Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
M.C.(W.A.) No. 178 of 2022
[Ref.: W.A. No. 39 of 2018]
1.
2.
AMPPTA, represented by its Secretary Wahengbam Somokanta
Singh, aged about 52 years, S/o (L) W. Nipamacha Singh, r/o
Keishamthong Top Leirak, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, Imphal West
District, Manipur, Pin No. 795001.
Shri Ahongsangbam Tamphayai Singh, aged about 58 years, s/o
(L) A. Amuba Singh, a resident of Khurai Nandeibam Leikai, P.O.
Lamlong, P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
….Applicants
Versus
1.
2.
3.
The Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., through its Chairman, Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd. Ali Yavar Jung Marg, Bandra (East), Mumbai India
– 400 051.
The Deputy General Manager, IOC, Retail cum State Level Coordination, Manipur.
The Deputy General Manager, IOC(OPS), Noonmati, Guwahati –
20.
…. Respondents
W.A. No. 39 of 2018
1.
2.
3.
The Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., through its Chairman, Indian Oil
Corporation Ltd. Ali Yavar Jung Marg, Bandra (East), Mumbai India
– 400 051.
The Deputy General Manager, IOC, Retail cum State Level Coordination, Manipur.
The Deputy General Manager, IOC(OPS), Noonmati, Guwahati –
20.
…. Appellants
Versus
1.
AMPPTA, represented by its President, Shri Hijam Tikendra Singh,
aged about 65 years, s/o H. Nilamani Singh, a resident of Kakwa
Bazar, P.O. & P.S. Singjamei, Imphal West District, Manipur.
2.
Shri Ahongsangbam Tamphayai Singh, aged about 58 years, s/o
(L) A. Amuba Singh, a resident of Khurai Nandeibam Leikai, P.O.
Lamlong, P.S. Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur.
….. Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the applicants
:
Mr. H.S. Paonam, Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. S. Gunabanta,
Advocate
For the respondents
:
Mr. L. Shashibhushan, Senior
Advocate assisted by Mr. K. Kamei,
Advocate
Mr. S. Nepolean, Government
Advocate.
:
Date of hearing
Date of judgment & order
:
:
11.10.2023
30.10.2023
ORDER
(CAV)
[A. Guneshwar Sharma, J]
[1]
Heard Mr. H.S. Paonam, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
S. Gunabanta, advocate appearing for the applicants, Mr. L. Shashibhushan,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K. Kamei, advocate appearing for the
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. and Mr. S. Nepolean, learned Government
Advocate appearing for the State respondent.
[2]
The present application has been filed by the applicants/writ
petitioners under Section 151 of Cr.P.C. for closing the W.A. No. 39 of 2018.
[3]
The applicants/writ petitioners filed W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017
challenging the validity and correctness of the NIT dated 10.11.2027 issued
by the Deputy General Manager, IOC (OPS), Guwahati, Indian Oil
Corporation inviting tenders “for Road Transportation of Bulk Petroleum
Products White Oil”.
[4]
The writ petitioner association is a registered society under the
Manipur Societies Registration Act, 1989. The association was formed in the
year 1981-82 by the transporters of POL products and its members are the
owners of the Tank Trucks/Oil Tankers (hereinafter referred to as “the TTs”)
who have been rendering their services for bridging input in respect of
Petrol, Kerosene and Diesel oil in the State of Manipur from other States
through NH-2 and NH-37. Keeping in mind the circumstances obtaining in
the State of Manipur, the IOC Ltd. used to issue NIT for the State of Manipur
only in respect of TTs with a carrying capacity of 12 KL for a total of 534 TTs
with the condition that the bidders will have to offer minimum three TTs, out
of which one should be owned by him/it.
[5]
Deviating from the earlier practice and procedure, the NIT
dated 10.12.2017 was issued by the General Manager, IOC (OPS), Guwahati
inviting tenders “for Road Transportation of Bulk Petroleum Products – White
Oil” for three locations, namely (i) Tinsukia / Digboi Terminal, (ii) Dimapur
Depot and (iii) Malom Depot, Imphal. As per the scope of work, the NIT
invited tenders in respect of 11 to 12 KL for 247 TTs as compared to earlier
tender for 534 TTs and 18 KL and above up to 40 KL for 336 TTs with the
aim and object to outs or negate the service of the State TT owners and to
attract/please the outside POL businessman only.
[6]
Being aggrieved by the said NIT, the writ petition has been
filed on the ground that :
(a)
The NIT was issued with a view to oust the members of the
petitioners association who have rendered their services
despite they being exposed to various threats, frequent
landslides and meeting illegal road taxes imposed by various
underground organizations. However, they have been rendered
ineligible to compete with the outsides in the tenders, as many
of them do not own two TTs registered in their names.
(b)
The rate fixed by the IOC Ltd. in the NIT is unreasonable, as
the same had been fixed at a rate lower than the one fixed in
the year 2013-14 completely ignoring the escalation of
price/cost with respect to maintenance of vehicle; salary of the
driver/handyman and essential items.
(c)
In the NIT, the security deposit was increased to Rs. 5,00,000/from Rs. 3,00,000/- although the rate quotation was decreased
from that of the previous year within an average range
between 12% and 14% without considering the increasing cost
factor due to GST.
(d)
The bidders will have to offer minimum three TTs, out of which
two will be owned by him/it deviating from the earlier eligibility
criteria whereby the bidders will have to offer minimum three
TTs, out of which he/it will own at least TT. The members of
the petitioners association have been rendered incapacitated as
most of them do have only TT registered in their names. In
order to make eligible, the members of the petitioners
association are required to purchase at least one more TT
costing about 20 to 25 lakhs in a short period of time.
(e)
The Retail Outlet Dealers (hereinafter referred to as “the ROs”)
under EOI (Expression of Interest) performance clause as
reflected at Page No. 5 of 98 of the NIT is also quite offensive
to the petitioners association as the NIT allowed the ROs to
participate in the tender as on date. There are about 101 TTs
under EOI and allowing them to participate in the NIT amounts
to granting double benefits/chances to them and a number of
110 TTs belonging to the General Transporters will have to
remain idle or wasted without their being utilized. This amounts
to unequal treatment meted out to the members of the
petitioners association.
(f)
The NIT invited tenders from TT owners having a capacity of
21 to 40KL for 334 Oil Tankers but since none of the local
transporters own such vehicle as the registration thereof is not
possible in Manipur, the offer is un-favourable to the
transporters from the State of Manipur. The TTs having
capacity of 24KL and 29KL were introduced only during
February, 2017 to June, 2017 by way of gateway notice. The
introduction of 21 KL to 40 KL in the NIT with different rates,
for the first time in the State of Manipur, affects the level
playing field.
(g)
Deviations in the NIT, from that of the earlier one, have been
made without taking into consideration the situation prevailing
in the State but with the aid and advice of the Assam based
Transporter
Association.
The
IOC
Ltd.
has
completely
overlooked the sacrificial services rendered by the members of
the petitioners association during natural as well as manmade
crisis when there is scarcity of petrol in the State of Manipur.
[7]
Another writ petition being W.P.(C) No. 933 of 2017 has been
filed by 3 (three) writ petitioners for setting aside the NIT dated 10.11.2017
issued by the Deputy General Manager, IOC(OPS), Guwahati, Indian Oil
Corporation for tender “for Road Transportation of Bulk Petroleum – White
Oil”.
[8]
Another writ petition being W.P.(C) No. 545 of 2018 has been
filed by the writ petitioner for quashing and setting aside the e-mail dated
12.06.2018 under the subject “Offer for acceptance of L1 rate” when the
NIT under Tender ID : 2017-NEISO-64145-1 is pending for finalization.
[9]
Vide common judgment and order dated 25.08.2018, three writ
petitions being W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017, W.P.(C) No. 933 of 2017 and
W.P.(C) No. 545 of 2018 are allowed and consequently, the NIT dated
10.11.2017 and the e-mail dated 12.06.2018 are quashed and set aside with
no order as to costs. However, it is open to the IOD Ltd. to float a new NIT
keeping in mind the observations made in the common judgment and order.
[10]
Being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 25.08.2018,
the IOC preferred 3 (three) writ appeals being W.A. No. 38 of 2018 against
W.P.(C) No. 933 of 2017; W.A. No. 39 of 2018 against W.P.(C) No 882 of
2017 and W.A. No. 40 of 2018 against W.P.(C) No. 545 of 2017.
[11]
During the pendency of the writ appeals, no interim order was
passed by this Court. It is stated that without obtaining any leave from this
Court, another NIT being Tender No. RCC/ERO/37/2021-22/PT-216, Etender ID 2022 ERO 148215 dated 02.03.2022 whereby many new
conditions have been introduced in great deviation of from the earlier NIT
even to the extent of reducing number of TTs in respect of 11-12 KL to 121
which was originally 534 in 2017 NIT to 212 in the fresh NIT mentioned
above.
[12]
The IOC appellant herein issued an order on 14.03.2022
notifying about the cancellation of the tender published on 10.11.2017
which was the subject matter of the writ petitions under appeal in the above
referred writ appeals. The cancellation order was uploaded in their website
knowing fully about the prevailing circumstances.
[13]
The writ appeal filed by the appellant is for quashing and
setting aside of the impugned judgment and order of the learned Single
Judge in its interference of the NIT of 2017 by quashing and setting aside
and thus, if the appeal is decided in favour of the appellant, the NIT of 2017
dated 10.11.2017 would stand revived and in the event appeals are decided
against the appellant, applicant writ petitioner will get the benefit of the
judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge impugned in the
present writ appeal and consequently, IOC would be legally obligated to
issue a fresh NIT in accordance with the observation made by the learned
Single Judge. However, by cancellation of the 2017 NIT on their own, the
cause of the writ petition as well as writ appeals has no longer survived and
virtually it has become infructuous. Further, insisting on continuing the writ
appeal would be only academic consideration as well as from getting away
from the omission and commission in issuing the new NIT of 02.03.2022 in
breach of the observation made by the learned Single Judge which would
not be legally permissible in the present facts and circumstances obtaining
as on today.
[14]
It is submitted that as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of “Shipping Corporation of India Ltd. vs. Machado
Brothers and Ors.” Which is gainfully quoted below as under :
“Thus, it is clear that by subsequent even if the original
proceeding has become infructuous, ex-debito justitiae, it will
be the duty of the Court to take such action as is necessary in
the interest of justice, which includes disposing of infructuous
litigation. For the said purpose, it will be open to the parties to
make application under Section 151 CPC to bring to the notice
of the Court the facts and circumstances which have made the
pending litigation infructuous. Of course, when such an
application is made, the Court will enquire into the alleged facts
and circumstances to find out whether the pending litigation
has in fact become infructuous or not.”
Therefore, the above referred writ appeal may be disposed of
as infructuous having regard to the subsequent event of issuance of the
cancellation of NIT of 2017 by the IOC which is the subject matter of the
original writ petition. Cancellation of the NIT of 2017 by the IOC is
reproduced herein below:
India Oil Corporation eProcurement Portal
Published Corrigendum Details
Organisation Chain :
Date : 14-Mar-2022 06:01 AM
IndianOil ll Marketting ll North East Integrated State Office ll
Operations
Tender ID :
Tender Ref. No. :
Tender Title :
Corrigendum Type :
2017 _NEISO_64145_1
IO AOD SO/OPS/POL/PT-8 of 2017
Road Transportation of bulk POL product
Cancellation of Tender
Corrigendum Document Details
Corr.
No.
Corrigendum
Title
Corrigendum
Description
Corrigendum
Reason
Published
Date
Document Name
1.
Cancellation of
Tender
Reason
for
cancellation of
tender as per
corrigendum
attached
Due
to
administrative
reason/issues
10-Mar2022 05:19
PM
Corrigendumfor
Cancellationof
tender:pdf
[15]
DOC
Size (in
KB)
388.92
It may be noteworthy to being on record about the various
action and order issued by the IOC Ltd. for circumventing the order of this
Court including undue favour to RO Dealers in the name of induction of TT
for the transportation of POL products by wholly ignoring the hard fact that it
is the member of the applicant association who has been continuously
shouldering the responsibility of transportation of POL product in the State
since the very beginning facing unfriendly environment and great life
threatening obstacles and as on today also there has not been any complaint
against the service of the member of the applicant. The IOC while ignoring
the case of the General Transporters have selectively taken up the case of
RO who are in possession of TT lying without utilization for transportation of
POL to Malom Depot in the name of induction. The proposal and
recommendation reflects consideration on the part of IOC for those RO
dealers who are in possession of TT and difficulty in discharging their EMI
and Insurance premium annually which is a favoritism and discrimination
shown to the general transporters who are members of the applicant/writ
petitioner who are also facing the same problem and issue. Applicant for
convenience and appreciation beg to reproduce the portion of the proposal
made on 09.08.2022 and approval accorded in principle on 16.08.2022 as
under:
“Proposal:
It is proposed that in-principle approval be
accorded for induction of dealer owned TTs into
operations for taking supplies ex. Malom Depot
(7D17).”
Therefore, applicant submitted that IOC writ appellant by their
own action goes to show that they will resort to any activities without limit
for imposing their condition on the general transporters irrespective of the
order passed from the ends of this Court which is wholly against the
constitutional edifice of this country hence, passing of an appropriate order is
highly called for so that unbridle power exercise by IOC is restrained.
[16]
Insisting on continuous induction to TTs of RO dealers for
utilizing of POL at Malom Depot from outside in addition to original intent of
EOI relying on provision/clause in the NIT, it would be best on the part of
IOC to do away with the floating of NIT for general transporter so that they
will be free to utilize the TTs of ROs wherever and whenever situation
demands as they claim without any apprehension of litigation in the Court.
[17]
The IOC filed replies to the counter affidavit stating that with
regard to the statements made in paragraph No. 4 and 5 of the
application/Misc. Case, the deponent states that the appellants / IOCL has
already issued letters/Corrigenda on 11.12.2023 and 13.02.2023 for
withdrawal of the EOI dated 09.04.2021 and General Tender dated
02.03.2022 as well as for revocation of earlier order dated 10.03.2022
whereby the NIT dated 10.11.2017 was cancelled/withdrawn. Thus, after the
aforesaid exercise undertaken by the IOCL, the writ petitions being W.P.(C)
No. 195 of 2022 and 495 of 2021 filed by the applicants against the newly
issued POL product transportation EOI and tender became infructuous and
were disposed of by this Court as such vide order dated 13.02.2023.
Corrigenda dated 11.02.2023 (Annexure – R1 & R2) and letter dated
13.02.2023 (Annexure – R3) are reproduced herein below:
Corrigendum : Cancellation of Tender
“Annexure R – 1
Tender Reference Number : RCC/ERO/37/2021-22/PT-216
Tender ID : 2022_ERO_148215_1
Tender Title : Road Transportation of Bulk Petroleum
Products by Top Loading Tank Trucks –
MS/HSD/SKO/Branded Fuels Ex-Imphal
Depot.
This is to inform all concerned that based on the detailed reasoning
cum supervening factors and consequent to the management
approval, the following tender(s) / communications issued by IOCL
stands cancelled and withdrawn with immediate effect.
Tender Reference Number: RCC/ERO/37/2021-22/PT-216 with ETender ID: 2022_ERO_148215_1 published by RCC, ERO for Road
Transportation of Bulk Petroleum Products by Top Loading Tank
Trucks – MS/HSD/SKO/Branded Fuels Ex-Imphal Depot.
As a result of the cancellation of the aforesaid tender, any/all
communication(s)/order(s) issued and exchanged with bidder(s) in
this behalf stand withdrawn.
Order dated 24.11.2022 from Hon’ble High Court at Manipur at
attached herewith.
Tender Inviting Authority
RCC, ERO”
“Annexure – R2
Corrigendum : Cancellation of Expression of Interest (EOI)
Tender Reference Number : IOAODSO/OPS/EOI/PT-17/IMPHAL
Tender ID : ID 2021 NEISO_134117_1
Tender Title : EOI for Imphal Depot
This is to inform all concerned that based on the detailed reasoning
cum supervening factors and consequent to the management
approval, the following tender(s)/communication(s)/EOIs issued by
IOCL stands cancelled and withdrawn with immediate effect.
EOI No. 90AODSO/OPS/EOI/PT-17/IMPHAL with Tender ID
2021_NEISO_134117_1 floated by IOAOD SO/Ops for Road
Transportation of Bulk Petroleum products ex-Imphal Depot.
As a result of the cancellation of the aforesaid Tender(s)/EOI, any/all
communication(s)/order(s) issued and exchanged with bidder(s) in
this behalf stand withdrawn.
Honable Manipur High Court dated 24.11.2022 is attached herewith.
Tender Inviting Authority
CGM(Ops)/IOAOD SO”
“Annexure – R3
To Whomsoever it may concern
This is to inform that the communication dated 10.03.2022
(Attached), issued in connection with Tender ref. No.
IOAODSO/OPS/POL/T-8
of
under
Tender
ID:
2017_NEISO_64145 for the Road Transportation of Bulk Petroleum
Products ex-Imphal Depot, stands withdrawn with immediate effect.
Accordingly, the withdrawal of the referred tender is revoked and the
tender No. IOAODSO/OPS/POL/T-8 of 2017 stands re-instated.
Further communication in this regard shall be issued contingent upon
the outcome of the pending Writ Appeal nos. 38, 39 and 40 of 2018,
pending before the Hon’ble High Court of Manipur and other
connected matters.
Tender Inviting Authority
Sd/DGM(Ops) IOAOD SO”
[18]
The applicant filed rejoinder to the counter affidavit of the IOC
stating that with reference to para No. 6 of the affidavit-in-opposition under
reply, deponent submits that the moment the EOI dated 09.04.2021 and
General Tender dated 02.03.2022 were floated after the disposal of W.P.(C)
No. 882 of 2017 & Ors., the writ appeal has become infructuous even though
the legality of the fresh tender are subjected to judicial review. It may be
pertinent to mention here that this Court had quashed and set aside the
impugned NIT dated 10.11.2017 in W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017 with further
direction to float the NIT afresh by keeping in mind the observation made in
the judgment and order. Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel submits
that after floating of the fresh tender, the respondents shall be deemed to
have been complied with the judgment and order passed in W.P.(C) No. 882
of 2017 from their part. Now, the respondents cannot turn back the clock by
canceling the fresh NIT and re-instating the NIT dated 10.11.2017 which has
been quashed by this Court. Further, the NIT dated 10.11.2017 was
cancelled by the appellants/respondents on the ground that the tender has
exceeded the validity date of 240 days without the leave of this Court on
11.03.2022. Therefore, there is no reasonable ground for revoking the
10.02.2022 whereby the NIT dated 10.11.2017 was cancelled and the
appellants/respondents in the Misc. Case cannot re-instate the NIT dated
10.11.2017 legally as the same has been quashed and set aside by this Court
in W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017 & Ors. The respondents upon failure to complete
the fresh tender process due to litigation cannot turn back after more than 1
year subsequent to the floating of fresh tender to claim that they have
cancelled it and re-instate the earlier NIT dated 10.11.2017 to adjudicate the
matter. Since the aforesaid fresh tender was issued after the judgment and
order passed in W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017 and cancellation of NIT dated
10.11.2017, the respondents have waived their right to challenge the
judgment and order dated 25.08.2018 passed in W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017 &
Ors. Re-instating NIT dated 10.11.2017 amounts to flogging dead horse as
the same has been quashed and set aside by this Court in W.P.(C) No. 882
of 2017 and a fresh NIT was floated. It is also stated that ligitations cannot
be fought on trial and error basis. Respondents are accountable for their
action and they cannot change their stand one after another to suit their
interest. Such action of the respondents has made the legal proceedings
before this Court a mockery in the eyes of the general public.
Further, it is submitted that the letter/notice dated 13.02.2023
which re-instates the Tender No. IO AOD So/OPS/POL/PT-8 of 2017 dated
10.11.2017 directly amount to challenging the judgment and order passed in
W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017 and as such, this Court may intimate suo moto
Contempt proceedings against the respondents for willful and deliberate
disobedience of the judgment and order dated 25.08.2018 passed in W.P.(C)
No. 882 of 2017 & Ors.
[19]
With reference to para no. 7 of the affidavit-in-opposition under
reply, deponent submits that statement of the respondents that the previous
tender of 2017 stands revived for all intents and purposes is contemptuous.
The respondents have tried to justify holding of fresh tender by stating that
the earlier tender of 2017 has been cancelled on the ground that the tender
has exceeded the validity date of 240 days. Therefore, when the respondents
failed to prevent passing of interim order staying the fresh tender, the
respondent cannot alter their stand and state that the EOI dated 09.04.2021
and General Tender dated 02.03.2022 is cancelled and NIT dated 10.11.2017
is re-instated for all intents and purposes. Respondents cannot be allowed to
keep on changing their stand. The appellants/respondents ought to have
considered this legal aspect of the appeal becoming infructuous upon floating
of fresh tender and cancellation of the NIT of 2017 before taking those
decisions. It is stated that the appellants upon floating the fresh tender and
cancelling the earlier NIT of 2017 are estopped from re-instating the NIT of
2017. Before floating the NIT afresh and before cancelling the NIT of 2017,
the appellants/respondents ought to have taken leave of this Court since the
appeal is pending. However, by doing so, the respondents have waived their
right to challenge the validity of the impugned judgment and order passed in
W.P.(C) No. 882 of 2017. Such act of the respondents for reviving the NIT of
2017 is also barred by the principle of estoppels and doctrine of promissory
estoppel.
[20]
We have gone through the materials on record and considered
the rival submissions made at bar. After floating fresh NIT by cancelling the
impugned NIT of 2017, the cause in the writ petitions as well as writ appeals
has not survived anymore. The NIT of 2017 is no longer in existence after its
cancellation by IOC and floating new NIT in its place. Reviving the NIT of
2017 which was quashed by learned Single Judge and cancelled by IOC itself
during pendency of the appeals, will be on the threshold of contempt of
court. Accordingly, the application is allowed and writ appeal being WA No.
39 of 2018 is closed.
[21]
Since the applicant has filed only one application for closing of
WA No. 39 of 2018, registry is directed to list remaining writ appeals being
WA Nos. of 38 of 2018 and 40 of 2018 on 21.11.2023 for further
proceedings.
JUDGE
JUDGE
Digitally signed
KH.
by KH. JOSHUA
JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2023.10.31
MARING 14:16:27 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review