Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 9th April, 2026
Uploaded on: 9th April, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 17919/2025 and CM APPL. 74115/2025, 79704/2025
16022/2026, 22769/2026
AMAR JEET & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Mr. A.K. Singla, Sr. Adv. with Mr. R.
K. Gupta and Mr. Arun Kumar,
Advocates (M: 8448126500).
versus
REGISTRAR COOPERATIVE SOCIETIES & ANR. ....Respondents
Through: Ms. Harshita Nathrani, Advocate and
Mr. Sameer Vashisht, Standing
Counsel (Civil), GNCTD.
Ms. Sonia A. Menon, Advocate for R3 to 8 (M: 9810865468).
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE MADHU JAIN
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
2.
The present petition has been filed by the Petitioners under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India, inter alia, assailing the impugned order
dated 12th November, 2025 passed by the Registrar Co-operative Societies
(hereinafter, ‘RCS’).
3.
Vide order dated 12th November, 2025, Respondent No.2- Mr. Ram
Kumar Savant was appointed as the Administrator of the Society.
4.
The order dated 12th November, 2025 was stayed by this Court on 26th
November, 2025 in the following terms:
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
“3.
Mr. Sameer Vashisht, Standing Counsel for
Government of NCT of Delhi (GNCTD) accepts Notice
on behalf of respondent nos.l & 2.
4. We have perused the impugned order and also the
Show Cause Notice and the reply tendered by petitioner
to the Show Cause Notice.
5. Having regard to the fact that the impugned order
is a non-speaking order, as the contentions of the
petitioner are not dealt with therein, we deem it
appropriate to stay the same until further orders.
6. Returnable on 8th January 2026.
7. Order be uploaded on the website of this Court.”
5.
The brief background is that the Petitioners, namely Mr. Amarjeet, Mr.
Ramesh Varadarajan, Ms. Mini Jha, Mr. Vinod Bhatia and Mr. Kamal Jeet
Singh are part of the Managing Committee of the Fakhruddin Memorial
Cooperative Group Housing Society, Plot No. 18, Sector-10, Dwarka, New
Delhi (hereinafter, ‘the Society’), are aggrieved by the appointment of the
Administrator, vide the impugned order, on various grounds. The Petitioners
are part of the Managing Committee of the Society. Complaints were filed
against the Managing Committee raising various allegations. The said
allegations include:
i)
Holding of an SGBM (hereinafter, ‘Special General Body
Meeting’) on 8th June, 2025 which is on the festival of Eid-Ul-Juha
despite the directions of RCS;
ii)
Increase of maintenance charges by the Managing Committee from
Rs. 2300/- to Rs.3200/-;
iii) Disqualification of certain members, who had been elected to the
Managing Committee, as they were not the primary members of the
Society;
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
iv) Audits not being conducted in time;
v)
Appointment of a Returning Officer and the elections fixed for 14th
December, 2025, wherein there were allegations of the electoral roll
being manipulated;
6.
After considering these allegations, the order dated 12th November,
2025 was passed, wherein the RCS came to the following conclusions:
“Upon careful examination of the records, complaints
and submissions of the society, it is evident that the
Managing Committee of Fakhruddin Memorial
Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd has failed to
discharge its statutory duties in accordance with the
provisions of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003
and the Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 2007. The
Committee has violated the directions issued by this
office under Section 42 of the Act, conducted the
Special General Body Meeting in defiance of official
orders, and unilaterally revised the maintenance
charges without approval of the General body in
contravention of Section 89 and 93 of the DCS Act,
2003 and Rule 102(2) & (3) of the DCS Rules, 2007.
Further, the inclusion of non-primary members in the
Managing Committee is in violation of Section 25(b)
of the Act read with Rule 22(1) of the Rules. The above
acts reflect continued negligence, non-compliance,
and disregard for cooperative principles and lawful
directions.
In this context, reliance is placed on the settled
interpretation of Section 25(b)of the DCS Act, 2003 read
with Rule 22(1)of the DCS Rules, 2007, wherein the
Hon'ble Delhi High Court has held that the right to vote
or contest can be exercised by a joint member only in
cases of legal inability of the primary member and not
otherwise. Since the inclusion of such joint members in
the Managing Committee is contrary to law, the election
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
and functioning of the present Committee stands
vitiated.
In view of the above facts and in the light of the
provisions contained under Section 37(1) of the Delhi
Cooperative Societies Act, 2003, the Managing
Committee of Fakhruddin Cooperative Group
Housing Society Lid. is hereby superseded with
immediate effect .
Accordingly, Sh. Ram Kunar Savant, Grade-I Officer,
Government of NCT of Delhi, is hereby appointed as
the Administrator under Section 37 of the Delhi Cooperative Societies Act, 2003, to manage the day-to-day
affairs of the society, and ensure due compliance with
the statutory provisions of the Act and the Rules made
thereunder. The Administrator shall be paid a
remuneration of Rs. 10,000/- (Ten Thousand only) per
month, which shall be borne from the society's funds.
It is also directed that the Administrator shall extend full
cooperation to the Returning Officer, Sh. Shailah
Gupta, for conducting free and fair elections scheduled
to be held on 14.12.2025 in accordance with the
provisions of the Act and the Rules.”
7.
As can be seen from the above order, the RCS came to the conclusion
that the Society had not discharged its statutory duties in accordance with law
and accordingly, Mr. Ram Kumar Sawant, Grade-I officer, Government of
NCT of Delhi was, therefore, appointed as an Administrator, to manage the
day-to-day affairs of the Society.
8.
Aggrieved by the said order dated 12th November, 2025, the Petitioners
had preferred the present petition. Thereafter, the court vide order dated 26th
November, 2025, had stayed the impugned order dated 12th November, 2025
in terms as extracted above in paragraph 4.
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
9.
During the pendency of this petition, an application being CM APPL.
77567/2025, had been filed by various applicants who were aggrieved by the
interim order dated 26th November, 2025, seeking impleadment in the present
petition. The said applicants are Ms. Meenu Chopra, Ms. Renuka Verma, Ms.
Susheela Verma, Mr. Manish Mahajan, Ms. Bindu Chaudhary and Ms. Sarita
Singh.
10.
The allegation in the said application was that the order dated 12 th
November, 2025 had not been fully attached with the present petition and it
was also alleged that the persons who are presently on the Managing
Committee of the Society, are not the primary members of the Society.
11.
According to the said Applicants, the electoral roll was also
manipulated by the Managing Committee of the Society, so as to ensure that
such persons, who are not qualified, are permitted to contest. Similar
allegations have also been raised by the RCS, which has sought vacation of
the interim order dated 26th November, 2025.
12.
The Court has heard Mr. A.K. Singla, ld. Sr. Counsel for the Petitioners,
Ms. Harshita Nathrani, ld. Counsel for RCS and Ms. Sonia A. Menon, ld.
Counsel for Respondent No.3
13.
After hearing the ld. Counsels for the parties, it becomes clear that the
term of the present Managing Committee, which is conducting the affairs of
the Society, has already come to an end on 10th December, 2025.
14.
Accordingly, fresh elections have to be conducted. For the said
purpose, a Returning Officer has to be appointed. However, the issue
concerning the manipulation of the electoral roll, as to whether those members
who are not primary members can either vote/contest or not has to be
considered.
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
15.
On this issue, ld. Counsel for the applicants/intervenors have relied
upon a decision of the Division Bench of this Court in Writ Petition (Civil)
3495/2019 titled ‘Sheetal Vihar Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd.
and Ors. v. The Registrar Cooperative Societies and Ors.’ dated 5th April,
2019, wherein the Court has categorically held as under:
“4. We have heard the submissions of Mr.Munjal and
considered the same. We have also perused the
impugned order and the other documents placed on
record as also the legal position emerging from the
relevant provisions of the Delhi Cooperative Societies
Act, 2003 (hereinafter referred to as “Act”) and the
Rules.
As would be seen, the impugned order itself observes
that the appointment of the petitioner nos.2 and 3 was in
violation of Section 25(b) and 35(6) of the Act. Section
25 of the Act insofar as it is relevant, reads as follows:“25. Votes of members Every member of a co-operative
society shall have one vote in the affairs of the cooperative society: PROVIDED that
– (a) xxx xxx xxx
(b) A nominal or associate or joint member shall not
have the right of vote
(c) xxx xxx xxx.”
5. The admitted position is that the petitioner nos.2 and
3 are joint members and they are not primary members
of the petitioner no.1/society. Thus, on the face of it, the
petitioner nos.2 and 3 did not have the right to vote at
any election of the petitioner no.1/society. It is well
settled that a member who has no right to vote, cannot
also offer his candidature to any executive post in an
organisation. 6. Sub rule (1) of Rule 22 permits
admission of joint members along with the primary
member, subject to certain conditions. The said rule
reads as follows:“22. Procedure for admission of joint member, minor
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
and person of unsound mind and inheriting the share or
interest of deceased member
(1) A co-operative society may admit joint member
provided the proposed joint member make a declaration
in writing that the person whose name stands first in the
share certificate shall have the right to vote and all other
rights shall be enjoyed jointly and severally and
liabilities shall be borne jointly and severally by them
as provided under the Act, the rules and the bye-laws:
PROVIDED that in case of inability of the person whose
name stands first in share certificate, he/she can
authorize the other to vote and attend the meeting on his
behalf. PROVIDED FURTHER that in case of
cooperative group housing/house building society, the
joint membership shall be restricted to only person in
first degree blood relationship.
(2) In accordance with the procedure laid down in the
bye-laws and these rules for admission of any member,
a co-operative society may admit minor and person of
unsound mind inheriting share or interest of deceased
member as its member through their legal
representative or guardian respectively. The members
so admitted will enjoy such rights and liabilities as are
laid down in the bye-laws of the co-operative society
that are consistent with the Act and rules.”
(emphasis supplied)
7. Thus, as per the first proviso to Rule 22(1), the right
to vote conferred upon joint members is only in case of
‘inability’ of the person whose name stands first in the
share certificate to act, and not otherwise. The
‘inability’ spoken of in the first proviso to Rule 22(1) of
the Rules is a legal inability. It does not cover voluntary
renunciation or transfer of the right of the primary
member of his right to vote as a member of a society.
The same relates to inability which the primary
members may suffer from on account of minority,
insanity or other legal disability. This is clear not only
from the heading of the Rule, but also from sub-rule
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
(2). In fact, Sub-Rule (1) clearly provides that the joint
member has to furnish a declaration that the person
whose name stands first in the share certificate shall
have the right to vote. If the first proviso to Rule 22(1)
were to be interpreted broadly – to mean that ‘inability’
includes a conscious decision of the primary member
to voluntarily give up or cede his/her right to vote in
favour of the joint member, it would mean that any
member would be able to authorise the joint member
to vote and attend meetings on his/her behalf. But such
an interpretation would clearly be contrary to proviso
(b) of Section 25 of the Act taken note of hereinabove.
There is no gain saying that rules are subordinate to the
provisions contained in the Act, and cannot survive if
they are in contravention of the statutory provisions.
Thus, the only way in which the first proviso to Rule
22(1) can be saved from being declared ultra vires, the
Act, is to read it meaningfully, i.e., to limit the scope of
the phrase ‘inability of the person’ to mean legal
‘inability’ or ‘disability’. Thus, it clearly emerges that
the petitioner nos.2 and 3 were not entitled to vote, much
less, contest in the elections for the post of President and
Secretary in the petitioner no.1/society.
8. Reliance placed by Mr.Munjal on our decision in
Krishna Devi (supra) is misplaced. The facts of that case
are materially different. Moreover, proviso (b) to
Section 25 of the Act was neither referred to, nor
considered in the said decision since its application did
not arise for consideration.
9. The submission of Mr.Munjal that the impugned
order is illegal, since the same has been issued without
authority by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies,
does not motivate us to invoke our discretionary
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, since it is clear to us that no injustice has been
done to the petitioners with the passing of the impugned
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
order. The petitioners cannot run away from the fact
that the petitioner nos.2 and 3 were not entitled to
contest the elections, and be elected as President and
Secretary of the petitioner no.1/society. This Court is
not obliged to exercise its discretionary jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India in every
case, even if there is some irregularity pointed out by
the petitioner. We are, therefore, not inclined to
interfere with the impugned order.
10. The writ petition is dismissed in the above terms
along with the pending application.”
16.
In terms of the aforesaid judgement, the clear dictum of the Court is
that the primary members would be entitled to vote and in case of joint
membership a declaration has to be furnished in favour of the person whose
name stands first in the share certificate. Only then the said member would be
entitled to vote and contest as well.
17.
The submission of Mr. A.K. Singla, ld. Sr. Counsel in response to the
decision in Sheetal Vihar Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. and Ors.
(Supra) is that one of the persons who is contesting the elections, i.e.
Petitioner No.1-Mr. Amarjeet, is a primary member whose name stands first
in terms of the share certificate dated 18th August, 2022. In this regard,
reliance is also placed upon the sale deed dated 4th June, 2014, which has been
executed in favour of the Petitioner No.1 and his wife.
18.
At this stage, this Court is not inclined to go into a factual analysis as
to who is the appropriate primary member or not. Needless to add, in terms of
the decision in Sheetal Vihar Cooperative Group Housing Society Ltd. and
Ors. (Supra), only primary members can contest and can cast the vote.
19.
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
Pertinently, the elections of the Society have to be held now.
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
Accordingly, this Court deems it appropriate to appoint an independent
Observer/Returning Officer to finalise the electoral roll and oversee the
conduct of the elections.
20.
Mr. S.S Ahluwalia, Advocate who is present in Court, is appointed as
the Independent Observer/Returning Officer for the conduct of the elections
of the Society. The said Observer/Returning Officer’s mandate is as follows:
i)
The Observer/returning Officer shall finalise the electoral roll in the
precincts of the Society. In the event of any challenge to the
membership of any particular individuals, the Observer/Returning
Officer shall examine the relevant documents and take a decision in
accordance with the judgment in Sheetal Vihar Cooperative Group
Housing Society Ltd. and Ors. (supra).;
ii)
After finalising the electoral roll, the agenda for the election
schedule shall be announced by the Observer/Returning Officer;
iii) Thereafter, the nominations shall be filed by only those candidates
whose names appear in the finalised electoral roll;
iv) The elections shall then be conducted in a free and fair manner, as
per the convenience of all the members;
v)
For the aforesaid purposes, in the event that any meeting is required
to be convened by the Observer/Returning Officer within the
Society, the same shall be duly held;
vi) The records of the Society shall be taken over by the
Observer/Returning Officer on 11th April, 2026 at 11.30 am. The
RCS shall depute an official to assist the Observer/Returning
Officer;
vii) The records of the Society shall not be tampered by the present
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
Managing Committee, in any manner, and shall be kept in safe
custody.
21.
For the aforesaid purpose, Captain Vivek Chopra along with Petitioner
No.1-Mr. Amarjeet shall visit the office of the Society today i.e., 9th April,
2026 and shall install a new lock on the safe. The key thereto shall thereafter
be handed over to Mr. S.S. Ahluwalia.
22.
The fee of Mr. S.S Ahluwalia, the Observer/Returning Officer is fixed
at Rs. 2.5 lakhs and shall be borne by the Society.
23.
Insofar as the impugned order dated 12th November 2025 is concerned,
the Court has perused the same and there are sufficient reasons in the said
order. Since the Court has appointed an Observer/Returning Officer today, the
merits of the order have not been gone into.
24.
The petition is disposed of in these terms. All pending applications, if
any, are also disposed of.
25.
All rights and remedies of the parties pertaining to the elections, are left
open.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
MADHU JAIN
JUDGE
APRIL 9, 2026
MR/SM
Signed By:DHIRENDER
KUMAR
21:06:27
W.P.(C) 17919/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review