Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 32ee ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE SEVENTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE E.V. VENUGOPAL
Between:
WRIT PETI Tto N NO:3720 I OF 2025
Akula Srinivas, S/o Brahma. Re!d1 AOed about 40 years
Occ_ Business, RUo
2-42, Kondrikata viilage, Metpaily VanIat, .lagital
Dijnct _ 505 32S.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its principal Secretary, Home
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
Department,
2. The Superintendent of police, Jagital District.
3. The Deputy Superintendent of police, Jagital District.
4. The Circle lnspector, Metpalli p. S, Jagital District.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Articre 226 0f the constitution of rndia praying
circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith,
the High court may be preased to
issue any writ, order or direction, one more particurarry
MANDAMUS, decraring the action of the 4th respondent
in the nature of writ of
in opening rowdy sheet which
against the petitioner vide cr. No.32lrowdy open/sdom/2o24
petitioner) without any varid grounds and the further
that in the
(copy not furnished to
action of the respondents in cafling
him to the police station on the strength of the rowdy
sheet, as iflegar, arbitrary, in
violation of Articres i4, 19(ixd) and 21 of the constitution
of rndia and contrary to the
law laid down by the Honbre Apex cou( and this Honbre
High court in a catena of
judgments and consequentry set aside
the rowdy sheet opened against the petitioner
with a direction to the respondents not to call him to the police
station.
l.A. NO:1 oF 2025
petition under
Sectic
T: f,n.|il,'l
,::nX* ;:,',:1 :;";"";1::J"ffi
the lire
The Court made the
disposal c , the above
SRI BADDAM ARAVTND
Counset for the Respondents:
SRI M.SRINIVAS,
following: ORDER
( rcu msta nces sta
ted in t he
ribertvor;lJ;l,Tr:',."**::l:T:l;
and
the rowdysheet maintainerlwith
I against him pending
Counsel for the petitioner:
"
RE: Dy
AGp F( R HOME
writ petition.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
T}iE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE E.V.VENUGOPAL
WRIT PETITI ON No .37209 of 2025
Datcd: 17.02.2026
Between:
Akula Srinivas
Petitioner
And
The State of Telalgana,
Rep. by its Principal Secretary,
Home Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad and three (3) others
Respondents
ORDER:
The present Writ petition is filed under Article 226 of
Constitution of India for the folloi,ving relief/s:_
"... to issue a writ order or direction more p:rrticularly one
in the nature of UIRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring the
action of the 4,h respondent in opening rowdy sheet ,i,hich
against
_ the petitioner vide Cr.No.32/rou,dy
ope_n/sdom/2024 (copy not lurnishcd ro peritioner)
without any valid grounds and the further action of the
respondents in catling him to the police station on the
strength of the rowdv sheet, as illegal, arbitrary in
violation of Articles 14 I9{ l)(d) and 2l oi the Constiturion
of India arrd contrarv to the larv laid dou,n bl.the Honble
Apex Court and this Honble High Court rn a carena o[
judgments and consequently set aside the rowdy sheet
opened against the petitioner rvith a direction to the
rcspondents not to call him to the police station and pass
such other order or orders ..."
2.
Heard Mr.Baddam Arvind Reddy, learned counsel for
. the
petitioner and Mr.M.Srinivas, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Home representing learned
GovernmenI Pieader for Home appearing li r respondents
Perused the record.
3.
When the matter is taken up for constct ration, learned
counsel lor the petitioner submits rir,r
..1 similar
circumstances, this Court vide order dated Ct7.L2.2O2O in
W.P.No.1B28B of 2O2O inad directed respondrr r Nos.4
and 5
therein to close the rou,dy sheet opened against the petitioner.
Rel,ying upon the same, he seeks to pass apprcI riate
.
orders.
Learned Assistant Government ple:Lr [, r for Home
contends that Order 60 1 of Telangana State )olice Manual
classifies the categories of persons as rowdies r rd that
sheet ma1. be opened in respect of those persl ts,
ror.vd,y
under the
order of higher authorities. He further states th: t the
Director
General of Police, Telangana issued Circular t.i): C.No.2172
C13lSCRB/CID/TSl22 dated 22.O7.2022, wh r tr pror.ides
/
a
procedure for opening and continuingr/t ( rre\(..ing the
rorvd_v/ suspect/
history sheets. He submir: thar the
resprndgnl Pr_rlice never harassed or threatened he petitioner
and discharged their legitimate duties. Stating sr, he
dismiss the Writ petirion.
seeks to
5.
Having regard to the submissions of both the leurrned
counsel and for the reasons alike mentioned in the order
dated O7.12.2O2O in W.P.No.18288 of 2020, rhis Writ peririon
is allow.ed by directing tlie respondents to close the ror,l,dy
sheet opened against the petitioner.
.
Accordingly, the Writ petirion is allou,ed. The
respondents are directed to close the rorvdy sheet forthu,ith
opened against the petitioner. Hoq,ever, this order sha_ll not
preclude the respondent authorities to open a ro."r,dy sheet
against the petitioner, if the petitioner is involved in more
tharl two (2) criminal cases, by follorving due process o[ lau,
and in accordance rvith the conditions prescribed in the Order
No.601 of the Telangana State police Manual (TSpM). There
shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous Petitions, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
S
/. P, PONNA KRISHNA
SISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
N OFFICER
To,
. The Principal Secretary, Home Department, Se
riat, Hyderabad, State of
Telangana.
2. The Superintendent of Police, Jagital District.
3. The Deputy Superintendent of Police, Jagital District.
4. The Circle lnspector, Itiletpalli P. S, Jagital District.
5. One CC to SRI BADDAM ARAVIND REDDY, Advocate [OPUC]
6. Two CCs to GP FOR HOME, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUT]
7. Two CD Copies
(Along with the copy of order dated Ol 12.2O2O, in W.P.No.18288 of 2020)
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1710212026
ORDER
WP.No.37209 ot 2025
..2J''', j sIa
,,t'n'<''
,se'
f,s
\'-c
I
I
I|
7[17F
I
,+
*
^
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
@)
Lo
b AL
c)
I
t
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P.NAVEEN RAO
WRIT PETITION NO.1A288 OF 2O2O
ORDER:
Hearcl learned counsel for petitioner ancl learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Home.
2.
Petitioner is aggrieved by opening of rowdy sheet and
rejecting his request for review of further continuation of rowdy
sheet by order dated 27.7.2O2O, impugned in the writ petition.
Crime No.22 of 2O19 was registered on 13.2.2019 under Sections
3O2, l2OB, 1O9, 2Ol,.2O2', 212 ol IPC and Section 2i {I) A Indian
'i
Arms Act. Petitioner was'shown as Accusecl No.4. On completion
i.. ,.
of investigatiorl, charge sheet is hled Vicle PRC No.485 of 2O19 in
-;/-
the Court;r of--VItt Raaitional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
I
Hyrlerabad an-d the matter is pending. In substance, aliegation is
that petitiorie) along with three others attacked one person by
name Syed iAir"".in with deadly weapons at Banala Market,
besictes Minai Garden, Nayapool, Hyderabad ald deceased
succumb to 'several stat"injuries. After. involvement of the
.
petitioner in the above. crime, rowcly sheet was opened on
''.
27.6.2019 in Mirchowk Police Staiion and on the polnt of
jurisdiction, the rowdy sheet rvas transferred to Bhavaninagar
Potice Station ot 22.12.2019. Petitioner was also implicated in
Crime No.120 of 2Oi9 in Mirchowk Police Station under Section
I07 of Criminal Procedure Code, petitioner was bound over for
good conduct by the Special Executive Magistrate, Hyderabad vide
his orders dated 22.08.2019 for a period of one year.
l
The issue for <:or-r srclera t ion is on account of involvcmr:t,l of
petitioner in Crime No.22 of 2O[9 and order of binding orcI in
Crime No.120 ol 20I9 rvhetller openitrg of rorv<ly sher:l : rd
continuing thc samc rs.lustificcl.
4.
Right to life ancl libcrty are sacrosanct to a Pcrson. A pc I ]u
is entitled to lead his life u,ith dignit-y and sclf respect. lle is
entitled to privacy llis riglrts flow out of Article 21 ot
he
Constitution o[ India. Surveillance on Person certainly infiirr cs
on his right to life. privacy and liberty. These rights canno l-re
infringe<l exccpt by clue proccss of lau'. Compelling Public int( r :st
may requilc intrrsion into prir';tt 1' of a llcrsor-r but while <loit-r 1 so
great care and caution l.ras to l)e obscrvcd. Thus, if police op'rr a
rowdy sheet to keep survetllaltcc otr .l Person it musl sl l'v
justification, impcllcil to ensltrr) peace anri order itr the societl
5.
.
Ttre scope anrl u'idth of Alticlc 21 of tlle Constitutio 1 of
India, scope of porvct o[ polict to infringe prtvacy of a persotr z ld
scope and amLrit of t'olice Star.rtling Olclers (lor short. 'PSOJ tv re
vividly analyzctl at.rcl tlealt rvtth cxfensivell' by two lcarned .Iu'l es
o[ this Court in Moharnmed Quadeer and othets
's.
Commissloner of Pollce, Hyderabad and anotherl and Sunl<' ra
Satyararayana Vs State of Andhra Pradesh, Home DePartn.r nt
and others2. In both thcse tlecisions it is heltl that PSOs ar. I rrr
statutory executive tnstructions and have no bincling force o[ ]a r
6.
ln Mohammed Quadeer and others (supra), it is held:
".ll ()Ic'rirrA ol a Io*(ly slr(','l agarrrsl n fllr7,.n is rrtrl.nrl)tedlI
trauslrt B.il1r scrnnrs (i)rs.,trI('fl.es. Arliclc 2l ot llrc
G,nslitut(,n ,'l lrxlia grrir,Irlct's riHlrl l(! lilc Nitlr (lrarrrlY and
wilh il llx'rrghl to
tlr. nglrt 1() hvr', as a drg,Ill(rl
I t999 (t) ALD 60
: t999 ((, ALT 249
rcotltalloll. RlRltl lo I'l'trlJ(ior
s dr' inreA'xl Irrn of ri'llrl lo lih
l,li,."i,i.",i ti^.i.r. ) r, arr'1 srr' rr a I;sh( r'drrrtot t'e dtsPrivc'l
willr llre l)rut'cdure 'srnl)lislred Ly law'
L*rt i,,
".-"rr,,*
the lt,lice lo open rowdy slreels artd
arrrl'ori*
*r,i"r'
i""r', l.*"
ex"rci.c s,rrv"itta,.ce ale re+rire(l to be very slrictly conslnred'
itr
o;"li,,r ;i rr,e rowtlY slrrets arr(l ter'nttn' rrrernf 'x''l't ur
lrill, liw wotll', (rtllorlrll l'r ltlli lltg"rrrlrl
**aji*.
tundarrertal righr Srrar'anlcerl trv Aliicle 2I ol llrc Cor)stilrrtl()n
;i In.lra. lr is t;e il'at tlte star. rs drrtv lxnrrrd at all lev(ls ro
,,,"i., , tf* rf,Is,rrs .rrr,l l,rol' r lv lr'nrr lltc crrrrrtlrjrls 'rxl
Li'"i,rar,',riJ,,t. Prcverrrrorr "r irrIrrri''d critru rs drr "bI* rrotr
on tlte t)arl ol rhe Srrrrc.
R.rght to Prlwacy:
32. hrn.larnental righrs arfi civrl lit)er{ics exist artd cnrt ortly
or,tciiv societv (:ivil lit'erlics and [undartrental
ii.r.i"t, i,,
",'
c<rrn, eierl rvrrtr rlre ttature arrd dvrrarrrir s
irt'ir .,. 1",,',,"'at
.i',i,. s,.i",r. lt rs;l'c d'rlv ',1 lt(' Polr'e lo Jeal wrllr 'ri'tre ald
lrrre
cri rtrrals expeditrorrslv atrd etfi'livelv wltile at the sanreriShrs
ir.ra",g," ri,. vahrcs anrl .on'cPts ol the ftrndameotal
u"a ,ii. tt""',i..t1.,, norh llre cottrpetnrg il(crests are lo l'e
."..rr.if*i fni. rnrrclr is clear so l'?rr as our Corlsrirtrliorral
i'..,'-'",^t that iltrnrsir)n into persortal lil'ertv wirl(nrl
lrrrrg ot
"r.i.,,,
,ir.'t,r*,,i," oi law i; Iorbi(lden srrrverllrnce ari(l rvat{
ol crnrIs';t,.',. ,,r.,,,. of a crlla || lry th(, I'olir c ts r,ot a ur^tter
i,','r, ,,"r,t^ ean r'e e.r, rcise.l l'v rlr': l'(rli' c orrlv rrr accor'lnrxe
ur rlris
L.J *t, r' plrrrrits sutI srrrvtillrtr'' TI)r i!riun!;ol
rrct'
'*ir,
r' * i, .'"."-t"'"' \vrrlr larv rruv r"sult irr
2I
{'l
llle
t)v
'.r."Jwr,*
Adicle
l
rrBlrts
l-lrrlrlrrrleed
of tho(fund^tnelrt
ri8lrt an(l
folt'"tir,,,i"t, ot krtlra. ivery cilrz.tl ltas lirrrdamental
or
.rii,rr.a t,,,,'a,,rg. rrr hannless 'r'riviries wirlxnrt ol)sctwa(rr)o
gtlrral'I(e tn
lnta ter.rrrr: lt is a riBlrt ro l)r k'tt alolx''llrc
'arti'f. u tlr IirrrolFan (orrv(nlIotI of llrIrran Righls lltat
:i";^-.",, "ft,,' ,r* ,,strr to .csl*. t [')r I sl'rivrrl( arrd farnilv ltte
rr-. irJ,,i,
lras ciirr.sportderrr' r'flects llorlr Ihe indiv(lual6
?un'' of
irr"rr(i'''-ne'
r'l rr..'l ro l{, s' r\"rr
" Ds,r(lrol,,pi,^,'a
srrrss wl'i'L crro
[,',,*,riii ,,,d It,rilY, arrr rl' rrrRrrrslr "Irrl
L,.,,n,rir w1,.,, rlrar,'('rre is viol'rr"l' 'l'lrc srvi'r* rlrrl.'ad
lo
I':'i*il,;.;'r
c""r,rfr,,-' " lrour rs Iris casrl. w, rl,l lF /qrrnll! at'pll.nl'L
r" sritl Irt'rr ntr'lrrlr'm crtrrtlrs
,trxl
rr
',,
'arr
".,',,
,'rsll..
rs hts
honre
-
In
si-rrr,;'cro-)r r,a.r ^o hcst ottod @h,tsoctEr to tclicttt"tf
,,-;" l',tdtttt a^ce and utu'ch bv th' Pottcc 'he
;i;;;";
',-iU
|nhl'rsc -ahc lu^dam'fiat rtgh's of a cfi1'c^'
"dn.t't"a.tch @ll:tch i' ^ot dut'brt"d bs
i""ii,*rti""i
and uE'ch
i. -"g t. "^.""rtttutfonal s]u.ch'sit'trllld^e ac-cordcftce
.r*^ t1 i, t" ."tt ".i."d bY tau but tt tt ts ^o' t"
-i* inot to- "nua squattg be wncotLt'ttutloa'aL"
(cn'Phasis strPPli{tll
i 1
paragraph 49 of Sunkara Satyanarayana (supra)' learned
single Judge culled out princiPles on police surveillance
history/rowdy sheeters. [t reads as under:
"49. Tl'crefore, rrr lhe contc\l of police srrrvcallarce aSailrst
luslorv s,reiets arxl ro$(lv sl(elcrs' ll!' r(,llowntg Pri"ciPles
vis.a v'r nclrr lo pItva.Y rrlnl''r Arlxle ')l ot lhe Constrl[tion
woulrl encigc:
lf the srlrveillalrce rs Iror ot'lrusivr" lltc sanrc dt' s rrol
2l ot rlre Cortsrrtrrrrolr
-,,il,. ii,. rnr,t to ptivacv rrtr'l'r Arri'te
t('Irm
i.i,". iri.*,,,. ioes nor ''rt''r irr nraterr'rr or palr)ar'I'
il be r'eld
"i
;;;;i"
;'" ortt," ",,"pn.' ro rtrove fr'elv lrorofcan
I'is I'ersonal
lrrsrory sli"rr / rolvdv sl'ctFr
;;;;p,i,-'i;
lb€ny
lil
tiil ln lesting whelher hrnd'trrrenlal flElrt of (ree
pli*',"r r,i"iii r" i,,rnltsed or lrot, rt is ro l'e rerrrertrbel'd rhar
against
rvfll."i.'Ilill''i;.1liiil liT'iil
,,,f,u,q.,,,.," sr,,"'ir't rr rr !'i ,ris
,:"
r,,,,,s In.,s,,,1,, s.,,s,r,i,(,cc.
rrcler rrrri rlil:;.,;
rrr''krrs
-,,'.r'i,,'n"'
j,,,,",, ,,,.,. y.,*,,"r
scrrsil iv'rress'
,rrr r I.rr"i $n'rrrrr::
:i,,,",,,i"';ll'llil"t"tll;
.l,l'::lli[',,,,11"',,,.
r,,r rrrc sr;rr.
'l
",
"*",,,,*.r,r,.r,',,1',
rr
.
lr,rrr
.t,rr,jrc , lIt
IrtllI*.. rlr.
"
r ,r r . rr
, !, .
,,,,ur.n,
.r,,
,,,
I'r,^' Irr''rt '\rr\'rrr:'rr^
""'* ,':il,' ll',.,; 'i', ,",,,,,lt'*ltlj*
t'rrir ''r tlr''"'-i'1i,"rr,,,,,,',,.,,,,*si,,v,ll"r'
,
i
r .
, ,
, ,,
'
, ,
'
, , ,
'
'
L'Ir'lr'lrtr''\ s' I' rl!' rl'\
l,'ll,{L''lllrr
'
'
hrrr!!l t'r "1"'l*":l]:;
rrvl ll llr' ri'li"rr r'l rl 'l'rln' r{
r,.llil,, .'*,",',""'"" "1. il:':"),*ii:li l"':*I;:'[,];:,''ll
vr,'l.rr'c lrrr rtqlr! I" I'nqr'v'ct". ii ,,,^" *',.,,.* ","1'*'.'1
cx'' rsrv'l\ tlrrrnrsrv' atrr ""'l'l',,,^,,*"
trnr'rrral rraht
I","'-','i',r'o',i, t',Itl
'rt
,nt tlr'' I'rr':r ; "r '! ' rri?'rr i's
s,'ll s llr'
as
r, 1,rrv i' t 'rr"r r" ts''!!ar lir" nv.'I "'r:,,;' ;;',;. r,rl{,rl or rh'
rrr.torrr,,r rr,,,vrrr,,.rrr E,*,"',r',.,., ;" j,,1,,.,,,,,_"ir,r".
r-,,'r<trtlll li 'tr !n'llrill'r arld tlk's:
irr [!r Irr srrrf illjrr"''
r\l f-vcrr wlx rc rhcrc rs sr;!lrrr'r'Y s
dr"irr*
I"!!r' rrrr' (r'r rs
,.:11,., l:;.li ;'.;;,;;.,,'-*,,y 'r,..,",
ol'u'rs'\'''
j
',;;'i';"'r" rr rrr'' surverrltr'(u
rs
p,,,.,'" :"i11.",'-,1:,1';:IL|;l'*"lii[ :l;ilil:I,],,,,,,trr'\
ll'"'
' "l:l i;,i; ,,," r'-,^* :rr.' r'(5/ro)'t)
'1" "ol'rrr'"r"""1,
'tr '!Lrr':re r,' ,,Irr" rln
I'
r".,r.ft,1
ii,,,
,,,,,rr...', ,,,,. . .[[.. wlll,
rL.,1x,,,r
,t.t,r
.r
{t,...r,.rs slr,$.
v,.," r,,rvr, tr,ns nr
r,,
\r1
rrrvirlv's rrur'rrr'r 'r'r'rr'.
:::1. ,':
{:,rtrr Irr s'rri:tv
",,' .,,,,,t,,"rtr,',, klarrt
i,,''''|Lrr i rL' s':r" " "''"1'll-l"l:,,'.,ri.,,,
,"r,,,,::,1,"i,:i",;,.-.,,..\,,
r.
,,.e,,(r,1r
.,,,,r,or
r,,,-,,,e,. ,r,.
l'f('j!ll\
|ttrlalr"r 's' lr\!'\1 |
r' rrrr'-l'r lr r\'' t"a !"1'rrt'rv1r'
'c .'rl''rr'
I
r(!,, rn .,,,..,,,,:
i,," iil'"i,,:':
\rstlsr''".],.];,,
tl'rn",,.,.,":;,.,11i,,,;1.i.:lll'_
;i';'J,
'l"rrrr'r"
l'''
'lrrrx' rr" r'r'rrrr r"rr'^1 rrl rr rrrF c'r'r 'r,I
"l"irll l'e r'1ltr"1l
,r"
r.
::l:lli;.r:.. '
':,,,
risc'
r'l'tisc rrorrr r)risorr ur riv"r \ '
,
"'*''ir'" "'
r
z#.^l':Yit{,';*i1:;r:E{i*t::H-"Yi
r,ffiW*#i#ffi,#
oJ thtt c!
:?,.ent atr'lsto^'
tn
;;#:;:":';;;;'*'^'E'ob' hcPt -"t,lu,' ** '',,,"'u
Manuat cleals wttl-r ,'nous
8. Thc Andhrir Pradcsh Potice
policc personnel which
aspects of iuncttoning of
registration of crimes' investigatior.l'
opening of rowcl:" sheets
rowdy stleet. According
etc
conducting oI
i: clude
I
re
PSO-6O1] deals with o1x
to Clause-Al thereof, i[ a Person
or abet
commits, attemPts to commit
the commissior1 of c fences
,Cl"-".L
as rosdies;r 't
Tl,. trl('ulrA !{rsons nrav Lc clacs,t'.'l
a,,(l \( l'lsDtt)
ie,n u ,t.I 1lr' odcrs ol rl(: aP/lx.P
(rr
to cor nunl or alEt lhc
who hal,rtrr{l iv .. nit, n 'Irtltr
R:6{n,r
ot t[' IEaa
olTc es trrv(nvt'A a bI'il h
r urg of
hz I ituallY
Roudv sh"rs il'
I
allcl
srlr.tFn." ',r ldl)[. o!11
tt P t:o lSl1EoF0l0
involving breach of peace, disturbance to public order and
security, a rowdy sheet can be opened to closely observe his
movements and activities. According to Clause-Bs thereof, the
persons who are bound over should be classified as rowdies and
rowdy sheets can be opened and continued.
9.
Reading of extracted provision of PSO-6O1-A, makes it clear
that to open rowdy sheet emphasis is on habitually committing
ollence involving breach of peace, disturbance to public order and
\ '-:
lO. The justifiiati6n shoivn to continu-e1ibwdy. sheet against
,:i;
. " ,,''
petitioner istldis yolrng and energetic ana if rb#ay{sfrLt is closed.,
!
t
. ..
he may cai:de liieach of public peace and tranquiliry.". \'i*i,,
,,-r :-';
.( - .i
- 11,
[toi.'..fiiei fexpression 'habitually' me:Ins 'repeatedly' or
$ f h'
lersistdntlyr: "lt '.implies a th reaa or .o.,ri.,,ity "rn-#J$"*",n.r
tri
I l.
l.':"
it:. -,similar idpddt'ive 'acts. Repeated, persistent and shrilAi,t but not
..n-'-.
-it.:, '
'. .\- .fir.6'
i
isolated, inil-ii,jdual cir. <lissimilar acls are necessary/t6 justify an
t',j1
" h
'of
habft lPaiaErap-li-s t, vri"y.Itt"rhln Slagh vs. state of
inference
.
' ,r-,'
i
against
Bihar - (1983) 4 SCC Lii. T tt" t*b.
"rr;i'.sf..gistered
'':. .petitioner are not on similar offences. Further, mere involvement
in two crimes it cannot be inferred that p€titioner is 'habitually'
committing oflences invohing breach of peace, disturbance to
public order and security.
12. It is not the case of Police that Petitioner is involving in
several crimes and is in the habit of disturbing peace and
tranquility. It is also not the case of Police that after opening of
rowdy sheet he indulged in activities detrimental to Peace in the
'choa-B. PeMs bou d ov.. undc. Sections 106. lo7, toE(l)(il&d llo(elElof cr.P.C.
locality. Thus, the ingredients of PSO 60l-A are not attracte{ .n
the case.
13. In W.P-No. 19194 ot 2012, learned single Judgc of tllis C( r rr
in the judgment rcndered on 24.08.2O15 reviewed the entire c? n)
law on the subject. The learned single Judge held thal t Lt:
requirement to open a rowdy sheet would arise if a persr,r Ll;
iavolved in more than two crimes and, therefore, held that operr .g
rowdy sheet for involving in two crimes as tainted in law front t ,e
inception. ln the case on hand.also, petitioner is involvcd in cr v
two crimes.
14. As held in precedent decisrons, PSO is non-statut:1'
instrument_to guide police in discharge of their dutics. Ir can 't )1
give [cense- to Dolice to open rowdy sheet in a casual r r d
mechanical manner. Opening of rowdy shcct is not as a mattei )l
course whenever crirnes arc reported. Opcrtu.rg rowrly sheei agai r ,t
petitioner' an(l - continuing, in the facts of this case, cannot lc
termed as in public lnterest. Pctitioncr's riglrt.to lifc ar.rd libertr ,s
infringed by potice rvithout reAsonable caust:. It is made in abrr e
of power and autholity, is rltegal and infraction of funclamer t .l
rights guarantced to pet itioner.
15. The dccision impugned in the Writ Petition to contir r s
rowdy sheet is set aside. Writ Petition is accordingly allou"
Respondents 4 and 5 arc drrected to forthwith close the roq(,,
sheet and inform the petitioner accordingly. Pending miscellanccr s
petitions if any shall stard closed.
JUSTICE P.NAVEEN R-/\ )
Date: 07.12.2O2O
Tuk/ kkm
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review