Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:24403
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.17411 of 2025 a/w
CWP No.16481 of 2025
Decided on: 22.06.2026
1. CWP No.17411 of 2025
Ajay Kumar and others
...Petitioners
Versus
Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative
Bank Ltd.
...Respondent
2. CWP No.16481 of 2025
Nakul Sharma and others
...Petitioners
Versus
Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative
Bank Ltd.
...Respondent
Coram
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes
For the petitioner(s):
Mr. Surender Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondent(s):
Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, Senior
Ad17411vocate with Mr. Raman
Jamalta, Advocate.
Jiya Lal Bhardwaj, Judge (Oral)
CMP No.12817 of 2026
By
way
of
present
application,
the
applicant/respondent has prayed for placing on record the
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
documents.
2.
Learned counsel for the non-applicants/petitioners
submits that he has no objection in case the application is
allowed and the documents annexed therewith are taken on
record.
3.
In view of the above, the application is allowed and
the documents annexed with the application are ordered to
be taken on record.
4.
The application stands disposed of.
CWP No.17411 of 2025 and CWP No.16481 of 2025
5.
Since
both
these
petitions
involve
common
questions of law and facts, the same are taken up together for
final disposal. Learned counsel for the respondent-Bank
submits that the reply filed on behalf of the respondent-Bank
in CWP No.17411 of 2025 may be considered reply in CWP
No.16481 of 2025. His statement is taken on record.
For
adjudicating the claim in these petitions, the facts of CWP
No.17411 of 2025 are taken up.
6.
The facts as emerge from pleadings are that the
petitioners were initially appointed as Junior Clerks with the
respondent-Bank in the months of September and October
2017 and joined duties. Thereafter, they have been promoted
to the post of Executive Assistant in the year 2023.
7.
The precise grouse of the petitioners in the writ
petition is that they have been denied the benefit of new
Assured Career Progression Scheme ( for short “ACPS”), which
was made applicable to the employees of the respondentBank, as per instructions dated 09.08.2012 (Annexure P-1). As
per ACPS, an employee who has completed four years’ service,
but less than eight years’ service in a cadre, will be placed in
next grade pay in the hierarchy of grade pays and his pay will
be fixed at next higher stage in the pay band, if he did not get
any promotion within four years of service. If the pay so fixed
is less than minimum of higher pay band, then his pay will be
fixed at the minimum of higher pay band. The next increment
in such cases will be given after qualifying service of 12
months in the higher pay band. Though the petitioners had
completed four years’ service without any promotion in the
months of September/October, 2021, but they were denied
the benefit of ACPS, which action is totally illegal, arbitrary and
discriminatory.
8.
It has also been averred in the petition that the
respondent-Bank has granted benefit of ACPS to other
employees on completion of four years’ service who were
appointed w.e.f. 01.01.2016 and non-grant of the benefit to
the petitioners is illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory and violative
of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
The
respondent-Bank cannot adopt double yardsticks and pick
and choose method in the matter of grant of benefit of ACPS.
The petitioners have placed on record office order dated
12.05.2021 (Annexure P-2), whereby increments under new
ACPS have been released by the respondent-Bank to its
employees. The petitioners have also placed on record the
instructions dated 03.01.2022 (Annexure P-3), which provides
that the ACPS, which is applicable under the pre-revised pay
structures will not be admissible on or after notified HP Civil
Services (RP) Rules, 2022 i.e. 03.01.2022. The petitioners have
also placed on record the office order dated 24.03.2023
(Annexure P-6), whereby the benefit of ACPS has been granted
to the employees working in the Education Department of the
State Government.
9.
The Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative Bank
Employees Union had made the request to release the
increments under ACPS to eligible employees on dated
15.06.2024 (Annexure P-4), but the said request was not
considered by the respondent-Bank and thereafter,
the
petitioners have filed the present petition before this Court,
praying the relief that they may be granted the benefit of
ACPS, after completion of four years of service since they were
not promoted within four years of their service.
10.
The respondent-Bank filed reply and has taken
preliminary objections that the petition is not maintainable, in
view of the fact that the respondent-Bank is neither a State or
other authority within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution of India, nor does it discharge any sovereign or
statutory function so as to be automatically amenable to the
writ jurisdiction. Further, it has been averred that even
assuming that the petitioners had any grievance regarding
service conditions, fixation of pay or denial of ACPS, the same
is
essentially
a
service/contractual
dispute
between
employees and a Co-operative Society and such disputes can
be raised under the H.P. Co-operative Societies Act/Rules/
Cooperative Tribunal/Registrar mechanism and also under the
applicable service rules/industrial forum. The petitioners have
specific, adequate and efficacious alternative remedy, which
can be invoked. The petitioners have already been extended
the benefit of higher initial pay corresponding to the rerevised pay scale of Rs.10300-34800 + Rs.3200 GP, instead of
their actual normal pay scale of Rs.5910-20200 + Rs.1900 GP.
The grievance raised pertains only to the mode and manner of
financial upgradation (ACPS) and interpretation of payrevision/clarificatory instructions. Neither fundamental right
nor any specific statutory right has been pleaded to be
violated. The controversy involves complex issues relating to
pay fixation, corresponding pay levels, re-revised scales,
Punjab
Pay
Commission
recommendations
and
ACPS
clarificatory instructions. The petitioners were appointed in
the year 2017 and completed four years of service in 2021.
The alleged entitlement to 1st ACPS would have arisen in 2021.
However, the petition has been instituted in the year 2025,
after a lapse of several years and as such the petition is hit by
delay and laches. It has further been averred that during this
interregnum, the pay revision, implementation of revised pay
rules of 2022 and clarificatory instructions have come into
force and the petitioners cannot now reopen settled pay
structures after having accepted the higher initial pay under
the re-revised scales. The petitioners have already been
substantially benefited by being placed in the re-revised pay
scale of Rs.10300-34800+Rs.3200 GP (with corresponding
level-3 pay of Rs.33,300/- from 01.01.2016) instead of the
actual scale of Rs.5910-20200+ Rs.1900 GP (corresponding
Level-3 pay Rs.20,200/-). As per clarificatory instructions on
ACPS
dated 26.02.2013 (Annexure R-1), where a financial
enhancement has already been granted, separate ACPS
benefits are not admissible. As such, the writ petition is liable
to be dismissed as misconceived.
11.
I have heard the learned counsel for parties and
also perused the record carefully.
12.
Mr. Surender Sharma, learned counsel for the
petitioners argued that the petition is maintainable in view of
the judgment passed by a coordinate Bench of the Court in
CWP No.4031 of 2021, titled, Suresh Kaushal vs. State of H.P.
and others. A perusal of the judgment reveals that the petition
is maintainable even if the Bank is not a State within the
meaning of Article 12 of the constitution of India. Relevant
paras of the judgment read as under:-
“11. Taking the issue of maintainability first, it will be
relevant to notice the mandate as rendered by the Hon’ble
Division Bench of this Court in C. K. Malhotra (supra). The
relevant extract of the same is reproduced as under:“98. Consequently, we have no hesitation in
holding that the three Societies, namely. The
Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative Bank Ltd.;
The Kangra Central Co-operative Bank Ltd, and
the Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative
Marketing and Development Federation Ltd, are
not other authorities' and, as such, cannot be
characterised as 'State' when the meaning of
Art. 12 of the Constitution and the same are also
not authority within the meaning and for the
purpose of Article 226 of the Constitution. Order
passed by the Societies under their respective
service regulations against its employees, as
such, or in connection with employment cannot
be corrected by way of writ petitions. The
petitions also would not be maintainable in
order to challenge the action of the Registrar
since the same is not an exercise of statutory
power conferred upon him under the provisions
of the Act or the Rules but an exercise of powers
by him under service regulations framed under
Bye-laws having no force of law. The writ
petition also will not be maintainable since none
of the three Societies are discharging any public
functions.”
12. Indisputably, it was mandated firstly that the Himachal
Pradesh State Co-operative Bank Limited was not the other
authority to be characterised as State within the meaning of
Article 12 of the Constitution and was also not an authority
for the purpose of Article 226 of the Constitution. It was
further held that the order passed by the Society under its
service regulations against its employees as such or any
kind of employment cannot be corrected by way of writ
petition. The petitions to challenge the action of Registrar
were also held to be not maintainable since the same was
not an exercise of statutory powers conferred upon him
under the provisions of the Act or the rules but an exercise
of powers by him under service regulations framed under
bye-laws having no force of law. Further, the writ petitions
against the bank were held to be not maintainable since the
Society was not discharging any public functions.
13. The pronouncement in C. K. Malhotra (supra) came for
consideration before a Full bench of this Court in CWP No.
3634 of 2012, titled as, Vikram Chauhan vs. Managing
Director & others along with connected matters reported in
Latest HLJ 2013 (H.P.) 742 (FB). The Hon’ble Full Bench of this
Court after taking notice of the question referred to it
observed as under:“The Division Bench while hearing CWP NO 3634 of
2012-D vide order dated 20 July, 2012 has referred the
following question to be considered by the Full Bench.
"Whether the Kangra Central Co-operative Bank,
the Himachal Pradesh State Co-operative Bank
Ltd and the Jogindra Central Co- operative Bank,
are 'State' within the meaning of Article 12 of
the Constitution of India and whether a writ
would lie against them?"
2. The question, as formulated raises two independent
issues. Firstly, whether the State Cooperative Banks are
State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution? The second question, which, in our view
is an independent question, is, whether a writ would
lie against those Cooperative Banks.”
14. After discussing the law on the issues, Hon’ble Full
Bench answered the formulated issues as under:“15 For the view taken by us on both facets of the referred
questions, proceed to answer the Reference as under:
(1) The question as to whether Kangra Bank is a State
within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of
India, is no more res Integra. It has been
authoritatively answered by the Apex Court in S.S.
Rana's case (supra).
(2) Even in the case of H.P, State Cooperative Bank Ltd.,
the question has been answered by the Division Bench
of our High Court in Chandresh Kumar Malhotra's
case (supra). There is no conflicting decision of
coordinate Bench of this Court necessitating
pronouncement on that question by the Full Bench.
(3) In the case of Jogindra Central Cooperative Bank,
the decision in Mehar Chand's case (supra) is rendered
by the learned Single Judge of this Court and no
conflicting decision of the co-ordinate Bench muchless
of the Division Bench or Larger Bench of our High
Court with regard to the stated Bank has been
brought to our notice. In any case, the said question
can be conveniently answered by the Division Bench in
appropriate proceedings whether in the form of writ
petition or Reference made by the learned Single
Judge of this Court, as the case may be. As and when
such occasion arises, the issue can be answered on the
basis of settled legal principles and including keeping
in mind the exposition of S.S. Rana's case (supra) of
the Apex Court concerning another Cooperative Bank
constituted under the Himachal Pradesh State
Cooperative Act.
(4) As regards the second part of the question as to
whether a writ would lie against the stated
Cooperative Banks, we hold that it is not appropriate
to give a definite answer to this question. For, it would
depend on several attending factors. Further, even if
the said Banks were held to be not a State within the
meaning of Article 12, the High Court in exercise of
powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
can certainly issue a writ or order in the nature of writ
even against any person or Authority, if the fact
situation of the case so warrants. In other words, writ
can lie even against a Corporative Society. Whether the
same should be issued by the High Court would
depend on the facts of each case.”
15. Thus, the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench in C.K. Malhotra was upheld in so far as it had held
that the Bank was not a State or other authority within the
meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution. However, while
answering the second facet of the issue, the Hon’ble Full
Bench specifically held that no definite answer could be
given to the question referred to it and would depend on
several attending factors. Even if the Bank was held to be
not a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution, the High Court in exercise of powers under
Article 226 of the Constitution was held jurisdiction to issue
a writ or order in nature of writ even against any person or
authority, if the fact situation of the case warranted. It has
further been held that the writ can lie even against the cooperative authorities, however, its maintainability would
depend on the facts of each case.
16. Recently, in petition for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil)
No. 1246 of 2015, titled as, The Kangra Central Co-operative
Bank Pensioners Welfare Association (Regt.) vs. State of H.P.,
three Judges Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court after
taking the notice of what has been held by the Full Bench in
Vikram Chauhan (supra) has held as under:“The issue concerning maintainability was considered
by the Full bench and the observations made by the
Full bench summed up the law on the point quite
succinctly. On the facts as found by the Single Judge,
which were recorded in paragraph 19 of the judgment,
without entering into any other question, in our view,
the petition as filed was perfectly maintainable. The
Division Bench was in error in setting aside the view
taken by the Single Judge in allowing the writ petition
and in rejecting the review petition.”
17. In view of above exposition, it cannot be said that the
writ against the Bank will not be maintainable in any
circumstance.”
13.
Again in another judgment passed in CWPOA
No.3767 of 2019, titled, Anil Abrol and others Vs. H.P. State
Cooperative Agriculture & Rural Development Bank Ltd. and
others, it has been held that writ petition against the
respondent-Bank
is
maintainable.
Therefore,
arguments
raised by the learned Senior counsel for the respondent-Bank
that the writ petition is not maintainable is rejected.
14.
appointed
It is not in dispute that the petitioners have been
as
Junior
Clerks
in
the
months
of
September/October, 2017 and had completed four years of
service in the months of September/October, 2021 and further
they did not get any promotion during this period. The
petitioners have been promoted to the post of Executive
Assistant in the year 2023. It is also not in dispute that the
instructions dated 09.08.2012 are not applicable to the
respondent-Bank. The plea taken by the respondent-Bank that
the
petitioners,
were
already
granted
the
financial
upgradation when they were appointed to the post of Junior
Clerk, cannot be accepted for the simple reason that as per
ACPS, an employee who had completed four years’ service but
less than eight years of service in the cadre was to be placed
in the next grade pay in the hierarchy of grade pays if not got
promotion. The relevant para of the ACPS dated 09.08.2012
(Annexure P-1) is reproduced hereunder:
“(b)
An employee who has completed
four years service but less than 8 years service
in a cadre will be placed in next grade pay in
the hierarchy of grade pays and his pay will be
fixed at next higher stage in the pay band. If the
pay so fixed is less than the minimum of higher
pay band than his pay will be fixed at the
minimum of higher pay band. The next
increment in such cases will be given after
qualifying service of 12 months in the higher
pay band.”
15.
A perusal of the above para clearly reveals that the
employees are entitled to be placed in next grade pay in the
hierarchy of grade pays and since the petitioner did not get
any promotion within a period of four years and ultimately,
they were promoted as Executive Assistants in the year 2023,
they cannot be denied the benefit of ACPS. Not only this, in
case of other employees of the respondent-Bank, who were
appointed have been granted the benefit of ACPS immediately
after completion of four years of service in the year 2016 and
thus denying the said benefit to the petitioners is unjust,
arbitrary and discriminatory.
16.
Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, learned Senior counsel has
placed much reliance upon the instructions dated 15.12.2011
(Annexure AR-1/1) to submit that once the petitioners, when
they were initially appointed as Junior Clerk were already
granted the revised scale of pay of Rs.10300-34800+ GP of
Rs.3200, the
benefit of ACPS cannot be extended to them.
However, the said submission cannot be accepted for the
simple reason that after issuance of instructions dated
15.12.2011
by
the
Government
of
Punjab,
the
State
Government had issued the instructions dated 09.08.2012
(Annexure P-1), whereby the benefit of next grade pay in the
hierarchy of grade pays was held to be granted to the
employees, who do not get any promotion within four years
of their service.
17.
In the present case, as already noticed above, the
petitioners were not promoted to the next higher post within
four years of their service and, therefore, they are entitled to
get the benefit of ACPS after completion of four years’ service.
18.
Mr. Sunil Mohan Goel, learned Senior counsel for
the respondent-Bank further placed much reliance upon the
instructions dated 26.02.2013 (Annexure AR-1/3), to contend
that as per these instructions, for the purpose of granting
benefit of ACPS under 4-9-14 and 8-16-24-32, the re-revision of
pay structures shall be treated as financial enhancement and
as such the petitioners are not entitled to get the benefit of
ACPS, once they have already been granted the financial
upgradation when they were initially appointed to the posts of
Junior Clerk. However, the said submission cannot be accepted
for the simple reason that as per instructions dated
09.08.2012, the employees who do not get any promotion
were held entitled to the benefit of ACPS after completion of
4, 9 and 14 years of service. It is relevant to mention here that
a coordinate Bench of this Court in CWPOA No.5536 of 2020,
titled, Sanjay Kumar Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & others
along with connected matters, decided on 01.11.2023, had the
occasion to consider the Notification dated 26.02.2013 and
held that financial upgradation, if any, on account of pay
revision/revision of grade pay cannot be a ground to deny
benefit of financial upgradation under ACPS which become
due after completion of 4, 9 and 14 years as per ACPS. The
relevant paras of the judgment read as under:
“11.
Careful perusal of aforesaid instructions clearly
reveals that an employee is granted three enhancements/
upgradations/ promotion, he/ she shall not be eligible for
grant of further benefit, if any, under ACPS, but in the
case at hand, petitioners after being appointed as JBT
though were given two benefits of financial upgradation
under ACPS, first benefit was granted under old ACPS
after their having completed eight years service, whereas
second benefit was granted in their favour after their
having completed nine years service under new ACPS and
third benefit in terms of new ACPS, for which petitioners
have already opted, is being denied on the ground that
vide order dated 26.02.2013 grade pay of the petitioners
has been enhanced w.e.f. 1.10.2012. However, as
observed hereinabove, financial upgradation, if any, on
account of pay revision/revision of grade pay cannot be a
ground to deny benefit of financial upgradations under
ACPS, which become due after completion of four, nine
and fourteen years as per new ACPS. Though, it has been
vehemently argued on behalf of the respondents/State
that grade pay of the petitioners was enhanced, as a
result of which, their pay was enhanced, but as has been
taken note above, financial enhancement on account of
annual increment or general pay revision, based on pay
commission, is not to be considered while considering the
case of an employee for grant of benefit of ACPS. Since, in
the case at hand pay of the petitioners came to be
enhanced on account of grant of grade pay, benefit of
financial upgradation in terms of provision contained
under ACPS cannot be denied.
12. True, it is that careful perusal of communication
26.02.2023, which has been relied heavily by the
respondents, suggests that a government employee after
rendering service of 4,9 and 14 years in a post or posts
without
any
financial
enhancement
in
the
same
cadre/post, if not promoted to higher level on account of
non availability of a vacancy or non- existence of
promotional avenue in the cadre, shall be granted the
grade pay, which is next higher in the hierarchy of grade
pay given in the schedule annexed to Revised Pay Rules,
2009 upto maximum grade pay of Rs.8900/- and on
placement in the next higher grade pay in the hierarchy
of grade pays after service of 4, 9 and 14 years, but such
benefit of re-revision of pay shall be treated as financial
enhancement for the purpose of granting benefit under
4-9-14 and 8-16-24-32 but there is nothing to dispute that
vide notification dated 7th July 2014 (Annexure P-5), it
specifically came to be clarified that once an employee
has already got three enhancements/financial upgradations i.e. grant of progression under the new or old
ACPS or promotion or any other financial enhancement,
except the annual increment or the general pay revision
based on the pay commission, in fourteen years or more
during his/her entire service will not be entitled for
placement in next higher grade pay in the ACP Scheme
introduced vide instructions dated 9th August 2012. It is
quite apparent from perusal of aforesaid letter that
financial upgradation, if any, on account of pay revision
cannot be a ground to deny benefit under ACPS. Since pay
of the petitioners came to be enhanced on account of
enhancement
in
grade
pay,
benefit
of
financial
upgradation in terms of ACPS cannot be denied.
13. Consequently, in view of the discussions made
hereinabove, this Court finds merit in the instant petitions
and accordingly same are allowed. Office order dated
3.08.2018 (Annexure A-8) is quashed and set aside and
the respondents are directed to consider the case of the
petitioners for grant of financial upgradation under ACPS
(4-9-14) time scale/enhancement after their having
completed 14 years of service at par with their
counterparts from the due date. Since petitioners have
been fighting for their rightful claim for years together,
this Court hopes and trusts that needful shall be done in
terms of the directions contained in the instant judgment
expeditiously, preferably within a period of six weeks.
Pending applications, if any, also stands disposed of.”
19.
Learned senior counsel for the respondent-Bank
has further contended that the dispute regarding ACPS can be
raised under the HP Co-operative Societies Act/Rules/Cooperative Tribunal/Registrar. However, the said contention
cannot be accepted for the simple reason that the service
disputes cannot be adjudicated under the Act and Rules. It is
admitted fact that there is no Tribunal having been created by
the State Government to redress the issues pertaining to the
employees, who are serving with the Banks, which has been
created under the HP Cooperative Societies Act, 1968 and thus
the said plea is rejected.
So far as another plea that the issue relating to pay
fixation, corresponding pay levels, re-revised scales etc. is to
be adjudicated only by the expert bodies is concerned, no
doubt, it is not within the realm of the Court to fix the pay
scale of an employee and it is within the domain of the
executive or the employer. However, in the present case, the
petitioners are not seeking the equation of the pay scale of
their category either on the analogy of pay scale granted to
the employees of the Punjab Government or in other
departments of the State Government. The petitioners are
only seeking the grant of benefit of ACPS, which admittedly is
to be enforced by the Court once the benefit thereof has not
been extended to them. As already noticed above, it is not the
case of the respondent-Bank that ACPS is not applicable to its
employees, but the only plea taken is that once the petitioners
have been granted financial upgradation at the time of
offering them appointments as Junior Clerks, they are not
entitled to get the same. Since the petitioners did not get any
promotion within four years of their initial service, they are
entitled to the benefit of ACPS once the benefit has been
granted to other employees of the respondent-Bank. It is a
case of discrimination.
21.
The other ground raised by the respondent-Bank
in the reply that the petition is hit by delay and laches on the
ground that the entitlement to 1st ACPS, had arisen in the year
2021 and the petition has been instituted in the year 2025.
Since the non-grant of the benefit of ACPS is affecting the
petitioners every month when they get salary, it is a recurring
cause of action and they cannot be denied the said benefit. At
the most, the petitioners can be denied the benefit of the
arrears on account of ACPS, in view of the law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India and others vs.
Tarsem Singh, (2008) 8 SCC 648, and the relevant paras of the
judgment read as under:
“7. To summarise, normally, a belated service related
claim will be rejected on the ground of delay and
laches (where remedy is sought by filing a writ
petition) or limitation (where remedy is sought by an
application to the Administrative Tribunal). One of the
exceptions to the said rule is cases relating to a
continuing wrong. Where a service related claim is
based on a continuing wrong, relief can be granted
even if there is a long delay in seeking remedy, with
reference to the date on which the continuing wrong
commenced, if such continuing wrong creates a
continuing source of injury. But there is an exception
to the exception. If the grievance is in respect of any
order or administrative decision which related to or
affected several others also, and if the reopening of
the issue would affect the settled rights of third
parties, then the claim will not be entertained. For
example, if the issue relates to payment or refixation
of pay or pension, relief may be granted in spite of
delay as it does not affect the rights of third parties.
But if the claim involved issues relating to
seniority or promotion, etc., affecting others,
delay would render the claim stale and doctrine of
laches/limitation will be applied. Insofar as the
consequential relief of recovery of arrears for a
past period is concerned, the principles relating to
recurring/successive wrongs will apply. As a
consequence, the High Courts will restrict the
consequential relief relating to arrears normally
to a period of three years prior to the date of
filing of the writ petition.
8. In this case, the delay of sixteen years would affect
the consequential claim for arrears. The High Court
was not justified in directing payment of arrears
relating to sixteen years, and that too with interest. It
ought to have restricted the relief relating to arrears
to only three years before the date of writ petition, or
from the date of demand to date of writ petition,
whichever was lesser. It ought not to have granted
interest on arrears in such circumstances.”
22.
From a perusal of the aforementioned dictum of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is crystal clear that the grant of
benefit of ACPS is affecting the petitioners every month and it
is a recurring cause of action. The petitioners are denied the
arrears from the initial date of the benefit accrued in their
favour in the year 2021 and the same shall be paid to them
three years prior to the filing of the writ petition.
23.
Consequently, both the petitions are allowed and
the respondent(s)-Bank is directed to grant the benefit of
ACPS to the petitioners after completion of four years of
service
with
all
consequential
benefits.
However,
the
petitioners shall be paid the arrears from three years prior to
the date of filing the present petition. In case arrears are not
paid to the petitioners within three months from today, the
respondent-Bank shall pay interest on the arrears @6% per
annum from today till actual payment.
24.
Both the petitions are accordingly disposed of. No
order as to costs. Pending application(s), if any, shall also
stand disposed of.
22nd June, 2026
(Kiran)
( Jiya Lal Bhardwaj )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review