Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Judgment reserved on: 18.11.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 05.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 09.01.2026
CRL.A. 1039/2025
SAZID
.....Appellant
Through:
Ms. Santosh and Mr. Noor-UlIslam, Advs.
versus
+
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Manoj Pant, APP for the
State.
Mr. Madan Mohan Bora and
Mr. Praveen Kumar, Advs. for
the complainant.
CRL.A. 1043/2025
AKRAM
.....Appellant
Through:
Ms. Santosh and Mr. Noor-UlIslam, Advs.
versus
STATE (NCT OF DELHI)
.....Respondent
Through:
Mr. Manoj Pant, APP for the
State.
Mr. Madan Mohan Bora and
Mr. Praveen Kumar, Advs. for
the complainant.
CORAM:
HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE SWARANA KANTA SHARMA
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
JUDGMENT
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
1.
By way of this judgment, this Court shall be disposing of two
connected criminal appeals preferred by the appellants, seek setting
aside the impugned judgment dated 09.05.2025 and order on sentence
dated 24.05.2025 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge02, Special Judge (NDPS) East District, Karkardooma Court, Delhi
[hereafter „Trial Court‟] in Sessions Case No. 1038/2016, arising out
of FIR bearing No. 423/2012, registered on 11.09.2012, at Police
Station Mandawali, Delhi, for the commission of offence punishable
under Sections 308/325/326/379/34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
[hereafter „IPC‟].
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
Briefly stated, the facts of the present case are that on
10.09.2012, upon receipt of DD No. 53A, HC Arvind along with Ct.
Arun Kumar had reached the spot at E-428, Gali No. 7, West Vinod
Nagar, Delhi, where it was learnt that the injured persons had already
been shifted to LBS Hospital, Khichdipur. At the hospital, MLCs
bearing Nos. 9951/12, 9952/12 and 9953/12 of the injured namely
Mohd. Shahid, Nabi Rasool and Mohd. Jabbar were collected, all
reflecting injuries caused due to assault, some of which were
subsequently opined as grievous, including fractures. The injured
Nabi Rasool gave a statement alleging that on the same evening, after
hearing noise outside his house, he saw his neighbours namely
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
Akram, Rashid, Sazid, along with Akram‟s wife and daughter Heena,
assaulting his son Jabbar. When he and his other son Shahid
intervened, they were also beaten with iron rods, chilli powder was
thrown into their eyes, and Rashid bit Nabi Rasool‟s lower lip,
causing serious injuries. It was alleged that the assailants acted in
furtherance of their common intention and inflicted grievous injuries
on all three victims. On the basis of the said statement, medical
records and circumstances, the present FIR No. 423/12 for
commission of offence under Sections 308/323/325/341/34 of IPC
was registered.
3.
Thereafter, the accused Akram, Rashid and Sazid were
arrested, while co-accused Heena and Sabnam were later granted
anticipatory bail. During the course of investigation, statements of the
injured and other witnesses were recorded, photographs of injuries
were seized, and upon receipt of final medical opinions opining the
injuries as grievous, Sections 324, 326 and 379 of IPC were added.
After completion of investigation, a charge-sheet under Sections
308/325/326/341/379/34 of IPC was filed against the accused
persons. The learned Trial Court, vide order dated 06.08.2014,
framed charges for the offences punishable under Sections
308/326/34 of the IPC against the present appellants Akram and
Sazid, as well as the other co-accused Rashid, Sabnam and Heena.
4.
After conclusion of trial, the learned Trial Court convicted the
appellants for the offence punishable under Section 326 read with
Section 34 of the IPC and sentenced them to undergo rigorous
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
imprisonment for a period of three years, along with payment of fine
of ₹5,000/-. The concluding portion of the impugned judgment is set
out below:
“...15. In view of the nature of punishment awarded to the
convicts and the fact that they have been on bail during trial,
the application are allowed. Convicts Akram, Sazid and Rashid
are admitted to bail on furnishing PB & SB in the sum of Rs.
10,000/- each till the next date in order that they may present
an appeal and obtain the orders from the Appellate Court under
section 389(1) Cr.PC. Bail bonds not furnished. Convicts are
accordingly sent to JC.
16. At this stage, fine of Rs. 5000/- each has been deposited by
the convicts Akram, Sazid and Rashid. Fine of Rs. 5000/- has
also deposited by convict Rashid. The fines imposed upon the
convicts shall be applied for defraying the expenses incurred by
the prosecution.
17. Copy of this order provided free of cost to the convicts.
Copy of this order be sent to Ld. Secretary, DLSA/East/KKD
Courts. A copy of this order be attached with the Jail warrant of
convicts...”
5.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid, the appellants Sazid and Akram
have preferred the present appeals.
SUBMISSIONS BEFORE THE COURT
6.
The learned counsel appearing for the appellant contends that
the impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence suffer
from grave legal and factual infirmities and both are liable to be set
aside. It is argued that the learned Trial Court has misappreciated
both the law and the evidence on record, resulting in a miscarriage of
justice. According to the appellant, the prosecution has failed to
establish its case beyond reasonable doubt, as the testimonies of the
prosecution witnesses are riddled with material contradictions,
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
inconsistencies, embellishments, and improvements from their earlier
statements, rendering them unreliable and unworthy of credence. It is
further submitted that no independent public witness was examined
by the prosecution, despite the incident having allegedly taken place
in a residential locality, and the prosecution case rests solely on
interested witnesses. The learned counsel further submits that the
medical evidence does not corroborate the ocular version, particularly
with respect to the alleged use of red chilli powder, knife, or iron rod,
and the treating doctors who conducted the MLCs were not
examined, with proxy medical witnesses being produced instead. It is
also contended that the photographs relied upon by the prosecution
were not proved in accordance with law and were inadmissible in the
absence of a certificate under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence
Act. The learned counsel emphasizes that there was prior enmity
between the parties, evidenced by earlier complaints and an FIR
registered against the complainant and his sons arising out of the
same incident, which clearly raises the possibility of false
implication, which aspect has been ignored by the Trial Court. It is
further argued that no recovery of any weapon of offence was
effected from the appellant, and the prosecution failed to establish the
charge of theft under Section 379 of IPC against one of the coaccused, leading to acquittal on that count, which, according to the
appellant, undermines the credibility of the entire prosecution case.
The learned counsel for the appellants also points out that their
antecedents are clean and that they have no prior or subsequent
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
criminal involvement. On these grounds, it is prayed that the
impugned judgment and order on sentence be set aside and the
appellants herein be acquitted.
7.
The learned APP for the State, while opposing the appeal,
argues that the impugned judgment of conviction and order on
sentence are well-reasoned, based on a proper appreciation of the
evidence on record, and do not suffer from any illegality, perversity,
or material irregularity warranting interference by this Court. It is
argued that the prosecution has successfully proved its case beyond
reasonable doubt through the consistent and cogent testimonies of the
injured witnesses, whose presence at the spot is undisputed and
whose evidence carries a high probative value in law. The learned
APP submits that the injured witnesses have given a clear and
coherent account of the incident, including the role attributed to each
of the accused persons, and their testimonies have withstood crossexamination. It is further contended that minor discrepancies or
variations in the statements of witnesses are natural and do not affect
the core of the prosecution case, particularly in an incident involving
multiple assailants and serious injuries. The learned APP submits that
medical evidence on record fully corroborates the prosecution
version, in as much as the injuries suffered by the victims have been
opined to be grievous, and the nature and severity of injuries are
consistent with the use of sharp and blunt weapons as alleged. The
non-examination of the treating doctors, it is argued, does not vitiate
the prosecution case, since the MLCs were duly proved by competent
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
medical witnesses and no prejudice has been shown to have been
caused to the accused. The learned APP further submits that nonrecovery of the weapon of offence is not fatal where there is reliable
ocular evidence, especially from injured witnesses, and the learned
Trial Court has rightly relied upon settled principles of law in this
regard. It is also argued that the alleged previous enmity between the
parties does not weaken the prosecution case; rather, it provides a
motive for the commission of the offence. The learned APP
emphasizes that the Trial Court has carefully considered all defence
pleas, including the alleged contradictions, prior complaints, and
acquittal of one co-accused for a separate offence, and has rightly
rejected them with cogent reasons. It is also contended that the
sentence awarded to the appellants is proportionate to the gravity of
the offence and the nature of injuries caused to the victims.
Accordingly, the learned APP prays that the present appeal be
dismissed and the judgment of conviction and order on sentence be
upheld.
8.
This Court has heard arguments addressed by the learned
counsel for the appellant and the learned APP for the State, and has
perused the material available on record.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
9.
This Court notes that eighteen prosecution witnesses were
examined during the course of trial before the learned Trial Court.
The defence, in turn, examined six witnesses before the learned Trial
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
Court, of whom DW-1, DW-2 and DW-3 were material; they were
examined on behalf of the accused, duly cross-examined, and
discharged, whereafter the matter proceeded to final arguments, after
which, the appellants herein were convicted by the learned Trial
Court.
Testimonies of Material Prosecution Witnesses
10.
At the outset, it would be apposite to take note of the
testimonies of the material prosecution witnesses examined before
the learned Trial Court.
11.
This Court notes that the injured-complainant, Nabi Rasool
Mohd., was examined as PW-1 before the learned Trial Court. He has
deposed that he had been residing at the address in question for about
fifteen years and had been employed with Mother Dairy since 1975.
He has stated that on 10.09.2012, at about 9:00 p.m., while he was
present in his house, he heard commotion from outside. Upon
looking from the balcony, he had noticed the accused persons, i.e.
Rashid, Akram, Sazid, Sabnam, and Heena, quarrelling with and
assaulting his son Jabbar. PW-1 identified accused Rashid, Akram,
Sazid, and Sabnam before the learned Trial Court and stated that he
was also able to identify accused Heena, who was not present in
Court at that time; but her identity was not disputed by the learned
defence counsel. PW-1 has further deposed that he had immediately
come down to the lane outside his house to intervene, but the accused
persons had paid no heed and instead caught hold of him and
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
assaulted him as well. He has deposed that accused Sabnam and
Heena had thrown red chilli powder into his eyes and into the eyes of
his son Jabbar. He has further deposed that his other son, Shahid, had
also reached the spot in an attempt to intervene, but he too was
assaulted by the accused persons. According to PW-1, accused Sazid
and Rashid were armed with iron rods and they had inflicted blows
on his head, on Jabbar, and on the legs of Shahid. He has further
stated that despite their cries, the assault continued and that accused
Rashid also bit his lower lip with his teeth.
12.
Mohd. Shahid, who is the son of the complainant Nabi Rasool
Mohd., was examined as PW-2 before the learned Trial Court. He has
deposed that he had been residing at the address for about 7–8 years
and was working as a driver in the year 2012. He has stated that on
10.09.2012, at about 9:30 p.m., upon hearing noise from outside his
house, he had come out and seen the accused persons Rashid, Akram,
Sazid, Sabnam, and Heena assaulting his brother Jabbar and his
father with iron rods and knives. PW-2 identified accused Rashid,
Akram, Sazid, and Sabnam before the learned Trial Court and stated
that he could also identify accused Heena, whose identity was not
disputed by the defence counsel. PW-2 has further deposed that when
he had intervened, chilli powder was thrown into his eyes and
accused Akram had struck him on his right leg with an iron rod,
causing him to fall. He stated that accused Akram had instigated the
others to kill them, while accused Rashid and Sazid had assaulted his
father on the head and chest, and accused Rashid had bit his father on
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
the lip. He has further deposed that a PCR van had arrived at the spot
and the injured persons were taken to LBS Hospital for medical
examination, after which he and Jabbar were treated at Metro
Hospital, Preet Vihar, and his father was admitted to Max Hospital
for plastic surgery. He has stated that he had also suffered multiple
fractures in his leg due to the assault.
13.
This Court further notes that Mohd. Zabbar, who is the second
son of Nabi Rasool, was examined as PW-3 before the learned Trial
Court. He has also deposed that on 10.09.2012, between 9:00 and
10:00 p.m., while returning from his office and parking his car
outside his house, accused Rashid had dragged him out of the vehicle
and assaulted him with a knife, causing injury to his right thigh. He
has stated that accused Akram, his wife Sabnam, and daughter Heena
had then arrived and had thrown red chilli powder into his eyes and
on his body, after which accused Akram had struck his left leg with
an iron rod, causing him to fall. PW-3 has further deposed that
accused Rashid had stolen ₹80,000/- cash from his car, and when his
father and brother Shahid had intervened, they were also assaulted,
chilli powder was thrown in their eyes, and accused Akram, Rashid,
and Sazid had jointly attacked his father, with accused Rashid biting
his father‟s lower lip. He had stated that the PCR had arrived and
taken them to LBS Hospital for medical examination, following
which he and Shahid were treated at Metro Hospital and his father
was admitted to Max Hospital for surgery.
14.
Mohd. Dilshad, third son of the complainant Nabi Rasool, was
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
examined as PW-4 before the learned Trial Court. He has deposed
that on 10.09.2012, while working as a Restaurant General Manager
at a KFC outlet in Sector 18, Noida, he had received a call from his
elder brother Mohd. Shahid around 9:30 p.m., informing him of a
quarrel with neighbours and requesting him to come home
immediately. PW-4 has stated that he thereafter had reached LBS
Hospital, where he had found his father Nabi Rasool and brothers
Mohd. Zabbar and Mohd. Shahid admitted with serious injuries, and
bleeding profusely. He has deposed that he had also taken
photographs of the injured family members using his mobile phone.
15.
PW-5 examined before the learned Trial Court was Sh.
Prakash Dubey, neighbor of the complainant, who has deposed that
on 10.09.2012, at about 9:30 p.m., while returning to his residence
after parking his car, he had reached near his house, where he had
seen accused Rashid, Akram and Sazid assaulting Nabi Rasool and
Shahid. He has stated that he did not initially notice any other persons
participating in the assault and that shortly thereafter a PCR van had
arrived at the spot, following which he had left the spot. PW-5 has
identified accused Akram and Rashid in Court and stated that he
could also identify the remaining accused persons, whose identity
was not disputed by the defence counsel. Since PW-5 resiled from
certain portions of his earlier statement recorded under Section 161 of
Cr.P.C., he was permitted to be cross-examined by the learned APP
of the State. During such cross-examination, PW-5 admitted that
when he had reached the spot near the said house at around 9:00 p.m.,
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
he had seen Akram, Sazid and Rashid along with their women family
members assaulting Nabi Rasool and his family members. He
specifically admitted that he had seen accused Akram beating Shahid
with an iron rod and further acknowledged that Nabi Rasool and his
family members had sustained injuries in the incident. PW-5 also
admitted that his statement was recorded by the police on the
following day.
16.
Another material witness, Smt. Shadab Heena was examined
as PW-7 before the learned Trial Court. She has deposed that on
10.09.2012, at about 9:15–9:30 p.m., upon hearing commotion from
outside, she had come to the balcony of her house and noticed that
their neighbours Rashid, Sazid and Akram (brothers), along with
Sabnam (wife of Akram) and Heena (daughter of Akram), were
assaulting her husband, Mohd. Zabbar. She has further stated that
upon her raising an alarm, her father-in-law Nabi Rasool and brotherin-law Mohd. Shahid had come downstairs to intervene, whereupon
the accused persons had also caught hold of them and assaulted them.
PW-7 has deposed that when she had attempted to intervene, Sabnam
had pushed her, though she did not sustain any visible injury. She has
stated that Rashid was armed with a knife, while Sazid and Akram
were carrying iron rods. She has further deposed that Rashid bit her
father-in-law on the lip with his teeth and also struck him with a
knife, while Sazid and Akram assaulted her husband and brother-inlaw with iron rods. She has further stated that Sabnam and Heena
threw chilli powder into the eyes of her father-in-law and brother-in-
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
law when they attempted to rescue her husband. PW-7 has also
deposed that she had dialled 100 number, pursuant to which a PCR
van had arrived at the spot, and upon noticing the gathering of public
and the PCR, the accused persons had fled. She has further stated that
the PCR officials had taken her husband, father-in-law and brotherin-law to LBS Hospital, and later, when she reached the hospital, her
husband informed her that ₹80,000/- kept in his car had been taken
away by accused Rashid. She had correctly identified Rashid and
Akram in Court and stated that she could also identify Sazid, Sabnam
and Heena.
17.
Dr. M. K. Saxena, Director, Apex Citi Hospital, West Vinod
Nagar, Delhi, was examined as PW-6 before the learned Trial Court.
He has deposed that on 13.09.2012, one patient, Nabi Rasool Mohd.
son of Musafir Ali, was admitted to Apex Citi Hospital. He has
further stated that prior thereto, the said patient had been taken to
LBS Hospital with an alleged history of assault, where MLC No.
9952/12 was prepared, and that the patient had subsequently received
treatment at Max Hospital, I.P. Extension, from where he was
discharged. PW-6 has deposed that upon admission to Apex Citi
Hospital on 13.09.2012, the patient had complained of giddiness and
nausea and remained admitted for a period of about 20 days. On
clinical examination, the patient was found to have multiple abrasions
on the face, both upper limbs, and lower limbs, and had also suffered
facial disfigurement. PW-6 had opined that the nature of the injuries
sustained by the patient was grievous. He has proved his medical
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
opinion dated 26.11.2012, which was furnished at the request of the
Investigating Officer. He also identified a hospital bill bearing No.
1064 dated 04.10.2012, and stated that the same was attested by the
hospital accountant, Sh. Vinod Mehta, whose signatures he identified
on the document.
18.
PW-16 Dr. Vikram Agrawal, Senior Resident (Orthopaedics),
LBS Hospital, Delhi, has deposed that he had been deputed to testify
on behalf of Dr. Arvind, who had left the hospital about 4–5 years
earlier. He has stated that he had worked with Dr. Arvind at LBS
Hospital and was familiar with his handwriting and signatures. He
has proved the medical opinion given by Dr. Arvind on the MLC of
injured Mohd. Shahid, son of Nabi Rasool dated 19.10.2012,
exhibited as Ex. PW16/A. As per the said opinion, a fracture of the
shaft of the tibia (proximal one-third of the leg bone) was observed.
The opinion was based on the X-ray report of the injured, exhibited
as Ex. PW16/B.
19.
PW-17 Dr. Shashwat Dayal, Assistant Medical Superintendent,
Max Hospital, Patparganj, Delhi, has produced the medical record of
patient Nabi Rasool Mohd., who was admitted on 11.09.2012 with an
alleged history of a human bite injury to the lower lip. He has
deposed that the patient was admitted for reconstruction of the lip and
was examined by Dr. Biraj N. Panchaal. He has further stated that on
12.09.2012, the injured underwent reconstruction of the lip with flaps
and was discharged on 13.09.2012. The discharge summary has been
proved as Ex. PW17/A, along with IPD and OPD bills, exhibited as
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
Ex. PW17/B (colly). He has stated that Dr. Biraj N. Panchaal had left
the services of the hospital and that no official presently working at
the hospital could identify her handwriting or signatures. He has
clarified that his deposition was based solely on the hospital records.
20.
PW-18 Dr. S. B. Jangpangi, CMO, LBS Hospital, Khichripur,
Delhi, has deposed that he had been working as a Medical Officer at
LBS Hospital since the year 2000 and had appeared before the Court
on the directions of the Medical Superintendent. He has stated that he
was testifying on behalf of Dr. Ranjeetesh, who had left the hospital
and whose present whereabouts were not known. He has further
stated that he was acquainted with the handwriting and signatures of
Dr. Ranjeetesh, having seen him write and sign during the course of
official duties. He has identified the signatures of Dr. Ranjeetesh on
the MLC of Mohd. Shahid bearing No. 9951/12 (Ex. PW16/A), on
the MLC of Nabi Rasool bearing No. 9952/12 (Ex. PW8/B), and on
the MLC of Mohd. Zabbar bearing No. 9953/12 (Ex. PW8/A).
21.
Therefore, the broad facts and allegations, as emerging from
the prosecution evidence, can be summarised as under:
●
On the night of 10.09.2012, at about 9:00–9:30 PM, a violent
altercation took place outside House No. E-428, Gali No. 7,
West Vinod Nagar, Delhi, involving the accused persons and
the victims‟ family.
●
The accused persons, i.e. Akram, Rashid, Sazid, Sabnam and
Heena, jointly assaulted Mohd. Zabbar, Mohd. Shahid and
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
Nabi Rasool, using iron rods and a sharp-edged weapon, acting
in furtherance of their common intention.
●
Red chilli powder was allegedly thrown into the eyes of the
injured victims to immobilise them.
●
The victim Nabi Rasool sustained grievous injuries, including
severe injury to his lower lip, which later required plastic
surgery, as corroborated by medical records.
●
Mohd. Zabbar and Mohd. Shahid also suffered fractures and
other grievous injuries, necessitating treatment at LBS Hospital
and subsequently at Metro Hospital, Preet Vihar.
●
The assault was witnessed by family members present at the
spot, including the wife of Mohd. Zabbar, who raised an alarm
and informed the police.
●
An independent witness (PW-5) reached the spot during the
incident and saw the accused persons assaulting the victims.
●
Following receipt of information, the PCR van arrived at the
spot, and the injured persons were taken to the hospital for
medical examination and treatment.
22.
Accordingly, this Court is of the view that the prosecution has
prima facie placed on record a clear and consistent chain of events
through the testimonies of the injured victims and the other
witnesses, which stands corroborated by the medical records and
surrounding circumstances.
Statement of Accused Persons
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
23.
Statements under Section 313 of the Cr.P.C. of the appellants
Akram and Sazid were recorded on 13.09.2023 and 16.09.2023
respectively. They stated that they were innocent and had not
committed any offence. No quarrel had taken place between them
and injured persons and they had been falsely implicated in this case.
Accused persons did not prefer to lead defence evidence.
24.
However, later, an application under Section 315 of Cr.P.C.
was moved by the appellant Sazid for leading defence evidence,
which was allowed.
Defence Evidence
25.
This Court notes that Sh. Neeraj Kumar Jain was examined as
DW-1 before the learned Trial Court. He has deposed that he was
running a ready-made garments shop at Vinod Nagar, Mandawali,
and that accused Sazid had been supplying trousers to his shop for
the last about 15 years and used to visit his shop every Monday. He
stated that 10.09.2012 was also a Monday and on that day accused
Sazid had come to his shop to collect payment. He further deposed
that both of them had gone together in the evening between 8:00–
9:00 PM to Dhan Sanchay Society to enquire about opening an
account or availing loan facilities. He stated that accused Sazid did
not come to his shop on the next Monday and he later learnt that
accused Sazid was in custody in connection with the present case.
According to him, accused Sazid subsequently informed him that he
had been falsely implicated in an incident alleged to have occurred
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
during the same time when he was with DW-1.
26.
This Court further notes that the accused/appellant Sazid
examined himself as DW-2 before the learned Trial Court. He has
deposed that he had been engaged in the business of selling readymade trousers and had been supplying garments to the shop of DW-1
for several years, visiting the shop every Monday. He produced a
diary maintained by him reflecting payments received from DW-1,
which was exhibited during trial. He also placed on record documents
relating to his CBSE Open School examination. DW-2 stated that on
10.09.2012, he had gone to the shop of DW-1 to receive payment and
thereafter accompanied him to Dhan Sanchay Society between 8:00–
9:00 PM, and thus was not present at the spot of the alleged incident.
He has further asserted that he had been falsely implicated due to
previous disputes between the complainant side and his brother.
27.
One
Sh.
Abhishek
Pandey,
Manager,
Dhan
Sanchay
Cooperative Bank, was also examined by the defence as DW-3
before the learned Trial Court. He has deposed that he was
summoned as defence witness to produce video footage relating to
the inauguration of the bank and other routine activities. He has
stated that upon verification of the bank records, no video footage of
the inauguration dated 28.07.2012, or of routine activities such as
distribution programmes, was available.
Appreciation of Evidence and the Rival Contentions
28.
While appreciating the oral as well as documentary evidence
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
on record, this Court notes that the prosecution case primarily rests
on the testimonies of PW-1 (Nabi Rasool), PW-2 (Mohd. Shahid) and
PW-3 (Mohd. Zabbar), all of whom are injured witnesses. The law is
well settled that the testimony of an injured witness carries greater
evidentiary value, since such a witness has himself witnessed the
incident/offence in question. This becomes more crucial when the
presence of such witness is proved beyond doubt. The Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in this regard has, in case of Balu Sudam Khalde v.
State of Maharashtra: (2023) 13 SCC 365, held as under:
“26. When the evidence of an injured eye-witness is to be
appreciated, the under-noted legal principles enunciated by the
Courts are required to be kept in mind:
(a) The presence of an injured eye-witness at the time and place
of the occurrence cannot be doubted unless there are material
contradictions in his deposition.
(b) Unless, it is otherwise established by the evidence, it must
be believed that an injured witness would not allow the real
culprits to escape and falsely implicate the accused.
(c) The evidence of injured witness has greater evidentiary
value and unless compelling reasons exist, their statements are
not to be discarded lightly.
(d) The evidence of injured witness cannot be doubted on
account of some embellishment in natural conduct or minor
contradictions.
(e) If there be any exaggeration or immaterial embellishments
in the evidence of an injured witness, then such contradiction,
exaggeration or embellishment should be discarded from the
evidence of injured, but not the whole evidence.
(f) The broad substratum of the prosecution version must be
taken into consideration and discrepancies which normally
creep due to loss of memory with passage of time should be
discarded.”
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
29.
PW-1, 2 and 3 have given a clear, cogent and consistent
account of the incident, describing the manner in which accused
Akram, Sazid and Rashid had assaulted them with iron rods, and
further detailing the role of accused Rashid in biting and avulsing the
lower lip of PW-1. Despite detailed cross-examination, their
testimonies have remained unshaken on all material particulars.
30.
The version of the injured witnesses also finds strong
corroboration from the medical evidence on record. The MLC of
PW-2 Mohd. Shahid (Ex. PW16/A), duly proved through PW-16 and
PW-18, establishes that he suffered a fracture of the proximal shaft of
the tibia, which has been opined to be grievous in nature. The MLC
of PW-1 Nabi Rasool (Mark PW8/B), read with the discharge
summary from Max Hospital (Ex. PW17/A), medical bills (Ex.
PW17/B) and the testimony of PW-6, conclusively proves that PW-1
suffered avulsion of the lower lip and underwent reconstructive
surgery, resulting in facial disfigurement. PW-6 has specifically
opined that the injury suffered by PW-1 was grievous. The learned
Trial Court has rightly held that these documents, when read together,
conclusively establish the nature and seriousness of the injuries.
31.
As regards PW-3 Mohd. Zabbar, his MLC (Mark PW8/A)
records traumatic swelling over the tendon measuring about 2 × 2
cm, tenderness of the thigh, abrasions over the knee, and injury to the
upper lip. Though the prosecution has not led evidence to identify the
handwriting of the doctor who gave the orthopaedic opinion on the
said MLC, the fact remains that PW-18 has duly identified the
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
signatures of the examining doctor on the MLC. More importantly,
the testimony of PW-3 regarding assault by iron rods stands
corroborated by the medical record showing injuries on the person of
PW-3.
32.
The contention raised on behalf of the appellants that PW-16,
PW-17 and PW-18 were not competent witnesses to prove the
medical documents has been rightly rejected by the learned Trial
Court. These witnesses have identified the handwriting and
signatures of the doctors who examined the injured persons and
prepared the MLCs, and have explained that the concerned doctors
had left the hospital and their whereabouts were not available. It is a
settled principle that medical documents can be proved through such
witnesses who are familiar with the handwriting and signatures of the
concerned doctors. The defence also chose not to cross-examine PW18 on this aspect, which further strengthens the prosecution case.
33.
This Court also finds no merit in the argument of the defence
regarding non-recovery of iron rods. It is well settled that nonrecovery of the weapon of offence is not fatal when the prosecution
has led reliable ocular evidence duly corroborated by medical
material. In the present case, the consistent testimonies of the injured
witnesses, supported by the nature, location and extent of injuries,
clearly establish that hard blunt objects were used in the assault. The
learned Trial Court has rightly relied upon this settled position of
law, and also referred to the decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
case of Mekala Sivaiah v. State of A.P.: (2022) 8 SCC 253 wherein
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
it has been held as under:
“26.2. When there is ample ocular evidence corroborated by
medical evidence, mere non-recovery of weapon from the
appellant would not materially affect the case of the
prosecution.”
34.
As regards the plea of alibi raised by appellant-accused Sazid,
the same has also been rightly rejected by the learned Trial Court.
The defence witnesses DW-1 and DW-2 (appellant himself) have
merely made oral assertions regarding the presence of Sazid
elsewhere, without producing any documentary evidence or
examining any independent witness from the alleged place. Even
DW-3 has stated that no video footage of the relevant date was
available. On the contrary, PW-3 has specifically stated that accused
Sazid joined the assault later, and PW-5, an independent public
witness, has also seen accused Sazid participating in the assault. In
these circumstances, the plea of alibi remains unsubstantiated and
unreliable.
35.
Moreover, although some witnesses have made reference to the
use of a knife, the medical evidence does not show any stab injury.
However, this discrepancy does not affect the core of the prosecution
case. The consistent and reliable version of the injured witnesses
regarding assault with iron rods and the grievous injuries caused
thereby is fully supported by the medical evidence. The learned Trial
Court has thus rightly held, inter alia, that the prosecution has proved
beyond reasonable doubt that appellants Akram and Sazid, alongwith
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
co-accused Rashid, acting in furtherance of their common intention,
caused grievous injuries to the injured persons. This Court finds no
reason to take a different view on the appreciation of evidence.
36.
Having observed so, this Court also concurs with the view
taken by the learned Trial Court that the evidence on record, when
read as a whole, does not disclose the requisite intention or
knowledge necessary to sustain a conviction under Section 308 of the
IPC.
37.
However, the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt
that the accused persons/appellants, acting in furtherance of their
common intention, caused grievous injuries to the victims, thereby
attracting the offence punishable under Section 326 of the IPC. The
nature of the injuries suffered, including the fracture of the right leg
of PW-2 Mohd. Shahid as established by MLC No. 9951/12 (Ex.
PW16/A) read with the X-ray report (Ex. PW16/B), and the serious
traumatic injuries sustained by PW-3 Mohd. Zabbar as recorded in
his MLC (Mark PW8/A) – all caused by use of iron rods – squarely
bring the case against the appellants Sazid and Akram within the
ambit of Section 326/34 of the IPC. The conviction of the appellants
Akram and Sazid for the offence under Section 326 of IPC is,
therefore, fully justified.
38.
Upon a comprehensive consideration of the entire evidence
available on record, this Court is of the considered view that the
findings recorded by the learned Trial Court are well-reasoned and
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
based on a correct appreciation of both facts and law. The impugned
judgment does not suffer from any perversity, illegality or material
infirmity. The prosecution has successfully established the guilt of
the appellants beyond reasonable doubt.
39.
Accordingly, this Court finds no ground to interfere with either
the judgment of conviction or the order on sentence passed by the
learned Trial Court. The conviction and sentence of the appellants
under Section 326 read with Section 34 of the IPC are hereby upheld.
40.
As regards the order on sentence, this Court notes that the
offence under Section 326 of the IPC is punishable with
imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for
a term which may extend to ten years, along with fine. In the present
case, the learned Trial Court has awarded a sentence of three years‟
rigorous imprisonment, which is well within the statutory limits and
cannot be said to be excessive or disproportionate, having regard to
the nature of the injuries caused and the role attributed to the
appellants. The sentence awarded is thus reasonable and calls for no
interference by this Court.
41.
The present appeals sans any merit are accordingly dismissed.
42.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
DR. SWARANA KANTA SHARMA, J
JANUARY 05, 2026/zp
T.S./T.D.
CRL.A. 1039/2025 & connected matter
Digitally Signed
By:ZEENAT PRAVEEN
18:17:23
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review