Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
signed
SHOUGRA Digitally
by
SHOUGRAKPAM
KPAM
DEVANANDA
DEVANAN SINGH
2023.05.29
DA SINGH Date:
11:32:02 +05'30'
AT IMPHAL
MC(El. Petn.) No. 5 of 2023
(Ref:- El. Petn. No. 13 of 2022)
Mr. Ahanthem Shanjoy Singh, aged about 46 years, S/o Ahanthem
Surchandra Singh, a permanent resident of Wangoo Sabal, Wangoo
Ahallup, P.O. Moirang & P.S. Kumbi, Bishnupur District, Manipur –
795133.
... Applicant
-Versus1. Mr. Sanasam Premchandra Singh, aged about 46 years, S/o
(Late) Jabamjao @ Sanasam Jaramajao Singh, Kumbi
Salangkonjin Part-2, Near Public Community Hall, P.O. Moirang
& P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
2. Mr. Ningthoujam Mangi Singh, aged about 71 years, S/o (Late)
Ningthoujam Ibomcha Singh, Kumbi Ward No. 9, P.O. Moirang &
P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
3. Dr. Khagembam Romesh Singh, aged about 45 years, S/o Shri
Khangembam Amrita Singh, Kumbi Khuga Wangma, P.O.
Moirang & P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
4. Mrs. Naorem Sorojini Devi, aged about 43 years, W/o
Shougrakpam Chandrakmar Singh, Saiton Maning Leikai, P.O.
Moirang & P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
5. The Returning Officer, 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency,
Manipur (of the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election,
2022), Bishnupur at DC Office-795126.
6. The Principal, P.L.C. Academy, Yairipok, P.O. & P.S. Yairipok,
District-Thoubal, Manipur-795149.
7. Uttar Purva Siksha Board, Guwahati, Assa (Bharatiya Educational
Birubari, G.B. Market Complex, 1st Floor, GHY-16, Assam.
8. The Union of India, represented by the Secretary, Ministry of
Human Resource Development, Department of School Education
& Literacy, Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi – 110001.
[2]
9. The State of Manipur, represented by the Commissioner/
Secretary (Education-S), Govt. of Manipur, at Imphal-795001.
… Respondents
-ANDIN THE MATTER OF:
Election Petition No. 13 of 2022
Mr. Ahanthem Shanjoy Singh, aged about 46 years, S/o
Ahanthem Surchandra Singh, a permanent resident of Wangoo
Sabal, Wangoo Ahallup, P.O. Moirang & P.S. Kumbi, Bishnupur
District, Manipur – 795133.
… Petitioner
-Versus1. Mr. Sanasam Premchandra Singh, aged about 46 years, S/o
(Late) Jabamjao @ Sanasam Jaramajao Singh, Kumbi
Salangkonjin Part-2, Near Public Community Hall, P.O. Moirang
& P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
2. Mr. Ningthoujam Mangi Singh, aged about 71 years, S/o (Late)
Ningthoujam Ibomcha Singh, Kumbi Ward No. 9, P.O. Moirang &
P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
3. Dr. Khagembam Romesh Singh, aged about 45 years, S/o Shri
Khangembam Amrita Singh, Kumbi Khuga Wangma, P.O.
Moirang & P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
4. Mrs. Naorem Sorojini Devi, aged about 43 years, W/o
Shougrakpam Chandrakmar Singh, Saiton Maning Leikai, P.O.
Moirang & P.S. Kumbi, Dist. Bishnupur, Manipur-795133.
5. The Returning Officer, 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency,
Manipur (of the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election,
2022), Bishnupur at DC Office-795126.
6. The Principal, P.L.C. Academy, Yairipok, P.O. & P.S. Yairipok,
District-Thoubal, Manipur-795149.
7. Uttar Purva Siksha Board, Guwahati, Assa (Bharatiya Educational
Birubari, G.B. Market Complex, 1st Floor, GHY-16, Assam.
8. The Union of India, represented by the Secretary, Ministry of
Human Resource Development, Department of School Education
& Literacy, Govt. of India, Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi – 110001.
[3]
9. The State of Manipur, represented by the Commissioner/
Secretary (Education-S), Govt. of Manipur, at Imphal-795001.
… Respondents
B E F O R E
HON’BLEMR. JUSTICE AHANTHEMBIMOL SINGH
For the Applicant
::
Mr. Serto T. Kom, Advocate
For the respondents
::
Mr. N. Mahendra, Advocate;
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate &
Mr. Leo Rommel, Advocate
Date of Hearing
::
02-05-2023
Date of Judgment
::
29-05-2023
J U D G M E N T
[1]
Heard Mr. Serto T. Kom, learned counsel appearing for the
applicant, Mr. N. Mahendra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No. 1, Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel appearing for the respondent No.
2 and Mr. Leo Rommel, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No. 3. None appeared for the other remaining respondents.
[2]
The present application had been filed under Order VI Rule 17 of
CPC read with Section 87 of the Representation of People Act, 1951
(hereinafter referred to as “RP Act”, for short) with a prayer to allow
amendment of the connected El. Petn. No. 13 of 2022 filed by the present
applicant. For ready reference, the prayer made in the present application
are reproduced hereunder:“P R A Y E R
In the premises stated above, it is prayed that your
Lordships be pleased to allow the amendment of the above
referred Election Petition No. 13 of 2022, by;
(1)
Deleting the words and numerical from the above referred
Election Petition which is reproduced hereunder:- “… and
Sec. 101” from Page No. 1 of the Election Petition;
[4]
(2)
Deleting the words at Page No. 2 of the Election Petition
which is reproduced hereunder:“… and to declare the petitioner Janata Dal (United0
candidate of the said 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency,
Manipur, ELECTED.”
(3)
Deleting the words at Para 2 Page No. 6 of the Election
Petition, which is reproduced hereunder:- ….. and to
declare the petitioner Janata Dal (United) candidate of the
said 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency, Manipur,
ELECTED.”
(4)
Deleting the Prayer No. (ii) at Page 28 of the said plaint
which is reproduced hereunder:“(ii) Declare the Petitioner, Janata Dal (United) Candidate of
the said 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency, Manipur,
ELECTED,” and
(5)
[3]
To correct Prayer No. (iii) as Prayer No. (ii) instead of
Prayer No. (iii) in the event of allowing the amendment.”
The brief background which culminates in filing the present
application is that the present applicant filed Election Petition No. 13 of 2022
before this court seeking for granting the following reliefs:“P R A Y E R
In the above stated facts, it is prayed that your Lordships
be pleased to;
(i)
Declare the election of the Returned Bharatiya Janata
Party (BJP) Candidate/ Respondent No. 1, Shri Sanasam
Premchandra Singh of 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency,
Manipur, in the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election,
2022 as VOID; and
(ii) Declare the petitioner, Janata Dal (United) candidate of
the said 29-Kumbi, Assembly Constituency, Manipur,
ELECTED.
(iii) Pass any other order or orders as your Lordships may
deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the
case.
And for this Act of kindness, the petitioner as duty bound,
shall ever pray.”
[5]
[4]
Respondents No. 1, 2, 3 and 8 in the said El. Petn. No. 13 of 2022
filed their respective written statements and the petitioner also filed
replication to the written statements filed by the respondents No. 1 and 3.
As respondents No. 4 to 7 did not appeared before this court despite service
of notice, the election petition was proceeded ex-parte against them. After
exchange of pleadings are complete, the said election petition was fixed on
10-01-2023 for framing of issues by an order dated 14-12-2022 passed by
this court. The respondent No. 1 in the main El. Petn. No. 13 of 2022 filed
El. Recr. Petn. No. 7 of 2022 and the respondent No. 2 in the said main
El. Petn. No. 13 of 2022 also filed El. Recr. Petn. No. 8 of 2022. After
exchange of pleadings amongst the parties in the said two election
recrimination petitions are completed, the said two cases were also fixed
for framing of issues vide order dated 17-10-2022 and 14-11-2022 passed
by this court. Before framing of issues in connection with the main election
petition as well as the two election recrimination petitions, the applicant filed
the present application with a prayer for allowing amendment of the main
El. Petn. No. 13 of 2022.
[5]
The grounds given by the applicant for seeking such amendment
are found in para 3 of the present application, which are reproduced
hereunder for ready reference:“3. That the above mentioned portions sought to be amended were
added in the above referred Election Petition by overlooking
the facts and law for seeking such relief and as such, the
deletion of the same are necessary for the purpose of
determining the reals question in controversy between the
parties without having to decide the issues to be framed arising
out of the above Prayer No. (ii) which is sought to be deleted.
In the event of allowing the deletion of the Prayer No. (ii) the
Prayer No. (iii) would become Payer No. (ii), hence the prayer
for the above mentioned amendment.
[6]
[6]
At the time of consideration of the present application, Mr. Serto
T. Kom, learned counsel appearing for the applicant advanced his
argument on the basis of a totally new ground which are not pleaded in the
present application. By referring to the provisions of Section 101 of RP Act
and by relying on the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of “Prakash Khandre Vs. Dr. Vijay Kumar Khandre & ors.” reported
in (2002) 5 SCC 568, It has been submitted by Mr. Serto T. Kom, learned
counsel appearing for the applicant that the ingredients of Section 101 of
the RP Act for declaring the candidate other than the Returned Candidate
are, firstly, error in counting valid votes and if it is found that in fact the
election petitioner or such other candidate received a majority of valid
votes, he is to be declared as elected and secondly, votes obtained by the
Returned Candidate were obtained by corrupt practice and but for such
votes the petitioner or such other candidate would have obtained a majority
of valid votes. The learned counsel further submitted that the first ingredient
for declaring the election petitioner or other candidate to have been duly
elected depends upon error for various reasons in counting of valid votes
and if it is found that in fact the petitioner or such other candidate received
a majority of valid votes, he is to be declared elected. It has also been
submitted that the second ingredient provides for establishing that the
votes obtained by the Returned Candidate were obtained by corrupt
practice and but for such votes the petitioner or such other candidate would
have obtained a majority of valid votes.
[7]
[7]
The learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the election
petitioner due to inadvertent mistake failed to mention any material facts,
more specifically any of the two ingredients stipulated under Section 101 of
the RP Act, which would amount to the cause of action for allowing
the prayer No. (ii) made in the election petition, i.e., for declaring the
petitioner, Janata Dal (United) candidate elected from 29-Kumbi Assembly
Constituency in the 12th Manipur Legislative Assembly Election, 2022. It
has also been submitted that in the absence of any material fact or cause
of action in the election petition for claiming to declare the petitioner
elected, this court has ample power to strike off the prayer No. (ii) made in
the election petition to avoid wastage of precious time of this court in the
trial in connection with the said prayer No. (ii).
[8]
By referring to the provisions of Section 87 of the RP Act and by
relying on the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court rendered in the case of
“Azhar Hussain Vs. Rajiv Gandhi” reported in 1986 (Supp.) SCC 315, it
has been submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the applicant that
the procedure provided under the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) applies
to the trial of election petition and that the court trying the election petition
can act in exercise of the procedure provided under the CPC including
O-VI R.-7 and O-VII R-11(a). It has also been submitted that the court
dealing with the election petition is empowered to strike off or delete
pleadings at any stage of the proceeding as provided under O-VI R-16 of
the CPC, if the pleadings does not disclose any cause of action or if such
pleadings are unnecessary or if such pleadings may delay the trial of the
[8]
petition. In support of his contention, the learned counsel cited the case law
“Dhartipakar Madan Lal Agarwal Vs. Rajiv Gandhi” reported in 1987
(Supp.) SCC 93.
[9]
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No. 2 submitted that under Section 82 of the RP Act, it is provided that in
an election petition where the petitioner, in addition to claiming declaration
that the election of all or any of the Returned Candidates is void, claims a
further declaration that he himself or any other candidate has been duly
elected, all the contesting candidates other than the petitioner, and where
no such further declaration is claimed, all the Returned Candidates shall be
joined as respondents in his election petition. The learned counsel
submitted that as the present applicant, in addition to claiming the
declaration that the election of the Returned Candidate is void, also claims
a further declaration that he himself has been duly elected, all the
contesting candidates including the respondent No. 2 have been impleaded
as respondents in the election petition. The learned counsel further
submitted that since the respondent No. 2 had been impleaded in the
election petition, the respondent No. 2 had already filed his written
statement to the said election petition. Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel
also submitted that under Section 97 of the RP Act there is provision for
filing Recrimination Petition if in an election petition a claim has been made
for declaring that any candidate other than the Returned Candidate has
been duly elected. The learned counsel submitted that as provided under
Section 97 of the RP Act, not only the Returned Candidate but the
[9]
respondent No. 2 has also filed Recrimination Petition and in both the
Recrimination Petitions, exchange of pleadings are completed and the
matters have already been fixed for framing of issues. It has also been
submitted by Mr. Ajoy Pebam that under Section 98 of the RP Act, it is
provided that at the conclusion of the trial of an election petition, the High
Court shall make an order, inter alia, declaring the election of all or any of
the Returned Candidates to be void and the petitioner or any other
candidate to have been duly elected. The learned counsel strenuously
submitted that if the prayer made by the applicant in the present application
is allowed, it will have the grave consequence of nullifying all the actions
taken by the respondents in connection with the election petition and
Recrimination Petitions in terms of the provisions provided under Sections
82, 87, 98, etc. of the RP Act, which is not permissible in law.
The learned counsel cited the following case laws:1) “K. Kamaraja Nadar: Mariappan: M.R. Masani Vs. Kunju
Theivar: V.R. Nedunchezhiyan: Election Tribunal, Ranchi”
reported in 1958 Legal Eagle (SC) 59.
“33. As regards the amendment of a petition by deleting the
averments and the prayer regarding the declaration that either
the petitioner or any other candidate has been duly elected, so
as to cure the defect of non-joinder of the necessary parties as
respondents, we may only refer to our judgment about to be
delivered in Mallappa Basapa v. Basavaraj Ayyappa, Civil
Appeal No. 76 of 1958: (A.I.R. 1958 SC 698)(D) where the
question is discussed at considerable length. Suffice it to say
here that the Election Tribunal has no power to grant such an
amendment be it by way of withdrawal or abandonment of a part
of the claim or otherwise, once an Election Petition has been
presented to the Election Commission claiming such further
declaration.”
[10]
“34. Considering Civil Appeal No. 763 of 1957 in the light of the
observations made above, we find that Sundaraju Pillai
whose name was included in the list of contesting candidates
prepared and published by the returning officer under S. 38
but who retired from the contest under S. 55A(2) before the
commencement of the poll was included in the expression
“contesting candidate” used in S. 82 and was by reason of the
first respondent claiming a further declaration that the second
respondent had been duly elected, a necessary party to the
petition. Inasmuch as he was not joined as a respondent, the
petition was liable to be dismissed under S. 90(3) of the Act.”
“35. This defect could not be cured by any amendment of the
petition seeking to delete the claim for such further declaration
and the Election Tribunal was clearly in error in allowing such
amendment on the grounds disclosed in I.A. No. 3 of 1957 or
otherwise.”
2) “Inamati Mallappa Basappa Vs. Desai Basavaraj Ayyappa & ors.”
reported in AIR 1958 SC 698.
“16. ……. If the withdrawal of a petition cannot be permitted and any
person who might have been a petitioner is entitled to continue
the proceedings, on a parity of reasoning, the withdrawal of a
part of the claim also could not be permitted without allowing
another person who might have been a petitioner an opportunity
of proceeding with that part of the claim by substituting himself
in place and stead of the petitioner who withdraws or abandons
the same. If the constituency as a whole is interested in the
petition presented before the Election Tribunal no such
withdrawal or abandonment of a part of the claim could ever be
permitted without giving an opportunity to any person who
might have been a petitioner to continue the proceedings and
pursue the petition to its logical conclusion.”
“17. The provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure
also contain inherent evidence which militates against this
contention. Order 23 Rule 1 sub-rule (2) provides for liberty
being given by the Court to a party withdrawing or abandoning
a part of his claim to file a fresh suit on the same cause of action,
if so advised. In the very nature of things such liberty could not
be reserved to a petitioner in an election petition. The provisions
above referred to in regard to withdrawal of petitions do not
provide for the same and if they do not do so, can it be urged
that the provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 sub-rule (2), though they
may not apply to the cases of withdrawal of petitions may
nevertheless apply where the petitioner withdraws or abandons
[11]
a part of his claim? If these provisions do not apply to the
withdrawal or abandonment of a part of the claim in the case of
an election petition, could it then be urged that nevertheless the
other provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 would apply and the
petitioner would be at liberty to withdraw or abandon a part of
his claim?”
“18. On a due consideration of all these provisions, we are of opinion
that the provisions of Order 23 Rule 1 do not apply to the election
petitions and it would not be open to a petitioner to withdraw or
abandon a part of his claim once an election petition was
presented to the Election Commission, more so when such a
withdrawal or abandonment of a part of the claim would have the
effect of depriving the returned candidate or any other party to
the petition of the right of recrimination which had accrued to
him under Section 97 of the Act.”
3) “Harnam Singh Vs. Tirath Singh” reported in 1963 Legal Eagle
(P&H) 377
“9. An election contest, as is well-settled, is not an action at law nor
is it a suit in equity. It is a purely statutory proceeding created and
governed by statute. Turning to the Act, therefore, we find that
Section 90 which prescribes the procedure to be followed by the
Tribunal provides, inter alia, for trial of every election petition by
the Tribunal to be as nearly as possible in accordance with the
procedure applicable under the CPC to the trial of suits, but this
is expressly made subject to the provisions of the Act and the
rules made thereunder. The provision of Order 6, Rule 17 of the
Code would thus be attracted provided it is not inconsistent with
any provision of the Act or the rules. The amendment of written
statement would accordingly be governed by Order 6, Rule 17 of
the Code and the considerations which control the amendment of
election petitions by incorporating therein fresh charges would
perhaps not stand in the way of the prayer for adding a new plea
in defence. But apart from this consideration, all other facts which
the Courts are enjoined or expected to keep in view in allowing or
disallowing amendments would have to be borne in mind. The
power of amendment of pleadings conferred by the Code is
undoubtedly very wide and according to the language of Order 6,
Rule 17, amendments may be allowed at any stage of the
proceedings. At the same time, the power of amendment has been
described to be discretionary. At the same time, the power of
amendment has been described to be discretionary. In S.M.
Banerjit Vs. Sri Krishna Agarwal, Subba Rao, J., speaking for the
Court, spoke thus:
[12]
At this stage we must guard against one possible
misapprehension. Courts and tribunals are constituted to do
justice between the parties within the confines of statutory
limitation, and undue emphasis on technicalities or enlarging
their scope would cramp their powers, diminish their
effectiveness and defeat the very purpose for which they are
constituted. We must make it clear that within the limits
prescribed by the decisions of this Court the discretionary
jurisdiction of the Tribunals to amend the pleadings is as
extensive as that of a Civil Court. The same well-settled
principles laid down in the matter of amendments to the
pleadings in a suit should also regulate the exercise of the
power of amendment by a Tribunal.
10. While considering the question of amendment of (sic)eadings in an
election contest, in my opinion, it would be legitimate for the
Tribunal not to ignore but (sic)o give due weight to the
consideration of expeditious disposal of election petitions. In
Section 90, the pro(sic)viso to Sub-section (1) empowers the
Tribunal for reasons to be recorded in writing to refuse to examine
any witness if, in its opinion, it is not material for the decision of
the petition and the party tendering him is doing so, inter alia, with
a view to delay the proceedings, Sub-section (6) makes an express
provision that every election petition shall be tried as expeditiously
as possible and endeavour shall be made to conclude the trial
within 6 months from the date of publication of the copy of the
petition in the Official Gazette. Similarly, in Section 116-A, SubSection (5), it is provided that endeavour should be made to
determine the appeal finally within 3 months from the date on
which the memorandum of appeal is presented to the High Court.
In the background of these provisions, in my opinion, amendment
of written statements in an election contest cannot be treated with
the same liberality with which the Court may be inclined to treat
amendment of written statement in an ordinary suit, the element of
delay being of fundamental importance in the disposal of an
election petition.
“11. In the case in hand a copy of the election petition in question was
directed to be published on 18th April, 1962 and the written
statement on behalf of the appellant (who was a Respondent in the
election petition) was filed on 16th July, 1962, though it should have
been filed on 9th July, 1962. One weeks' time was granted to him on
payment of costs. Issues were settled on 21st July, 1962 and 8th
September, 1962, was fixed for the evidence of the petitioners on
which date, as already noticed, the application for amendment was
presented. No cogent ground was disclosed in the application for
[13]
the omission of this plea from the written statement filed on 16th
July, 1962, the only excuse mentioned being that the matter had
inadvertently not been raised in the written statement. Even this
reason was not supported by any affidavit; nor was the application
verified. In these circumstances, in my opinion, the Tribunal was
fully justified in disallowing the amendment, for, however, wide the
power to allow amendment of written statement in an election
contest and however liberal its exercise may be described to fee,
such amendment is not intended by law to be claimed as of right
and for the mere asking, without establishing good grounds and
justice in its support. If this were not so, then a returned candidate
can be by merely seeking successive amendments of his written
statement on payment of costs prolong the disposal of the election
petition for the full or almost full duration of the Legislature and
make the challenge to his election, at least for such duration,
completely infructuous. This certainly cannot be, and, is, in my
humble opinion, not the intention of the law. Justice delayed in
election contest might well be justice defeated. In my opinion,
therefore, the amendment sought in the instant case could not
have been allowed without injustice to the Petitioner.
“12. As suggested by the Supreme Court in Banerji's case (5) the order
disallowing amendment is passed in the exercise of discretionary
jurisdiction. Though this jurisdiction, in as extensive as that of a
Civil Court, nevertheless, as is the case with all discretionary
jurisdictions, is has to be exercised in accordance with the wellrecognised judicial principles in order to promote the cause of
justice; in the case in hand no such recognised judicial principle is
shown to have been violated by the Tribunal; nor am I convinced
that the, amendment sought would have substantially promoted
the cause of justice or that the impugned order has occasioned any
failure of justice. It is true that Section 116-A does not in terms
place any restriction on the power of the Court of appeal in
reviewing the order appealed against and a discretionary order is
as much open to scrutiny and review as any other order; at the
same time it is clear that unless an appellate Court is satisfied that
a discretionary jurisdiction has been wrongly exercised in violation
of a well-settled rule and that it should have in the interest of justice
been exercised in the contrary way, the impugned order is
ordinarily not interfered with. I am unable in this case to hold that
any such ground for interference has been made out.
“13. I am not unmindful of the fact that it is not Gurdial Singh, whose
nomination papers were rejected, but this factor cannot be
conclusive, for the simple reason that improper rejection of a
nomination paper is per se fatel to ah election, irrespective of the
personality of the Petitioner in the election petition. It may be
[14]
remembered that an election petition is not a matter in which the
only person interested are the parties to the petition or the
candidates who strove against each other at the election; the
public and certainly the electorates are also interested in it because
an election is an essential part of our democratic process. It is,
therefore, not possible to interfere with the order disallowing
amendment.”
[10]
I have heard the rival arguments advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties at length and also carefully examined all the materials
available on record. The only question for consideration is as to whether the
application for amendment of the prayer clause thereby deleting the prayer
for declaration of the election petitioner as a Returned Candidate can be
permitted to be deleted/ withdrawn or not? In a number of reported cases, the
Hon'ble Apex Court has consistently held that the right to elect or to be elected
or dispute regarding election are neither fundament right nor common law right
but are confined to the provisions of the RP Act and the rules made thereunder
and consequently the rights and remedies are all limited to those provided by
the statutory remedies. It has also been consistently held by the Hon'be Apex
Court that the provisions of CPC would apply to the election dispute as nearly
as may be and subject to the provisions of the RP Act and any rules made
thereunder and the provisions of the code cannot be invoked to permit that
which is not permissible under the RP Act.
[11]
After hearing the rival submissions advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties, this court find considerable force and merit in the
submission advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the respondent
No. 2. This court is also of the considered view that if the prayer made in the
present application is allowed, it will have the grave consequence of nullifying
[15]
all the actions taken by the respondents in connection with the election
petition, in pursuance with the statutory provisions provided under the relevant
provisions of the RP Act. The result of allowing the present application will
bring about deletion of all the respondents except the Returned Candidate in
the election petition, nullifying the two recrimination petitions filed by the
respondents No. 1 and 2 in the election petition as provided under Section 97
of the RP Act or nullifying the relief which can be granted under Section 98(c)
of the RP Act.
[12]
In my considered view, the statutory provisions provided under
Sections 82, 97 and 98 of the RP Act cannot be nullified or any action taken
pursuant to the statutory provisions provided under the aforesaid sections of
the RP Act cannot be rendered infructuous by invoking the provisions of the
CPC. Just because the petitioner failed to plead material facts to make out a
case for obtaining the relief of declaring himself as the elected candidate, it
cannot be a ground for allowing the prayer of amendment made in the present
application. In the result, I find no merit in the present application and the same
is hereby dismissed, however without any order as to cost
JUDGE
FR / NFR
Devananda
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review