Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT I N D O R E
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE VIVEK RUSIA
&
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ANIL VERMA
ON THE 4th OF JANUARY, 2024
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3783 of 2018
BETWEEN:AMBARAM S/O KANHAJI, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, R/O GRAM BAJNA,
THANA KANAD, DISTRICT AGAR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....APPELLANT
(BY SHRI SANTOSH KUMAR MEENA, ADVOCATE.)
AND
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH STATION HOUSE OFFICER THRU.
P.S. KANAD, DISTT. SHAJAPUR (MADHYA PRADESH)
.....RESPONDENTS
(BY SHRI AMIT RAWAL, GOVERNMENT ADVOCATE.)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This appeal coming on for judgment this day, Justice Vivek Rusia
passed the following:
JUDGMENT
With the consent of parties, heard finally instead of hearing on
application for suspension of jail sentence.
The appellant has filed the present appeal being aggrieved by the
judgment of conviction dated 04.04.2018 passed by Additional Sessions
Agar, District Shajapur (M.P.) in Session Case No.153/2016 whereby
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-2-
the appellant has been convicted under Section 302 of IPC and
sentenced to undergo Life Imprisonment with fine of Rs.1,000/- with 2
years’ default stipulation.
(2)
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is as follows: -
(a)
The complainant:Dheerajsingh R/o Gram Bajana informed the
police station Kanad that at near about 6.00 pm, he was returning from
the forest area alongwith his goats, when he reached in front of the cycle
shop of Nabbu Mehtar, Harijan Mohalla, appellant-Ambaram was
assaulting Antarsingh from the stick intending to kill and was telling that
why Antarsingh was objecting from consumption of liquor by him .
according to him while assaulting he dragged him to the house of Pyarji
Balai, Antarsingh sustained injuries on various parts of body and died.
At the time of said incident Kalusingh, Santosh, Rambabu and Dayaram
also came and intervened.
(b)
The police recorded Dehati Nalish Ex.P/1 and P/16 and reached
the spot, Safina form was drawn and Lash Panchnama was prepared.
Police station Kanad registered an FIR on 09.05.2016 and started the
investigation. The spot map was prepared, this appellant was arrested
and a memorandum statement under Section 27 of the Evidence Act was
recorded and a stick was recovered from his house. The post-mortem
was carried out, the death was found homicidal due to the injuries
caused to Antarsingh all over the body. The investigation was completed
and charge-sheet was filed under Section 302 of IPC. The charge was
framed which the appellant denied and pleaded for trial.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-3-
The prosecution examined 9 witnesses and exhibited 24 documents. In
defence, the appellant examined mother-Kantibai. After evaluating the
evidence that came on record the appellant was convicted as stated
above.
(3)
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that there was no
previous enmity between the appellant and deceased Antarsingh. Both
were consuming liquor and suddenly a dispute arose and this appellant
started assaulting the deceased, therefore, the offence will not travel
more than Section 304 Part-II of IPC hence, the appellant has wrongly
been convicted under Section 302 of IPC, therefore, the conviction may
kindly be altered by acquitting him under Section 302 of IPC. The
appellant is not assailing the other findings recorded by the trial Court.
(4)
Learned Government Advocate for the respondent / State opposes
the aforesaid prayer by submitting that Dr. Saxena (PW/3) conducted the
autopsy and found as many as 16 injuries on all over the body of the
deceased, the appellant assaulted the deceased till his death therefore, he
was intending to kill him hence, the appellant has rightly been convicted
under Section 302 of IPC. There are eye-witnesses PW/1, and PW/2
who fully supported the case of prosecution hence, the conviction under
section 302 is liable to be maintained and the criminal appeal be
dismissed.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record.
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-4-
(5)
According to Dheerajsingh (PW/1), at near about 6.00 pm he was
returning to his village and when he reached in front of the shop of
Nabbu Mehtar, the Harijan Mohalla Ambaram was assaulting
Antarsingh by means of a stick on the pretext that he was objecting to
his liquor consumption, thereafter, he dragged him upto the house of
Pyarji Balai. Antarsingh sustained injuries on his chest and died on the
spot, he is a witness to the seizure of the stick also. In crossexamination, he admits that he was not aware that as to why they were
fighting. Likewise, Dayaram (PW/2) is also a witness of the incident and
he tried to save the deceased and sustained the injury and according to
him, the appellant assaulted Antarsingh till his death on the spot.
(6)
The evidence of PW/1 and PW/2 has remained unrebutted,
therefore, the findings in respect of the complicity of this present
appellant have been established by the Dheerajsingh (PW/1) and
Dayaram (PW/2). Dr. Shashank Saxena (PW/3) conducted the autopsy
and found various injuries. Kalusingh (PW/5) has turned hostile. The
rest of the witnesses have supported the case of the prosecution,
therefore, the date of incident, and cause of death have been fully
established by the prosecution and the findings recorded by the trial
Court are not liable to be disturbed. The only ground on which this
appellant has assailed this appeal is that there was no previous enmity
and it was not a preplanned murder, therefore, it will not travel more
than Section 304 Part-II of IPC.
(7)
It is correct that the prosecution has failed to prove that there was
a previous enmity between the appellant and the deceased. On the issue
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-5-
of consumption of liquor, a dispute suddenly arose and the appellant
started assaulting the deceased with a stick. As per pre-MLC and postmortem reports, the deceased was also in an intoxication condition. On a
petty issue, this appellant became annoyed and out of anger assaulted
the deceased.
It was not a preplanned murder but due to sudden
provocation. Out of anger, the appellant assaulted the deceased. The
number and nature of injuries are not important but the mensrea or
intention are important.
(8)
The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in Gurpal Singh v. State of
Punjab, AIR 2017 SC 471. Para 10 of the judgment reads thus:
“10. However, in the singular facts of the case and noticing in particular,
the progression of events culminating in the tragic incident, we are
inclined to reduce the sentence awarded to him. Incidentally, the
occurrence is of the year 2004 and meanwhile twelve years have elapsed.
Further, having regard to the root cause of the incident and the events that
sequentially unfolded thereafter, we are of the comprehension that the
appellant was overpowered by an uncontrollable fit of anger so much so
that he was deprived of his power of self-control and being drawn in a
web of action reflexes, fired at the deceased and the injured, who were
within his sight. The facts do not commend to conclude that the appellant
had the intention of eliminating any one of those fired at, though he had
the knowledge of the likely fatal consequences thereof. Be that as it may,
on an overall consideration of the fact situation and also the time lag in
between, we are of the view that the conviction of the appellant ought to
be moderated to one under Sections 304 Part 1 IPC and 307 IPC. Further,
considering the facts of the case in particular, according to us, it would
meet the ends of justice, if the sentence for the offences is reduced to the
period already undergone. We order accordingly.”
(9)
The Hon'ble Supreme Court has laid down in Prabhakar Vithal
Gholve v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 2016 SC 2292 that if the assault
on deceased could be said to be on account of the sudden fight without
premeditation, in heat of passion and upon a sudden quarrel, Conviction
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-6-
of the appellant cannot be sustained under S. 302 and altered to one
under Section 304 Part-I of IPC. In Sikandar Ali Vs. State of
Maharashtra, AIR 2017 SC 2614, the Court altered the conviction u/s
302 IPC to one u/s 304 part-2 IPC in the following circumstances:
“7. We have no doubt about the complicity of all the accused in the
homicide of Sarfraj. A-1 attacked the deceased with the knife and
caused injury on his neck which resulted in his death. The other
accused assisted him in committing the crime by holding the hands
of the deceased. However, the only question that falls for our
consideration is whether the accused are liable to be punished for an
offence under Section 302 IPC. After considering the submissions
made by the counsel for the Appellants and scrutinising the material
on record, we are of the opinion that the accused are not liable to be
convicted under Section 302 IPC. We are convinced that there was
neither prior concert nor common intention to commit a murder.
During the course of their business activity the accused reached the
dhaba where the deceased was present. An altercation took place
during the discussion they were having behind the dhaba. That led to
a sudden fight during which A-1 attacked the deceased with a knife.
Exception 4 to Section 300 is applicable to the facts of this case. As
we are convinced that the accused are responsible for the death of
Sarfraj, we are of the opinion that they are liable for conviction
under Section 304 part II of the IPC. We are informed that A-1 has
undergone a sentence of seven years and that A-2 to A-4 have
undergone four years of imprisonment. We modify the judgment of
the High Court converting the conviction of the accused from
Section 302 to Section 304 part II of the IPC sentencing them to the
period already undergone. They shall be released forthwith.”
(10) In the case of PREMCHAND v. THE STATE OF
MAHARASHTRA (Criminal Appeal No. 211 of 2023) reported
in 2023 (2) S.C.R. 119 the apex court has recently held as under :24.
Exception 4 to section 300, IPC ordains that culpable homicide is
not murder if it is committed without premeditation in a sudden fight in
the heat of passion upon a sudden quarrel and without the offender having
taken undue advantage or acted in a cruel or unusual manner. The
explanation thereto clarifies that it is immaterial in such cases which party
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
-7offers the provocation or commits the first assault. Four requirements
must be satisfied to invoke this exception, viz. (i) it was a sudden fight;
(ii) there was no premeditation; (iii) the act was done in a heat of passion;
and (iv) the assailant had not taken any undue advantage or acted in a
cruel or unusual manner. 25. Taking an overall view of the matter, we are
inclined to the opinion that the appellant was entitled to the benefit of
Exception 4 to section 300, IPC. 2
(11) In view of the above discussion and verdicts of the apex court, we
hereby confirm all the findings given by the learned Additional Session
Judge except the conviction which is hereby altered to Section 304 PartII of IPC, instead of Section 302 of IPC and accordingly sentence is
reduced from Life Imprisonment to 10 years' Rigorous Imprisonment.
The fine amount as imposed by the trial Court is also maintained. The
appellant be set free after depositing the fine amount and completion of
10 years RI if he is not required to stay in jail in any other case.
(12) With the aforesaid, this Criminal Appeal is partly allowed to the
extent indicated above.
(13) Let the record of the trial Court be sent back along with a copy of
this judgment.
(VIVEK RUSIA)
JUDGE
Divyansh
Signed by: DIVYANSH
SHUKLA
Signing time: 09-01-2024
16:56:12
(ANIL VERMA)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review