms. Srishti Negi, Advocate for the
petitioner, that the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned Courts below are erroneous and liable to be quashed
and set aside. She submits that the learned Courts below have
not appreciated the point in controversy in hand and have
wrongly rejected the application filed by the plaintiff for grant of
interim injunction. She further submits that after accepting the
present petition, the application filed by the petitioner/plaintiff
under the provisions of Order 39 Rules 1 & 2 CPC is liable to be
allowed.
17.
On the other hand, Mr. Diwakar Dev Sharma, learned
Additional Advocate General for the respondent/State, has
defended the impugned judgment and order passed by the
learned Courts below. He submits that the Courts below have
concurrently and rightly passed the impugned judgment and
order, and there is no scope for interference in the same. He
further submits that this Court, while exercising its power under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, will not interfere in the
well-reasoned findings returned by the Courts below.
18.
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the record carefully.
19.
The plaintiff/petitioner has primarily approached the
learned trial Court for grant of permanent prohibitory injunction
restraining defendants No. 1 and 2, that is the State of H.P. and
the Block Development Officer, from sanctioning and releasing
the grant-in-aid for the proposed cremation ground in favour of
defendant No. 3, and restraining them personally or through its
agents and servants from constructing the proposed cremation
ground over the land of Khasra No. 6830, measuring 00-16
Marlas, comprised in Khewat No. 1074, Khatauni No. 1231, as
per Jamabandi for the year 2004-05, situated in Mohal Badhera,
Tehsil Haroli, District Una, H.P.
20.
As per the case of plaintiff, as an abadi is situated near
Khasra No. 6830, the defendants cannot be permitted to raise
construction of a 'Shamshan Ghat' and in case the same is
allowed and permitted to be constructed near the abadi, toxins
will be released into the air. The plaintiff has alleged that the
environmental effects include the emission of millions of tons of
carbon dioxide pollution into the air, and as such with the
proposed construction of the 'Shamshan Ghat' there would be
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
extreme pollution in the vicinity leading to bad health issues and
hazards, and children as well as ladies would get depressed
under fear of ghosts.
21.
As per the case of the defendant, the cremation ground
('Shamshan Ghat') is lying open and dead bodies are cremated
and funeral rites are performed in the open space, due to which
there remains an apprehension of fire spreading and causing
damage to the crops and to undertake the development of the
area, the Government has sanctioned an amount of Rs.
14,45,000/- for the improvement of 'Shamshan Ghat' by raising a
boundary wall, cremation sheds, providing water facility, sitting
benches etc., for the safety and facility of the general public.
22.
As per the defendant, no new cremation ground is
being built in Khasra No. 6830, but only improvements has to be
made to the old existing 'Shamshan Ghat' by constructing a
boundary wall, cremation sheds, sitting benches etc., and
providing water facilities to the general public.
23.
As far as the averments of the plaintiff are concerned,
it has been stated in the plaint that the abadi of Sada Ram is
about 30 metres, the abadi of Shadi Lal is about 50 metres, the
abadi of Jasvinder Singh is about 60 metres, and the abadi of
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
Balwinder and Ajay Kumar is 100 metres away from the
proposed 'Shamshan Ghat'. However, none of the aforesaid
persons has joined as party to the present proceedings, and
the petitioner cannot be permitted to raise grouse on behalf of
the said persons.
24.
In the present proceedings, as a matter of fact, with
respect to the same dispute one Sh. Amrit Lal had filed Civil Suit
No. 64 of 2003, titled Amrit Lal versus Gram Panchayat, decided
on 09.04.2007. The plaintiff in the said suit was one of the coowners along with the present plaintiff. Thereafter, the appeal
preferred came to be disposed of by learned District Judge on
31.01.2008. In the said civil suit, the dispute which was raised
was the same. The presumption raised by the present
defendants that the cremation ground has been in existence for
the last 20-25 years seems to be probable and correct. Though
as per the case of the plaintiff, in pursuance to the compromise
effected, a gift deed dated 25.11.2014 was executed with
respect to Khasra No. 7370 in favour of the Panchayati Raj
Department for the construction of a cremation ground. It has
been stated by the learned counsel for the respondents that
Khasra No. 7370 is at a distance of more than 3 km from Khasra
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
No. 6830 and is not convenient for the villagers of Mohal
Badhera, Tehsil Haroli, District Una, H.P. Village Badhera is a
big village and Khasra No. 7370 is jointly owned and possessed
by co-sharers along with the Gram Panchayat situated near the
boundary of the village. Therefore, it cannot be held that all the
inhabitants of Village Badhera can conveniently use the
cremation ground in Khasra No. 7370.
25.
In order to rebut the case of the plaintiff, respondents
have filed a copy of the Jamabandi for the year 2004-2005,
which reflects that Khasra No. 6830 is owned by the Panchayat.
The respondents have also placed on record a copy of the
Khasra Girdawari/Jamabandi for the year 2014-15, wherein the
nature of the suit land is recorded as "Gair Mumkin 'Shamshan
Ghat'".
26.
A presumption of truth is attached to the entries in the
revenue record unless the same are rebutted. From the perusal
thereof, it can safely be gathered and inferred that there is an
old existing cremation ground, and the said fact is corroborated
by the entry of "Gair Mumkin 'Shamshan Ghat'" in the revenue
record of 2014-15. Not only this, the Gram Panchayat has
already passed a resolution duly signed by its members and
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
residents, whereby it has been agreed upon that the Panchayat
shall construct a cremation shed and develop the 'Shamshan
Ghat'. Therefore, this Court is of the considered opinion that a
majority of the persons of the Gram Sabha are in favour of
carrying out developmental activities by raising construction over
the already existing cremation ground.
27.
It has also been contended by the learned
Additional Advocate General for the State that the resolution has
been signed by 170 persons in the Gram Sabha for the
construction of a cremation shed on the cremation ground, and
the State has sanctioned a sum of Rs. 14,45,000/- for the same.
The photographs placed on record demonstrate that 'Shamshan
Ghat' is already existing over the suit land and only
improvements are required to be made to the old existing
cremation ground by constructing a boundary wall, cremation
sheds, sitting benches etc., and providing water facilities to the
general public at large as well as for the safety and security of
the people and agricultural land of adjoining field owners out of
the funds sanctioned by the State. The plea raised by the
plaintiff that the defendants are trying to construct a new
'Shamshan Ghat' is incorrect, and in the considered opinion of
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
this Court, the plaintiff has not come to the Court with clean
hands and has suppressed material facts.
28.
In order to obtain an ad interim injunction, the plaintiff is
required to satisfy triplicate test of prima facie case, balance of
convenience, and irreparable loss and injury. In the present
case, on the strength of the Jamabandi for the year 2014-15
along with the Khasra Girdawari showing the nature of the land
as "Gair Mumkin 'Shamshan Ghat'", it is evident that there is
already existing a 'Shamshan Ghat' over the suit land and
developmental activities are intended to be undertaken by the
Gram Panchayat with the aid of Government funds approved by
the State of H.P.
29.
The plaintiff has failed to show a prima facie case in his
favour, rather, it is defendant No. 3, who has got strong prima
facie case. The balance of convenience also lies in favour of the
respondents, as the resolution passed by the Gram Panchayat
is signed by more than 170 persons and none of the other
villagers
has
joined
in
the
present
proceedings.
Most
importantly, the Government has already sanctioned a sum of
Rs. 14,45,000/- for developmental activities on the already
existing 'Shamshan Ghat'. Therefore, it is the defendants who
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
shall suffer irreparable loss in case defendants No. 1 and 2 are
restrained from releasing the said sanctioned fund for the
construction of a pucca 'Shamshan Ghat' on the suit land.
30.
The learned Courts below have concurrently come to
the conclusion that the plaintiff has failed to make out a prima
facie case in his favour. The respondents/defendants have
placed on record the photographs of the cremation ground,
whereby it can be presumed that during the corona period, dead
bodies have been cremated. The copy of jamabandi for the year
2014-15 pertaining to Khasra No. 6830 indicates that the
Panchayat is the owner of the suit land. The khasra girdawari,
which has been placed on record, reveals that the nature of the
land has been shown as 'Gair Mumkin 'Shamshan Ghat''.
31.
The Executive Engineer (R.D.D.), Zonal Office,
Dharamshala, District Kangra, vide its sanction letter dated
05.08.2021, had sanctioned a sum of ₹14,45,000/- for the
construction of Moksh Dham, Ward No. 2, Gram Panchayat
Lower Badehra, Development Block Haroli, District Una, H.P.
Noticeably, as per resolution dated 14.03.2021 as passed by the
Gram Panchayat, wherein Agenda No. 9 was fixed for the
construction of the cremation ground over Khasra No. 6830. The
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
said resolution has been signed by more than 170 persons and
it has been discussed by the Gram Panchayat, whereby it has
been stated that Khasra No. 6830 is being used for the last more
than 30 to 35 years in the form of cremation ground, and the
majority of the inhabitants are using the said 'Shamshan Ghat'.
In the said meeting, it was resolved that since the said land is
being used as a cremation ground, therefore, it is required to be
improved/developed, and it was resolved unanimously that the
said development/improvement is required in the interest of the
general public.
32.
The said facts clearly prove and establish that Khasra
No. 6830 has been used as 'Shamshan Ghat' for a long period,
and the plaintiff, in order to grind his own axe, has instituted the
present suit to deprive the general public from the use of the
cremation ground, for which administrative sanction has been
granted by the authorities by providing a sum of ₹14,45,000/-.
33.
The record reveals that the majority of the persons of
the Gram Panchayat are in favour of the construction of the
cremation ground. However, on account of personal interest, the
plaintiff is trying to stall the same on one pretext or the other.
34.
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
The conduct of the plaintiff/petitioner does not entitle
him to get the equitable and discretionary relief of injunction. The
Courts below have concurrently disbelieved the version of the
plaintiff, as he could not pass the triplicate test of prima facie
case, balance of convenience, and irreparable loss. This Court
has not been persuaded by the petitioner to interfere with the
legal orders passed by the Courts below. Therefore, no
interference is required with the same.
35.
Relying upon the Jamabandi for the year 2014-15, the
copy of Khasra Girdawari, the resolution of the Gram Panchayat
signed by 170 persons, and on the basis of funds sanctioned by
the State of H.P. to the tune of Rs. 14,45,000/-, the Courts below
have rightly adjudicated the point in controversy.
36.
This Court does not see any infirmity or illegality in the
impugned order passed by the learned Courts below. The two
Courts have passed a well-reasoned order, and while invoking
the provisions of Article 227 of the Constitution of India, this
Court will not act as an Appellate Court.
37.
The Hon’ble Apex Court has repeatedly held that the
scope of interference in a petition filed under Article 227 of the
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
Constitution of India is very limited. The Hon’ble Apex in Civil
Appeal No(s).13801 of 2025, titled as Shri Digant vs M/s
P.D.T. Trading Co. & others, has discussed the scope of
interference while exercising the power under Article 227 of
Constitution of India. The relevant paragraphs thereof read as
under:“22. The scope of High Court’s jurisdiction under Articles
226/227 fell for consideration before a threeJudge Bench of this
Court in Radhey Shyam & another v. Chhabi Nath & Ors. 1
This Court held that judicial orders of civil courts are not
amenable to a writ of certiorari under Article 226, though they
may be questioned in the supervisory jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 227 of the Constitution. The power under
Article 227 is intended to be used sparingly and only in
appropriate cases for the purpose of keeping the subordinate
courts and tribunals within the bounds of their authority and not
for correcting mere errors. The power may be exercised in
cases occasioning grave injustice or failure of justice such as
when (i) the court or tribunal has assumed a jurisdiction which it
does not have, (ii) has failed to exercise a jurisdiction which it
does have, such failure occasioning a failure of justice, and (iii)
the jurisdiction though available is being exercised in a manner
which tantamounts to overstepping the limits of jurisdiction.”
23. In the case on hand, the appellate court had considered
whether the proceeding in detail the issue as to court was
justified in trial with the case, without further notice to the
defendants, after submission of pursis (Exh.42) by defendants’
counsel, claiming no instructions. After a threadbare analysis
and taking into consideration surrounding circumstances, the
appellate court held that the trial court had committed no wrong
proceeding with the matter court representing with noticed the
the that defendants matter. The appellate Court noticed tht the
advocate representing the defndants had claimed no
instructions but not sought withdrawal of his Vakalatnama and
the matter thereafter remained pending for over three months
till it was decided in March 2015. In between no effort was
made by the defendants to engage another lawyer. Moreover,
the defendants did not come up with a case that their lawyer’s
notice was not served on them therefore, they could not
engage another counsel Besides that, the record also indicated
that the intention of the defendants was to delay the
proceedings because earlier also the suit had proceeded ex
parte against them though, later, those orders were recalled.
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
Therefore, in our view, once the appellate court took into
consideration all relevant aspects including the fact that pursis
(Exh.42) did not seek withdrawal of the Vakalatnama, and
withdrawal was not even permitted, there was no such
jurisdictional error which warranted exercise of powers under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The High Court without
any justification procedure went consider the procedure
prescribed for withdrawal Vakalatnama when neither
withdrawal of Vakalatnama was permitted by the Trial Court nor
the pursis prayed for its withdrawal. In such circumstances, the
entire exercise of the High Court was misconceived. More so,
when the view taken by the appellate Court that defendant
cannot take advantage of his own wrong was a plausible view
based on materials available on record. Hence, in our view,
appellate court’s order was not amenable to interference in
exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226/227 of the Constitution
of India. The High Court clearly exceeded its jurisdiction under
Article 227 of the Constitution in interfering with well reasoned
order of the appellate Court.”
38.
The Hon’ble Apex Court in M/S GARMENT CRAFT
Vs. PRAKASH CHAND GOEL, (2022) 4 SCC 181, has held that
High Court while exercising Supervisory Jurisdiction will not act
as a Court of First Appeal to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence
on facts upon which the determination under challenge is based.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as follows:15. Having heard the counsel for the parties, we are
clearly of the view that the impugned order is contrary to
law and cannot be sustained for several reasons, but
primarily for deviation from the limited jurisdiction
exercised by the High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. The High Court exercising
supervisory jurisdiction does not act as a court of first
appeal to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence or facts
upon which the determination under challenge is based.
Supervisory jurisdiction is not to correct every error of fact
or even a legal flaw when the final finding is justified or
can be supported. The High Court is not to substitute its
own decision on facts and conclusion, for that of the
inferior court or tribunal.1 The jurisdiction exercised is in
the nature of correctional jurisdiction to set right grave
dereliction of duty or flagrant abuse,1Celina Coelho
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
Pereira (Ms) and Others v. Ulhas Mahabaleshwar Kholkar
and Others, (2010) 1 SCC violation of fundamental
principles of law or justice. The power under Article 227 is
exercised sparingly in appropriate cases, like when there
is no evidence at all to justify, or the finding is so perverse
that no reasonable person can possibly come to such a
conclusion that the court or tribunal has come to. It is
axiomatic that such discretionary relief must be exercised
to ensure there is no miscarriage of justice.
16. Explaining the scope of jurisdiction under Article 227,
this Court in Estralla Rubber v. Dass Estate (P) Ltd.2 has
observed:“6. The scope and ambit of exercise of power and
jurisdiction by a High Court under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India is examined and explained in a
number of decisions of this Court. The exercise of power
under this article involves a duty on the High Court to
keep inferior courts and tribunals within the bounds of
their authority and to see that they do the duty expected
or required of them in a legal manner. The High Court is
not vested with any unlimited prerogative to correct all
kinds of hardship or wrong decisions made within the
limits of the jurisdiction of the subordinate courts or
tribunals. Exercise of this power and interfering with the
orders of the courts or tribunals is restricted to cases of
serious dereliction of duty and flagrant violation of
fundamental principles of law or justice, where if the High
Court does not interfere, a grave injustice remains
uncorrected. It is also well settled that the High Court
while acting under this article cannot exercise its power
as an appellate court or substitute its own judgment in
place of that of the subordinate court to correct an error,
which is not apparent on the face of the record. The High
Court can set aside or ignore the findings of facts of an
inferior court or tribunal, if there is no evidence at all to
justify or the finding is so perverse, that no reasonable
person can possibly come to such a conclusion, which
the court or tribunal has come to.”
19. The factum that the counsel for the appellant had
applied for the certified copy would show that the counsel
for the appellant was aware that the ex-parte decree had
been passed on the account of failure to lead defence
evidence. This would not, however, be a good ground
and reason to set aside and substitute the opinion formed
by the trial court that the appellant being incarcerated was
unable to lead evidence and another chance should be
given to the appellant to lead defence evidence. The
discretion exercised by the trial court in granting relief, did
not suffer from an error apparent on the face of the record
or was not a finding so perverse that it was unsupported
( 2026:HHC:41815 )
by evidence to justify it. There could be some justification
for the respondent to argue that the appellant was
possibly aware of the ex-parte decree and therefore the
submission that the appellant came to know of the exparte decree only on release from jail on 6th May 2017 is
incorrect, but this would not affect the factually correct
explanation of the appellant that he was incarcerated and
could not attend the civil suit proceedings from 6th
October 2015 to 6th May 2017. If it was felt 30 that the
application for setting aside the exparte decree was filed
belatedly, the court could have given an opportunity to the
appellant to file an application for condonation of delay
and costs could have been imposed. The facts as known,
equally apply as grounds for condonation of delay. It is
always important to take a holistic and overall view and
not get influenced by aspects which can be explained.
Thus, the reasoned decision of the trial court on elaborate
consideration of the relevant facts did not warrant
interference in exercise of the supervisory jurisdiction
under Article 227 of the Constitution.”
39.
In the considered opinion of this Court, the impugned
judgment/order does not call for any interference. Therefore, in
view of the observations made here-in-above, the present
petition, being devoid of any merit, deserves to be dismissed.
40.
Needless to say, the observations made here-in-above
are meant only for the adjudication of the present petition and
shall not be construed as a reflection on the merits of the main
case.
All the pending miscellaneous application(s) if any,
shall also stand disposed of.
(Romesh Verma)
Judge
September 28, 2026
(Nisha)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review