Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:2180
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S. A. No. 212 of 2022
Akshay Kumar Jaiswal, aged about 47 years, son of Ugra Narayan
Jaiswal, resident of Godda Town, P.O. Godda, P.S. Sub-Division,
District-Godda.
…
…
Plaintiff/Appellant/Appellant
Versus
1. Rukmani Devi, Wife of Chandra Shekhar Ramdas.
2. Rakesh Ramdas, Son of Late Chandra Shekhar Ramdas.
3. Shewata Ramdas, Daughter of Chandra Shekhar Das.
4. Putul Ramdas, Daughter of Chandra Shekhar Das.
5. Shankar
6. Rajeev Ramdas
7. Sanjeev Ramdas all sons of Late Devendra Ramdas
8. Sanjukta Devi, Daughter of Late Devendra Ramdas, Residents of
Village Korka, P.O. and P.S. Pathargama, District-Godda.
... ...
Defendants 1st party/Respondent 1st party/Respondent
1st party
9. Shatrughan Mishra, Son of Late Radhika Mishra
10.Nutan Dubey, Wife of Prem Kumar Dubey, Resident of Babupara,
P.O. and P.S. Godda (T), District-Godda.
11.Bharatji Mishra, Son of Late Radhika Mishra
12.Smt. Jaymala Devi, Daughter of Late Radhika Mishra.
13.Dinkar Mishra
14.Madhukar Mishra
15.Bablu Mishra, Sons of Ramji Mishra
16.Papu Mishra
17.Bijay Shankar Mishra, Sons of Bharatji Mishra
18.Roshan Kumar Mishra
19.Babul Mishra both sons of Satrughan Mishra, all residents of
Godda Town, P.O.-Godda, P.S. Sub-Division and District-Godda.
... ...
Defendant 2nd party/Respondent 2nd
party/Respondent 2nd party
20.Sabitri Devi, Wife of Late Ugra Narayan Jaiswal
21.Bipin Kumar Jaiswal, Son of Ugra Narayan Jaiswal
22.Upendra Narayan Jaiswal
23.Birendra Narayan Jaiswal
All sons of Late Babu Chakndrika Prasad Jaiswal
24.Rajpati Devi, Daughter of Late Babu Chandrika Prasad Jaiswal,
Resident of Godda Town, P.O. Godda, P.S. Sub Division and
District-Godda.
... ...
Plaintiffs/Appellants/Proforma Respondents
--CORAM :HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Appellant
: Mr. Sandeep Verma, Advocate
---
2026:JHHC:2180
Lastly, heard on 20.01.2026
1.
Pronounced on 28.01.2026
This second appeal has been filed by the plaintiff against the
judgment dated 30.09.2022 (decree signed on 25.11.2022) passed by
learned District Judge-1st, Godda in Civil Appeal No. 07 of 2009. The
learned 1st appellate court has partly dismissed the appeal filed by the
plaintiffs. The trial court judgment is dated 09.04.2009 (decree signed
on 27.07.2009) passed by learned Sub-Judge 1st, Godda in Title Suit
No. 27 of 1985 and the suit was dismissed.
2.
The suit was filed by the plaintiffs against two sets of
defendants, defendant 1st party and defendant 2nd party.
3.
The plaintiffs sought a declaration of their title with respect to
Schedule ‘A’ land alleging that the same was in illegal possession of
defendant 1st party and also with respect to schedule ‘B’ land alleging
that the same was in illegal possession of defendant No. 2 to 4
amongst the defendant 2nd party. The plaintiffs also sought a decree
for recovery of possession of the suit land from the defendants.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the suit
property consisted of schedule ‘A’ and schedule ‘B’ and the suit was
dismissed. At the 1st appellate stage, the appeal was allowed only in
connection with schedule ‘A’ property and so far as schedule ‘B’
property is concerned, the 1st appeal was also dismissed and
accordingly, the plaintiff/appellant is aggrieved with respect to finding
of the learned 1st appellate court in connection with schedule ‘B’
property only.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the finding
of the learned court that Radhika Mishra, father of the defendant No. 2
to 4, was in possession with respect to schedule ‘B’ property since
1936-37 was based on three facts (A) Oral Settlement, (B) Kurfanama
(Which was never exhibited) and (C) Compromise decree passed in
Title Suit No. 08 of 1962. He has also submitted that the compromise
decree was exhibited by the plaintiffs as Exhibit-8.
6.
Learned counsel has submitted that Kurfanama was never
produced before the court and accordingly, the very basis on which
defendant No. 2 to 4 claimed possession was not exhibited. He has
2026:JHHC:2180
submitted that the finding of the court that the aforesaid defendants
were in possession of the suit property 12 years prior to coming into
force of S.P.T. Act is not in accordance with law.
7.
Learned counsel has submitted that the finding in connection
with possession since 1936 is perverse.
8.
He has relied upon judgment passed by Hon’ble Patna High
Court reported in 1975 PLJR 446 [Ram Narain Sah vs. The State of
Bihar & Others] has referred paragraph 8 and the said judgement also
refers to the judgment passed by Hon’ble Patna High Court (full
bench) reported in 1972 PLJR 415 Pat [Bhauri Lal Jain vs. SubDivisional Officer, Jamtara].
9.
Case of the plaintiffs:a. The plaintiffs claimed to be the legal heirs and successors of
Karulal Choudhary, the recorded tenant, with respect to J.B. No.
11, which stood exclusively recorded in his name. The suit
property has been described in Schedule ‘A’ and ‘B’ property.
b. It was the case of the plaintiffs that Karulal Choudhary died in
the year 1933-34, after the survey settlement, leaving behind his
son Babulal, who also died leaving his daughter Madan Devi
and wife Manti Devi. Madan Devi was married to one
Chandrika Pd. Jaiswal and the plaintiffs are their sons. Both
Chandrika Pd. and Madan Devi had died. Further, Madan Devi
had expired in the year 1972 and her mother expired in the year
1974.
c. In the month of May 1974, the plaintiffs wanted to plough the
suit land, but the defendants requested the plaintiffs to continue
their permissive possession as they were coming in possession
since the life time of Manti Devi, but the defendants on
15.05.1974 refused to give up their possession by saying that
they were in possession of the suit land on the basis of purchase
from Manti Devi.
d. It was alleged that the claim of the defendants was based on
forged and fabricated documents and the predecessors in
interest of the plaintiffs had never transferred the suit lands to
2026:JHHC:2180
the defendants nor executed any documents in their favour. It
was also asserted that Manti Devi was a pardanashin lady and
also that the suit lands are not transferable lands as per the
provisions of Santhal Paragana Tenancy Act (S.P.T. Act) and
even on the basis of collusive title suits, if any, the defendants
have no right to continue in possession of the suit land. It was
asserted that the collusive title through judgment or decree in
title suit is not binding on the plaintiffs being in violation of
sprit of S.P.T Act.
10.
Since, the relief has been ultimately granted to the appellant in
connection with schedule-A property, no discussion is required so far
as schedule-A property is concerned.
11.
Case of the Defendant 2nd party
in connection with
schedule B property:i.
The defendants appeared and filed their written statement. It
was asserted that there was misjoinder of cause of action as
against defendant No.1 on one hand and defendant No. 2 to 4 on
other hand. There was nothing common amongst the sets of
defendants.
ii.
The property in connection with schedule-B is related to
defendant 2nd party.
iii.
It was the specific case of the defendant 2nd party that Radhika
Pd. Mishra, the father of defendants, was an old resident of
Godda town and had opened book stall sometimes in the year
1935 and he had opened book-stall in a rented house in Godda
bazar, but had no land of his own. At that time, the sons and
widow (Manti Devi) of Babulal Choudhary had extensive land
in their possession which they could not cultivate. So Manti
Devi thought it prudent to settle portion of plot No. 12 and
invited settles and the father of defendant 2nd party needed some
land for residential accommodation, approached Manti Devi in
1936 and she settled 8 kathas of land in plot No.12 with
Radhika Prasad Mishra (orally), father of the defendants, who
came in possession and constructed a wall with wood and plank
2026:JHHC:2180
door and the defendants built a house inside the compound wall
and a portion of the schedule land was also used as kitchen
garden and cow shed was also established in the property. The
defendants 2nd party asserted that they were still living in the
house of schedule-B property since 1937.
iv.
It was denied that the plaintiffs wanted to plough the suit lands
in May 1974 and it was asserted that there were no fields to
plough. It was also asserted that Manti Devi never objected to
any construction over the suit property. It was also asserted that
in the year 1962 Manti Devi, at the instance of her daughter
Madan Devi, filed a Title Suit No. 8 of 1963 in the Court of
Deputy Collector Godda for recovery of possession over the
suit land described in Schedule-B property against the father of
the defendant 2nd party, but good sense prevailed on her and she
compromised with defendant 2nd party and the compromise was
recorded on 07.02.1963 and Manti Devi gave up her claim over
the suit property. The defendant 2nd party got their name
mutated in Mutation Case No.154 of 1972-73. It was asserted
that the father of the defendant 2nd party during his lifetime
acquired title to the suit land by adverse possession before 1949
and continued in possession till 1967 when he died and after his
death the defendant 2nd party have inherited the property.
v.
It was also asserted that the defendant 2nd party were granted
Kurfanama, but the same was not required after the decision in
title suit. It was also asserted that Manti Devi was a literate lady
and was not a pardanashin lady. The defendant 2nd party
claimed to have acquired title over the land of schedule-B by
adverse possession and it was asserted that it was false to say
that the decree in Title Suit No.8 of 1963 was collusive in any
manner and the compromise entered into between Manti Devi
and the father of the defendant 2nd party is binding on the
plaintiffs.
vi.
It was also asserted that the compromise was never objected by
Manti Devi till her death in the year 1974. It was also asserted
2026:JHHC:2180
that the plaintiffs had falsely filed suit for declaration of their
title, although the plaintiffs earlier filed R.E.R. No.4 of 1982-83
against the defendant 2nd party for eviction from Schedule-B
land and other occupants of plot No.12 being settlees of Manti
Devi and in that case the plaintiffs claimed that defendant 2 nd
party had come in possession over the schedule-B land after
1949 and in the said case there was averment that defendant 2 nd
party were requested in 1974 to allow them to cultivate the land
of schedule-B property. It was submitted that the title suit was
not maintainable. It was also asserted that the power of eviction
rests only with the revenue court and suit was barred under
Section 9 of C.P.C.
12.
The following issues were framed by the learned trial court:1. Is the suit as framed maintainable?
2. Have the plaintiffs any valid cause of action for the suit?
3. Is the suit barred by law of limitation, estoppel,
acquiescence and waiver and on the principle of adverse
possession?
4. Does the suit suffers defect of parties and cause of action?
5. Have the plaintiffs got any valid title over the suit land and
if so the what extent?
6. Whether the plaintiffs are heir of recorded tenant?
7. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to a decree, if so to what
extent?
8. To what other or relief or reliefs, if any, are the plaintiffs
entitled?
9. Whether the suit is bad for non joinder and misjoinder of
parties (cause of action)?
10. Whether the court has jurisdiction to entertain this suit
in view of pendency of R.E.R Case no. 40 of 83-84 in the
court of S.D.O.?
13.
It was asserted in the written statement filed by the defendant
1st party and has also come in the evidence of the defendants including
the evidence of the defendant 2nd party , D.W-1 (Satrughan Mishra)
that Madan Devi died issueless and the plaintiffs are sons from second
wife and Madan Devi died first.
14.
The learned trial court recorded that by virtue of order dated
29.12.1972 passed by learned Circle Officer, Godda in Mutation Case
2026:JHHC:2180
No. 154 of 1972-73, the property was mutated in the name of Ramjee
Mishra and rent receipts were issued with respect to Schedule-B
property. The learned trial court also considered the plaint of Title
Suit No. 8 of 1963 (Exhibit-G) which was filed by Manti Devi
(mother of Madan Devi) on 19.11.1962 against Radhika Pd. Mishra
and his sons with respect to schedule-B property wherein she sought
recovery of possession and vide order dated 07.02.1963, the suit was
dismissed on the basis of compromise (Exhibit-H). It was the case of
the plaintiffs that they are the heirs of recorded tenant (Karulal
Choudhary). Madan Devi daughter of Babulal Choudhary died in
1972 and Manti Devi wife of Babulal Choudhary died on 26.01.1974.
15.
It was the case of the defendants that Madan Devi had no issue,
so her husband Chandrika Pd. Jaiswal took the second wife and all the
plaintiffs were the sons of Chandrika Pd. Jaiswal, but not the son of
Madan Devi and therefore, it was for the plaintiffs to prove that they
were the heirs of Madan Devi and admittedly, Madan Devi
predeceased her mother and Madan Devi could not have inherited the
property and thereby the plaintiffs failed to establish that they were the
legal heirs of recorded tenant.
16.
It was also found that no appeal was filed by Manti Devi
against the compromise decree passed in Title Suit No.8 of 1963.
Consequently, it was observed by the learned trial court that it was
evident that Manti Devi had settled the property by Kurfa with
defendant 1st party and 2nd party and they were also put in possession
of the same and had constructed houses etc over the suit property.
The court also recorded that Manti Devi, who filed a suit being Title
Suit No. 08 of 1963 which was dismissed on the basis of compromise.
The learned trial court also recorded that the defendants had come in
possession of the land in the year 1936 in his own right and capacity
of bonafide settlee and the plaintiffs admitted the possession of
Radhika Pd. Mishra (father of the defendant no. 2 to 4 who were
amongst the defendant 2nd party) and Devendra Ramdas (defendant 1st
party) in the year 1934-35. The learned trial court recorded that both
the schedule A and schedule B property were under different
2026:JHHC:2180
circumstances and different dates with respect to different portion of
plot No.12 and there was nothing in common. The learned trial court
held that the suit suffered from the defect of misjoinder of cause of
action.
17.
While deciding issue No.10, the learned trial court recorded
that the learned S.D.O had the jurisdiction of ejectment under Section
42 of S.P.T. Act and the plaintiffs would not invoke the civil
jurisdiction for the same subject matter. The plaintiffs had invoked
first revenue courts of S.D.O. Godda and later on invoked the
jurisdiction of Civil Court. The learned trial court held that the suit of
civil court was barred under S.P.T. Act and Section 9 of the CPC and
therefore, the suit was not maintainable.
18.
While deciding issue Nos.2 and 3, the learned trial court
recorded that the plaintiffs had no cause of action and the defendants
had completed 12 years of adverse possession prior to passing of the
S.P.T. Act of 1949 and continued in possession thereafter and the
learned trial court ultimately dismissed the suit. This finding has not
been disturbed by the learned 1st appellate court with respect to
schedule-B property.
19.
The learned 1st appellate court from paragraph 16 considered
the issue Nos.(i), (ii), (iii) & (iv) together. The learned 1st appellate
court recorded a finding on the basis of oral and documentary
evidence which is as follows:“18..............................................................................................
...................... So it is clear that Radhika Mishra got lands in
1936 from Manti Devi and they construct the house boundary
wall and living with family in the Schedule B land, who after
compromise the case in Title suit no. 8/62 filed by Manti Devi
compromise the case on the basis of compromise petition, the
case is disposed off and Radhika Mishara filed a Mutation
case no. 1972-73 and mutated his name and paid rent to the
government, so court found that on the basis of oral evidence,
these issues decided partly in favour of respondent no.2 and
against the plaintiff, whereas partly in favour of plaintiff and
against the respondent no.1st set.”
20.
With respect to defendant 1st party/respondent 1st party, the
learned 1st appellate court held that the defendant 1 st set did not
2026:JHHC:2180
produce any compromise petition, Kurfanama or any documentary
evidence in support of their case although they claimed on the basis of
such documents and allowed the claim of the plaintiffs with respect to
schedule A property.
21.
With respect to defendant 2nd party relating to schedule B
property, the learned 1st appellate court recorded the following findings:
“20. …………………………………………….
Whereas respondent 2nd party claim possession before 12
years of S.P.T. Act 1945 and claimed on the basis of
Kurfanama but no Kurfanama produced before the court
during the trial and never brought on the record, whereas
respondent 2nd party also taken the same ground and on the
basis of compromise , they got a decree is in his favour and
apply a mutation case and got successful his name mutated in
the record and they paid rent to the government. Devendra
Ramdas also examined in the court. They recorded his age at
80 years according to their age counting, they are 7-8 years at
the time of purchase the schedule A land, so it is not possible
that they working as a Homeopathic doctor and purchase the
land, so in this way the claim of respondent 1st party is totally
baseless that they purchase the suit land where as Radhika
Mishra established a Radhika Press and bookstall, who taken
the land in 1936-37 from Manti Devi for residential purpose
and from the commissioner report, it is clear that they are
legal heirs are presenting living after constructing the house,
so the provision of S.P.T. Act is not operative against the
Respondent 2nd party and 2nd party on the basis of mutation
in 1972-73 in the life time of Manti Devi mutated his name in
the record and pay revenue to the government, hence the
plaintiff have no any right title and possession on the schedule
land of B in the light of documentary and oral evidence as on
record……”
22.
The learned 1st appellate court on the basis of materials on record,
both oral and documentary, held that plaintiffs have right, title and
possession over schedule A property and allowed the appeal partly with
respect to schedule A property and further held that plaintiff have no any
right, title and possession over the schedule B property and also held that
the defendant 2nd party has right, title and possession of schedule B
property as father of the defendant 2nd party had taken the land in 19369
2026:JHHC:2180
37 from Manti Devi and the defendant 2nd party have been living on the
same after constructing the house.
23.
Therefore, concurrent findings have been recorded by both the
courts that the defendant 2nd party was in possession with respect to
the suit property 12 years prior to coming into force of S.P.T. Act and
had perfected their title by virtue of adverse possession and later on
Manti Devi filed a Title Suit No.8 of 1963 against the father of
defendant No. 2 to 4 (defendant 2nd party) which ended in a
compromise. The court also recorded that Manti Devi, during her
lifetime, neither challenged the compromise nor challenged the
mutation carried on in favour of the defendant 2nd party.
24.
In the judgment reported in 1972 PLJR 415 (Supra) it has been
clearly held that a person could perfect the title by adverse possession
after completion of 12 years in possession prior coming into force of
the S.P.T. Act 1949.
25.
In the judgment cited by the learned counsel for the appellant
reported in 1975 SCC Online Pat 14 (supra), it was the case of the
appellant that they came in possession in the year 1944 and admittedly
they had not completed the possession 12 years prior to coming into
force of the S.P.T Act, 1949. This judgement is clearly distinguishable
on facts.
26.
This Court finds that the learned 1st appellate court has rightly
scrutinized the materials on record and has rejected the case of the
plaintiffs as against defendant 2nd set so far as the schedule B property
is concerned. This appeal is related only with schedule-B property as
the learned 1st appellate court has already granted relief to the
plaintiffs with respect to schedule-A property as against defendant 1st
set.
27.
This Court finds that no question of law, much less substantial
question of law involved in this 2nd appeal.
28.
Accordingly, this 2nd appeal is dismissed.
29.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, is dismissed as not
pressed.
2026:JHHC:2180
30.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the concerned
courts through “Fax/E-mail”.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
28.01.2026
Rakesh/Uploaded on:- 28th January, 2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review