Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MLHC:891
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
MC (EL) Pet. No. 26 of 2023 in
El. Pet. No. 5 of 2023
Date of Decision :17.08.2026
…. Applicant(s)
Shri Sanjay A. Sangma
Versus
…. Respondent(s)
Ali Akbar
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Applicant(s)
:
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv. with
Mr. A.M. Pala, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Khyriem, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
Yes/No
This application under Section 86 of the Representation of
People Act, 1951 read with Order 7 Rule 11 of the CPC and Gauhati High
Court Rules (as adopted by the High Court of Meghalaya), has been filed by
2026:MLHC:891
the respondent in the main Election petition with the prayer for dismissal of
the Election petition, as not maintainable in law.
2.
The grounds set out by the applicant are that the copy of the
petition served upon him was not attested by the petitioner under his own
signature as a true copy, as required under Section 81(3) of the RP Act, but
instead the affirmation was allegedly done by the petitioner’s advocate.
Further, it has also been highlighted that there are significant differences
between the copy filed in the Court Registry (bearing the Notary Stamp of
one M. Lyngwa) and the copy served upon the respondent (bearing the
Notary Stamp of one J. Blah) and that only specific pages of the served copy
were notarized. The petition it is alleged, has been verified improperly and
that it lacks the mandatory affidavit in the prescribed form for allegations
regarding corrupt practice under Section 83(1) (c) of the RP Act. It has also
been contended that the petitioner has committed fraud on the Court and
committed perjury and has approached the Court with unclean hands.
3.
Mr. A.S. Pandey, learned counsel for the respondent/applicant
has submitted that though there are various objections to the maintainability
of the election petition including the contention that the election petition had
not been presented in accordance with Section 81(1) of the RP Act, this
question is preceded with the issue whether the election petition has been
filed in derogation of Section 81(3) of the RP Act, as the true copy of the
2026:MLHC:891
Election petition was not supplied to the applicant. The learned counsel has
referred to Chapter-VIII-A of the Gauhati High Court Rules as applicable in
the High Court of Meghalaya, which he submits that all copies should be
fully attested by the petitioner under his own signature to be a true copy of
the petition. Further, it is argued that in the served copy only certain pages
were notarized and the remaining pages including annexures are not
notarized, the election petition does not bear the attestation of the election
petitioner that it is a true copy and the annexures were affirmed to be true
copy by the advocate.
4.
From the facts he submits, it clearly shows that the election
petition filed by the petitioner before this Court is significantly different
from the election petition supplied to the applicant. Section 81(3) of the RP
Act he submits, mandates that all pages have to be fully attested by the
election petitioner to be true copies and the learned counsel has placed
reliance on the followings decisions in support of his case: i)
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Arati Boro, 2021 SCC OnLine
Gau 2646
ii)
Prataprai Trumbaklal Mehta v. Jayant Nemchand Shah, 1991
SCC OnLine Bom 205
iii)
Mithilesh Kumar Pandey v. Baidyanath Yadav (1984) 2 SCC 1
iv)
G.V. Sreerama Reddy v. Returning Officer (2009) 8 SCC 736
v)
Jagan Nath v. Jaswant Singh (1954) 1 SCC 57
2026:MLHC:891
5.
It is then contended that in the light of the aforementioned
judgments, the filing of a true copy of the election petition is a mandatory
requirement and cannot be extended beyond typographical or clerical
mistakes. With regard to the presentation, reference has been made by the
learned counsel to the Gauhati High Court Rules which he submits that the
election petitioner has failed to comply with, while presenting the election
petition before the Stamp Reporter. Reliance has been placed on the
judgments namely; Abdul Jabbar vs. Syeda Anwara Taimur & Ors. and
also Nazir Ahmad vs. King Emperor, in support of this contention.
6.
On the objections raised by the election petitioner that the
instant petition under Order 7 Rule 11, has been filed without permission
being obtained under Rule 10 of Chapter-VIII-A of the Gauhati High Court
Rules, it has been argued that the said objection has not been taken in the
pleadings/reply filed by the election petitioner and the same is not liable to
be considered by this Court. It is also further submitted that this provision in
the High Court Rules is merely directory in nature as the term ‘may be’ has
been used, which he contends is permissive in nature and no consequence is
provided for non-compliance of the same. In this context, reference has been
made to the case of Shri Kartush R. Marak vs. Shri John Marak (MC) EP
No. 18/2023 in EP 1/2023 dated 19.06.2024, wherein this objection was
overlooked and not considered as the same had been made under the
2026:MLHC:891
procedural provision of Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, which has been similarly done
in the instant case. It is lastly submitted that the application was permitted to
be on record vide orders passed by this Court and further proceedings
thereafter were in pursuance to orders passed by this Court itself, and as such
requirement of Rule 10 of Chapter-VIII-A of the Gauhati High Court Rules
stands satisfied.
7.
In reply Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Khyriem, learned counsel for the petitioner has firstly submitted that the
election petition was presented personally before the Stamp Reporter on
13.04.2023, with requisite Court Fees paid. With regard to the main
contention raised by the applicant, it is submitted that the requirements of
Section 81(3) of the RP Act, 1951 is of ‘substance and not of form’ in which
he submits as held by the Supreme Court in various judgments, if not of a
vital nature, then the same can be corrected. The copies served upon the
applicant he submits, bear the signature of the election petitioner at every
page, and as such, the requirements as provided under Section 81(3) of the
RP Act have been complied with. The word ‘true copy’ he contends, as it
appears under Section 81(3) of the RP Act does not mean an absolute exact
copy, but refers to a copy that shall be so true that no reasonable man can by
any possibility, misunderstand or misconstrue it. He further submits that if
the copy served upon the applicant has the effect of misleading, as to the
2026:MLHC:891
contents of the petition and the allegations made therein, the applicant has to
specify the same in the Order 7 Rule 11 application, stating how he has been
misled and should state therein, the variance in the contents of the petition
served upon him and the copy filed before this Court. The applicant he
asserts, has failed in this aspect to demonstrate as to how he has been misled
and has also failed to justify the allegations of corrupt practices in the
election proceedings.
8.
It is then submitted that the defects pointed out by the applicant
with respect to notarial stamps and signatures of the election petitioner are
only ancillary and curable in nature, and cannot be construed as an omission
or variation of a vital nature that would result in the applicant and this Court
being misled, further with the fact that notarization is not a defect for the
purposes of Section 81(3) of the RP Act. The fundamental requirement he
submits, is that the copies served upon the applicant must bear the signature
of the election petitioner at every page of the election petition, which in the
instant case, has been duly attested by the election petitioner at every page
of the election petition to be a true copy, and as such therefore, the petition
fulfils the requirement of substantial compliance under the RP Act. Learned
Senior counsel has then referred to the judgment of Murarka Radhay
Shyam Sundar vs. Roop Singh Rathore & Ors. (1963) SCC OnLine 129,
in support of his argument of substantial compliance. He therefore, submits
2026:MLHC:891
that the objections pointed out by the applicant do not constitute any material
defect of a vital nature, but rather refers to two ancillary markings, which
cannot render the election petition defective as there is no variation in the
contents of both documents to mislead the applicant. Learned Senior counsel
has also placed reliance on the following two decisions i.e. T.M. Jackob vs.
C. Poulose & Ors. (1999) 4 SCC 274 and P. Phunzathang vs.
Hangkhanlian & Ors. (2001) 8 SCC 358.
9.
The learned Senior counsel has also raised additional issues on
the application under Order 7 Rule 11 being filed in violation of ChapterVIII-A, Rule 10 of the Gauhati High Court Rules, where he submits it has
been provided that any interlocutory application can only be filed with leave
granted by the Court, whereas from the orders of this Court dated
15.06.2023, and 23.07.2023, no leave was sought or granted by this Court
for filing of the application under Order 7 Rule 11. As such, he submits the
application of Order 7 Rule 11, is liable to be rejected.
10.
On hearing the learned counsel for the parties, the issues that
arise for determination is whether firstly, the petition was filed in violation
of Section 81(1) of the RP Act i.e. whether it was presented personally by
the election petitioner in accordance with law and secondly, whether the
petition violates Section 81(3) of the RP Act because the copies served were
not attested by the petitioner under his own signature, as true copies.
2026:MLHC:891
11.
On the first issue i.e. on presentation though allegation had been
made that the petitioner had not personally presented the election petition
before the Stamp Reporter, this allegation has been countenanced by the
election petitioner in his affidavit by stating that the election petition had
been personally presented on 13.04.2023, before the Stamp Reporter. On
this issue it is noted, both in the application filed by the respondent/returned
candidate and in the affidavit in reply thereto, no particulars or instances
have been stated or disclosed to substantiate the allegation or to disprove the
same to enable this Court to come to a definitive finding. As this Court has
held in similar matters where this question has arisen, as the same is crucial
in nature, inasmuch as, non-compliance of Section 81(1) of the RP Act and
Rule 1 of Chapter-VIII-A of the Gauhati High Court Rules would be fatal to
the maintainability of the election petition and warrant dismissal under
Section 86, this aspect is to be taken up for preliminary consideration by way
of evidence.
12.
On the second issue, as held by this Court in other similar
matters, non-furnishing of duly signed attested copies is a curable defect as
the same is governed by the doctrine of substantial compliance as held in the
cases of Murarka Radhay Shyam Sundar vs. Roop Singh Rathore & Ors.
T.M. Jackob vs. C. Poulose & Ors. and P. Phunzathang vs. Hangkhanlian
& Ors. (supra). The Notary Seal discrepancies and partial notarization are
2026:MLHC:891
ancillary, non-statutory irregularities that do not mislead the applicant and
thus are non-fatal. It is also relevant to note that as held in the case of G.M.
Siddeshwar vs. Prasanna Kumar (2013) 4 SCC 776, Section 86 of the RP
Act, makes no reference to Section 83, and non-compliance to Section 83
i.e. verification in affidavits is a curable defect and does not justify threshold
dismissal. Further, the allegations of fraud and perjury have not been made
out since no variation is present, which may mislead the application as to the
substance of allegations, and as such it passes the settled ‘true copy’ test
following the judgment of Murarka Radhay Shyam Sundar vs. Roop Singh
Rathore & Ors.(supra), where at Para-11 the extracts of which are
reproduced hereinbelow, it has been held as follows:“11. ……We are of the view that the word “copy” in subsection (3) of Section 81 does not mean an absolutely exact
copy, but means that the copy shall be so true that nobody can
by any possibility misunderstand it (see Stroud’s judicial
Dictionary, 3rd Edn., Vol. 4, p. 3098)………We are of the view
that the word “copy” does not mean an absolutely exact copy.
It means a copy so true that nobody can by any possibility
misunderstand it. The test whether the copy is a true one is
whether any variation from the original is calculated to
mislead an ordinary person. Applying that test we have come
to the conclusion that the that the defects complained of with
regard to Election Petition No. 269 of 1962 were not such as
to mislead the appellant; therefore there was no failure to
comply with the last part of sub-section (3) of Section
81…….”
13.
The other additional issues argued by the election petitioner i.e.
the application under Order 7 Rule 11 being filed in violation of ChapterPage 9 of 10
2026:MLHC:891
VIII-A Rule 10 of the Gauhati High Court Rules, without leave being sought,
being an issue that has not been objected to in the reply affidavit or objected
to initially by the counsel and keeping the order passed in the case of Shri
Kartush R. Marak vs. Shri John Marak (MC) EP No. 18/2023 in EP
1/2023 dated 19.06.2024 in mind, the same is overlooked.
14.
The objections raised by the applicant on the first issue being a
triable preliminary issue and the second being non-fatal, the election petition
remains legally maintainable to be determined on a preliminary hearing on
presentation and on merits.
15.
Accordingly, as per the discussions and findings made
hereinabove, the instant Misc. application is accordingly disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
17.08.2026
“V. Lyndem- AR-PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2026.08.17 15:40:04 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review