The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. For the foregoing reasons, the judgment and decree dated ated
11. 09.2025 passe assed by the learned First Appellate llate Court cannot be sustained and are hereby set et as aside. The judgment and decree ree dated 27.07.2023 passed byy the learned trial Court Cou dismissing the suit are rest restored. Both the Regular Second cond Appeals are accordingly acco allowed. Misc Applications, if any stand dispo Misc. disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RSA Nos. 4175 & 4231
423 of 2025
IN THE HIG
HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HAR
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
I.
RSA No. 4175 of 2025
25(O&M)
Anil Kumar
…Appellan
llant
Versus
Amrik Singh & Or
Ors.
…Respondent
ents
II.
RSA No. 4231 of 2025
25 ((O&M)
Parveen Rani
…Appellan
llant
Versus
Amrik Singh & Ors
Or
…Respondent
ents
Reserved on: 13.02.202
.2026
Pronounced on: 16.022.2026
Pronounced fully/ ope
operative part: Fully
CORAM: HON’BL
N’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK GUPTA
PTA
Argued by:- Mr. Piyush Setia, Advocate
For the
t appellant in RSA 4175 off 202
2025.
Mr. Rajesh Narang, Advocate and
Mr. Abhinav Narang, Advocate
For appellant
a
in RSA 4231 of 2025.
25.
Mr. Sandeep Jasuja, Advocate
For the
t respondents.
DEEPAK GUPTA,
TA, J.
This order shall dispose of two
o Re
Regular Second Appeals, as both
arise out of the same judgment & decreee da
dated 11.09.2025 passed by the
learned First App
Appellate Court, whereby the suit
uit ffiled by the plaintiffs for recover
very
of damages/com
compensation was decreed, after
ter rreversing the dismissal recorded
rded
by the learned
ed trial
t
Court on 27.07.2023. For the sake of clarity, partiess are
ar
referred to ass per
pe their status before the triall Co
Court.
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.02.16 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 1 of 5 Pages
ages
RSA Nos. 4175 & 4231
423 of 2025
2.
Trial court record called & perused.
sed. To avoid confusion, parties shall
sha
be referred ass per
pe their status before trial court.
urt.
3.
The admitted factual position is that the plaintiffs purchased
ased
agricultural land
and measuring 66 kanals 18 marlass vide sale deed dated 12.03.2012
and further land
and measuring 112 kanals vide sale deed No.303 dated 27.08.2012
from their respe
espective vendors. It is equally
lly u
undisputed that at the time
e of
o
purchase, thee de
defendants were in possession
n of the suit land. The grievance
ce of
o
the plaintiffss was
w that despite having purch
urchased the land for a valuabl
uable
consideration,
n, they
th were unable to enjoy posses
ssession thereof for several years
rs on
account of thee defendants’
d
continued occupatio
ation and the pendency of litigation
ation
initiated at their
heir instance. Possession was ultim
ultimately delivered on 22.01.2018
018.
Alleging that the
they had been wrongfully deprived
rived of cultivating their agricultura
ltural
land and had thu
thus suffered financial loss, the pla
plaintiffs instituted the presentt suit
sui
on 19.03.2019
9 seeking
se
compensation along with
ith interest.
4.
The defendants contested the suit
uit p
primarily on the ground thatt the
Civil Court lacke
acked jurisdiction in view of Sect
Sections 14 and 77 of the Punjab
njab
Tenancy Act,, 188
1887, the dispute being one relati
elating to occupation of agricultura
ltural
land and recove
covery of money for use and occ
occupation thereof. It was furthe
rther
pleaded that eve
ven otherwise the claim wass ba
barred by limitation as prescribed
ribed
under Section
n 77(5)
77 of the Act.
5.
Upo framing of issues and appreci
Upon
reciation of evidence led by parties
rties,
the learned trial
tria Court held that the claim
laim, in substance, was one for
fo
compensation
n fo
for use and occupation off ag
agricultural land by personss in
unauthorized pos
possession. Relying upon Section
ion 114 read with Section 77(3), Third
Group clause (n) of the Punjab Tenancy Act, it w
was concluded that such a claim
im is
i
exclusively triabl
riable by the Revenue Court and
nd tthat the jurisdiction of the Civil
Civ
Court is express
ressly barred. The trial Courtt al
also noticed that the limitation
ation
prescribed forr su
such a claim before the Revenue
nue Court is one year and observed
rved
that even on tha
that count the claim appeared
d to be time-barred. Consequently
ntly,
the suit was dismissed.
dism
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.02.16 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 2 of 5 Pages
ages
RSA Nos. 4175 & 4231
423 of 2025
6.
In appeal,
ap
the learned First Appella
pellate Court reversed the aforesaid
esaid
finding by observ
serving that the plaintiffs were not claiming batai or share in crop
but compensatio
sation for monetary loss and me
mental harassment. Holding that
tha
Section 77 had
ad been
b
wrongly interpreted byy th
the trial Court, it decreed the suit
sui
partly and award
arded compensation at the ratee of ₹20,000/- per killa with interes
erest
@ 6% per annum
num.
7.
Havi considered submissions of learned counsel for the partie
Having
rties
and perusing the record, this Court is of the con
considered view that the approach
oach
adopted by the trial Court was in consonance
nce with the statutory scheme and
binding preceden
edent, whereas the First Appellate
te C
Court misdirected itself in law.
8.
Sect
Section
14 of the Punjab Tenan
nancy Act makes any person
n in
possession off land
lan without the consent of the
he la
landlord liable to pay for the
e use
or occupation
n of
o that land at the rate of rrent payable in the precedin
ding
agricultural year,
year or at such rate as the Court
ourt may determine. Section 77(3)
77(3
categorically pro
provides that the suits mentioned
ed ttherein shall be instituted in and
heard by Revenu
venue Courts and that no otherr Co
Court shall take cognizance off any
an
dispute with resp
respect to which such suit might
ht b
be instituted. Third Group clause
lause
(n) specifically
ly inc
includes suits for sums recoverabl
rable under Section 14.
9.
The language employed in Section
ion 77(3) is peremptory and create
eates
an express bar
ar on
o the jurisdiction of the Civilil Co
Court in respect of matters fallin
alling
within its ambit.
bit. The determinative factor, ther
therefore, is the true nature off the
relief claimed.
10.
A reading
re
of the plaint makes it ev
evident that the plaintiffs sough
ught
compensation
n o
on account of their inabilityy to cultivate the agricultural land
during the period
eriod of the defendants’ occupation
on. The foundation of the claim
im is
i
deprivation of use and occupation of agr
agricultural land. Though durin
uring
arguments, itt was
wa suggested that damages wer
were also claimed for physicall and
mental loss, the relief clause does not disclose
se aany independent cause of action
ction
in tort divorced
ed from
f
the occupation of agricultu
ultural land. The claim is intrinsicall
ically
linked to wrongfu
ngful possession and loss of agricult
icultural use.
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.02.16 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 3 of 5 Pages
ages
RSA Nos. 4175 & 4231
423 of 2025
11.
The question whether a suit for m
mesne profits or compensation
ation
against a person
son in unauthorized possession of aagricultural land is triable byy the
Civil Court is no longer
l
res integra. A Division Ben
Bench of this Court in Pritam Singh
v. Mehal Singh
ngh, 1986 RRR 574 has authorita
ritatively held that the expression
ssion
“landlord” in Section
Sec
14 must be understood in tthe sense of landowner and that
tha
a suit by an owner
own for recovery of mesne prof
profits against a person in wrongfu
ngful
possession is covered
cov
by Section 14 and conseq
nsequently triable exclusively byy the
th
Revenue Court
rt under
u
Section 77(3)(n). The earl
earlier contrary view was expressl
essly
overruled. The
he ssame principle has been reitera
iterated in Mandir Maharaj Jagan
agan
Nath Puri, Ladw
adwa v. Man Singh;S. Palwinder
der Singh Vs. Guru Granth Sahib
ahib,
2010(11) RCR(Civ
R(Civil) 66; and Ram Karan Vs. The Financial Commissioner & Ors.
Ors
1980 PLJ 295.
12.
In view
v
of the above authoritati
itative pronouncements, the mere
mer
characterization
ion of the claim as “damages” can
cannot alter its essential character
cter.
What cannot be done directly cannot be permit
rmitted to be achieved indirectly
ly by
b
clever drafting.
ng. If
I the substance of the claim
m is recovery of money for use and
occupation of agricultural
a
land, the jurisdict
diction of the Civil Court stand
tands
excluded.
13.
The learned First Appellate Court,
urt, while reversing the trial Court
ourt,
did not advert
ert to the binding Division Bench
ench judgment nor examined the
statutory barr in its
i correct perspective. The reve
reversal thus rests on an erroneou
eous
understandingg of the scope of Sections 14 and 77 of the Act and amounts to a
substantial misap
isapplication of law.
14.
It may
m be observed that the questio
estion of jurisdiction under a specia
ecial
statute, once set
settled by binding precedent off a D
Division Bench, leaves little room
for interpretative
ative deviation. The Hon’ble Supre
upreme Court has repeatedly held
that interference
ence with concurrent or well-foun
founded findings is not warranted
nted
unless such findings
find
are shown to be perve
erverse or based on a substantia
ntial
misapplication
n of law.
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.02.16 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 4 of 5 Pages
ages
RSA Nos. 4175 & 4231
423 of 2025
15.
In the
t
present case, the triall Co
Court had correctly applied the
th
statutory barr as interpreted by binding author
thority. The First Appellate Court’
urt’s
departure theref
erefrom was legally unsustainable.
le. TThis Court, therefore, has merel
erely
restored the posi
position in accordance with settled
tled law, and no substantial question
stion
of law survives
es beyond
be
the jurisdictional issuee ad
addressed herein.
16.
For the foregoing reasons, the judgment and decree dated
ated
11.09.2025 passe
assed by the learned First Appellate
llate Court cannot be sustained and
are hereby set
et as
aside. The judgment and decree
ree dated 27.07.2023 passed byy the
learned trial Court
Cou dismissing the suit are rest
restored. Both the Regular Second
cond
Appeals are accordingly
acco
allowed.
Misc Applications, if any stand dispo
Misc.
disposed of.
(DEEPAK GUPTA)
JUDGE
16.02.2026
Jiten
Whe
hether speaking/reasoned
Whe
hether reportable
: Yes/No
: Yes/No
Uplo
Uploaded
on : February 16, 2026
YOGESH MEHTA
2026.02.16 14:36
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Page N: 5 of 5 Pages
ages
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review