Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:3356
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
Cr. MP(M) No. 2996 of 2025
Reserved on: 16.01.2026
Date of Decision: 23.01.2026.
Amrish Rana
….Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P.
….Respondent
_____________________________________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr Justice Rakesh Kainthla, Vacation Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 No
For the Petitioner(s)
:
For the Respondent/State:
Ms. Sheetal Vyas, Advocate.
Mr. Pushpender Singh Jaswal,
Additional Advocate General.
Rakesh Kainthla, Vacation Judge
The petitioner has filed the present petition seeking
regular bail in FIR No. 40 of 2025, dated 16.4.2025, registered at
Police Station, Gagret, District Una, H.P. for the commission of
offences punis hable under Sections 126(2), 308(4), 324(5),
351(2), 352, 62, 111(2)(b) and 238 read with Section 3(5) of
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS).
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:3356
2.
It has been asserted that as per the FIR, the petitioner
and the co-accused went to the spot on 15.04.2025 at around
10:00 pm and threatened the JCB driver Shiv Kumar and Tipper
Driver Sanjay Rana by waiving a darat and asked them to take
away their vehicles. The petitioner deflated the tyres of the
vehicles and put some substance in their engine. The allegations
in the FIR even if, taken to be true do not constitute any heinous
offence. No injury was inflicted on any person. No recovery of
weapon was effected from the petitioner. The offence punishable
under Section 308(4) of BNS is not made out. The allegations are
false. The charge sheet has been filed before the Court and no
fruitful purpose would be served by detaining the petitioner in
custody. The police added Section 111 of BNS without any
foundation. There is no evidence of any continuing criminal
activity, financial gain or organized group structure to support
the allegation. The petitioner is a permanent resident of District
Una and has been blessed with a baby girl. He has roots in the
society and there is no chance of his absconding. Hence, it was
prayed that the present petition be allowed and the petitioner be
released on bail.
2026:HHC:3356
3.
The petition is opposed by filing a status report
asserting that the informant, Kanwar Sandeep Singh, made a
complaint to the police stating that he had established Thakur
Store Crusher Guglehar about 03 years before the incident. He
had employed the drivers to drive the vehicles and the JCB.
Amrish Rana visited the Swan River on 12.04.2025 with his
friends and threatened the drivers. He again visited the spot on
15.04.2025 at 10:00 pm with Amit Mankotia in the vehicles
bearing registration Nos. HP67-9251 and HP72D-0695. They
threatened Shiv Kumar, the driver of the JCB and Sanjay Rana,
the driver of the tipper. Amrish Rana had a “darat”, and he
threatened to kill the drivers on failure to accompany him. The
drivers drove the vehicles to the Swan River. Amrish Rana and his
friends put something into the engine and deflated the tyres of
the tipper. Amrish Rana had already threatened the informant
and Rohit Kumar to face dire consequences on failure to pay
money to him. Police registered the FIR and investigated the
matter. It was found after the investigation that the accused had
2026:HHC:3356
threatened the informant Kanwar Sandeep Singh and Rohit
Kumar, owner of Sai Stone Crusher, for ransom. Hence, the
offence punishable under Section 111(2) of the BNS was added.
Amrish Rana and Amit Mankotia produced the vehicles bearing
registration No. HP-72D-0695 and HP-67-9251, along with
documents and the keys, which were seized by the police. Amrish
Rana did not produce his mobile phone or darat, which was used
during the incident. Amit Mankotia produced his mobile phone,
which was analyzed and it was found that it was used for calling
someone virtually. Amrish Rana was convicted in FIR No.
489/1999, 419/2006, 537/2000, 69/2001, 677/2002, 40/2003,
73/2006, and 498/2002. He was acquitted in FIR No. 437/2000,
51/1999 and 6/2001. FIR No. 249/1996 was compromised
between the parties, and FIR No.115/2013 is pending. The
informant stated during the investigation that Amrish Rana,
Amit Mankotia and two other persons had threatened him on
15.4.2025. Amrish Rana, Amit Mankotia and Aman Rana named
Jagpal as their accomplice. Jagpal produced a bail order passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, and he was released on bail
in terms of the order. The charge sheet was filed before the
2026:HHC:3356
learned
Additional
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate,
Amb,
on
26.08.2025. As per the result of the analysis, hydrocarbons were
detected in the contents of the parcel sent for analysis. The result
of the analysis of the mobile phone is awaited. The petitioner
would indulge in the commission of a similar offence in case of
his release on bail. Hence, the status report.
4.
I have heard Ms Sheetal Vyas, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Mr Pushpender Singh Jaswal, learned Additional
Advocate General for the respondent/State .
5.
Ms Sheetal Vyas, learned counsel for the petitioner,
submitted that the petitioner is innocent and he was falsely
implicated. The offence punishable under Section 111 of the BNS
is not made out against the petitioner because no FIR was
registered against him or any other person in the preceding ten
years, which is a requirement of Section 111 of the BNS. The
police have filed the charge sheet before the Court, and the
custody of the petitioner is not required for the investigation. No
fruitful purpose would be served by detaining the petitioner in
custody. Hence, he prayed that the present petition be allowed
and the petitioner be released on bail.
2026:HHC:3356
6.
Mr
Pushpinder
Singh
Jaswal,
learned
Deputy
Advocate General for the respondent/State, submitted that the
petitioner had threatened the informant on the previous
occasion for ransom. The petitioner was involved in the
commission of similar offences earlier, and he would indulge in
the commission of a similar offence in case of his release on bail.
Hence, he prayed that the present petition be dismissed.
7.
I have given considerable thought to the submissions
made at the bar and have gone through the records carefully.
8.
The parameters for granting bail were considered by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Pinki v. State of U.P., (2025) 7 SCC
314: 2025 SCC OnLine SC 781, wherein it was observed at page 380:
(i) Broad principles for the grant of bail
56. In Gudikanti Narasimhulu v. High Court of A.P., (1978) 1
SCC 240: 1978 SCC (Cri) 115, Krishna Iyer, J., while
elaborating on the content of Article 21 of the Constitution
of India in the context of personal liberty of a person
under trial, has laid down the key factors that should be
considered while granting bail, which are extracted as
under: (SCC p. 244, paras 7-9)
“7. It is thus obvious that the nature of the charge is
the vital factor, and the nature of the evidence is also
pertinent. The punishment to which the party may be
liable, if convicted or a conviction is confirmed, also
bears upon the issue.
2026:HHC:3356
8. Another relevant factor is whether the course of justice
would be thwarted by him who seeks the benignant
jurisdiction of the Court to be freed for the time being.
[Patrick Devlin, “The Criminal Prosecution in England”
(Oxford University Press, London 1960) p. 75 —
Modern Law Review, Vol. 81, Jan. 1968, p. 54.]
9. Thus, the legal principles and practice validate the
Court considering the likelihood of the applicant
interfering with witnesses for the prosecution or
otherwise polluting the process of justice. It is not only
traditional but rational, in this context, to enquire into the
antecedents of a man who is applying for bail to find
whether he has a bad record, particularly a record which
suggests that he is likely to commit serious offences while
on bail. In regard to habituals, it is part of criminological
history that a thoughtless bail order has enabled the
bailee to exploit the opportunity to inflict further crimes
on the members of society. Bail discretion, on the basis of
evidence about the criminal record of a defendant, is
therefore not an exercise in irrelevance.” (emphasis
supplied)
57. In Prahlad Singh Bhati v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2001) 4
SCC 280: 2001 SCC (Cri) 674, this Court highlighted various
aspects that the courts should keep in mind while dealing
with an application seeking bail. The same may be
extracted as follows: (SCC pp. 284-85, para 8)
“8. The jurisdiction to grant bail has to be exercised on the
basis of well-settled principles, having regard to the
circumstances of each case and not in an arbitrary
manner. While granting the bail, the court has to keep in
mind the nature of accusations, the nature of evidence in
support thereof, the severity of the punishment which
conviction will entail, the character, behaviour, means
and standing of the accused, circumstances which are
peculiar to the accused, reasonable possibility of securing
the presence of the accused at the trial, reasonable
apprehension of the witnesses being tampered with, the
larger interests of the public or State and similar other
2026:HHC:3356
considerations. It has also to be kept in mind that for the
purposes of granting the bail the legislature has used the
words “reasonable grounds for believing” instead of “the
evidence” which means the court dealing with the grant
of bail can only satisfy it (sic itself) as to whether there is a
genuine case against the accused and that the prosecution
will be able to produce prima facie evidence in support of
the charge.” (emphasis supplied)
58. This Court in Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh,
(2002) 3 SCC 598: 2002 SCC (Cri) 688, speaking through
Banerjee, J., emphasised that a court exercising discretion
in matters of bail has to undertake the same judiciously. In
highlighting that bail should not be granted as a matter of
course, bereft of cogent reasoning, this Court observed as
follows: (SCC p. 602, para 3)
“3. Grant of bail, though being a discretionary order, but,
however, calls for the exercise of such a discretion in a
judicious manner and not as a matter of course. An order
for bail bereft of any cogent reason cannot be sustained.
Needless to record, however, that the grant of bail is
dependent upon the contextual facts of the matter being
dealt with by the court and facts do always vary from
case to case. While placement of the accused in the
society, though it may be considered by itself, cannot be a
guiding factor in the matter of grant of bail, and the
same should always be coupled with other circumstances
warranting the grant of bail. The nature of the offence is
one of the basic considerations for the grant of bail — the
more heinous is the crime, the greater is the chance of
rejection of the bail, though, however, dependent on the
factual matrix of the matter.” (emphasis supplied)
59. In Kalyan Chandra Sarkar v. Rajesh Ranjan, (2004) 7
SCC 528: 2004 SCC (Cri) 1977, this Court held that although
it is established that a court considering a bail application
cannot undertake a detailed examination of evidence and
an elaborate discussion on the merits of the case, yet the
court is required to indicate the prima facie reasons
justifying the grant of bail.
2026:HHC:3356
60. In Prasanta Kumar Sarkar v. Ashis Chatterjee, (2010) 14
SCC 496: (2011) 3 SCC (Cri) 765, this Court observed that
where a High Court has granted bail mechanically, the said
order would suffer from the vice of non-application of
mind, rendering it illegal. This Court held as under with
regard to the circumstances under which an order
granting bail may be set aside. In doing so, the factors
which ought to have guided the Court's decision to grant
bail have also been detailed as under: (SCC p. 499, para 9)
“9. … It is trite that this Court does not, normally,
interfere with an order passed by the High Court granting
or rejecting bail to the accused. However, it is equally
incumbent upon the High Court to exercise its discretion
judiciously, cautiously and strictly in compliance with the
basic principles laid down in a plethora of decisions of
this Court on the point. It is well settled that, among
other circumstances, the factors to be borne in mind
while considering an application for bail are:
(i) whether there is any prima facie or
reasonable ground to believe that the accused
had committed the offence;
(ii) nature and gravity of the accusation;
(iii) severity of the punishment in the event of
conviction;
(iv) danger of the accused absconding or fleeing,
if released on bail;
(v) character, behaviour, means, position and
standing of the accused;
(vi) likelihood of the offence being repeated;
(vii) reasonable apprehension of the witnesses
being influenced; and
(viii) danger, of course, of justice being thwarted
by grant of bail.” (emphasis supplied)
xxxxxxx
62. One of the judgments of this Court on the aspect of
application of mind and requirement of judicious exercise
of discretion in arriving at an order granting bail to the
2026:HHC:3356
accused is Brijmani Devi v. Pappu Kumar, (2022) 4 SCC 497 :
(2022) 2 SCC (Cri) 170, wherein a three-Judge Bench of this
Court, while setting aside an unreasoned and casual order
(Pappu Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2021 SCC OnLine Pat 2856
and Pappu Singh v. State of Bihar, 2021 SCC OnLine Pat 2857)
of the High Court granting bail to the accused, observed as
follows: (Brijmani Devi v. Pappu Kumar, (2022) 4 SCC 497 :
(2022) 2 SCC (Cri) 170]), SCC p. 511, para 35)
“35. While we are conscious of the fact that liberty of an
individual is an invaluable right, at the same time while
considering an application for bail courts cannot lose
sight of the serious nature of the accusations against an
accused and the facts that have a bearing in the case,
particularly, when the accusations may not be false,
frivolous or vexatious in nature but are supported by
adequate material brought on record so as to enable a
court to arrive at a prima facie conclusion. While
considering an application for the grant of bail, a prima
facie conclusion must be supported by reasons and must
be arrived at after having regard to the vital facts of the
case brought on record. Due consideration must be given
to facts suggestive of the nature of crime, the criminal
antecedents of the accused, if any, and the nature of
punishment that would follow a conviction vis-à-vis the
offence(s) alleged against an accused.” (emphasis
supplied)
9.
The present petition has to be decided as per the
parameters laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10.
As per the prosecution, the petitioner and the co-
accused, including Jagpal Singh Rana and Amit Mankotia, had
intimidated the informant and other persons. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court released Jagpal Singh Rana on pre-arrest bail in
2026:HHC:3356
Criminal Appeal No.4609 of 2025 (arising out of SLP CrL No.
11389 of 2025) titled Jagpal Singh Vs. State of HP, decided on
27.10.2025. Learned Additional Sessions Judge-I, Una released
Amit Mankotia in Bail Application No.293 of 2025, titled Amit
Mankotia Vs. State of HP, decided on 8.9.2025. Petitioner had
applied for bail before the learned Additional Sessions Judge-I,
Una, but his application was dismissed on the ground that he had
criminal antecedents. The offences alleged against them were
grave, involving violence and risk to public peace. Therefore, he
could not be released on bail.
11.
of
The police have registered the FIR for the commission
offences
punishable
under
Sections
126(2)
(wrongful
restraint), 308(4) (extortion), 324(5) (mischief), 351(2) (criminal
intimidation), 352 (intentional insult), 62 (attempt to commit
offence punishable with imprisonment) and 111 (organized
crime). The FIR did not mention that Amrish Rana, Amit
Mankotia or any other person had threatened the informant or
any other person before the incident for ransom. A statement
was made during the pendency of the investigation to this effect.
Therefore, prima facie, it is doubtful that such an offence had
2026:HHC:3356
been committed because had it been so, the matter would have
been reported to the police at the earliest or at least while
registering the present FIR.
12.
The police have also added section 111 of BNS. It reads
as follows:
“111. Organised Crime. “(1) Any continuing unlawful
activity including kidnapping, robbery, vehicle theft,
extortion, land grabbing, contract killing, economic
offence, cyber-crimes, trafficking of persons, drugs,
weapons or illicit goods or services, human trafficking for
prostitution or ransom, by any person or a group of
persons acting in concert, singly or jointly, either as a
member of an organized crime syndicate or on behalf of
such syndicate, by use of violence, threat of violence,
intimidation, coercion, or by any other unlawful means to
obtain direct or indirect material benefit including a
financial benefit, shall constitute organized crime.
Explanation. —For the purposes of this sub-section,—
(i) “organised crime syndicate” means a group of
two or more persons who, acting either singly or
jointly, as a syndicate or gang, indulge in any
continuing unlawful activity;
(ii) “continuing unlawful activity” means an
activity prohibited by law which is a cognizable
offence punishable with imprisonment of three
years or more, undertaken by any person, either
singly or jointly, as a member of an organised crime
syndicate or on behalf of such syndicate in respect
of which more than one charge-sheets have been
filed before a competent Court within the preceding
period of ten years and that Court has taken
2026:HHC:3356
cognizance of such offence, and includes economic
offence;
(iii) “economic offence” includes criminal breach of
trust, forgery, counterfeiting of currency notes,
bank notes, bank-notes and Government stamps,
hawala transaction, mass-marketing fraud or
running any scheme to defraud several persons or
doing any act in any manner with a view to defraud
any bank or financial institution or any other
institution organization for obtaining monetary
benefits in any form.
(2) Whoever commits organised crime shall—
(a) If such offence has resulted in the death of any
person, be punished with death or imprisonment for
life, and shall also be liable to a fine which shall not
be less than ten lakh rupees;
(b) In any other case, be punished with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less
than five years but which may extend to
imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to a
fine which shall not be less than five lakh rupees.
(3) Whoever abets, attempts, conspires or knowingly
facilitates the commission of an organised crime, or
otherwise engages in any act preparatory to an organised
crime, shall be punished with imprisonment for a term
which shall not be less than five years but which may
extend to imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to
fine which shall not be less than five lakh rupees.
(4) Any person who is a member of an organised crime
syndicate shall be punished with imprisonment for a term
which shall not be less than five years but which may
extend to imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to
a fine which shall not be less than five lakh rupees.
(5) Whoever, intentionally, harbours or conceals any
person who has committed the offence of an organised
crime shall be punished with imprisonment for a term
2026:HHC:3356
which shall not be less than three years but which may
extend to imprisonment for life, and shall also be liable to
fine which shall not be less than five lakh rupees: Provided
that this sub-Section shall not apply to any case in which
the harbour or concealment is by the spouse of the
offender.
(6) Whoever possesses any property derived or obtained
from the commission of an organised crime or proceeds of
any organised crime or which has been acquired through
the organised crime, shall be punishable with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than
three years but which may extend to imprisonment for life
and shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less than
two lakh rupees.
(7) If any person on behalf of a member of an organized
crime syndicate is, or at any time has been in possession
of movable or immovable property which he cannot
satisfactorily account for, shall be punishable with
imprisonment for a term which shall not be less than
three years but which may extend to imprisonment for ten
years and shall also be liable to fine which shall not be less
than one lakh rupees”.
13.
A bare perusal of the section shows that a person
should indulge in a specified activity either singly or jointly as a
member of an organised crime syndicate in respect of which
more than one charge sheet has been filed before a court within
the preceding period of ten years, and the Court has taken
cognisance of such offence.
2026:HHC:3356
14.
This section was explained by the Karnataka High
Court in Avinash vs. State of Karnataka (11.03.2025 - KARHC):
MANU/KA/0938/2025 as under:
1. The primary intent behind introducing Section 111 of
BNS, 2023, is to provide a targeted and effective
mechanism to dismantle organised crime syndicates.
From a reading of the said provision of law, it is manifest
that for the purpose of invoking Section 111 of BNS, 2023,
there are certain basic parameters, and if it is found that
the accused comes within the said parameters, the offence
punishable under Section 111 of BNS, 2023 can be invoked.
The said parameters are as follows:
(a) the offences enlisted in the Section must have
been committed;
(b) accused should be a member of an organised
crime syndicate;
(c) he should have committed the crime as a
member of an organised crime syndicate or on
behalf of such a syndicate.
(d) he should have been chargesheeted more than
once before a competent Court within the preceding
period of ten years for a cognizable offence
punishable with imprisonment for three years or
more, and the Court before which the chargesheet
has been filed should have taken cognisance of such
offence, including an economic offence.
(e) the crime must be committed by using violence,
intimidation, threat, coercion or by any other
unlawful means.
15.
It was laid down by the Kerala High Court in Mohd.
Hashim v. State of Kerala, 2024 SCC OnLine Ker 5260, where no
2026:HHC:3356
charge sheet was filed against the accused in the preceding ten
years, he cannot be held liable for the commission of an offence
punishable under Section 111 of the BNS Act. It was observed:
“10. Section 111 (1) explicitly stipulates that to attract the
offence, there should be a continuing unlawful activity, by
any person or group of persons acting in concert, singly or
jointly, either as a member of an organised crime
syndicate or on behalf of such syndicate. The material
ingredient to attract the above provision, so far as the
present case is concerned, is that there should have been a
continuing unlawful activity committed by a member of
an organised crime syndicate or on behalf of such
syndicate.
11. Explanation (i) and (ii) of sub-section (1) of Section 111
of BNS define an organised crime syndicate and a
continuing unlawful activity, respectively.
12. Continuing unlawful activity under explanation (ii) of
Section 111(1) of the BNS means an activity prohibited by
law, which is a cognizable offence punishable with
imprisonment of three years or more, undertaken by any
person, either singly or jointly, as a member of an
organised crime syndicate or on behalf of such syndicate
in respect of which more than one charge-sheet has to be
filed before a competent Court within the preceding period
of ten years and that Court has taken cognizance of such
an offence. Furthermore, an organised crime syndicate
under Explanation (i) of sub-section (1) of Section 111 of
the BNS means a group of two or more persons who,
acting either singly or jointly as a syndicate or gang,
indulge in any continuing unlawful activity.
13. While interpreting the analogous provisions of
the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999,
which mandates the existence of at least two charge
sheets in respect of a specified offence in the preceding
2026:HHC:3356
ten years, the Honourable Supreme Court in State of
Maharashtra v. Shiva alias Shivaji Ramaji Sonawane [(2015)
14 SCC 272] has unequivocally held as follows:
“9. It was in the above backdrop that the High Court
held that once the respondents had been acquitted for
the offence punishable under the IPC and Arms Act in
Crimes No. 37 and 38 of 2001 and once the Trial Court
had recorded an acquittal even for the offence
punishable under Section 4 read with Section 25 of
the Arms Act in MCOCA Crimes No. 1 and 2 of 2002 all
that remained incriminating was the filing of charge
sheets against the respondents in the past and taking
of cognizance by the competent court over a period of
ten years prior to the enforcement of the MCOCA. The
filing of charge sheets or taking of the cognisance in
the same did not, declared the High Court, by itself
constitute an offence punishable under Section 3 of the
MCOCA. That is because the involvement of
respondents in previous offences was just about one
requirement, but by no means the only requirement,
which the prosecution has to satisfy to secure a
conviction under MCOCA. What was equally, if not more
important, was the commission of an offence by the
respondents that would constitute “continuing unlawful
activity”. So long as that requirement failed, as was the
position in the instant case, there was no question of
convicting the respondents under Section 3 of the MCOCA.
That reasoning does not, in our opinion, suffer from any
infirmity.
10. The very fact that more than one charge sheet had
been filed against the respondents, alleging offences
punishable with more than three years' imprisonment,
is not enough. As rightly pointed out by the High Court,
commission of offences before the enactment of MCOCA
does not constitute an offence under MCOCA. Registration
of cases, filing of charge sheets and taking of cognisance by
the competent court in relation to the offence alleged to
2026:HHC:3356
have been committed by the respondents in the past is but
one of the requirements for invocation of Section 3 of the
MCOCA. Continuation of unlawful activities is the second
and equally important requirement that ought to be
satisfied. Only if an organised crime is committed by the
accused after the promulgation of MCOCA, he may, seen in
the light of the previous charge sheets and the cognisance
taken by the competent court, be said to have committed
an offence under Section 3 of the Act.
11. In the case at hand, the offences which the
respondents are alleged to have committed after the
promulgation of MCOCA were not proved against them.
The acquittal of the respondents in Crimes Nos. 37 and
38 of 2001 signified that they were not involved in the
commission of the offences with which they were
charged. Not only were the respondents were acquitted
of the charge under the Arms Act, but they were also
acquitted in Crimes Case Nos. 1 and 2 of 2002. No
appeal against that acquittal had been filed by the
State. This implied that the prosecution had failed to
prove the second ingredient required for completion of
an offence under MCOCA. The High Court was, therefore,
right in holding that Section 3 of the MCOCA could not be
invoked only on the basis of the previous charge sheets for
Section 3 would come into play only if the respondents
were proved to have committed an offence for gain or any
pecuniary benefit or undue economic or other advantage
after the promulgation of MCOCA. Such being the case,
the High Court was, in our opinion, justified in
allowing the appeal and setting aside the order passed
by the Trial Court”.
14. Subsequently, the Honourable Supreme Court in State
of Gujarat v. Sandip Omprakash Gupta [2022 SCC OnLine SC
1727], while interpreting the analogous provisions of the
Gujarat Control of Terrorism and Organised Crime Act,
2015, clarified the ratio in Shivaji alias Shivaji Ramaji
Sonawane (supra) by observing thus:
2026:HHC:3356
“52. It is a sound rule of construction that the
substantive law should be construed strictly so as to
give effect and protection to the substantive rights
unless the statute otherwise intends. Strict
construction is one that limits the application of the
statute by the words used. According to Sutherland,
‘strict construction refuses to extend the import of
words used in a statute so as to embrace cases or acts
which the words do not clearly describe’.
53. The rule as stated by Mahajan C.J. in Tolaram
Relumal v. State of Bombay, (1954) 1 SCC 961: AIR 1954 SC
496, is that “if two possible and reasonable
constructions can be put upon a penal provision, the
court must lean towards that construction which
exempts the subject from penalty rather than the one
which imposes a penalty. It is not competent to the
court to stretch the meaning of an expression used by
the legislature in order to carry out the intention of the
legislature.”
In State
of
Jharkhand v. Ambay
Cements, (2005) 1 SCC 368, this Court held that it is a
settled rule of interpretation that where a statute is
penal in character, it must be strictly construed and
followed. The basic rule of strict construction of a penal
statute is that a person cannot be penalised without a
clear reading of the law. Presumptions or assumptions
have no role in the interpretation of penal statutes.
They are to be construed strictly in accordance with the
provisions of law. Nothing can be implied. In such
cases, the courts are not so much concerned with what
might possibly have been intended. Instead, they are
concerned with what has actually been said.
54. We are of the view and the same would be in tune with
the dictum as laid in Shiva alias Shivaji Ramaji
Sonawane (supra) that there would have to be some act or
omission which amounts to organised crime after the 2015
Act came into force i.e., 01.12.2019 in respect of which, the
2026:HHC:3356
accused is sought to be tried for the first time in the special
court.
55. We are in agreement with the view taken by the
High Court of Judicature at Bombay in the case
of Jaisingh (supra) that neither the definition of the
term ‘organised crime’ nor of the term ‘continuing
unlawful activity’ nor any other provision therein
declares any activity performed prior to the enactment
of the MCOCA to be an offence under the 1999 Act nor
the provision relating to punishment relates to any
offence prior to the date of enforcement of the 1999
Act, i.e., 24.02.1999. However, by referring to the
expression ‘preceding period of ten years' in Section 2(1)
(d), which is a definition clause of the term ‘continuing
unlawful activity’ inference is sought to be drawn that in
fact, it takes into its ambit the acts done prior to the
enforcement of the 1999 Act as being an offence under the
1999 Act. The same analogy will apply to the 2015 Act.
56. There is a vast difference between the act or
activity, which is being termed or called an offence
under a statute and such act or activity being taken into
consideration as one of the requisites for taking action
under the statute. For the purpose of organised crime,
there has to be a continuing unlawful activity. There
cannot be continuing unlawful activity unless at least
two charge sheets are found to have been lodged in
relation to the offence punishable with three years'
imprisonment during the period of ten years.
Indisputably, the period of ten years may relate to the
period prior to 01.12.2019 or thereafter. In other words,
it provides that the activities, which were offences
under the law in force at the relevant time and in
respect of which two charge sheets have been filed and
the Court has taken cognisance thereof, during the
period of the preceding ten years, then it will be
considered as continuing unlawful activity on
01.12.2019 or thereafter. It nowhere by itself declares
2026:HHC:3356
any activity to be an offence under the said 2015 Act
prior to 01.12.2019. It also does not convert any activity
done prior to 01.12.2019 to be an offence under the said
2015 Act. It merely considers two charge sheets in
relation to the acts which were already declared as
offences under the law in force to be one of the
requisites for the purpose of identifying continuing
unlawful activity and/or for the purpose of an action
under the said 2015 Act.
57. If the decision of the coordinate Bench of this Court
in
the
case
of Shiva
alias
Shivaji
Ramaji
Sonawane (supra) is looked into closely along with
other provisions of the Act, the same would indicate
that the offence of ‘organised crime’ could be said to
have been constituted by at least one instance of
continuation, apart from continuing unlawful activity
evidenced by more than one chargesheets in the
preceding ten years. We say so, keeping in mind the
following:
(a) If ‘organised crime’ was synonymous with
‘continuing unlawful activity’, two separate
definitions were not necessary.
(b) The definitions themselves indicate that the
ingredients of the use of violence in such activity
with the objective of gaining pecuniary benefit
are not included in the definition of ‘continuing
unlawful activity’, but find place only in the
definition of ‘organised crime’.
(c) What is made punishable under Section 3 is
‘organised crime’ and not ‘continuing unlawful
activity’.
(d) If ‘organised crime’ were to refer to only
more than one chargesheets filed, the
classification of crime in Section 3(1)(i) and 3(1)
(ii) resply on the basis of consequence of
resulting in death or otherwise would have been
2026:HHC:3356
phrased differently, namely, by providing that ‘if
any one of such offence has resulted in the
death’, since continuing unlawful activity
requires more than one offence. Reference to
‘such offence’ in Section 3(1) implies a specific
act or omission.
(e) As held by this Court in State of
Maharashtra v. Bharat Shanti Lal Shah (supra)
continuing unlawful activity evidenced by more
than one chargesheets is one of the ingredients
of the offence of organised crime and the
purpose thereof is to see the antecedents and not
to convict, without proof of other facts which
constitute the ingredients of Section 2(1)(e) and
Section 3, which respectively define commission
of offence of organised crime and prescribe
punishment.
(f) There would have to be some act or omission
which amounts to organised crime after the Act
came into force, in respect of which the accused
is sought to be tried for the first time, in the
Special Court (i.e. has not been or is not being
tried elsewhere).
(g) However, we need to clarify something
important.
Shiva
alias
Shivaji
Ramaji
Sonawane (supra) dealt with the situation where a
person commits no unlawful activity after the
invocation of the MCOCA. In such circumstances, the
person cannot be arrested under the said Act on
account of the offences committed by him before the
coming into force of the said Act, even if he is found
guilty of the same. However, if the person continues
with the unlawful activities and is arrested, after the
promulgation of the said Act, then such a person can
be tried for the offence under the said Act. If a person
ceases to indulge in any unlawful act after the said
Act, then he is absolved of the prosecution under the
2026:HHC:3356
said Act. But, if he continues with the unlawful
activity, it cannot be said that the State has to wait
till he commits two acts of which cognisance is taken
by the Court after coming into force. The same
principle would apply, even in the case of the 2015
Act, with which we are concerned.
58. In the overall view of the matter, we are convinced
that the dictum as laid by this Court in Shiva alias
Shivaji Ramaji Sonawane(supra) does not require any
relook. The dictum in Shiva alias Shivaji Ramaji
Sonawane (supra) is the correct exposition of law”.
16. Section 111 (1) of the BNS in respect of organised crime
is, in essence, analogous to the provisions of the
Maharashtra Control of Organised Control Act and the
Gujarat Control of Terrorism and Organised Crime Act.
The legal principles laid down by the Honourable Supreme
Court in its interpretation of organised crime as defined by
the above two state legislations are applicable on all fours
to Section 111 (1) of the BNS. Thus, it is not necessary to
have a further interpretation of the above analogous
provision.
17. In view of the above discussion, to attract an offence
under Section 111 (1) of the BNS it is imperative that a
group of two or more persons indulge in any continuing
unlawful activity prohibited by law, which is a cognizable
offence punishable with imprisonment of three years or
more, undertaken by any person, either singly or jointly,
as a member of an organised crime syndicate or on behalf
of such syndicate in respect of which more than one
charge-sheet has to be filed before a competent Court
within the preceding period of ten years and that Court
has taken cognizance of such an offence.
18. In the present case, it is undisputed that no charge
sheet has been filed against the petitioner in any court in
the last ten years. Therefore, prima facie, the offence
under Section 111(1) is not attracted. Nevertheless, these
are matters to be investigated and ultimately decided after
2026:HHC:3356
trial. Additionally, the petitioner has been in judicial
custody for the last 57 days, and recovery has been
effected.
16.
This judgment was followed in Pesala Sivashankar
Reddy v. State of A.P., 2024 SCC OnLine AP 5422, wherein it was
held:
“8. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of State of
Maharashtra v. Shiva Alias Shivaji Ramaji Sonawane 2015
SCC OnLine SC 648 was dealing with the Maharashtra
Control of Organised Crime Act, 1999 (MCOC) Act and the
offence of organised crime under the said act. The Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held that only if an organised crime is
committed by the accused after the promulgation of the
MCOCA Act, that he may be seen in the light of the
previous charge sheet, which is taken cognisance by the
competent court, would have committed an offence under
Section 3 of the Act.
9. The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the matter of Mohamad
Iliyas Mohamad Bilal Kapadiya v. State of Gujarat 2022 Live
Law (SC) 538, held that to invoke the provisions of the
Gujarat Control of terrorism and Organised Act Crime,
2015, in respect of an act of organised crime, more than
one charge sheet should be filed in the preceding ten
years. Section 111 of B.N.S. is analogous to the organised
crime acts of various states, which were dealt with by the
Hon'ble Supreme Court.
10. The Hon'ble High Court of Kerala in the matter
of Mohammed Hashim v. State of Kerala 2024 SCC OnLine
Ker 5260. The learned Judge of the Kerala High Court has
emphasised that Section 111 can be invoked only if more
than one charge sheet has been filed for such offences in
the preceding ten years before a competent court, and
such charge sheets are taken cognisance of by the court.
2026:HHC:3356
11. This Court agrees with the observations of the Kerala
High Court, and admittedly, no charge sheet has been filed
against the petitioner for similar offences in any court of
law in the preceding ten years; as such, a cause for
invocation of Section 111 of B.N.S. has to be dealt
appropriately by the investigating officer during the
course of investigation of the crime.”
17.
It was held in Suraj Singh vs. State of Punjab
(25.09.2024 - PHHC): MANU/PH/4288/2024 that the police must
gather legally admissible evidence to connect the accused with
the commission of a crime punishable under Section 111 of the
BNS Act. It was observed:
“15. To bring an offence into the four corners of an
organised crime, the offence must fall under a category
described in S. 111 of BNS, 2023. The prima facie evidence
must be legally admissible to constitute any continuing
unlawful activity to constitute an organised crime as
defined in S. 111 BNS. Without legally admissible prima
facie evidence, the State cannot make any suspect undergo
custodial interrogation to hunt for such evidence against
the suspect or others. The evidence must be gathered first
to make out a prima facie case within the scope of S. 111 of
BNS, and such evidence alone would justify custodial
interrogation to carry out further investigation. Without
legally admissible accusations, allegations, or evidence,
the State cannot arrest a suspect to fish evidence against
them or use such a suspect as custodial bait by any hook,
line, and sinker to bring the case into the fold of S. 111 of
BNS. Prima facie evidence must be admissible, and if such
evidence is deemed inadmissible, the entire foundation
will collapse.”
2026:HHC:3356
18.
In the present case, the only allegation of the
petitioner indulging in organised crime is based upon the fact
that he and other co-accused had threatened the informant and
another person for ransom, which, as stated above, is highly
doubtful because of the absence of any such allegation in the FIR.
The status report also does not show that the petitioner was part
of a syndicate against which cognisance was taken in the
preceding ten years. Therefore, the material on record does not,
prima facie, connect the petitioner to the commission of a crime
punishable under Section 111 of BNS.
19.
The other offences alleged against the petitioner are
not so serious as to justify his pre-trial detention. The police
have already filed the charge sheet before the Court, and the
petitioner’s custody is not required for investigation.
20.
The police asserted that the petitioner would indulge
in the commission of a similar offence and would intimidate the
witnesses in case of release on bail. These apprehensions are
without any basis and can be removed by imposing the
conditions. Therefore, this apprehension is not sufficient to deny
bail to the petitioner.
2026:HHC:3356
21.
It was submitted that the petitioner has criminal
antecedents and he should not be released on bail. The Learned
Trial Court was also influenced by this consideration while
denying bail. Mere criminal antecedents without the, prima facie,
involvement of the petitioner in the commission of a heinous
offence are not sufficient to deny bail to him. Since, prima facie,
involvement of the petitioner in any heinous offence is not
established in the present case. Therefore, the bail cannot be
denied to the petitioner on the ground that he has criminal
antecedents.
22.
The police have not asserted that the petitioner had
absented in the previous cases; rather the police reported that
the petitioner was acquitted in some of the cases registered
against him, which means that the petitioner had faced the trial,
and there is no material to conclude at this stage that the
petitioner would not attend the trial if released on bail.
23.
In view of the above, the present petition is allowed,
and the petitioner is ordered to be released on bail subject to his
furnishing bail bonds in the sum of ₹1,00,000/- with one surety
in the like amount to the satisfaction of the learned Trial Court.
2026:HHC:3356
While on bail, the petitioner will abide by the following
conditions:
(i)
The petitioner will not intimidate the witnesses, nor will
he influence any evidence in any manner whatsoever.
(ii)
The petitioner shall attend the trial and will not seek
unnecessary adjournments.
(iii)
The petitioner will not leave the present address for a
continuous period of seven days without furnishing the
address of the intended visit to the concerned Police
Station and the Court.
(iv)
The petitioner will furnish his mobile number and social
media contact to the Police and the Court and will abide by
the summons/notices received from the Police/Court
through SMS/WhatsApp/Social Media Account. In case of
any change in the mobile number or social media
accounts, the same will be intimated to the Police/Court
within five days from the date of the change.
24.
It is expressly made clear that in case of violation of
any of these conditions, the prosecution will have the right to file
a petition for cancellation of the bail.
25.
The petition stands accordingly disposed of. A copy of
this order be sent to the Superintendent of District Jail, Una at
Bangarh, H.P., and the learned Trial Court by FASTER.
2026:HHC:3356
26.
The observations made hereinabove are regarding the
disposal of this petition and will have no bearing whatsoever on
the case's merits.
23rd January, 2026
(Nikita)
(Rakesh Kainthla)
Vacation Judge
signed by
CHANDER SHEKHAR
CHANDER Digitally
Date: 2026.01.23
SHEKHAR 16:53:46 +0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review