Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010803812024
+
CS(COMM) 1018/2024, I.A. 45137/2024 and I.A. 8733/2026
Date of decision: 29.09.2026
IN THE MATTER OF:ANI MEDIA PVT LTD
THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE:
MR. RAJESH JAIN
REGISTERED OFFICE AT:
6G , VANDANA BUILDING,
TOLSTOY MARG ,
NEW DELHI- 110001
.....Plaintiff
Through:
Ms. Lahar Jain, Advocate.
versus
1. RSY NEWS
THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE/SOLE
PROPRIETOR:
MR. RAJ KUMAR
602, B BLOCK
RADHIKA APARTMENT , EXHIBITION ROAD
PATNA , BIHAR , INDIA -800001.
2. GOOGLE LLC
ATTENTION: COPYRIGHT AGENT AT YOUTUBE
THROUGH ITS RESIDENT GRIEVANCE OFFICER:
MR. SURAJ RAO
REGISTERED OFFICE AT:
GOOGLE LLC - INDIA LIAISON OFFICE
UNIT NO . 26
THE EXECUTIVE CENTER ,
LEVEL 8, DLF CENTRE,
SANSAD MARG,
CONNAUGHT PLACE ,
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
NEW DELHI - 110001
.....Defendants
Through:
D-1 ex parte.
Ms. Mamta Rani Jha, Mr. Rohan
Ahuja, Ms.Shruttima, Ms.Aishwarya
and Ms. Jahanvi, Advocates for D-2.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV
JUDGEMENT
PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV, J. (ORAL)
CS(COMM) 1018/2024 and I.A. 8733/2026 (for summary judgment)
1.
The plaintiff, ANI Media Pvt. Ltd., has instituted the present suit
seeking permanent and mandatory injunction, damages and other
consequential reliefs against defendant no. 1, RSY News, in respect of the
unauthorised reproduction and publication, on four YouTube channels
operated by it, of video works in which the plaintiff claims copyright.
Defendant no. 2, Google LLC, which owns and operates the platform
YouTube, has been impleaded as the intermediary hosting the impugned
content.
2.
By way of I.A. 8733/2026, preferred under Order XIII-A of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 (“CPC”), as applicable to commercial disputes,
read with Rule 27 of the Delhi High Court Intellectual Property Rights
Division Rules, 2022 (“IPD Rules”), the plaintiff seeks a summary
judgment and a decree in the suit. Since the adjudication of the application
would dispose of the suit itself, the application and the suit are being taken
up together.
3.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Defendant No. 2 is represented through its counsel. Defendant No. 1,
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
who is the contesting defendant, has already been proceeded ex parte. On
20.08.2026, learned counsel for the plaintiff gave up prayer (e) made in the
suit, which sought a direction to defendant no. 2 to take down or delete all
the YouTube channels owned and managed by defendant no. 1. The
application bearing I.A. 8733/2026, therefore, deals with the remaining
prayers for summary judgment.
4.
The prayers made in paragraph 62 of the plaint, to the extent they
survive for consideration, read as under:
―(a) Pass a decree of permanent and mandatory injunction against the
Defendant No. 1, restraining it from posting, publishing, uploading,
distributing, republishing on any platform, or using in any manner,
Plaintiff's Original Videos, or any other copyrighted work or content of
the Plaintiff, including on the platform YouTube maintained by Defendant
No. 2;
(b) Pass a decree of permanent and mandatory injunction against the
Defendant No. 1, directing it to take down the Infringing Videos to the
extent that it uses, in any manner, the Plaintiff's Original Videos, or any
other copyrighted work or content of the Plaintiff, including on the
platform YouTube maintained by Defendant No. 2;
or alternatively
Pass a decree of permanent and mandatory injunction against the
Defendant No. 1 or its agents or any person acting on its behalf of or
under its authority, directing it to remove and take down the Infringing
Videos, or any other content infringing the copyrighted work of the
Plaintiff, including its Original Videos;
(c) Pass a decree of permanent and mandatory injunction against
Defendant No. 2 to de-index, take-down, block and disable access to the
infringing content published by Defendant No. 1 on their platform,
particularly the Infringing Videos, available at the link(s) below:
(d) Pass a decree directing Defendant No. 1 to publish prominently a
statement on YouTube and other social media platforms, acknowledging,
and accepting that the Original Videos are produced by the Plaintiff and
that Defendant No. 1 has illegally reproduced them in the Infringing
Videos;
(f) Pass a decree for damages against the Defendant No. 1, directing them
to pay an amount of INR 2,00,00,500/- (Rupees Two Crore Five Hundred
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Only) to the Plaintiff;
(g) Cost of this suit and consequent litigation be awarded to the Plaintiff;
and
(h) Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court deems fit and proper, against
the Defendants and in favour of the Plaintiff.‖
5.
The plaintiff describes itself as a multimedia news agency providing a
syndicated news feed under the brand names “Asian News International”
and “ANI”. It is stated that, since its inception in 1971, the plaintiff has
engaged journalists and camerapersons across more than one hundred
bureaus in India, South Asia and elsewhere for reporting and creating video
content in relation to news events. The plaintiff claims over seven million
subscribers on YouTube and over eight million followers on the platform X,
and asserts that news channels, newspapers and other news agencies
subscribe to its syndicated feed for valuable consideration.
6.
Defendant No. 1, RSY News, is stated to be a purported news agency
having its place of business at 602, B Block, Radhika Apartment, Exhibition
Road, Patna, Bihar. It operates four YouTube channels, namely, “RSY
News”, “RSY News UP”, “RSY News Delhi” and “RSY News Bihar”,
which, at the time of institution of the suit, had more than four million
subscribers combined. Defendant No. 2, Google LLC, owns and controls the
platform YouTube, on which defendant no. 1 runs these channels.
7.
The record discloses that between 17.08.2024 to 27.10.2024,
defendant no. 1 uploaded twelve videos (“Infringing Videos”) on its
aforesaid channels, reproducing, in whole or in substantial part, ten videos
of the plaintiff (“Original Videos”), without any licence, permission or
consent of the plaintiff. The particulars pleaded in paragraphs 11 to 41 of the
plaint, including the respective dates, durations and timestamps, are
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
tabulated hereunder:
S.
No.
Plaintiff's Original Video
(subject | date | duration)
Infringing Video
(channel | date | duration)
Extent of reproduction
as pleaded
1.
First Original Video
Exclusive interview of Ms. Saayoni
Ghosh, Member of Parliament
01.07.2024 | 00:43
First Infringing Video
RSY News UP | 17.08.2024
| 00:43
Second Infringing Video
RSY News Delhi |
17.08.2024
Entire work reproduced
in both videos.
2.
Second Original Video
Live recording of Mr. Arvind
Kejriwal's roadshow from
Chandgiram Akhara to the residence
of the Chief Minister of Delhi
13.09.2024 (subscriber-only
syndicated feed; on YouTube from
02.11.2024) | 05:27
Third Infringing Video
RSY News | 13.09.2024 |
01:04:06
3:24 to 4:00 of the
original reproduced as-is
at 45:40 to 46:16 (36
seconds).
3.
Third Original Video
Interview of Mr. Ravneet Singh Bittu,
Member of Rajya Sabha
15.09.2024 | 04:23
Fourth Infringing Video
RSY News Bihar |
16.09.2024 | 04:15
0:01 to 4:12 reproduced
at 0:04 to 4:15.
4.
Fourth Original Video
Exclusive interview of Mr. Prashant
Kishor ahead of the launch of the Jan
Suraaj Party
30.09.2024 | 19:31
Fifth Infringing Video
RSY News UP | 01.10.2024
| 20:23
Sixth Infringing Video
RSY News UP | 01.10.2024
| 05:25
Fifth: 0:01 to 19:22
reproduced at 1:03 to
20:23.
Sixth: 12:42 to 18:05
reproduced at 0:03 to
5:25.
5.
Fifth Original Video
Interview of Mr. Nayab Singh Saini,
Chief Minister of Haryana
09.10.2024 | 12:09
Seventh Infringing Video
RSY News Bihar |
09.10.2024 | 10:50
0:49 to 11:56 reproduced
at 0:03 to 10:49.
6.
Sixth Original Video
Recording of Dr. S. Jaishankar,
Minister of External Affairs, boarding
the aircraft after the SCO Summit
16.10.2024 | 02:15
Eighth Infringing Video
RSY News | 16.10.2024 |
02:07
0:00 to 2:04 reproduced
at 0:03 to 2:07.
7.
Seventh Original Video
Exclusive interview of Mr. Prashant
Kishor on the liquor issue in Bihar in
the wake of the hooch tragedy
17.10.2024 | 09:26
Ninth Infringing Video
RSY News UP | 17.10.2024
| 09:58
0:00 to 9:17 reproduced
at 0:42 to 9:58.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
S.
No.
Plaintiff's Original Video
(subject | date | duration)
Infringing Video
(channel | date | duration)
Extent of reproduction
as pleaded
8.
Eighth Original Video
News report on the blast near CRPF
Public School, Rohini, with reactions
of parents
22.10.2024 | 03:19
Tenth Infringing Video
RSY News UP | 23.10.2024
| 03:11
0:00 to 3:09 reproduced
at 0:02 to 3:12.
9.
Ninth Original Video
News report on Mr. Akhilesh Yadav's
birthday posters, including an
exclusive interview of Mr. Fakhrul
Hassan Chand
23.10.2024 | 02:37
Eleventh Infringing Video
RSY News Delhi |
23.10.2024 | 02:29
1:34 to 2:10 reproduced
at 1:36 to 2:12 (36
seconds).
10.
Tenth Original Video
Exclusive interview of Swami
Jagadguru Rambhadracharya
27.10.2024 | 03:45
Twelfth Infringing Video
RSY News Delhi |
27.10.2024 | 03:36
0:00 to 3:35 reproduced
at 0:01 to 3:36.
8.
The plaintiff has also placed on record screenshots comparing the
frames of the original videos with those of the infringing videos. A perusal
thereof, including Annexure A to the written note filed on behalf of the
plaintiff, shows that the frames of the infringing videos retain the plaintiff’s
“ANI” logo on the microphones and on-screen graphics, with defendant no.
1’s mark superimposed at the top of the frame; certain frames even carry the
legend “Source: ANI”.
9.
It is the plaintiff’s case that, owing to the routine reproduction of its
works, it invoked the copyright protection mechanism of defendant no. 2
and issued copyright strikes against the infringing videos, whereupon
defendant no. 2 removed them from defendant no. 1’s channels. The
plaintiff categorically avers that it has never granted any licence or
authorisation to Swami Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. to use or sub-license any of
its works. The plaintiff further avers that defendant no. 1 itself deleted the
tenth infringing video on 28.10.2024 after issuing a counter-notification
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
claiming to hold the requisite licence.
10.
The suit was first listed on 18.11.2024, when this Court issued
summons and, having found a prima facie case in favour of the plaintiff,
granted an ex parte ad interim injunction. Defendant No. 1 was restrained
from posting, publishing, uploading, distributing, republishing on any
platform, or using in any manner, the plaintiff’s original videos or any
copyrighted work or content of the plaintiff. Defendant No. 1 was directed
to remove and take down the infringing videos or any other content
infringing the copyrighted work of the plaintiff and defendant no. 2 was
directed to take down, block and disable access to the infringing videos on
the YouTube platform.
11.
As recorded in the order dated 19.02.2025, defendant no. 1 was
served on 02.12.2024. Despite service, defendant no. 1 neither entered
appearance nor filed its written statement. Consequently, vide order dated
04.03.2025, the interim injunction was made absolute and defendant no. 1
was proceeded against ex parte.
12.
Defendant No. 2 has filed its written statement. As noticed above, on
20.08.2026, the plaintiff gave up prayer (e) of the plaint. The plaintiff has
thereafter pressed the present application for summary judgment.
13.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the plaintiff, submits that the
plaintiff is the first owner of copyright in the original videos under Section
17 of the Copyright Act, 1957 (“Copyright Act”), and holds the exclusive
right to reproduce them and communicate them to the public under Section
14(d) thereof. It is contended that the infringing videos are verbatim
reproductions of the original videos, in most instances of their entirety,
published without licence, and that the use is not fair dealing since defendant
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
no. 1 neither reviews nor criticises the plaintiff’s content. It is urged that the
plea of a licence from Swami Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. is false, that defendant
no. 1 has chosen not to defend the suit, and that the averments in the plaint
thus stand unrebutted. It is, therefore, prayed that the suit be decreed.
14.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of defendant no. 2, submits that
defendant no. 2 is an intermediary under Section 2(1)(w) of the Information
Technology Act, 2000 and has no role in the creation of the impugned
content. It is stated that the twelve URLs have already been removed by the
uploader. Learned counsel states that in terms of paragraph 6 of its written
statement, defendant no. 2 would act upon an appropriate direction of this
Court for removal of content at specified URLs, once the plaintiff’s rights
are adjudicated.
15.
Order XIII-A of the CPC was introduced by the Commercial Courts
Act, 2015, with the object of enabling the disposal of commercial disputes in
a time-bound manner, without the necessity of recording oral evidence in
every case. Rule 3 thereof, which sets out the grounds for summary
judgment, reads as under:
―3. Grounds for summary judgment.—The Court may give a summary
judgment against a plaintiff or defendant on a claim if it considers that—
(a) the plaintiff has no real prospect of succeeding on the claim or the
defendant has no real prospect of successfully defending the claim, as the
case may be; and
(b) there is no other compelling reason why the claim should not be
disposed of before recording of oral evidence.‖
16.
In so far as suits before the Intellectual Property Division of this Court
are concerned, Rule 27 of the IPD Rules further provides as under:
―27. Summary Adjudication
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
In cases before the IPD, the Court may pass summary judgment, without
the requirement of filing a specific application seeking summary judgment
on principles akin to those contained in Order XIIIA, Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 as applicable to commercial suits under the Commercial
Courts Act, 2015.‖
17.
The contours of the expression “no real prospect” were examined by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court in Su-Kam Power Systems Ltd. v. Kunwer
Sachdev,1 wherein, drawing upon the jurisprudence under Part 24 of the
Civil Procedure Rules of England and Wales and the decision of the
Supreme Court of Canada in Hryniak v. Mauldin, it was held as under:
―42. Consequently, the new Rule, applicable to commercial disputes,
demonstrates that trial is no longer the default procedure/norm.
xxx
xxx
xxx
49. Consequently, this Court is of the view that when a summary judgment
application allows the Court to find the necessary facts and resolve the
dispute, proceeding to trial would generally not be proportionate, timely
or cost effective. It bears reiteration that the standard for fairness is not
whether the procedure is as exhaustive as a trial, but whether it gives the
Court the confidence that it can find the necessary facts and apply the
relevant legal principles so as to resolve the dispute as held in Robert
Hryniak (supra).
xxx
xxx
xxx
52. Consequently, this Court is of the opinion that there will be ‗no real
prospect of successfully defending the claim‘ when the Court is able to
reach a fair and just determination on the merits of the application for
summary judgment. This will be the case when the process allows the
court to make the necessary finding of fact, apply the law to the facts, and
the same is a proportionate, more expeditious and less expensive means to
achieve a fair and just result.‖
18.
The Supreme Court has recently had occasion to consider the scheme
of Order XIII-A of the CPC in Reliance Eminent Trading and Commercial
Private Limited v. Delhi Development Authority,2 while setting aside an
2019 SCC OnLine Del 10764.
2026 INSC 436.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
order of this Court declining summary judgment. Referring, inter alia, to
Bright Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. v. MJ Bizcraft LLP3 and Su-Kam (supra), the
Supreme Court explained the standard of “real prospect” and laid down the
following non-exhaustive guidelines:
―51. …It postulates that the likelihood of success must be real and
substantial, as opposed to being merely fanciful or speculative. In other
words, the standard envisages a degree of certainty higher than that of a
claim which is merely arguable. Accordingly, where the Court finds that a
claim or defence is so weak that it prima-facie discloses no reasonable
prospect of success, it is neither necessary nor desirable to subject the
parties to the rigours of a full-fledged trial…
xxx
xxx
xxx
57. There is no gainsaying that the Court ought not to conduct a mini-trial
in this regard, rather take the statements and facts on the face, until any
contemporaneous document indicates otherwise. In doing so, the Court
ought to not only take into account the evidence actually available on the
record, but also the evidence that can be reasonably be expected to be
available in the process of trial.
xxx
xxx
xxx
59. Therefore, while considering an application for summary judgment
under Order XIII-A of the CPC, the following non-exhaustive guidelines
have to be complied –
(i) That the procedural mandate under Order XIII-A, CPC be strictly
complied.
(ii) The Court should consider, (a) Whether Plaintiff has no real prospect
of succeeding on the claim or issue; or (b) Whether the defendant has no
real prospect of successfully defending the claim or issue; and
(iii) The Court should also consider whether there is no other reason why
the case or issue(s) should be allowed to go to trial.
(iv) While ascertaining above, the Court does not have to take everything
on the face value, but it must also not conduct a mini trial at the same
time.
(v) That the Court has to differentiate between a cause of action/defence
respectively, which is real as opposed to fanciful prospect.
(vi) That the Court ought to grasp the nettle, when dealing with the
2017 SCC OnLine Del 6394.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
summary judgment applications to decide short points of law and
interpretations.
(vii) The Court must take into account not only the evidence before it but
also the evidence that can reasonably be expected to be led/available at
the trial.
(viii) That the Court's usage of power under Order XIII-A, CPC is
exceptional as it cuts short the process of trial and ought to be exercised
where oral evidence and full trial is not required.
(ix) In order to ascertain the need for full trial over summary judgment,
the Court has to see whether, in the interest of justice, it is more suited to
conduct trial to – (a) Weigh the evidence, (b) Evaluate the credibility of a
deponents, (c) Draw reasonable inferences from the evidence.‖
19.
The Supreme Court in Reliance Eminent (supra) has also
underscored that the scheme of Order XIII-A of the CPC is adversarial and
not inquisitorial, and that service upon the defendant is mandatory. In the
present case, defendant no. 1 was duly served on 02.12.2024, as recorded in
the order dated 19.02.2025, and has consciously chosen to stay away. In
Applause Entertainment Private Limited v. www.9xmovies.com.tw,4 a
coordinate Bench of this Court, while decreeing a copyright suit concerning
the unauthorised online communication of a web series, held that where the
defendants have been proceeded against ex parte, it is not necessary to issue
fresh notice before deciding an application under Order XIII-A of the CPC:
―21. Since defendants no.3, 4, 5, 7, 9, 12 and 13 have already been
proceeded against ex parte and the contesting defendants no. 1, 2, and 14
to 19 are infringing websites/URLs that did not enter an appearance, I do
not find it necessary to issue fresh notices before deciding the present
application under Order XIII-A, CPC seeking summary judgment.‖
20.
Defendant No. 1 was served on 02.12.2024, and the outer limit of one
hundred twenty days for filing its written statement under the proviso to
2025:DHC:1994.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC, as applicable to commercial suits, expired on
01.04.2025. No written statement has been filed. Order VIII Rule 10 of the
CPC, as applicable to commercial disputes, provides as under:
―10. Procedure when party fails to present written statement called for by
Court.—Where any party from whom a written statement is required under
rule 1 or rule 9 fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed
by the Court, as the case may be, the Court shall pronounce judgment
against him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit and
on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall be drawn up.
Provided further that no Court shall make an order to extend the time
provided under Rule 1 of this Order for filing of the written statement.‖
21.
Consequently, the averments in the duly verified plaint stand
unrebutted, and since no affidavit of admission or denial has been filed, the
documents on record are deemed to be admitted. In Associated
Broadcasting Company Limited v. Google LLC,5 a case which, too, arose
out of copyright strikes on YouTube, this Court held as under:
―7. …Accordingly, all the averments made in the Plaint have to be taken
to be admitted. Further, since no affidavit of Admission / Denial has been
filed on behalf of the Defendant Nos. 2 to 5 in respect of the documents
filed with the Plaint, in terms of Rule 3 of the Delhi High Court (Original
Side) Rules, 2018, the same are deemed to have been admitted.‖
22.
The absence of a defence, however, does not relieve this Court of the
obligation to satisfy itself that the plaint, read with the documents on record,
establishes the plaintiff's entitlement to the reliefs claimed. The claim is,
therefore, examined on its merits.
23.
Equally, the power under Rule 27 of the IPD Rules enables this Court
to pass a summary judgment in a suit before the Intellectual Property
Division even without a specific application. Here, a specific application has
2026:DHC:1833.
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
in fact been filed and has been pressed. The procedural requirements are,
therefore, satisfied.
24.
Examination on merits indicates that each of the original videos is a
work of visual recording accompanied by sound and is, therefore, a
“cinematograph film” within the meaning of Section 2(f) of the Copyright
Act. Proviso (b) to Section 17 of the Copyright Act provides as under:
―(b) subject to the provisions of clause (a), in the case of a photograph
taken, or a painting or portrait drawn, or an engraving or a
cinematograph film made, for valuable consideration at the instance of
any person, such person shall, in the absence of any agreement to the
contrary, be the first owner of the copyright therein;‖
25.
The plaint specifically avers, in respect of each original video, the
name of the journalist or cameraperson who recorded it, and that it was
recorded for valuable consideration, at the instance of the plaintiff and with
the plaintiff’s equipment. The plaintiff has also placed on record the
Professional Services Agreement, Clause 11 whereof assigns the intellectual
property in such works to the plaintiff. These averments stand unrebutted.
The plaintiff is, therefore, the owner of copyright in the original videos, as
recordings.
26.
Section 14(d) of the Copyright Act confers upon the owner of
copyright in a cinematograph film the exclusive right, inter alia, to make a
copy of the film, including by storing it in any medium by electronic means,
and to communicate the film to the public. Under Section 51(a)(i), copyright
is infringed when any person, without a licence from the owner, does
anything, the exclusive right to do which is conferred upon the owner.
27.
The tabulation in paragraph 7 above shows that ten of the twelve
infringing videos reproduce the corresponding original videos either in their
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
entirety or virtually so, and that the sixth infringing video reproduces a
continuous block of more than five minutes of the fourth original video. By
uploading these videos on its YouTube channels, defendant No. 1 has copied
the plaintiff’s cinematograph films and communicated them to the public,
both being acts within the exclusive domain of the plaintiff.
28.
The only justification ever put forward by defendant no. 1 is the
purported licence from Swami Entertainment Pvt. Ltd., asserted in its
counter-notifications on the YouTube platform. The existence of such a
licence lay within the knowledge of defendant no. 1, which, despite service,
has neither appeared before this Court nor produced the same, in the face of
a specific denial by the plaintiff. Such a defence is fanciful and not real,
within the meaning of paragraph 59(v) of Reliance Eminent (supra).
29.
Nor can the use be regarded as fair dealing for the reporting of current
events under Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act. The wholesale
reproduction of ten videos operates as a substitute for the plaintiff’s works.
30.
The third infringing video was published on 13.09.2024, the very day
the second original video was made available only to the plaintiff’s
subscribers on its secure syndicated feed, and nearly two months before it
was published on YouTube. Defendant No. 1 is admittedly not a subscriber.
The segment used in the eleventh infringing video constitutes nearly a
quarter of that video and, as specifically pleaded and now admitted, includes
an exclusive interview and is qualitatively substantial. The use in neither
case is trivial or incidental to any independent reporting.
31.
The relevant facts, namely the dates, channels, durations and
timestamps of the videos, the frame-wise comparison, and the strikes and
counter-notifications, are all documentary and stand admitted. No question
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
arises which requires the weighing of evidence or the evaluation of the
credibility of any witness. This Court is, therefore, of the view that
defendant no. 1 has no real prospect of successfully defending the claim, and
there is no compelling reason why the claim should not be disposed of
before recording of oral evidence.
32.
The plaintiff is, therefore, entitled to a decree of permanent and
mandatory injunction against defendant no. 1 in terms of prayers (A) and
(B). As regards prayer (C), the direction against defendant no. 2 is confined
to the twelve specifically identified URLs, now adjudicated to be infringing,
which is in consonance with the stand taken by defendant no. 2 itself. Prayer
(D), seeking a direction to defendant no. 1 to publish a public
acknowledgment, is not warranted, since the injunction and the directions
for removal adequately protect the plaintiff’s rights.
33.
Accordingly, I.A. 8733/2026 is allowed, and the suit is decreed ex
parte against defendant no. 1, and against defendant no. 2 to the extent
indicated hereinbelow:(i)
Defendant No. 1, its proprietors, partners, directors, officers,
servants, agents and all persons acting for or on its behalf, are
permanently
restrained
from
publishing,
communicating
to
reproducing,
uploading,
the
distributing,
public,
republishing or otherwise exploiting, on YouTube or any other
platform, the plaintiff’s original videos or any other
copyrighted work of the plaintiff, without the plaintiff’s
authorisation.
(ii)
Defendant No. 1 is directed to remove and take down, from all
platforms including its YouTube channels “RSY News”, “RSY
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
News UP”, “RSY News Delhi” and “RSY News Bihar”, the
twelve infringing videos identified in the plaint, and any other
content reproducing the plaintiff's copyrighted works, to the
extent not already removed.
(iii)
The directions issued against defendant no. 2 vide order dated
18.11.2024, for taking down, blocking and disabling access to
the infringing videos, shall stand confirmed and made absolute.
Defendant No. 2 shall ensure that the infringing videos
available at the following URLs are, and remain, taken down,
blocked and disabled.
(iv)
Prayer (D), seeking a direction to defendant no. 1 to publicly
acknowledge on YouTube and other social media platforms that
it had illegally reproduced the plaintiff’s original videos, and
prayer (F) are declined. Prayer (E), seeking deletion of all
YouTube channels of defendant no. 1 by defendant no. 2,
stands given up by the plaintiff on 20.08.2026.
34.
I.A. 45137/2024, in which the interim injunction was made absolute
on 04.03.2025, stands merged with the present decree and is disposed of
accordingly.
35.
The suit, along with pending applications, if any, stands disposed of in
the above terms.
(PURUSHAINDRA KUMAR KAURAV)
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 29, 2026
Nc/ NK
Signed By:NEHA CHOPRA
16:27:49
Signed
By:PURUSHAINDRA
KUMAR KAURAV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review