Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LAIRENMAYUM
INDRAJEET
SINGH
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
LAIRENMAYUM INDRAJEET
SINGH
Date: 2023.06.27 14:21:52
+05'30'
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
1.
Alhaj Keramat Ali aged about 57 years S/o (L) Md. Haman Haji, resident
of Yairipok Bamon Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Yairipok, Thoubal District,
Manipur, Pin No. 795138.
2.
Md. Maqbul Ahmad, aged about 33 years, S/o Keramat Ali, resident of
Yairipok Bamon Leikai P.O. & P.S. Yairipok, Thoubal District, Manipur,
Pin No. 795138.
….Petitioners
- Versus -
Nongmaithem Herojit Singh aged about 42 years S/o (L) N. Kuber Singh
resident of Heigrujam Nongmaithem Leikai, P.O. & P.S. Nambol, Imphal West
District, Manipur, Pin No. 795134.
…Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioners
For the respondent
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment & Order
:
:
:
:
Mr. Md. Jalaluddin, Sr. Advocate
Mr. P. Tomcha, Advocate
28.03.2023 & 03.04.2023
27.06.2023
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
By the present petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India read with Section 115 of CPC, the petitioners/defendants challenged
the impugned order dated 11.08.2022 passed by the learned District Judge,
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 1
Thoubal, in Civil Misc. Appeal Case No. 1 of 2021. By the impugned order,
the learned District Judge set aside the order dated 15.07.2021 passed by
the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal in Judl. Misc. Case No. 53
of 2021 (Ref: O.S. Suit No. 25 of 2021) and allowed the prayer of the
respondent/plaintiff and passed an order of temporary injunction in favour
of the respondent/plaintiff thereby restraining the petitioners/defendants, his
men and privies from interfering in the business of running the disputed oil
pump. Vide order dated 26.08.2022, this Court stayed the operation of the
impugned order dated 11.08.2022 passed in Civil Misc. Appeal Case No. 1 of
2021 till the next date and permitted Mr. P. Tomcha, learned counsel for the
respondent, to place on record the documents which were filed before the
Trial Court and Appellate Court but not in this revision. The interim order is
extended from time to time. Vide order dated 18.01.2023, this Court gave
an opportunity to the parties to attempt a mutually acceptable settlement.
As recorded in the order dated 02.02.2023 passed by this Court, Mr. Md.
Jalaluddin, learned senior counsel for the petitioners/defendants, submitted
that his clients were willing to refund a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty
Lakhs) in two installments of Rs. 30,00,000/- (Thirty Lakhs) each. However,
vide order dated 16.02.2023, Mr. P. Tomcha, learned counsel for the
respondent/plaintiff, stated that his clients was not willing to take final
settlement of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Sixty Lakhs) and submitted that the matter
be heard on merit. Accordingly, matter was heard on 28.03.2023 and
03.04.2023.
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 2
[2]
The
brief
fact
of
the
present
case
is
that
the
respondent/plaintiff filed a suit being O.S. No. 25 of 2021 against the
petitioners/defendants in the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal,
inter alia praying that the respondent/plaintiff, his men and agents have
every right and authority to operate the disputed petrol pump in the name
of M/S Keramat and Sons at Yairipok, Bamon Leikai, Thoubal District, till the
determination of the lease as indicated in Money Receipt dated 05.02.2021
and also for mandatory injunction against the defendants, their men and
privies from causing any disturbance to the plaintiff in the running of business
of the disputed property. Along with the suit, the plaintiff also filed an
application under Order 39 Rules 1 & 3 CPC, being Judl. Misc. Case No. 53
of 2021 for passing an ad-interim ex-parte injunction restraining the
petitioners/defendants, their men and privies from entering the premises of
the disputed property and from disturbing the respondent/plaintiff from
peaceful operation of the disputed petrol pump. It is also stated that the
respondent/plaintiff and petitioners/defendants are jointly running on
business as dealers of Petrol/HSD Pump at Yairipok, Thoubal District, being
License No. P/EC/MN/14/1(P51851), and the petrol pump was jointly
registered in the name of the petitioners/defendants. It is also stated that an
agreement between the respondent/plaintiff and petitioners/defendants
under which the respondent was allowed to run the petrol pump under a
lease and the petitioners/defendants took a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees
sixty lakhs) from the respondent/plaintiff and allowed him to run the said
petrol pump from the month of February, 2021. The money was received by
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 3
the petitioners/defendants on 05.02.2021 and necessary money receipt was
executed on the same day clearly mentioning the intention of leasing of the
petrol pump. Money Receipt dated 05.02.2021 acknowledging the receipt of
Rs. 60,00,000/-(Rupees sixty lakhs) by the petitioners/defendants from the
respondent/plaintiff was executed and recorded that the same was in
connection with leasing of the petrol pump in the name and style of M/S
Keramat and Sons at Yairipok, Thoubal District. It is also stated that due to
Lockdown in view of the Covid-19 pandemic, formal lease deed could not be
registered. However, the respondent/plaintiff through its employees has
been running the petrol pump from the month of February, 2021 and was
catering the need of the people even during the lockdown period. It is also
stated that the petitioners/defendants started to disturb the plaintiff’s
business of running petrol pump from 05.06.2021 and threatened him to
vacate the petrol pump within 10 minutes. The respondent/plaintiff
approached the Superintendent of Police, Thoubal with a report on
07.06.2021 and again on 12.06.2021, but there was no further action. Having
no alternative, the respondent/plaintiff approached the Court of the learned
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal, for declaration that the plaintiff, his
men and agents have every right and authority to operate the disputed petrol
pump till the lease as mentioned in Money Receipt dated 05.02.2021 is
lawfully determined; and also for a mandatory injunction. Along with the suit,
the respondent/plaintiff has also filed an application under Order 39 Rules 1
& 3 CPC, being Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021 praying for temporary
injunction.
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 4
[3]
Vide order dated 19.06.2021 in Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021,
learned Civil Judge(Senior Division), Thoubal, passed an ex-parte ad-interim
order restraining the petitioners/defendants, their men and privies from
entering the premises of the disputed property and disturbing the
respondent/plaintiff, his men and privies at their peaceful operation of the
petrol pump till the disposal of the application or modification of the order
and fixed the matter on 30.06.2021 for appearance and filing of the written
objection.
[4]
The petitioners/defendants filed written statement stating that
the respondent/plaintiff has no right, interest in running the business of the
petrol pump as Memorandum of Agreement executed on 14.12.2013
between the petitioners/defendants and officials of the Indian Oil
Corporation(IOC) Ltd, and the respondent/plaintiff is a third party. It is also
stated that there was no lease deed or agreement executed between the
respondent/plaintiff and the petitioners/defendants with respect to the oil
pump and the petrol pump could not be sub-let in view of the memorandum
of agreement dated 14.12.2013. However execution of Money Receipt dated
05.02.2021 was not denied.
[5]
The petitioners/defendants also filed written objection to the
application being Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021 inter alia stating that no
agreement has been executed for leasing of the petrol pump to the
respondent/plaintiff and such agreement is barred under the Memorandum
of Agreement executed on 14.12.2013 between the petitioners/defendants
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 5
and IOC Ltd. However, nothing is mentioned about the Money Receipt of Rs.
60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) executed by the petitioners/defendants
acknowledging a receipt of sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) from
the respondent/plaintiff in connection with leasing of the petrol pump. The
respondent/plaintiff also filed replication to the written objection filed by the
petitioners/defendants in Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021 by stating that by
execution of money receipt dated 05.02.2021, he was allowed by the
petitioners/defendants to run the business of the oil pump on lease. With
respect to clause 35 of the Memorandum of Agreement, it is stated that
dealership can be sub-let subject to the provision of clause 35 of the
memorandum and on earlier occasion also the petitioners/defendants
executed registered lease deed with another person in respect of the
disputed petrol pump and hence, they are barred by estoppel from raising
operation of clause 35. It is also stated that the respondent/plaintiff has been
paying a sum of Rs. 1,20,000/- every month as rent and has deposited a sum
of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) as security deposit. Vide order dated
15.07.2021, in Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021 the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division),
Thoubal,
disposed
of
the
application
filed
by
the
respondent/plaintiff under Order 39 Rules 1 & 3 CPC and vacated the exparte ad-interim order dated 19.06.2021. It was held that there was a prima
facie case in favour of the respondent/plaintiff to go for trial in view of the
existence of the registered lease deed dated 12.11.2014 executed between
the petitioners/defendants and one Hangoibam Suraj Sharma for a period of
20 years and oral lease deed on the basis of a money receipt dated
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 6
05.02.2021 between the petitioners/defendants and respondent/plaintiff.
However, it was held that the balance of convenience was not in favour of
the respondent/plaintiff as earlier registered lease deed was for a period of
20 years and there was nothing on record to show that oral agreement has
been permitted by the IOC Ltd. Accordingly, it was held that on failure to
prove existence of balance of convenience and irreparable loss in favour of
the respondent/plaintiff, temporary injunction was not granted and
accordingly ex-parte injunction order was vacated. Being aggrieved by the
order
dated
15.07.2021
vacating
ex-parte
ad-interim
order,
the
respondent/plaintiff approached the learned District Judge, Thoubal, by way
of an appeal, being Civil Misc. Appeal Case No. 1 of 2021 under Order 43
Rules 1 & 3 CPC amongst on the ground that the petitioners/defendants did
not deny the correctness of the money receipt executed on 05.02.2021 and
also receiving a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs). It was also
stated that while granting ex-parte ad-interim order, the learned Civil Judge
(Senior Division) had already held that a person could not be evicted without
due process of law and as such balance of convenience was in his favour and
irreparable loss would cause to him. It is also stated that clause 35 of the
Memorandum of Agreement between the IOC and the petitioners/defendants
is only directory and no penal action has been provided for his
noncompliance. Deposit slips produced by the respondent/plaintiff show
prima facie evidence that he was running the business of the oil pump. Vide
impugned order dated 11.08.2022, the learned District Judge set aside the
order dated 15.07.2021 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division),
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 7
Thoubal in Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021 and passed an order of temporary
injunction
against
the
petitioners/defendants
from
interfering
the
respondent/plaintiff in running the business of the petrol pump and directed
to hand over the keys of the petrol pump to the respondent/plaintiff.
[6]
It may be stated that while admitting the appeal and vide order
dated 02.08.2021 in Civil Misc. Appeal No. 1 of 2021, learned District Judge,
Thoubal, stayed the order dated 15.07.2021 passed by the learned Civil
Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal in Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021 till the
next date of hearing. Against this order, the petitioners/defendants preferred
a petition being CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021 and this Court issued notice
on 09.09.2021 and stayed the order dated 02.08.2021 passed by the learned
District Judge, Thoubal, as no reason was given for staying the order dated
15.07.2021 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division). It is recorded
in para 3 of the order dated 09.06.2022 passed by this Court in
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021 and connected applications that taking
advantage of the order dated 09.09.2021 passed by this Court, the
petitioners/defendants secured the possession of the disputed oil pump on
10.09.2021 and respondent/plaintiff filed contempt Case (C) No. 3 of 2021
before this Court and misc. application for dismissal of the revision petition.
While disposing the petition and the connected applications, this Court
recorded in para 6 the admission made by the counsel for the
petitioners/defendants herein that the possession of the petrol pump was
handed over to the respondent/plaintiff on receipt of Rs. 60,00,000/-
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 8
(Rupees sixty lakhs) from him and he was operating the said petrol pump on
the date of institution of the suit.
[7]
In the impugned order dated 11.08.2022, learned District
Judge recorded the admission made by the learned counsel for the
petitioners/defendants herein in para 6 of the order dated 09.06.2022 in
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021 passed by this Court to the effect that after
receiving a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) from the
respondent/plaintiff, the petitioners/defendants delivered possession of the
petrol pump to him and he was operating the said petrol pump as on the
date of institution of the suit and this fact has been recorded in para 27 of
the impugned order. The learned District Judge observed in para 34 of the
impugned order that the respondent/plaintiff has a strong prima facie case
as he was in possession of the disputed oil pump at the time of presentation
of the original suit before the Trial Court and this finding is also corroborated
by the admission made by the counsel for the petitioners/defendants before
this Court and supported by money receipts. Since the respondent/plaintiff
was running the disputed oil pump till his dispossession by the
petitioners/defendants, it was held that all the three cardinal principles of
granting temporary injunction was in favour of the respondent/plaintiff.
Accordingly, the application under Order 39 Rule 1 & 3 CPC was allowed.
[8]
Being
aggrieved
by
the
impugned
order,
the
petitioners/defendants approached this Court by way of revision petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution inter alia on the ground that no
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 9
agreement was entered into between the parties for leasing of the petrol
pump. It is stated that the petitioners/defendants took a sum of Rs.
60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) on loan from the respondent/plaintiff by
issuing a money receipt on 05.02.2021 for leasing of the oil pump. It is
pointed out that clause 35 of the agreement entered between the
petitioners/defendants and IOC Ltd. prohibits mortgage, sub-letting or
transferring of the dealership to any party except as permitted by the IOC
Ltd. and the petitioners/defendants did not execute any lease agreement in
favour
of
the
respondent/plaintiff.
It
is
also
stated
that
the
respondent/plaintiff did not have possession of the disputed petrol pump at
any point of time. In another suit being O.S. No. 30 of 2021, the IOC
(defendant No. 3 therein) stated in their written statement that
respondent/plaintiff has no legal right to operate the dealership unless
specifically permitted in writing by IOC Ltd. It is stated that the
petitioners/defendants are ready to refund an amount of Rs. 60,00,000/(Rupees sixty lakhs) to the respondent/plaintiff taken from him in reasonable
time.
[9]
The respondent/plaintiff also filed counter affidavit to the
petition and stated that the learned District Judge has taken into account all
the relevant materials and passed a reasoned order. It is also stated that the
present proceeding is arising out of O.S. No. 25 of 2021 and the pleadings
of O.S. No. 30 of 2021 will not have a bearing on the present petition. The
pleadings of IOC (Defendant No. 3 in O.S. No. 30 of 2021) will not have any
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 10
bearing on the present petition and stated that the issue involved in the
present case is not about the refund of the amount. In their rejoinder affidavit
filed before this Court, the petitioners/defendants reiterated that they never
leased the oil dealership to the respondent/plaintiff and to any other person
as the same is barred by clause 35 of the agreement executed between them
and the IOC and learned District Judge, Thoubal, never considered the
contents of the said agreement. It is also stated that the proceedings of O.S.
No. 25 of 2021 and O.S. No. 30 of 2021 are same involving the same disputed
petrol pump. It is also stated that the petitioners/defendants are bound to
refund a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakh) as lease could not be
executed in terms of clause 35 of the terms of agreement.
[10]
Mr.
Md.
Jalaluddin,
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
petitioners/defendants, submits that the learned District Judge, Thoubal, has
committed serious error while granting temporary injunction by setting aside
a reasoned order of the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal,
rejecting the application for temporary injunction on the ground that the
respondent/plaintiff could not show balance of convenience and irreparable
loss in his favour. He further submits that the learned District Judge could
not appreciate the fact that clause 35 of the memorandum of agreement
executed between the IOC Ltd. and the petitioners/defendants specifically
barred sub-letting, leasing, creating agency in respect of the petrol pump
without permission of the IOC. Mr. Md. Jalaluddin, learned senior counsel,
has pointed out that the respondent/plaintiff at most should have filed a suit
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 11
for recovery of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) on the basis of the
money receipt dated 05.02.2021 and the prayer in the suit being O.S. No. 25
of 2021 is barred by clause 35 of the memorandum of agreement. Regarding
the factum of presumption of possession, Mr. Md. Jalaluddin, learned senior
counsel, relies on the decisions of Andhra Pradesh High Court in the case of
G. Trinadha Swamy V. Gandham Satyanarayana & ors. reported as
AIR 2006 Andhra Pradesh 381 wherein it was held that there is a
presumption of possession of a property to a person having title over the
same. In written submission dated 05.04.2023 submitted by the
petitioners/defendants, it was reiterated that this Court in earlier proceeding
observed that the lease agreement of money receipt produced by the
respondent/plaintiff could not be considered and matter was remanded for
early disposal. It is prayed that the impugned order be set aside and the
order passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal, rejecting
the application for temporary injunction filed by the respondent/plaintiff be
restored.
[11]
Per contra, Mr. P. Tomcha, learned counsel for the
respondent/plaintiff, submits that there is a concurrent finding of the learned
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal, as well as learned District Judge,
Thoubal, to the fact that there is a prima facie case in favour of the
respondent/plaintiff and the petitioners/defendants have not challenged the
finding of existence of prima facie case and the same attains finality. Learned
counsel has pointed out that the petitioners/defendants did not deny the
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 12
money receipt dated 05.02.2021 in the written statement to the suit and in
the written objection to the Judl. Misc. Case No. 53 of 2021, thereby
admitting receipt of an advance deposit of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty
lakhs) in consideration of executing a lease deed in favour of the
respondent/plaintiff for running the business of the disputed petrol pump
owned by the petitioners/defendants. It is only in the petition before this
Court that the petitioners/defendants admitted the execution of the money
receipt dated 05.02.2021. It is also an admitted fact that lease deed could
not be executed due to the lockdown imposed to control covid pandemic.
Referring to the admission made by the learned counsel for the
petitioners/defendants herein before this Court as recorded in order dated
09.06.2022 in CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021 to the effect that after
receiving receipt of sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) from the
respondent/plaintiff, it has been reiterated that the petitioners/defendants
delivered possession of the oil pump to him and he was operating the said
petrol pump as on the date of the institution of the suit. Mr. P. Tomcha,
learned counsel, has insisted that upon the execution of the money receipt
dated 05.02.2021 as well as admission in the order dated 09.06.2022, it is
clear that the possession of the petrol pump was with the respondent/plaintiff
and he was running the petrol pump on the date of institution of the suit. In
order dated 09.06.2022, it was also recorded that taking advantage of the
interim order dated 09.09.2021, the petitioners/defendants secured the
possession of the disputed petrol pump and out of this contempt case was
filed. Learned counsel for the respondent/plaintiff submits that clause 35 of
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 13
the memorandum of agreement is only directory as no penal provision is
provided for its violation. He draws the attention of this Court that the
petitioners/defendants have also executed a registered sale deed dated
12.11.2014 for a period of 20 years with one Hangoibam Suraj Sharma for
running of the business of petrol pump and as such by the principle of
estoppel they cannot now plead that no lease or sub-letting can be done in
view
of
clause
35.
Mr.
P.
Tomcha,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent/plaintiff, submits that the learned District Judge has rightly held
that balance of convenience and irreparable loss will be caused to the
respondent/plaintiff if the application for temporary injunction is not granted.
He prays that the present petition may be rejected and the well-reasoned
order dated 11.08.2022 passed by learned District Judge, Thoubal in Civil
Misc. Appeal No. 1 of 2021 be upheld.
[12]
It is an admitted fact that both the learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Thoubal and the learned District Judge, Thoubal have given a
finding that there is a prima facie case in favour of the respondent/plaintiff.
However, learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal, was of the view that
the pre-existing registered sale deed dated 12.11.2014 in favour of H. Suraj
Sharma will have more evidentiary value than the oral lease deed between
the petitioners/defendants and the respondent/plaintiff and held that balance
of convenience is not in his favour and irreparable loss and injury will not be
caused. Accordingly, the application for temporary injunction was rejected
and the interim order dated 19.06.2021 was vacated by order dated
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 14
15.07.2021. On the other hand, learned District Judge, Thoubal, upon relying
para Nos. 6 & 7 of the order dated 09.06.2022 passed by this Court in
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021 where the petitioners/defendants have
admitted possession of the respondent/plaintiff over the suit land as on date
of institution of the suit after receiving a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees
sixty lakhs) and also on perusal of the money receipt executed on 05.02.2021
held that respondent/plaintiff has a strong prima facie case in his favour. It
was further held that balance of convenience was in favour of the
respondent/plaintiff as he was in possession of the disputed petrol pump at
the
time
of
institution
of
the
suit
and
was
dispossessed
by
petitioners/defendants taking advantage of the interim order dated
09.09.2021 passed by this Court. It was further held that oral agreement
giving permission to the respondent/plaintiff to run the disputed oil pump by
the petitioners/defendants was permissible or not in view of the
memorandum of the IOC was a matter to be decided at the time of the trial
and not during the hearing of an application for temporary injunction under
Order 39 CPC. In para 34, learned District Judge, Thoubal, gave a finding
that prima facie case was in favour of the respondent/plaintiff, balance of
convenience was in his favour as he was in possession and running the petrol
pump at the time of the filing of the suit and irreparable lost will be caused
to him if the injunction is not granted. Para 34 is reproduced as:
“34. The plaintiff has a strong prima facie case as he was in
possession of the disputed oil pump at the time of presentation of
the original suit before the Ld. Civil Judge. This finding is also
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 15
corroborated by the admission of the Ld. Counsel for the
defendants before the Hon’ble High Court and supported by the
money receipt. The plaintiff has been able to show that balance
of convenience is also in his favour as he was running the disputed
oil pump until his dispossession by the defendants. Thirdly,
irreparable loss or injury would be caused to the plaintiff which
cannot be compensated by money if the injunction is withheld as
the loss could not be ascertained. Again, as the disputed oil pump
is for the public at large, withholding of temporary injunction
would not be in favour of the plaintiff.”
[13]
In the case of Dalpat Kumar v. Prahlad Singh: (1992) 1
SCC 719, Hon’ble Supreme Court explained the three principles of- (i)
existence of prima facie case, (ii) balance of convenience and (iii) irreparable
loss in the following para:
“4. Order 39 Rule 1(c) provides that temporary injunction may be
granted where, in any suit, it is proved by the affidavit or otherwise,
that the defendant threatens to dispossess the plaintiff or otherwise
cause injury to the plaintiff in relation to any property in dispute in
the suit, the court may by order grant a temporary injunction to
restrain such act or make such other order for the purpose of staying
and preventing … or dispossession of the plaintiff or otherwise
causing injury to the plaintiff in relation to any property in dispute in
the suit as the court thinks fit until the disposal of the suit or until
further orders. Pursuant to the recommendation of the Law
Commission clause (c) was brought on statute by Section 86(i)(b) of
the Amending Act 104 of 1976 with effect from February 1, 1977.
Earlier thereto there was no express power except the inherent
power under Section 151 CPC to grant ad interim injunction against
dispossession. Rule 1 primarily concerned with the preservation of
the property in dispute till legal rights are adjudicated. Injunction is
a judicial process by which a party is required to do or to refrain from
doing any particular act. It is in the nature of preventive relief to a
litigant to prevent future possible injury. In other words, the court,
on exercise of the power of granting ad interim injunction, is to
preserve the subject matter of the suit in the status quo for the time
being. It is settled law that the grant of injunction is a discretionary
relief. The exercise thereof is subject to the court satisfying that (1)
there is a serious disputed question to be tried in the suit and that
an act, on the facts before the court, there is probability of his being
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 16
entitled to the relief asked for by the plaintiff/defendant; (2) the
court’s interference is necessary to protect the party from the species
of injury. In other words, irreparable injury or damage would ensue
before the legal right would be established at trial; and (3) that the
comparative hardship or mischief or inconvenience which is likely to
occur from withholding the injunction will be greater than that would
be likely to arise from granting it.
5. Therefore, the burden is on the plaintiff by evidence aliunde by
affidavit or otherwise that there is “a prima facie case” in his favour
which needs adjudication at the trial. The existence of the prima facie
right and infraction of the enjoyment of his property or the right is a
condition for the grant of temporary injunction. Prima facie case is
not to be confused with prima facie title which has to be established,
on evidence at the trial. Only prima facie case is a substantial
question raised, bona fide, which needs investigation and a decision
on merits. Satisfaction that there is a prima facie case by itself is not
sufficient to grant injunction. The Court further has to satisfy that
non-interference by the Court would result in “irreparable injury” to
the party seeking relief and that there is no other remedy available
to the party except one to grant injunction and he needs protection
from the consequences of apprehended injury or dispossession.
Irreparable injury, however, does not mean that there must be no
physical possibility of repairing the injury, but means only that the
injury must be a material one, namely one that cannot be adequately
compensated by way of damages. The third condition also is that
“the balance of convenience” must be in favour of granting
injunction. The Court while granting or refusing to grant injunction
should exercise sound judicial discretion to find the amount of
substantial mischief or injury which is likely to be caused to the
parties, if the injunction is refused and compare it with that which is
likely to be caused to the other side if the injunction is granted. If on
weighing competing possibilities or probabilities of likelihood of injury
and if the Court considers that pending the suit, the subject matter
should be maintained in status quo, an injunction would be issued.
Thus, the Court has to exercise its sound judicial discretion in
granting or refusing the relief of ad interim injunction pending the
suit.”
[14]
Courts
In the case in hand, there is concurrent finding from the two
about
the
existence
of
prima
facie
case
in
favour
of
respondent/plaintiff and this finding is not challenged before any competent
Court and hence has attained finality. As rightly held by the learned District
Judge, Thoubal, the possession is with the respondent/plaintiff as on the date
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 17
of institution of the suit as seen from the admission made by the learned
counsel for the petitioners/defendants herein as recorded in order dated
09.06.2022 in CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021 about the delivery of
possession of the petrol pump to the respondent/plaintiff herein after
receiving a sum of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) except for illegal
dispossession on the basis of interim order dated 09.09.2021 passed by this
Court. In the Courts below, the petitioners/defendants did not deny the
execution of money receipt acknowledging receipt of a sum of Rs.
60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) in consideration for execution of a lease
deed for running the petrol pump. It is only before this Court that the
petitioners/defendants have stated that he borrowed a sum of Rs.
60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakh) from the respondent/plaintiff and admitted
the execution of the deed. On perusal of the money receipt dated
05.02.2021, it is not simply a money receipt for a loan of Rs. 60,00,000/(Rupees sixty lakhs) but the receipt of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs)
is in consideration for leasing of the petrol pump to the respondent/plaintiff.
Hence, it is clear that it is not a case of mere borrowing and lending of a sum
of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs), but the same is in consideration for
leasing out of the petrol pump. Whether leasing or sub-letting of agency of
petrol pump without permission of the IOC is prohibited by clause 35 of the
memorandum of agreement or not is a question to be decided in the
proceedings of main suit as one of the main issues. While considering an
application for temporary injunction, the Court has to examine whether the
plaintiff have a prima facie case in his favour. The existence of money receipt
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 18
acknowledging a receipt of Rs. 60,00,000/- (Rupees sixty lakhs) as
consideration for leasing of the petrol pump is a triable issue and prima facie
case
in
favour
of
the
plaintiff.
As
per
the
admission
of
the
petitioners/defendants before this Court in order dated 09.06.2022, the
possession of the petrol pump was handed over to the respondent/plaintiff
by the petitioners/defendants and the respondent/plaintiff was running the
petrol pump till he was dispossessed by the petitioners/defendants taking
advantage of an interim order dated 09.09.2021 passed by this Court in
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 29 of 2021. Since the respondent/plaintiff was in
possession and running the petrol pump on the date of the institution of the
suit, irreparable loss would be caused to him if the relief prayed for is not
granted. This Court is of the view that the respondent/plaintiff has satisfied
all the three cardinal principles of granting temporary injunction. There is no
infirmity in the impugned order.
[15]
Accordingly, the revision petition is dismissed and finding of the
learned District Judge, Thoubal, in impugned order dated 11.08.2022 in Civil
Misc. Appeal No. 1 of 2021 is upheld. Interim order dated 26.08.2022 is
vacated.
[16]
It is clarified that this Court does not express any opinion on
the merit of the case in the main suit and nothing stated herein shall
prejudice the case of the parties in the proceedings of the suit.
[17]
Send a copy of this order to the learned District Judge, Thoubal,
and as well as to the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Thoubal, for
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 19
information and proceedings as per law. Learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Thoubal, shall make an endeavor to dispose of the suit
expeditiously, preferably within a period of 6(six) months from the date of
receipt of this order.
[18]
Parties are to bear their own expenses.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Indrajeet
CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 42 of 2022
Page 20
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review