Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:17287
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 5607 of 2023
….…..
Amit Kumar, aged about 54 years, S/o Surya Narayan
Sharma, R/o 16, Green Park, Near Shyam
Automobiles, Piskamore, Hehal, P.O. Hehal, P.S.
Sukhdeonagar & District-Ranchi. ..… Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Jharkhand, officiating at Project
Building, H.E.C Town Ship, P.O., P.S Dhurwa &
District - Ranchi.
2. The Principal Secretary, Department of Home, Prison
& Disaster Management, Government of Jharkhand,
officiating at Project Building, H.E.C Town Ship, P.O.,
P.S Dhurwa & District - Ranchi.
3. The Under Secretary, Department of Home, Prison &
Disaster Management, Government of Jharkhand,
Officiating at Project Building, H.E.C Town Ship, P.O.,
P.S Dhurwa & District - Ranchi.
4. The Director General of Police, Jharkhand,
officiating at Police Headquarters, Dhurwa, P.O., P.S
Dhurwa & District - Ranchi.
5. The Inspector General of Police (Personnel),
Jharkhand, officiating at Police Headquarters, Dhurwa,
P.O., P.S Dhurwa & District - Ranchi.
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
….…
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Ajit Kumar, Sr. Adv
Ms. Aprajita Bharadwaj, Adv
Ms. Tanya Singh, Adv
Mrs. Satakchhi Priya Verma, Adv
For the Respondents : Mr. Amitesh Kumar Geasen, A.C. to AAG-IA
…..
C.A.V. ON: 12/05/2026
PRONOUNCED ON:15/06/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
The instant writ petition has been preferred by the
petitioner for the following reliefs:i. For showing cause the respondents as to why and on what
basis/reason they are not adhering to their own policy decision
contained in letter no. 10785 dated 17.10.1998 (Annexure - 4) which
in clear and specific term stipulates that the Police Inspectors who
have been awarded with the Gallantry Award President Police
2026:JHHC:17287
Medal will be given seniority three years, however even in spite of
the fact that the petitioner has also been awarded with the
Gallantry Award President Police Medal way back in the year 2002,
he has not been awarded the seniority of three years of and the
petitioner further prays for holding and declaring the office order
contained in memo no. 1477 dated 16.06.2016 issued by the
respondent no. 5 whereby and whereunder he has expressed that
on account of petitioner already having granted promotion in the
rank of Dy.S.P. his claim of seniority stands as infructuous as bad
and non-est in view of the Government decision, above referred.
ii. For showing cause the respondents as to how and under what
circumstances the matter of shifting of date of promotion of the
petitioner in the rank of Dy.S.P. could be placed or decided at the
level of Respondent no. 4 or 5 or even by a committee headed by the
respondent no. 5 instead of placing the same before the State
Government and for further showing cause the respondents as to
whether in the light of the reference made by the office of respondent
no. 5 vide letter dated 26.10.2016 which has been duly responded
by the office of the Respondent no. 2 and 3 vide letter no. 87 dated
04.01.2017, the respondents are sitting tight over the matter and
why the grievances of the petitioner has not been placed before the
State Government for appropriate decision which is amounting to
serious discouragement to the petitioner who has been always
praised for his contribution at all his ranks i.e Sub-Inspector,
Inspector and even as Dy.S.P. and the petitioner prays for issuance
of appropriate directions upon the respondents to immediately and
forthwith take final decision on the reference made by the
Respondent no. 5 to the State Government vide his letter dated
26.10.2016.
iii. For issuance of appropriate writ(s)/order (s)/direction(s) in the
nature of mandamus commanding upon the respondents directing
them to correct and shift the date of promotion of the petitioner in the
rank of Dy.S.P. (with appropriate seniority position) from 18.07.2012
to the retrospective date i.e 17.05.2010 when the juniors / nonentitled persons were granted the appropriate promotion to which
the petitioner was actually entitled and the petitioner prays for
further directing the respondents to grant all consequential effects
and benefits to the petitioner as a result of the said correction
/shifting of the date of promotion to which he is found legally
entitled.
AND/OR
For any other appropriate relief or reliefs for which the Petitioner is
found to be entitled in the fact and circumstances of this case.
3.
The brief facts of the case as per the pleadings are that
the petitioner was appointed as Sub-Inspector of Police in the
erstwhile State of Bihar vide Memo No. 6656/P-3/CPS-5 dated
21.08.1994. After training, he joined service and was confirmed
with effect from 08.11.1997. During service, he was awarded
2026:JHHC:17287
the
Gallantry
Award/President
Police
Medal
twice;
first
pursuant to notification dated 22.02.1999, published in the
Gazette of India on 13.03.1999, and again vide notification
dated 18.10.2002, published on 23.11.2002.
4.
The petitioner is claiming benefit of three years’ seniority
under Letter No. 10785 dated 17.10.1998, which provides such
benefit to Gallantry Award/President Police Medal awardees for
promotion from Inspector of Police to Deputy Superintendent of
Police.
5.
The grievance of the petitioner is that in the seniority list
issued vide Memo No. 1120/P dated 22.05.2009, and final
seniority list vide Memo No. 1002 dated 30.04.2010, the said
benefit was not granted despite his objection dated 04.06.2009.
6.
According to the petitioner, if three years’ seniority had
been granted, his seniority as Inspector would have been
reckoned from 08.11.1994 instead of 08.11.1997, and he
would
have
been
considered
for
promotion
as
Deputy
Superintendent of Police in the year 2010, when juniors were
promoted vide Notification No. 2875 dated 17.05.2010.
However, the petitioner was promoted belatedly on
18.07.2012 vide Memo No. 3242.
7.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner submitted representation
dated 14.03.2016, but his claim was rejected vide Memo No.
1477/P dated 16.06.2016 on the ground that, since he had
2026:JHHC:17287
already been promoted; the matter had become infructuous. He
again submitted representation dated 27.09.2016, whereafter
the Inspector General of Police forwarded the matter to the
Home Department on 26.10.2016. The Home Department vide
Letter No. 87 dated 04.01.2017 directed reconsideration of his
claim, but no final relief / consequential relief was granted.
Being aggrieved by such action, the petitioner had preferred
the present writ application.
8.
Mr. Ajit Kumar, Ld. Sr. Counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioner had submitted that the respondents have acted
arbitrarily in not granting the petitioner the benefit of three
years’ seniority despite the fact that the petitioner admittedly
holds
the
Gallantry
Award/President
Police
Medal.
He
contended that Letter No. 10785 dated 17.10.1998 creates a
clear entitlement in favour of such gallantry awardees for grant
of three years’ seniority for the purpose of consideration of
promotion from Inspector of Police to Deputy Superintendent of
Police and the grounds taken by the Respondents cannot be
held as legal and justified to deny the benefits to which the
petitioner is otherwise entitled to as per the strict and
unambiguous provisions of the State’s own scheme / letter no.
10785 dated 17.10.1998.
9.
Learned Sr. Counsel had contended that the rejection of
the petitioner’s claim vide Memo No. 1477/P dated 16.06.2016
2026:JHHC:17287
on the ground that the matter had become infructuous after
his promotion to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police is
wholly misconceived. The grievance of the petitioner was not
merely for promotion simpliciter, but for correction of seniority
and shifting of the date of promotion to the post of Deputy
Superintendent of Police from 18.07.2012 to 17.05.2010, with
all consequential benefits, therefore, the subsequent promotion
of the petitioner could not have rendered his claim infructuous.
10.
Mr. Kumar lastly submitted that similarly situated police
officers, including one Ajay Kumar and other officers, were
granted seniority by modifying their seniority position in view of
the very same Letter No. 10785 dated 17.10.1998. The denial
of similar benefit to the petitioner, despite his distinguished
service record and gallantry awards, amounts to hostile
discrimination and is violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
11.
Per contra, Ld. Counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondents had submitted that the petitioner was appointed
as Sub-Inspector of Police in the year 1994 and his promotion
as Inspector of Police was granted with effect from 08.11.1997
therefore the petitioner’s claim for shifting the date of seniority
as Inspector of Police to 08.11.1994 is not sustainable, as in
the year 1994 itself the petitioner was appointed as SubInspector of Police. He further submitted that the petitioner has
2026:JHHC:17287
already been granted promotion to the post of Deputy
Superintendent of Police on 18.07.2012 and, therefore, the
claim made by him is not legally sustainable.
12.
He lastly submitted that the promotion granted to the
petitioner by the Home Department vide notification no. 3242
as Deputy Superintendent of Police from Inspector of Police
w.e.f. 18.07.2012 is as per the rules and requires no
interference as per the prayer made in the writ petition.
13.
However, Ld. Counsel representing the State could not
controvert the provisions of the State’s scheme as notified vide
Home Department letter no. 10785 dated 17.10.1998 which
provides for granting 3 years seniority to an officer with no
other ridder or conditions for denial of the same if the officer
concerned is a Gallantry Award / President Police Medal
recipient.
14.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon
perusal of the materials available on record, it appears that the
main grievance of the petitioner is that despite being awarded
the Gallantry Award/President Police Medal, he has been
denied the benefit of three years’ seniority under Letter No.
10785 dated 17.10.1998, and consequently he has been
deprived of consideration for promotion to the post of Deputy
Superintendent of Police from the date when his juniors were
promoted.
2026:JHHC:17287
15.
The main issues which arise for consideration before this
Court are as follows:
i. Whether the petitioner, being a recipient of the Gallantry
Award/President Police Medal, is entitled to the benefit of
three years’ seniority in terms of Letter No. 10785 dated
17.10.1998 issued by the Home Department, Government of
Bihar ?
ii. Whether the order contained in Memo No. 1477/P dated
16.06.2016, whereby the claim of the petitioner was
rejected as infructuous merely because he had already
been promoted to the post of Deputy Superintendent of
Police, is legally sustainable ?
iii. Whether the petitioner is entitled to correction/shifting of
his date of promotion to the post of Deputy Superintendent
of Police from 18.07.2012 to 17.05.2010, with all
consequential benefits ?
16.
With regard to the first issue, it appears that Letter No.
10785 dated 17.10.1998 clearly provides that a police officer
who has been awarded the Gallantry Award/President Police
Medal shall be granted seniority of three years for the purpose
of consideration of promotion from the post of Inspector of
Police to the post of Deputy Superintendent of Police. For
ready reference the relevant portion of Letter No. 10785 dated
17.10.1998 is quoted herein below:
“(4)
नर
म
17. The
वर यता
के
क/सूबेदार/प रबार
लए
ो न त म तीन वष क
petitioner
रा प त
पु लस
पदक
से
अलंकृत
आर ी
वर को ट के पदा धका रय को आर ी उपाधी क क को ट
ाथ मकता द जायेगी।”
admittedly
received
the
Gallantry
Award/President Police Medal and there is no dispute with
2026:JHHC:17287
regard to the fact that he was a recipient of such gallantry
recognition.
18. Once the policy decision contained in Letter No. 10785
dated 17.10.1998 is admitted and once the petitioner falls
within the class of police officers for whose benefit the said
policy was framed; denial of the said benefit to the petitioner
without assigning any legally sustainable reason cannot be
countenanced. The respondents are bound by their own policy
decision and cannot apply the same selectively.
19. The contention of the respondents that the petitioner
cannot be granted seniority from 08.11.1994 on the ground
that he was then serving as Sub-Inspector of Police does not
answer the real issue. The petitioner’s claim is not for actual
promotion as Inspector from 1994, but for grant of notional
seniority benefit of three years for the limited purpose of
consideration
of
promotion
from
Inspector
to
Deputy
Superintendent of Police, as contemplated under Letter No.
10785 dated 17.10.1998. The very object of the said policy is
to give accelerated seniority benefit to gallantry awardees.
Therefore, the respondents cannot defeat the policy by
mechanically stating that the petitioner was appointed as SubInspector in the year 1994.
20. It is further evident that in the case of similarly situated
officers, the benefit of three years’ seniority was granted by
2026:JHHC:17287
modifying their seniority position and this fact has not been
controverted by Ld. Counsel for the Respondents. Therefore,
denial of the same benefit to the petitioner, who is also a
gallantry awardee and has an unblemished and distinguished
service record, amounts to arbitrary and discriminatory
treatment.
21. Accordingly, the first issue is answered in favour of the
petitioner, and it is held that the petitioner is entitled to
consideration for grant of three years’ seniority in terms of
Letter No. 10785 dated 17.10.1998.
22. Now coming to the second issue, the order contained in
Memo No. 1477/P dated 16.06.2016 proceeds on the premise
that since the petitioner had already been promoted to the
post of Deputy Superintendent of Police, the matter had
become infructuous. Such reasoning is wholly misconceived.
The petitioner’s grievance did not come to an end merely
because he was promoted in the year 2012.
His grievance was that he ought to have been granted the
benefit of three years’ seniority and, on that basis, should have
been considered for promotion along with his juniors in the
year 2010 itself.
23. The right claimed by the petitioner was not merely for
promotion, but for correct seniority, correct date of promotion,
2026:JHHC:17287
and consequential benefits. Therefore, subsequent promotion
could not have rendered the dispute infructuous.
The impugned order dated 16.06.2016 reflects nonapplication of mind to the actual grievance of the petitioner
and is liable to be quashed. The second issue is accordingly
answered in favour of the petitioner.
24. With regard to the third issue, this Court finds that the
petitioner has specifically prayed for correction and shifting of
his date of promotion to the rank of Deputy Superintendent of
Police from 18.07.2012 to 17.05.2010, i.e., the date on which
juniors/others were granted promotion. Once it is held that
the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of three years’ seniority
in terms of Letter No. 10785 dated 17.10.1998; the natural
consequence would be that his case ought to have been
considered for promotion from the corrected seniority position.
The denial of such benefit resulted in the petitioner being
left out from consideration in the promotion exercise notified
vide Notification No. 2875 dated 17.05.2010, and he was
granted promotion only belatedly vide Memo No. 3242 dated
18.07.2012. Therefore, the petitioner cannot be made to suffer
for the inaction and erroneous approach of the respondents.
25. The third issue is accordingly answered in favour of the
petitioner.
2026:JHHC:17287
26. Accordingly,
in
view
of
the
discussions
made
hereinabove, this Court holds that the petitioner is entitled to
the benefit of three years’ seniority in terms of Letter No.
10785 dated 17.10.1998. Consequently, the order contained
in Memo No. 1477/P dated 16.06.2016, whereby the claim of
the petitioner was rejected as infructuous, is hereby, quashed
and set aside.
27. The respondents are directed to correct/revise the
seniority position of the petitioner by granting him the benefit
of three years’ seniority and, upon such correction, shift the
date of promotion of the petitioner to the post of Deputy
Superintendent of Police from 18.07.2012 to 17.05.2010, as
prayed for in the writ petition, with all consequential service
benefits,
including
seniority,
notional
fixation
of
pay,
pensionary benefits and other admissible benefits.
28. The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of
eight weeks from the date of receipt/production of a copy of
this order.
29. As a result, the instant writ petition stands allowed.
Pending I.A., if any, is also disposed of. No cost.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated:15/06/2026
Amardeep/
A.F.R
Uploaded on
16.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review