Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:829-DB
Serial No.01
Supple. List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
W. A. No. 33 of 2024
Reserved on
: 27.08.2024
Date of Decision: 10.09.2024
Shri Ajit Paul,
Vs. 1.State of Meghalaya, represented
S/o Shri. Sudhir Chandra Paul
by the Chief Secretary to the
Aged about:37 years
Govt. of Meghalaya, Shillong.
R/o, Boyce Road Laitumkhrah,
Shillong East Khasi Hills,
2.Commissioner and Secretary,
District, Meghalaya.
Department of Education,
Meghalaya.
::::WRIT APPELLANT.
3.Women’s College Shillong,
Laitumkhrah, Shillong,
Represented by its Principal.
4.The Principal, Women’s
College, Laitumkhrah, Shillong.
5.The Governing Body of
Women’s College Laitumkhrah,
Shillong represented by its
President.
6. North Eastern Hill University,
Umshing Mawkynroh, Shillong
Represented by its Registrar.
7. Meghalaya Board of School
2024:MLHC:829-DB
Education, Tura West Garo
Hills represented by its
Chairman.
::::RESPONDENTS.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Chief Justice (Acting)
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E.Wanniang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N. D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z. E. Nongkynrih, GA. (R:1 & 2)
Ms. A. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mrs. R. Dutta, Adv. (R: 3 – 5)
Mr. S. Sen, Adv. (R: 6)
Mr. S. P. Mahanta, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. M. Lyngdoh, Adv. (R: 7)
(JUDGMENT & ORDER)
Per. B. Bhattacharjee, Judge:
This writ appeal seeks to challenge the order dated 14-05-2024 passed
in WP(C) No. 107 of 2020 by which the writ petition filed by the
appellant herein was dismissed by holding that the same was not
maintainable.
2024:MLHC:829-DB
1.
The facts of the case giving rise to the filing of the present writ
appeal is that the appellant was inducted in the Women College,
Shillong in the year 2011 to impart computer education for the Higher
Secondary section and subsequently to run the add-on courses for the
Degree students and being satisfied with the performance of the
appellant, the Governing Body (respondent No.5) in its meeting 0806-2013 passed resolution to bring the appellant under the regular
pay-scale of the college. Pursuant to the above resolution, the
appellant was paid a regular pay-scale w.e.f. 01-06-2013 by
regularizing his service against the college sanctioned post. However,
the appellant was never issued with any appointment letter, whereas
all the other faculty members under the college sanctioned post had
received their respective appointment letters. Nevertheless, the
College Authority being happy with the sincere and industrious
approach of the appellant towards his duty as a teacher in the college,
redesignated his post from lecturer to that of the Assistant Professor
and, accordingly the pay-scale of the appellant was revised w.e.f. 0109-2018. As no appointment letter was issued to the appellant, the
teachers’ representative of the college adopted an agenda in its
meeting held on 01-12-2018 in the matter of non-issuance of
2024:MLHC:829-DB
appointment letter to the appellant besides other issues and forwarded
the same to the respondent No 5 for looking into the matter. In the
midst of the aforesaid situation, the appellant was taken by surprise
when he received an oral information in the later part of the year 2019
from the respondent college to the effect that the pay-scale extended to
the appellant would be discontinued and he would get a remuneration
of only Rs.500/- per class for taking classes in the Higher Secondary
section. The appellant immediately sent emails on 29-10-2019, 10-122019 and 14-12-2019 to the respondent college seeking clarification
of his status in the college. The respondent college, thereupon, vide
reply dated 16-12-2019 informed the appellant that the respondent
Governing Body had decided to do away with the Department of
Computer Science in the college as it never started as a separate
department in the Degree section and as on that date, the Department
of Computer Science was not there in the college and the appellant
was instructed not to resume his duties.
2.
In the above circumstances, having left with no other
alternative, the appellant approached the High Court by filing the writ
petition No. 107 of 2020 challenging the resolution dated 12-10-2019
adopted by the Governing Body (respondent No.5 herein) and the
2024:MLHC:829-DB
impugned letter/mail dated 16-12-2019 of the Principal of the
Women’s College (respondent No.4) intimating the appellant about the
discontinuation of his service.
The appellant also prayed for a
direction for his reinstatement in service with all benefits. The writ
court dismissed the above writ petition by holding: “13. Looking at any angle, in my considered opinion, the writ
petition is not maintainable, when the post itself ceases to exist,
owing to bifurcation and the College has no sanctioned post to
accommodate the petitioner. Hence, this Court has no other
option, but to dismiss the writ petition as not maintainable.
14. Accordingly, the Writ Petition stands dismissed.”
3.
Assailing the order of the writ court, the appellant has filed this
writ appeal by raising several grounds mentioned in his Memo of
Appeal.
4.
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the appellant submits that the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate
that the appellant was regularized in a college sanctioned post and the
benefit of regular pay-scale was conferred upon him. He submits that
as per the provision of rule 2(10) of the Recognition of Secondary and
Higher Secondary School Rules, 2012, the respondent college is a
recognized private institution falling under the purview of the
2024:MLHC:829-DB
Meghalaya School Education Act, 1981 and hence, the conclusion
reached by the learned Single Judge that the writ petition was not
maintainable, is totally wrong. He further submits that the finding of
the Single Judge that the college had no sanctioned post to
accommodate the appellant is contradictory to the available materials
on record. The learned Senior Counsel has drawn attention of this
Court to the various documents appended with the writ petition and
submits that as per several reports of All India Survey on Higher
Education and the Prospectus issued by the respondent college, it is
apparent that there exists a Computer Department in the college. By
referring to the proceeding of the Staff Council Meeting dated 10-062013 and the certificate dated 21-12-2015 issued by the then Principle
of the college, he submits that the appellant was a full-time lecturer in
the Department of Computer Science and being a regular employee of
the college, could not have been terminated from service without
affording an opportunity of hearing and without prior approval of the
competent authority in terms of Section 9(2) of the Meghalaya School
Education Act, 1981.
The learned Senior Counsel further refers to
rules 23 (9) & 23 (10) of the Meghalaya Deficit Aided College
Management School Rules, 2013 and submits that adherence to the
2024:MLHC:829-DB
principle of natural justice and equity is a mandatory requirement in
case of termination and removal of service of employees of the
college, but the same was not done in the case of the appellant despite
the fact that he acquired regular and permanent status in a college
sanctioned post and deduction for provident fund was made from his
salary. On the basis of his submissions, the learned Senior Counsel
prays for setting aside and quashing of the impugned order of the
learned Single Judge and for issuance of necessary direction for
reinstatement of the writ petitioner back into service with all benefits.
To buttress his argument, the learned Senior Counsel places reliance
on the decisions of the Apex Court reported in (1997) 7 SCC 550,
Chief General Manager, State Bank of India and Another versus Bijoy
Kumar Mishra, (2011) 13 SCC 760, Satimbla Sharma & Ors. vs
St.Paul Sr.Secondary School & Ors., (2016) 6 SCC 541, Raj Kumar vs
Director of Education & Ors., (2020) 14 SCC 449, Marwari Balika
Vidyalaya vs. Asha Srivastava and others and the decision of the
Allahabad High Court in Special Appeal No.115 of 2024, C/M
Pratibha Inter College Vs. State of U.P & Ors.
2024:MLHC:829-DB
5.
Per contra, Ms. A. Paul, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
the respondents. No. 3 – 5 submits that the appellant was engaged in
the service of the college in the Higher Secondary section without any
advertisement and interview and no appointment letter was issued to
him and, as such, the appellant cannot claim himself to be a regular
employee of the college. The learned Senior Counsel submits that the
Department of Computer Application was only for the Higher
Secondary section and no permission was accorded by the respondent
No.6, the University, for opening the same department in the degree
level of the college. It is further submitted that the Higher Secondary
section was bifurcated from the college on instruction from the
respondent No.7, the Board, and the same was approved vide
communication dated 01-04-2019 of the Board. After the bifurcation
of the Higher Secondary section, there exists no Department of
Computer Application in the college. The learned Senior Counsel
refers to a letter dated 22-07-2017 written by the appellant addressed
to the principal of the college requesting for consideration of his
tenure of service from the year 2011 as a faculty in the college and for
providing him an appointment letter, and submits that the letter itself
is the proof that the appellant was never provided with any regular
2024:MLHC:829-DB
appointment in the college. The learned Senior Counsel contends that
since the appellant was not appointed in the college by holding a
regular selection process and no appointment letter was ever issued to
him, the provision of Section 9(2) of the Meghalaya School Education
Act, 1981 would not apply to him. Further, the appellant was not
appointed in the degree level of the college at any point of time and,
hence, the provision of the Meghalaya Deficit College Management
Rules, 2013 is also not applicable in the present case. The learned
Senior Counsel submits that though the pay-scale of the appellant was
fixed at par with regular pay-scale to avoid disparity, his service was
never regularized any sanctioned post in the college. She submits that
appellant does not have any legally enforceable right and, hence, the
order of the Single Judge cannot be faulted with and this writ appeal is
liable to be dismissed.
6.
Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for the State-
respondents No. 1 & 2 submits that no relief has been claimed against
the State-respondents in the matter. Further, the State had no role in
the appointment of the appellant in the college and no approval was
accorded to any such appointment.
2024:MLHC:829-DB
7.
Mr. S. Sen, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No. 6
submits that the University has not accorded any permission or
sanction to the college for conducting course in Computer Application
and the college does not have affiliation of the University to offer any
programme on Computer Science.
8.
Mr. S. P. Mahanta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondent No.7 submits that the Board has no connection with the
appointment and removal of the appellant from the service of the
college.
9.
Perusal of the materials on record reveal that though the
appellant was engaged in the college in the year 2011 to impart
computer education in the Higher Secondary section of the college, no
appointment order showing the terms and condition of the service of
the appellant was issued to him. There is also nothing to show that the
appellant was taken into service of the college after holding a regular
selection process. The terms and conditions of the appointment of the
appellant is also not disclosed anywhere. In absence of proof of any
specific terms and conditions of appointment, it is difficult to hold that
the appellant was appointed in the college on a regular basis.
2024:MLHC:829-DB
10.
The proceedings of the Staff Council Meeting dated 10-06-
2013, basing on which the appellant has asserted his claim of regular
appointment, is not a proceeding of the Governing Body of the college
and thus, cannot be made a basis for deciding the claim of regular
appointment of the appellant. The certificate dated 21-12-2015, relied
on by the appellant is also not a proof of regular appointment of the
appellant as the same was issued in the form of a salary certificate.
The content of the said certificate that the appellant was serving as a
full-time lecturer in the college since 20-06-2011 is totally at variance
with the claim of the appellant that he was brought under regular scale
w.e.f.
01-09-2013.
Furthermore, the letter dated 22-07-2017,
admittedly written by the appellant requesting for consideration of his
tenure of service as a faculty in the institution by issuing an
appointment letter, goes against the very claim of the appellant that he
was appointed as a regular employee in the college in the year 2011.
11.
The appellant does not dispute the fact he was taken into the
service of the college without any advertisement and without holding
a regular selection process. There is also no dispute that the Higher
Secondary section of the college was bifurcated on the basis of the
2024:MLHC:829-DB
approval accorded by the respondent No.7 on 01-04-2019. Except for
asserting his claim of regular appointment on the basis of conferment
of structured pay-scale by the college, the appellant is not able to
furnish any material to establish his claim. Moreover, there is nothing
on record to show that the appellant was appointed in the degree
section of the college for taking regular classes. In such a situation, it
cannot be said that the appellant has any legally enforceable right to
seek regular appointment in the college.
12.
The various case laws relied upon by the learned Senior
Counsel for the appellant do not appear to be relevant for
consideration of appellant’s claim in the present matter. The case of
Chief General Manager, State Bank of India and Another (supra) was
in relation to a subject concerning period of probation and deemed
confirmation in service. The appellant’s case in the present matter is
no way relatable to any appointment on probation and confirmation in
service. The case of Satimbla Sharma & Ors. (supra) was with regard
to pay parity between the teachers of a private schools and
government aided schools and, hence, has no connection with the facts
and situation of the present case.
The decision rendered in Raj
2024:MLHC:829-DB
Kumar (supra), was with regard to retrenchment of a person employed
as a driver who became permanent in the year 1994. The case of the
appellant in the present matter has no similarity with the said decision.
The decision rendered in Marwari Balika Vidyalaya (supra), was in
relation to an appointment made with approval of the competent
authority and no approval was obtained for the purpose of removal. It
is not the case of the appellant here that his appointment was approved
at any point of time by the competent authority. The case of C/M
Pratibha Inter College (supra) by the Allahabad High Court relates to
termination of service wherein enquiry was required to be made under
Clause 9 of the Regulation 2000 framed under the U.P. Intermediate
Education Act, 1921 and, as such, has no bearing with the case of the
appellant before this Court.
13.
The appellant’s claim in the present case is with regard to
termination of a service from the post of the Assistant Professor. The
Recognition of Secondary and Higher Secondary School Rules, 2012
framed under the provision of Meghalaya School Regulation Act,
1981 does not show there exist any post of Assistant Professor in the
Higher Secondary section of any institution. The Rules 15, 16, 17, 18
2024:MLHC:829-DB
& 19 provides for the posts of the Head of the Institution, Assistant
Head of the Institution, Subject Teachers, Office Staffs and Librarian.
Hence, the petitioner cannot make any claim basing on the provision
of the aforesaid Act of 1981 and the Rule of 2012.
14.
Since the learned Senior Counsel has referred to the provisions
of Rule 2(d), Rules 23(9) and 23(10) of the Meghalaya Deficit Aided
Colleges Management Rules, 2013, it would be appropriate to take
into consideration the provisions of the aforesaid rules which are as
follows:
“2.(d) “Employee” means every person employed in an
Educational institution whose entire salary is drawn from
maintenance grants received from the State Government except
menials, i.e., all employees covered by grant-in-aid.
23.(9) To appoint staff and other persons that is necessary to
run the affairs of the colleges after due advertisement and
interview. All such appointments shall however be made in
conformity with prevailing relevant rules governing
appointments. No such approval is necessary in case of
appointment of substitute teacher maintained by the college
from its own fund provided that such teacher possesses the
required qualification. No such approval is necessary in case
of appointment of persons in the menial category.
(10) The Governing Body shall adhere all procedures
prescribes under the relevant Employee Rules approved by
2024:MLHC:829-DB
Government in the matter of dismissal of any incumbent
holding a post under the deficit funding system. In case of
other categories of employees, the principles of natural justice
and equity should be adhered to.”
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid rules makes it amply clear that the
appointment of regular staffs and other persons to run the affairs of the
colleges can only be made after due advertisement and interview in
conformity with prevailing rules governing appointment except in
case of appointment of substitute teachers maintained by a college
from its own fund.
The adherence to the rules approved by the
Government is also required in case of dismissal of any incumbent
holding a post under the deficit system and for employees of other
categories, the principle of natural justice and equity needs to be
followed.
15.
Since the appellant was not taken into service by following the
procedures of law laid down for appointment either in the Higher
Secondary section or in the degree level of the college, the petitioner
cannot claim to be a regular employee of the respondent college.
Mere extension of benefit of regular pay-scale would not make him a
regular employee of the college. Apart from the contentions raised on
behalf of the respondents No. 3, 4 & 5, the submissions advanced on
2024:MLHC:829-DB
behalf of the State-respondents No.1 & 2, the respondent No.6 and the
respondent No.7, make it crystal clear that the appointment of the
appellant in the college had no approval of the competent authority.
There is nothing in the aforesaid provisions of the Act and the Rules
implying inclusion of contract or temporary workers or those who are
not appointed by following the prescribed norms of appointment, be
termed as employees of the institution.
16.
It is clear that the appellant’s induction in the service of the
respondent-college has no involvement of public law element.
If
according to the appellant, there is an illegality or infirmity in his
discontinuation of service, the same totally falls under the realm of
private contract. It cannot be said the college was discharging any
public duty in connection with the appointment of the appellant.
17.
For what has been discussed above, the impugned order dated
15-04-2024 passed in WP(C) No. 107 of 2020 does not call for any
interference.
18.
The appeal stands dismissed. No costs.
2024:MLHC:829-DB
(B. Bhattacharjee)
Judge
(H. S. Thangkhiew)
Chief Justice (Acting)
Meghalaya
10.09.2024
“Biswarup-PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.09.10 15:35:50 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review