Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on : 29th May 2026
Pronounced on : 02nd July 2026
Uploaded on : 03rd July 2026
+
MAC.APP. 629/2013 & CM APPL. 4888/2014CM APPL.
4889/2014
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pankaj Seth and Ms. Shruti
Jain, Mr. Shaumik Mazumdar,
Advs.
versus
SHYAM SUNDER & ORS.
Through:
+
.....Respondents
Mr Manish Maini, Adv. Amicus
Curiae for claimants
MAC.APP. 725/2013
AMIT KALRA & ANR
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. V.N. Jha and Mr. B.K. Singh,
Advs.
versus
+
SHYAM SUNDER & ANR
.....Respondents
Through:
Mr Manish Maini, Adv. Amicus
Curiae for claimant
Mr. Pankaj Seth and Ms. Shruti
Jain, Mr. Shaumik Mazumdar,
Advs. For Insurance Co.
MAC.APP. 194/2014
SHYAM SUNDER
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr Manish Maini, Adv. Amicus
Curiae
versus
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
1/24
AMIT KALRA & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. V.N. Jha and Mr. B.K. Singh,
Advs. for R-1 & 2.
Mr. Pankaj Seth and Ms. Shruti
Jain, Mr. Shaumik Mazumdar,
Advs. for Insurance Co.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
The judgment shall dispose of three appeals in relation to the
accident which occurred on 18th July 2002, when Shyam Sunder suffered
grievous injuries due to a collision which occurred near Mool Chand
flyover, New Delhi allegedly with the offending vehicle Maruti van
bearing registration No. DL-3CF-0772; while another vehicle, a TSR/Auto
was also allegedly involved in the collision. The Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal (‘MACT’) awarded a compensation of Rs.10,79,229/- along with
interest @9% per annum:
(i)
MAC.APP. 629/2013 has been filed by the Insurance
Company seeking to set aside the impugned award, primarily
on the ground that the offending vehicle i.e. Maruti Van was
not involved in the accident; instead it was the TSR/auto that
was involved in the accident.
(ii)
MAC.APP. 725/2013 has been filed by driver and owner of
the Maruti Van namely, Amit Kalra and Rajiv Kumar Singh,
seeking setting aside of the impugned award on the ground
that the accident did not occur due to the rash and negligent
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
2/24
driving of the Maruti van; instead it was the TSR/auto that
was involved in the accident.
(iii)
MAC.APP. 194/2014 has been filed by the injured/appellant
claiming enhancement of compensation by a sum of
Rs.15,00,000/-.
The impugned award
2.
In deciding Issue No. 1 relating to causation and negligence, the
MACT noted the broad circumstances in which the accident took place.
Shyam Sunder/claimant at about 01:15 p.m. on 18th July 2002 alleged that
when he was travelling on his two-wheeler scooter bearing Registration
No. DL-3SZ-0794 near Mool Chand flyover, a Maruti van collided with
him. He was rushed to the hospital on the same day and discharged on 02nd
August 2002, but yet again was hospitalised and finally discharged on 07th
August 2002. He suffered spinal fracture resulting in 75% disability and
he was rendered paraplegic.
3.
The driver/owner claimed that the accident had not been caused by
Maruti van, but the claimant collided with a stationary TSR. It was further
argued that the Maruti van was not being driven by Amit Kalra, the alleged
driver, but by its owner Rajiv Kumar Singh. It was claimed that the Maruti
van was just passing through; having seen the accident of claimant with
the auto and as a good Samaritan took him to the hospital and paid the
initial deposit for his medical expenses. It was alleged that since the TSR
was not insured, the claimant has sought to fasten liability on the Maruti
van.
4.
Rajpal Singh, the Investigating Officer (‘IO’), deposed as R2W3;
the treating doctor, Dr. Arun Goel also testified as R2W5.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
3/24
5.
The MACT noted that the claimant at all stages had confirmed that
the accident had occurred due to the erring driver Amit Kalra, who was
plying the white colour Maruti van and the testimony remained unshaken.
On the other hand, there were material deviations in the cross-examination
of the driver/owner regarding the mode and manner of the accident. Taking
into account other facts and circumstances and on the assessment of
evidence, it was held basis preponderance of probabilities that the accident
was caused by the offending vehicle. Accordingly, compensation was
computed as under:
Submissions on behalf of the Insurance Company
6.
Mr. Pankaj Seth, counsel for Insurance Company, canvassed the
appeal on the following grounds: firstly, that driver of the offending
vehicle was not holding any driving licence and he had been chargesheeted, though acquitted later and, therefore, recovery rights ought to
have been granted against driver and owner; secondly, that the offending
vehicle was not involved in the accident and the same has been recorded
in the MLC, wherein it was noted that the road traffic accident happened
with auto No. 5368, given by the patient who was conscious, and the
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
4/24
Maruti Van was implicated after about 7-10 days of the accident; thirdly,
the IO proceeded with the enquiry after receiving complaint regarding the
Maruti van. During that process, the driver was arrested and later released.
The Mechanical Inspection was carried out on 07th October 2002, after
three months from the date of the accident.
7.
Aside from the MLC, Mr. Seth, counsel for Insurance Company,
relied on the Mechanical Inspection Report, which did not show any
notable damage on the vehicle and that the patient was stated to be
conscious, oriented and cooperative and, therefore, the reporting in the
MLC that the accident happened with auto was possibly correct.
Submissions on behalf of the driver/owner
8.
Mr. V. N. Jha, counsel for driver and owner, pointed out that Amit
Kalra had been acquitted in the criminal case in FIR No. 471/2002 under
Sections 279/338 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and that the Maruti van
was driven by Rajiv Kumar Singh, owner of the Maruti Van, on the date
of the accident. The injured heard name of Amit when he was being
transported. Since there was no way the injured who was driving ahead of
the Maruti van would know who was driving the Maruti van. Amit Kalra
did not possess a driving licence and there was no reason why he would
have been driving the vehicle instead of Rajiv Kumar Singh.
9.
The counsel for Amit Kalra, therefore, stated that the liability to pay
compensation would rest with the Insurance Company since Rajiv Kumar
Singh was driving the Maruti van and possessed a licence but Amit Kalra
did not possess the license.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
5/24
Submissions on behalf of the claimant through Amicus Curiae
10.
Mr. Manish Maini, Advocate, was appointed as Amicus Curiae by
this Court’s order dated 19th May 2026, since the claimant was from
weaker section of the society and was not being represented properly.
11.
Mr. Manish Maini, Amicus Curiae, contended that the persons in
the Maruti van took the injured to the hospital and paid the hospital charges
which showed guilty intent, that they had caused the accident. Moreover,
the injured was in a semi-conscious state at the time he was taken to the
hospital and, therefore, his statement that the TSR had been responsible
for the accident may not be taken seriously. On the contrary, the accident
happened due to Maruti van coming from the back side in fast and
negligent manner and hit the scooter from the rear.
12.
Moreover, R2W5, Dr. Arun Goel testified that he had not prepared
the MLC. It was further contended that the statement of MLC was
influenced by the driver and the owner, as it is not the attending doctor
which gives the factum of the accident.
13.
As regard the Mechanical Inspection Report, it was submitted that
the Maruti van was being plied at a high speed and hit against a scooter
but may not have damages to the body as the front bumper of Maruti van
is made of plastic which may not been damaged otherwise and in any
event, it was done 3 months after the accident. In the reply to notice under
Section 133 given to the owner, no mention has been made as to who was
driving the vehicle at the time of the accident, and it just mentions that
Amit Kalra was ‘present with him’ on the date of the accident.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
6/24
Analysis
14.
Dramatis personae in this case have canvassed different versions of
the incident. Therefore, it might be useful to first unravel who was
probably responsible for the accident. The accident occurred on 18 th July
2002 near Moolchand flyover, Delhi. FIR No. 471/2002 was registered at
P.S. Lajpat Nagar under Sections 279/338 of IPC on 18th July 2002 itself.
The injured was admittedly taken to Moolchand Hospital by Amit Kalra
in the offending vehicle where his MLC was prepared.
15.
The MLC, exhibited as Ex.CW1/A, notes that the injured was
brought in at 01.45 p.m. on 18th July 2002, recording that there is an
alleged history of road traffic accident over Moolchand flyover with an
auto/TSR bearing No.5368. It was further noted that patient was conscious,
oriented and cooperative, but was unable to move both the lower limbs and
there were other injuries which were marked as ‘dangerous’. Accordingly,
the referral was made to surgery.
16.
Dr. Arun Goel, Consultant/Orthopaedic Surgeon and Head of
Orthopaedics Moolchand Hospital (R2W5) gave his testimony on 17th
October 2012, and brought along with him the records of the patient. He
stated that the injured had remained conscious throughout treatment and
he was in hospital till 19th July 2002 and due to poor prognosis, took
discharge and left the hospital in night on the same day. In his crossexamination, he confirmed that the MLC was not prepared in his presence
and he was not the person who recorded the history of the accident on the
MLC. He stated that he did see the patient on the next day. Usually, an
enquiry is made from the patient about the history, cause of injury and a
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
7/24
separate note is made, in case the history does not tally with what was
stated in the MLC.
17.
He, therefore, stated that since there was no separate note, he was
of the view that the history told by the patient may be the same as recorded
earlier. It is also stated that consulting doctor does not deeply go into the
details of the involvement of the vehicle or whether vehicle’s number if it
is reflected/recorded properly.
18.
Mr. Maini argued that Amit Kalra had been charge-sheeted for rash
and negligent driving and they did not complain or give any representation
for false implication in the FIR. Moreover, no attempt was made by the
driver/owner to summon and examine the TSR driver to substantiate their
version of the occurrence of the accident. This contention by Mr. Maini is
of some importance, considering that a huge challenge has been launched
by the owner/driver regarding the non-involvement in the accident and it
would have been easy enough for them to summon the TSR driver in order
that his testimony could be placed on record.
19.
Mr. Maini relied upon the statement of appellant/injured himself
which gave the colour, description and registration number of the
offending vehicle and name of the driver, as also the testimony of PW3,
Meenu, wife of petitioner, who testified that respondent no.1/Amit Kalra
had apologized to her for his mistake.
20.
Perusal of the testimony of PW3 is important. In the cross-
examination, she states that when she got the information of the accident
telephonically, she rushed to the hospital, found her husband to have
already been examined and the police was present. She stated that “the fact
regarding the running of the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner, was
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
8/24
disclosed to me by my husband at the hospital” and “respondent no.1/Amit
Kalra had also apologized before me for his mistake”. She further stated
that no three-wheeler/auto person had contacted them and neither did the
owner of the vehicle Rajiv Kumar Singh visited the house at any point of
time. The husband could not attend the TIP proceedings in the criminal
case owing to the fact that he was not in a proper medical condition. She
denied that the accident was caused due to the negligence of a threewheeler.
21.
PW1, the injured claimant’s testimony has to be considered with
some focus. PW1 denied that the accident has not occurred due to Maruti
van. He stated that he was conscious when he reached the hospital and a
statement was recorded by the police at the hospital. He specifically stated
that the right side of the scooter had been broken due to the accident but
does not remember what was the distance between the scooter and the
TSR. He disclosed to the police that one Maruti van hit the scooter.
22.
The testimony of the Amit Kalra is also to be assessed carefully. He
states that the claimant was driving a scooter at a very high speed and one
TSR was going ahead of the claimant. The three-wheeler stopped suddenly
and the claimant could not stop himself from driving and, therefore,
collided with the stationary three-wheeler. He further stated that the
Maruti Van was driven by Rajiv Kumar Singh and he was sitting inside the
Maruti Van. They had helped the claimant as good Samaritans. He
admitted in his cross-examination that he did not have any driving license
and was sitting in the van along with Rajiv Kumar Singh. He further stated
that he had written to the police authority regarding false implication, but
that complaint was not placed on record.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
9/24
23.
The testimony of the IO examined as R2W3 is notable. He states in
his examination-in-chief that he received one DD No. 8A, after which, he
went to Moolchand Hospital, saw injured Shyam Sunder, who was
hospitalized. The MLC was received by him and prepared on his request.
The treating doctor reported the injured to be unfit for making his
statement. He went to the spot and found one TSR and one Bajaj Chetak
scooter. He seized both the vehicles and sent the tehrir for registration as
FIR. The FIR was lodged basis of DD entry and MLC result. The statement
of the injured had not been recorded till the registration of the FIR. Later,
he recorded the statement of the complainant but did not remember the
date, but could be after 10 to 15 days after the accident.
24.
On the allegation of the claimant that the vehicle was being driven
by Amit Kalra, he made the search and came to know that the vehicle was
owned by someone else and notice under Section 133 had been given. The
owner produced the vehicle and Amit Kalra when he was arrested and the
van was seized. The injured did not participate in the TIP, due to which,
the TIP could not be conducted. Later, a charge-sheet was filed and
Mechanical Inspection Report (MIR) was requisitioned. He states that as
per the MIR, damage was seen on the scooter and TSR, but no damages
were seen on a Maruti van. He stated that on 18th July 2002 when he
reached the hospital, Shyam Sunder was not conscious.
25.
R2W3 in his cross examination stated that he did not arrest the TSR
driver as there was no allegation against him. He also stated that Amit
Kalra when asked about the DL, said that he was not holding the same. He
did not receive the papers of insurance policy of TSR and stated that “I
cannot say that the accident occurred due to the TSR as has also been
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
10/24
shown by the site plan and has no liability of the Maruti Van.” He further
states that “I say that the probability of TSR hitting the scooter and causing
accident is remote as the TSR was ahead of the scooter and the van was
behind it”. He stated that Rajiv Kumar Singh, owner of the Maruti van,
never told him that he was plying the vehicle at the time of the accident,
denied the suggestion that he falsely implicated the Maruti van. He further
reiterated in another cross-examination that the injured was not conscious
when he reached the hospital and he was not fit for statement.
26.
Testimony with respect to the Mechanical Inspection Report was
given by R2W4, Shadi Lal, retired Foreman. He stated in his crossexamination that he could not say whether the TSR and Bajaj scooter both
suffered accident with each other as he has not visited the place. He stated
that the damages on the Maruti van may not be visible since the front
bumper is of plastic and few scratches can be noted. It was also stated that
‘I cannot say that the TSR may have hit the scooter as it is noted that its
front tyre of the TSR has been found bursted”
27.
Reference may also be made to the statement of Shyam Sunder
recorded before the police on 21st July 2002. He stated that when he was
coming from his office and reached Moolchand flyover, a Maruti car hit
him from behind. He fell on the side and due to the high speed, the Maruti
van also hit the three-wheeler and then the owner of the Maruti van
stopped the van on the same place. Some people put him in the Maruti van.
After the accident when he reached hospital, he told the doctor details and
later on became unconscious. He had heard the name of the driver as Amit
in the vehicle.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
11/24
28.
Counsel for Amit Kalra relied upon the statements made by the
claimant in his cross-examination in the criminal case, where he stated “I
do not remember which vehicle was going ahead of me at the time of
accident. There was no collision with the vehicle which was moving ahead
of my vehicle” and that “I do not remember whether the police have
recorded my statement. I do not remember I have ever made my statement
before the police. I had filed the complaint with the police after about one
and a half week of the accident. The complaint was filed by my wife”.
29.
In comparing the testimonies of PW3, wife of injured and R2W3
/IO, counsel contended that the testimony of the wife was falsified since
when the police reached the hospital the claimant was unconscious,
whereas as per PW3 when she reached the hospital the police was already
present. If the accident being caused by Maruti van was known to PW3,
there is no reason why the complaint was made 2 weeks after the accident.
Therefore, the statement is an afterthought.
30.
Moreover, testimony of the IO that they did not report for the TIP
and TIP could not be conducted was also asserted. It was further stated
that the Amit Kalra was acquitted in the Criminal Case No.355/2014 by
Judgment dated 22nd August 2015. Rajiv Kumar Singh in the response
statement recorded pursuant to Notice under Section 133 of the MV Act
stated that he was producing Amit Kalra who was seated along with him
in the vehicle.
31.
It is pertinent to note that a notice under Section 133 of the Motor
Vehicles Act was issued to the owner of the offending Maruti Van bearing
registration No. DL-6CF-0772, namely Rajiv Kumar Singh. By the said
notice, the owner was specifically directed to produce the driver, with or
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
12/24
without the vehicle, on 7th October 2002 to facilitate completion of the
investigation. In response to the said notice, Rajiv Kumar Singh produced
Amit Kalra before the Investigating Officer and stated that Amit Kalra had
been “seated with him” in the offending vehicle on 18 July 2002.
32.
This circumstance assumes considerable significance for two
reasons. Firstly, the notice required the owner only to produce the driver
of the offending vehicle. Therefore, when the owner produced Amit Kalra
in compliance with the notice, the natural and logical inference is that Amit
Kalra was the person driving the vehicle at the relevant time. It would be
wholly artificial to presume that the owner, when specifically directed to
produce the driver, instead produced a person who was merely an occupant
of the vehicle.
33.
Secondly, the owner's statement that Amit Kalra was "seated along
with him" is, by itself, vague and does not expressly clarify whether Amit
Kalra was driving the vehicle. However, that ambiguity stands resolved
when the statement is read in conjunction with the purpose of the notice
under Section 133. Since Amit Kalra was produced in response to a
direction requiring production of the driver, the only reasonable inference
is that he was, in fact, the driver of the offending vehicle at the time of the
accident.
34.
This inference is further fortified by the evidence of R2W3, who, in
his cross-examination, categorically stated that Rajiv Kumar Singh had
never informed him that he himself was driving the Maruti Van at the time
of the accident. Thus, there is no contemporaneous evidence to support the
owner's subsequent claim that he was the driver.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
13/24
35.
The MACT, in paragraph 34 of the impugned award, rightly
concluded that the offending vehicle was being driven by Amit Kalra. The
Tribunal based its finding on (i) the testimony of the injured witness,
which remained unimpeached in cross-examination, (ii) the production of
Amit Kalra pursuant to the notice issued under Section 133 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, and (iii) the evidence of the IO, who confirmed that Amit
Kalra had been produced in compliance with the said notice. This Court
finds no infirmity in the appreciation of evidence by the Tribunal.
Accordingly, the finding that Amit Kalra was the driver of the offending
vehicle is affirmed.
36.
It is also significant that the response to the notice under Section
133 was furnished in the year 2002, contemporaneously with the
investigation. In contrast, the affidavits of Amit Kalra (R1W1) and Rajiv
Kumar Singh (R2W2) were filed only in 2009, nearly seven years later.
Their cross-examinations were conducted even later, in 2011 and 2012,
respectively. These subsequent assertions, made after the lapse of several
years and contrary to the contemporaneous documentary record, do not
inspire confidence and appear to be a clear afterthought intended to evade
liability.
37.
Further, it is admitted by the Amit Kalra/ R1W1 in his cross
examination by Insurance Company that he was produced along with the
alleged offending vehicle before the IO, and he was subsequently arrested.
This read along with response to the Section 133 notice and the testimony
of IO/ R2W3, it cannot be doubted that that Amit Kalra was driving the
offending vehicle at the time of the accident.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
14/24
38.
For these reasons, the findings recorded by the MACT regarding the
identity of the driver are based on a proper appreciation of the evidence on
record and warrant no interference.
39.
In the opinion of this Court the plea of Insurance Company that
offending vehicle was not involved in the accident, is untenable and
unacceptable.
40.
Firstly, there is no forensic evidence that the accident occurred due
to the TSR, as has been otherwise asserted by Amit Kalra and Rajeev
Kumar Singh, or by the Insurance Company. Quite to the contrary,
IO/R2W3 in his cross examination stated that he could not say that
accident occurred due to the TSR, as has been shown in the site plan. He
further stated that probability of the TSR causing accident is remote.
Secondly, testimony of R2W4, the foreman who had done the mechanical
inspection, also denied any confirmation that TSR may have hit the
scooter, as it was noted that the front tyre of the TSR was found burst.
Thirdly, per testimony of PW1, injured claimant, suggestion that accident
had not occurred due to Maruti Van was denied. Fourthly, no attempt was
made by Amit Kalra and Rajeev Kumar Singh, driver and owner, to
summon TSR driver in order to substantiate their claim that the accident
had occurred with TSR. Fifthly, as stated subsequently, mechanical
inspection of the scooter of claimant shows that rear number plate had been
bent. Sixthly, there is also evidence of PW3, wife of injured claimant
whose testimony accused Amit Kalra for having caused accident in
question. Seventhly, that FIR and charge-sheet was filed against Amit
Kalra, and even though he was acquitted, issue of negligence will have to
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
15/24
be seen on preponderance of probability rather than beyond reasonable
doubt which obviously formed basis of order of acquittal.
41.
Keeping all these points in mind, the Court notes that the MACT
was not amiss in finding that accident occurred due to negligent driving of
Amit Kalra, driver of the offending vehicle.
42.
Counsel for driver/Amit Kalra submitted that Amit Kalra was
acquitted in the criminal case (FIR no. 471/2002 under Sections 279/338
of Indian Penal Code, 1860) vide judgment dated 22nd August 2015 passed
by Metropolitan Magistrate. However, in this regard the judgment of
Supreme Court in N.K.V. Bros. (P) Ltd. v. M. Karumai Ammal, (1980) 3
SCC 457, wherein it was held that acquittal of driver does not bar civil
liability, as standard of culpable rashness is higher in criminal case than
the negligence required in tort law, is taken into consideration and the plea
on behalf of Amit Kalra is therefore rejected.
43.
Having held that Amit Kalra was driving the offending vehicle, it
stands established that he did not possess either a valid driving license or
even a learner's license on the date of the accident. Consequently, the issue
raised by the appellant-insurance company regarding its entitlement to
recovery rights falls for consideration.
Recovery Rights
44.
The MACT, in paragraph 33 of the impugned award, held that Amit
Kalra, being the driver of the offending vehicle, was the principal
tortfeasor, while Rajiv Kumar Singh, as the owner, and the insurer were
jointly and vicariously liable to satisfy the award. In light of the finding
that Amit Kalra was driving the vehicle without a valid driving license, it
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
16/24
becomes necessary to examine whether the insurer has established breach
of the policy conditions so as to entitle it to pay the compensation to the
claimants in the first instance with liberty to recover the same from the
owner and driver in accordance with law.
45.
The Supreme Court in various judgments, right from National
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Swara Singh, 2004 3 SCC 97, Parminder
Singh v New India Assurance Co. Ltd. 2019 (7) SCC 217 and Shamanna
v The Divisional Manager Oriental Insurance Ltd. 2018 (9) SCC 650 has
deliberated upon the principle of pay and recover. No doubt, the Supreme
Court states that the insurance companies have to establish the available
defenses and the breach of part of owner of the vehicle and the burden of
proof being on them, in the peculiar facts of this case, it is quite evident
that the owner, Rajiv Kumar Singh has made a concerted attempt to
obfuscate the factum of Amit Kalra driving the offending vehicle. This is
evident from the response to the notice under Section 133 of the Motor
Vehicles Act and the delay in filing of affidavits by Amit Kalra/R1W1 and
Rajiv Kumar Singh/ R2W2. Moreover, it also stands in contrast to the
testimony provided by PW3, who stated that Amit Kalra had apologized
to her in the hospital for his mistake.
46.
Clearly, a serious attempt was made in order to cover up the issue
of driving the offending vehicle by an unlicensed Amit Kalra. Therefore,
the Court is inclined to grant recovery rights to Insurance Company in this
regard.
47.
It is not as if insurance company has not chosen to cross examine
Amit Kalra and Rajiv Kumar Singh on the issue of lack of a valid license
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
17/24
and Amit Kalra driving the offending vehicle. In this regard the following
extracts may be relevant and are produced as under:
(i)
Cross Examination of Amit Kalra/ R1W1 by Insurance
Company— “it is correct that on 07.10.2002, Rajiv Kumar Singh
produced me under the reply under section 133 MV Act before
the IO as I was sitting in the van bearing no. DL 6C F-0772 with
Mr. Rajiv Singh, who was driving. It is correct that Rajiv Kumar
Singh produced me before the IO along with the alleged
offending vehicle. it is correct that I was arrested by the IO
concerned in the case FIR No.471/2002 under Sec 279/338 IPC,
PS Lajpat Nagar. It is correct that I have not issued any DL at
the time of the alleged accident…. It is wrong to suggest that I
named Rajiv Kumar Singh as the driver of the alleged offending
vehicle to rescue from the claim”
(ii)
Cross Examination of Rajiv Kumar Singh/ R2W2 by Insurance
Company — “it is incorrect that on 18.07.2002, my Maruti Car
no. DL6CF0772 was being driven by Amit Kalra. It was driven
by me….It is wrong to suggest that I am trying to save Amit Kalra
from present prosecution as he was not holding DL when he
caused the accident.”
48.
Accordingly, the MACT having reached a finding on the identity of
the driver being Amit Kalra and this Court not inclined to displace the said
finding, the right of recovery should consequently follow.
49.
Rajiv Kumar Singh at no stage has given any evidence in relation to
the fact that he did check the license and exercised due diligence.
Obviously, this evidence was not provided since the stand of Rajiv Kumar
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
18/24
Singh was that Amit Kalra was not driving the vehicle. Moreover, counsel
for Rajiv Kumar Singh/ owner specifically admitted that Amit Kalra did
not have a valid license.
50.
The assertions by Amit Kalra that the accident actually occurred
with an auto and mechanical inspection report of the Maruti Van stated
that there was no dent in the front bumper to justify a rear end collision
with the scooter. However, what has not been noticed is the mechanical
inspection report of the scooter which was being driven by the injured/
claimant on the date of the accident, the said report notes the following
damages: 1. Right hand bend, 2. & damage, 3. Scratches on the right hand,
4. W.S Beading, 5. Front Left Chassis bend, 6. Clutch mutha broken, 7.
Handle bend, 8. Stepnee cover tornout 9. Rear no. plate bend.
51.
Notably the finding at Sr. No. 10 reflects that the rear number plate
was bent which clearly justified the assertion of the claimant that there was
a rear collision. As regards to the auto being involved, it has been found
that there was tyre-burst. In this regard the testimony of Shadi Lal as
R2W4, the retired foreman who had conducted the Mechanical Inspection
Report would be relevant, as narrated in paragraph 26 above, question of
offending vehicle Maruti Van, driven by Amit Kalra, causing collision
cannot be doubted.
52.
Accordingly, MAC APP. 629/2013 filed by the Insurance
Company on the ground that offending vehicle was not involved in the
accident, stands dismissed. MAC APP 725/2013 filed by Amit Kalra and
Rajiv Kumar Singh on ground that accident did not occur due to rash and
negligent driving of Maruti Van also stands dismissed. Recovery rights, as
discussed above, are granted to the Insurance Company.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
19/24
Quantum of Compensation
53.
Residual issue relates to enhancement of compensation sought by
claimants. In this regard, Mr. Manish Maini, Amicus Curiae contended that
the MACT had erred in adopting the claimants net salary at Rs.5,481/- per
month of the claimant after deductions towards statutory benefits like
GPF, CGHS, CGEGIS etc. As per the salary slip of appellant, gross salary
was Rs.8,754/- per month.
54.
Further, no compensation was given towards loss of earning
capacity despite the fact that the injured was totally incapacitated for his
entire life which led to loss of marketability. A multiplier of ‘9’ ought to
have been taken post-retirement to calculate loss of earning capacity. The
claimant was a national level football player and had a promising sports
career which got ruined after the accident.
55.
The compensation towards non-pecuniary heads was also
inadequate, considering the permanent disability was assessed at 75% with
respect to the whole body. Mr. Maini submits that the injured was wheel
chair bound and was living at the mercy of the family and accordingly,
suffered 100% functional disability.
56.
On the issue of deductions from the gross salary, Mr. Maini has
relied upon the decision of the Supreme Court in Manasvi Jain v. Delhi
Transport Corporation Ltd. & Ors. (2014) 13 SCC 12, wherein it was
held that deductions on account of Provident Fund, GIS, house rent, were
not to be deducted from the monthly salary. Reliance can also be placed
on decision of Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indira
Srivastava & Ors. (2008) 2 SCC 763, Meenakshi v. Oriental Insurance
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
20/24
Co. Ltd. 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1872, Manorma Sinha v. Divisional
Manager Oriental Insurance Ltd. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2241, Triveni
Kodkany v. Air India Ltd. (2021) 19 SCC 214 and Sebastiani Lakra &
Ors. v. National Insurance Company Ltd., (2019) 17 SCC 465, wherein
the allowances which were beneficial to the members of the entire family
were considered as part of the pay packet. Deductions on account of
insurance, pensionary benefits and gratuity cannot be made from the
income, since these amounts are earned by the deceased during his lifetime
and are separate from the compensation granted to dependents under the
MV Act.
57.
The Court has perused the payslip of claimant and finds that he was
on a pay-scale of Postal Assistant (4000-100-6000) and on a gross salary
of Rs.8,754/- per month. In view of the above cited decisions, the
deductions towards GPF, CGHS and CGEGIS would form part of the
salary as has been enunciated by the Supreme Court in various decisions.
Accordingly, salary of would taken at Rs.8,754/- per month.
58.
The Disability Certificate assessed the permanent physical
disability at 75% with respect to the whole body and he was 35 years of
age on the date when this determination had been done. The claim which
has been made is of the potentiality of earning post-retirement at the age
of 60. Reliance can be placed on the judgment of this Court in Govind
Singh Mauni v Tej Bhan & Ors. 2026: DHC:1020 in relation to
potentiality of earning post-retirement, multiplier of 9 would be taken for
loss of earning capacity, the judgment relied upon the decisions of
Coordinate Bench in Desh Raj Singh Gautum v Sunil Kumar 2016: DHC
4159 and Rajbir Singh v National Insurance Company Ltd & Ors.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
21/24
2024:DHC:9034.Accordingly, the multiplier of 9 shall be adopted. As
regard future prospects, injured was under 40 years of age at the time of
the accident and was employed with Department of Post, therefore, based
on the principles enunciated in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay
Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680, future prospects are taken at 50%.
59.
Considering that he suffered from 75% permanent disable, and was
wheelchair bound, the Court is inclined to consider his functional
disability at 75% itself, basis the principles enunciated in Raj Kumar v.
Ajay Kumar & Anr., (2011) 1 SCC 343.
60.
As regards non pecuniary heads, considering the functional
disability at 75%, the compensation awarded under non pecuniary heads
is inadequate. Accordingly, the compensation awarded under head of pain
and suffering is enhanced to Rs.2,00,000/- and an amount of Rs. 2,00,000/is awarded under the head of loss of amenities of life.
61.
The revised compensation is computed as under:
S. no
Heads of Compensation
Awarded by
Awarded by
tribunal
the Court
Rs. 1,25,469/-
Rs. 1,25,469/-
Pecuniary Loss
1.
Treatment Expenses (A)
2.
Expenditure on special Rs. 30,000/-
Rs. 30,000/-
diet and conveyance (B)
3.
Attendant Charges (C)
Rs. 6,65,856/-
4.
Income of injured per Rs. 5,584/-
Rs. 6,65,856/Rs. 8,754/-
month (D)
5.
Future prospects @ 50% Nil
Rs. 4,377/-
(E)
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
22/24
6.
Functional disability (F)
75%
75%
7.
Multiplier (G)
Nil
8.
Loss of income (C x 6)
Rs.32,904/-
Rs. 52,524/-
9.
Loss of future income
Rs. 2,00,000/-
Rs. 10,63,611/-
[(D+E) x 12 x F x G]= H
(Lumpsum
towards
disability)
Non-pecuniary loss
10.
Pain and suffering (I)
Rs. 50,000/-
11.
Loss of Amenities of Life Nil
Rs. 2,00,000/Rs. 2,00,000/-
(J)
12.
Less Interim Award
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 25,000/-
13.
Total
Rs. 10,79,229/- Rs. 23,12,460/-
14.
Enhanced Compensation
Rs. 12,33,231/-
15.
Interest
9%
9%
Directions
62.
In view of the above, the compensation is enhanced by Rs.
12,33,231/-.
63.
By order dated 18th July 2013, this Court had directed the Insurance
Company to deposit the entire originally awarded amount before Registrar
General of this Court to be kept in FDR in auto renewal mode, subject to
which there shall be stay on the execution of the impugned award. By order
dated 08th October 2013 it was directed that 50% of the deposited amount
shall be released in favour of claimant in terms of the impugned order
passed by the tribunal.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
23/24
64.
It is directed that the balance amount deposited with the Registrar
General of this Court along with accrued interest shall be disbursed to the
claimant in terms of the directions of the MACT in the impugned award.
65.
Enhanced amount along with 9% interest per annum from the date
of filing the petition shall be deposited before the Registrar General of this
Court within a period of four weeks. It is directed that a lump sum amount
of Rs. 2,00,000/- shall be released to the claimant from the deposit of
enhanced amount within a period of two weeks thereafter. Remaining
enhanced amount, along with accrued interest, shall be kept in Fixed
Deposit Receipts (FDRs) of Rs. 25,000/- each for periods of 3 month, 6
months, 9 months and so on, in succession as maybe calculated. Interest
accruing on said FDRs shall be credited to the designated Savings Bank
Account of claimant. The amount of FDRs on maturity would be released
to the Savings Bank Account of claimant upon due verification.
66.
The Appeals stand disposed of in above terms. Pending
applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
67.
Statutory deposit be refunded to appellant/Insurance Company, only
if the order of deposit has been complied with.
68.
A copy of this judgment be sent to the concerned bank for
information and compliance.
69.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
ANISH DAYAL
(JUDGE)
JULY 2, 2026/mk+ak+sm/zb
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
14:56:15
MAC.APP. 629/2013
24/24
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review