Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 07th April, 2026.
Pronounced on: 29th May, 2026.
Uploaded on: 31st May, 2026.
+
W.P.(C) 6602/2018, CM APPL. 25197/2018, CM APPL.
39328/2019, CM APPL. 18467/2021, CM APPL. 28891/2021, CM
APPL. 45215/2023, CM APPL. 11247/2024, CM APPL.
65700/2024, CM APPL. 73156/2025
ALI AHMAD KHAN
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Biswajit Das, Mr. Deepak Kumar
and Ms. Neha Yadav, Advocates.
versus
THE CHAIRMAN NATIONAL BOOK TRUST INDIA & ANR
....Respondents
Through: Mr. Nalin Kohli, Senior Advocate
with Ms. Anshul Malik and Mr.
Ayuushman Arora, Advocates for R3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J.:
1.
This writ petition concerns the legality of the relieving order dated
29th May, 2018 issued by National Book Trust, India,1 by which the
Petitioner, who was serving as Joint Director (Administration & Finance) on
deputation, was prematurely repatriated to his parent organisation, Council
“NBT”
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
for Leather Exports.2 The Petitioner also seeks consequential directions for
release of dues which, according to him, were payable during his deputation
in NBT.
2.
This case is connected with W.P.(C) 5425/2019, in which the
Petitioner has challenged the charge-sheet dated 1st March, 2019, the
disciplinary proceedings initiated by CLE, and the suspension order dated
15th April, 2019. The two petitions arise from a common factual chain of
events but are premised on separate causes of action. W.P.(C) 5425/2019
concerns disciplinary action by CLE. The present petition, on the other
hand, concerns NBT’s premature repatriation order and deputation-linked
dues.
3.
By a separate judgment pronounced today in W.P.(C) 5425/2019, this
Court has considered the objection of CLE that it is not amenable to writ
jurisdiction. For the reasons recorded therein, the Court has held that CLE is
an authority or instrumentality of the State within Article 12 and is, in any
event, amenable to writ jurisdiction under Article 226. The said finding
applies to CLE’s objection in the present petition as well, to the extent any
consequential relief is sought against CLE. In any case, the principal
challenge in the present writ petition is to the relieving order issued by NBT,
a body functioning under the Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Government of India.
Factual background
4.
NBT issued a vacancy notice inviting applications for the post of Joint
Director (Administration & Finance) on deputation basis. The advertised
post was in PB-3, Rs.15600-39100 with Grade Pay Rs.7600, and the period
“CLE”
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
of deputation was initially three years, extendable by a maximum of one
year. The eligibility clause contemplated candidates from Government,
Semi-Government or autonomous organisations, with experience in
Government administrative and financial rules and office procedure.
5.
The detailed terms and conditions appended to the vacancy notice,
inter alia, stated that the pay and other terms of deputation would be
regulated under the DoPT instructions on deputation, as amended from time
to time, and that the initial appointment would be for three years.
Applications were required to be sent through proper channel along with
integrity certificate, vigilance clearance, penalty statement and APARs.
6.
The Petitioner, then serving in CLE, applied through proper channel.
NBT selected him for appointment on transfer on deputation basis. The
appointment letter dated 10th March, 2017 stated that the Petitioner’s
deputation would be for three years. NBT reserved the right to repatriate him
at any time if his performance was not satisfactory or if his services were not
required by the Trust. The appointment letter also stated that his pay would
be governed by DoPT OM dated 17th June, 2010, as amended from time to
time.
7.
On 31st March, 2017, CLE relieved the Petitioner from the post of
Regional Director, Central Region, Kanpur, to report to NBT. The relieving
order certified that no vigilance case was pending or contemplated against
him. NBT thereafter issued Office Order No. 236/2017 dated 6th April, 2017
appointing the Petitioner as Joint Director (Administration & Finance) with
effect from 31st March, 2017 afternoon. The order specifically recorded that
the appointment on deputation would initially be for three years and that the
service conditions would be governed by the terms communicated in the
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
offer letter dated 10th March, 2017.
8.
On 20th April, 2017, CLE conveyed approval of its Chairman to the
Petitioner’s appointment in NBT. It also supplied his last pay details, 7th
CPC pay level, deductions, PF contribution, pension contribution and other
service particulars. The letter further set out remittances to be made by NBT
to CLE, including employer contribution at 12% on basic pay and DA,
pension salary contribution at 20%, gratuity-related remittance, leave
encashment and other service benefits.
9.
By Office Order No. 357/2017 dated 26th May, 2017, NBT fixed the
Petitioner’s pay after he assumed charge as Joint Director (Administration &
Finance). The order recorded basic pay of Rs.1,30,400, deputation
allowance, PF deduction, pension contribution and remittances to be made
by NBT.
10.
During the Petitioner’s tenure in NBT, disputes arose regarding
deputation-linked payments. The Petitioner claims that NBT withheld
legitimate and statutory dues contrary to the terms agreed between NBT and
CLE. On 3rd May, 2018, he submitted a representation to the Director, NBT,
referring to NBT’s memorandum dated 19th April, 2018 and raised claims
relating to deputation benefits, household shifting, LTC, statutory
remittances and other admissible allowances.
11.
On 29th May, 2018, NBT issued the impugned relieving order. The
order states that the Petitioner is repatriated to his parent department, namely
CLE, Chennai, and stands relieved in the afternoon of 29th May, 2018. It
directs him to report for duty to the Executive Director, CLE, Head Office,
Chennai. No reason for repatriation is recorded in the order.
12.
On the very next day, the Petitioner submitted a representation dated
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
30th May, 2018 seeking revocation of the relieving order. He invoked para 9
of the DoPT OM dated 17th June, 2010 and asserted that premature reversion
to the parent cadre required advance notice of at least three months to the
lending department and to the employee concerned. He also pointed out that
his deputation was for three years and that, under the terms of deputation,
foreign service would end only when he resumed charge in the parent office.
13.
After the relieving order, the Petitioner attempted to report to CLE.
On 9th July, 2018, he submitted a joining report to CLE stating that he was
reporting for duty after availing admissible joining time/leave from the date
of his untimely relieving from NBT. He requested CLE to accept the joining
report and advise him further.
14.
CLE did not accept the Petitioner’s joining at that stage. By
communication dated 11th July, 2018, CLE informed the Petitioner that it
had written to NBT seeking reasons for his sudden premature repatriation
and that no response had been received. CLE also stated that it had reminded
NBT to provide reasons and to allow the three-month notice period
contemplated by para 9 of the DoPT OM dated 17th June, 2010. The
Petitioner was asked to await NBT’s response.
15.
The Petitioner thereafter physically reported at CLE’s Chennai office
on 30th July, 2018 and again sought posting and regularisation of the leave
availed after the NBT relieving order. CLE’s later communication dated 5th
September, 2018 stated that the matter regarding his posting was under
discussion. Its communication dated 17th September, 2018 described the
matter as “re-absorption” after premature repatriation and stated that it was
under consideration. That communication also referred to a letter received
from the Department of Commerce concerning issues from the Petitioner’s
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
tenure in the Central Waqf Council.3
16.
The NBT justifies the Petitioner’s premature repatriation by relying
on an interim audit observation dated 30th May, 2018, notably one day after
the Petitioner was relieved. This audit characterized the Petitioner’s
appointment as “erroneous”, alleging he had misrepresented the status of his
parent office (CLE) as an autonomous organization to meet eligibility
criteria. Furthermore, the record reveals that NBT’s actions were influenced
by May, 2017 PMO reference and complaints from the CWC alleging
“financial embezzlement” during the Petitioner’s prior tenure.
17.
Thus, the Petitioner’s grievance is that NBT abruptly curtailed his
deputation without reasons and in a manner contrary to the governing
deputation framework. According to him, the decision was founded upon
adverse material that was never disclosed to him. He further contends that
the action carries a stigmatic character, as NBT now seeks to justify the
curtailment on grounds of ineligibility, alleged misrepresentation and audit
objections. It is also his case that the impugned action left his service
position uncertain, as CLE did not permit him to resume duties.
Interim directions and procedural course
18.
The present writ petition was initially filed against NBT and its
authorities. The Petitioner also moved an application to implead CLE. On
19th July, 2018, the Court declined impleadment at that stage, observing that
the petition challenged NBT’s relieving order and that CLE was not then a
necessary party.
19.
The position changed when the Petitioner asserted that, after
repatriation, CLE had not permitted him to join. Accordingly, by order dated
“CWC”
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
20th November, 2018, CLE was impleaded as Respondent no. 3.
20.
On 18th December, 2018, counsel appearing for CLE stated, on
instructions, that CLE was not ready to give joining to the Petitioner but
would pay salary from 9th July, 2018 till further orders. The Court recorded
that statement and made it clear that CLE shall continue to pay salary to the
Petitioner. The issue of salary from 29th May, 2018 to 9th July, 2018 was left
for final disposal.
21.
On 5th February, 2026, CLE was directed to file an affidavit
explaining its revenue model and clarifying whether it receives funding from
the Government. In compliance, CLE thereafter filed an affidavit reiterating
that it is a Section 25 company, not a Government organisation, and that
Government funding, if any, is limited to scheme-specific export-promotion
activities under MAI/MDA schemes and not to establishment or
administrative expenditure.
The Petitioner’s case
22.
The Petitioner submits that NBT’s relieving order dated 29th May,
2018 is arbitrary, unreasoned and contrary to the terms of deputation. He
submits that his appointment was for three years and was made after a
regular selection process through proper channel. CLE relieved him, NBT
accepted him, fixed his pay, and the deputation arrangement was acted upon
for more than one year.
23.
He contends that NBT could not prematurely repatriate him without
following para 9 of the DoPT OM dated 17th June, 2010. The Petitioner
stresses that this OM governed his deputation because the vacancy notice,
the offer letter and the office order expressly incorporated the DoPT
framework. He says that three months’ advance notice to the lending
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
organisation and to the employee was mandatory before premature
reversion.
24.
The Petitioner further submits that the relieving order is not a simple
administrative order. Though it is worded neutrally, NBT’s counter-affidavit
discloses that the real basis of repatriation was alleged ineligibility, alleged
misrepresentation regarding CLE’s status, audit objections and allegations
concerning his earlier tenure in the Central Waqf Council. These grounds,
according to the Petitioner, are stigmatic. They could not have been used
against him without notice, disclosure of material and opportunity to
respond.
25.
The Petitioner also contends that NBT’s plea of ineligibility is an
afterthought. CLE forwarded his application, issued the relieving order,
certified that no vigilance case was pending or contemplated and NBT
selected him after scrutiny. NBT then appointed him and fixed his pay. It
therefore cannot, after more than one year of service, say that the Petitioner
was never eligible because CLE was not Government, Semi-Government or
autonomous.
26.
The Petitioner points out that CLE itself, after his repatriation, wrote
to NBT seeking reasons for premature repatriation and insisted upon the
three-month notice contemplated by the DoPT OM. He argues that this
shows that even the lending organisation understood the repatriation as
procedurally defective.
27.
On dues, the Petitioner relies on his representation dated 3rd May,
2018 and subsequent affidavits. He claims unpaid salary, deputation
allowance, statutory remittances, PF/pension contribution, LTC and other
deputation-linked benefits. He submits that NBT’s action, followed by
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
CLE’s refusal to permit joining, left him without salary for the interregnum
until this Court intervened.
The stand of NBT
28.
NBT contests the petition. It submits that a deputationist has no vested
right to continue for the full deputation tenure. It relies on the terms of
appointment which reserve to NBT the right to repatriate the Petitioner if his
performance was not satisfactory or if his services were not required. NBT
also relies on decisions such as Kunal Nanda v. Union of India,4 Umapati
Choudhary v. State of Bihar,5 and allied authorities to submit that
repatriation is an incident of deputation.
29.
NBT further submits that the Petitioner was not eligible for
appointment to the post of Joint Director because he did not come from a
Government, Semi-Government or autonomous organisation. NBT relies
upon the Ministry of Commerce letter dated 21st July, 2017, which described
CLE as an industry body, autonomous in internal administrative functions,
and not a Government organisation.
30.
NBT submits that audit objections were raised concerning the
Petitioner’s eligibility and also concerning alleged financial irregularities
during his earlier tenure as Secretary, CWC. It submits that the action taken
by it must be understood in that background.
31.
NBT also relies on the DoPT OM dated 19th May, 1993 to submit that
if a person is not qualified or eligible in terms of the recruitment rules, or if
false information has been furnished to secure appointment, such person
should not be retained in service. According to NBT, the relieving order was
(2000) 5 SCC 362
(1999) 4 SCC 659
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
justified because the Petitioner’s initial appointment itself suffered from a
defect.
32.
As regards dues, NBT disputes the Petitioner’s claims. It contends
that some claims were inadmissible or required verification from the parent
organisation. It relies on its memorandum dated 19th April, 2018, by which
several claims were either rejected, deferred or kept in abeyance.
The stand of CLE
33.
CLE’s principal stand, so far as maintainability is concerned, has been
dealt with in the judgment pronounced today in W.P.(C) 5425/2019. Be that
as it may, in the present petition, CLE states that it was impleaded only after
the Petitioner complained that he had not been allowed to join after NBT
repatriated him.
34.
CLE further submits that, pursuant to the order dated 18th December,
2018, it paid salary from 9th July, 2018 until the Petitioner was placed under
suspension on 15th April, 2019. Thereafter, according to CLE, only
subsistence allowance was payable under its Standing Orders. CLE’s
position on suspension and the disciplinary proceedings has been considered
in the companion judgment in W.P.(C) 5425/2019.
Issues
35.
The following issues arise for determination in the present petition:
i.
Whether the writ petition is maintainable, particularly in view of
CLE’s objection to writ jurisdiction.
ii.
Whether NBT’s relieving order dated 29th May, 2018 is a simple
administrative repatriation order or whether it is founded on adverse and
stigmatic material.
iii.
Whether the Petitioner’s deputation was governed by the DoPT
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
deputation framework, including the requirement of advance notice before
premature reversion.
iv.
Whether NBT could repatriate the Petitioner on the grounds now
disclosed in the counter-affidavit without issuing notice, disclosing material
and granting him an opportunity to respond.
v.
Whether NBT’s plea that the Petitioner was ineligible because CLE
was not a Government/Semi-Government/autonomous organisation can be
accepted.
vi.
What monetary or consequential relief, if any, should follow in
respect of the period after the relieving order and in respect of the
Petitioner’s representation dated 3rd May, 2018.
Analysis
Maintainability
36.
The objection to maintainability, in substance, is CLE’s objection.
NBT is the principal Respondent in the present petition and the impugned
order is issued by NBT. There is no serious dispute that the writ petition, in
so far as it challenges NBT’s order, is maintainable under Article 226.
37.
As regards CLE, this Court has, by a separate judgment pronounced
today in W.P.(C) 5425/2019, held that CLE is an authority/instrumentality
of the State within Article 12 and is amenable to writ jurisdiction. The
reasons recorded in that judgment need not be repeated. It is sufficient to
state that CLE’s objection to maintainability in the present petition is
rejected for the same reasons.
38.
There is an additional reason why CLE’s objection cannot defeat this
writ petition. CLE was not impleaded as the author of the impugned
relieving order. That order was passed by NBT. CLE was brought on record
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
because NBT’s premature repatriation immediately affected the Petitioner’s
ability to resume charge in his parent organisation, and because CLE did not
permit physical joining after such repatriation. CLE’s role in this writ is
therefore consequential to the principal challenge against NBT. Its objection
cannot render a petition directed, in substance and in relief, against NBT’s
order dated 29th May, 2018, to be non-maintainable.
Nature of the relieving order
39.
The relieving order dated 29th May, 2018 is brief. It states that the
Petitioner is repatriated to CLE and stands relieved in the afternoon of that
date. It directs him to report to the Executive Director, CLE, and says that he
is entitled to TA and other benefits as per rules. The order does not state that
the Petitioner’s services were no longer required or that his performance was
unsatisfactory. Nor does it record any administrative exigency or refer to
eligibility, misrepresentation, audit objection, or any pending complaint.
40.
If the order were to be judged only by its form, it may appear to be a
simple repatriation. However, NBT’s own defence reveals otherwise. NBT
now contends that the Petitioner was not eligible for appointment because
CLE was not a Government/Semi-Government/autonomous organisation. It
also refers to audit objections and allegations from the Petitioner’s tenure at
CWC. These considerations bear directly upon the Petitioner’s eligibility,
integrity and suitability and cannot be treated as routine administrative
matters.
41.
A deputationist may not have an indefeasible right to continue till the
last day of the deputation period. That proposition is well settled. But it does
not follow that every premature repatriation is immune from scrutiny. A
deputationist is entitled to question the order where the reversion is ordered
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
without notice and rests, in substance, on undisclosed adverse material.
42.
A borrowing organisation may, for genuine administrative reasons,
state that it no longer requires the services of a deputationist. Such a
decision ordinarily stands on a different footing. But where the borrowing
organisation justifies the repatriation on the ground that the deputation itself
was vitiated by ineligibility, irregularity, misrepresentation, or material
adverse to the officer, the matter ceases to be a routine administrative return.
The order then carries a stigmatic foundation and attracts the minimum
requirements of fairness in procedure.
43.
In Kunal Nanda, the Supreme Court held a deputationist has no right
either to continue on deputation indefinitely or to claim absorption in the
borrowing organisation. That principle, however, does not authorise every
form of premature reversion. In Union of India v. V. Ramakrishnan,6 the
Supreme Court held that where the tenure of deputation is specified, it
should ordinarily not be curtailed except on just grounds, such as
unsuitability or unsatisfactory performance. The Court also recognised that
an order of reversion, even in the case of a deputationist, may be examined
if it is mala fide.
44.
The present case must therefore be tested not on the abstract
proposition that a deputationist has no vested right to continue, but on the
real character of the order by which the deputation was brought to an end.
NBT did not merely exercise a simple administrative option to send back a
deputationist whose services were no longer required. It repatriated a
selected officer midway through a three-year tenure, recorded no reason in
the order, and has since sought to justify the action on grounds of eligibility,
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
alleged misrepresentation, audit objection, and alleged irregularities in
another organisation. These grounds are adverse in nature. If they formed
the basis of the decision, fairness required that they be disclosed to the
Petitioner and that he be afforded an opportunity to respond before the order
was passed.
45.
The legal principle in Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election
Commissioner7 that an administrative order must stand or fall on the reasons
which informed it, also assumes relevance. If NBT’s order was a simple
administrative repatriation because the Petitioner’s services were no longer
required, it had to be justified on that footing. It could not thereafter be
defended by invoking alleged ineligibility, misrepresentation, audit
objections or adverse material relating to the Petitioner’s earlier tenure
elsewhere. Conversely, if those adverse matters formed the real basis of the
decision, the Petitioner was entitled to notice and an opportunity to respond
before the order was passed.
Applicability of the DoPT deputation framework and the requirement of
notice
46.
The deputation arrangement was not informal or ad hoc; it was a
structured arrangement governed by express terms. NBT’s vacancy notice
advertised the post on deputation for a period of three years, required
applications to be routed through proper channel, and mandated vigilance
clearance, penalty details and APARs. It further stipulated that pay and other
deputation conditions would be regulated by the applicable DoPT
instructions.
(2005) 8 SCC 394
(1978) 1 SCC 405
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
47.
The same framework was carried forward in the appointment
documents. The office order dated 6th April, 2017 records that the
Petitioner’s deputation would initially be for three years and would be
governed by the offer letter dated 10th March, 2017. NBT’s pay-fixation
order dated 26th May, 2017 then gave practical effect to that arrangement by
fixing pay, deputation allowance, deductions and remittances.
48.
NBT could not adopt this framework selectively. Having invited
applications through proper channel, appointed the Petitioner on deputation
for a defined tenure, fixed his pay, and acted upon the foreign service terms,
it was bound to follow the corresponding procedural discipline when it
chose to curtail that tenure. The deputation arrangement had to be read and
applied as a whole.
49.
NBT relies on the clause in the appointment letter reserving to it the
power to repatriate the Petitioner if his services were no longer required or if
his performance was unsatisfactory. But a reserved power must be exercised
for the purpose for which it is conferred. If NBT no longer required the
Petitioner’s services, it could have said so. If it found his performance
unsatisfactory, that ground ought to have been recorded. If, however, the
real concern was alleged ineligibility, misrepresentation or adverse audit
material, an altogether different course was required. Since such allegations
bore directly upon the Petitioner’s eligibility, reputation and service record,
fairness demanded that he be put to notice, shown the material relied upon,
and given an opportunity to respond before any adverse decision was taken.
50.
CLE’s own conduct reinforces this position. By its communication
dated 11th July, 2018, CLE informed the Petitioner that it had sought reasons
from NBT for the sudden premature repatriation and had also called upon
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
NBT to honour the three-month notice requirement under para 9 of the
DoPT OM dated 17th June, 2010. In its counter-affidavit as well, CLE
asserts that premature reversion ought to have been preceded by at least
three months’ notice to the lending department and that this requirement had
not been observed.
51.
That position may explain why CLE sought clarification from NBT. It
does not, however, explain CLE’s refusal to accept the Petitioner’s joining
after he reported back to his parent organisation. The Petitioner’s lien
remained with CLE. Once NBT had relieved him and he had reported to the
parent organisation, CLE could not keep him in a state of uncertainty,
merely because NBT had failed to furnish reasons for the repatriation. CLE
was free to pursue NBT on questions of notice, reasons or inter se
adjustment. The Petitioner, however, could not be made to suffer because of
that institutional dispute.
52.
NBT’s default was equally serious. It neither gave prior notice nor
disclosed reasons, with the result that the Petitioner’s return to his parent
organisation was rendered uncertain and without salary, until this Court
intervened. The resulting service vacuum was thus created by two
institutions, each shifting the consequences of its own procedural lapse onto
the Petitioner.
Whether NBT could rely on alleged ineligibility without notice
53.
NBT’s principal defence is that the Petitioner was ineligible for
appointment because CLE was not a Government, Semi-Government or
autonomous organisation. That contention cannot be accepted in the manner
in which it is now sought to be advanced. The reasons are fourfold.
54.
First, the appointment process was regular and transparent. The
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
Petitioner did not enter NBT through any irregular route. His application
was forwarded by CLE through proper channel; CLE relieved him; NBT
accepted the relieving; and, upon seeking his last pay certificate and service
particulars, received the same from CLE. NBT thereafter issued the formal
appointment order and the consequential pay-fixation order. The deputation
was thus processed, approved and acted upon through the institutional route.
55.
Second, CLE’s institutional status was never concealed. NBT
remained in correspondence with CLE throughout. The appointment letter
itself was addressed to CLE. CLE’s letterhead described it as a body
sponsored by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India,
and its communication dated 20th April, 2017 conveyed the Chairman’s
approval together with pay particulars and service terms. In these
circumstances, NBT cannot plausibly contend that CLE’s status emerged as
a hidden or newly discovered fact.
56.
Third, any later doubt about eligibility required a fair process. Even if
NBT developed a bona fide doubt about CLE’s status after receiving the
Ministry’s letter dated 21st July, 2017, it could not act unilaterally. The
vacancy notice required applications to be routed through proper channel
and to be accompanied by vigilance clearance, penalty details and APARs.
The Petitioner’s candidature was processed, scrutinised and accepted on that
basis. If NBT subsequently considered the material placed before the
Selection Committee to be insufficient, incorrect or misleading, the proper
course was to disclose that concern to the Petitioner and revisit the matter in
accordance with law. It could not sidestep that obligation by issuing an order
of repatriation.
57.
Fourth, the DoPT OM dated 19th May, 1993 does not assist NBT.
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
That office memorandum deals with cases where an employee is found
ineligible for initial recruitment into service. The present case stands on an
entirely different footing. The Petitioner was not a fresh recruit entering
service for the first time; he was a permanent employee of CLE serving on a
sanctioned transfer on deputation. NBT’s reliance on that OM is therefore
misplaced and, in any event, cannot justify dispensing with the minimum
requirements of fairness.
Consequences of the defective repatriation
58.
The events following the relieving order are material. The Petitioner
immediately sought revocation on 30th May, 2018. He then submitted a
joining report to CLE on 9th July, 2018. He physically reported at CLE,
Chennai, on 30th July, 2018.
59.
CLE did not permit the Petitioner to physically join. Instead, it asked
him to await NBT’s response. At the same time, CLE sought from NBT the
reasons for the sudden premature repatriation and called upon it to comply
with the three-month notice requirement under para 9 of the DoPT OM
dated 17th June, 2010.
60.
In this backdrop, CLE stated before the Court that it was not prepared
to permit the Petitioner to join, though it was willing to pay salary with
effect from 9th July, 2018. The Court recorded that statement in its order
dated 18th December, 2018 and left open, for final adjudication, the issue of
salary for the intervening period from 29th May, 2018 to 9th July, 2018.
61.
Thus, it is demonstrated that the Petitioner consistently challenged the
impugned action. He first sought revocation of the relieving order, then
reported to CLE, and thereafter requested posting and release of salary.
These steps demonstrate that he did not acquiesce in the premature
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
repatriation, yet remained ready and willing to resume duty. Had the
deputation framework been followed, and had NBT provided prior notice,
reasons, and an orderly transition to the parent organisation, this service
vacuum would not have arisen. The Petitioner cannot be made to bear the
consequences of this institutional failure.
62.
Be that as it may, the Court is conscious that the original three-year
deputation tenure has long expired. A direction for reinstatement in NBT
would now serve no practical purpose. But the expiry of tenure does not
erase the legal consequences of an order which was passed without notice,
reasons or fair procedure.
Conclusion
63.
The Court therefore holds that NBT could not have prematurely
repatriated the Petitioner on the grounds now pleaded without first putting
the material to him and affording him an opportunity to respond. If the real
basis of the decision was alleged ineligibility, misrepresentation, audit
objection or adverse material from another organisation, the Petitioner was
entitled to know that case before the order was passed. The subsequent
refusal of CLE to accept his physical joining does not cure the defect in
NBT’s order. It only demonstrates the civil consequences which followed
from an abrupt repatriation made without notice, reasons or an orderly return
arrangement with the parent organisation.
64.
The relieving order dated 29th May, 2018 is therefore declared
unsustainable and is set aside for the limited purpose of monetary and
consequential relief. The setting aside of the order shall not revive the
deputation, which has already come to an end by efflux of time. The relief
must now be confined to dues and consequential benefits flowing from the
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
Petitioner’s deputation and the interregnum created by the defective
repatriation.
Dues and consequential directions
65.
The Petitioner’s representation dated 3rd May, 2018 sought release of
outstanding dues relating to his deputation period. It referred to household
shifting, LTC, statutory remittances and other admissible claims. His later
affidavit quantified the alleged outstanding salary and statutory dues from
NBT for the period 1st April, 2017 to 8th July, 2018.
66.
The Court does not consider it appropriate to mechanically accept the
Petitioner’s figures in writ jurisdiction without a proper accounting exercise.
At the same time, NBT cannot be permitted to leave the representation
unresolved or reject claims by relying on the same defective premise which
led to the impugned repatriation.
67.
The deputation documents show that NBT was to regulate pay,
deputation allowance, deductions and remittances in accordance with the
deputation terms. CLE’s letter dated 20th April, 2017 set out remittances to
be made by NBT, including employer’s contribution, pension contribution,
leave salary contribution and other service-related payments. NBT’s own
Office Order dated 26th May, 2017 accepted the structure by fixing pay and
recording remittances to be made.
68.
In view of the findings recorded above, the following directions are
issued:
i.
CLE’s objection to maintainability is rejected in terms of the
judgment pronounced today in W.P.(C) 5425/2019.
ii.
The relieving order dated 29th May, 2018 issued by NBT is declared
unsustainable and is set aside. As a result, the Petitioner shall be entitled to
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
monetary and consequential reliefs. However, no direction for reinstatement
in NBT is issued, since the deputation tenure has already expired by efflux
of time.
iii.
The period from 30th May, 2018 till 8th July, 2018 shall be
appropriately regularised by NBT in accordance with the applicable
deputation and service rules, having due regard to the findings recorded in
this judgment. The said period shall not be treated as a break in service. CLE
shall pass consequential orders to update the Petitioner’s service record,
leave account, continuity of service and other allied benefits.
iv.
NBT shall undertake a fresh computation of all admissible dues
payable to the Petitioner for the deputation period from 1st April, 2017 till
29th May, 2018, and for the interregnum from 30th May, 2018 till 8th July,
2018. The computation shall be made by a speaking order within six weeks
from the date of this judgment. If any claim is rejected, NBT shall specify
the rule, term or document on which it relies.
v.
While undertaking the computation, NBT shall consider the
appointment letter dated 10th March, 2017, NBT Office Order dated 6th
April, 2017, CLE’s terms dated 20th April, 2017, NBT’s pay fixation order
dated 26th May, 2017 and the applicable DoPT deputation instructions. It
shall include every admissible component under those documents, including
salary, deputation allowance, statutory remittances, PF/pension contribution,
leave salary contribution, TA/transfer entitlements and LTC, after adjusting
amounts already paid.
vi.
If any amount is found payable, it shall be released within four weeks
thereafter.
vii.
The Petitioner shall not receive double payment for any overlapping
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
period or component. If any adjustment or reimbursement is required
between NBT and CLE because of payments made pursuant to orders of this
Court, the same shall be worked out inter se between them. The Petitioner
shall not be denied admissible dues merely because the borrowing and
lending organisations have a dispute regarding their respective financial
responsibility.
viii. NBT shall, within four weeks, transmit to CLE all monetary
remittances as per Petitioner’s terms of appointment, all service records, pay
particulars, leave account, remittance details, deputation records and such
other documents as may reasonably be required for regularisation of the
Petitioner’s
service
and
consequential
service
benefits
following
repatriation.
ix.
The Petitioner’s salary and other service benefits w.e.f, 9th July, 2018
shall be governed by the judgment pronounced today in W.P.(C) 5425/2019.
69.
The writ petition is allowed in the above terms. Pending applications,
if any, stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
MAY 29, 2026/ab
Digitally Signed
By:ANITA BAITAL
00:41:10
W.P.(C) 6602/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review