Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:HHC:28771
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH,
SHIMLA
CWP No. 11479/2024 a/w connected matters
Decided on: 15.07.2026
1.
CWP No. 11479/2024
Satuti & Ors.
…..Petitioners
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
2.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 11213/2024
Priyansha
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
3.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 11724/2024
Swastik
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
4.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 11771/2024
Janesha Sharma
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
5.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 11774/2024
Aishika Verma
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
6.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 11775/2024
Edha Mehra
…..Petitioner
( 2026:HHC:28771
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
7.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 11988/2024
Shradha Thakur
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
8.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 12228/2024
Priya Verma & Anr.
…..Petitioners
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
9.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 12229/2024
Hardik Tank
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
10.
.....Respondents
CWP No. 14286/2024
Suchi Thakur
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
11.
.....Respondents
CWP No.14366/2024
Akhilesh Thakur
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P. & Ors.
.....Respondents
………………………………………………………………………………
Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
( 2026:HHC:28771
For the petitioners:
Mr. Vinay Sharma & Mr. Pawan K.
Sharma, Advocates, for the
petitioners in the respective
petitions.
For the respondents:
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General
with Ms. Seema Sharma, Deputy
Advocate
General,
for
the
respondents-State
in
all
the
petitions.
Mr. Bhuvesh Sharma, Sr. Advocate
with Mr. Rupesh Kumar, Mr. Shekhar
Badola, Mr. Parav Sharma Mr. Rahul
Mahajan, Mr.
Arhant
Mahajan,
Mr. Pankaj Choudhri, Mr. Shashi
Bhushan and
Mr. Sandeep K.
Pandey, Advocates,
for
the
respective respondents in the
respective petitions.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua, J.
These writ petitions involve common questions of law and
overlapping facts, hence, for the said reason, they were connected.
With the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the matters
have been taken up together for the purpose of their adjudication.
(i)
For convenience, reference hereinafter is made to the
facts of CWP No. 11479 of 2024 (Satuti & Ors. v. State of H.P. &
Ors.). The said petition has been filed for the grant of the following
substantive reliefs: “A.
That the Annexure P-7 may be quashed in the interest of
justice.
B.
The respondents may kindly be directed to initiate fresh
counseling of MBBS seats after identifying the candidates who have
( 2026:HHC:28771
more than one State Domicile and further respondents be directed to
cancel the seats allotted to these candidates.
C.
That the petitioners may kindly be consider for State Quota of
85% in MBBS course as per result dated 26.7.2024 by allowing them
participate in the selection process.
D.
That the respondents may be directed to form Special
Investigation Team (SIT) for the purpose of scrutinizing and verifying
the credentials of the selected candidates in MBBS seats throughout
the Medical Colleges in the State of Himachal Pradesh.”
(ii)
Somewhat similar reliefs have been prayed for in CWP
No. 11213/2024 (Priyansha Vs. State of H.P. & Ors.) : “i)
That the respondents may kindly be directed to identify the
candidates who have more than one domicile and have applied for
admission under State quota in different States using different
domiciles.
(ii)
That the respondents may kindly be directed to register FIR
against the candidates who have filed false affidavit before them
claiming that they have not applied in other States under State quota
of that State.
(iii)
That the respondents may kindly be directed to cancel the
seats allotted to the candidates who have applied for State quota in
different States and the cancel seat may kindly be offered to the
petitioner.
(iv)
That SIT may kindly be constituted to identify the candidates
who have sought double benefits of domicile certificate in State of
Himachal Pradesh and in other States in the interest of justice and
fair play.
(v) That the respondents may kindly be directed to decide the
representations (Annexure P-4 and Annexure P-6) and directed to
take action on these representations in the interest of justice and fair
play.”
( 2026:HHC:28771
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties & considered the
case file.
2(i)
Respondent No.4-Atal Medical & Research University,
H.P. issued a Common/Centralized Counselling Prospectus for
admission to MBBS & BDS Courses on the basis of merit in NEETUG-2022 (Session 2022-23). Clause 2 of Chapter (IV) of the
prospectus provided specific criteria for eligibility of candidates for the
State quota seats. One of the conditions prescribed therein was that
the children of Bonafide Himachalis, who had passed at least two
examinations (out of Middle or equivalent/Matric or equivalent/10+1 or
equivalent/10+2 or equivalent) from recognized schools or colleges
situated in the State and affiliated to Boards/Universities established
by law in India, would be eligible. For the session 2024-25, the above
criteria was changed by respondent No.4-University. In terms of the
prospectus
issued
for
session
2024-25,
bonafide
Himachali
students/children of Bonafide Himachalis, irrespective of their place of
schooling, were eligible for the State quota seats for admission to
MBBS/BDS courses on the basis of merit in NEET-UG-2024.
These petitions are mainly concerned with admissions for
session 2024-25. Petitioners' grievance is that they qualified the NEET
examination but were not able to secure seats under the 85% State
quota, whereas private candidates in all these petitions, from outside
the State, who have domicile of more than one State, have been able
( 2026:HHC:28771
to secure State quota seats in the State of Himachal Pradesh on
account of their being bonafide Himachalis.
2(ii)
Learned counsel for the petitioners have submitted that, in
terms of Clause VI(xii) of Chapter IV of the Prospectus for session
2024-25, the candidates were required to furnish affidavits (format at
Appendix-15 of the prospectus) to the effect that the advantage of the
domicile State was being availed by them only in the State of Himachal
Pradesh and nowhere else; That the affidavits furnished by the private
respondents in terms of Appendix-15 read with Clause VI(xii) were
false, as the private respondents had availed the benefit of the
Domicile State in more than one State, including the State of Himachal
Pradesh; That respondent No.4-University has not been vigilant
enough in identifying such candidates like the private respondents,
who, on the basis of their false affidavits, have been permitted to
secure admission against the State quota in the State of Himachal
Pradesh.
During hearing of the case, learned counsel for the
petitioners in CWP No. 11479 of 2024 further submitted that
respondent No. 4-University, in the prospectus issued for the session
2025–26 onwards, has again incorporated the eligibility condition
requiring the candidate to have passed at least two examinations out
of Middle, Matric, 10+1 or 10+2 from recognized schools/colleges
situated in the State of Himachal Pradesh. In view thereof, learned
( 2026:HHC:28771
counsel submitted that the prayers made in the aforesaid petition in
relief clauses A, B and C have been rendered infructuous and that
prayer in this writ petition is now confined only to seek direction to the
respondents to constitute a Special Investigation Team (SIT) for
scrutinizing and verifying the credentials of the candidates selected to
MBBS seats in the Medical Colleges in the State of Himachal Pradesh.
Learned counsel for the petitioners in CWP No. 11213 of
2024, however, insisted upon all the reliefs claimed in their petition.
2(iii)
The defence of the private respondents is almost similar in
all the petitions. For the sake of convenience, the stand taken by
respondent No. 5 in CWP No. 11479 of 2024 is referred to hereinafter.
Baba Farid University of Health Sciences (BFUHS),
Faridkot, Punjab, issued a prospectus on 09.08.2024 for admission to
the MBBS course in the State of Punjab for the academic session
2024-25. Respondent No. 5, being a bona fide Himachali and also
holding the domicile of the State of Punjab, after passing 10+2
examination, got himself registered with BFUHS on 11.08.2024 for
admission in the State of Punjab. Four days later, i.e. on 15.08.2024,
respondent No. 4-University issued its prospectus for admission to the
MBBS course for session 2024-25. As per the eligibility criterion laid
down therein, respondent No. 5, being a bonafide Himachali, was
eligible for State quota seat in terms of the prospectus. Accordingly, he
registered himself with respondent No. 4-University on 18.08.2024.
( 2026:HHC:28771
On the basis of his registration with BFUHS, name of
respondent No. 5 was included in the merit list of BFUHS published on
23.08.2024. The said University sought the choice of respondent No. 5
to proceed further with the admission process. Respondent No. 5 did
not exercise the said choice, as he had already registered himself with
respondent No. 4-University on 18.08.2024. Respondent No. 4University released its merit list on 23.08.2024. Respondent No. 5
exercised his choice for admission in the State of Himachal Pradesh
on 29.08.2024 and, consequently, participated in different rounds of
counselling, pursuant to which he was finally allocated a seat in Shri
Lal Bahadur Shastri Government Medical College & Hospital
(SLBSGMCH), Ner Chowk, Mandi, Himachal Pradesh, on 27.09.2024.
3.
The reply filed by respondent No.4-Atal Medical &
Research University, H.P. clearly indicates that, in terms of the
eligibility criteria prescribed in the Prospectus for the session 2024-25,
bonafide Himachali students, irrespective of their place of schooling,
were eligible for the State quota seats in the State of Himachal
Pradesh. In view of this eligibility condition, it was not incumbent upon
the respondents to ascertain whether the candidates, having more
than one domicile, had applied for admission under the State quota in
the respondent-State. No clause in the Prospectus prohibited the
bonafide Himachali candidates, also possessing the domicile of any
other State from registering for admission in other State. In terms of
( 2026:HHC:28771
the Prospectus for the session 2024-25, the Government of Himachal
Pradesh had decided to allow all bonafide Himachali candidates to
participate in the admission process in Himachal Pradesh under the
State quota, irrespective of place of their schooling. The only eligibility
criterion being the requirement that they should be bonafide
Himachalis. Respondent No.4-University has also gone on to submit
that, in view of the main eligibility conditions prescribed in Clause 2(i)
of Chapter IV of the Prospectus for the session 2024-25, the
procedural condition imposed in Clause VI(xii) of the Prospectus,
requiring affidavit from the candidates that the advantage of the
domicile State had been taken only in the State of Himachal Pradesh
and nowhere else, was redundant. The said clause was an oversight
and irrelevant, as it was not supported by any clause relating to the
eligibility and qualification criteria published in the Prospectus. In terms
of Clause 2(i) of Chapter IV of the Prospectus, bonafide Himachali
candidates were eligible for admission to the Medical & Dental
courses. It has also been pleaded in the reply that registration alone in
any other State neither guaranteed admission nor prohibited the
candidate from admission in respondent-State under the Prospectus
issued by respondent No.4 for the session 2024-25. The registration of
the private respondents in BFUHS was only an indication that such
candidates were eligible to participate in the counselling process for
securing a seat. The candidates were further required to participate in
( 2026:HHC:28771
the choice-filling and seat allocation process. It is only thereafter that
admission could be secured by them in the said university. It will be in
place to extract the stand of respondent No.4-University: 3.
That it is respectfully submitted that the petitioners had
claimed that the respondents have to identify the candidates who
have more than one domicile and applied for admission under state
quota in different states but there is no reason for counseling
committee to do so. No clause in prospectus prohibits candidate to
possess domicile of other state or to apply for counseling in other
states. The Govt. of Himachal Pradesh had decided to allow all
Bonafide Himachali candidates to participate in the counselling of
Himachal Pradesh under state quota irrespective of their schooling.
There is no direction that if a candidate is in possession of domicile
of any other state, or if a candidate has registered for the counseling
of any other state, then he/she becomes ineligible for admission in
Himachal Pradesh. It is also reiterated that the eligibility for seat
allocation in Himachal Pradesh is on the basis of Bonafide Himachali
status irrespective of the domicile status of the candidate.
4.
That it is respectfully submitted that there is a provision in the
clause VI and sub clause (xii) of the prospectus that "Affidavit on
plain paper indicating that the advantage of Domicile State is being
taken in Himachal Pradesh only and nowhere else as per specimen
attached at Appendix-15". The point (iii) appendix-15 reads as "that
the advantage of Domicile State is being taken in Himachal Pradesh
only and nowhere else". Copy of Appendix 15 (Specimen of Affidavit)
is being annexed herewith as Annexure R-4/B for the kind perusal of
this Hon'ble Court. This clause is an oversight and may be
considered unintentional and irrelevant because this clause is not
supported by any clause in the "Eligibility and Qualifications" criterion
published in the prospectus. As described in point no.2 only Bonafide
Himachali are eligible for admission in medical and dental courses
and not the candidates who possess a Domicile Certificate of
Himachal Pradesh, so a candidate cannot take advantage of domicile
state of Himachal Pradesh for admission in Himachal Pradesh. It is
( 2026:HHC:28771
also informed that the online counselling process is designed as a
multi-step process that is completed in multiple rounds. The process
starts with registration of candidate, followed by the publication of the
merit list. The process culminates in the seat allocation and
admission
of
the
candidate.
Under
no
circumstances does
registration alone guarantee admission, it is just an indication that the
candidate is eligible to participate in the counseling process. For
securing a seat the candidates must further participate in the choice
filling and seat allocation processes, after which admission is
granted. Thus, in a multistep process, word counseling represents
the process of choice filling for allocation of seat and subsequent
seat allocation. It is important to note that while a candidate may
register for counselling in multiple states, it is only upon allocation of
a seat and subsequent admission that the advantage of a domicile
certificate is realized. The registration process, by itself, does not
imply that a candidate has taken undue advantage of the domicile
state unless they are granted admission in more than one state
under the respective state quotas. The claim of the petitioners that
the respondents have to identify the candidates who have more than
one domicile and applied for admission under state quota in different
states is not justified because the replying respondent No.4 does not
have any mechanism to find out whether a candidate is participating
in the allocation process in one or more states and there is no clause
in the prospectus that prohibits a candidate from applying in other
states or to remove the candidate from counselling because he/she
possesses the domicile of any other state. The point no.3 of the
Appendix 15 was inserted with a specific purpose to prevent blocking
of the seats by the candidates in more than one state. Now this
purpose is served by a National Portal developed by the MCC on the
direction of Hon'ble Supreme Court that contains information about
the candidates admitted in different states but point no.3 of appendix15 was overlooked though it had become irrelevant when the
National Portal became functional.
5.
That it is important to bring to the kind notice of this Hon'ble
Court
that
now
the
Medical
Counseling
Committee/DGHS,
Government of India has developed a National Portal that contains
( 2026:HHC:28771
data of admitted candidates in different states. This information is
used to eliminate the candidates who are admitted in any state, from
the list of allocation for the stray round. It is humbly submitted that
the replying respondent No.4 is not aware of admission of any
candidate who was admitted in any other state under state quota and
admitted in Himachal Pradesh also in the same round of counseling.
It is further reiterated that if the candidate provides documents that
makes him/her eligible for allocation under State Quota, the
counselling committee cannot remove him/her from the allocation list
if his/her name reflects in the merit list of other states because
inclusion of name in the merit list does not prove that the candidate
has participated in the seat allocation process in that state by taking
advantage of the domicile as described in point no.4. It is also
important to mention here that registration for counseling is a onetime process and usually there is no mechanism to delete the names
from the state merit list on request and if a candidate does not want
to participate in the counseling process, he/she can do so by not
filling the choices for allocation. So, a candidate may be said to have
taken advantage of the domicile state if he/she secures a seat in any
state and he/she was eligible for admission because of the domicile
certificate only. The name of candidate is removed from the
allocation list only in the stray round if that candidate is also allocated
seat under the All-India quota in 3rd round or if the candidate is found
admitted in any state in any of the earlier rounds.”
Based upon terms & conditions in the prospectus issued
for academic session 2024-25, respondent No.4 has taken a categoric
stand that if a candidate was domicile of any other State or if a
candidate had registered for counselling in any other State, he/she did
not become ineligible for admission in State of Himachal Pradesh.
Registration alone does not guarantee admission. Registration
indicates eligibility of candidate to participate in the counselling
( 2026:HHC:28771
process. For securing admission, candidate must further participate in
the choice filling & seat allocation process. Only upon allocation of seat
& subsequent admission, advantage of domicile certificate is realized.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for all private respondents are
consistent in their submissions that these respondents had only
registered with the Medical Universities of the other States based upon
the terms & conditions of the Prospectuses issued by the other States.
They had not availed the choice-filling option consequent upon
registration in the different Medical Universities of the other States.
After their registration with respondent No.4-University, they had
participated only in the admission process carried out by respondent
No.4-University. They never participated in the counselling or secured
seats in any other Medical University of different States. This factual
position has not been disputed by respondent No.4-University. It will
also be prudent to note of further pleadings of respondent no.4University regarding credentials/certificates of private respondents: -
“7.
That it is respectfully submitted that the counselling
committee is constituted by Government of Himachal Pradesh to
ensure that the eligible candidates as per the eligibility criteria
decided by the Government of Himachal Pradesh are admitted
according to their merit and Quota/Category in MBBS and BDS
courses. As per various provisions of Chapter VIII, the admission
committee are constituted at the Institute level under the
Chairmanship of the Principals of the Institutes, who verify the
original documents of the candidates before admission of
( 2026:HHC:28771
candidates. It is worthwhile to mention here that the respondent
No.4 did not receive any communication from any institute that the
documents of any candidates are incorrect or fake. It is humbly
submitted that on receipt of complaint from the candidates through
email, the replying respondent replying respondent.
No.4
immediately issued directions to all the Principals of the Medical
and Dental Colleges to provide the details of those candidates,
who are Bonafide Himachali, but have not studied in Himachal
Pradesh. It is pertinent to mention here that the list of such
candidates is provided by the institutes after completion of the
process of the admission. It is further respectfully submitted that
the replying respondent No.4 apprised the Director, Medical
Education and Research, Shimla, the Chairman of the Counselling
Committee and requested him to constitute a committee to look
into the matter and now a committee has been constituted to
inquire whether any actionable mistake has been committed by
these candidates.
8.
That it is respectfully submitted that now the process of
admission has been completed and the list of admitted candidates
has been uploaded on the NMC Portal by the institutes, i.e., all the
candidates have been verified and not admitted in more than_one
college in India. All the candidates have submitted their affidavits
at the time of admission in the concerned institute. Hence, in view
of the detailed submissions made hereinabove, the Civil Writ
Petition filed by the petitioners, being devoid of any merit,
deserves to be dismissed.”
There is nothing of substance on record from the
petitioners to controvert the above stand. Given this factual position,
the reliefs of the nature prayed for cannot be granted to the petitioners.
In view of the above, no case for interference is made out.
Accordingly, the petitions are dismissed.
( 2026:HHC:28771
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stand
disposed
accordingly.
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
15th July, 2026 (rohit)
of
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review