Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P(S). No. 5388 of 2024
---Jata Shankar Singh, aged about 68 years, Son of Late Marsa Ram Singh,
Resident of near Old Sai Mandir, Barganda, P.O-Giridih, P.S. Giridih, District
Giridih/Jharkhand, District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
.......Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Secretary, Department of Higher and Technical Education, Govt. of
Jharkhand at Nepal House, P.O-Doranda and P.S Doranda, District
Ranchi, Jharkhand
3. The Vice-Chancellor, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O Hazaribagh, P.S
Hazaribagh, District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
4. The Registrar, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O Hazaribagh, P.S Hazaribagh,
District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
.....Respondents
With
W.P(S). No. 5585 of 2024
---Usha Singh aged about 71 years, daughter of Dr. R.P Sinha resident of house
No. 90, Bank colony Mission School road P.S Sadar, P.O Hazaribagh, District
Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
.......Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Secretary, Department of Higher and Technical Education, Govt. of
Jharkhand at Nepal House, P.O-Doranda and P.S Doranda, District
Ranchi, Jharkhand
3. The Vice-Chancellor, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O Hazaribagh, P.S
Hazaribagh, District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
4. The Registrar, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O Hazaribagh, P.S Hazaribagh,
District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
.....Respondents
With
W.P(S). No. 5847 of 2024
---Ajit Kumar Pathak, aged about 67 years, son of Late Krishna Kumar Pathak,
resident of Imli Kothi, Barka Gaon Road, P.O Hazaribagh, P.S Hazaribagh,
District Hazaribagh, Jharkhand
.......Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand
2. Secretary, Department of Higher and Technical Education, Govt. of
Jharkhand at Nepal House, P.O-Doranda and P.S Doranda, District
Ranchi, Jharkhand
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
3. The Vice-Chancellor, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O Hazaribagh
Jharkhand, P.S Hazaribagh, District Hazaribagh,
4. The Registrar, Vinoba Bhave University, P.O Hazaribagh, P.S Hazaribagh,
District Hazaribagh,
.....Respondents
--CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
--For the Petitioners
: Mr. Saurav Aurn, Advocate
: Mr. Bhanu Kumar No.1, Advocate
: Mr. Rohit Ranjan Singh, Advocate
: Ms. Ayushi, Advocate
For the Respondents
: Mr. Abhinay Kumar, AC to GA-I
: Mr. Amaresh Kumar, Advocate
: Mr. Namita Sahay, Advocate
: Mr. J.F. Toppo, GA-V
: Mr. Neil Abhijit Toppo, AC to GA-V
--03/ Dated: 23.06.2026
Since the issue involved in all these three applications are same
and similar and facts are also inter-connected, accordingly, with
the consent of the parties, all these writ applications are being
disposed of by this common order. For brevity, the prayer made in
the respective writ petitions are mentioned hereinbelow:
WP(S) No. 5388 of 2024
The instant writ application has been preferred by the petitioner for
the following relief(s):i.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or
a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing of
part of Letter dated 15.09.2022, especially note
part as contained in Annexure-2, by which the pay
scale of the Petitioner has been fixed at Rs.12,000
in place of Rs 14,940 and further it has stated that
the increment will be given to the lecturer only.
ii.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or
a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing of
Letter
dated
08.09.2023,
as
contained
in
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
Annexure-6 as by Executive order section 2(v) of
University Act cannot be amended.
iii.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or
a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
upon the respondents to fix pay scale of the
Petitioner in the terms of letter dated 30.11.2004 &
30.05.2005 and fix the same in basic pay scale of
Rs 14,940 and pay arrears thereof.
iv.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or
a writ in the nature of mandamus declaring the act
of the authority as bad in law, as section 2(v) of
University Act cannot be amended by executive
order and moreover wrong fixation has been done
without giving any show cause to the Petitioner,
no opportunity has been given for being heard
before issuance of impugned order.
v.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or
a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding
upon the Respondents to fix the basic pay scale of
Rs 14,940 on completion of 5 years as a Reader
and being having PhD and also declare the
fixation is wrong as Rs 3625 w.e.f. 01.01.1996
which replacement scale is Rs 12000 in place of Rs
14940.
WP(S) No. 5585 of 2024
The instant writ application has been preferred by the petitioner for
the following relief(s):i.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing of part
of Letter dated 16.06.2022, especially note part as
contained in Annexure-2, by which the pay scale of
the Petitioner has been fixed at Rs.12,000 in place
of Rs 14,940 and further it has stated that the
increment will be given to the lecturer only.
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
ii.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing of
Letter dated 08.09.2023, as contained in Annexure6 as by Executive order section 2(v) of University
Act cannot be amended.
iii.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon
the respondents to fix pay scale of the Petitioner in
the terms of letter dated 30.11.2004 & 30.05.2005
and fix the same in basic pay scale of Rs 14,940 and
pay arrears thereof.
iv.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus declaring the act of
the authority as bad in law, as section 2(v) of
University Act cannot be amended by executive
order and moreover wrong fixation has been done
without giving any show cause to the Petitioner, no
opportunity has been given for being heard before
issuance of impugned order.
v.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon
the Respondents to fix the basic pay scale of Rs
14,940 on completion of 5 years as a Reader and
being having PhD and also declare the fixation is
wrong
as
Rs
3625 w.e.f. 01.01.1996
which
replacement scale is Rs 12000 in place of Rs 14940.
WP(S) No. 5847 of 2024
The instant writ application has been preferred by the petitioner for
the following relief(s):i.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing of part
of Letter dated 13.06.2022, with its enclosure where
the pay has been fixed wrongly, especially note part
as contained in Annexure-2, by which the pay scale
of the Petitioner has been fixed at Rs.12,000 in
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
place of Rs 14,940 and further it has stated that the
increment will be given to the lecturer only.
ii.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing of
Letter dated 08.09.2023, as contained in Annexure6 as by Executive order section 2(v) of University
Act cannot be amended.
iii.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon
the respondents to fix pay scale of the Petitioner in
the terms of letter dated 30.11.2004 & 30.05.2005
and fix the same in basic pay scale of Rs 14,940 and
pay arrears thereof.
iv.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus declaring the act of
the authority as bad in law, as section 2(v) of
University Act cannot be amended by executive
order and moreover wrong fixation has been done
without giving any show cause to the Petitioner, no
opportunity has been given for being heard before
issuance of impugned order.
v.
For issuance of a writ(s)/order (s)/direction (s) or a
writ in the nature of mandamus commanding upon
the Respondents to fix the basic pay scale of Rs
14,940 on completion of 5 years as a Reader and
being having PhD and also declare the fixation is
wrong
as
Rs
3625 w.e.f. 01.01.1996
which
replacement scale is Rs 12000 in place of Rs 14940.
2. At the outset, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that
the issue involved in these writ applications is squarely covered
by the order passed by this Court in WP(S) No. 5455 of 2023,
wherein this Court has dealt the issue in detail, as such, similar
benefit may be granted to the above petitioners.
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
3. Learned counsel for the State and the University does not
oppose the aforesaid contention and submits that all these cases
are covered by the judgment rendered by this Court in WP(S)
No. 5455 of 2023.
4. Having regard to the above submissions and after going through
the facts and prayer made in all these applications, it appears
that the prayer of increment/ pay-scale raised by the respective
petitioners in their respective writ-applications have been dealt
in detail in the above referred case.
5. For brevity, para-6 to para-9 of W.P(S) No. 5455 of 2023 are
extracted herein below:“6. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after
going through the documents annexed with the respective
affidavits
especially
Annexure-5,6,11&15
in
W.P.S
No.5455/23, W.P.S No.5789/23, W.P.S No.7396/23, it
appears that after the appeal preferred by the State was
allowed and two scale of Reader was set aside; thereafter,
the respondents came with provisional pay fixation of
teachers in several colleges in which at the bottom it has
been indicated as "Note-PhD increments will be applicable
only for Lecturer/Assistant Professor" which has directly
affected the pay scale of these petitioners who are readers. It
has been stated that PhD increment is admissible to the
Lecturer only.
In this regard it is necessary to indicate that Section
2(V) defines Teacher as Principal, University Professor,
College Professor, Reader, Lecturer, Demonstrator, and other
person imparting instruction in Department, College or
Institute maintained by the State. It further transpires from
the Statute No.1 which is the general condition of the service,
wherein Section 22(1) stipulates that the increment can be
withheld as measures of punishment; otherwise entitles as a
matter of course. At this stage it is also pertinent to mention
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
that no notice was ever served to the respective petitioners
before taking the decision.
7. It has been admitted by both the parties that statute no.22,
4th UGC pay scale has been adopted by State by virtue of
appendix-1 Clause (11). Further 5th UGC scale has been
adopted by the State and Clause 6 speaks about incentive for
PhD/M. Phil qualification. Therefore, when Section 2(V) of
the University Act itself says that Teacher means Reader also
then simply by an executive order Section 2(V) of the
University Act cannot be amended. In this regard it would be
profitable to refer the judgment in the case of K. Kuppusamy
& Anr. Vs. State of T. N. and others reported in (1998) 8
Supreme Court Cases 469 wherein it has been held by Hon'ble
Apex Court that Rule framed cannot be overridden by
executive orders or executive practice. For brevity para-3 of
the said judgment is quoted hereinbelow:
3. The short point on which these appeals must
succeed is that the Tribunal fell into an error in
taking the view that since the Government had
indicated its intention to amend the relevant rules,
its action in proceeding on the assumption of such
amendment could not be said to be irrational or
arbitrary and, therefore, the consequential orders
passed have to be upheld. We are afraid this line
of approach cannot be countenanced. The relevant
rules, it is admitted, were framed under the proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution. They are
statutory rules. Statutory rules cannot be
overridden by executive orders or executive
practice. Merely because the Government had
taken a decision to amend the rules does not mean
that the rule stood obliterated. Till the rule is
amended, the rule applies, Even today the
amendment has not been effected. As and when it
is effected ordinarily it would be prospective in
nature unless expressly or by necessary
implication found to be retrospective. The
Tribunal was, therefore, wrong in ignoring the
rule.
8. The law is now no more res-integra that administrative
instructions/circular/orders cannot override statutory rules. The
note part in Annexure-5 & 6 referred to hereinabove indicates
that PhD increment is admissible to Lecturer only which is
against Section 2(V) of the University Act and as stated
( 2026:JHHC:18961 )
hereinabove the statute cannot amend by an executive order and
accordingly Section 2(V) of the University Act cannot be
amended by executive Act, even the increment payable to
employees under the provisions of article 22 of the Statutes,
framed under the provision of the University Act and approved by
the Chancellor, and according to the said Article, increment is
payable to the University servant as a matter of course, unless it
is withheld by the authority empowered to appoint him, as a
measure of punishment, on this ground also order impugned is
bad in law.
9. Having regard to the aforesaid discussions, the note part
indicated in Annexure-5 & 6 of W.P.(S) No.5455 of 2023, W.P.(S)
No.5789 of 2023, W.P.(S) No.7396 of 2023 and also Annexure11& 15 in respective Interlocutory Application wherein it has
been stated that PhD increment is admissible to the Lecturer only,
is hereby, quashed and set aside.
6. Since the issue has already been decided which has been
admitted by the respective respondents; as such, all these writ
applications stands allowed.
7. Accordingly, part of Letter dated 15.09.2022 and 08.09.2023 in
WP(S) No. 5388 of 2024; part of Letter dated 16.06.2022 and
08.09.2023 in WP(S) No. 5585 of 2024 and part of Letter dated
13.06.2022 and 08.09.2023 in W.P(S) No. 5847 of 2024, is
hereby, quashed and set aside.
8. As a result thereof, consequential benefits along with arrears
shall be extended to the respective petitioners, within a period
of 12 weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
23.06.2026
Abha/-
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review