The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
3. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has drawn attention to Rule 12 Chapter II Part IV of the Bar Council of India Rules of Legal Education, whereunder minimum 70% of classes held 2008, in the concerned subject are required to be attended for appearing in end semester test in the subject. In terms of proviso thereof, if a student for any exceptional reasons ( 2026:HHC:16047 ) fails to attend 70% of the classes held in any subject, discretion is vested in the Competent Authority to allow the student to take the test if the concerned student had attended at least 65% of the classes held in the subject concerned and attended 70% classes in all the subjects taken together. The said rule reads as under:“12. End Semester Test No student of any of the degree program shall be allowed to take the end semester test in a subject if the student concerned has not attended minimum of 70% of the classes held in the subject concerned as also the moot court room exercises, tutorials and practical training conducted in the subject taken together. Provided that if a student for any exceptional reasons fail to attend 70% of the classes held in any subject, the Dean of the University or the Principal of the Centre of Legal Education, as the case may be, may allow the student to take the test if the student concerned attended at least 65% of the classes held in the subject concerned and attend…
4. Admittedly, Akshat Singh had the attendance percentage of 57.29% whereas that of Akshat Ahlawat was 39.88%, out of total classes held in the 7 th semester by the respondent-University. Learned counsel for the respondent- University submitted that aforesaid percentage of the classes attended by both the petitioners has been computed by excluding the lectures which were though held but the petitioners might not have attended on account of their suspension/ late admission. Though no justification has been offered by the respondent- University for not holding all the classes in ( 2026:HHC:16047 ) terms of Clause 10, learned counsel for the respondentUniversity submits that its curriculum is approved by Bar Council of India and therefore, it is not required to hold number of classes in terms of Clause 10 of the aforesaid Rules and the respondent-University is governed by its own set of admission and examination regulations framed under H.P. National Law University Act, 2016. This is disputed by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners. According to learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners, even under the rules and regulations cited by respondent-University as applicable to them, it was required to conduct much more classes that actually held by it. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners further submits that from the provisional list Annexure P-6 dated
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP Nos. 19747 &19748/2025
Decided on: 12.05.2026.
1. CWP No. 19747/2025
Akshat Singh
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P and others
..Respondents
2. CWP No. 19748/2025
Akshit Ahlawat
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P and others
..Respondents
------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the Petitioners:
Mr. N.S. Chandel, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Ankit Dhiman, Advocate.
For the Respondents: Mr. L.N. Sharma, Additional Advocate
General, for respondent No.1.
Mr.
Arjun
Lall,
Advocate,
respondents No. 2 to 4.
for
------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Both
these
writ
petitions
involve
almost
similar questions of law and facts, hence, with consent of
learned counsel for the parties have been taken up
together for adjudication.
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
2.
Petitioners in both these writ petitions are
students of B.A.LL.B.(Hons.) integrated five years course
in respondent- Himachal Pradesh National Law University.
Both the petitioners were
pursuing 7 th Semester in
December,
in CWP No.19747/2025,
2025. Petitioner
Akshat Singh had 57.29% attendance in the semester and
the petitioner in CWP No.19748/2025, Akshit Ahlawat had
39.88% attendance. Due to shortage in the attendance,
the respondent- University did not permit the petitioners
to appear in end-term examination of 7th Semester and
detained them in the 7th Semester in terms of Annexure P8
dated
06.12.2025.
Feeling
aggrieved,
petitioners
instituted these writ petitions.
2(i).
Under interim order passed on 12.12.2025 in
these writ petitions, the petitioners were allowed to
appear in the end-term examination of 7 th Semester held
in December, 2025 subject to their depositing an amount
of ₹50,000/-
each in the
Registry of this Court. Such
permission was not to create any
equity in petitioners’
favour. Further, the respondents were directed not to
declare the result of the petitioners without leave of the
Court. The order reads as under:“Notice in above terms. In the meanwhile,
applicant/petitioner shall be allowed in the 7th
Semester End-Term Examinations commencing
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
from 15.12.2025, subject to his paying an amount
of Rs.50,000/- with the Registry of this Court. It is
clarified that the permission which is being given
to the petitioner to participate in the examination
shall not create any equity in his favour. The result
of the petitioner shall not be declared without the
leave of the Court.”
2(ii).
Pursuant
to
above,
both
the
petitioners
deposited an amount of ₹50,000/- each in the Registry of
this Court and appeared in the end-term examination of
7th Semester. The result of end-term examination
of 7 th
Semester was produced before this Court on 10.03.2026.
In terms of the result, both the petitioners have passed
end-term examination of 7th Semester.
Looking at the
result, petitioners under order dated 20.03.2026 were
allowed to provisionally attend classes of 8th Semester
with the rider that attending classes of 8 th Semester will
not
create
any
rights
or
equities
in
their
favour.
Petitioners’ attending 8th Semester classes was to abide
by the outcome of the main writ petitions.
3.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has
drawn attention to Rule 12 Chapter II Part IV of the Bar
Council
of
India
Rules
of
Legal
Education,
whereunder minimum 70% of classes held
2008,
in the
concerned subject are required to be attended for
appearing in end semester test in the subject. In terms of
proviso thereof, if a student for any exceptional reasons
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
fails to attend 70% of the classes held in any subject,
discretion is vested in the Competent Authority to allow
the student to take the test if the concerned student had
attended at least 65% of the classes held in the subject
concerned and attended 70% classes in all the subjects
taken together. The said rule reads as under:“12. End Semester Test
No student of any of the degree program
shall be allowed to take the end semester test in a
subject if the student concerned has not attended
minimum of 70% of the classes held in the subject
concerned as also the moot court room exercises,
tutorials and practical training conducted in the
subject taken together.
Provided
that
if a student for any
exceptional reasons fail to attend 70% of the
classes held in any subject, the Dean of the
University or the Principal of the Centre of Legal
Education, as the case may be, may allow the
student to take the test if the student concerned
attended at least 65% of the classes held in the
subject concerned and attended 70% of classes in
all the subjects taken on together. The similar
power shall rest with the Vice Chancellor or
Director of a National Law University, or his
authorized representative in the absence of the
Dean of Law.
Provided further that a list of such students
allowed to take the test with reasons recorded be
forwarded to the Bar Council of India.”
Reference was also made to following Rule 10
of the aforesaid Rules to contend that respondentUniversity was required to hold around 400 classes in the
7th Semester. whereas
it had held only 215 classes
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
thereby depriving the petitioners to complete their
attendance:“10. Semester system
The course leading to either degree in law,
unitary or on integrated double degree shall be
conducted in semester system in not less than 15
weeks for unitary degree course or not less than 18
weeks in double degree integrated course with not
less than 30 class-hours per week including
tutorials, moot room exercise and seminars
provided there shall be at least 24 lecture hours
per week.
Provided further that in case of specialized
and/or honours law courses there shall be not less
than 36 class-hours per week including seminar,
moot court and tutorial classes and 30 minimum
lecture hours per week.
Provided further that Universities are free to
adopt trimester system with appropriate division of
courses per trimester with each of the trimester
not less than 12 weeks.”
4.
Admittedly, Akshat Singh had the attendance
percentage of 57.29% whereas
that of Akshat Ahlawat
was 39.88%, out of total classes held in the 7 th semester
by the respondent-University. Learned counsel for the
respondent-
University
submitted
that
aforesaid
percentage
of the classes attended by both the
petitioners has been computed by excluding the lectures
which were though held but
the petitioners might not
have attended on account of their suspension/ late
admission. Though no justification has been offered by the
respondent- University for not holding all the classes in
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
terms of Clause 10, learned counsel for the respondentUniversity submits that its curriculum is approved by Bar
Council of India and therefore, it is not required to hold
number of classes in terms of Clause 10 of the aforesaid
Rules and the respondent-University is governed
by its
own set of admission and examination regulations framed
under H.P. National Law
University Act, 2016.
This is
disputed by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners.
According to learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners,
even
under
the
rules
and
regulations
cited
by
respondent-University as applicable to them, it was
required to conduct much more classes that actually held
by it. Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners further
submits that from the provisional list Annexure P-6 dated
04.12.2025 prepared by the respondents of several
candidates having less than requisite attendance, the
respondents
had
including
petitioners
the
shortlisted only eight candidates
for
detention,
remaining
students were allowed to appear in their respective
examinations. Learned Senior counsel for the petitioners
raised the issue of discrimination allegedly meted out to
the petitioners.
Learned
Senior counsel for the petitioners
placed reliance upon Courts on its own motion in Re:
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
Suicide Committed by Sushant Rohilla, Law Student
of I.P. University versus …….2, more particularly upon
one of the directions issued in para 249 therein to the
effect that “no
student entered in any recognized Law
College, University or institution in India shall be detained
from taking examination or be prevented from further
academic pursuits or career progression on the ground of
lack of minimum attendance.” Reference was also made
to Ms. Muskaan Aamir versus Union of India and
another3, which is
Rohilla2.
primarily
based
upon
Sushant
Attention was also invited to Adarsh Raj
Singh versus
Bar Council of India and others 4.
Learned counsel for the respondent- University submitted
that Adarsh Raj Singh4 was assailed in University of
Delhi
and Others
versus Adarsh
Raj Singh
&
another5 and the Hon’ble Division Bench held therein
that order shall not be treated as a precedent as it was
passed in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this
case based upon undertaking
and concession given by
the University. It has not been disputed
for the
respondents that there were only 215 number of classes
W.P.(CRL)793/2017, decided on 3.11.2025, by Delhi High Court.
W.P.(C) No.13273/2025 & connected matters, decided on 15.01.2026, by
Delhi High Court.
W.P.(C) No.5062/2018 & connected matters, decided on 06.07.2018, by
Delhi High Court.
2018 SCC Online Del 10781
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
held in the 7th Semester. Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners has raised an issue that
such number of
classes in all held by the respondent- University was not
in consonance with applicable Rules & Regulations though
this is very strongly refuted by learned counsel for the
respondents. According
to the respondents, petitioners
did not adhere to the prescribed academic discipline and
no circumstance existed in petitioners’ favour for exercise
of any discretion in their favour. Respondents have inter
alia pleaded that “had the shortage of attendance not
been willful and deliberate, requisite relief would have
been granted to the petitioners.”
Another aspect highlighted by learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioners is about holding of remedial
classes
by
the
respondent-
University
in
similar
circumstances for the students detained in previous years
on account of shortage of lecturers to enable them to
have requisite attendance and absence of any remedial
classes having been held
in the 7th Semester for the
petitioners. Reference in this regard was made to certain
documents on record. Learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners also emphasized that petitioners have already
been permitted
though provisionally to undertake 07 th
Semester end-term examination in terms of interim orders
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
passed
in
these
writ
petitions
subject
to
certain
conditions; The petitioners have fulfilled those conditions
and appeared in the 7th Semester end-term examination
held in December, 2025; The petitioners despite shortfall
in attendance have also passed 7 th Semester end-term
examinations, therefore, the impugned detention orders
in their cases are required to be quashed and set-aside.
Learned counsel for the respondents has
opposed the prayer of the petitioners as also, all the
grounds taken by them. However, at this stage, I am of
the view that since the petitioners had been permitted to
provisionally
undertake the 7th Semester end-term
examination,
which
the
petitioners
have
not
only
undertaken but cleared as well & the petitioner are now
attending classes of 8th Semester, keeping in view the
issues highlighted for the
remedial
classes for
petitioners about absence of
them in 7 th Semester, reliance
placed for the petitioners upon several decisions of
different High Courts as also, the applicable rules position,
ground of discrimination raised by them, interest of
justice will be met
in the given facts of the case if a
direction is issued to respondent- Himachal Pradesh
National Law University to reconsider its decision of
detention of the petitioners in 7th Semester, afresh, and
( 2026:HHC:16047 )
for allowing them to
regularly attend 8th Semester
classes. Ordered accordingly. Fresh decision be taken
expeditiously preferably within four weeks keeping in view
not only applicable rules position but also keeping in mind
the academic interest of the students. The decision so
taken be also intimated to the petitioners. Till such time,
the petitioners be permitted to continue to attend the
classes of 8th Semester.
The writ petition stands disposed of in the
above
terms,
so
also
the
pending
miscellaneous
application(s), if any.
May 12, 2026
yogesh
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review