Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010572882024
+
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
AMAN SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Naman Jain, Adv. with the
petitioner in person
versus
DELHI TRANSPORT CORPORATION
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Rikky Gupta, SC with Ms.
Ananya Singh, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
19.08.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
We may commence the recital of facts in the present case by
referring to a notice dated 27 July 2018, served on the petitioner, who
was working as a conductor with the Delhi Transport Corporation 1,
whereby an amount of ₹ 4,45,740/-, purported to have been paid to
him in excess, was sought to be recovered from his gratuity.
A representation preferred by the petitioner against the said notice on
27 July 2018 was rejected by the DTC. An appeal preferred
thereagainst met with the same fate. The petitioner, therefore,
approached the Central Administrative Tribunal2 by way of OA
1 “DTC” hereinafter
2 “Tribunal” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
2063/2020.
2.
It is profitable to reproduce the prayer clause in the OA, which
read thus:
“In view of the above facts and ground mentioned above the
Applicant prays that this Hon’ble Tribunal may be pleased to:
a)
Quash and set aside the impugned notice and orders
dated 27.07.2018, 06.09.2018, and 26.11.2018 respectively,
issued / passed by the Respondent;
b)
Direct the Respondent to correctly re-fix the pay of
the Applicant herein, and thereafter grant all benefits to the
Applicant, due under law, and make good on all shortfalls
existing:
c)
Direct the Respondent to refund the amount illegally
recovered / deducted from the amount of gratuity payable to
the Applicant;
d)
Direct the Respond to pay such interest on all
amounts due and payable to the Applicant, as may be
deemed appropriate by this Hon’ble Court; and
e)
Pass any other orders as this Ld. Tribunal may deem
fit in the interests of justice.”
3.
We may note that the orders dated 27 July 2018, 6 September
2018 and 26 November 2018, of which quashing was sought in the
OA, alleged that an amount of ₹ 4,45,740/- had been paid to the
petitioner by mistake and proposed recovery thereof. As such, the
orders related both to refixation of the petitioner’s pay as well as
recovery of the amounts stated to have been erroneously overpaid.
4.
The Tribunal, by order dated 18 October 2022, allowed the OA.
The concluding para 9 and 10 of the order of the Tribunal read thus:
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
“9.
Thus, this Tribunal is of the view that the recovery so
ordered against the applicant needs to be quashed. Accordingly, the
impugned orders dated 27.07.2018, 06.09.2018 and 26.11.2018
are quashed and the respondents are directed to refund the amount,
which is already recovered from his salary or from pensionary
benefits i.e., from the Gratuity of the applicant, within a period of
120 days from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
10.
The OA is disposed of in the aforesaid terms. There shall be
no order as to costs.”
5.
By quashing the order dated 27 July 2018, the Tribunal set aside
not only the decision to recover ₹ 4,45,740/- from the petitioner but
also the decision to refix the petitioner’s pay on the basis of which it
was sought to be contended that amount of ₹ 4,45,740/- had been paid
to the petitioner in excess.
6.
The aforesaid judgment of the Tribunal was carried to this
Court at the instance of the DTC by way of WP (C) 2927/2023, which
was disposed of by a Coordinate Bench of this Court by order dated
10 March 2023, the concluding para 8 of which reads thus:
“8.
Keeping in view the totally of the circumstances, this Court
is of the view that the impugned order should not be interfered with
by this Court in exercise of its power under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.”
7.
Thus, with the passing of the aforesaid order of this Court, the
decision to refix the petitioner’s pay, as well as to effect recovery
from the petitioner of the alleged overpaid amounts, both stood set
aside.
8.
The DTC challenged the aforesaid order before the Supreme
Court by way of SLP (C) 12433/2023 which was also dismissed in
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
limine by the Supreme Court by order dated 5 July 2023.
9.
As such, there is no escape from the fact that, up to the Supreme
Court, the stand of the respondent that the petitioner had been
overpaid amount of ₹ 4,45,740/-, as well as the decision to recover the
same amount from the petitioner, both stood set aside.
10.
The inexorable sequitur would be that the petitioner would be
entitled not only to refund of the amount recovered from his gratuity
but also to have his pay refixed as it was prior to the passing of the
order dated 27 July 2018.
11.
As the respondent was not, however, refixing the petitioner’s
pay and restoring the status quo ante as it stood prior to 27 July 2018,
the petitioner approached the Tribunal once again by means of MA
94/2024, seeking a clarification in that regard. The prayer in the MA
read thus:
“In light of the aforesaid, it is most humbly prayed that this
Hon’ble Tribunal may kindly be pleased to:
A.
Allow the present Application, and clarify the Order dated
18.10.2022, passed in the present OA, to the extent that the
Respondent is directed to take all necessary action consequent to
the Order dated 18.10.2022 being passed, thereby re-fixing the
Applicant’s pay correctly and disbursing all benefits in a time
bound manner;
B.
Direct the Respondent to pay interest at the rate of 18%
p.a., on all dues illegally withheld, from the date they became due,
till date of actual payment; and,
C.
Pass any other orders as may be deemed necessary in the
interest of justice.”
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
12.
Unfortunately, the Tribunal has mechanically disposed of the
MA without, apparently, even noting what the MA actually sought.
The MA was disposed of by the Tribunal by the following order dated
30 April 2024:
“Order of The Tribunal
M.A. No.94/2024 in O.A. No.2063/2020
The instant MA has been filed seeking certain clarifications in
Order dated 18.10.2022 in the captioned OA.
2.
After going through the records and pleadings available, it
is amply clear that the respondents were directed to refund the
amount, which is already recovered from his salary or from
pensionary benefits i.e., from the Gratuity of the applicant, within a
period of 120 days from the date of receipt of a certified copy of
this order.
3.
I find that there is no ambiguity in the said order. Hence,
the same requires no clarification. Accordingly, the MA is
dismissed.”
13.
The Tribunal, therefore, while dealing with the MA, appears to
have proceeded on the premise that the only issue involved was the
aspect of refund of the amount recovered. The Tribunal has
overlooked the fact that the petitioner’s main grievance was that, as
the decision to refix his pay itself had been set aside, he was entitled to
restoration of the pay being drawn by him prior to the passing of the
order dated 27 July 2018.
14.
Aggrieved by the order dated 30 April 2024, passed by the
Tribunal in the MA, the petitioner has approached this Court by means
of the present writ petition.
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
15.
We have heard Mr. Naman Jain, learned Counsel for the
petitioner and Mr. Rikky Gupta, learned Standing Counsel for the
respondent, at length.
16.
Learned Counsel for the respondent submits that the only aspect
of the matter which was taken up by the Division Bench of this Court
in its order dated 10 March 2023 while disposing of WP(C)
2927/2023 was the aspect of refund of ₹ 4,45,740/-. He submits that
the order cannot be read as one which interferes with the decision to
refix the petitioner’s pay. Rather, submits learned Counsel for the
petitioner, in cognate matters listed involving other similarly situated
employees, this Court had, by other orders, upheld the decision to
refix the pay of the respondents in those cases.
17.
Learned Counsel for the respondent also submits that the
amount of ₹ 4,45,740/- stands refunded to the petitioner, which
learned Counsel for the petitioner also acknowledges.
18.
We cannot be concerned with orders passed by the Division
Bench of this Court in other matters, as the order dated 10 March 2023
was carried in appeal to the Supreme Court and the SLP was also
dismissed, albeit in limine. While this may not amount to merger of
the order passed by this Court with the order passed by the Supreme
Court, nonetheless, it clearly indicates that the order dated 10 March
2023 passed by this Court in WP (C) 2927/2023, in which the
petitioner was the respondent, has attained finality. No application was
ever moved for clarification of the said order.
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
19.
Para 8 of the order dated 10 March 2023, in categorical terms,
holds that there was no cause to interfere with the order passed by the
Tribunal. The entire order passed by the Tribunal, therefore, stands
affirmed, and the affirmation stands upheld by the Supreme Court.
20.
The order passed by the Tribunal was not restricted to the
aspect of refund but also set aside the order dated 27 July 2018 in
which it was stated the amount of ₹ 4,45,740/- had been paid to the
petitioner in excess. In other words, the very stand of the respondent
that an amount of ₹ 4,45,740/- was paid to the petitioner in excess
stands discredited by the Tribunal and by this Court, against which the
challenge to the Supreme Court has also failed.
21.
The respondent was, therefore, duty bound to reverse the
decision contained in the order dated 27 July 2018.
22.
As such, the impugned order dated 30 April 2024 passed by the
Tribunal in MA 94/2024 is quashed and set aside. It is clarified that
the petitioner would be entitled to all benefits which would flow from
the setting aside of the order dated 27 July 2018.
This would,
needless to say, entail restoration of the petitioner’s pay as it stood
prior to the passing of the order dated 27 July 2018
23.
Let the consequential payments to the petitioner, if any, be
made within a period of six weeks from today.
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
24.
The writ petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms with no
orders as to costs.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
VINOD KUMAR, J.
AUGUST 19, 2026/AR
W.P.(C) 12202/2024
KUMAR
19:04:25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review