Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 3 of 2023
Date of Decision: 06.04.2023
Shri. Amit Kumar Shah
Vs.
Shri. Parvez Sharif
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. S. Sen, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
Oral:
1.
The case of the petitioner is that, he is a tenant of the
respondent who had instituted a suit for eviction, being Ejectment Suit
No. 25(H) of 2022, before the Court of the Assistant District Judge,
Shillong against him, and that even before his appearance in the case, the
electricity to the suit premises was disconnected. A Misc. Case was then
filed by the petitioner under Section 6 and 7 of the Meghalaya Urban
Areas Rent Control Act, read with Section 94 and 151 of the CPC, for
restoration of the electricity connection, before the Court of the Assistant
District Judge, Shillong, which by order dated 22.02.2023, while issuing
notice, also ordered that, in the interim the connection be restored
pending the disposal of the said Misc. Case.
2.
The respondent being aggrieved, then preferred an appeal
against the order dated 22.02.2023, under Section 8 of the Meghalaya
Urban Areas Rent Control Act, before the Court of the District Judge,
Shillong, and the same was registered as FAO No. 1(H) of 2023. The
Learned District Judge, thereafter, disposed of the appeal vide order
dated 06.03.2023, and set aside the order dated 22.02.2023, however,
without hearing the petitioner. The petitioner being highly aggrieved
thereby, has presented this petition under Article 227 for quashing and
setting aside the order dated 06.03.2023.
3.
Mr. S. Jindal, learned counsel on behalf of the petitioner
submits that, the impugned order is without jurisdiction, firstly as the
appeal was not maintainable as the order dated 22.02.2023, was not
appealable under Section 8, as it was an order granted under Section 7(1)
of the Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control Act, read with Section 94
of the CPC. Secondly, he submits that, the order dated 22.02.2023, was
an interim order and not a final adjudication of the matter, and the Lower
Appellate Court, should have allowed the Court of the Assistant District
Judge, to finally adjudicate the matter, and then entertain an appeal under
Section 8 of the Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control Act. He lastly
submits that, what compounds the illegality is that, the impugned order
was passed without any issuance of notice, or affording any opportunity
of hearing to the petitioner.
4.
Mr. S. Sen, learned counsel for the respondent submits that, the
appeal was occasioned in view of the patent illegality of the order dated
22.02.2023, passed by the Assistant District Judge in the Misc. Case,
inasmuch as, apart from not following the procedure under Section 7 of
the Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control Act, the same was also
entertained under Section 94 and 151 of the CPC. Learned counsel
submits that, Section 7(1) of the Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control
Act, mandates that notice on the application of the tenant seeking
maintenance of essential supplies is to be issued to the landlord, who is
to show cause to the same, only after which, effective orders can be
passed. The same not having been complied with, and the restoration of
electricity allowed by the Assistant District Judge, by order dated
22.02.2023, the learned counsel submits that, the impugned order only
corrected this position, by directing that due procedure be followed, and
an opportunity to show cause against the application of the petitioner be
given to the respondent.
5.
On another limb of submission, the learned counsel has
submitted that, Section 6 of the Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control
Act, only speaks of maintenance of existing essential supplies such as
supply of electricity etc., which he contends will not be attracted in the
present case, inasmuch as, the suit premises has been without an
electrical connection since 2020, and as such, is not an existing service.
He therefore submits that, the application of the petitioner before the
Assistant District Judge, itself is incompetent. It has also been further
submitted that, the petitioner has approached this Court, on his failure to
obtain a favourable order as to reconnection, after the last hearing which
was held on 24.03.2023, whereby the Trial Court had directed for
production of documents to establish the actual date, as to when the
electricity was disconnected. A copy of the order dated 24.03.2023, has
also been produced before this Court.
6.
Having heard learned counsels for the parties and on perusal of
the impugned order dated 06.03.2023, as well as the order dated
22.02.2023, it appears that the basic grievance of both the parties herein,
is the deprivation of the right to be heard, firstly by the respondent, when
the order for reconnection of electricity was passed by the Learned
Assistant District Judge, and by the petitioner when the said order was
set aside by the Learned District Judge on appeal.
7.
This Court therefore, as the matter has come by way of an
application under Article 227, is to examine whether the powers under
supervisory jurisdiction are to be exercised in the facts and circumstances
of the case. In this respect, it would be worthwhile and necessary to refer
to the order dated 22.02.2023, passed by the Assistant District Judge,
whereby the electricity connection was directed to be restored till the
disposal of the said Misc. Case. The order though interim in nature, had
directed for restoration of electricity, which as per Section 7(2) of the
Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control Act, which could have been
passed only after notice to the landlord to appear and show cause against
the application of the tenant. Section 7(1) and (2) which is relevant, is
quoted hereinbelow.
“Notice on landlord
to perform duties
7. (1) If the landlord neglects to make
such repairs or to maintain such
existing essential supplies and
services as he is bound to do under
the provisions of section 6, the
Court may, on the application of the
tenant, direct the landlord by notice
to appear before is and to show
cause against the application of the
tenant.
(2) If the landlord fails to show
sufficient cause, the court, the
Court may direct him to make such
repairs or as the case may be, to take
such measures for the restoration of
the essential supplies and services
as contemplated in section 6 within
a period fixed by the Court.”
8.
The grievance therefore of the respondent is founded upon
sufficient reason, as he was not heard nor allowed to show cause before
the order of restoration of electricity was passed. Though the order dated
22.02.2023, is not under direct challenge, it is however, central to the
proceedings which are now before this Court and as such, deserves
consideration.
9.
Coming to the impugned order dated 06.03.2023, it is also noted
that, the appeal was disposed of without affording any opportunity to the
petitioner, which in effect has also deprived him of an opportunity to
defend his case. Though, technical objections as to its maintainability
have also been raised by the petitioner, looking into the totality of the
facts and circumstances of the case, as observed earlier, the baseline is
that, both the orders in question were passed after hearing only one side.
Further, this Court also cannot ignore the fact that, the matter is still
under contest before the Court of the Assistant District Judge, as
evidenced by the order dated 24.03.2023.
10.
This Court in exercise of powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution, is not sitting as an Appellate Court over the orders of the
Court below, but in exercise of supervisory jurisdiction is to see as to
whether the proceedings are within the set parameters. Judicial
intervention under Article 227 of the Constitution, is to be exercised not
to correct errors of law or fact, but to ensure that, the Courts below are
within the bounds of their jurisdiction and is to be exercised sparingly.
In the instant case, as can be seen from the discussions above, the
invocation of Article 227 of the Constitution, is warranted only to the
extent to ensure that fair procedure in accordance with law is maintained
by the Courts below, which was denied to the petitioner, as well as to the
respondent in the entire proceedings, commencing from the order dated
22.02.2023, to the impugned order dated 06.03.2023.
11.
In these circumstances therefore, to correct the course of the
proceedings, the impugned order dated 06.03.2023, is set aside and the
parties relegated to resume the proceedings before the Court of the
Assistant District Judge, in Misc. C/ No. 1(H) 2023/T.S C/No. 25(H)
2022. It is further directed that, the Court of the Assistant District Judge,
notwithstanding the setting aside of the impugned order, is to
recommence the proceedings from the order dated 24.03.2023, in
accordance with law, especially keeping in mind the provisions of the
Meghalaya Urban Areas Rent Control Act, before any further orders are
passed as to the restoration of electricity in the suit premises.
12.
As ordered above, this Revision Petition is accordingly
disposed of.
13.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
06.04.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review