Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 23rd February, 2026
Uploaded on: 27th February, 2026
FAO (COMM) 220/2025 & CM APPL. 50471/2025
ANAMIKA PRAKASHAN
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Utkarsh, Mr. Vipul Saluja, Ms.
Anshu Priyanka, Ms. Manya Purwar,
Mr. Abhiraj Singh, Mr. Abhishek
Khare, Advs.
versus
VANI PRAKASHAN & ANR.
Through: None.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
.....Respondents
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant - Anamika
Prakashan under Order XLIII Rule 1(r) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(hereinafter ‘the CPC’), inter alia, challenging the impugned order dated 7th
July, 2025 passed by the ld. District Judge-12, Commercial Court, Central,
Delhi in an application under Order XXXIX Rule 2A of the CPC in the
Contempt Petition No. 21/24 titled Vani Prakashan (through Proprietor Ms
Ameeta Maheshwari) v. Mahendra Mishra (deceased) through LRs & Anr.
3.
Vide the impugned order, the Appellant has been sentenced to undergo
simple imprisonment of two months in Civil Prison and attachment of the
property of the Appellant has also been directed vide the impugned order for
a period of one year on the ground that the Appellant is guilty of contempt of
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
the orders dated 5th December, 2020 and 20th December, 2023 passed in the
commercial suit being CS(Comm) No. 1753/2020 titled Vani Prakashan vs
Mahendra Mishra & Anr.
4.
The brief background of the present case is that, both the
Appellant/Defendant - Anamika Prakashan and Respondent/Plaintiff – Vani
Prakashan, are publishing houses. One Mr. Mahendra Mishra (deceased) was
the author of the book titled ‘Bhartiya Cinema’ (hereinafter ‘the subject
book’).
5.
An agreement dated 2nd August, 2018 was signed between Vani
Prakashan and Mr. Mahendra Mishra. In terms of the said agreement, Vani
Prakashan had to publish the subject book, which was an anthology of Indian
cinema. The agreement vested rights of the said book in Vani Prakashan
including the copyright in the work. Disputes appear to have arisen between
the author and Vani Prakashan, due to which the author appears to have passed
on the rights in the subject book to the Appellant – Anamika Prakashan who
thereafter published the same.
6.
Aggrieved by the said publication by the Appellant, Vani Prakashan
filed a suit before the Commercial Court, Central District, Tis Hazari Courts
being CS(Comm) No. 1753/2020. The prayer in the said suit was for a
restraint order against the Appellant/Defendant from publishing the subject
book. In the said suit, vide order dated 5th December, 2020, an ex-parte order
of interim injunction was passed in the following terms:
“15. It is therefore ordered that till the next date of
hearing, the defendants are restrained from the sale
or offering for sale the book titled “Bhartiya
Cinema” published by the defendant no.2 under the
authorship of defendant no.1, in any form (i.e.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
physical, electronic or kindle etc.) and on any sale
platform, whether online or offline. This obligation
shall commence on the expiry of seven days of the
service of this order upon the defendant no.2, so that
the defendant no. 2 has a reasonable time at its
disposal to do the needful.”
7.
The said ex-parte injunction was, thereafter, confirmed and made
absolute on 20th December, 2023. At that stage, the allegation by Vani
Prakashan was that in violation of the injunction order, the Appellant had
published and sold the subject book on e-commerce platforms including
Flipkart, Amazon as also through offline methods. Accordingly, Vani
Prakashan had filed an application under Order XXXIX Rule 2A of CPC. The
said order dated 20th December 2023 reads as under:
“Ld. Counsel for plaintiff has taken me through the
Interim Order dated 05.12.2020 and para no.14 and
15 thereof. Ld. Counsel submits that the defendant
no.2 was restrained from sale or offering for sale,
the book titled “Bhartiya Cinema” published by
defendant no.2 under the authorship of defendant
no.1 in any form (i.e. physical, electronic or kindle
etc. ) and on any sale platform whether online or
offline. Ld. Counsel submits that defendant no.2 is
in flagrant violation of interim Order is selling the
book through online E-commerce website of
Flipkart and Amazon.
Plaintiff has a prima-facie case in its favor. This
Court is shown from screen-shots and other
material that defendant is still continuously selling
the books through online E-commerce website of
Flipkart and Amazon. Considering the fact situation
as also the observations in Order dated 05.12.2020,
the interim Order dated 05.12.2020 is hereby made
absolute.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
The application under Order XXXIX rule 1 and 2
CPC stands disposed off.
Arguments heard on the application under Order
XXXIX rule 2-A CPC as address by ld. Counsel for
plaintiff.
Be put up for orders on the same. Defendant no.2 is
at liberty to address her submissions on or before
22.12.2023 at 11.00 AM.”
8.
Subsequently, the application under Order XXXIX Rule 2A of CPC
came to be heard and vide the impugned order, the Court found the Appellant
guilty of contempt. The findings of the Commercial Court in the impugned
order are set out below:
“18. Keeping in view the settled position under law
and adverting to the facts of the case, the
Respondent was restrained from selling or offering
for sale the book titled ‘Bhartiya Cinema’ published
by them under the authorship of Respondent no.1, in
any form i.e. physical, electronic or kindle etc. and
on any safe platform whether online and offline.
However, in blatant disregard to the Orders,
Respondent has continued with sale of the book in
market and through website Amazon and other
portals. The two Invoices dated 27.01.2024 show the
sale by Respondent of the impugned Book by said
Invoices annexed as Annexure A2 (colly) on record.
The same is further demonstrable from the Purchase
Order dated 03.08.2024 placed by Applicant
showing purchase of the impugned goods on
websites and Invoice dated 03.08.2024 alongwith
the screen-shots of the details of the Order on
Amazon, annexed as Annexure-A3 and A4.
19. The documents amply establish that Respondent
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
despite knowledge of the stay orders has been
indulged in such infringing activities in a brazen
manner. In fact, the Respondent has no defence to
put forth and she has shown complete disregard to
the Orders of the Court. The Respondent has not
only flouted the judicial Orders but also has
interfered with the administration of justice
intentionally to bring the majesty of law to
disrepute.
20. I observe that during proceedings also, the
Respondent has remained defiant and shown
complete disregard to the judicial Orders and same
is observable from Court’s order sheets, in
particular the Order dated 21.09.2024. The
Respondent has given an impression to the Court
that she has no respect and sanctity to the Orders of
the Court. It would be a great disaster if the fountain
of justice is allowed to be poisoned and if the Court
allows the gross contempt of Court to go
unpunished.
21. The stream of justice cannot be defiled and any
such act must be dealt with stern manner. Also no
one can be permitted to undermine the dignity of the
Court and interfere with the due course of judicial
proceedings. The judicial system has its foundation
in the faith of the people and the same cannot be
effective unless respect for it is maintained. If the
Courts’ Orders are violated with impunity without
any deterrence, the first and foremost casualty is the
faith of people which holds the system in place.
When the violators go scot free, it only emboldens
the others to follow the suit and this has cascading
effect.
22. Considering the facts and circumstances in
their entirety, I hold the Respondent Ms Geeta
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
Shukla, Proprietor of M/s Anamika Prakashan to
be guilty of Contempt of Court under Order 39 rule
2 (A) of CPC for deliberate disobedience of the
Orders dated 05.12.2020 and 20.12.2023. The
application stands allowed.
23 (a) The Contemnor-Respondent is sentenced to
undergo simple imprisonment of two months in
Civil Prison.
(b) Properties belonging to respondent- contemnor
including the property no 52, Tula Ram Bagh,
Prayagraj-211006 be attached by the DM
concerned for a period of one year. A Report be filed
of such attachment by DM, Prayagraj, UP on or
before 30.07.2025.
(c) Issue arrest warrants against the respondent –
Contemnor Ms Geeta Shukla to be issued through
SSP concerned, returnable on 30.07.2025.
Copy of this order be sent to the Court of Ld.
Principal District and Sessions Judge, Prayagraj,
UP with a request of due execution of the Order by
the Registry.
Contempt petition be tagged alongwith main suit
and the same be put up on 30.07.2025.”
9.
As can be seen from the above order, Ms. Geeta Shukla, Proprietor of
the Appellant Publication has been held to be guilty of contempt and held to
be in deliberate disobedience of the orders dated 5th December, 2020 and 20th
December, 2023. She has been sentenced to two months simple imprisonment
and her properties have also been directed to be attached.
10.
Aggrieved by the impugned order, the Appellant has preferred the
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
present appeal.
11.
On 18th August, 2025, this Court had issued notice in the present appeal.
Thereafter, on 22nd August, 2025, ld. Counsels for the parties had made their
submissions. The same is recorded as under:
“[...]
10.
Insofar as the main suit itself is concerned,
ld. Counsels have informed that the judgment was
reserved on 18th January, 2025. However, vide
order dated 13th February, 2025 the Commercial
Court had sought certain clarifications and
accordingly, listed the matter for further arguments
on 28th February, 2025. The relevant portion of the
order dated 13th February, 2025 reads as under:
“While the matter is listed today for
pronouncement of final Order, I find the
Plaintiff has placed reliance on various
Judgments in support of damages/ aggravated
damages and financial losses suffered by the
Plaintiff.
This Court requires certain clarifications in
view of the written synopsis and the reliance
placed on judicial precedents and the factum
of clause (d) of Prayer clause of Plaintiff
asking for Rs. 10 lakhs as damages. Further,
the suit is filed by Vani Prakashan and not in
the name of Sh. Arun Maheshwari. The same is
filed in the name of Proprietorship firm and the
entertainability of the suit is in question in view
of the settled law laid down in this regard.
Be put up for further arguments on these
aspects on 28.02.2025.”
11.
Thereafter, an application under Order
VI Rule 17 of CPC and an application under
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
Order I Rule 10 of CPC for adding the name of
the proprietor of Vani Prakashan as the Plaintiff,
appears to have been moved by the Plaintiff. The
same was allowed vide order dated 27th May,
2025 which was passed after the judgement was
reserved. The said order has been challenged by
the Appellant in CM(M) 1375/2025 wherein the
following order has been passed:
“1. Learned counsel for respondents
appears on advance notice and submits
that copy of order passed by this Court on
28.07.2025 has already been placed
before learned Trial Court and in terms of
a specific direction contained therein,
learned Trial Court would defer the
hearing of final arguments.
2. To make things clear, learned Trial
Court is requested to defer hearing of
final arguments.”
12.
Thus, the proceedings have been
deferred. It is also submitted by the ld. Counsels
for the parties that another CM(M) 216/2025
relating to an earlier order is also stated to be
listed before the ld. Single Judge.
13.
In this appeal, this Court is only
concerned with the order dated 7th July, 2025
passed under Order 39 Rule 2 (A) of CPC. Both
the parties are publishers and the author has
expired. The rights qua the subject book are to be
adjudicated in the main suit and the injunction
order is operating in this matter. There are
allegations of violation of the same.
14.
Ld. Counsel for the Defendant/Appellant
whose proprietor has been sentenced to civil
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
imprisonment, submits that the documents which
were the basis of the finding of contempt are
themselves unreliable and have not been taken on
record. Ld. Counsel further submits that the
Appellant has only sold 30 books since the time the
rights were given by the Author. The Appellant had
printed a total of 300 copies of the book.
15.
On the other hand, the ld. Counsel for the
Respondent submits that the Appellant has shown no
respect to the interim injunction order which stands
confirmed. The book was freely available on
Amazon and Flipkart which was purchased and
even placed before the Commercial Court.
12.
After hearing the matter in considerable detail, on 22nd August, 2025,
the Court had directed as under:
16.
On a query from the Court, it is informed
that the retail price of the book is Rs. 2000/-. There
is no doubt that the interim injunction order,
which is operating ought to be unscrupulously
complied with. However, the Appellant’s
proprietor who has been held guilty of contempt is
a lady who is 67 years of age and that too a
Publisher. The contempt appeal filed deserves a
deeper scrutiny as to whether the civil
imprisonment and attachment is to be sustained or
not. In the overall facts and circumstances, this
Court is of the view that considering the Appellant
is a publisher and an elderly lady, who is stated to
be 67 years of age, it is directed that the Appellant
shall deposit a sum of Rs.70,000/- before the Trial
Court on or before 15th September, 2025.
17.
The deposit shall be without prejudice to
the rights and contentions of the parties.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
18.
Subject to the said deposit, the directions
for civil imprisonment/arrest warrant and the
attachment of the property shall remain stayed. If
the deposit is not made, the Respondent is free to
move an application before this Court.
19.
List on 13th November, 2025 for hearing of
the appeal.”
13.
In terms of the above order, the directions for civil imprisonment/arrest
warrant and attachment to property were stayed, subject to deposit of Rs.
70,000/- by the Appellant.
14.
On the said date, the Respondents were represented before the Court.
However, thereafter, none has appeared for the Respondents, on the last three
hearings.
15.
Ld.Counsel for the Appellant submits that the amount of Rs. 70,000/-
stands deposited before the ld. Trial Court.
16.
The proof of deposit has been placed on record along with an affidavit.
17.
The said FDR shall be renewed during the pendency of the suit by the
Appellant.
18.
In view of the deposit which has been made, this Court is satisfied that
in the facts of this case, the deposit of the FDR is sufficient for the purging of
the contempt by the Appellant.
19.
No further orders would be required to be passed in the application
under Order XXXIX Rule 2A of CPC.
20.
The said FDR shall abide by the decision in CS(Comm) No. 1753/2020
which is pending in the Court of Ms. Ravinder Bedi, ld. District Judge
(Commercial Court)-12, Tiz Hazari Courts, Delhi.
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
21.
The FDR shall be kept in safe custody with the said Court and shall
abide by the final decision in the suit.
22.
None of the findings in the impugned order shall come in the way of
the final adjudication of the suit.
23.
The appeal is disposed of. Pending applications, if any, are also
disposed of.
24.
Copy of this order be communicated to the concerned Principal District
Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi in order to ensure that the file of the Contempt
Contempt Petition No. 21/24 is transmitted to the Court where the suit
CS(Comm) No. 1753/2020 is pending as also to ensure that the FDR is
retained in safe custody and is renewed from time to time during pendency of
the suit.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
FEBRUARY 23, 2026/b/sm
Signed By:RENUKA
NEGI
16:55:08
FAO (COMM) 220/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review