Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:1609-DB
I N THE HI GH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT
NAI NI TAL
W r i t Pe t i t i o n ( S/ B) N o . 2 9 0 o f 2 0 1 8
Aj ay Kum ar & Anot her
… Pet it ioners
Versus
St at e of Ut t arakhand & Ot hers
… Respondent s
Mr. Deep Chandra Joshi, Advocat e, for t he pet it ioners.
Mr. P.C. Bisht , Addit ional CSC, for t he St at e.
Mr. Vikas Bahuguna, Advocat e, for t he r espondent no. 5.
JUD GMENT
H o n ’ b l e M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.
H o n ’ b l e Pa n k a j Pu r o h i t , J.
( Pe r : H o n ’ b l e M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.)
Pet it ioners
have
challenged
t he
j udgm ent and order dat ed 1.6.2018, rendered by
Ut t arakhand Public Services Tribunal in Claim
Pet it ion No. 19/ DB/ 2016 and Claim Pet it ion No.
30/ DB/ 2017. By t he said j udgm ent , t he challenge
t hrown by t he pet it ioners t o t he seniorit y list
dat ed 7.6.2017 was rej ect ed and it was held t hat
int er
se
seniorit y
of
pet it ioners
and
privat e
respondent s was right ly det erm ined in t erm s of
Rule 7 of Ut t arakhand Governm ent
Servant s
Seniorit y Rules, 2002.
2.
Brief fact s of t he case, as culled out
from t he im pugned j udgm ent , are t hat pet it ioners
and privat e respondent s were appoint ed t o Group
II
post
in
t he
year
1999;
pet it ioners were
appoint ed on t he said post on 17.12.1999, while
privat e respondent no. 5 was so appoint ed on
2026:UHC:1609-DB
11.1.1999.
It
is
also
not
in
disput e
t hat
respondent no. 5 was appoint ed on t he result of
earlier select ion, while pet it ioners part icipat ed in
a select ion process, which was init iat ed lat er.
Pet it ioners were subsequent ly prom ot ed t o a
Group I post vide order dat ed 26.10.2005, while
respondent no. 5 was prom ot ed t o a Group I post
on 2.2.2006. Pet it ioners have challenged t he final
seniorit y list of Group I officers, published on
7.6.2017, by cont ending t hat since t hey were
prom ot ed earlier in point of t im e com pared t o
respondent no. 5, t herefore, t hey are ent it led t o
be placed above respondent no. 5 in t he final
seniorit y list .
3.
Learned
Tribunal
considered
t he
provisions of t he recruit m ent rules applicable for
t he post s in quest ion and also t he Ut t arakhand
Governm ent Servant s Seniorit y Rules, 2002 and
held
t hat
in
view
of
non
obst ant e
clause
cont ained in Rule 3 of t he Seniorit y Rules, t hey
shall
prevail
over
t he
det erm ining seniorit y.
recruit m ent
rules
for
Learned Tribunal relied
upon Rule 7 of Ut t arakhand Governm ent Servant s
Seniorit y Rules, 2002, which is ext ract ed below:
“ 7 . Seniorit y where appoint m ent by prom ot ion
only from several feeding cadres – Where according t o
t he service rules, appoint m ent are t o be m ade only by
prom ot ion but from m ore t han one feeding cadres, t he
seniorit y int er se of persons appoint ed on t he result of
any one select ion shall be det erm ined according t o t he
dat e of t he order of t heir subst ant ive appoint m ent in t heir
respect ive feeding cadres.
2026:UHC:1609-DB
Explanat ion – Where t he order of t he subst ant ive
appoint m ent in t he feeding cadre specifies a part icular
back dat e wit h effect from which a person is subst ant ively
appoint ed, t hat dat e will be deem ed t o be t he dat e of
order of subst ant ive appoint m ent and, in ot her cases it
will m eant t he dat e of issuance of t he order.
Provided t hat w here t he pay scales of t he
feeding cadres are different , t he persons prom ot ed from
t he feeding cadre having higher pay scale shall be senior
t o t he persons prom ot ed from t he feeding cadre having
lower pay scale.
Provided furt her t hat t he persons appoint ed
on t he result of a subsequent select ion shall be j unior t o
t he persons appoint ed on
t he result
of
a previous
t he
pet it ioners
select ion. ”
4.
Learned
Counsel
for
subm it s t hat learned Tribunal erred in law in
m isint erpret ing Rule 7, while Rule 7 provides t hat
anyone who is prom ot ed earlier in point of t im e
shall be t reat ed as senior on t he prom ot ional
post , even t hough t wo or m ore persons belonging
t o different feeding cadres are prom ot ed pursuant
t o t he sam e select ion.
5.
We do not find any reason t o int erfere
wit h t he im pugned j udgm ent , rendered by t he
Tribunal. Rule 7 of t he Seniorit y Rules applies
when prom ot ion is t he only m ode of appoint m ent
t o a post , which is t o be filled from m ore t han
one feeding cadre. Adm it t edly, in t he feeding
cadre, respondent no. 5 was senior as he was
appoint ed pursuant t o an earlier select ion and his
dat e of subst ant ive appoint m ent was also prior in
point of t im e. I n such a sit uat ion, Rule 7 provides
2026:UHC:1609-DB
t hat t he int er se seniorit y of persons appoint ed on
t he result of one prom ot ion exercise shall be
det erm ined
according
to
subst ant ive
appoint m ent
t he
in
dat e
of
t heir
t heir
respect ive
feeding cadres. Adm it t edly, respondent no. 5 was
appoint ed on a Group I I post in January 1999,
while pet it ioners were appoint ed on a Group I I
post in t he m ont h of Novem ber and Decem ber
1999, t herefore t here is no scope for any doubt
t hat pet it ioners were j unior in t he feeding cadre.
Even t hough respondent no. 5 was prom ot ed t o a
Group I post against an ant icipat ed vacancy and
t he prom ot ion was given t o respondent no. 5 on
a lat er dat e upon occurrence of vacancy on such
post , however t hat fact will not be det erm inat ive
of int er se seniorit y bet ween pet it ioners and
respondent
no. 5, as Seniorit y Rules clearly
provide t hat
anyone
who is senior
in
t heir
respect ive feeding cadre will be t reat ed t o be
senior upon prom ot ion, if t wo or m ore persons
are recom m ended for prom ot ion in t he sam e
prom ot ion
exercise. I n t he present case, bot h
pet it ioners
and
recom m ended
respondent
by
t he
no.
sam e
were
Depart m ent al
Prom ot ion Com m it t ee, t herefore t he delay in
issuing
order
of
prom ot ion
in
favour
of
respondent no. 5 will have no effect .
6.
t hen
Learned
subm it s
considered
Counsel
t hat
t he
for
Tribunal
ent ire
Rule
t he
ought
7,
pet it ioners
to
including
explanat ion and t he t wo provisos t heret o.
have
2026:UHC:1609-DB
7.
Explanat ion t o Rule 7 does not have
any applicat ion t o t he present case, as it deals
wit h a sit uat ion where som eone is appoint ed on
t he feeder post wit h ret rospect ive effect , which is
not t he case here. Sim ilarly, first proviso t o Rule
7 also is not applicable as t he pay scale of
pet it ioners as well as respondent s on t he feeder
post was t he sam e and t here was no difference in
t heir pay scales. The second proviso t o Rule 7
also
does
not
apply
to
t he
fact s
and
circum st ances of t he case, as pet it ioners as well
as respondent no. 5 were prom ot ed t o Group I
post on t he result of t he sam e select ion, which
was held on 24.10.2005. Thus t he reasoning
given by learned Tribunal cannot be fault ed. Thus
t here is no scope for int erference. Writ pet it ion
fails and is dism issed.
( Pa n k a j Pu r o h i t , J.)
( M a n o j K u m a r Ti w a r i , J.)
1 1 .3 .2 0 2 6
Pr
PRABODH
KUMAR
DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH
COURT OF UTTARAKHAND,
2.5.4.20=3a082a00a95aff911a9559743af8f21c50602ff6eae4e
61af3aeab198d462503, postalCode=263001,
st=UTTARAKHAND,
serialNumber=0DC111E8D8CA66E16B940EFDF806ACCC1AB
588052DF6FCA58C67F3C91957BE53, cn=PRABODH KUMAR
Date: 2026.03.18 18:35:09 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review