Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010470652026
+
W.P.(C) 14452/2026, CM APPLs. 67771/2026, 67772/2026 &
67773/2026
ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF
MEDICAL SCIENCES
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Anand Varma and Mr.
Ayush Gupta, Advs.
versus
GIRDHARI LAL JAKHAR
.....Respondent
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
29.09.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
A.
A Prefatory Note of Appreciation
1.
We see before us, day in and day out, with some dismay, young
Counsel merely seeking passovers or adjournments on behalf of
arguing Counsel, and confessing ignorance, or at times “lack of
instruction”, if we call upon them to address arguments. This case
presented a welcome difference. Not only did Mr. Ayush Gupta argue
the matter as Mr. Anand Varma was on his legs elsewhere; he argued
commendably, and was thoroughly conversant with the file and the
record. Equally commendably, we have to note, Mr. Anand Varma,
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
when he did reach midway during arguments, did not “take over” the
case, but sat beside Mr. Gupta, merely helping at times when he
faltered. This is what we expect of senior as well as junior counsel.
The junior counsel should be prepared, and the senior counsel should
not discourage the junior from presenting the case. We record our
appreciation for Mr. Gupta as well as Mr. Varma. It gives us hope.
B.
Facts
2.
This writ petition assails judgment dated 5 August 2025 passed
by the Central Administrative Tribunal1 allowing OA 3804/2022,
preferred by the respondent before the Tribunal.
3.
The respondent applied, in response to an advertisement issued
by the All India Institute of Medical Sciences2, for recruitment to the
post of Driver Ordinate (Grade C) as a candidate belonging to the
Other Backward Classes3. He participated in the selection process and
succeeded in the written examination. The result notification 88/2022
dated 18 May 2022 declared that the respondent had secured 161
marks out of 200 and had obtained the 5th rank.
4.
Clauses 3, 5 and 10(i) of the advertisement are relevant, and
may be reproduced thus:
“3.
The applicants applying in response to this advertisement
should satisfy themselves regarding their eligibility for the post
applied for. They must be fulfilling all the eligibility criteria as on
1 “the Tribunal” hereinafter
2 “AIIMS” hereinafter
3 “OBC” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
the closing date of applications, failing which their application will
be rejected. Required educational qualification/ experience should
be completed on or before last date of application. In case of
educational qualification, the candidate should have completed
residency period for the desired educational qualification including
internship on or before last date of submission of application and
should had been declared to have passed examination on or before
this date. Likewise candidate must have completed duration of
desired experience on or before cutoff date i.e last date of
submission of online application.
5.
The On-line Registration will be closed by 05:00 PM on
19.11.2020. The candidature of such applicants who fails to
complete the online registration by the stipulated date and time will
not be considered and no correspondence in this regard will be
entertained.
10.(i) Candidates applying under any of the reserved category viz.
SC/ST/OBC will be considered subject to submission of valid
Caste certificate on a prescribed format issued by the competent
authority. The vacancies are being advertised in financial year
2020-2021, therefore, valid NCL-OBC certificate issued during the
period from 1.4.2020 to 31.3.2021 will be considered valid.
Candidature who have NCL-OBC certificate issued before or after
this period (i.e 1.4.2020 to 31.3.2021), will not be considered valid
for this advertisement. Candidates applying under OBC category
must produce the valid caste certificate in the format provided by
the DoP&T vide O.M. No. 36036/2/2013-Estt. (Res.) dated
30.05.2014 and further clarification issued by DoP&T OM No.
36036/2/2013-Estt(Res-I) dated 31.03.2016. Certificate must be
valid for employment in Central Government Institutions. OBC
candidate's eligibility will be based on Castes borne in the Central
List of Govt. of India. Their Sub-caste should also match with the
entries in Central List of OBC, failing which their candidature as
OBC candidate will not be considered. They will however be
treated as UR candidate. The OBC certificate should clearly show
that the applicant does not belong to the Creamy Layer.”
5.
Clause 3 stipulated that all eligibility criteria were required to
be satisfied by the aspirant candidate as on the closing date of
applications, failing which the application would be rejected. It went
on to clarify that the required educational qualification/experience had
to be possessed on or before the last date of the application.
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
6.
The respondent initially furnished an OBC-NCL certificate for
the year 2017-2018, which was submitted on 1 June 2022. The
respondent sought to contend that he was unable to produce a
certificate for year 2020-2021 owing to the intervening COVID-19
pandemic.
7.
On 7 September 2022, the AIIMS addressed the following
communication to the respondent:
“ALL INDIA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES
(RECRUITMENT CELL)
No.1-14/2021-Estt.(RCT)
Ansari Nagar, New Delhi-110029
Dated: 07 SEP 2022
Roll No. 9430698
Rank NO. 5
Ms.Girdhari Lal Jakhar
S/o. Nanu Rain Jakhar
Village-Basda, Post Jorpura,
Vaya-Jobner, The-Phulera, Jobner, Rajasthan, PIN. 303328
Email: tejaichoudhary6@gmail.com
Mob: 8630095198
SUBJECT:
Recruitment to the post of Driver Ordinary Grade at
AIIMS, New Delhi-submission of OBC (NCL).
This is with reference to his provisionally selection to the
post of Driver Ordinary Grade against the reserved post of OBC
(NCL) subject to verification of her documents on or before
09/06/2022, as per the instructions given on the Institute's website.
It is informed that after examination of the documents provided by
her, it has been observed that his OBC (NCL) certificate issued on
20/01/2022, whereas, it has been clearly mentioned that the valid
OBC (NCL) certificate issued during the period from 01/04/2020
to 31/03/2021 will be considered valid. The OBC (NCL) certificate
issued before or after this period (i.e. 01/04/2020 to 31/03/2021)
will not be considered valid as per the conditions laid down in the
advertisement for the above said post.
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
Therefore, in this effect, you are required to produce the
valid OBC (NCL) certificate during the period from 01/04/2020 to
31/03/2021 as per instructions given in the Institute's advertisement
within 15 days from the date of issue of this office letter, failing
which, your candidature for the post of Driver Ordinary Grade will
be treated cancelled/withdrawn.
Sd/(Rajender Singh)
Administrative Officer”
8.
Thus, by the communication dated 7 September 2022, the
AIIMS itself extended the date for producing the OBC-NCL
certificate by the respondent to 15 days after the issuance of the said
letter.
9.
Within the aforesaid period of 15 days, the respondent produced
the following certificate issued by the Sub Divisional Officer,
Sambhar Lake, Jaipur, on 13 September 2022:
“OFFICE OF THE SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER, SAMBHAR
LAKE (JAIPUR) JAIPUR, RAJASTHAN
TELE-FAX:- 01425-228253
E-mail- sdosmbr@gmail.com
S.Ν.:- 243
Date: 13-09-22
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that applicant Sh. Girdhari Lal Jakhar son of Mr
Nanu Ram Jakhar village-basda post-jorpura via-jobner, Jaipur in
District Jaipur of state Rajasthan having caste certificate No.
RJ/2017/REVENUE DEPARTMENT/Digital Caste OBC For
Central /18090197314 Dated 26/02/2018 so on the basis of this
applicant belongs to the 58 JAT (EXCEPT IN BHARATPUR
AND DHAULPUR DISTRICTS) Community which is
Recognized as a backward class under the Government of India,
Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerments Resolution no.
12011/68/98 - BCC dated 27/10/1999* and his family ordinarily
reside in Jaipur district of the Rajasthan for financial year 2020-
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
2021 period from 01/04/2020 to 31/03/2021.
This is also certify that Sh. Girdhari Lal Jakhar son of Mr. Nanu
Ram Jakhar village-basda post-jorpura via-jobner, Jaipur in District
Jaipur of state Rajasthan was belong to the "OBC (Non Creamy
Layer)" category for financial year 2020-2021 period from
01/04/2020 to 31/03/2021 mentioned in Column 3 of the Schedule
to the Government of India, Department of Personnel & Training
O.Μ. No. 36012/22/93- Estt. (SCT) dated 08/09/93** which is
modified vide OM No. 36033/3/2004 Estt. (Res.) dated
09/03/2004, further modified vide OM No. 36033/3/2004-Estt.
(Res.) dated 14/10/2008, again further modified vide OM
No.36036/2/2013-Estt (Res) dtd. 30/05/2014 and further
clarification issued by DoP&T OM No. 36036/2/2013-Esst(Res-I)
dated 31.03.2016.
*The authority issuing the certificate needs to mention the details
of Resolution of Government of India, in which the caste of the
candidate is mentioned as OBC.
**As amended from time to time.
Note:This certificate has been issued on the basis of required
information furnished by the applicant through an affidavit and on
the report of concerned Tehsildar.
Date
Sd/SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER &
MAGISTRATE”
10.
It needs to be mentioned, here, that the AIIMS does not dispute
either the competence of the officer who had issued the aforesaid
certificate, or the genuineness or credibility of the certificate itself, or
the correctness of the facts stated in the certificate, i.e., that the
respondent was in fact an OBC-NCL category candidate. On his
eligibility and entitlement for recruitment as an OBC-NCL candidate,
therefore, there is no real contest.
11.
The AIIMS, however, rejected the respondent’s candidature on
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
the ground that the aforesaid certificate had not been issued during the
period 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021 as required by Clause 10(i).
12.
Aggrieved by the rejection of his candidature, the respondent
approached the Tribunal by way of OA 3804/2022, seeking quashing
of the rejection letter dated 13 December 2022 and acceptance of the
OBC-NCL certificate dated 13 September 2022 produced by him in
response to the extension letter dated 7 September 2026 issued by the
AIIMS.
C.
The Impugned Judgment
13.
By judgment dated 5 August 2025, the Tribunal, has followed
the judgment of this Court in A.I.I.M.S. v. Ravi Kumar4, the Special
Leave Petition against which was also dismissed by the Supreme
Court, alongwith the respondent’s OA and has directed the certificate
dated 13 September 2022 to be treated as a valid OBC-NCL
certificate.
14.
Aggrieved thereby, the AIIMS has approached this Court by
means of the present writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
15.
We have heard Mr. Anand Varma and Mr. Ayush Gupta,
learned Counsel for the petitioner.
4 2024 SCC OnLine Del 2147
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
D.
Submissions and Analysis
16.
Despite the sincere efforts of Mr. Ayush Gupta, we do not find
any real ground to interfere with the order passed by the Tribunal.
17.
Mr. Gupta invoked Clauses 3, 5 and 10(i) of the advertisement.
18.
Re. Clause 3
18.1 Clause 3 stipulated that all eligibility criteria were required to
be satisfied by the aspirant candidate as on the closing date of
applications, failing which the application would be rejected. It went
on to clarify that the required educational qualification/experience had
to be possessed on or before the last date of the application.
18.2 Though Mr. Gupta has invoked this clause, we are of the
opinion that this clause has no application as there is no dispute
regarding the eligibility or educational qualifications of the
respondent, in so far as his entitlement for being recruited as Driver
(Ordinate) is concerned.
19.
Re. Clause 5
19.1 Clause 5 stated that the online registration would close by 5 pm
on 19 November 2020 and that the candidature of the candidates who
failed to complete online registration by that date or time, could not be
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
considered, and that no correspondence in that regard would be
entertained.
19.2 Mr. Gupta sought to rely on this clause as well. As in the case
of Clause 3, we are of the opinion that Clause 5, too, has no
application. The cut-off date prescribed in Clause 5 was for
registration. Registration was stated to be closing at 5 pm on 19
November 2020 and candidates who could not complete the online
registration by that date were ipso facto disqualified. There is no
dispute that the respondent registered before the cut-off date and time
of 5 pm on 19 November 2020. As such Clause 5 can also not operate
as an impediment to the entitlement of the respondent for recruitment
as Driver (Ordinate).
20.
Clause 10(i)
20.1 Clause 10(i) states that candidates applying under the SC, ST
and OBC categories were required to submit a valid caste certificate
on the prescribed format issued by the competent authority. We may
note that no prescribed format has been annexed to the advertisement.
Though the clause goes on to state that the OBC certificate was to be
in the format provided by OMs dated 30 May 2014 and 31 March
2016 issued by the Department of Personnel and Training5, neither of
the said OMs was annexed to the advertisement.
20.2 We are of the opinion that it would be unfair to expect
5 “DOPT” hereinafter
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
candidates to scour the internet or other sources to access official
Office Memoranda issued by the DOPT and other such agencies and
verify the formats in which the certificate was required to be
submitted. The least that could be expected in such cases would be
that the format of the certificate , or, at the very least, copies of the
OMs would be contained in or annexed to the advertisement, for the
information and instruction of applying candidates.
20.3 The following stipulation in Clause 10(i) is of pivotal
significance in the present case:
“The vacancies are being advertised in financial year 2020-2021,
therefore, valid NCL/OBC certificate issued during the period
from 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021 will be considered valid. The
candidates who have NCL / OBC certificate issued before or after
this period, (i.e.,1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021), will not be
considered valid for this advertisement”.
20.4 It is clear, from a meaningful reading of this stipulation, that the
requirement of issuance of the OBC-NCL certificate during the period
1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021 was only because the vacancies were
being advertised in the financial year 2020-2021. What was, therefore,
being sought to be ensured was that the OBC-NCL status of the
candidate was known during the financial year 2020-2021. This is
obviously, because the unlike the SC or ST status, which remains
inviolate and permanent, the NCL character of a candidate could
fluctuate. This has also been held by the Supreme Court in, inter alia,
Sakshi Arha v. Rajasthan High Court6, on which Mr. Gupta himself
has placed reliance.
6 2025 SCC OnLine SC 757
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
20.5 It would be unrealistic to bisect the clause and concentrate only
on the stipulation that the NCL-OBC certificate had to be issued
during the window period 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021, without
recognising the fact that this stipulation was intended to ensure that
the OBC-NCL status of the candidate was known during the financial
year 2020-2021. Obviously, therefore, an OBC-NCL certificate
pertaining to a financial year other than the financial year 2020-2021
would not suffice.
20.6 In applying the OBC-NCL policy of the Government, we have
to bear in mind the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India and Ors.7 and all authorities which
furthered the policy of reservation for the candidates belonging to
OBC who do not belong to the creamy layer.
20.7 The only reason why the respondent’s candidature was not
accepted was ultimately because the certificate provided by him had
not been issued during the period 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021.
20.8 We find this approach to be unacceptable on facts and in law. In
the first place, having itself extended, by its letter dated 7 September
2022, the time for the respondent to produce the OBC / NCL
certificate by a further period of 15 days, and the respondent having
actually provided the said certificate issued during the said period of
15 days, it would be unfair to reject the certificate on the ground that it
7 1992 (3) SCC (Supp) 217
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
was not issued during the period 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021,
which was over more than a year and half before the extension letter
was issued.
20.9 One only wonders whether, if the respondent had not been
forthright and honest and produced a certificate issued to him on 13
September 2022, and had produced an antedated certificate for the
period issued during 1 April 2021 to 31 March 2022, he would not
have been luckier in securing entitlement.
20.10 The issuance of the certificate was not something which was
within the power of the respondent. We cannot also be oblivious of
the fact that, during the period 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021, the
COVID-19 pandemic was at its peak. It would be unrealistic to expect
candidates to be able to obtain certificates issued during that period.
Travel, even within city limits, was, at that time, an ordeal.
20.11 Nonetheless, within the extension of time granted to the
respondent by the letter dated 7 September 2022, the respondent
produced the certificate dated 13 September 2022.
20.12 There is no dispute about the competence of the authority who
issued the said certificate. There is also no dispute to the OBC or the
NCL status of the respondent.
20.13 Moreover, the certificate actually pertains to the financial year
2020-2021. The purpose for requiring the certificate to have been
issued between 1 April 2020 and 31 March 2021, which was only to
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
insure that the OBC-NCL status of the candidate was known during
that financial year, was equally subserved by the certificate dated 15
September 2022, which the respondent ultimately provided.
E.
Conclusion
21.
Keeping in mind all these facts, and the genuine difficulty
which the respondent had in not providing a certificate during the
period 1 April 2020 to 31 March 2021, we are of the opinion that the
impugned judgment of the Tribunal does not merit interference in
exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction vested in us by Article 226 of
the Constitution of India.
22.
For these reasons, we decline to interfere in the present writ
petition which is accordingly dismissed.
23.
The AIIMS is directed to process the candidature of the
respondents further in terms of the directions contain in the impugned
judgment within a period of eight weeks from today.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
NIVEDITA ANIL SHARMA, J.
SEPTEMBER 29, 2026/aky
W.P.(C) 14452/2026
KUMAR
13:02:48
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review