Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta
WPA 23103 of 2015
With
CAN 1 of 2022
Amresh Kumar
Versus
Union of India & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Rabindranath Bag, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Piyas Chowdhury, Adv.
Ms. Nazni Khatun, Adv.
Mr. Swagata Saha, Adv.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Debapriya Gupta, Adv.
Mr. Moni Shankar Sengupta, Adv.
Heard on
:
23.07.2026
Judgment on
:
15.09.2026
Uploaded on
:
15.09.2026
WPA 23103 of 2015
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.: 1.
The petitioner prays for a direction, inter alia, in the nature of
mandamus for quashing and/or setting aside of the impugned order
No. 3325 dated 28.09.2013 passed by Group Commander, Guwahati,
thereby penalty was imposed i.e. “Compulsory retirement from service
with eligible pensionary benefits with immediate effect” and further to
reinstate the petitioner in service with applicable back salaries along
with other consequential reliefs in this instant writ petition.
2.
The petitioner was enrolled in the Central Industrial Security Force
(in short, ‘CISF’) on 04.07.1994. During his tenure of service, the
petitioner had received ten rewards for his good performance.
3.
The origin of the present disciplinary proceedings lies in an alleged
incident dated 04.02.2013 at around 20.50 hrs., the petitioner, who
was detained at the WTP Post for night ("C") shift duty commencing at
21.00 hrs., got into a quarrel with Constable B. Shekhar, who had
just completed his "A" shift duty. The altercation, arising out of a
personal dispute concerning their previous place of posting, escalated
into a physical scuffle, in the course of which B. Shekhar sustained a
fracture to his ring finger. It was alleged that B. Shekhar first picked
up a wood-cutter (DAB), whereupon the petitioner picked up his
service rifle. The incident was recorded in two General Diary entries-
WPA 23103 of 2015
G.D. Entry No. 797 dated at the WTP Post (21.30 hrs.) and G.D.
Entry No. 178 at the CISF Control Room (21.40 hrs.). Accordingly,
both the enrolled members of the Force, i.e., the petitioner as well as
Constable B. Shekhar, were charged with undisciplined activities and
further disciplinary action was recommended.
4.
Accordingly, a charge memo no. V-150 Maj-10/GHG/L&R/20132133 dated 01.07.2013 was sent to the petitioner along with a copy
thereof to Deputy Commandant CISF Unit, IOC, Guwahati, annexing
the proposed names of witnesses and other relevant documents. The
following charges were framed: “Charge – I
On 04.06.2013 the Constable Amresh Kumar the petitioner
was detained a WTP for night shift duty from 21.00 hrs. till
5.00 hrs. on 05.06.2013. In the barrack on said date i.e.
04.06.2013 at about 20.00 hrs. the petitioner got indulged in
quarrel with another constable B. Shekhar (now removed from
service) as such the said act of petitioner manifests
misconduct, gross negligence towards duty flouting and
indiscipline which shows indiscipline and the same is not
befitting for a member of a disciplined force.
Charge – II
The Constable Amresh Kumar (the Petitioner) was enrolled on
04.07.1994 and according to his service record he has already
been awarded 12 punishments but he has failed to correct his
conduct and he also failed to bring in positive amendment in
his in disciplined conducts.”
5.
The Petitioner denied the charges, following which a departmental
enquiry was ordered. By order dated 19.07.2013, Sh. D.K. Nath, AC,
WPA 23103 of 2015
and SI (Exe) Akhilesh Kumar, both of CISF Unit, IOC Guwahati, were
appointed as Enquiry Officer and Presenting Officer respectively. The
Enquiry Officer recorded the statements of six prosecution witnesses,
and upon receipt of the Presenting Officer's brief dated 09.08.2013,
submitted findings dated 21.08.2013 holding both articles of charge
proved against the petitioner. The Enquiry Officer came to the
findings that both Constable B. Sekhar and Constable Amaresh
Kumar were found guilty of quarrelling and entering into altercation
with each other and the charges of quarrelling levelled against them
is established beyond doubt.
6.
Subsequently, after considering the enquiry report and entire
proceedings, the Disciplinary Authority by order no. V-15014/Maj10/GHG/L&R/2013-3325 dated 28.09.2013 imposed major penalty
of “Compulsory retirement from service with eligible pensionary
benefits with immediate effect” under Rule 34 of the CISF Rules,
2001 after accepting the finding of the enquiry, subsequently followed
by a Corrigendum No. V-15014/Maj-10/GHG/L&R/2013-3720 dated
29.10.2013.
7.
Feeling aggrieved with the said order, the petitioner preferred a
statutory appeal dated 09.10.2013 before the Appellate Authority, the
DIG, CISF, North Eastern Zone, which came to be dismissed by order
WPA 23103 of 2015
dated 28.02.2014 (No. V-11014/Appeal-29/AK/Adm-II/NEZ/2013/
1981).
8.
The petitioner, thereafter, invoked Revisional remedy under Rule 54
of the CISF Rules, 2001, before the Inspector General, CISF,
NSE/NEZ. This revision too was rejected by order dated 27.07.2014.
9.
Being aggrieved by the concurrent orders of the Disciplinary,
Appellate, and Revisional Authorities, the petitioner has approached
this Court in the instant writ petition seeking aforesaid relief thereof.
10. Learned senior counsel, Mr. Bag, appearing on behalf of the
petitioner, submitted that the Petitioner was innocent and falsely
implicated in the present case; however, the disciplinary authority
found him guilty without any reasonable material and explanation.
The Petitioner was compulsorily retired based on the alleged quarrel,
identifying the incident as gross misconduct; however, the term
‘Misconduct’ has not been specifically defined in the CISF Rules.
11. The Petitioner was found guilty and punished solely based on hearsay
evidence. No direct evidence was produced by the prosecution against
the Petitioner. The whole case is based on hearsay, although hearsay
evidence has no value in the eye of the law.
12. It was further submitted that the eyewitnesses (P.Ws. 3 and 4) did
not specify the role of the petitioner. Neither the injured person nor
WPA 23103 of 2015
the medical document, like injury report was produced in the present
case to substantiate the prosecution case. Furthermore, even for the
sake of argument, if it is assumed that there was a quarrel between
the two employees, the same would be beyond the official working
hours.
13. It was further submitted that the petitioner cannot be punished on
the basis of previous antecedents; otherwise, it would be double
jeopardy and a violation of Article 20(2) of the Constitution of India.
He has further placed reliance on the following judgments: i.
State of Assam v. J.N. Roy Biswas 1;
ii. T.P. Gopalakkrishnan v. State of Kerala 2;
iii. Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board and
Ors. v. T.T. Murali Babu3.
14. Learned Counsel has further relied upon the judgment passed in the
case of Kuldeep Singh v. The Commissioner of Police and Ors. 4 in
support of his argument that if the finding of guilt is based on no
evidence, it would be a perverse finding and would be amenable to
judicial scrutiny. Further, relying upon Rajinder Kumar Kindra v.
(1976) 1 SCC 234
(2022) 14 SCC 478
(2014) 4 SCC 108
(1999) 2 SCC 10
WPA 23103 of 2015
Delhi Administration5, it was submitted that where a finding of
misconduct is based on no legal evidence, which is wholly incapable
of supporting such finding, the conclusion would be one which no
reasonable person could have arrived at. Such a finding is liable to be
characterised as perverse and set aside in law.
15. Therefore, the punishment imposed upon the petitioner is highly
disproportionate. It is a major punishment. The same is liable to be
set aside.
16. Learned counsel, Mr. Gupta, on the other hand, appearing on behalf
of the Respondents, submitted in response to the judgment relied
upon by the Petitioner, that a relief granted in a specific case cannot
be treated as precedent.
17. Learned Counsel further placed reliance on a decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Union of India and Ors. v. Subrata
Nath6, wherein it was held that a person’s past conduct cannot be
taken into consideration while awarding penalty, subject to the
condition that the same is made part of a separate charge, as was
done in the instant case.
18. It was further submitted that the petitioner's conduct was against the
Force. He was punished earlier on 12 occasions; however, he did not
(1984) 4 SCC 635
(2022) 18 SCR 605
WPA 23103 of 2015
rectify himself and continued his behaviour despite cautions. His
conduct in the incident and previous antecedents became detrimental
to the Force.
19. Learned Counsel has relied upon the following decisions in support of
his submissions:i. Union of India v. R. Kasivelu7;
ii. Union of India v. Const. Sunil Kumar 8;
iii.Union of India v. Bihamber Das Dogra 9;
iv. CISF v. Abrar Ali10;
v. State of Mysore v. K. Manche Gowda 11;
vi. Muzaffar Husain v. State of UP 12;
vii. B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India 13;
viii. Ram Kishan v. Union of India 14.
20. Learned counsel further refuted the contention of the petitioner that
the prosecution failed to prove the case against him. The prosecution
witnesses clearly saw the incident with their own eyes and narrated
the same at the time of their examination. During cross-examination,
MAT 2290 of 2024
(2023) 1 SCR 961
(2009) 9 SCR 828
(2017) 4 SCC 507
(1964) 4 SCR 540
2022 SCC OnLine SC 567
(1995) 6 SCC 749
(1995) 6 SCC 157
WPA 23103 of 2015
the petitioner failed to shake their evidence and rather admitted the
facts of the quarrel. The case of the petitioner was affirmed by the
appellate authority as well as on revision. Therefore, the writ petition
is liable to be dismissed with costs.
21. Having heard the submissions of the learned counsels appearing on
behalf of the respective parties and having gone through the
materials on records, this court finds that the petitioner joined in the
Central Industrial Security Force (in short, ‘CISF’) on 04.07.1994.
During his tenure of service, admittedly, he was punished on 12
occasions for ill behaviour and illegal deeds.
22. The petitioner was awarded 12 punishments in his whole service
tenure. A charge has been framed that the Petitioner was enrolled on
04.07.1994. According to his service record, he failed to correct his
conduct and bring about a positive change in his conduct. His last
conduct was about the quarrel with Constable B. Shekhar, who had
just completed his "A" shift duty. The altercation, arising out of a
personal dispute concerning their previous place of posting, escalated
into a physical scuffle in the course of which B. Shekhar sustained a
fracture to his ring finger. Prosecution fails to prove the fact that B.
Shekhar sustained a fracture to his ring finger either by oral or
medical documents. However, the prosecution proved the quarrel
WPA 23103 of 2015
without any doubt together with charge no.1. It is undisputed facts
that quarrel took place with B. Shekhar on the date, time and place
as mentioned by the prosecution witnesses and ultimately awarded
penalty i.e. “Compulsory retirement from service with eligible
pensionary benefits with immediate effect” under Rule 34 of the CISF
Rules, 2001
23. The petitioner was unable to succeed in the appeal filed after feeling
aggrieved by the said order of compulsory retirement. The petitioner
preferred a statutory appeal on 09.10.2013 before the Appellate
Authority, the DIG, CISF, North Eastern Zone, but the same was
dismissed
by
order
dated
28.02.2014
(No.
V-11014/Appeal-
29/AK/Adm-II/NEZ/2013/1981). The petitioner, thereafter, invoked
Revisional remedy under Rule 54 of the CISF Rules, 2001, before the
Inspector General, CISF, NSE/NEZ. The revision too was rejected by
order dated 27.07.2014.
24.
Considering the overall facts of the case and the arguments advanced
by the respective parties, the issue that requires for determination is
whether the Authorities wrongfully inflicted the punishment of
compulsory
retirement
on
the
Petitioner,
having
taken
into
consideration his past conduct while inquiring into the alleged
incident?
WPA 23103 of 2015
25. It is well settled that the writ court does not sit in appeal over the
findings of a domestic enquiry, nor does it reappreciate evidence, as
an appellate forum would. Interference is warranted only where the
enquiry suffers from a breach of natural justice, or where the finding
of guilt rests on no evidence at all, rendering it perverse. No
procedural irregularity was found in the departmental proceedings,
and furthermore the principles of natural justice were duly observed.
In the present case, there is no dispute regarding a quarrel with
Constable B. Shekhar, who had just completed his "A" shift duty. The
altercation, arising out of a personal dispute concerning their
previous place of posting, escalated into a physical scuffle. B.
Shekhar first picked up a wood-cutter (DAB), and the petitioner also
picked up his service rifle. This type of quarrel is unexpected from a
cadre of the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) after all it is one
of the disciplined Forces of India.
26. On the question of previous punishments being taken into account,
learned senior counsel for the petitioner has argued that reliance on
antecedent conduct amounts to double jeopardy under Article 20(2)
of the Constitution of India. This contention does not survive
scrutiny. Article 20(2) protects a person from being "prosecuted and
punished" more than once "for the same offence." The twelve prior
WPA 23103 of 2015
punishments imposed on the petitioner were not sought to be repunished in the present proceeding; rather, they were incorporated as
Charge No. II, framed and put to the petitioner as part of the very
charge-sheet dated 01.07.2013, to which the petitioner was called
upon to respond and did respond. The Disciplinary Authority did not
resurrect closed disciplinary matters to inflict a fresh, independent
penalty for those past acts; it considered the petitioner's continued
and unremedied pattern of indiscipline as a circumstance material to
assessing the gravity of the present misconduct and the appropriate
quantum of punishment.
27. On the record placed before this Court, the Petitioner's record of
twelve prior punishments was not introduced for the first time at the
penalty stage; it formed part of the article of charge itself, the chargesheet expressly averring that the Petitioner awarded 12 punishments
but he has failed to correct his conduct and he also failed to bring in
positive
amendment
in
him
in
disciplined
conducts.
This
distinguishes the present case from the line of authority the
Petitioner would otherwise invoke, and brings it squarely within the
ratio of Subrata Nath (supra). In that case, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court held that a Disciplinary Authority "could not be expected to
wear blinkers" in respect of a delinquent employee's past conduct
WPA 23103 of 2015
while imposing penalty, precisely because that past conduct had been
made part of a specific, separate charge, thereby affording the
delinquent notice and opportunity to meet it, rather than being
invoked for the first time after the enquiry concluded.
28. The Respondents’ submission that a relief granted on the facts of a
particular case cannot be elevated to a precedent independent of its
ratio is well founded. It is the principle in Subrata Nath (Supra),
that past conduct may permissibly inform the penalty where it is
charged, not merely invoked, that governs here, not the bare outcome
of that case.
29. On this footing, the Court is unable to accept that the reliance placed
by the Disciplinary Authority on the Petitioner's past conduct was
impermissible. The vice that would ordinarily attend such reliance is
the absence of notice to the delinquent that his record would be
weighed against him, which is absent, since the past conduct was
itself made part of the article of charge and was, therefore, squarely
before the Petitioner from the inception of the proceedings, affording
him full opportunity to respond to it.
30. Accordingly, on the point of determination, this Court finds that the
Authorities did not act in excess of, or contrary to, law in taking into
consideration the Petitioner's past conduct while awarding the
WPA 23103 of 2015
penalty of compulsory retirement, that having formed part of the
charge itself; nor has it been demonstrated that the finding of guilt is
one arrived at on no evidence to attract the limited interference
contemplated in Kuldeep Singh (Supra).
31. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kuldeep Singh (Supra), held that a
finding arrived at on no evidence, or on evidence, no reasonable
person would act upon, is perverse and open to judicial scrutiny.
However, a finding resting on some evidence, no matter how
compendious, is not to be disturbed merely because another view was
possible. Tested against this standard, the Petitioner's submission
that the finding of guilt rests solely on hearsay is an assertion that
must be measured against the actual record of the enquiry, rather
than accepted at the level of submission alone.
32. The Petitioner's further contention is that "misconduct" is undefined
under the CISF Rules, 2001. This submission is unsustainable. The
absence of a codified definition does not leave the term at large;
conduct involving a physical scuffle with a fellow member of a
disciplined, armed force, in the course of duty or even out of duty
hours, and involving recourse to a service weapon, is evidently
conduct unbecoming of a member of such a Force. A charge of
misconduct is not rendered vague or void merely for want of a
WPA 23103 of 2015
statutory definition where the conduct alleged is intrinsically
incompatible with the discipline the Force is expected to maintain.
33. None of the authorities relied upon by the petitioner is shown to have
been rendered on facts analogous to the present matter, involving an
incident of physical confrontation within an armed force accompanied
by resort to a service weapon.
34. For the reasons recorded above, this Court finds no infirmity,
procedural or substantive in the impugned order No. V-15014/Maj10/GHG/L&R/2013-3325
Corrigendum
No.
dated
28.09.2013,
as
corrected
V-15014/Maj-10/GHG/L&R/2013-3720
by
dated
29.10.2013, or in the concurrent orders of the Appellate Authority
dated 28.02.2014 and the Revisional Authority dated 27.07.2014.
35. Consequently, WPA 23103 of 2015 stands dismissed without order
as to costs. CAN 1 of 2022 and all connected applications, if any, are
also, thus, disposed of.
36. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
37. Parties shall act on the server copies of this Judgment duly
downloaded from the official website of the High Court at Calcutta.
WPA 23103 of 2015
38. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this Judgment, if applied for, be
supplied to the parties upon compliance of all necessary and legal
formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
Later
After passing the judgment in the Court, Mr. Bag, Learned Senior
Counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner prays for stay of the
judgment for four weeks.
Such prayer is considered and rejected.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J.)
(P.A.)
WPA 23103 of 2015
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review