Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!"
%
!
& $
!
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
"
'
#
$
%
"
%&'& (
%&'& ($
!
"
#
$$
$$)
*
-2-
$)
$
$ $(
$(
$
$)
$ $(
+
%
, -
.
/01 23404056 01 70839 :; 4/3 234040563< 133=06> 45
?@A1/
51 $
4/3
5B9;1/334
5 $ C093
$
5<93<
9A439
$(
$)
$ $(
:3A<06>
2A1139 :; <312569364
663D@<3%
4 01 4/3 EA13 57 4/3 234040563< 4/A4 /3 01 4/3
:@106311FA6 <310906> A4
A8A:@<A>0
B<04436 A 83443< 45 <312569364
312569364
5 $ 36@F3<A406> 4/3
934A081 57 4/3 EA13 <3>0143<39 A>A0614 4/3 234040563<
@<1@A64 45 4/A4 <312569364
5 $ <3043<A406> 4/3 E5643641
57 4/3 83443< 14A406> 4/A4 4/3 234040563< B04/ /01 1@225<43<1
01 0640F09A406> 4/<3A43606> A69 136906> B<56> F311A>31
-3-
45 4/3 2@:80E A69 AE406> 06 ><5@21 A69 9014@<:06> 8AB A69
5<93< 06 4/3 C088A>31
4/3 234040563< 06
5 $ H $(
I
I)
3E4056
36E3 A EA13 01 <3>0143<39 A>A0614
4A4056
AGA<
580E3
4A4056 06
75< 4/3 57736E31 2@601/A:83 @693<
$
$I
I
&(I &(
A69
<0F3
3E40561
($ <3A9 B04/
IH 57
A139 56 4/3 <3>014<A4056 57 4/3 E<0F3 A69 70806>
57 4/3 E/A<>3 1/334 <312569364
<3E5FF36939
234040563< /3<306
A
<5B9;
6123E45< 57
1/334
A>A0614
A139 56 B/0E/ <312569364
580E3
4/3
5 $ /A1
2A1139 4/3 5<93< 06E8@906> 4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< :;
523606> <5B9; 1/334 A>A0614 /0F 06 4/3 <3>0143< 9A439
$)
$ $(
A1 4/3 234040563< BA1 06C58C39 06
<0F3
5 $ H $(
I
4 01 E56436939 :; 4/3 E5@6138 75< 4/3 234040563<
4/A4 4/3 234040563< /A1 :336 AE?@04439 06
5 '' $( ) A<0106> 5@4 57
56 $) (
$( '
<0F3
312043 B/0E/
5 $ H $(
3110561
A13
BA; :AE=
4/3 234040563<-1 6AF3 01
06E8@939 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 A69 /3 01 1@FF5639 45 4/3
-4-
2580E3
14A4056
B/A4153C3<
<93<
40F3
A69
A>A06
B04/5@4
A6;
<3A156
0883>A88; A69 E564<A<; 45 4/3 2<5C010561 57
51 (&' A69
(&H 57 4/3
A<6A4A=A
580E3
A6@A8
4 01 A815 E56436939 4/A4 65 1/5B EA@13 6540E3 01 011@39
A69 F3<38; 56 4/3 :A101 57 A6 3A<803< E<0F3 6@F:3< 4/3
6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< 01 06E8@939 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334
/3<375<3
4/3
<312569364
234040563<
FA93
<32<31364A4056
$($&
75<
4/3
(& (
<3C03B06>
0F2@>639 5<93< A69 45 938343 /01 6AF3 7<5F 4/3 <5B9;
1/334 A1 /3 /A1 :336 AE?@04439 06 4/3 EA13 :A139 56
B/0E/
/01 6AF3 BA1 06E8@939 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334
1AF3 /A1 654 :336 E561093<39 :; <312569364
&
/3
4 01 E56436939 4/A4 B/36 4/3 234040563< FA93
A2280EA4056 5< <32<31364A4056 4/3 <312569364 A@4/5<04031
5@>/4 45 /AC3 AEE32439 4/3 <32<31364A4056 A69 2<5C0939
A6 5225<4@604; 45 4/3 234040563< 45 2@4 75<4/ /01 EA13 57
4/3<3 :306> 65 A883>A4056 57 E<0F06A8 EA131 236906> A>A0614
/0F A69 4/A4 06E8@1056 57 /01 6AF3 A69 E56406@06> /01
-5-
6AF3 06 4/3
5B9;
/334
3>0143< 01 C058A40C3 57 4/3
2<06E02831 57 6A4@<A8 J@140E3 06E8@906> /01 23<156A8 80:3<4;
4 01 A815 E56436939 4/A4 06 12043 57 4/3
234040563< :306> AE?@04439 06 4/3 EA13 4/A4 BA1 70839
A>A0614 /0F A69 9312043 4/3 <32<31364A4056 :306> FA93
4/3 234040563<-1 6AF3 01 654 14<@E= 577 7<5F 4/3 <3>0143< 57
<5B9031 4/3<3:; EA@106> @64589 /A<91/02 A69 C058A4056 57
/01 7@69AF364A8 <0>/4 57 7<33 F5C3F364 A69 /01 80:3<4;
)
4 01 A815 E56436939 :; 4/3 83A<639 E5@6138 4/A4
<3125693641 /AC3 654 75885B39 4/3 63E311A<; >@09380631
8A09 95B6 :; 4/01
5@<4 06 4/3 EA13 57
<325<439 06
/3<375<3 /3 E5643691 4/A4 0F280EA406> 4/3
234040563< A69 <3>0143<06> /01 6AF3 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 01
0883>A8 A69 C058A40C3 57 2<06E02831 57 6A4@<A8 J@140E3
36E3
4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< <3?@0<31 45 :3 <3F5C39 A69
E5613?@3648; 4/3 1A09 5<93< :3 ?@A1/39
234040563< 01 23<75<E39 45 A22<5AE/ 4/01
B<04 J@<0190E4056
36E3
4/3
5@<4 06C5=06> 4/3
-6-
'
83A<639
9C5EA43
<32<3136406>
9904056A8
<312569364% 4A43
5C3<6F364
A9F041
4/3
AE?@044A8 57 4/3 234040563< 06 4/3 A75<31A09 E<0F06A8 EA13
A69 56 C3<070EA4056 A69 A743< 4A=06> 0614<@E40561 1@:F041
4/A4 4/3 234040563<-1 6AF3 01 14088 E56406@06> 06 4/3 <5B9;
1/334 :@4 4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< BA1 06E8@939 06 4/3
5B9;
/334
3>0143< 2<05< 45 AE?@044A8 A69 A815 ?@314056
57 75885B06> 4/3 >@09380631 8A09 95B6 :; 4/3
36E/ 57 4/01
5%5<906A43
5@<4 06 4/3 EA13 57
!1@2<A# B5@89 654 A<013 75< 4/3 <3A156 4/A4 06E8@1056 57 4/3
6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< 06 4/3
45 4/3 1A09 J@9>F364
5B9;
/334
3>0143< 01 2<05<
36E3 4/3 1AF3 B088 654 36@<3 45
4/30< :363704
EE5<906>8; /3 133=1 45 901F011 4/3 23404056
H
/AC3 /3A<9 83A<639 E5@6138 75< 4/3 234040563<
A69 83A<639
(
9904056A8
5C3<6F364
9C5EA43 75< 4/3
4A43
4 01 A 7@69AF364A8 <@83 57 8AB 4/A4 B/36 A
23<156 01 0F280EA439 A1 A <5B9; 1/3343< :; 06E8@906> /01
6AF3 06 4/3 8014 57 <5B9; 1/334 4/3 56@1 01 @256 4/3
4A43
45 75885B 4/3 9@3 2<5E39@<3 E5643F28A439 @693< 4/3
-7-
<383CA64 <@831 A69 <3>@8A40561
A<6A4A=A
580E3
6 4/3 2<31364 EA13 4/3
A6@A8 F5<3 123E070EA88; 4/3
5B9031 FA064A0639 06 5<93<
3>0143< 57
(&H B/0E/ 93A81 B04/
/0145<; 1/3341 A69 <5B9; 1/3341 A69 36<588F364 5<
<3>014<A4056 57 23<1561 06 4/3 1A09 1/334 75< <3>0143< 75<
E56406@5@1 F56045<06> :; 4/3 2580E3 A@4/5<04031
75885B39
4A6906>
57 <5B9031
<93<
01 654
(&H 93A81 B04/ <3>014<A4056
/3 9370604056 2<5C0939 01 4/A4 A <5B9; FA; :3
9370639 A1 A >@69A A69 06E8@931 A /5580>A6
45@>/
CA>A:569 5< A6; 23<156 B/5 01 9A6>3<5@1 45 2@:80E 23AE3
A69 4<A6?@0804;
/3<3 A<3 FA6; 75<F1 57 <5B901F B/0E/
A<3 931E<0:39 4/3<306 A69 4/3 2<5E311 A69 2<5E39@<3
E5643F28A439 45 :3 FA064A0639 06 90773<364 2A<41 6AF38;
A<4
A<4
A69
A<4
B/0E/ >5C3<6 4/3 FA06436A6E3
57 A <3>0143< A69 4/3 6AF31 57 4/3 <5B9031 06 4/30<
<3123E40C3 2A<41
4 01 4/3 9@4; A69 5:80>A4056 EA14 @256
4/3 <3125693641 B/0E/ 01 654 524056A8 45 75885B 4/3 9@3
2<5E39@<3 E5643F28A439 @693< 4/3 14A6906> 5<93<1 57 4/3
A<6A4A=A
580E3
A6@A8
B/083 3643<06> 4/3 6AF3 57 A
-8-
23<156
4/3
<5B9;
1/334
A69
4/3<3
A<3
E3<4A06
2<5E39@<31 45 :3 FA69A45<08; 75885B39 :375<3 3643<06> 4/3
6AF31
1 E56436939 :; 83A<639 E5@6138 75< 4/3 234040563<
4/3 2<5E311 A69 2<5E39@<3 A1 E5643F28A439 @693< 4/3
14A6906>
<93<
(&H 57 4/3
A<6A4A=A
580E3
A6@A8
/A1 654 :336 75885B39 A69 65 5225<4@604; BA1 >0C36 45 4/3
234040563< 45 7083 /01 <328; 5< 3D28A6A4056 75< <3F5C06> /01
6AF3 06 4/3
5B9;
/334
3>0143< A69 F3<38; :3EA@13 /3
BA1 06C58C39 06 E<0F06A8 EA13 06 B/0E/ A815 4/3 234040563<
/A1 :336 AE?@04439 06 4/3 ;3A< $( '
4 01 A815 E56436939
4/A4 4/5@>/ 4/3 234040563< /A1 FA93 <32<31364A4056 45 4/3
<312569364 A@4/5<04031 A743< 4/3 AE?@044A8 56 (& ( $($&
4/3 <32<31364A4056 /A1 654 :336 E561093<39 A69 3C36 A743<
4/3 AE?@044A8 /3 /A1 :336 1@FF5639 45 4/3 J@<0190E4056A8
2580E3 14A4056 75< @663E311A<; 0643<<5>A4056 B/36 4/3<3 01
65 EA13 236906> A>A0614 /0F
4 B5@89 :3 <383CA64 45 3D4<AE4 2A<A><A2/
57 4/3 J@9>F364 57
0C01056
!"
36E/ 57 4/01
"
)
5@<4 06 4/3 EA13
-9-
<325<439 06 #$
%&&
'
(
B/3<306 4/3
0C01056
36E/ 93A84 B04/ 10F08A< 1@:J3E4 FA443< B/0E/ <3A91 A1
@693<
!
"
#
#
%
&'(
$
#
)
$
#
%
)
* )
$
&'(
#
+
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
#
)
)
)
)
,
)
#
-
K
$
A6@A8
4A6906>
<93<
(&H 57
A<6A4A=A
HH' 01 3D4<AE439 :385B
&'( . / 0
#
)
)
580E3
- 10 -
.2/
3+
/
!
,
/ 6
#
)
)
#
/
)
/
!
)
)
,
)
+
+
)
))
/*
,
,
/
,
/
.7/ 6
#
#9
)
;
%
:
.</ . / %
&&
)
#
)
)
)
. / %
)
)
=
8"
:
)
#
)
. / %
)
>% #
>
+
- 11 -
.'/
$
+* #
)
$
#
.?/ %
)
)
!
:
)
. / @
)
#
)
#
)
$
.A/
#
)
)
)
)
)
)
"
)
*
)
)
.(/ $
"
*
#
)
#
#
:
)
)
"
)
*
* $
#
#
. &/
)
#
)
#
#
)
)
- 12 -
.
/ @
#
+
$
!
8:8
)
)
$
!
. 2/ @
+
8:8
@
)
!
$
. 7/ %
8:8
)
!
)
)
)
+* #
. </
$
)
+
)
)
)
. '/ B
!
C
./
)
#
!
)
- 13 -
. /
))
)
2(<
4 .
/,
. /
#
!
(2 . / .)/ .1/
(?7
. /
D
#
. #/ 0
!
) #
C
&A . /
,
.#/ 0
& 4
.# / 0
&4
.# / 0
,
)
# / EC
'?
#
#
)
D
''
!
. C/ 0
(?7,
'&( 6
# +
. ?/ E#
)
E
"
:
)
)
#
+
)
+ +
#
)
)
!
)
+
.
/ @
#
$
)
)
"
#
#
. A/
)
)
&?
- 14 -
3+
/
%
2/ %
)
7/ 5
)
)
</ %
)
'/
?/ $
F
/%
A/
!
. (/ 6
)
)
#
)
)
#
!
)
/3
5%5<906A43
-
36E/ 57 4/01
5@<4 06 4/3 EA13
!1@2<A# /A1 8A09 95B6 >@09380631
B/0E/ A<3 45 :3 75885B39 B/083 <3>0143<06> 4/3 6AF3 57 A
23<156 06 4/3
5B9;
/334
3>0143< B/0E/ 3C36 2<05< 45
4/3 1A09 J@9>F364 BA1 A FA69A43 75< 4/3 <3125693641 45
/AC3 75885B39 14<0E48; 06 AEE5<9A6E3 45 4/3 14A6906> 5<93<
(&H 57 4/3
A<6A4A=A
580E3
A6@A8
B/0E/ 06 F;
- 15 -
5206056
E561093<06> 4/3 7AE41 A69 E0<E@F14A6E3 57 4/3
2<31364 EA13 /A1 654 :336 75885B39 A69 3C36 A743< 4/3
AE?@044A8
4/3
234040563<
A69
3C36
A743<
4/3
<32<31364A4056 >0C36 :; 4/3 234040563< 75< <3F5C06> /01
6AF3 7<5F 4/3
5B9;
/334
3>0143<
4/3<3 01 65
<3125613 5< <328; 5< AE4056 :; 4/3 <3125693641 06
<3F5C06> /01 6AF3
I
6 C03B 57 656%E5F280A6E3 57 4/3 2<5E39@<3
E5643F28A439
A<6A4A=A
@693<
580E3
14A6906>
5<93<
(&H
4/3
A6@A8 A69 656%E561093<A4056 57 4/3
<32<31364A4056 >0C36 :; 4/3 234040563< 2@<1@A64 45 /01
AE?@044A8 4/01
5@<4 01 57 4/3 5206056 4/A4 4/3 234040563<
/A1 FA93 5@4 A CA809 EA13 45 E561093< 7AC5@<A:8;
&
EE5<906>8;
2A11 4/3 75885B06>
/3
<04 3404056 01
/3
0F2@>639
))
5<93<
<3>A<906> 523606>
9A439
5B9;
/334
$)
$ $(
3>0143< 06
- 16 -
4/3
6AF3
5$
4/3
234040563<
5B9;1/334
<312569364
$(
:3A<06>
2A1139 :;
5 $ 01 /3<3:; ?@A1/39
/3 <3125693641 A<3 /3<3:; 90<3E439 45
<3F5C3 4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< 7<5F 4/3
5B9;
/334
3>0143< FA064A0639 :; 4/3F
B04/06 A 23<059 57 75@< B33=1 7<5F 4/3 9A43
57 <3E3024 57 E3<407039 E52; 57 4/3 5<93<
0C
0:3<4;
/5B3C3<
<312569364
<313<C39
4/3
4A43 45 2<5E339 06 AEE5<9A6E3
B04/ 8AB A>A0614 4/3 234040563< 07 A4 A88 A6;
EA13 01 FA93 5@4 A69 B/083 9506> 15 4/3;
1/A88 14<0E48; 75885B 4/3 >@09380631 8A09 95B6
:; 4/01
5@<4 06 4/3 EA13 57
<325<439 06
()
&
!
%
H
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review