Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA. No. 11 of 2023
Date of Decision: 26.04.2023
Shri. Angushuman Deb & 4 Ors.
Vs.
State of Meghalaya
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. A. Bhattacharya, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. N.G. Shylla, Sr. GA with
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. A. Bhattacharya, learned counsel, who has submitted
that this is an application under Section 439 Cr.P.C with a prayer for grant of
bail on behalf of the accused persons, Angushuman Deb, Robin Singha, Raja
Singh @ Rajbir Singh, Sudip Singh and Shubra Bhowmick @ Ratul, all
represented by Mr. Pradip Singh, were arrested by the police in connection
with Umiam P.S. Case No. 04 (01) of 2023 under Section 307/326/34 IPC.
2.
The learned counsel has submitted that the accused persons
abovenamed were arrested on different dates, that is, petitioners No. 4 and 5
were arrested on 24.03.2023 while the petitioners No. 1, 2 and 3 respectively
were arrested on 30.03.2023 pursuant to action taken on the basis of the FIR
lodged before the Officer-in-Charge, Umiam Police Station, Ri-Bhoi District
by
Mr.
Abhineet
Srivastava
on
26.01.2023,
wherein
the
complainant/informant has stated that on 21.01.2023 at about 7:30 pm, he
along with three friends had come to Orchid Umiam Lake to attend an event
called “Riders Mania 23” organized by the Royal Enfield Riders Association
of Meghalaya (RERAM). After the registration process was over, the said
informant went inside the camp and on reaching near the stage area they saw
Mr. Jumma Khan and three other persons drinking alcohol. Suddenly, upon
seeing them, Jumma Khan and the others attacked him with a big size
wooden log on his head, but he defended himself by raising his right hand as
a result of which the blow hit his forearm. After the incident, the informant
and his friends met the organizers of the event on 22.01.2023 and they were
requested to leave the camp. Thereafter, the informant went back to his home
town to Silchar for medical treatment where it was revealed that his forearm
has been broken.
3.
The learned counsel has also submitted that an application for
grant of bail on behalf of one of the accused, Jumma Khan, has also been
preferred before this Court in connection with the same case and that this
Court vide order dated 20.04.2023 has enlarged the said accused on bail, the
facts and circumstances being the same.
4.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the Investigating
Officer (I/O) while forwarding the accused persons to the court of the
learned Chief Judicial Magistrate on 31.03.2023 has remarked that from the
statements of the accused duly recorded, what transpired was that there was
an argument between the complainant and the accused persons on
21.01.2023 at the place of occurrence, but according to the version of the
accused persons they did not beat or assault the alleged victim and therefore
Section 307 IPC could not have been included in the case along with Section
325 IPC since the complainant has stated that he was seriously injured, but
had attended a meeting called by the organizers on the next day of the
alleged incident, that is, on 22.01.2023 and thereafter he had returned to
Silchar. It could not be imagined as to how he managed to ride back to
Silchar which is about 299 Kms from Shillong on his bike, if his forearm
was fractured.
5.
Again, the learned counsel has submitted that the accused
persons having been detained in custody for almost three months, their
statements having been recorded, therefore there is no requirement for their
continued detention and they may be enlarged on bail on any conditions to
be imposed by this Court. In this regard, the case of Sanjay Chandra v.
Central Bureau of Investigation: (2012) 1 SCC 40 para 21 was referred to by
the learned counsel to support his submission.
6.
Ms. N.G. Shylla, learned Sr. GA appearing for the State
respondent has strongly opposed the prayer of the petitioner and has
countered the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner by
submitting that the fact that of the five accused persons herein, two of them
were arrested on one date while three of them were arrested on a different
date is only because of the fact that when the police were looking for them,
they were not to be found.
7.
As to the contention that Section 307 IPC may not be the
appropriate section of law on the ground that the complainant has not been
able to prove that he was seriously injured, given the fact that after the date
of the incident, he had attended the meeting on the next date and thereafter
has decided to return to Silchar, presumably by riding the same bike he came
with, the learned Sr. GA has submitted that records would show that the
complainant on being grievously injured had gone back to Silchar by a taxi.
That, the statements given by the accused persons separately also shows that
they corroborated each other which only goes to prove that the incident had
actually taken place, submits that learned Sr. GA.
8.
The learned Sr. GA has also submitted that the fact that one of
the accused persons was already enlarged on bail by this Court vide order
dated 20.04.2023, the accused persons herein cannot claim parity as the
ground on which the said accused person was released was on medical
ground which is not the case of any of the accused persons herein.
9.
This Court after considering the submission made by the parties,
has perused the petition in hand as well as the case diary which was
produced by the prosecution.
10.
What is noticed is that on the basis of the FIR filed by the
complainant Mr. Abhineet Srivastava, the police on investigation being
launched had caused arrest of the accused persons, most of whom are still in
custody. It is also noted from the case diary that most of those involved in
the said incident have had their statements taken down, including the
complainant and the accused persons herein. From the statements of the
accused persons herein, it is seen that they have denied having assaulted the
complainant but has however, admitted that there was an argument among
them at the venue of the event at Orchid Lake, Umiam, mostly connected
with the fact that the goody bag, meant for the accused persons herein, given
out by the organizers to all the participants was allegedly taken by the
complainant. Hence the argument.
11.
In view of the fact that the investigation has proceeded
considerably and that the main object of bail jurisprudence is not to
unnecessarily detained an accused for the sake of detention, keeping in mind
the cardinal principle of right to life, upon which the concept of an accused
person being held innocent until proven guilty is based, the court of law has
been guided by general principles of bail while considering an application
for grant of bail, the common factor to be looked into being the nature and
gravity of the offence alleged, the antecedent of the accused person as to
whether there is any possibility that he or she may abscond, if enlarged on
bail and also the apprehension that the witnesses and evidence may be
tampered if the person is granted bail.
12.
However, as has been held in a number of decisions rendered by
the Apex Court of our Country, the principle of bail and not jail has more
often than not been employed to allow a detenue to be able to defend his case
effectively.
13.
The case of Sanjay Chandra (supra) cited by the learned counsel
for the petitioner would also be relevant inasmuch as para 21 of the same,
reproduced herein can be relied upon by this Court to favourably consider
the prayer of the petitioner.
“21. In bail applications, generally, it has been laid down from
the earliest times that the object of bail is to secure the
appearance of the accused person at his trial by reasonable
amount of bail. The object of bail is neither punitive nor
preventative. Deprivation of liberty must be considered a
punishment, unless it is required to ensure that an accused
person will stand his trial when called upon. The courts owe
more than verbal respect to the principle that punishment begins
after conviction, and that every man is deemed to be innocent
until duly tried and duly found guilty.”
14.
In the light of the above observations, the prayer of the petitioner
is hereby allowed. The accused persons named herein are accordingly
directed to be enlarged on bail on the following conditions, failure to adhere
to the said conditions would allow the I/O to move the competent court for
cancellation of the bail granted, the conditions being that they collectively or
individually:
i.
shall not abscond or tamper with the evidence and
witnesses
and
particularly
shall
not
threaten
the
complainant;
ii.
shall appear before the Investigating Officer as and when
required;
iii.
shall not leave the jurisdiction of India without prior
permission of the I/O or the Court concerned; and
iv.
shall furnish a personal bond of ₹ 30,000/- (Rupees thirty
thousand) only each with two solvent sureties of like
amount to the satisfaction of the concerned court.
15.
Registry is directed to return the case diary immediately.
16.
Bail application disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
26.04.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review