Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
CWP-38698-2025
Date of decision: 21.01.2026
Akashdeep Kaur and others
....Petitioners
Versus
State of Punjab and others
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present:
Dr. Rau P.S. Girwar, Advocate,
Ms. Archana Rau, Advocate and
Ms. K.T. Rau, Advocate
for the petitioners.
Mr. Vikas Arora, DAG, Punjab.
HARPREET SINGH BRAR, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present civil writ petition has been filed under Articles 226
and 227 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ in the nature of
certiorari for quashing the entire recruitment process conducted pursuant to
Advertisement No.6 of 2023 (Annexure P-1), including the written examination
held on 28.01.2024, the result declared on 12.08.2024, and the subsequent
typing test conducted from 01.12.2025 to 02.12.2025. The petitioner further
seeks issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus directing respondent No.2
to conduct a fresh, fair, and transparent recruitment examination for all posts
advertised under Advertisement No.6 of 2023; directing respondents No.1 to 3
to publish the Judicial Inquiry Report; directing respondent No.5 or any other
independent investigating agency to register an FIR and conduct a thorough
investigation into the recruitment scam, including allegations of paper leakage,
mass copying, and the involvement of officials and private individuals; and
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
directing respondent No.2 to initiate appropriate disciplinary as well as criminal
proceedings against the tainted candidates and officials involved in the said
malpractices.
2.
Learned State counsel has produced the inquiry report dated
24.06.2025 prepared by a retired Judge of this Court, in the original, in a
sealed cover before this Court today. The sealed cover is opened in Court and
the report is taken on record. The Registry is directed to tag the same at the
appropriate place in the case file.
CONTENTIONS
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioners, inter alia, contends that the
petitioners participated in the selection process initiated for recruitment to 184
posts of Senior Assistant-cum-Inspector pursuant to Advertisement No.06 of
2023 (Annexure P-1). The result of the said selection process was declared on
12.08.2024 (Annexure P-2). Shortly thereafter, the petitioners, along with other
candidates, noticed that the OMR answer sheets of the top 44 rank-holders
were circulating on Telegram and other social media platforms (Annexures P-3
to P-6), disclosing striking similarities in the answer patterns. On 11.11.2024,
some of the petitioners submitted representations to the authorities and also
participated in large-scale protests, alleging serious irregularities in the conduct
of the examination. Subsequently, the respondent-Board decided to initiate a
judicial inquiry to ascertain the fairness and transparency of the selection
process. In furtherance thereof, on 16.06.2025, as discernible from Annexure P8, the petitioners were directed to appear before the Inquiry Officer for a
personal hearing. Thereafter, a legal representation dated 02.09.2025
(Annexure P-9) was also submitted, seeking a fair, independent, and impartial
probe into the recruitment process.
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
4.
Despite the representations submitted by the petitioners, the
respondents proceeded to conduct the typing test on 01.12.2025 and 02.12.2025
with a view to finalising the recruitment process. Learned counsel for the
petitioners further draws the attention of this Court to the comparative chart
(Annexure P-20) and submits that the petitioners have compiled the data
pertaining to the top 43 candidates and a striking similarity in the incorrect
answers to the questions attempted by them is evident. It is contended that
although the same questions were placed at different serial numbers across the
four sets of question papers, an unusual and conspicuous uniformity in the
incorrect responses is apparent, which raises serious doubts regarding the
sanctity of the examination. Further, the petitioners claim that the answer sheets
were initially left blank and were subsequently filled in a coordinated manner.
This is further buttressed by the fact that out of the said 43 candidates, as many
as 17 belong to the same district. Further, learned counsel further refers to the
inquiry report prepared by a retired Judge of this Court and submits that the
conclusions drawn therein are factually erroneous and unsustainable in light of
the material on record.
5.1.
In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the petitioners
places reliance upon the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
‘Tanvi Sarwal Vs. Central Board of Secondary Education and others’
2015(6) SCC 573, which reads as under:
“20. As would be available from the status reports, out of
123 solved answers of a particular code and retrieved from the
mobile set of one of the persons arrested i.e. Dr Bhupender, 102
answers were found correct on a comparison with the answer
key provided by CBGE. AS referred to hereinabove, 358 mobile
numbers had been pressed into service and at least 300 vests
fitted with electronic devices have been used. Having regard to
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the uncompromising essentiality of a blemishless process of
examination involving public participation, we have no
alternative but to hold that the examination involved, suffers
from an infraction of its expected requirement of authenticity
and credence. We are conscious of the fact that every
examination being conducted by a human agency is likely to
suffer from some shortcomings, but deliberate inroads into its
framework of the magnitude and the nature, as exhibited, in the
present case, demonstrate a deep-seated and pervasive impact,
which ought not to be disregarded or glassed over, lest it
may amount to travesty of a proclaimed mechanism to
impartially judge the comparative merit of the candidates
partaking therein. If such an examination is saved, merit would
be a casualty generating a sense of frustration in the genuine
students, with aversion to the concept of examination. The
possibility of leaning towards unfair means may also be the
ultimate fallout. Even if, one undeserving candidate, a
beneficiary of such illegal machination, though undetected is
retained in the process it would be in denial of the claim of more
deserving candidates. At present, the examination stands
denuded of its sanctity as it is not possible to be cleansed of all
the participating beneficiary candidates with certainty. We are
thus, on an overall assessment of the materials on record, left
unpersuaded to sustain the examination. We must observe that
till this stage of the Investigation, no conscious lapse or
omission on the part of the Board, contributing to the otherwise
appalling mischief has surfaced.”
5.2.
Learned counsel for the petitioners further relies upon the
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘Sachin Kumar and others Vs.
Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board (DSSSB) and others’ (2021) 4
SCC 631, wherein the following was observed:
“35. In deciding this batch of SLPs, we need not reinvent
the wheel. Over the last five decades, several decisions of this
Court have dealt with the fundamental issue of when the process
of an examination can stand vitiated. Essentially, the answer to
the issue turns upon whether the irregularities in the process
have taken place at a systemic level so as to vitiate the sanctity
of the process. There are cases which border upon or cross over
into the domain of fraud as a result of which the credibility and
legitimacy of the process is denuded. This constitutes one end of
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the spectrum where the authority conducting the examination or
convening the selection process comes to the conclusion that as
a result of supervening event or circumstances, the process has
lost its legitimacy, leaving no option but to cancel it in its
entirety. Where a decision along those lines is taken, it does not
turn upon a fact -finding exercise into individual acts involving
the use of malpractices or unfair means. Where a recourse to
unfair means has taken place on a systemic scale, it may be
difficult to segregate the tainted from the untainted
participants in the process. Large-scale irregularities including
those which have the effect of denying equal access to similarly
circumstanced candidates are suggestive of a malaise which has
eroded the credibility of the process. At the other end of the
spectrum are cases where some of the participants in the process
who appear at the examination or selection test are guilty of
irregularities. In such a case, it may well be possible to
segregate persons who are guilty of wrongdoing from others
who have adhered to the rules and to exclude the former from
the process. In such a case, those who are innocent of
wrongdoing should not pay a price for those who are actually
found to be involved in irregularities. By segregating the
wrongdoers, the selection of the untainted candidates can be
allowed to pass muster by taking the selection process to its
logical conclusion. This is not a mere matter of administrative
procedure but as a principle of service jurisprudence it finds
embodiment in the constitutional duty by which public bodies
have to act fairly and reasonably. A fair and reasonable process
of selection to posts subject to the norm of equality of
opportunity under Article 16(1) is a constitutional requirement.
A fair and reasonable process is a fundamental requirement of
Article 14 as well. Where the recruitment to public employment
stands vitiated as a consequence of systemic fraud or
irregularities, the entire process becomes illegitimate. On the
other hand, where it is possible to segregate persons who have
indulged in malpractices and to penalise them for their
wrongdoing, it would be unfair to impose the burden of their
wrongdoing on those who are free from taint. To treat the
innocent and the wrongdoers equally by subjecting the former to
the consequence of the cancellation of the entire process would
be contrary to Article 14 because unequals would then be
treated equally. The requirement that a public body must act in
fair and reasonable terms animates the entire process of
selection. The decisions of the recruiting body are hence subject
to judicial control subject to the settled principle that the
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
recruiting authority must have a measure of discretion to take
decisions in accordance with law which are best suited to
preserve the sanctity of the process. Now it is in the backdrop of
these principles, that it becomes appropriate to advert to the
precedents of this Court which hold the field.”
5.3.
Finally, reliance is also placed upon the judgment rendered by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vanshika Yadav Vs. Union of India and others’
W.P. (C) No. 335 of 2024., wherein the following was held:
“11. We proceed to record the essential conclusions in the
following terms:
(i) The fact that a leak of the NEET (UG) 2024 paper took place
at Hazaribagh in the State of Jharkhand and at Patna in the
State of Bihar is not in dispute;
(ii) Following the transfer of the investigation to it, the CBI has
filed its status reports dated 10 July 2024, 17 July 2024 and 21
July 2024. The disclosures by the CBI indicate that the
investigation is continuing. The CBI has indicated that at the
present stage, the material which has emerged during the course
of the investigation would indicate that about 155 students
drawn from the examination centres at Hazaribagh and Patna
appear to be the beneficiaries of the fraud;
(iii) Since the investigation by the CBI has not attained finality
at the present point of time, this Court had in its previous order
required the Union Government to indicate whether trends in
regard to the existence of abnormalities can be deduced through
data analytics on the basis of the results emanating from 4,750
centres situated in 571 cities. Pursuant to the directions of the
Court, the Union Government has produced a report of Indian
Institute of Technology, Madras. The objection of the petitioners
to the report of IIT, Madras on the grounds of alleged bias
would be considered in the course of the reasoned judgment
which will follow. At this stage, in order to obviate any
controversy, the Court has independently scrutinized the data
which has been placed on the record by the NTA:
(iv) At the present stage, there is an absence of material on the
record to lead to the conclusion that the entire result of the
examination stands vitiated or that there was a systemic breach
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
in the sanctity of the examination;
(v) Added to the absence of conclusive material on the record at
the present stage, the data which has been produced on
the record city-wise and centre-wise and the comparison of data
for the years 2022, 2023 and 2024 are not indicative of a
systemic leak of the question paper impacting the sanctity of the
examination;
(vi) In arriving at the ultimate conclusion, the Court is guided by
the well-settled test of whether it is possible to segregate tainted
students from those whose candidature does not suffer from any
taint. If the investigation reveals the involvement of an increased
number of beneficiaries over and above those who are suspects
at the present stage, action shall be pursued against every
student found to be involved in wrong doing at any stage,
notwithstanding the completion of the counselling process. No
student who is revealed to have engaged in acts of fraud or to
have been the beneficiary of malpractice would be entitled to
claim a vested right or interest in the continuation of the
admission in the future by virtue of the findings in this judgment;
and
(vii) Directing a fresh NEET (UG) to be conducted for the
present year would be replete with serious consequences for
over two million students who have appeared in the
examination. Adopting such a course of action would, in
particular, (i) lead to a disruption of the admission schedule for
the commencement of medical courses, setting back the entire
process by several months; (ii) lead to cascading effects on the
course of medical education; (iii) impact the availability of
qualified medical professionals in the future; and (iv) cause a
serious element of disadvantage to students belonging to
marginalized communities and weaker sections for whom
reservation has been made in the allocation of seats.”
6.
Per contra, learned State counsel submits that the claims of the
petitioners pertain to disputed questions of fact, which have already been
thoroughly examined pursuant to a detailed inquiry conducted by a retired
Judge of this Court. Moreover, the inquiry report dated 24.06.2025 upheld the
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
sanctity of the recruitment process and categorically concluded that no instance
of malpractice has been established. Learned State counsel further submits that
the petitioners’ contention regarding similarity in the incorrect answers
allegedly indicating a statistically improbable pattern, suggestive of external
coordination or a common source of preparation, was specifically considered
during the inquiry. The Inquiry Officer, while dealing with the said contention,
observed that out of a total of 27,764 candidates who appeared in the said
examination, the alleged pattern was only observed with respect to 45
candidates. The factum of 45 candidates incorrectly answering certain
questions, albeit in a similar manner, could reasonably be attributed to a
similarity in mindset, intelligence, and aptitude. In the absence of any cogent
material, such similarity by itself could not lead to an inference of malpractice.
7.
Furthermore, petitioner-Akashdeep Kaur never raised any
complaint regarding the examination while it was being held or immediately
after declaration of the result. Neither did the petitioner-Akashdeep Kaur
appear before the Inquiry Officer nor did she submit any evidence in support of
the allegations now sought to be raised. In fact, she secured only 46 marks in
EWS category and was not even within the zone of consideration for the typing
test. The other petitioners, who had joined the proceedings later, also have
identical backgrounds and have not scored well in the said examination. Thus,
it is evident that the petitioners are raising baseless allegations, without any
cogent material to support the same as a post-result attempt to unsettle a lawful
recruitment process after failure on merit.
8.
Learned
State
counsel
further
submits
that
this
Court,
while deciding CWP No. 27993 of 2025, had directed the respondent-Board to
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
complete the selection process expeditiously. In compliance with the said
directions, the Inquiry Report was accepted, the typing tests were conducted,
and recommendations were made only in respect of those candidates who
successfully qualified all stages of the selection process. It is submitted that
several candidates either failed to qualify or remained absent during the typing
test, which, according to learned counsel, reinforces the transparency, integrity,
and rigour of the selection process. It is pointed out that, out of the initial 44
candidates who had secured high merit in the written examination, 03 remained
absent for the mandatory typing test while another 03 candidates either failed to
clear the same or were declared unqualified at the stage of document
verification.
9.
Learned counsel further argues that it is settled law that courts
ought not to interfere with recruitment processes merely on suspicion or
dissatisfaction of unsuccessful candidates. Allegations of mass copying or
paper leak must be proved by clear, cogent and convincing evidence, not
conjectures. A reasoned inquiry conducted by a former Judge of this Court
deserves due deference unless any perversity or mala fide is demonstrated,
which are conspicuously absent. He submits that every allegation raised by the
petitioners has been dealt with in the Inquiry Report dated 24.06.2025 in an
exhaustive, reasoned and evidence-based manner, and it was concluded that
they are fabricated, speculative and rooted in post-result dissatisfaction. Thus,
they fail to meet the legal threshold for judicial interference in a recruitment
process. As such, learned State counsel prays that the present writ petition be
dismissed as it is devoid of any merit.
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
OBSERVATION & ANALYSIS
10.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and after perusing
the record with their able assistance, it transpires that the allegations raised by
the petitioners, questioning the sanctity of the examination conducted in
pursuance of Advertisement No.6 of 2023 (Annexure P-1), are based on
disputed questions of fact. Consequently, a detailed fact-finding inquiry was
conducted by a retired judge of this Court wherein the following allegations
were considered:
“A. All the toppers are from the Ghaggar belt, a region where the
cheating mafia has been firmly entrenched for long time (Mansa,
Sangrur, Jind, Fatehabad etc.); and
B. The results of these toppers were disappointing in earlier exams (Very
few candidates manage to improve their preparation significantly in a
short time so that they top in the next exam); and
C. Some candidates are between 40 and 45 years of age and they did not
appear in any other exam and now they become toppers in this exam;
and
D. The toppers are either relatives or belong to the same family; and
E. Many toppers scored very low in easier exams like Patwari, yet they
are ranked first in this exam; and
F. All the toppers answered the same questions incorrectly, the questions
that the first-ranked candidate got wrong were also answered
incorrectly by all the other 43 candidates; and
G. Across all these instances, all the candidates chose identical
incorrect answers for the questions they answered wrong; and
ਿਹੰਮਤ
11.
The findings of the Inquiry Officer, as mentioned in the report
dated 24.06.2025, are summarised as under:
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
a. Alleged Regional Concentration: The Inquiry Officer conducted a
detailed district-wise, centre-wise and roll-number-wise analysis of the
top 50 candidates and the data revealed that 45 of them were from 08
districts of Punjab and 05 were from 03 districts of Haryana. These
candidates had appeared for the examination at different centres, with no
clustering in seating or roll numbers. Thus, the Inquiry Officer held that
geographical concentration alone, without evidence of collusion or
malpractice, cannot be a ground to vitiate the selection process. The
relevant part of the Inquiry Report is reproduced below:
“Prima Facie, it is found that significantly 23 candidates of
District Mansa are in top 50 candidates. But this fact by itself is
not sufficient to condemn their right to contest and defeat. This
may be attributed to a growing focus on education, increasing
access to learning resources, and a competitive academic
environment of that area... The consistent performance of
candidates from a particular area should not automatically be
seen as suspicious but rather as an opportunity to study and
understand and the will of the candidate are the factors
contributing to academic improvement in that region.”
b. Poor performance in earlier examinations: The report emphasized that
each competitive examination is an independent test of merit and that
improvement through focused preparation, experience and effort is
neither implausible nor unprecedented. The Inquiry Officer concluded as
follows in this regard:
“Improvement in performance in a competitive examinations is
neither unprecedented nor implausible. Candidates often engage
in intensive, focused preparation following previous attempts,
benefiting from experience, targeted study plans, and enhanced
understanding of the examination pattern. The capacity for
significant academic or competitive improvement is well
recognized in educational jurisprudence and competitive
examination practices. It is neither legally justifiable nor
procedurally sound to discredit a candidate’s success solely on
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the basis of past performance and without any cogent evidence
that the candidate used unfair means. The examination system is
designed to assess current merit and competence, and each
attempt is treated as an independent exercise. To impugn the
validity of a candidate's success on the grounds of prior results
would amount to an arbitrary restriction that is inconsistent with
principles of fairness and equality.”
c. Age of candidates: The Inquiry Report records that only two candidates
among the top 50 were above 40 years of age and their candidature was
fully protected by statutory age relaxation. It was emphasised therein that
merit in a competitive examination is age-neutral and any presumption
otherwise would be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.
d. Familial relationship: The inquiry also revealed that only 02 candidates
among the top 50 belonged to the same family, however, both possessed
verifiable academic credentials. It was observed that there is no legal
prohibition against relatives appearing in the same examination or
qualifying it. Mere existence of a filial relationship alone cannot raise an
inference of favouritism in absence of any evidence to that effect.
e. Identical wrong answers: The allegation regarding identical wrong
answers was thoroughly analysed and the original OMR sheets were sent
for forensic examination. The forensic expert categorically ruled out
common authorship of any two OMR sheets and found no evidence of
impersonation or mass fabrication. The Inquiry Officer explained that the
similarity in wrong answers can naturally arise due to common
preparation material, elimination strategies or exam stress, and does not,
by itself, establish collusion or cheating. In absence of proof of
tampering, usage of communication devices, or access to answer keys,
the allegation was found to be speculative and legally unsustainable.
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
Furthermore, the NIELIT conducted its own internal scrutiny and
categorically stated that multiple question paper sets were used and the
printing thereof was done at a confidential location. No anomaly was
detected at any stage and thus, there is no probability of paper leak. In
light of the aforementioned findings, the Inquiry Officer concluded as
follows:
“12. After a comprehensive review of the complaints, relevant
records, examination materials, and the forensic expert's report, it
is found that neither the complainants have submitted nor the
undersigned has come across any concrete or verifiable evidence
which may substantiate the allegations levelled by the
complainants, in accordance with the law. The material available
does not indicate any procedural irregularities, misconduct, or
even remote involvement of any external or unauthorized factor in
the examination process. The similarity in certain answer patterns
can reasonably be attributed to common preparation sources and
does not, in itself, establish wrongdoing. The complaints appear to
be biased largely on conjectures and surmises, rather than on
demonstrable facts or substantiated irregularities.”
12.
It is a settled position of law that mere suspicion, surmise, or
conjecture is not sufficient to warrant interference with or setting aside a
selection or examination process. A petitioner seeking cancellation of an
examination bears a heavy onus to establish that the process stood vitiated by
fraud and that there exists credible and cogent material demonstrating a
systemic taint or illegality going to the very root of the selection process. In this
regard, a two-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Joginder Pal Vs.
State of Punjab’ 2014 (3) SCT 431, succinctly summarised the governing legal
principles in this regard as previously laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in
‘Inderpreet Singh Kahlon Vs. State of Punjab’ (2006) 11 SCC 356. Speaking
through A.K. Sikri, the following was opined:
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
“6.
xxx
xxx
xxx
From the reading of the judgment, one can discern the following
principles:
(a) An appointment made in violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India would be void. It would be a nullity. Since the
services of the appellants were terminated not in terms of the rules but in
view of the commission of illegality in the selection process involved, the
applicability of the relevant provisions of the statutes as also the effect of
the provisions of Article 311 of the Constitution need not be considered.
(b) Before a finding that an appointment has been made in violation of
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution can be arrived at, the appointing
authority must take into consideration the foundational facts. Only
when such foundational facts are established, can the legal principles
be applied. When the services of employees are terminated inter alia on
the ground that they might have aided and abetted corruption and,
thus, either for the sake of probity in governance or in public interest
their services should be terminated, the court must satisfy itself that
conditions therefor exist. The court while setting aside a selection may
require the State to establish that the process was so tainted that the
entire selection process is liable to be cancelled. In a case of this nature,
thus, the question which requires serious consideration is as to whether
due to the misdeed of some candidates, honest and meritorious
candidates should also suffer.
(c) A distinction exists between a prove case of mass cheating for a
board examination and an unproven imputed charge of corruption
where the appointment of a civil servant is involved. Only in the event
it is found to be impossible or highly improbable that the tainted cases
can be separated from the non-tainted cases could en masse orders of
termination be issued. Both the State Government as also the High
Court in that view of the matter should have made all endeavours to
segregate the tainted from the non-tainted candidates.
(d) Cases which may arise where the selection process is perceived to be
tainted may be categorised in the following manner:
(i) Cases where the "event" has been investigated.
(ii)Cases where CBI inquiry took place and was completed or a
preliminary
investigation was concluded.
(iii) Cases where the selection was made but appointment was not
made.
(iv) Cases where the candidates were also ineligible and the
appointments were found to be contrary to law or rules.
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
If the services of appointees who had put in a few years of service were
terminated, compliance with three principles at the hands of the State
was imperative viz.: (1) to establish satisfaction in regard to the
sufficiency of the materials collected so as to enable the State to arrive
at its satisfaction that the selection process was tainted; (2) to
determine the question that the illegalities committed went to the root
of the matter, which vitiated the entire selection process. Such
satisfaction as also the sufficiency of materials were required to be
gathered by reason of a thorough investigation in a fair and
transparent manner; (3) whether the sufficient material present
enabled the State to arrive at a satisfaction that the officers in majority
had been found to be part of the fraudulent purpose or the system itself
was corrupt.
(e) Once the necessary factual findings as enumerated above are
arrived at, or it is found impossible or highly improbable to separate
tainted from untainted cases, all appointments traceable to the officers
concerned could be cancelled. But admittedly, in the present case,
although there had been serious imputations against Ravinderpal Singh
Sidhu being at the helm of the affairs of the State Public Service
Commission, all decisions made by the Commission during his tenure
are yet to be set aside.”
(Emphasis added)
13.
Furthermore, after an exhaustive review of the earlier precedents
on the subject, in ‘Vanshika Yadav Vs. Union of India’ 2024 INSC 568, a
three-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, speaking through Dr. Justice
D.Y. Chandrachud, has conclusively settled the legal position in the following
terms:
“61. The facts of this case and the resultant issue before this Court do
not call for the development of new legal principles. It is settled law that
the cancellation of an examination, either for the purposes of gaining
admission into professional and other courses or for the purpose of
recruitment to a government post, is justified only in cases where the
sanctity of the exam is found to be compromised at a systemic level.
Courts may direct the cancellation of an examination or approve such
cancellation by the competent authority only if it is not possible to
separate the tainted candidates from the untainted ones.
62. In Anamica Mishra v. U.P. Public Service Commission, (1990)
Supp SCC 692 the recruitment process concerning appointment to
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
various educational services posts in Uttar Pradesh was cancelled. The
process consisted of two stages - a preliminary written examination and
an interview. Only those candidates who scored high marks in the
former were invited to participate in the latter. In that case, mistakes in
data entry resulted in some candidates who scored high marks being left
out of the interview process even as other candidates who scored low
marks were interviewed and even selected. Upon realising this error, the
State Public Service Commission cancelled the entire recruitment
process. The High Court of Allahabad upheld this decision. The appeal
against the decision of the High Court was allowed by this Court. This
Court found that there was no justification for cancelling the written
examination, considering that the errors were confined to the interview
process. It found that a more appropriate course of action would have
been to set aside the selection of candidates and conduct a fresh set of
interviews on the basis of the written exam which had already taken
place. Hence, in that case, the Court was of the opinion that it was not
a suitable course of action to cancel an examination when no systemic
issues persisted. Although not expressly stated by the Court, a proper
appreciation of the decision leads to the conclusion that it considered
whether a fresh examination was proportionate to the nature of
grievance and the extent to which the integrity of the exam was
vitiated.
63. From the observations of this Court in Bihar School Examination
Board v. Subhas Chandra Sinha, (1970) 1 SCC 648 it can be seen that
the number or proportion of students who can be believed to have
indulged in malpractice is a relevant factor in deciding cases such as the
present one. The relevant observations are extracted below:
"13. This is not a case of any particular individual who is being
charged with adoption of unfair means but of the conduct of all
the examinees or at least a vast majority of them at a particular
centre. If it is not a question of charging any one individually with
unfair means but to condemn the examination as ineffective for the
purpose it was held ..."
64. In Madhyamic Shiksha Mandal, M.P. v. Abhilash Shiksha Prasar
Samiti, (1998) 9 SCC 236 the Board concerned with the exam in that
case cancelled the exam upon receiving a report from a Naib Tehsildar
who had visited the exam centre. He found that the students were
copying even before the question paper was distributed and that they
were permitted to enter the exam hall with their books and other
material. The report also stated that the invigilators and supervisors
did nothing to prevent the students from copying. This Court found
that the Board was left with no alternative but to cancel the exam and
that it was exceedingly difficult to identify the students who were
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
committing malpractice and those who were not.
65. In Sachin Kumar v. Delhi Subordinate Service Selection Board,
(2021) 4 SCC 631 the Court analysed multiple judgments related to the
issue before us and made the following pertinent observations on the
scope of judicial review in such proceedings:
"56. The decisions in Railway Recruitment Board [All India
Railway Recruitment Board v. K. Shyam Kumar, (2010) 6 SCC
614 : (2010) 2 SCC (L&S) 293] , Gohil [Gohil Vishvaraj
Hanubhai v. State of Gujarat, (2017) 13 SCC 621 : (2018) 1 SCC
(L&S) 80] and Kalaimani [State of T.N. v. A Kalaimani, (2021) 16
SCC 217 : 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1002] all go to emphasise that a
recruiting authority is entitled to take a bona fide view, based on
the material before it, that the entire process stands vitiated as a
result of which a fresh selection process should be initiated. The
integrity of the selection process cannot be lightly disregarded by
the High Court substituting its own subjective opinion on the
sufficiency of the material which has been taken into account by
the decision making authority. Undoubtedly, fairness to
candidates who participate in the process is an important
consideration. There may be situations where candidates who
have indulged in irregularities can be identified and it is then
possible for the authority to segregate the tainted from the
untainted candidates. On the other hand, there may be situations
where the nature of the irregularities may be manifold and the
number of candidates involved is of such a magnitude that it is
impossible to precisely delineate or segregate the tainted from the
untainted. A considered decision of the authority based on the
material before it taken bona fide should not lightly be interfered
in the exercise of the powers of judicial review unless it stands
vitiated on grounds of unreasonableness or proportionality."
66. The purpose of testing whether the integrity of the exam has been
compromised at a systemic level is to ensure that the cancellation of the
exam which has already taken place and the conduct of a fresh
examination is a proportionate response. This is also why courts are
required to assess the extent of the use of unfair means and separately,
consider whether it is possible to separate tainted and untainted
candidates. A holistic view must be taken.
67. In arriving at a conclusion as to whether an examination suffers
from widespread issues, courts must ensure that allegations of
malpractice are substantiated and that the material on record,
including investigative reports, point to that conclusion. There must be
at least some evidence to allow the Court to reach that conclusion. This
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
standard need not be unduly strict. To elaborate, it is not necessary for
the material on record to point to one and only conclusion which is
that malpractice has taken place at a systemic level. However, there
must be a real possibility of systemic malaise as borne out by the
material before the Court. In Bihar School Examination Board
(supra), this Court recognised that "sufficient material" must be
present to justify a decision to cancel examinations:
"14. ... If at a centre the whole body of students receive assistance
and are managed to secure success in the neighbourhood of 100%
when others at other centres are successful only at an average of
50%, it is obvious that the University or the Board must do
something in the matter. It cannot hold a detailed quasi- judicial
inquiry with a right to its alumni to plead and lead evidence etc.,
before the results are withheld or the examinations cancelled. If
there is sufficient material on which it can be demonstrated that
the university was right in its conclusion that the examinations
ought to be cancelled then academic standards require that the
university's appreciation of the problem must be respected."
68. In Madhyamic Shiksha Mandal, M.P. (supra), too, the Court
placed great reliance on the report of the Naib Tehsildar, which
indicated that the students in question were copying unchecked and
that it was not possible to separate them from the ones who were not
copying.
xx
xx
xx
xx
xx
b. The present case
xx
84. Hence, sufficient material is not on record at present which
indicates a systemic leak or systemic malpractice of other forms. The
material on record does not, at present, substantiate the allegation that
there has been a widespread malpractice which compromised the
integrity of the exam. To the contrary, an assessment of the data
indicates that there are no deviations which indicate that systemic
cheating has taken place. The information before us at this stage does
not show that the question paper was disseminated widely using social
media or the internet, or that the answers were being communicated to
students using sophisticated electronic means which may prove
difficult to trace. The students who were beneficiaries of the leak at
Hazaribagh and Patna are capable of being identified. The CBI
investigation reveals the number of students who are the beneficiaries of
the malpractice at Hazaribagh and Patna at this stage. This leads us to
conclude that it is possible to separate the beneficiaries of malpractice
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
or fraud from the honest students. This being the case, the Court cannot
direct a re-exam.”
(Emphasis added)
14.
Significantly, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vanshika Yadav
(supra) expressly distinguished the decisions in Tanvi Sarwal (supra) and
Sachin Kumar (supra) in the following manner:
“89. Tanvi Sarwal's case (supra) is distinguishable from the case
before us on many counts. First and foremost, the unscrupulous
candidates in that case used sophisticated technology including vests
fitted with micro SIMs to cheat. No such technology has come to light
at present, in this case. Second, the question paper was found to have
been shared on WhatsApp before the date of the exam. Once shared
through social media, it is exceedingly difficult to trace the journey of
a post or message or document. Here, the record at present does not
indicate that the question paper was shared on social media before the
date of the exam. Third, In Tanvi Sarwal's case (supra), the assistance
of a gang with a nationwide network was stated to have been taken and
calls were made by the accused to persons living in numerous states in
the country. No such nationwide ring is seen at present in this case.
Fourth, the Court found that it was not possible to separate the
beneficiaries of the leak from the honest candidates. Here, the Court
has concluded that the fraudulent candidates may be identified by the
investigating agency. For these reasons, the decision in Tanvi Sarwal
(supra) does not support the case of the petitioners. The allegations in
this case are not substantiated by the material on record.
90. In Sachin Kumar's case (supra), the two-Judge Bench of this Court
(of which one of us, D Y Chandrachud, J., was a part) was concerned
with the recruitment process for the post of Head Clerk. The
Government of the National Capital Territory of Delhi cancelled the
process on the basis of certain irregularities in the conduct of the
examination. The Central Administrative Tribunal annulled this decision
of the Government. In proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
before a Division Bench of the Delhi High Court, the decision of the
Central Administrative Tribunal was partly affirmed. The appeals
arising from the decision of the High Court resulted in the case before
this Court.
xx
xx
xx
94. That case, too, is distinct from the one before us. In Sachin Kumar
(supra), the material before the Court was sufficient to lead to the
conclusion that there was mass malpractice, which attacked the
integrity of the exam at a systemic level. This is indicated by the fact
that a large number of candidates in the zone of selection were from
the same concentrated geographical region and that candidates from
the same family were sitting in consecutive spots during the exam.
There was also impersonation and the coordinated dilution of security
protocols in that case. There was an abundance of material before the
Court in that case. The same cannot be said to be true in the instant
case. Hence, the ruling in that case cannot influence the outcome in
this case. Moreover, in cases such as these, courts must take a holistic
view of the facts before them and reach an independent conclusion.
Different courses of action are appropriate in different circumstances.”
(Emphasis added)
15.
Adverting to the facts of the present case, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the petitioners have failed to place sufficient, cogent, or
verifiable material on the record to substantiate the grave allegations of
systemic fraud, paper leakage, or mass copying. The entire case of the
petitioners rests upon similarities in answer patterns and geographical
concentration of successful candidates. However, as per the settled principles
of service jurisprudence, mere suspicion or a post-result dissatisfaction of
unsuccessful candidates cannot be elevated to the status of proof. To warrant
the extreme step of quashing a recruitment process, there must be evidence of a
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
systemic taint that goes to the very root of the selection, rendering it impossible
to separate the tainted from the untainted. In the instant case, the petitioners
have provided only conjectures and surmises which do not meet the heavy legal
onus required for judicial interference.
16.
This Court has carefully perused the original Inquiry Report dated
24.06.2025, which provides a methodical and exhaustive rebuttal to each
allegation raised by the petitioners.
The Inquiry Officer has conducted a
detailed district-wise and center-wise analysis, concluding that geographical
concentration, such as the 23 candidates hailing from District Mansa, is not
indicative of any foul play but may be attributed to local academic focus and
coaching environments. Furthermore, the allegation regarding identical wrong
answers was clinically examined through forensic experts using advanced
scientific instruments, which categorically ruled out common authorship of
OMR sheets. The report correctly notes that in objective-type examinations,
convergence in responses often arises from common preparation materials or
shared reasoning patterns and does not, by itself, establish collusion. Moreover,
it must be pointed out that as per the details provided in the Inquiry Report, the
top-ranking candidates did not appear at the same examination center. Instead,
the examination centers of these candidates were located in different cities. The
inquiry specifically noted that out of the 23 candidates from District Mansa, 22
appeared for the examination at different centers in Chandigarh while 01 wrote
the examination in SAS Nagar. Similarly, the candidates from District Sangrur
appeared at different centers, and those from Districts Fatehabad, Jind, and
Kaithal were also distributed across various locations. This lack of regional
clustering or common seating arrangements further reinforces the conclusion
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
that the selection was not marred by mass copying or coordinated malpractice.
17.
The legal position as enunciated by the three-Judge Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Vanshika Yadav (supra) is squarely applicable
here. The Hon’ble Apex Court has clarified that the cancellation of an
examination would be a disproportionate response unless the sanctity thereof is
compromised at a systemic level. Furthermore, this Court is of the considered
view that the reliance placed by the learned counsel for the petitioners on the
judgments in Tanvi Sarwal (supra) and Sachin Kumar (supra) is entirely
misplaced, as the factual matrices of those cases are clearly distinguishable
from the present matter. In Tanvi Sarwal (supra), the recruitment process was
compromised by a nationwide network using sophisticated technology, such as
vests fitted with micro-SIMs, and the widespread sharing of question papers on
WhatsApp prior to the examination, none of which has surfaced in the present
case. Similarly, in Sachin Kumar (supra), there was an abundance of material
proving mass malpractice, including impersonation, the coordinated dilution of
security protocols, and candidates from the same family sitting in consecutive
spots during the exam. In stark contrast, the present case lacks any such
credible evidence of a systemic breach.
CONCLUSION
18.
In view of the discussion above, this Court finds that the
recruitment process does not suffer from any systemic malaise that would
justify its cancellation. The allegations raised by the petitioners have already
been thoroughly investigated and rejected by the Inquiry Officer being devoid
of any merit. Consequently, no ground for interference is made out and thus,
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
the present writ petition is hereby dismissed.
19.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
20.
The original inquiry report 24.06.2025 is directed to be returned to
the learned State counsel.
21.
Needless to say, the interim relief granted by this Court vide order
dated 22.12.2025, is hereby vacated.
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
JUDGE
21.01.2026
Neha
Whether speaking/reasoned
Whether reportable
NEHA
2026.01.30 14:56
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
:
:
Yes/No
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review