Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Specia! Original Jurisdiction)
[ 3300 I
WEDNESDAY,THE TWENTY FIFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO: 34084 OF 2024
Between
1. AMR INDIA LTD., Saikrupa, D. No.8-3-833, Plot No.37 and 38, Phase-|,
Kamalapuri Colony, Hyderabad - 500073 (Through its Authorised
Representative, A. It/ahesh Kumar Reddy)
2. A. TUAHESH KUtvlAR REDDY, aged around 58, s/o Sh. Adinarayana Reddy,
. Occupation. Business Saikrupa, D.No. 8-3-833, Plot No. 37 and 38, Phase-|,
Kamalapuri Colony, Hyderabad - 500073
t
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. RESERVE BANK OF lNDlA, 6-1-56, Secretariat Road, National Highway 65,
Saifabad, Khairatabad, Hyderabad - 500 004 Telangana, lndia Also, at.
Central Office Building, Shahid Bhagat Singh Marg, Fort, Mumbai - 400001,
Maharashtra
2. BANK OF BARODA, Mid Corporate Branch, 3-6-26212, Tirumala Estates, I St
Floor, Himayatnagar, Hyderabad - 500 029 Also at. Baroda House, [Vlandvi,
Baroda, Gujarat - 390001
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to pass an order or orders or writ one more particularly in the nature of a
Writ of Mandamus, declaring the action of Respondent No. 2 Bank in initiating
and conducting steps against and/or classifying the Petitioner No. 1s Cash Credit
Account No. 25210500000043 as Non-Performing Asset (NPA) with retrospective
effect from 30.09.2024, communicated vide Email dt. 21.10.2024 and the
subsequent action of freezing the said account as illegal, arbitrary, and
unconstitutional and for being in contravention of the Master Direction - Reserve
Bank of lndia (Transfer of Loan Exposures) Directions, 2021 dt. 24.09.2021
bearing No. RB!/DOR/2021-22186 DOR.STR.REC.51 121.04.04812021-22 and
Master Circular on lncome Recognition, Asset Classification, Provisioning and
a,
Other Relatr:d Matters- UCB dt. o2.o4.2o24 bearing no. RBU2024-2s113
DOR.STR.RE:C.9/ 21.04.04812024-25 issued by Respondent No. 1 and set aside
lA NO: 1 OF 11024
Petitiorr under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend/ keep in abeyance the impugned classification of the Petitioner No. 1's
Cash Credit ,Account No. 25210500000043 as Non-Performing Asset ('NpA")
with effect frc,m 30.09.2024, communicated vide Email dt. 21 .10.2024 and the
subsequent action of freezing the said account pending disposal of the writ
petition
lA NO: 2 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased For
the reasons mr:ntioned in the present affidavit along with the material on record
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRl. BENDI RAVTTEJA
Counsel for thre Respondent No.2: SRI SRINIVAS CHITTURU, SC
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: The Court made the following: ORDER
I
a
i
)
!
'
ry
1,1
TN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
WRIT PETITION No. 34084 OF 2o24
25..O2.20/26
Between:
AMR lndia Ltd.,
(Through its Authofized Representative
A. Mahesh Kumar Reddy) & another
..... Petitioners
And
Reserve Bank of tndia & another
.. Respondents
ORDER:
The case of petitioners is that Petitioner No. t has
been maintaining a Cash Credit Account No. 2521O5OO0OOO43
with Respondent No. 2 bank for the last ten years, with a limit
of Rs. 2096 crores, and in addition thereto, they had also
availed a Bank Guarantee facility from Respondent No. 2 for an
amount of Rs. 8 crores. The said Cash Credit Account has been
periodically reviewed and renewed in accordance with the RBI
guidelines and the existing credit facilities were extended up to
28.04.2025 uide sanction letter dated 15.05.2024. The said CC
Account maintained with Respondent No. 2 Bank is utilised by
Petitioner No. 1 for the purpose of meeting out its regular
businer;s expenses; as such, the same is essentiat and vital for
the continued functioning of Petitioners' business.
1.1.
Petitioner No. t has been maintaining the said CC
Account without any default and within the sanctioned limits
for mo:^e than one year and the same is evident from the
accounl- statement of Petitioner No. 1 with Respondent No. 2
Bank fcr the period october, 2023 to october, 2024. petitioner
has not committed default including clause 2 of RBI Master
circular on Prudential Norms. Unrelated to the above Account
Petitionr:r No. t had executed a Master Lease Agreement dated
24.O3.2OL7 with SREI Equipment Finance Limited (,SREI',),
wherein SREI would lease out construction equipment to
petitione,r No. 1 pursuant to which separate Rental Schedules
were to be executed from time to time in respect of equipment
supplied under Master Lease Agreement.
1.2.
It is stated, between 2OLZ and 2T .OZ .2022,
Petitioner No. 1 addressed several letters to sREI highlighting
the poor quality of the leased equipment and seeking repair /
replacement thereof, while also informing SREI that its
construct-ion activities were being adversely affected due to the
supply of the sub-standard and non-functional equipment,
resulting in substantial financial losses to petitioner. sREI, on
the other hand, alleged that Petitioner No. t had defaulted in
€1J
rental payments- Despite the poor quality of the leased
making
equipment supplied by SREI, Petitioner No' 1 continued
periodical payments to SREI in respect of the various
lease
accounts maintained with it up to March, 2021' As such'
there
wasnooccasionforclassificationofanyoftheaccountsof
Petitioner No. 1 with SREI as NPA in 2O2O'
1.3.
Subsequently, an Arbitral Tribunal comprising
Hon,bre Justice Indira Banerjee (presiding Arbitrator),
Hon'ble
Justice Pranab Kumar chattopadhyay (co-Arbitrator)
Hon'ble Justice shyamlal Kanti chakrabarti
of
and
(co-Arbitrator) was
constitutedtoadjudicatethedisputesunderthesaidMaster
Lease Agreement and SREI fited a claim against
Petitioner No' 1
for Rs. 586,03,7 1,397f -, alleging default in payment of
schedules
rentals in respect of assets detailed under 27 tental
lease
includingthefourschedulesreferredtobyRespondentNo.2
said Arbitral
bank in their imPugned e mails' Further, in the
Proceedings, Petitioner No' 1
filed a counter claim for
Rs. 739,40,00,OOO/- towards lease rentals paid
for damaged /
scrapped equipment, expenses incurred for equipment
purchasedtoreplaceunworkableandirreparableequipment
and loss of profits. The said proceedings before Arbitral
are pending and the matter is presently reserved for
the award
Tribunal
passing of
.t
While the matter stood thus, on 21.LO.2O24,
L.4.
Respondent No. 2 addressed e mail to Petitioner No.1, declaring
Petitioner's Lease Loan Account No. 136532 as an NpA and the
same has been purchased by the respondent bank. The
contenl-s of e mail are as under:
"
Company's account rvith our bank has matched with list of
accounts purchased from (M/s SREI Equipment Financial Ltd.) under
'commorL PAN'. Since your company account (account no 136532) turned
NPA wittr the NBFCs, our bank also supposed to mark these accounts as
NPA w.e.i. 30.09.20 under 'common PAN identifier' account."
[) Simultaneously, Petitioner No. l's cc Account was frozen and
Since Petitioner No. I had no idea as to how Respondent No. 2 Bank was
concerne<l with the rental agreement between Petitioner No. 1 and SREI, the
Petitioner No. 1 personnel immediately contacted the officials of Respondent
No. 2, wtro in turn for the lirst time informed to the petitioner No. 1, that
SREI had sold/ assigned the lease receivables in relation with Account No.
136532 tc,Respondent No. 2.
(k) Petitioner No. t had not received an-v notice of such assignment,
contrary t: the terms of the Master Lease Agreement. Therefore, immediately
after receiving the said email, Petitioner No. 1 addressed a letter dt.
2l.Lo.2o2+ to Respondent No. 2 informing that it had no knowledge of any
such sale or assignment and bringing forth the fact that arbitral proceeding
between tt.e parties are pending.
(l) rhree days later, on 24.ro.2o24, Respondent No. 2 addressed
another er:ail increasing the list of NPAs and mentioning three new ,,loan
accounts in addition to Account No. 136532 mentioned in email dt.
2l.Lo.2o2z.. References were made to contract Nos. 136574, 142331 and
142341. Irr the said email, it is noted that the four loan accounts were
declared NPAs on o4.o8.2o2o b}'SREI. It is pertinent to reiterate that the
Responden:s did not intimate Petitioner No. I about any such declaration for
over four y(:ars.
,
(m) rln 01.11.2024, Petitioner No. 1 objected the said action and
requested F:espondent No. 2 to upgrade the account with immediate effect.
\;
Further, another email dated 04.11.2024 was sent enclosing invoices and
clarifying that the SREI was merely an operational'creditor.
(n) On 26.11.2024, Petitioner No. 1 received another email from
Respondent No. 2 referring to the four "loan accounts" and indicating the
total principal outstanding amount in relation with the four Rental
Schedules as on O4.O8.2O22 to be a total of Rs. 9,54,02,1 18/-(o) on 27.11-2024, the Respondent No.2 addressed an email to
Petitioner No. 1 stating as follows:
"It is to inform you that the company has availed the following Credit
facilities from our branch, Cash Credit: Rs 20.96 Crores; BG Limits: 8.00
Crores. Though the conduct of the above mentioned facilities of the company
is satisfactory, due to status Company's accounts with M/s SREI Equipment
Finance Limited which were part of the pool purchased by our bank from
M/s SREI Equipment Finance Limited & as per the instructions of the
Statutory nuaitors, M/s AMR India Limited credit facilities mentioned above
were downgraded (NPA) on common PAN basis. However, company has
informed that the Issue with M/s SREI finance Limited is under dispute and
currently matter is under Arbitration, company has submitted relevant
informaiion along with the request to upgrade the account. Further
company's request is under process with our higher authorities'"
(p) tt is thus evident that the Petitioners were kept completely
uninformed about the alleged assignment and NPA classification for more
than four years, and were apprised of the same only after their CC account
was suddenly frozen in October 2024(q) Aggrieved by the impugned actions of the Respondent No' 2, and
challenging the impugned communication dated 21.1O.2024, the Petitioners
had approached this Court by filing the present Writ Petition'
1.5.
It is stated, three days later, on 24.1O'2024,
Respondent No.2 addressed another e mail increasing the list of
NPAs and mentioning three new loan accounts in addition to
Account No. 136532 mentioned in e mail dated 2L.LO.2O24; the
four loan accounts were declared NPAs on 04.08.2020. on
L.LL.2O24, petitioner No.l objected to the same and requested
Respondent No.2 to upgrade the account with immediate effect.
,
Another e mail was sent on 04. tl.2o24 providing copies of
invoice,s and clarifying that SREI was merely an operational
creditol-. Petitioner No.1 received another e mail from
Respondent No.2 referring to the four loan accounts and
indicating the total principal outstanding amount in relation
with the four Rental Schedules as on 04.O8 .2022 to be a total of
Rs.9,54,02,1181-. It is further stated, on
27 'll'2o24,
Respondent No.2 addressed e mail to petitioner No.l stating
that the conduct of the facilities of petitioner No.1 company
were s:rtisfactory and the status of the credit facilities was
downgraded to NPA due to the status of company's accounts
with sR:EI and as per the instructions of statutory auditors.
1.6.
It is further stated, petitioners till date have not
been informed about any assignment of lease receivables from
SREI t6 Respondent No.2. In case any such assignment was
undertaken, SREI was bound to inform petitioner No.l of the
same at; per Clause 16 of the Master Lease Agreement. In fact,
Responrlent No.2 bank also never raised any invoices I
ta><
invoices on petitioner No.l and as such there is no liability of
petition,:r No.1 to Respondent No.2. In the absence of any such
notice, oetitioner No.1 continued making payments to SREI in
compliance with the Agreement. According to petitioner, the
purportr:d declaration of certain assets as NPA on 04.O8.2O2O
I
canonlybepremisedonfailureofsREltomakepaymentsto
RespondentNo.2bankaspertheirinterseagreement;
petitioner No- 1 is neither party nor privy to any
such agreement
and has not received any notice thereof. Therefore,
petitioner
No.1 account cannot be declared as NPA'
1.7.
Respondent No'2 has categorically admitted
that
the bank had an ongoing and satisfactory credit
relationship
with petitioner No.1, therefore, as per its own record
of recovery'
there was no reason for Respondent bank to
declare petitioner
No.l account as NPA since no amount was overdue
for more
thang0daysasrequiredbytheMasterCircularonlncome
Recognition,AssetClassificationProvisioningandotherRelated
Matters-UCB,datedo2.o4.2o24.Furthermore,theactionof
RespondentNo.2from2l'lO'2O24onwards'beingbasedona
on
purported declaration of four loan accounts as NPA
o4.os.2o2oisbarredbylimitation.Themalafidesof
Respondent No.2 are evident from the said delay'
1.8.
tt is also stated, in this regard' Respondent No'1
issued.MasterDirective_ReserveBankoflndia(Transferof
for the
Exposures) Directions, 2O2l' dated 24'09'2021
Loan
purpose of laying down a comprehensive' self-contained
set of
regulatoryguidelinesgoverningtransferofloanexposures'
for
when loan transfers are resorted to by lending institutions
multitude of reasons rangirig from liquidity management,
rebal.ncing their exposures or strategic sales. chapter [v,
clause 66 of the said RBI Master Direction expricitly mandates
that rvhere the transferee institution already has an existing
exposr-lre to the borrower, the classification of the acquired
exposure shall align with the classification of the transferee,s
existing exposure.
1.9.
The Hon'ble supreme court in pro Knits a. Board.
of Directors of canara Bankl held that such directions
/
circulars issued by Respondent No.l have statutory force and
a.re m€:ndatory; non-compliance with the same would
render
action of a bank illegal. According to petitioner, the arbitrary
classifir:ation of cash credit Account as NpA has caused
irrepare-ble harm to the business operations and linancial
health c,f petitioners.
2'
The facts as pleaded by Respondent No. r, in its
counter-affidavit, in brief, are as follorvs:
In exercise of po\ryers conferred uncler Section 21
read with section 3sA of the Banking Regulation Act, !g4g,
Respondent No. 1 issued various directives and guidelines
includingl interest rate directives and guidelines to banks from
time-to-time regulating payment of interest chargeable on loans
'2o2qsccch tine sc 1864
\
and advances granted by banks to borrowers and payment of
interest on deposits. Respondent No. 1 issued instructions uid.e
RBI Master circular (Prudential Norms on Income Recognition,
Asset classilication and Provisioning pertaining to Advances)
dated April 02, 2024 and Master Direction Reserve Bank of
India (Transfer of Loan Exposures) Directions, 2o2L dated
september 24, 2o2r, to the banks in exercise of its powers
under the provisions of Banking Regulation Act, lg4g. As the
action of Respondent No. 2 is under challenge, it is for the said
Respondent to substantiate and justify their action. No
contentions have been made against RBI, hence, they do not
call for any reply from this respondent for want of knowledge.
2.r.
It is stated, RBI issued instructions to the banks in
exercise of its power under the provisions of the Banking
Regulation Act, 1949. As the action of Respondent No.2 is under
challenge, it will be for that Respondent to substantiate their
action. Petitioner has failed to pima facie demonstrate any
cause of action or violation of any of his fundamental or legal
right by this respondent, hence, the writ petition as against the
respondent is devoid of merits.
3.
The facts as pleaded by Respondent No. 2 Bank in
their Counter Affidavit, in brief, are as follows:
\
IU
Respondent No. 2 had lawfully acquired petitioners,
loan accounts from SREI Infrastructure Finance Limited under
a Pool Purchase Agreement/Direct Assignment (DA) transaction,
and since those accounts were already classified as NpA by
SREI, ':he Bank was mandated under RBI guidelines to classify
the erLtire borrower exposure as NpA. It is stated that
Respondent No. 2 acquired r4s3 loans amounting to
Rs. 2,',767.54 crores from M/s SREI Infrastructure Finance
Limited as standard assets under a pool purchase Agreement,
which included four accounts of petitioners, ,*,hich were
subsequently classified as NPA by SREI.
3.1.
Reliance has been placed on clause 4.2.T of the RBI
Master circular on Prudential Norms to contend that asset
classification is
borrower-centric, requiring uniform
classification of all facilities of a borrower. Accordingly. upon
receipt of payout reports from SREI, Respondent No. 2 classified
Petitionr:r No. l's accounts as NpA, including its direct lending
accountl;.
3.2.
It is further contended that RBI guidelines do not
mandate prior borrower notification in DA transactions and that
statutory auditors have validated the classification. Upon
receiving the payout reports from SREI, the Bank classified
AMryp assigned account as NpA in compliance with RBI
ll
(
prudential norms and consequently, all related accounts of the
borrower, including direct lending accounts, were also
downgraded. It was further contended that Direct Assignment
(DA) framework requires the Bank (assignee) to independently
classiff the asset based on its records and by applying
prudential norms, not merely on the assignor's classification.
The Bank classified AMR's accounts in its pool books as NPA
with effect from August 4, 2O2O, based on the payout reports
received from SREI. The subsequent action in 2024 was merely
the alignment of AMR's asset classification in the Bank's direct
lending books with the NPA status already reflected in its pool
books. It is contended that any delay in such alignment does
not imply any error on the part of the Bank nor does it create
any right or equity in favour of Petitioner.
3.3.
The facility documents between SREI and AMR
India Ltd. explicitly include a clause allowing SREI to assign the
accounts. Therefore, prior consent from AMR India Ltd. was not
required at the time of assignment.
4.
Heard learned senior counsel Sri Y.V. Ravi Prasad
assisted by Sri Qazi Salar Masood Aatif, learned counsel for
petitioners, M/s N. Legal, learned counsel for Respondent No.1
and sri B. Narasinga Rao, learned Standing counsel for
Respondent No.2.
\
t2
5.
Learned Senior counsel contends that till date,
Petitic,ners have not been informed of any assignment of lease
receiviebles from SREI to Respondent No. 2 bank. In case any
such rrssignment was undertaken, sREI was bound to inform
Petitioner No. 1 of the same as per clause 16 of the Master
Lease Agreement. Further, any assignment affected without
compliance with the said clause is incomplete, and
unenforceable. It is argued that clause 2.s.g of the RBI
Guidelines on Securitization Transactions dated oz.os.2ol2
mandai-es that transfer of assets from selling bank must not
contravene the terms and conditions of any underlying
agreem(tnt governing the assets and all necessary consents from
obligors (including from third parties, where necessary) should
have br-'en obtained. Accordingly, Respondent No. 2 Bank
without applying mind, had mechanically adopted sREI's NpA
classific:rtion without issuing any prior notice to petitioners,
solely b:rsed on the advice of its statutory auditors, in clear
violation of the said Guidelines. Further, it was contended that
contractual and regulatory regimes converge on the same
fundamental requirement that no transfer or assignment can
operate to the prejudice of the obligor behind its back without
due notice.
l3
t
Learned senior counsel further contended that
6.
reliance on Clause 4.2.7 of the RBI Master Circular on
Prudential Norms dated O1.O7.2O15 (latest as applicable is
O2.O4.2O24) is wholly misplaced, as borrower-wise classification
applies only within the same bank and cannot justify the
importation of SREI's asset classification into Respondent No.
2's books. Further contended that, in the absence of a
completed and notilied assignment, Respondent No. 2 had no
privity of contract with respect to SREI receivables. Alternatively
it was submitted that even assuming the assignment to be
complete, Clauses 65 and 66 of the RBI Master Direction on
Transfer of Loan Exposures dated 24.09.2021 require that
acquired exposures assume the Same classification aS the
borrower's existing exposure with the transferee bank, and
thereafter be classilied solely based on the transferee's own
record of recovery. Further it was also contended that the
Master Circular 2024 is applicable only to the transactions
among schedule commercial banks and not to the transactions
involving to Non- Banking Financial companies.
Learned Senior Counsel also "rb*itttd that
7.
Petitioners'Cash Credit Account was a Standard Asset as on the
date of acquisition, if &DY, and the precise date of such
acquisition has neither been disclosed by Respondent No. 2-
\
-\i
I
I
I
I
1- ,,',,..;
:.,.;ir,.l-,i'',.1
\
t4
Bank nor is known to petitioners. It was pointed out that
Respo:edent No. 2 has expressly admitted that loans acquired
from siREI were standard at the time of acquisition. In these
circurrrstances, it is contended that Respondent. No.2 could not
have r'ltrospectively imported sREI's prior NpA classilication or
adjustt:d its own books on the basis of a third part5r's asset
classification, and that the impugned downgrading and freezing
of Petil.ioners' cash credit Account is contrary to clauses 65
and 66 of the RBI Master Directions, ultra uires the RBI
regulatory framework, violative of prudential norms and liable to
be set rtside. It was also submitted that cash credit Account of
the l"t petitioner was being regurarly renewed by the 2nd
respondent every year, even after the alleged acquisition of SREI
accounts said to have been declared NpAs on o4.og.2o2o. It is
further submitted that the 2nd respondent is one of the
consortium banks of the lst petitioner company and that in the
two con:;ortium meetings held on 20.12.2023 and 2g.o3.2o24,
the issue with regard to lease payments of sREI Equipments
had come up for discussion and that all the consortium banks,
including; the 2"d respondent bank, were apprised by the l"t
petitione:: company of the reference of the dispute between SREI
Equipments and petitioner to the Arbitral Tribunal, and that the
matter is sub judice before the said Tribunal. It was contended
l5
that the 2"d respondent bank, despite being fully aware that the
claims of SREI Equipments, including the four lease accounts
mentioned in the impugned e mails, were in dispute and
pending before the Arbitral Tribunal headed by Hon'ble Justice
lndira Banerjee, would not have purchased the said lease
accounts. Further, the 2"d respondent never put petitioners on
notice regarding the said assignment, nor demanded for
payment of lease rentals said to be due under the said four
lease accounts. Further, it is strangely stated in the counter
affidavit of the 2.d respondent that the bank classilied Petitioner
Accounts as NPA on 04.08.2020, but the impugned e mail is
only an intimation in 2024.
8.
Learned counsel for Respondent No. I contended
that Respondent No. t has been impleaded only as a formal
party in its capacity as the regulator of the banking sector and
that no substantive relief has been sought against it in the
present Writ Petition. It was therefore, submitted that Writ
Petition, insofar as it concerns Respondent No. 1, is liable to be
dismissed, and that the merits of the case, including
justification for the impugned actions, are to be answered by
Respondent No. 2 Bank.
t6
9.
Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 vehemently
opposeC the contentions made by Petitioners and contented that
the Bank lawfully acquired Petitioners' four loan accounts from
SREI Infrastructure Finance Limited under a Pool Purchase /
Direct Assignment transaction and, based on payout reports
receivecl from SREI, classified those accounts as NpA in
accordance with RBI prudential norms. Relying on Clause 4.2.7
of the RBI Master Circular, it was submitted that asset
classification is borrower-wise and, therefore, Petitioners' CC
account and other facilities with Respondent No. 2 were also
requirec. to be downgraded once any of the exposures of the
borrower became NPA. Learned counsel further contended that
the subsequent action taken in 2024 was only to align the
classific:rtion in Bank's direct lending books with NpA status
already reflected in its pool books and that any delay in effecting
such alil;nment does not invalidate the classification nor create
any equi[y in favour of Petitioners.
10.
Learned Counsel for Respondent No. 2 further
contended that facilities with SREI expressly permitted
assignme:nt. without requiring further borrower consent; RBI
guidelines do not mandate issuance of prior notice in Direct
Assignme:nt transactions, and that Respondent No. 2, not being
a party to the disputes or arbitration proceedings between
l7
Petitioners and SREI, was nonetheless bound to classify the
accounts strictly in conformit5r with RBI directives and
prudential norms.
1.
In the present Writ Petition, the primary question
that arises for consideration is whether the 2'd respondent.bank
is entitled to classify the cash credit Account of the lst
petitioner company as a Non-Performing Asset (NPA), even
though the said account is being maintained satisfactorily,
solely on the ground that it has purchased certain defective
accounts from a Non-Banking Financial Company (NBFC). For
adjudication of the said issue, this court feels appropriate to
examine the relevant provisions of Master Directions and
Circulars issued by the Reserve Bank of India-
RBI Guidelines on Securitization Transactions dated
07.os.2012
Section B : Guidelines on Transactions Involving Transfer of
Assets through Direct Assignment of Cash Flows and the
Underlying Securities
The transfer of assets from selling bank must contravene
the terms and conditions of any underlying agreement governing the
2.5.9.
assets and all necessary consents from obligors (including from third
parties, where necessary) should have been obtained'
l8
Master: Direction - Reserve Bank of India (Transfer of Loan
Expos-:res) Directions, 2021, datec! 24.O9.2021
'
65.
It the transferee(s), except ARCs, have no existing
exposure to the borrower whose stressed loan account is acquired, the
acqui::ed stressed loan shall be classified as ,,Standard', by the
transl'eree(s). Thereafter, the asset classification status of the loan
acqui'ed, shall be determined by the record of recovery in the books of
the transferee(s) with reference to cash flows estimated at the time of
transf:r of the loan.
66.
In case the transferee(s), except ARCs, have existing
exposllre to the borrower whose stressed loan account is acquired, the
asset ,:lassification of the acquired exposure shall be the same as
the
existing asset classification of the borrower with the transferee. This
treatment shall be applicable even if such acquisition is pursuant to
the
transfe:ree being a successful resolution applicant under the Insolvency
and Bernkruptcy Code, 2016."
Master circular Prudential norms on Income Recognition, Asset
classifi<:ation and provisioning pertaining to Advances dated
02.o4.21)24
DEFINITIONS
2.1 Non-performing Assets (NpA)
2.1.1 An Asset, including a leased asset, becomes non-performing when it
ceases to lSenerate income for the bank.
2.1.1 A non-performing asset (NpA) is a loan or an advance where:
(i) int,3rest and/ or installment of principal remains overdue for a period
of more then 9O days in respect of a term loan,
(iil
th() account remains'out of order' as indicated. at paragraph
belo',v, in respect of an Overdraft
(iiil
2.2
/ Cash Credit (OD/CC).
bill remains overdue for a period of more than 90 days in
-)hepurchased and discounted.
of bills
the case
l9
(iv)
the installment of principal or interest thereon remains overdue for
two crop seasons for short duration crops.
(v)
the installment of principal or interest thereon remains overdue for
one crop season for long duration crops.
(vi)
the amount of liquidity facility remains outstanding for more than 90
days, in respect of a securitization transaction undertaken in terms of the
Reserve Bank of India (Securitization of Standard Assets) Directions, 2021.
(vii) in respect of derivative transactions, the overdue receivables
representing positive mark-to-market value of a derivative contract, if these
remain unpaid for a period of 90 days from the specified due date for
payment.
2.1.3.
In addition, an account may also be classified as NpA in
terms of certain specific provisions of this Master Circular, including inter
alia Paragraphs 4.2.4,4.2.9 and Part 82.
2.2.'Out of Order' status
2.2.1. A CC/OD account shall be treated as'out of order'if:
(i) The outstanding balance in the cc/oD account remains continuously in
excess of the sanctioned limit/drawing power for 90 days, or
(ii) The outstanding balance in the cc/oD account is less than the
sanctioned limit/drawing power but there are no credits continuously for 90
days, or the outstanding balance in the cc/oD account is less than the
sanctioned limit/drawing power but credits are not enough to cover the
interest debited during the previous 9O days period.
2.2.2.
The definition of "out of order" as at paragraph 2.2.1 above
shall be applicable to all loan products being offered as an overdraft facility,
including those not meant for business purpose and/or which entail interest
repayments as the only credits.
2.3.
'Overdue'status
2.3.L. Any amount due to the bank under any credit facility is 'overdue' if it
is not paid on the due date fixed brr the bank. The borrower accounts shall
be flagg=d as overdue by the banks, part of their day-end processes for the
due datt:, irrespective of the time of running such processes.
4.2
Guidelines for ciassification of assets
4.2.7.
Asset Classilication to be borrower-wise and not facility-wise
4.2.7.1 It is difficult to envisage a situation when only one facility to a
borrower'/one investment in any of the securities issued by the borrower
becomes a problem credit/investment and not others. Therefore, all the
facilities granted by a bank to a borrower and investment in all the securities
issued by the borrower will have to be treated as NpA/Npl and not the
particular facility/investment or part thereof w,hich has become irregular.
L2-
Before adverting to the principle issue relating to
the povzer of Respondent No.2 Bank to classify the running
cash credit Account as NpA, this court feels it appropriate to
determine whether there exists any valid agreement or lawful
purchase of the Loan Accounts by the 2.d respondent from SREI
Equipmr:nt Financial Ltd. The directions issued by the Reserve
Bank ol India under Sections 2r and 3sA of the Banking
Regulation Act, 1949 are statutorily-binding on all banking
compani,-'s and operate as part of the regulatory framework
governinl3 their conduct. Such directions/instructions, so long
as they remain in force, are required to be treated as law for the
purposes of testing the legality of administrative actions taken
by the banks.
13-
As per the Master Direction Reserve Bank of India
(Transfer of Loan Exposures) Directions, 2o2L, dated
';
l.il
r;!,
.,/
"
"__y
,/
2t
24.09-2021, or any previous applicable instructions, it is sine
qua non that any assignment or transfer of loan exposures must
be effected through a valid contractual arrangement, and such
agreement alone crystallizes the rights, liabilities and
obligations inter se the transferor, transferee and the obligor.
14.
[t is observed from the record that, on L2.I2.2O24,
learned counsel for Respondent No. 2 represented before this
Court that, "Respondent No.2 Bank purchased the loan
accounts from M/s. SREI Equipment Financial Limited (SREI)
through direct assignment of Cash Flows only to the extent of
9Oo/o of the economic interest
in the loan accounts and that
SREI continued to hold remaining LOo/o of the share in the loan
accounts and also stated that the assignment of debt was not
complete and that, therefore, there was no requirement to issue
notice to the petitioners before marking the accounts as NPAS."
This statement made by the counsel for the 2"d respondent on
instructions, assumes significance that the Bank has not yet
entered into any valid agreement or document to establish that
there was a valid assignment or transfer, or even that there was
any concluded direct assignment of Leased Accounts of SREI
Equipment Finance Ltd. in accordance with RBI directions in
favour of the 2"d Respondent Bank.
\
15.
Upon perusal of Clause 2.5.9. of the RBI
Guidelrnes on Securitisation Transactions dated or.os.2ol2, it
is evid:nt that transfer of assets by the transferor, must not
contran'ene the terms and conditions of
the underlying
agreement governing the assets and all necessary consents
from obligors (including from third parties, where necessary)
should have been obtained. Even assuming that assignment
had taken place, there is nothing on record to demonstrate that
such ar;signment was in compriance with clause 2.5.9 of the
RBI ciuidelines on Securitization Transactions dated
a7-05-21)12, and, on the contrary, petitioners have categorically
stated ()n aflidavit that they did not receive any intimation
whatsoever from either the transferor or the transferee
regarding the alleged assignment, and the said fact is not denied
by ths !'ra Respondent Bank in its counter affidavit and, on the
contrary, mentioned that no intimation of assignment need to
be given. Even during the consortium meetings held in 2023
and 202'4, the alleged assignment was never disclosed by the
2nd respondsnl. This conduct of the 2nd Respondent raises
serious coubts regarding the very existence of the assignment
deed or document by SREI.
16.
Learned Senior counser appearing for petitioners
h^ave J.ral'n our attention to clause 16 of the Master
Lease
z5
f../
Agreement between petitioner No. 1 and SREI Equipment
Finance Limited, wherein it is expressry provided that, ,,Lessor
mag sell and/ or assign or transfer all or ang Lessor,s
and/ or obligations und.er this Agreement and./
Equipment or grant a security interest in the
or to the
Equipment to a
seatred Party or Assignee- (rpon such assigrument or
creation of
seatity interest, tressor shail send. a notice in the agreed
-
rights
format.,,
In fact, petitioners have specificalry contended that
no such notice was ever received by them, either from
Respondent No. 2 or from SREI Equipment Finance
Also, Respondent No. 2 has neither established that
Limited.
any notice
in the agreed format was in fact, issued in compriance with
clause 16, nor produced any documentation pertaining
to the
alleged assignment. The 2rd respondent failed to furnish
any
relevant evidence to establish that there is a valid assignment.
Further, the 2"d respondent does not contain any information
as
to the date of assignment. petitioner was kept in suspended
animation, except for stating that the 2.d respondent purchased
the right to collect lease amounts from SREI, which accrued
to
it through different lease agreements. [n fact, the contentions of
the 2nd respondent at the time of granting interim order
are
recorded by this court, which state that assignment was
not
fully completed and was still in progress. Thereafter, in the
count3r affidavit, the 2nd respondent statect that SREI has
assigr ed its lease agreernents and that it has accrued the right
to collect the lease amounts. As the contentions in the counter
afl-rdavit of the 2nd respondent are inconsistent and not
suppo::ted by any va.lid document, and in view of the contrary
contentions raised by the 2*d respondent in its counter affidavit,
it is <lifficult to accept the version of the 2nd respondent
regarding a valid assignment for the collection of rentals under
the fourr loan accounts mentioned in the impugned emails. In
view ol' the foregoing discussion and in the absence of any
convinc'ing evidence, this court firmly holds that the alleged
assignnrent is shrouded in serious doubt, and its very veracity
is queslionable and doubtful and the same is not in existence.
18-
Alternatively, even assuming that there is any
assignrrrent or sale of lease accounts by the 2rd respondent from
M/s sFrEI Equipment Finance Ltd. took place, no power or
authority for such action uias traceable under the Master
Guidelines issued by the RBI, as referred to in the preceding
paragraphs. Guideline No. 2.s.9 of the RBI Guidelines on
securitization Transactions dated oz.os.2o12 specifically states
that transfer of assets by a selling bank must not contravene
the term:; and conditions of any underrying agreement governing
such assets on the necessary consent from the obligors,
;41
::
{
""/
including third parties, must be obtained. Accordingly, this
statutory provision imposes a mandatory obligation on the 2"d
respondent bank to verify whether M/s SREI Equipment
Finance Ltd. complied with Clause No. 16 of the Master Lease
Agreement dated 31.03.2017 executed with the l"t petitioner
company. Further, an implied obligation seems to have been
imposed upon the 2nd respondent bank under Regulation No.
2.5.9, requiring that the consent of obligors, including third
parties, if any, should likewise have been obtained. [n the
present case on hand, although the 2"d respondent, in its e
mails dated 21.10.2024 and 2+.1O.2O24, asserted that SREI
Equipment Finance Ltd. had declared the four loan accounts of
the 1st petitioner as NPA on O+.O8.2O2O, the 2"d respondent
bank failed to bring the same to the notice of petitioner
company for the last five years and despite the alleged NPA
classification, the 2"d respondent continued to renew the cash
credit account of the 1."t petitioner company from time to time.
19.
Further, the 2nd respondent also stated in the
counter, they also classified petitioner Accounts maintained by
them including C.C. Account as NPA on 04.O8.2O2O and the
impugned e mail dated 21.10.2024 is only a consequential
intimation. This contention of the 2nd respondent clarified that
ignoring the said alleged classificatio4, they have renewed the
c.c. A<:count of the lst petitioner all these years. The contention
of the 1l"d respondent is tot-ally perverse and casual. Hence, after
a lapse of five years, the 2nd responcient bank is estoppecr from
declaring the satisfactorily-maintained cash credit account of
petitioner as NPA on account of its purchase of the alleged NpA
accoun -s
20.
It is relevant to mention here that the 2nd
responcent bank by its e mail dated 27.10.2024, specifically
acknowledged that cash credit account of the lst petitioner,
which has been sanctioned by it, had been operating and
maintained satisfactorily. In light of the said admission of the
2"rt re:;pondent bank, the action of the 2nd respondent to
declare the said accounts as NpA is totaly arbitrary, highhanded, and indicative of a complete non-application of mind,
as well as misinterpretation and misapplication of the relevant
regulations. Apart from that, as per Regulations 65 and 66 of
the RBI Guidelines on securitization Transfers, 2o!2, the 2",r
responde,nt bank must treat any loan accounts acquired as
"standarrl accounts" and intimate the same to the borrowers
regarding; the outstanding, if any, available in the said acquired
accounts, and inform them to clear it within a specified time. In
the present case, the 2"d respondent bank had neither informed
petitioner about the date of assignment nor about any
I
outstanding, if any, due in the accounts alleged to have been
acquired. In addition to that, the 2.d respondent bank, having
fully aware about pendency of the arbitral claim between SREI
Equipment Finance Ltd. and the lst petitioner, acquired the said
four loan accounts and thereby, proceeded to purchase the said
disputed accounts solely by relying upon the statements of SREI
Equipment Finance Ltd. and its auditors, thereby unnecessarily
declared the satisfactorily-running cash credit account of the l"t
petitioner as NPA. [n fact, such a power is also not available to
the 2"d respondent.
2L.
Further, what is meant by NPA, when an account
will become overdue, and how the same is to be declared NPA,
are clarified under Regulation 2 of the RBI Master Circular,
2024, which has been extracted in the preceding paragraphs.
The lst petitioner's case can not fall under the sAid Regulation
for declaring NPA. Petitioners had placed before this Court a
Master Circular, i.e., RBI Master Circular on Prudential Norms
on Income Recognition, Asset Classification, and Provisioning
pertaining to Advances dated O2.O4.2O24. In the opening page
of the said Circular, it is specifically stated that the Master
Circular applies exclusively to transactions among commercial
banks only. Clause No. 4.2.7 of the said Master Circular states
as follows:
4.2.7. Asset Classification to be borror.ver-wise and not facility-wise
4'2.7.1 It is difficult to envisage a situation when only one facility to
a borrou'er/one investment in any of the securities issued by the
borrou'er becomes a problem credit/rnvestment and not others.
Therefrlre, all the facilities granted by a bank to a borrower and
investrnent in all the securities issued by the borrower will have to be
treated as NPA/NPI and not the particular facility/investment or part
thereol which has become irregular."
22.
In fact, the 2nd respondent bank relied upon the
said regulation/clause of the Master circular to declare the 1st
petitionr:r's satisfactorily-running cash credit account as NpA.
After a careful reading of the language deployed in the said
regulation/clause, it is clear that it cannot come to the rescue
or justily the 2n,t respondent's action in declaring the 1st
petitioner's cash credit account as NpA. In fact, the said
Regulations are applicable only to loan transactions pertaining
to transf:rs, acquisitions or similar activities among commercial
banks, but not to transactions with NBFCs. In fact, the Master
circular specifically states that it applies only to transactions
among c,)mmercial banks. In addition to that, it is specifically
stated in the Regulation No. 4.2.7 that if any loan account or
facility granted by a commercial bank becomes irregular or a
problem r:redit, all other loans or facilities granted by the same
commercial bank to the borrower must also be treated as NpA to
I
I
maintain uniformity, as the asset classification is borrower-wise
I
and not facility-wise. In view of this, the power under Clause No.
4.2.7 of the Master Circular could be used by the 2nd
respondent only in respect of any further loans granted to the
petitioner company apart from the cash credit facility, but
however, it is not applicable to transactions between the 2"d
respondent and SREI, which is not a commercial bank, but an
NBFC.
23.
According to the counter affidavit, it is the case of
the 2"d respondent that they have granted cash credit facility to
the lst petitioner, which is running satisfactorily and that since
they purchased the alleged NPA loans from a Non-Banking
Finance Company (SREI Equipment Finance Ltd.), they have
declared the cash credit facility granted by them as NPA. In fact,
such a power is not traceable under Clause 4.2-7 of the Master
Circular, as stated supra, since the power available under the
said clause cannot be extended to purchased loan accounts
from NBFCs, as it is impliedly stated in the said clause that any
loans granted to the borrower by the commercial bank do not
include any loan acquired from an outside agency or NBFC.
Hence, the power exercised by the 2"d respondent bank is ultra
uires to the RBI Regulations. Apart from that, the lst
Respondent (RBI), who has also filed counter affidavit, does not
\
i0
support the impugned action of the 2.d respondent, except to
state r-hat the obligatiorr of the 2,,d respondent to sustain its
action under challenge.
24-
Thus, thc- )tt<t responrlent has not provided any
proper explanation nor produced any supporting material to
substantiate the impugned e rnail dated 2r.1o.2o24 as well as
the subsequent e mail dated 24.Lo.2a24. Further, since a
disputr: is pending before the Arbitral Tribunal, the 2nd
responrlent ought not have purchased those disputed loans
from slRE[, an& based on the same, cannot declare the
satisfactorily-running cash credit accr.runt of the 1"t petitioner as
NPA. Ttre 2"d respondent is expected to be vigilant ancl expected
to act irr due diligence before passing such an impugned order,
as the .<iame has serious repercussions on banking business as
it strai;:rs the banker-customer relationship, and ultimately
results in loss to the banking sector. In view of the foregoing
discussion, the action of tlr. 2nd respondent is wholly
unsustainable, high-handed, and apart from arbitrary.
25-
Hence, in view of the foregoing discussions and the
statutor-.r guidelines discussed supra, the proceedings issued by
the 2"d llespondent rhrough e mail dated 21.10.2024 cannot be
sustainec, hence the same is hereby declared as invalid, ultra
uires, an,1 arbitr&ry.
3l
26.
Accordingly, the Writ petition is allowed setting
aside the e mail dated 2L.1O.2O24 issued by the 2"a respondent
in classifying the 1st petitioner's cash credit Account as NpA,
with a specific direction to restore the said cash credit Account
No. 252105oooooo43 of the l"t petitioner company forthwith.
No costs.
27.
ConJequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
any shall stand closed.
/
SD/. C. DEEPIKA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The RESERVE BANK OF lNDlA, 6-1-56,
Road, National Highway
65, Saifabad, Khairatabad, Hyderabad - 500 004 elangana, lndia Also, at.
Central Office Building, Shahid Bhagat Singh Ma rg , Fort, Mumbai - 400001,
ft/aharashtra
:
2. One CC to SRl. BENDI RAVITEJA Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to MiS. N LEGAL HYDERABAD Advocate [OPUC]
4. One CC to SRl. SRINIVAS CHITTURU,STANDING COUNSEL IOPUC]
5. Two CD Copies
BIU
GJP
I
e
HIGH GI)URT
DATED:2510212026
I
t
O
THE S
1 1 ilA8 7n7fr
*
*
ORDER
WP.No.3i4084 of 2024
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
r\
q
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review