Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No.37524 OF 2021
AND
WRIT PETITION No.'16757 OF 2025
WRIT PETITION NO: 37524 OF 2021
Between:
Amit Agarwal, _S/o _ Sri Munnalal Agarwal, Aged about 40 years, Occupation:
Business, Rl/o. E7, Mayur Kushal Complex, Gunfoundry, Hyderab-ad.
...PET|T|ONER
AND
. Southern
Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited, (A Government
-Telangana
'1
of
Undertakilg) (Formerly Central Power Distributidn Company of
A P. Ltd )Corporate Office # 6-1-50, Mint Compound, Hyderabad - 500 d63.
Rep. by its Managing Director
2. The Divisional Engineer, Operation, lbrahimbagh Division, TSSPDCL,
Cybercity.
The Superintendent Engineer, Operation Circle, Cybercity, TSSPDCL, Nanal
Nagar X Roads, Rethibowli, Hyderabad -28.
4. The Assistant Divisional Engineer, Operation, lbrahimbagh Sub-Division,
TSSPDCL, Cybercity.
...RESPONDENTS
Pelition under Article 226 ot Ihe Constrtution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate Writ or Writs,
Order or Direction, declaring:
A. The action of Respondents on 14-10-2021 of disconnectlng power to the
installed transformer and sanctioned connection for L.T. supply, 1 No_ 3
phase, 25KW, domestic load vide LR. No. DE/OP/IBRAHIMBAH/F.No.178/
2021-22, D.No.1398, DI: 17.09.2021 , as illegal, arbitrary, unfair and
unreasonable, further being in disregard of principles of natural justice,
therefore in violation of Articles 14, 19, 21, and 3Ol A of the Constitution
of lndia, so also in derogation of the Electricity Act 2003 consequently to
direct the Respondents to effectuate the said sarc ioned connection by
restoring the electricity to the transformer rnstal t d in the petitioners
premises at Sy. No.214l3/A, MirjaGuda, Janwada S,hankarpally, Ranga
Reddy District.
B- Award costs.
lA NO: 1 OF 2021
Petition under Section 15'l CPC praying that in the ) rcumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cor- i may be pleased to
direct the Respondents to restore the electricity to the tran:; rrmer installed in the
Petrtioners premises at Sy. No.214l3/A, Mirja Guda, Jar ruada, Shankarpally,
Ranga Reddy District, pending disposal of the Writ petition
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI ANAND KUMAR KAPOOR
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI N. SREEDHAR REDDy. i C. FOR TGSPDCL
WRIT PET|TION NO: 16757 OF 2O2s
Between:
Amit Agarwal, S/o Sri [\/unnalal Agan,ual, Aged about zr years, Occuoation
Business, R/o. E7, [\,4ayur Kushal Comptex, Gunfoundry, Hyder b'ad.
...PETITIONER
AND
Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Lir iied., (A Government
of Telangana Undertaking) (Formerly'Central p6wer D I tribution Comoanv o[
A P Ltd )Corporate Office # 6-1-50. I\,4int Compound, I yderabad SbO fjOf
Rep. by its Managing Director.
The Drvisional Engineer, Operation, lbrahimbagh )ivisron, TSSpDCL,
Cybercity.
The Superintendent Engineer, Operation Circle, Cyber::v, TSSpDCL, Nanal
Nagar X-Roads, Rethibowli, Hyderabad - 28.
The Assistant Divisional Engineer, Operation,
TSSPDCL, Cybercity.
lbra t'i rbagh Sub-Division,
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ot rhe constitution of lndiz praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the lrgh court may be
//
pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate Writ or Writs, Order
or Direction, declaring the
A. High-handed action of Respondents on 16-06-2025 of disconnecting power
to the Petitioner's Service Connection vide SC No. '120701682 under
category - 2 B pertaining to the property premises situated at Survey No.
214131A, Mirja Guda, Janwada, Shankarpally, Ranga Reddy District, as the
same is illegal, arbitrary, unfair and unreasonable, further being in drsregard
of principles of natural justice, therefore in violation of Articles 14, 19, 21
,
and 300-4 of the Constitutron of lndia, so also in derogation of the
Electricity Act, 2003, therefore to direct the Respondents to restore the
power supply to the Petitioner's service connection vide SC No, 120701682
situated in the Petitioners premises at Sy. No.214l3/A, tr/irja Guda,
Janwada, Shankarpally, Ranga Reddy District.
B. Award costs.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct
the Respondents to restore the power supply to the Petitioner's service connection
vide SC No.120701682 situated in the Petitioner's premises at Sy. No.214l3/A,
Mirja Guda, Janwada, Shankarpally, Ranga Reddy District, pending disposal of
the Writ Petition.
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Between:
1. Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited., Corporate
Office at 6-1-50, Mint Compound, Hyderabad - 500 063 Represented by its
Managing Director.
2. The Divisional Engineer, Operation, Ibrahimbagh Division, TGSPDCL,
Cybercity.
3. The Superintendent Engineer, Operation Circle, Cybercity, TGSPDCL, Nanal
Nagar X-Roads, Rethibowli, Hyderabad.
4. The Assistant Divisional Engineer, Operation, lbrahimbagh Sub-Division,
TSSPDCL, Cybercity.
..PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS
AND
Amit Ag_arwal, S/o Sri Munna.lal Aganival, Aged about 44 ,e,ars, Fl/o. E7, Mayur
Kushal Complex, Gunfoundry, Hydeiabad. "
...RESPONDE I TAVRIT PETITIONER
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in the ci crumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High cou r may be pleased to
vacate the order dated 20.06.2o2s passed in l.A.No.1 oI 2c25 in w.p.No..16757 of
2025. ln the interests of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI DIDA VIJAYA KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondents: SRt N. SREEDHAR REDDY ;.C. FOR TGSPDCL
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
I
IN THE HIGII COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAI(A
WRIT PETITION No. 37524 OF 2O2l
AND
WRIT PETITION No. L6757 OF 2()25
2L.O1.2026
Between:
Amit Agarwal
Petitioner
And
Southern Power Distribution Company of
Telangana Limited,
Rep. by its Managing Director
And others
Respondents
COMMON ORDER:
Since petitioner is common and the lis involved in
both the writ Petitions is similar, both of them are heard
together and a common order is being passed.
2.
Petitioner states that he is the owner and
possessor of open agricultural land admeasuring Acs' 2'25
guntas in Survey No. 214/B o[ Janwada Village, Shankarpally
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District having purchased the same
through Registered Sale Deed daLed 21.5.2O08; Revenue
authorities have also mutated his name and issued pattadar
pass book. Petitioner states that electricity Service Connection
was issued to the above property uide l.iT SC No 120701682
)
and till this date, there are no arrears on thc zrid Service
Connection.
2.1.
While so, it is stated that the 3.d Il s;ponde nt -
Superintendent Engineer issued Notice dated
. 6.08.2019
stating that HT SC No. CBC 363 (Old SC No. RRI) l)53) which
was initially in the name of Giridhar Ispat and sulr ru:quently in
the name ol M/s Airan Comptrax Pvt. Ltd. has 1rt pending
arrears of consumption charges to
tune
thr
of
Rs. 6,58,94,764 l- as on 3i.O7.2O17 a-rrd thert:lc -,:, directed
petitioner to pay the said amount or else Servic,: Oonnection
No- 1207O1682 would be disconnected apart frr rL initiating
proceedings under the Revenue Recovery Act
Petitioner
contends that he has hled a reply dated 28.72.2011 to the said
notice intimating that he is no way concerned/cor rected with
the dues of above Service Connection as ment ned in the
(
notice. It is stated by him that except thc LT Servlce
Connection lor lhe agricultural propert5z, there is r r HT Service
Connection belonging to him and further contenrl , that he is
not liable to pay the electricity dues of abov: mentioned
companies, hence requested for withdrawing the s:r I notice.
2.2.
It is further contended that in 2021 . F espondents
have also installed a transformer for supply o[ ,'l power 3
phase, 25 KW in the open agricultural land ::longing to
_)
petitioner but without any notice, the said connection was
disconnected ol 14.1O.2021. Hence petitioner was constrained
to file Writ Petition No. 37524 of 2021. When the matter is
pending adjudication, respondents, without any notice and
without issuing any proceedings, all of a sudden, came to
petitioner's property on 16.06.2025 and disconnected power to
the service connection and demanded petitioner to clear the
dues pertaining to HT SC No. CBC353 (old SC No. RRD 353)
It is contended that the action of respondents is in
contravention of the Electricity y Act, 2OO3 and the Regulations
made thereunder by the Regulatory Commission. Hence,
petitioner filed Writ Petition No. 16757 of 2025.
3.
Respondents filed Counter Affirdavit vehemently
contending that the property in which Service Connection of
pctitioner viz. LT SC No. 120701682 is given, earlier belonged
to M/s Giridhar Ispat who had industrial Service Connection
bcaring HT SC No. CBC 353 (O1d SC No. RRD 353) which had
bcen subsequently changed in the records of Respondents in
the name of Airan Comptrax Pvt. Ltd. The said Service
Connection was disconnected for non-payment of arrears of
Rs. 1 ,64,40,4 40 I - and in spite o[ several communications
issued, dues have not been paid. Therefore, steps were taken
by Respondents for recovery of dues under the Revenue
\
Recovery Act, by issuing Notices in Form A', 'B' r-rd 'C' and
arrears as on 31.7.2O22 stood atRs.7,34,76'2641'
It is stated that the Managing Di -, c tor of the
3. L
previ.ous companies viz. one Munnalal Agarwal I nouc other
than thc fathcr of petitioner. It is contendec{ that 1; litioner and
his father, to avoid payment of electricity dues, lr r/e changed
the ownership of the subject land in the name of xrtitioner by
treating the properry to be an agricultural [and. thc District
Collector also initiated proceedings under tl t
Revenue
Recovery Act and issued Distraint Notice for sel: of subject
properry for recovery of dues on 25.11.2019. It i; contended
that Respondents addressed several letters to tlr: Tahsildar,
District Tou,n and Country Planning Officer, Conr rissioner of
HMDA and Environmental Engineer of Pollution (:r ntrol Board
requesting them not to grant any permission rr respect of
subject properw. Therefore to avoid payment r I amounts,
petitioner secms to have got the property transl, rrecl in his
name and obtainecl LT Service Connection I earing No.
120701682 in 2O2l by suppressing the fact of dur: ()f previous
owner. This is nothing but fraud played by petitir ter and his
father to avoid payment of electricity dues to Respt,; rlent s.
3.2.
It is srated that as HT SC No. CBC 351 was in the
very same propertv claimed by petitioner, even I pctitioner
..--.
a}}i
----:'e::_-:-r:-E:
-.r
. i:t:'a
I i{'tji
-
_
i
claims to be alien to the earlier industries and also claims to be
a bonafde purchaser of the property, still he is liable to pay
the dues of previous owner. The issue of payment of dues of
previous owner is no more res-integra in view of the judgment
of Hon'ble Supreme Court in TGSPDCL v. Srigdhaa
Beueragesl, which was thereafter reiterated by a 3-Judge
Bench in K.C. Ninnan us Kerala State Electricitg Boar&. IL
is further contended that as per Clauses 5.9.6 and 8.4 ot
General Terms & Conditions of Supply, no new Service
Connection can be granted in the very same property which
had outstanding dues, unless the same are fully paid and
cleared and therefore, prays for dismissal of Writ Petition.
4.
In the reply, petitioner almost reiterated the
averments in the writ afhdavit.
5.
Heard Sri Anand Kumar Kapoor, learned counsel
for petitioner in Writ Petition No. 37254 of 2O2l and Sri D.
Vijal.a Kumar, learned counsel for petitioner in Writ Petition
No. 16757 ot 2025 and Sri N. Sreedhar Reddy, learned
Standing Counsel for TGSPDCL.
6.
[t is the specihc case of Respondents that in the
very same property i.e. land admeasuring Acs.2.25 guntas in
Survey No. 214/B of Janwada Village, Shankarpally Mandal,
t
t2o2o) 6 SCC 404
lt4) SCC 431
: 2023
\6
Ranga Reddy District, therc was earlier : H'l Service
Connection No. CBC 353 (Old SC No. RRD 353,) r the name of
M / s Giridhar Ispat initially ancl the reafter in
tht rame of M/ s
ti
Airan Comptrax Pvt. Limited. It is also conten j )C that father
i
I
of petitioner rvas the Managing Director o[ the srr c Companies.
This fact is not specihcally denied by petitioner, >.cept vaguely
stating that the said contention is without any e z Jence.
7.
Further, [he documents filed by pe r ioner in both
the Writ Petitions show that he purchased the rroperty from
one Rajendra Prasad Goyal who is in fact not t]r owner of the
property. The contents of Sale Deed dated 21.t) 1.2008 shows
that one Rachuri Pcntaiah and Rachuri Mallaiat. .r,err: absolute
owners of the land admeasuring Acs.1.13 guntai in Survey No.
214/3lA and Acs.i-12 guntas in Survey N<'. 214/3lB of
Janwada Village and they sold the said proper$' to
M/s Giridhar Ispat Pvt. Limited through Regist,: e.d Sale Deed
dated 16.07.1985 uide Doc. No. 4852 of 1985. Ir r,rrn, the said
Giridhar Ispat Pvt. Ltd. sold the
)roperty to
M/s Airan Comptrax Tou,ers Pvt. Ltd through I t:gisterd Sale
Deed dated 04.O8.2OOO uide Doc. No. 6323 of 2( CrO. It is seen
that M/s Airan Comtrax Towers Pvt. Ltd. repre sented by its
Managing Director, Agarwal M.L. (father of petir tner) entered
into an Agreement of Sale and GPA dated 1O.O4 i ()O3 with one
Rajender Prasad Goyal in respect of the above property and
that the said document was validated by the District Registrar
& Collector under Indian Stamp Act, Ranga Reddy District on
28.10.2006 ir.r File No. 981S/AR/06. Sri Rajender Prasad Goyal
who rvas only a GPA Holdcr sold the property in favour of
petitioner uide Registered Sale Deed dated 2 i.05.2O08 which
clearly shorvs that petitioner had become owner of the property
which had electricity dues. Therefore, this Court is satisf-red
that the propcrty claimed by petitioner having purchased
through Registered Sale Deed dated 21.5.2008 had earlier HT
SC No. CBC 353 (Old No. RRD 353) which had dues of
Rs. 7,34,16,264 /- as on 31.7.2022. Petitioner, having
purchascd the said property, is liable to pay the dues of
previous owners. Therefore, Respondents have the right to
deny power supply to the very same property which had dues
by previous owners. Aiso, this Court is convinced that
petitioncr and his father, in order to avoid dues, seems to have
transferred the property in the name of petitioner and have
clandcstinely obtained LT SC No. 120701682 for the very same
property.
8.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in K.C. Ninncn's case
while referring to earlier judgment rn Hgderabad. Wdnaspathg
Limited, held at Para 78 that even under Indian Electricity
Supply Act, 1948, there is an obligation on the rr',v owner to
clear the arrears of previous owner, as a pre-conrl : on to avail
electricity supply r.l,hich havc statutorv character. /it para 89,
while referring to earlier judgment in Paschimant .hal Vidgut
Vitharan Nigam, the Hon'ble Apex Court reL :rated that
distribution licensees can insist for clearance I arrears of
electricity dues of previous consumer befo', rcsuming
electricity supply to the premiscs, which i:; valid and
permissible under Electricity Act, 2003- At Para 9.i it was held
that Electricity Supply Code requiring paymen L I electricity
dues of previous olr,ners as a condition for grar t ,l electricity
connections have a clear nexus to the scheme o the parent
legislations anri the objectives sought to be achier. rC and it is
just and reasr>nable for distribution licensees to specify the
conditions of supply requiring thc subsequelt lwners or
occupiers of premises to pay the elcctricitv dur::, c,f previous
owner or occupier as a pre condition for grant r I electrici$r
connection to protect their commercial interest zrs well as
we lfare of consumers of electricity.
9.
AIso, Clauses 5.9.6 and 8.4 of Gener r. Terms &
Conditions of Supply abundantly make it clear L rlt no new
Service Connection shall be provided to the prt:r r i:;es unless
the existing dues are cleared. As petitioner is tl: owner of
,/
property which had electricity dues of previous owner, he is
tiable to pay the same- In view of the above discussion, this
Court sees no grounds to interfere u'ith disconnection of power
supply to [he properly of pctitioner- No grounds are made out
for granting the relief as sought in the Writ Petitions.
Accordingly both the Writ Petitions are dismissed'
lO.
No cosLs.
.Consequently, the miscellaneous Applications, if
1l
any shall star-rd closed
SD/ A. SREENIV ASA RED
SISTANT REG
//TRUE COPY//
To
SECTION OFFICER
ate o PUC]
Ad
One CC to SRI ANAND KUMAR KAPOOR'
cl
Advocate I
One CC to SRI DIDA VIJAYA KUMAR'
OnC CC tO SRI N. SREEDH,ARREDDY'SC
Two CD CoPies
I
MP
GJP
'
forTGSPDCL[OPUC]
HIGH COURT
DAI ED:21 10112026
;
(
a)
I
Hr:ll
rq 1t,
k n,_.S.
?i\?
o
*
COI4MON ORDER
W.P.No.li7524 OF 2021
AND
W.P.No.'6757 OF 2025
DISMISSING THE WFI T PETITIONS
WIT .IOUT COSTS
a\
& Iat
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review