Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
"
!
% $
&
!
"
#$%& '&(
)
Digitally signed
by NIJAMUDDIN
JAMKHANDI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
*
+
'
+
!
+
!
#$ ( (('
!
!
# $%& '('
#$%& '('
&
#
!
,
-2-
#$%& '('
$
"
#$%& '('
"
#$%& '('
)
*
!
'
,
!
#
(-
!
( $
,
* ,
* ,
!
* ,
(- ( $
*
"
( ''
# ,
( $
. /
12 32454567 58 95:2; <= 412 324545672> ?1@::27A57A 412
2B42>7C274
6>;2>
>28367;274
;@42;
(
'' ( $
3@882;
2B42>757A 412 324545672> 9>6C
584>5?4 46 +D;@:@A5 E5::@A2
F +D;@:@A5
<=
@5?1D>
584 !5G@=@7@A@>
-3-
H541 2992?4 9>6C (
''
( $ 46 (
('
(
96> @ 32>56; 69
C67418
12 9@?48 69 412 ?@82 @>2 @8 D7;2>
24545672>
!5::@A2
584>5?4
@
32>C@7274
@5?1D>
>285;274
5>I@3D>
2 58 57E6:E2; 57 @A>5?D:4D>@:
@E6?@4567 6H757A @ 8C@:: 352?2 69 :@7;
2 58 @ C@>>52;
C@7 >285;57A H541 158 H592 @7; ?15:;>27
4 58 ?6742742; <=
:2@>72;
?6D782: 96>
324545672>
41@4 412
5C3:5?@42; @A@5784 412 324545672> @>2 9@:82
H5416D4 @7= 8D<84@745@: C@42>5@:
?67E5?4567
<@82:288
H15?1 H6D:; :2@; 46
12 324545672> H@8 57545@::= @>>@=2; @8 672 69
412 @??D82; 57
6 %''
?1@>A28
( (
>5C2
>5C2
( ( 57
6 ''
( ' 57
32?5@:
@82 * ,
6 - $J
( '
H12>257 412 324545672> ?@C2 46 <2 @?FD5442; 57 8@5; ?@828
76412> ?@82 57
>5C2
J
( & 58 327;57A 4>5@:
4 58
@:86 ?6742742; 41@4 57 4158 ?@82 @:86 324545672> H@8
D772?288@>5:= ;>@AA2; 5746 <D4 H@8 764 57E6:E2; 57 @7=
8D?1 ?>5C2 @8 12 58 5776?274
-4-
158 <257A 412 84@42 69 @99@5>8
& @7;
324545672>
>28367;274
4@K57A 7642 69 412 366> <@?KA>6D7; 69 412
57 6>;2> 46 6E2>>2@?1 412 @?FD544@: 6>;2>8
3@882; 57 9@E6D> 69 412 324545672> @7; 412>2 <257A 764 @7=
?>2;5<:2 C@42>5@:
1@8 3>23@>2; @ >236>4 824457A 96>41
A272>@: @7; 6C75<D8 @::2A@45678 H5416D4 412>2 <257A @7=
832?595? 6E2>4 @?48 @A@5784 412 324545672>
>28367;274
@82; 67 H15?1
96>H@>;2; @ >236>4 46 >28367;274
>2?6CC27;57A 412 2B42>7C274 69 324545672>
28367;274
6 & 67 >2?2534 69 412 >236>4 >2FD2842; >28367;274
57545@42
@?4567
>28367;274
3D>8D@74
>236>4
6&
8D<C5442;
<=
@82; 67 H15?1 >28367;274
?6C324274 @D416>54= A64 588D2; 816H ?@D82 7645?2 ;@42;
'' (
( $
4 58 ?67427;2; <= :2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412
324545672> 41@4 76 >236>4 96>H@>;2; <= >28367;274
3>23@>2; <= >28367;274
6>
6 & 86 @::2A2; H@8 8274 @:67A
H541 412 816H ?@D82 7645?2 46 412 324545672>
2E2>412:288
412 324545672> 95:2; 158 ;24@5:2; 6<G2?45678 46 412 8@5; 816H
?@D82 7645?2 588D2; <= >28367;274
6H2E2> @942>
-5-
27FD5>= 67 412 3>6?22;57A8 412 C@442> H@8 ?67?:D;2; <=
3@8857A @7 2B42>7C274 6>;2> 67 ( ''
&
E212C274
( $
?674274567
:2@>72;
?6D782: 96> 412 324545672> 41@4 5C3DA72; 6>;2> 3@882; <=
>28367;274
2B2>?5857A 2B4>@6>;57@>= GD>58;5?4567 @7;
C2@8D>2 E56:@428 412 3>57?53:2 69 9D7;@C274@: >5A14 69 412
324545672>
AD@>@7422;
678454D4567 69
D7;2>
7;5@
>28367;2748
1@E2
?6742C3:@42;
D7;2>
>45?:2
'J*',*;,
4 58 9D>412> ?6742742; 41@4 412
96::6H2;
;D2
+@>7@4@K@
*12>257@942> >292>>2; 46 @8 .412 +
3>6?2;D>2
6:5?2
?4/,
?4
@8
'J
725412> 412
3>57?53:28 69 7@4D>@: GD845?2 76> 412 GD84 69 >2@867@<:27288
@>2 96::6H2;
$
D>412>
54 58 ?67427;2; 41@4 412 >28367;274
58 764 GD845952; 57 158 @?4 69 2B42>7C274 69 324545672>
+D;@:@A5
E5::@A2
!5G@=@7@A@>@
584>5?4
@8
324545672> 58 412 86:2 <>2@;2@>72> 69 158 9@C5:= 412>2<= 412
8@C2 @?48 ?674>@>= 46
7;5@
>45?:2
' 69 412
678454D4567 69
7 E52H 69 412 D7>2@867@<:2 6>;2> H15?1 58 @><54>@>=
-6-
@7; 412>2 58 :@?K 69 C@42>5@:8 @7; @:86 @ 767 832@K57A
6>;2> 324545672> 58 <296>2 4158
6D>4 822K57A 46 >2E6K2 @7;
FD@81 412 2B42>7C274 6>;2> 3@882; <= 412 >28367;274
4 58 9D>412> ?6742742; <= :2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412
324545672> 41@4 412 5C3DA72; 6>;2> 58 5::2A@: 32>E2>82 @7;
?@3>5?56D8
@7; 58 E56:@45E2 69 412 9D7;@C274@: >5A14
AD@>@7422; D7;2>
7;5@
>45?:2 'J *',*;, 69 412
678454D4567 69
12 6>;2> 32> 82 58 32>E2>82 @8 412>2 58 767
@33:5?@4567 69 GD;5?56D8 @7; 57;2327;274 C57; H5416D4
412>2
<257A
@7=
?6A274
C@42>5@:
96>
57E6K57A
2B42>7C274 @A@5784 412 324545672> 9>6C 672 3:@?2 46 412
6412>
>28367;274
@:86
E212C274:=
1@8 9@5:2; @7; 5A76>2; 46 :66K 5746 412
@?FD544@: 6>;2>8 3@882; <= 412
324545672>
?6742742;
41@4
6D>4 57 9@E6D> 69 412
4 58 @:86 9D>412> ?6742742; 41@4 412 >28367;274
1@8 <227 4@K27 @H@= 6> 579:D27?2; <= 412 >236>4 8274
<= 412
5>?:2 7832?46> 69
6:5?2 @7; 1@8 15C82:9 9@5:2; 46
96>C @7 5742::5A5<:2 6357567 67 412 <@858 69 @7= 4@7A5<:2
-7-
C@42>5@: 6> ?6A274 H547288 46 @>>5E2 @4 @ ?67?:D8567 69
2B42>7C274 69 412 324545672>
12 ?6D782: 9D>412> ?67427;8
41@4 3@84 ?>5C57@: ?@828 >2A5842>2; @A@5784 412 324545672>
H6D:; 764 <2 @ ?@D82 6> >2@867 46 2B42>7 412 324545672>
9>6C 672 3:@?2 46 412 6412> C6>2 86 96> 412 >2@867 41@4 57
4H6 69 412 ?@828 412 324545672> 1@8 <227 @?FD5442; 69 @::
?1@>A28
7;2> 412 ?5>?DC84@7?28 :2@>72; ?6D782: 3>@=8
41@4 4158 32454567 <2 @::6H2; @7; 412 5C3DA72; 6>;2> 69
2B42>7C274 <2 FD@812;
-
2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412 324545672> >2:528 D367
412 GD;AC274 69 ?6#6>;57@42
( %-J
27?1 69 4158
( $ @7; @:86 412 GD;AC274 69
6D>4 57
67/<:2
'
6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69
%
1@E2 12@>; :2@>72; ?6D782: 96> 412 324545672>
@7; :2@>72;
;;54567@:
6E2>7C274
;E6?@42 96> 412
>28367;274# 4@42 @7; 32>D82; 412 5C3DA72; 6>;2>
(
32B
7:572
JJ
-8-
J
7 ?@>29D: 32>D8@: 69 5C3DA72; 6>;2> 54 58 8227
41@4 412>2 58 767 @33:5?@4567 69 C57; @7; 86 @:86 412>2 58
>236>4
>28367;274
27?:682;
>28367;274
68 &
@7;
@8 54 58 764 @772B2; @:67A H541 412 816H
?@D82 7645?2 A5E27 46 412 324545672>
12 >28367;2748 @>2
>2FD5>2; 46 ?6785;2> 412 2B42>7C274 57 412 :2442> @7; 835>54
69 412 3>6E58567 D7;2>
2?4567 $
69 412 +
?4 @8 @7=
8D?1 6>;2> H15?1 58 3@882; 2B42>757A @ 32>867 9>6C 672
3:@?2 46 @76412> H5416D4 3>632> C@42>5@: @7; 3>28DC34567
@7; @33:5?@4567 69 C57; H5:: ?2>4@57:= :2@; 46 E56:@4567 69
412 9D7;@C274@: >5A14 A>@742; D7;2>
>45?:2 'J *',*;, 69
678454D4567 69 7;5@ 412>2<= 412 9>22 C6E2C274 69
412 324545672> 58 >284>5?42;
4 58 @:86 72?288@>= 96> 412
>28367;274 @D416>54528 46 >2?6>; @ 8D<G2?45E2 8@4589@?4567
@8 ?6742C3:@42; D7;2>
2?4567 $
69 412 +
?4 54 H6D:;
?2>4@57:= <2 67 412 <@858 69 412 C@42>5@:8 3:@?2; <296>2 412
?6C324274 @D416>54=
7 412 3>28274 ?@82 67 1@7;
@332@>8 41@4 @<86:D42:= 76 C@42>5@: @7; 76 ;58?D88567 58
412>2
H541
>2A@>;
41>2@4
6>
57GD>=
41@4
-9-
?6742C3:@42; 6> 32>?25E2; <= 412 ?6C324274 @D416>54= 46
3D<:5? 32@?2 @7; 4>@7FD5:54=
2>2:= <2?@D82 69 412
2B58427?2 69 @ ?>5C57@: ?@82 H6D:; 764 :2@; 46 41>2@4 46
3D<:5? 32@?2 @7; 4>@7FD5:54=
12 @D416>54= H6D:; 1@E2 46
C@K2 6D4 @ A66; ?@82 <@82; 67 8D<G2?45E2 @33>2?5@4567 69
412 C@42>5@:8 41@4 412 324545672> H6D:; ?2>4@57:= 57E6:E2 57
@?45E54528 H15?1 H6D:; ?@D82 41>2@4 46 3D<:5? 32@?2 @7;
4>@7FD5:54=
@E57A A672 41>6DA1 412 C@42>5@:8
;6 764
957; @7= 8D?1 C@42>5@:8 1@E57A <227 C@;2 @E@5:@<:2 <= 412
?6C324274 @D416>54=
67/<:2
32B
6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69
* D3>@, @4 3@>@A>@31
'
@7; '$ 1@8 12:;
@8 96::6H8
!
"
"
$
#
%
&
& #
(
(
%
$
$
#
&
#
&
"
"
&
&
&
'
&
)
*
- 10 -
&
(
+((
,
%
(&
$
& #
"
&
#
* #
-
&
"
(
%
.
)
&
&
#
"
-
&
#
&
&&
#
$
&
/
#
"
)
(
"
/
#
* #
#
#
# "
(
"
)
#
)
&
"
#
'
"
-
# &
+((
$
&
&
"
'
# "
$
#
&&
)
'
)
#0
.
- 11 -
'(
>2@8678
@885A72;
<=
?6C324274
@D416>54= @>2 @8 D7;2>
! "
#$%& ' (
) $ *! +, ! " #$%& ' ( #
, - ,
( .! +,
!/( * ! 0 1
$ 2 1 3
! " 4 5
! 8 4 - 2 1!3
.:
;2
1 !. <
=
- >- + ?@A B<
" $
#!C =
D5
!. !
5 *
$- E %
;
! B
!F G- !F-E H I
*D" $
(G4 5, 6 !
J =- $=E2 1
) 2!3
A
$ ! " KL MN
! - .1 O ;
K R
"
*
1 .M 1 3
T
-%
> 'P ;Q
5 *
<
-S ! "
:
B; * 1 ! $
1 U V! $
WW
, 1
!C
G < -J
- %
B
"
! G. =S1
!F R 1
"
FD 2!+D"!,
B G
G # X
, D"
D
%
# X
, = Y1
/
; " Z # ! 7 !.
1 7
;
.M! K> N- %
1 O -K .
N 7 $
G -.M 1 O
D- 1 .M- N' 1 3
[ O1
/<
:7
. $
\5
%] .! +
#
<
(G- " #
1 B
O 1
(G- 4 11 0F
7 >
7 >
5 1 3
@ 1 7 - > #!
G # X 5^ ! 1
/
D"! Z; "
- R %
1 _>
- R 2 1 3
^
G
# X
- 12 -
` 1 7 a b>' " 1
c -E $ G
(G- " 0F
7 >
! " ;I % 7
<
! " 4 11 #
!1
1!3
d
- .1 B1 4 - B 1
!C - >- +
cD"g ! <
(! " 4 5
e 6f .- 2!+. ! !.
[[
! B<
"
K
- .1
? Z! !
a (. 5! + 3h
-\1 ^
(G-
''
@885A72;
<=
>2@8678
=S $ %D
?6C324274
@D416>54= @>2 96> 2B42>7C274 H6D:; 764 <2 8D995?5274 46
2B42>7 412 324545672> 9>6C 672 3:@?2 46 @76412> @8 57 ?@82
412 324545672> 58 ?@D857A @7= 41>2@4 6> ;@C@A2 412 8@C2
H6D:; 1@E2 46 <2 7645952; 46 412 324545672> 57 412 816H
?@D82 7645?2 @7; 412 >2:2E@74 >236>4 6DA14 46 1@E2 <227
A5E27 46 412 324545672> 46 >23:= 46 412 8@5; 816H ?@D82
7645?2 H15?1 1@8 764 <227 ;672 57 412 3>28274 ?@82 67
1@7;
12>296>2
57 C= 6357567 412 8@5; 6>;2> :@?K8
@33:5?@4567 69 C57; @7; 8D<G2?45E2 8@4589@?4567 @8 12:; <=
670<:2
32B
6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69
* D3>@,
12 6>;2> 69 2B42>7C274 H@8 3@882; H541 2992?4 9>6C
- 13 -
(
''
( $ 46 (
@:>2@;=
?6C2
('
(
@7
H12>257 2B42>7C274 32>56; 1@8
27;
?@82
@D416>54528
@>2
@33>2127;57A @7= 69 412 @?45678 6> @?45E54528 69 412
324545672>
412= 81@:: 96::6H 412 3>632> 3>6?2;D>2 @8
?6742C3:@42; D7;2>
2?4567 $
57E6K57A 8D?1 @ 3>6E58567
69 412 +
?4
7 ?@82 69
412= 81@:: 3>6E5;2 @ 3>632>
6336>4D754= @7; 96::6H 412 3>57?53:28 69 7@4D>@: GD845?2 @7;
3>6E5;2 @:: 8D?1 C@42>5@:8 <296>2 4@K57A @7= ;>@845? 8423
7 412 3>28274 ?@82 67 1@7;
412 2B42>7C274 32>56;
1@E57A @:>2@;= ?6C2 46 @7 27; 4158 C2>2:= >2C@578 @7
@?@;2C5?
5742>284
96>
767#96::6H57A
3>6?2;D>2 ?6742C3:@42; D7;2> 412 +
GD;AC274 69 412
* D3>@,
670<:2
32B
3>632>
?4 @7; 412
6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69
6D>4 58 57?:572; 46 816H 57;D:A27?2 57 412
C@442> 96> 1@E57A 764 96::6H2; 412 AD5;2:5728 :@5; ;6H7 <=
670<:2
??6>;57A:=
32B
6D>4 57 412 ?@82 69
3@88 412 96::6H57A
* D3>@,
- 14 -
12 H>54 32454567 58
5C3DA72;
3@882; <= >28367;274
6>;2>
E5;2
;@42;
(
772BD>2#
''
( $
58 12>2<=
FD@812;
6H2E2> 54 58 C@;2 ?:2@> 41@4 4158 6>;2> H5::
3>2?:D;2
3>6?22;57A8
@D416>54528
H@>>@748
57545@42
<D4
@33>63>5@42
H15:2
;657A
>28367;274 @D416>54528 81@:: 96::6H ;D2 3>6?2;D>2 69 :@H 57
84>5?4 @;12>27?2 46 412 GD;AC274 69
67/<:2
32B
6D>4 57
412 ?@82 69
'(
%
&
!
(
'
:
7:572
$'
JJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review