Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
signed by
KHOIROM Digitally
KHOIROM
BIPINCHANDRA
BIPINCHAN Date: 2024.05.13SINGH
DRA SINGH 13:53:41 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 29 OF 2023
Ainul Haque Talukdar, aged about 49 years, S/o Late
Asakandar Ali Talukdar, resident of Dudhpatil Pt. VI,
P.O- Aticherra-7, Cachar, Assam-788002.
…. Petitioner
- Versus –
The Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, represented
by its Intelligence Officer, Imphal Regional Unit,
Manipur, Office of Hotel Imphal, North AOC Point,
Imphal-Dimapur
Road,
Imphal
West
District,
Manipur-795001.
…. Respondent
BEFORE
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
For the petitioner
:
Mr. Juno Rahman, Advocate
For the respondent
:
Mr. Th. Sanachouba, Advocate
Date of hearing
:
16.02.2024
Date of order
:
10.05.2024
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 1
J U D G EM E N T & O R D E R
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. Juno Rehman, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner and Mr. Th. Sanachouba, learned counsel appearing
for the respondent at length.
[2]
The present Bail Application has been filed under section
439 of Cr.P.C, 1973 r/w Section 37 of the ND&PS Act, 1985 and
Section 167 (2) Cr.P.C, 1973 for releasing the petitioner on bail till
the conclusion of Special Trial (ND&PS) Case No. 05 of 2023 pending
before the Court of Special Judge, ND&PS, Tamenglong, Manipur.
with the following prayers:
“(ii) to release the humble petitioner on bail in connection
with Crime Case No. 01/CL/NDPS/HEROIN/ILP/2022-23 dated
18.03.2023 u/s 22, 23 & 25 of the ND&PS Act, 1985 in the
facts and circumstances of the present Bail Application.”
[3]
On 18th March, 2023 at around 03:30 pm while en-route
to Imphal, the petitioner’s Truck was stopped at Khongsang Village,
Nungba, Tamenglong by the officials of Directorate of Revenue
Intelligence, Imphal. Thereafter, the petitioner along with his Truck
was directed/ instructed to follow the officials to their office at
Porompat, Imphal East District, Manipur. Upon reaching the office of
the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence at Porompat, Imphal East
District, Manipur the officials recovered around 170 (one hundred
and seventy) soap cases believed to be Heroin. Accordingly, the
petitioner was arrested and placed under custody on 18.03.2023 in
connection with case No. 01/LD/NDPS/HEROIN/DRI/IMP/2022-23
dated 18.03.2023 U/s 21(c), 23(c), 25, 29 & 60 of the ND&PS Act,
1985.
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 2
[4]
Subsequent to the arrest, the petitioner was produced
before the Court of the Duty Magistrate/ Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Tamenglong in Cril. Misc. Case No 9 of 2023. Accordingly, the Court
of Duty Magistrate/ CJM, Tamenglong passed an order dated
19.03.2023 remanding the petitioner to judicial custody for
14(fourteen) days with direction to produce the petitioner before the
Hon’ble Special Judge, (ND&PS), Tamenglong on 01.04.2023. Since,
then the petitioner has been languishing in jail till date.
[5]
As the petitioner was languishing in jail for more than 180
days prior to filing of the Charge Sheet, the petitioner moved the
Court of Special Judge, ND&PS, Tamenglong, Manipur for releasing
the petitioner on bail by way of Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 5 of 2023.
After hearing both the parties and upon perusal of the materials
placed on record, the Court of Special Judge, (ND&PS), Tamenglong,
Manipur passed an order dated 14.09.2023 in Cril. Misc. (B) Case No.
5 of 2023 releasing the petitioner on bail by furnishing PR bond of
Rs. 1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only and 2(two) local sureties of
the like amount to the satisfaction of the Court. However, the
petitioner was unable to furnish the PR bond immediately and took
some time.
[6]
Meanwhile on 27.09.2023, the petitioner made a request
to furnish the said PR bond before the Court of Special Judge, ND &
PS, Tamenglong but the same was refused and remanded into
further custody of 15(fifteen) days with no specific ground for
refusing the said PR bond furnished by the petitioner.
[7]
On
11.10.2023,
the
Special
Judge
(ND
&
PS),
Tamenglong passed an order in Special Trial (ND & PS) Case No. 5
of 2023 thereby cancelling the order dated 14.09.2023 passed in
Cril. Misc (B) Case No. 05 of 2023 wherein the petitioner was
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 3
released on bail on the ground that charge sheet has already been
filed.
[8]
During the course of hearing the learned counsel for the
petitioner submitted that the Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong,
Manipur failed to appreciate the fact that the petitioner was already
granted bail prior to filing of the Charge sheet on 14.09.2023 and
that the charge sheet was filed only on 27.09.203. The only reason
that the petitioner was still in custody at the time of filing the charge
sheet was for the reason that the petitioner was not able to furnish
the PR of Rs. 1,00,000/- and 2 local sureties of like amount. That on
27.09.2023 when the petitioner was ready to furnish the said
conditions, the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong refused
to entertain the same on the ground that the charge sheet has been
filed by the Special PP for DRI, only on the ground that charge sheet
has been filed, the right to be released on bail was curtailed thereby
remanding the petitioner into further custody. Since then the
petitioner has been languishing in jail till date with no hope for
freedom even though Bail has already been granted by the Court.
[9]
In support of his case, the learned counsel for the
petitioner mentioned “Bail Application No. 8 of 2019”
where the
petitioners was released on bail by the Hon’ble High Court of
Manipur in which the petitioners were languishing in jail for more
than 400 days.
[10]
The learned counsel for the respondent has filed their
objection stating that the petitioner himself admitted in his voluntary
statement dated 18.03.2023 that he has successfully smuggled &
delivered contraband drugs in earlier one occasion and the instant
case is his second attempt. The officer of DRI, Imphal Regional Unit
arrested the petitioner along with his vehicle Tata truck u/s 42 & 43
of the NDPS Act, 1985 on the reasonable believe that he has
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 4
committed an offence punishable u/s 22, 23 & 25 of the NDPS Act
and filed a case.
[11]
The officer of DRI, Imphal Regional Unit sent the sample
of the seized 1989.98 grams of Heroin Powder to Director of
Forensic Science, Pangei, Manipur for testing and got testing report
issued vide Memo No. 31/10/88-DFS (CHEM) dated 21.06.2023
mentioned that the seized substance gave positive response to
the test of Heroin.
[12]
The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that
the respondent has already file a final complaint to the Hon’ble Court
of the Special Judge, ND&PS, Tamenglong, Manipur vide Special
Trial (NDPS) Case No. 5 of 2023. The I.O. has completed the
investigation and filed a charge sheet on 21.09.2023 clearly
establishing his role and complicity in the inter-state drug smuggling
syndicate. The Hon’ble Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong
has taken cognizance of the offence and also noted that the
materials on records enclosed therein with the charge sheet, exist
sufficient materials for prosecuting the accused and thus, the bail
granted earlier vide order dated 14.09.2023 was cancelled on
27.09.2023 considering the facts stated above.
[13]
According to the learned counsel for the respondent, if
the investigation reveals that the accused has committed a serious
offence and charge sheet is filed, the bail granted under proviso (a)
to section 167(2) of Cr.P.C. could be cancelled on an application by
the prosecuting agency. Section 437(5) provide for the cancellation
of bail by a Court other than a High Court or a Session Court.
Meaning thereby it confers power of cancellation on the magistrate
court. As per section 37 of the NDPS Act, the court can grant bail to
the accused only if it is satisfy that there are reasonable grounds for
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 5
believing that he is not guilty of such offense and that he is not likely
to commit any offense while on bail. The bail granted u/s 436 Cr.P.C.
can be cancelled by High Court or Session Court u/s 439 (2) – Orissa
High Court.
[14]
The learned counsel for the respondent further submitted
that the default bail is not granted on merits, it may be canceled
after the filing of a charge sheet if a strong case is made against the
accused for a non bailable offence. But section 437(5) is the
provision understood as the provision enabling a magistrate for
cancelation of bail granted by the Magistrate in respect of a non
bailable offence. Similarly, section 439(2) is the provision understood
as locating the power of session judge and the High Court for
cancelling the bail.
[15]
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted written
argument on behalf of the petitioner and further submitted that
although the bail granted under section 167(2) Cr.P.C can be
cancelled on an application made by the prosecution, till date no
application has been filed by the prosecution till date for cancellation
o the bail granted by the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS),
Tamenglong in Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 5 of 2023 order dated
14.09.2023.
In State through Central Bureau of Investigation Vs T.
Gangi Reddy, (2023) 4 SCC 253 it is observed as under:
“27. From the above, the law, which emerges is that mere
filing of the charge-sheet subsequent to a person is released
on default bail u/s 167(2) Cr.P.C. cannot be a ground to cancel
the bail of a person, who is released on default bail.”
In Babu Singh & Ors Vs The State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR
1978 SC 527 it has been observed as under:
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 6
“2. …..an order refusing an application for bail does not
necessarily preclude another on a later occasion, giving more
materials further developments and different considerations.
8. …...personal liberty, deprived when bail is refused, is too
precious a value of our constitutional system recognized under
Art. 21 that the crucial power to negate it is a great trust
exercisable, not casualty but judicially, with lively concern for
the cost to the individual and the community. To glamorize
impressionistic orders as discretionary may, on occasions,
make a litigative gamble decisive of a fundamental right. After
all, personal liberty of an accused or convict is fundamental,
suffering lawful eclips nly in terms of procedure established by
‘law’. The last four words of Art.21 are the life of that human
right.”
In Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre Vs State of Maharashtra
and Ors, (2011) 1 SCC 694 it has been observed as under:
“14. When we carefully analyse this section, the wisdom of the
legislature becomes quite evident and clear that the legislature
was keen to ensure respect for the personal liberty and also
pressed in service the age-old principle that an individual is
presumed to be innocent till his is found guilty by the court.”
In Sanjay Chandra Vs Central Bureau of Investigation
(2012) 1 SCC 40 it has been observed as under:
“40. The grant of refusal to grant bail lies within the discretion
of the court. The grant or denial is regulated, to a large extent,
by the facts and circumstances of each particular case. But at
the same time, right to bail is not to be denied merely because
of the sentiments of the community against the accused. The
primary purposes of bail in a criminal case are to relieve the
accused of imprisonment, to relieve the State of the burden of
keeping him, pending trail, and at the same time, to keep the
accused constructively in the custody of the court, whether
before or after conviction, to assure that he will submit to the
jurisdiction of the court and be in attendance thereon
whenever his presence is required.”
In Registrar General, High Court of Patna Vs. Pandey
Gajendra Prasad and Others, (2012) 6 SCC 357 it has been observed
as under:
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 7
“15. Bearing in mind the scope of Article 235 of the
Constitution we may now advert to the facts at hand. As
aforesaid, according to the report of the enquiry officer only
Charges II and III, as extracted above, stood proved against
Respondent 1. It is manifest that in both cases, the charge is
related to the grant of bail by Respondent 1. While it is true
and relevant to note that “grant of bail” is an exercise of
judicial discretion vested in a judicial officer to be exercised
depending on the facts and circumstances before him, yet it is
equally important that exercise of that discretion must be
judicious having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances
and not as a matter of course.”
[16]
It is admitted fact that the learned Special Judge
(ND&PS), Tamenglong released the accused/petitioner on bail as
default bail i.e. after the expiry of 180 days of Judicial remand and also
before filling of charge sheet, further it is also admitted fact that charge
sheet was filed by the prosecution after the default bail was granted by
the learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong, further it is also
admitted facts that I.O of the case submitted charge sheet on
21.09.2023, further it is also an admitted fact that the prosecution did
not filed any application to cancelled the bail order of the
accused/petitioner
before
the
learned
Special
Judge
(ND&PS),
Tamenglong. But, the accused/petitioner failed to furnish the required
bonds immediately due to the petitioner being from a very poor family
and accordingly took time to furnish the same before the learned court.
However, the accused/petitioner filed an application on 27.09.2023
with the request to allow him to furnish the required bond but the
learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong rejected.
[17]
The learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong passed
the following orders;
“The UT has been produced by the Jail Authority of
Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa through Video Conferencing using
Jitsi Meet.
Ld. Counsel for the UT has filed Vakalatnama tody.
She prays for releasing the UT on bail u/s 167(2)
Cr.P.C. as per order dated 14th September, 2023 passed in Cril.
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 8
Misc (B) Case No. 5 of 2023 pending investigation and inquiry
of the case by furnishing required bonds as per the said order
passed by this Court.
However, the prosecution being the Intelligence Officer,
Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Imphal Regional Unit had
already submitted chargesheet vide order dated 21st
September, 2023 and accordingly this Court has taken
cognizance of offence u/s 21, 22(c), 23(c) & 25 of NDPS Act,
1985 vide order dated 27th September, 2023. Further, the
prosecution has submitted that the R.P. has already bee n
furnished to the UT through the Addl. S.P. Central Jail, Sajiwa,
Manipur on 3rd October, 2023.
Upon submission of the chargesheet vide order dated
21st September, 2023 and the UT being unable to furnish
necessary bonds was further remanded into judicial custody
u/s 309(2) of Cr.P.C. vide order dated 27th September, 2023 for
standing trail against the charges leveled by the prosecution.
The Ld. PP has appears and prays for adjourning the
charge consideration hearing today on the ground that he is
suffering from viral fever.
In the meantime, Ld. Counsel for the UT is allowed to
interview and receive R.Ps from the Jailor, Manipur Central Jail,
Sajiwa.
The Ut may be allowed to contact his family member
through phone whatever necessary.
Hence, the hearing is adjourned today.
In the meantime, the order dated 14th September, 2023
passed in Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 5 of 2023 is not maintainable
and stands cancelled.
The Addl. S.P. of Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa, Manipur
is directed to produce the accused on 25.10.2023 at 11:30 AM
for charge consideration and hearing.
Send an extract copy of this order to the Addl. S.P of
Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa, Manipur and Standing Counsel of
DRI for information.”
[18]
The point to be considered now is after the default bail is
granted but before the submission of required bonds chargesheet is
filed by the prosecution whether the Court can dismissed the bail on
the ground that the chargesheet is filed and cognizance of the offences
taken.
[19]
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that bail
granted under section 167(2) can be cancelled on an application but
the order dated 11.10.2023 of the learned special Judge (ND&PS),
Tamenglong was passed thereby cancelling the bail order dated
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 9
14.09.2023 only on the ground that the chargesheet was filed without
any application filed by the prosecution. Further, referred to section
437(5) and section 439(2) but both sections are not applicable in the
present bail application.
[20]
The learned counsel for the petitioner made reference to
the following judgement of the supreme court in support of his case;
1. In State through Central Bureau of Investigation Vs T.
Gangi Reddy, (2023) 4 SCC 253 it is observed as under:
“27. From the above, the law, which emerges is that mere
filing of the charge-sheet subsequent to a person is released
on default bail u/s 167(2) Cr.P.C. cannot be a ground to cancel
the bail of a person, who is released on default bail.”
2. In Babu Singh & Ors Vs The State of Uttar Pradesh,
AIR 1978 SC 527 it has been observed as under:
“2. …..an order refusing an application for bail does not
necessarily preclude another on a later occasion, giving more
materials further developments and different considerations.
8. …...personal liberty, deprived when bail is refused, is too
precious a value of our constitutional system recognized under
Art. 21 that the crucial power to negate it is a great trust
exercisable, not casualty but judicially, with lively concern for
the cost to the individual and the community. To glamorize
impressionistic orders as discretionary may, on occasions,
make a litigative gamble decisive of a fundamental right. After
all, personal liberty of an accused or convict is fundamental,
suffering lawful eclips nly in terms of procedure established by
‘law’. The last four words of Art.21 are the life of that human
right.”
3. In Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre Vs State of
Maharashtra and Ors, (2011) 1 SCC 694 it has been observed as
under:
“14. When we carefully analyse this section, the wisdom of the
legislature becomes quite evident and clear that the legislature
was keen to ensure respect for the personal liberty and also
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 10
pressed in service the age-old principle that an individual is
presumed to be innocent till his is found guilty by the court.”
4. In Sanjay Chandra Vs Central Bureau of Investigation
(2012) 1 SCC 40 it has been observed as under:
“40. The grant of refusal to grant bail lies within the discretion
of the court. The grant or denial is regulated, to a large extent,
by the facts and circumstances of each particular case. But at
the same time, right to bail is not to be denied merely because
of the sentiments of the community against the accused. The
primary purposes of bail in a criminal case are to relieve the
accused of imprisonment, to relieve the State of the burden of
keeping him, pending trail, and at the same time, to keep the
accused constructively in the custody of the court, whether
before or after conviction, to assure that he will submit to the
jurisdiction of the court and be in attendance thereon
whenever his presence is required.”
5. In Registrar General, High Court of Patna Vs. Pandey
Gajendra Prasad and Others, (2012) 6 SCC 357 it has been observed
as under:
“15. Bearing in mind the scope of Article 235 of the
Constitution we may now advert to the facts at hand. As
aforesaid, according to the report of the enquiry officer only
Charges II and III, as extracted above, stood proved against
Respondent 1. It is manifest that in both cases, the charge is
related to the grant of bail by Respondent 1. While it is true
and relevant to note that “grant of bail” is an exercise of
judicial discretion vested in a judicial officer to be exercised
depending on the facts and circumstances before him, yet it is
equally important that exercise of that discretion must be
judicious having regard to all relevant facts and circumstances
and not as a matter of course.”
[21]
In the facts and circumstances discussed above and in
conjunction with the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s observation made in the
forgoing I am of the view that the submission made about by the
learned counsel for the petitioner found reasonable, hence, accepted
and on top of that in the present case the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s
observation made in State through Central Bureau of Investigation Vs
T. Gangi Reddy, (2023) 4 SCC 253 squarely covered. Accordingly the
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 11
accused/petitioner is released on bail on his furnishing of PR bond of
Rs. 2,00,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh) only with 2 (two) sureties of two
local Government employee of like amount to the satisfaction of the
learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong. The petitioner should not
leave the State of Manipur without prior permission from the Court
concerned.
As the charge sheet has already been filed and as the trial
is to be started, the accused/petitioner is directed to appear before the
Ld. Trial Court on every date/dates fixed by the Ld. Court for further
proceeding of the trial.
[22]
The accused/petitioner is directed to furnish the required
bonds before the learned Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong within
7(seven) days.
[23]
Accordingly, the present bail application is allowed and
disposed of.
[24]
Send an extract copy of this order to the Court of learned
Special Judge (ND&PS), Tamenglong.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lucy
Bail Application No. 29 of 2023
Page 12
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review