Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 05.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 13.02.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 13.02.2026
+
W.P.(C) 15303/2025 and CM APPL. 62744/2025
ANANT KUMAR RAO
Through:
.....Petitioner
Dr. Kamini Lau, Ms. Jyoti
Vashisht, Ms. Suniti Bhatt and
Mr. Rudraksh Jain, Advs.
versus
UNION PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ravinder Agarwal, Mr.
Manish Kumar Singh, Mr. Vasu
Agarwal and Mr. Lekh Raj
Singh, Advs. for R-1 and R2/UPSC.
Mr. Shrey Sharawat, SPC with
Mr. Arvind, GP and Ms. Ishita
Misra, Adv. for R-3 and R-4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
By invoking the extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the Petitioner prays for
issuance of the writ in the nature of certiorari to quash the Order
passed on 23.07.2025 [hereinafter referred to as the ‘Impugned
Order’] by the Central Administrative Tribunal [hereinafter referred to
as ‘CAT’] whereby the Original Application preferred by the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
Petitioner came to be dismissed and the rejection of his candidature
for the post of Prosecutor in the Serious Fraud Investigation Office
[hereinafter referred to as ‘SFIO’] was upheld.
2.
To comprehend the issues involved in the present case, the
relevant facts in brief are required to be noticed. Pursuant to
Advertisement No. 18/2022 issued by the Union Public Service
Commission [hereinafter referred to as ‘UPSC’], inviting online
recruitment applications [hereinafter referred to as ‘ORA’], inter alia,
for twelve posts of Prosecutor in the SFIO, Ministry of Corporate
Affairs, the Petitioner applied for the aforesaid post. As per the
Recruitment Notice, the following experience was required for
applying to the post of Prosecutor:
“(B) EXPERIENCE: For Graduate in any discipline plus
bachelor's degree in Law Holders:- One year experience in
handling litigation & court matters/administration of Law in a
Government organization OR For integrated graduate in Law
(five years duration) Holders: Two years’ experience in handling
litigation & court matters/administration of Law in a Government
organization. DESIRABLE: (i) Additional one year experience in
corporate/criminal law matters. (ii) Masters’ in Law (LL.M.) from
recognized University or Institute. NOTE-I: The Qualifications are
relaxable at the discretion of the Union Public Service
Commission, for reasons to be recorded in writing, in the case of
candidates otherwise well qualified. NOTE-II: The qualification(s)
regarding experience is/are relaxable at the discretion of the Union
Public Service Commission for reasons to be recorded in writing in
the case of candidates belonging to the Scheduled Castes or the
Scheduled Tribes, if at any stage of selection the Union Public
Service Commission is of the opinion that sufficient number of
candidates from these communities possessing the requisite
experience are not likely to be available' to fill up the vacancies
reserved for them.”
(Emphasis supplied)
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
3.
The last date for submitting the online application was
13.10.2022, whereas 14.10.2022 was the last date for printing the
completely submitted online application. The Petitioner submitted his
application, disclosing that he holds a five-year integrated degree in
law. Under the advertisement, candidates holding such an integrated
law degree were required to possess two years’ experience in handling
litigation and court matters or administration of law in a government
organisation, subject to the notes appended thereto. In the Online
Recruitment Application (ORA), he disclosed experience in Willard
Advisory Pvt. Ltd. for the period commencing from 01.03.2020 to
13.10.2022, i.e., up to the cut-off date of the application, claiming to
have a total experience of 2 Years 7 Months 13 days. In the column of
nature of duties performed, he disclosed as follows:
“Nature of Duties Performed:
Drafting and negotiating contracts with third parties to
address the risks identified and levels of performance required
from the third party. The agreements and contracts should include
o Memorandum of Understanding o Non- Disclosure Agreement.
Non- Complete Agreement o Technology Transfer Agreements. o
Freelancing Agreements. o Partnership Agreements. o TPA o Rent.
Leave & License. Lease Agreements. o IP Licensing Agreement. o
Trademark Filing Application., EULA End User Licensing
Agreement. Criminal cases regarding forgery and conspiracy.
Actively Drafting and Reviewing Contracts. Corporate
Compliance.- Documents. Drafting and Vetting of Wide Variety of
Contracts and Other leg.”
4.
Subsequently, the Petitioner also filed, after the cut-off date,
certain other certificates showing experience of working in different
capacities. The candidature of the Petitioner was rejected for the
following reasons:
“Reasons for rejection:
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
Lacking 02 years Experience of handing litigation & court
matters/administration of Law in a Government organization.
August 2018 - Sept. 2019 - Worked with Sanjai Kumar Pathak for
01 year 2 Months. The PERIOD OF EXPERIENCE is not
admissible as the same has NOT been claimed in ORA Application
01.10.2019-30.01.2021 - Working as Associate with Deepak
Chauhan & Associates for 01 year 4 Months. Only 11 months
experience is admissible and the PERIOD OF EXPERIENCE from
01.10.2019 to 29.02.2020 is not admissible as the same has NOT
been claimed in ORA Application
31.01.2021 - 13.10.2022 - The PERIOD OF EXPERIENCE is not
admissible as No Experience Certificate provided.
Oct. 2022 to Dec. 2023 - Working as Associate with Anil Mehta,
Additional Advocate General for 01 year 2 Months. The PERIOD
OF EXPERIENCE is not admissible as the experience is gained
after closing date of application i.e. 13.10.2022.”
5.
Upon scrutiny of the application and the documents furnished,
the candidature of the Petitioner came to be rejected by the UPSC.
The reasons communicated for such rejection, inter alia, indicated that
the petitioner was found lacking the requisite experience. It was
further noted that certain periods of experience, though sought to be
relied upon subsequently after the cut-off date of the application, were
either not claimed in the ORA, were unsupported by admissible
certificates as on the cut-off date, or related to periods beyond the
closing date of applications.
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner approached the CAT by filing
Original Application. During the pendency of the proceedings, the
Tribunal permitted the Petitioner to provisionally participate in the
selection process, subject to the outcome of the Original Application,
and his result was directed to be kept in a sealed cover. Ultimately,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
however, upon consideration of the pleadings and submissions, the
Tribunal dismissed the Original Application by the Impugned Order.
7.
Heard the learned counsel for the Petitioner at length and, with
their able assistance, perused the paper book.
8.
Learned counsel representing the Petitioner has submitted that
the Petitioner belongs to the Scheduled Tribe (ST) and certificates
submitted by him subsequently should have been taken into
consideration. She further submitted that the Petitioner ought to have
been extended the benefit of relaxation under the notes appended to
the advertisement, and that the experience gained by him at Willard
Advisory ought to have been treated as sufficient compliance with the
experience requirement. It was also urged that the post in question
does not mandate actual appearance before courts and that a bona fide
omission in the ORA should not operate to his prejudice.
9.
This Court has duly considered the submissions advanced.
In the Recruitment Notice, it was notified that the successful candidate
will have to perform the following duties:
“DUTIES: (i) To assist filing of prosecutions/complaints in all the
cases that are investigated-by the SFIO in the concerned courts
and pursue their progress. (ii) Coordination with the counsels
detailed by the Government. (iii) Maintenance of data-base of court
cases. (iv) Any other work assigned from time to time. HQ: New
Delhi with All India Service Liability (AISL).”
10.
It is evident that the Petitioner, while submitting the application,
had claimed experience only in the company Willard Advisory Pvt.
Ltd. As per Annexure ‘A’ (in terms of the agreement between the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
company and the Petitioner), the Petitioner was expected to undertake
the following spectrum of work of the Company:
ANNEXURE A
The Party of the Second Part hereby agrees to undertake the following spectrum of work for the Company:
In addition to traditional consulting services, the Employee is to undertake extensive agreements which may
include large complex contracts involving varied avenues of law. This role involves the negotiation of the
legal terms and conditions of such contracts; providing a legal analysis of the associated risks; and related
advice to address, manage and mitigate the risks identified. The work is complex and requires sound
experience in contract law, professional services, contract drafting, intellectual property and the negotiation
of large, complex deals.
• Drafting and negotiating contracts with third parties to address the risks identified and levels of
performance required from the third party. The agreements and contracts should include:
o Memorandum of Understanding.
o Non- Disclosure Agreement.
o Non-Compete Agreements.
o Technology Transfer Agreements.
o Freelancing Agreements.
o Partnership Agreements.
o TPA.
o Rent, Leave & License, Lease Agreements.
o IP Licensing Agreement.
o Trademark Filing Application.
o EULA (End User Licensing Agreement).
o Criminal cases regarding forgery and conspiracy.
• Actively Drafting and Reviewing Contracts.
• Corporate Compliance.
• Drafting and Vetting of Wide Variety of Contracts and Other Legal Documents
11.
The UPSC is a constitutional and specialised recruiting agency
entrusted with the task of evaluating the eligibility and suitability of
candidates in accordance with the recruitment rules and the terms of
the advertisement. The court exercising jurisdiction under Article 226
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
of the Constitution ordinarily refrains from interfering unless the
action complained of is vitiated by mala fides, manifest arbitrariness,
or patent illegality. In matters of recruitment, the scope of judicial
review is thus confined to examining the legality of the decisionmaking process and not the merits of the decision itself. The Court is
not expected to substitute its opinion in place of the recruiting
agency/employer.
12.
Tested on the aforesaid parameters, it is evident that the
Petitioner, at the stage of submission of the ORA, had claimed
experience only in Willard Advisory Pvt. Ltd., and the nature of duties
disclosed therein pertained predominantly to drafting and vetting of
commercial contracts, compliance documentation and allied corporate
legal work. Significantly, during the course of proceedings before the
Tribunal, the petitioner did not assert that he had undertaken
appearances in Court or engagement in court proceedings as part of
such employment.
13. The principal question that arises for consideration is whether the
Petitioner fulfilled the essential experience requirement for the post of
Prosecutor in the Serious Fraud Investigation Office as on the cut-off
date prescribed in Advertisement No. 18/2022, on the basis of the
disclosures made by him in the Online Recruitment Application, and
whether the rejection of his candidature on that ground calls for
interference in exercise of writ jurisdiction.
14.
It is a matter of record that no other period of experience was
claimed by the petitioner in the ORA as on the cut-off date.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
Certificates and material relating to earlier engagements or subsequent
periods of work were sought to be relied upon only after the cut-off
date, either during scrutiny or in the course of proceedings before the
Tribunal. The relevance and admissibility of such material, therefore,
fell to be examined in the backdrop of the settled principle that
eligibility has to be assessed on the basis of disclosures made by a
candidate in the application as on the prescribed cut-off date.
15.
The duties attached to the post of Prosecutor in the SFIO, as
notified in the advertisement, include assisting in filing of
prosecutions and complaints before courts, pursuing their progress,
coordinating with counsel engaged by the Government, and
maintaining records relating to court cases. The experience
requirement, therefore, bears a rational nexus with the functional
responsibilities of the post. In that context, the view taken by the
recruiting agency that the experience disclosed by the Petitioner did
not satisfy the essential requirement cannot be said to be irrational,
arbitrary or perverse.
16.
The Supreme Court in Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah
Khan & Ors1., has authoritatively held that the selection process has
to be conducted strictly in accordance with the stipulated selection
procedure, and that when a particular schedule is mentioned in an
advertisement, the same has to be scrupulously maintained. It has been
further held that there cannot be any relaxation in the terms and
conditions of the advertisement unless such power is specifically
reserved, and that relaxation of any condition in the advertisement
(2011) 12 SCC 85
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
without due publication would be contrary to the mandate of equality
contained in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. The
relevant extract from Bedanga (Supra) is extracted herein:
28. We have considered the entire matter in detail. In our opinion, it is too
well settled to need any further reiteration that all appointments to
public office have to be made in conformity with Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. In other words, there must be no arbitrariness
resulting from any undue favour being shown to any candidate.
Therefore, the selection process has to be conducted strictly in
accordance with the stipulated selection procedure.
Consequently, when a particular schedule is mentioned in an
advertisement, the same has to be scrupulously maintained. There can
not be any relaxation in the terms and conditions of the advertisement
unless such a power is specifically reserved. Such a power could be
reserved in the relevant Statutory Rules. Even if power of relaxation is
provided in the rules, it must still be mentioned in the advertisement. In
the absence of such power in the Rules, it could still be provided in the
advertisement. However, the power of relaxation, if exercised has to be
given due publicity. This would be necessary to ensure that those
candidates who become eligible due to the relaxation, are afforded an
equal opportunity to apply and compete.Relaxation of any condition in
advertisement without due publication would be contrary to the mandate
of quality contained in Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
29. A perusal of the advertisement in this case will clearly show that there
was no power of relaxation. In our opinion, the High Court committed an
error in directing that the condition with regard to the submission of the
disability certificate either along with the application form or before
appearing in the preliminary examination could be relaxed in the case of
respondent No. 1. Such a course would not be permissible as it would
violate the mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
(Emphasis supplied)
17.
Much emphasis was laid on behalf of the Petitioner on the
certificates and material sought to be produced after the cut-off date,
as well as on the relaxation clauses contained in the advertisement.
It is, however, a settled principle that the sanctity of the cut-off date
prescribed in a recruitment process has to be strictly maintained.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
Permitting candidates to improve or supplement their eligibility after
the cut-off date would introduce uncertainty and inequality into the
selection process and would be contrary to the mandate of Articles 14
and 16 of the Constitution of India. The recruiting agency was,
therefore, justified in confining its consideration to the eligibility
claimed and substantiated as on the closing date of applications.
18.
Viewed in the aforesaid legal backdrop, Note-I and Note-II
appended to the advertisement, confer a discretionary power upon the
UPSC to relax the qualifications, including experience, in specified
circumstances and for reasons to be recorded in writing. Such a
provision does not vest an enforceable right in any candidate to claim
relaxation as a matter of course.
19.
In the present case, no material has been placed to demonstrate
that the circumstances contemplated under the notes were attracted or
that the refusal to exercise such discretion suffered from arbitrariness.
The fact that the Petitioner belongs to the Scheduled Tribe category,
by itself, does not mandate relaxation in the absence of satisfaction of
the conditions stipulated therein.
CONCLUSION
20.
The Tribunal, upon a consideration of the pleadings and the
applicable recruitment conditions, has taken a view which is plausible
and consistent with settled principles governing judicial review in
service matters. No ground is made out for this Court to interfere with
the Impugned Order.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
21.
The Writ Petition is, accordingly, dismissed. Pending
application, if any, also stand disposed of.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
FEBRUARY 13, 2026
sp/ad
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
13:24:15
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review