Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
APHC010429512024
[3483]
WRIT PETITION No: 22758 of 2024 along with
W.P.Nos.22091, 22103, 22124, 22131, 22138, 22759,
22760, 22818, 22820, 22918, 22919, 22921, 22923,
22935, 22937, 22940, 22962, 22968, 23002, 23014,
23016, 23051, 23104, 24120, 24124, 24202, 24289,
24324, 24420, 24459, 24460, 24461, 24467, 24477,
24638, 24642, 24706, 24707, 24728, 24730, 24733,
24893, 26395, 26453, 26482, 26513, 26580, 26585,
26654, 26804, 26865, 28993, 29310, 29419, 30311,
30458, 31022, 31143 & 31220 of 2024
Agriculture Insurance Company Of India
Ltd
...Petitioner
Vs.
The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
and Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Petitioner:
Mr. Motupalli Vijaya Kumar, learned
Senior Counsel appearing for Mr. P.
Mohan Rao
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s):
Mr. Kushank Sindhu,
Mr. Varun Byreddy,
GP for Agriculture
CORAM :THE CHIEF JUSTICE DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR
SRI JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
DATE
: 30.01.2026
Per DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CJ:
Since common questions of law and fact arise in the present batch of
petitions, we propose to deal with the same by way of this common judgment
and order.
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
2.
All the petitions are filed by the Agriculture Insurance Company of India
Limited challenging the orders passed by the National Consumer Disputes
Redressal Commission, dated 25.06.2024, by virtue of which revision
petitions filed by the farmers against the order passed by the State
Consumer Commission were partly allowed and the petitioner – Insurance
Company was directed to refund the premium amount collected from the
complainants/farmers. Besides this, an amount of Rs.40,000/- each was
directed to be paid to the complainants as cost of litigation and suffering on
account of mental agony and harassment.
Briefly stated, the material facts are as under:
3.
The Government of India floated a scheme called ‘Weather Based
Crop Insurance Scheme’ (WBCIS) by virtue of its order, dated 03.03.2010.
Thereafter, the Government of Andhra Pradesh issued G.O.Rt.No.7, dated
03.01.2012 for implementation of a pilot weather based crop insurance
scheme, which was to operate in certain districts including in Kurnool District.
The crops which could be insured under the scheme were the crops of
banana and mango. The scheme is stated to have been widely publicized by
the officers in the villages in the concerned districts including Kurnool District.
As per the notification, the Government, by virtue of G.O.Rt.No.7,
notified insurance cover for the mango crop for certain districts including
Kurnool, whereas banana crop was notified to be insured for the districts of
Vizianagaram, East Godavari and Y.S.R. Kadapa.
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
4.
The main features according to clause 5 of the ‘operational modalities’
pertained to the perils which were covered, whereas clause 6 deals with the
risk period. Both are reproduced hereunder:
“5. PERILS COVERED:
Following are the weather perils, which are deemed to cause “Adverse Weather
Incidence” affecting crop health, leading to crop loss, would be covered under the Scheme:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Excess/unseasonal rainfall
Pests and diseases (High Rh & Low Temperature)
Daily temperature fluctuations and
Daily maximum wind speed
6. RISK PERIOD: Risk period commences from 1st January, 2011 to and the
table containing the coverage periods at phases as given here:
S.No.
Name of the cover
Excess/Unseasonal
Rainfall cover
Cover against Pest and
Disease incidence
Daily
Temperature
Fluctuation Cover
Daily Max Wind Speed
Cover
Table – 1: Coverage details”
Period
1st January, 2012 to 29th February, 2012
1st January, 2012 to 29th February, 2012
1st January, 2012 to 15th March, 2012
1st March, 2012 to 31st May, 2012
The scheme envisaged that a farmer would only be required to pay
50% of the total premium and that the balance to be shared by the Central
Government and Government of Andhra Pradesh on a 50:50 basis.
5.
According to clause 13 of the notified scheme, the claims of insurance
would be based upon the data as regards the wind speed, temperature
fluctuations, etc., which data was envisaged to be provided by ‘automatic
weather stations’ set up by the Andhra Pradesh Disaster Mitigation Society to
the petitioner Insurance Company on a day-to-day basis for the period from
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
01.01.2012 to 31.05.2012, as that was the period during which the insurance
cover would be available to the farmers.
In the aforementioned backdrop, complaints came to be filed by the
complainants wherein it was claimed that their mango crop had suffered
damage thereby causing huge monetary loss to them on account of heavy
rain and storm coupled with high-speed winds which occurred on 13.05.2012.
The farmers claimed deficiency of service on the part of the petitioner
alleging failure to settle their insurance claims.
6.
The stand of the claimants was that the Assistant Director of
Horticulture upon visiting the fields of the complainants, had given a
certificate certifying that there was crop failure on account of the
unfavourable weather conditions.
7.
The stand of the complainants was that they had filled up the proposal
forms with a view to be protected by the insurance cover for their crops and
that the respondents in the complaint including the appellant had not supplied
the terms and conditions of the scheme, including various parameters, on the
happening of which, the insurance claim could be triggered.
8.
Complainants claimed that the horticulture officers who acted as
agents between the farmers and the Insurance Company had given an
impression that the complainants would be compensated on account of any
crop loss that would occur and had been kept in the dark as regards the
various factors and that it was for the first time that they were being told
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
during the proceedings before the District Forum that the compensation was
not payable.
9.
According to the stand of the petitioner - Insurance Company before
the District Consumer Forum, there was no adverse incident on the date
when the complainants claimed that there were unseasonal/excessive rains
during the specified cover period and therefore, the stand was that the claims
were untenable under the WBCIS and consequently, there was no deficiency
of service on its part in refusing to pay the insurance amount.
According to the scheme, the daily maximum wind trigger for the
period between 01.03.2012 to 31.05.2012 was as under:
Daily Max Wind Trigger
Fortnights
Wind speed
(Km/Hr)
10.
1-Mar to
15-Mar
16-Mar
to
31Mar
1-April to
15-April
16-April
30-April
to
1-May to 15May
16-May
May
to
31-
The District Forum allowed the complaints filed by the complainants
holding that most of the farmers were illiterate and that the only person
competent to give reasons for loss of crop was the Horticulture Officer. It was
also held that the concerned Tahsildar, Dhone, had issued a Certificate of
Renewal during the rabi season in 2011-12, according to which, it had rained
continuously for four days from 10.05.2012 to 13.05.2012 in the area, which
had received about 20 mm of rainfall and since it was the time when the
flowers were to convert into fruits, the loss occurred on account of heavy
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
rains and winds. The complaints were accordingly allowed with a direction for
payment of the assured amount to the complainants.
11.
The petitioner challenged the order passed by the District Consumer
Forum in First Appeal before the State Consumer Commission, which set
aside the order passed by the District Consumer Forum on the ground that it
had proceeded to allow the complaint based on Ex.A9, which was a
certificate issued by the Horticulture Officer and further held that the said
claim could not have been allowed inasmuch as the complainants had not
adduced any evidence and not filed any documents stating that there was a
storm on 13.05.2012.
12.
The order passed by the State Consumer Commission was then
challenged before the NCDRC in revision, who by its common order, dated
25.06.2024, partly allowed the revision petitions and set aside the orders of
the State Commission and the District Forum and directed the Insurance
Company to refund the premium amount collected from the complainants
along with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of filing
complaint as also to pay an amount of Rs.40,000/- to each of the
complainants/farmers as cost of litigation and suffering on account of mental
agony and harassment.
The basis for allowing the revision petitions, though partly allowed by
the NCDRC, was that the complainants/farmers had not been informed in
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
detail the manner in which the scheme would operate and that the
information that was provided was an extremely limited piece of information.
13.
Learned counsel for the appellants – Insurance Company would
submit that the view expressed by the NCDRC was unsustainable in law
inasmuch as it had erroneously come to a conclusion that the scheme had
not been fully explained to the farmers. Reference in this regard was made to
the proposal form which was signed by each of the farmers, who came to be
covered under the aforesaid scheme. It was urged that the view expressed
by the State Consumer Commission was the correct view, which had gone
into the entire issue minutely.
It was further urged that the basis of the claim of the complainants in
the complaint was loss to the mango crop that had been caused on account
of a storm and heavy rain on 13.05.2012 coupled with high speed winds
whereas the claim with regard to excess/unseasonal rainfall would be
covered only for the period from 01.01.2012 to 29.02.2012 and in any case,
did not cover and did not extend to 13.05.2012. It was stated that wind speed
was much below the trigger point of 35 and therefore, in no case could the
claimants be entitled to claim deficiency of service for non-payment of
compensation on account of the alleged crop loss.
14.
Learned counsel for the respondents/claimants, on the other hand,
reiterated the grounds earlier urged before the State Commission and sought
to justify and buttress the view already expressed by the NCDRC.
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
15.
The issue that falls for our consideration is as to whether the claimants
are entitled to the compensation in terms of the policy of insurance on
account of loss to the mango crop, which, according to the petitioners, they
had suffered on account of the storm with heavy rain coupled with high speed
winds on 13.05.2012.
Admittedly, the claim on account of loss to the mango crop would be
maintainable only if the claimants had established that there was
excess/unseasonal rainfall and that the daily maximum wind speed had
exceeded the daily maximum wind trigger as was prescribed under the
scheme.
16.
Insofar as the excess/unseasonal rainfall is concerned, the said
insurance cover was relevant only for the period from 01.01.2012 to
29.02.2012 and therefore, would in no case cover the alleged damage on
13.05.2012, which was otherwise claimed by the claimants.
Insofar as the alleged damage to the mango crop on account of the
excessive wind speed is concerned, the said could be covered if the loss had
occasioned from the period commencing from 01.03.2012 to 31.05.2012.
However, the daily maximum wind trigger in that case ought to have been at
least 35, as was prescribed for the period from 01.05.2012 to 15.05.2012
under the scheme.
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
17.
According to the case of the appellant – Insurance Company, the wind
speeds had not exceeded the prescribed trigger points and therefore, no
claim could be made by the claimants on that account.
However, we have to look at the issue from a different perspective, as
has been held by the National Commission and that is whether the Insurance
Company had made full disclosure of the scheme and, in particular, the
trigger points with regard to the wind speed etc. to the complainants at the
time when they were persuaded to get the insurance cover.
18.
At this stage, it will be relevant to refer to the Apex Court judgment
rendered in the case of Mahakali Sujatha vs. Branch Manager, Future
General India Life Insurance Company Limited and another1, where the
Apex Court emphasized the duty of both the insured and also the insurer to
make full disclosure in regard to the contract of insurance so that the parties
could make an informed decision with regard to the contract of insurance.
The Supreme Court in the judgment supra held thus:
“39.
From the aforementioned discussion, it is clear that the
principle of utmost good faith puts reciprocal duties of
disclosure on both parties to the contract of insurance. These
reciprocal duties mandate that both the parties make complete
disclosure to each other, so that the parties can take an
informed decision and a fair contract of insurance exists
between them. No material facts should be suppressed, which
may have a bearing on the risk being insured and the decision
of the party to undertake that risk. However, not every
question can be said to be material fact and the materiality of a
fact has to be adjudged as per the rules stated in the
aforementioned judgment.”
(2024) 8 SCC 712
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
19.
The necessity and importance of conveying to the beneficiary of an
insurance policy holder the conditions of the said insurance policy was also
dealt with earlier in Anju Kalsi vs. HDFC Ergo General Insurance
Company Limited and another2.
20.
In the aforesaid case, the claimant’s son had obtained the benefit of an
insurance cover under a policy called “Cardsure Package Policy”. The
claimant’s son was an accountholder with HDFC Bank Limited and had
availed a Debit Card from the Bank, who in turn had obtained an insurance
cover from HDFC Ergo General Insurance Company Limited for providing an
insurance cover for cardholders of the Bank. The claimant’s son however
died in an accident whereafter a claim was made under the insurance cover,
which was repudiated by the Insurance Company on the ground that the
deceased had not undertaken “non-ATM transaction” in the period of three
months immediately preceding the date of accident.
It is in that context that the Apex Court held that the insurance cover
was governed by a policy between the Bank and the Insurance Company
and that the terms and conditions of the insurance cover had to be
specifically communicated to the accountholder and should also be put on
notice that the insurance cover would become available only after a
transaction took place of the nature spelt out in the subject conditions of the
insurance policy. It also held that unless the respondents were able to
(2022) 6 SCC 394
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
establish on a cogent basis that the special conditions of the policy which
was issued by the Insurance Company to the Bank were drawn to the notice
of the accountholder, the claim could not have been repudiated.
21.
When we test the facts of the present case on the touchstone of the
ratio of the aforesaid judgments, it can be seen that even in the present case,
the claimants were not informed specifically that the insurance cover would
be available only if the trigger points were met in regard to wind speeds
during the relevant period.
22.
At this stage, we deem it apposite to deal with the argument of learned
Senior Counsel appearing for the Insurance Company that this was not a
case where the scheme of the insurance policy had not been intimated to the
claimants in its entirety. A lot of emphasis was placed by the learned Senior
Counsel on the declaration made by the claimants in the proposal form, one
of which reads as under:
“I hereby declare that the provisions of the Weather
Based Crop Insurance Scheme & the Product structure therein
have been read and understood by /explained to me in detail in
my language before completing the proposal form. I hereby
further declare that the particulars furnished above are true and
correct. I am aware and agree that the payout, if any, would be
made as per the data of the Reference Weather Station (RWS)
as mentioned in this proposal form. …”
23.
In the ordinary course, one would have accepted the argument of
learned Senior Counsel based upon the declaration so made, however, the
statement made by learned counsel for the Insurance Company before the
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
NCDRC suggests otherwise. What was recorded by the NCDRC in para
No.12 of its order is as under:
“12. Learned Counsel for the Insurance Company
submitted that the Scheme was explained to the farmers by way
of printing and distribution of a pamphlet in Telugu. I have gone
through the pamphlet and I notice that it is a one page pamphlet
back to back and contains extremely limited information. What
is contained are the four perils, along with period of operation of
such peril. The other details include the details of the crop
insured, payment of premium with certain details and farmer (s)
who are covered. Even the risk period mentioned in the
pamphlet has been incorrectly printed. For example, for the risk
of daily temperature fluctuation, the risk period is mentioned as
16th January - 3rd March, whereas actually it is 1st January 15th March as per the Notification. It could be a typographical
printing mistake. However, it is also a fact that the pamphlet
does not contain any further detail (s) of how the Scheme would
operate. Evidently, I am in agreement with the District Forum's
Order (s) to the extent that the farmers were not supplied with
full particulars of the Scheme, considering that the Scheme is
so highly technical and the trigger points in availing the
insurance claim put so high that any ordinary variation, if
detected in weather condition would not allow triggering of the
risk to be indemnified. … In this connection, I would like to
quote from the original Notification of Government of India,
wherein it has been stated that the proposed pilot scheme aims
"to mitigate the hardships of the farmers against the likelihood
of financial losses on account of anticipated crop loss resulting
from the incidence of adverse weather conditions of weather
parameters like temperature, rainfall, humidity etc.". Thus, it can
be seen that this is mainly to help mitigate the hardship of the
farmers. Defining the intricacies of the Scheme would amount to
proper disclosure.”
Learned counsel for the Insurance Company submitted that the
scheme was explained to the farmers by way of printing and distribution of a
pamphlet in Telugu.
24.
Therefore, it does transpire that while the declaration is said to have
been made by the claimants that they had been made to understand and
explained in detail the weather based crop insurance scheme and the
product structure, in fact, what was explained was only by way of the printing
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
and distribution of a pamphlet in Telugu, which pamphlet did not at all
mention the trigger points as regards wind speed etc. The NCDRC also
recorded that even the pamphlet had been incorrectly printed in regard to the
risk of daily temperature fluctuations where the risk period was mentioned as
16th January – 3rd March, whereas it was 1st January – 15th March as per the
notification.
In the facts and circumstances as discussed hereinabove, we are of
the opinion that the insurance claim of the claimants could not have
repudiated and they would be entitled to get indemnified to the extent of loss
for which they were otherwise insured in terms of the contract of insurance.
The claimants also are held entitled only to an extent of Rs.10,000/- per
claimant as cost of litigation and mental agony, as against Rs.40,000/awarded by the NCDRC. The insurance company would also not be under
any obligation to return to the claimants the premium amount as was ordered
to be refunded to the claimants, by the NCDRC. The order passed by the
NCDRC would stand modified to that extent.
The present batch of writ petitions shall stand disposed of accordingly.
No costs. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand closed.
DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CJ
RAVI CHEEMALAPATI, J
akn
HCJ & RC, J
W.P. No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, CHIEF JUSTICE
&
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
Writ Petition No: 22758 of 2024 & Batch
DATE : 30.01.2026
AKN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review