Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:17642
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (C) NO. 6299 OF 2022
…..
Afan Khan, aged about 52 years, Son of Late Rahman Khan, resident
of village Kindirkela, P.O. and P.S. Basia, District-Gumla
(Jharkhand).
….Petitioner
-versus1. State of Jharkhand
2. Secretary, Revenue, Land Reforms and Registration Department,
Government of Jharkhand, Project Building Dhurwa, Ranchi, P.O.
and P.S. Jagarnathpur, District-Ranchi.
3. Deputy Commissioner, Gumla, P.O., P.S. and District-Gumla.
4. Land Reforms Deputy Collector, Gumla, P.O., P.S. and DistrictGumla.
5. Circle Officer, Basia, P.O. and P.S. Basia, District-Gumla.
…Respondents
CORUM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
…..
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Amar Kumar Sinha, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. Ashutosh Anand (AAG-III)
Mr. S.K.Sinha, Adv
…..
CAV On: 02/4/2026
Pronounced on:15/06/2026
1.
Heard the parties.
2.
The instant writ petition has been filed seeking the following
relief:
For issuance of an appropriate writ for quashing the order
dated 10.5.2019, passed by the Circle Officer, Basia, in
Mutation Case No. 5R27/2018-19, contained in Annexure 2 to
the writ petition, by which the Respondent No. 5 has rejected
the petition filed by the Petitioner for mutation of name with
respect to the land measuring an area of 1.54 acres pertaining
to RS Plot No. 1291 of Khata No. 4 situated at Mouza Kaliga,
PO, PS and District Gumla and for quashing the order dated
14.6.2022 passed by the Land Reforms Deputy Collector,
Gumla, in Mutation Appeal No. 7 of 2019-20, (Annexure-3)
dismissing the appeal filed by the Petitioner on absolutely
irrelevant consideration of materials on the record and for
quashing the order dated 05.09.2022 passed by the Deputy
Commissioner, Gumla, in Mutation Revision Case No. 36 of
2022-23 (Annexure-4), dismissing the revision filed by the
2026:JHHC:17642
Petitioner contrary to the provisions of the Bihar Tenant
Holding (Maintenance of Records) Act, 1973, and the rules
framed thereunder; and for such other reliefs to which the
Petitioner is entitled.”
3.
Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits that the
land forming the subject matter of the instant petition was purchased
for valuable consideration by virtue of a registered sale deed dated
8.9.2012 from Dr. Raghawendra Narayan Sharma and others. He
submits that upon execution of the sale deed, the Petitioner came into
possession of the land.
4.
Learned counsel further submits that the land in question was
Bakast land of the ex-landlord, namely Pandey Maheshwarnath Roy.
The ex-landlord sold the land to one Deokinandan Sharma by virtue
of a registered sale deed dated 7.3.1944. He submits that the land
was mutated in the name of Deokinandan Sharma and revenue rent
receipts were issued in his name. The legal heirs of Deokinandan
Sharma sold the land to the Petitioner by virtue of the abovementioned sale deed.
5.
Learned counsel further submits that after purchasing the land,
the Petitioner filed an application before Respondent No. 5, praying
that the land be mutated in his name. The said case was registered as
mutation case No. 5R27 of 2018-19. However, as per the Petitioner,
Respondent No. 5, without making any inquiry with respect to the
possession and claim of the Petitioner, rejected the application on the
ground of the pendency of a writ petition, being WP(PIL) No. 4024
of 2017, on 10.5.2019. He submits that the finding returned by
2026:JHHC:17642
Respondent No. 5 is perverse, as the said public interest litigation
[WP(PIL) No. 4024 of 2017] had already been dismissed on
28.9.2018 with a cost of ₹10,000/- (INR Ten Thousand Only).
6.
Learned counsel further submits that he preferred an appeal
against the above order, which was registered as Mutation Appeal
No. 7 of 2019-20. Respondent No. 4 dismissed the appeal without
proper consideration on 14.6.2022. Thereafter, the Petitioner chose
to file a revision registered as mutation revision case No. 36 of 202223 before Respondent No. 3. The Ld. counsel contends that
Respondent No. 3, without proper consideration, dismissed the said
revision vide order dated 5.9.2022.
7.
On the basis of the above said facts, the Petitioner submits that
he has acquired a right over the property by virtue of a registered
document and is in possession of the same. As per the submissions
of the Ld. Counsel for the Petitioner, the impugned orders will show
that the application of the Petitioner for mutation has been rejected
on the ground that the entry in Register-II is suspicious. He submits
that mutation cannot be rejected on such frivolous grounds, and as
such, the instant writ petition ought to be allowed. The Petitioner has
placed reliance on the case of Chattar Pal v. Mandir Thakur ji (2003
2 PLJ 191) to contend that the mutating authority is required to find
out who is in lawful possession of the property on the date of
consideration of the application and must adjudicate the application
accordingly. If the applicant is found to be in lawful possession, then
in such a case, mutation is to be allowed.
2026:JHHC:17642
8.
Per contra, the Ld. counsel appearing for the Respondent-
State has urged that the instant writ petition ought to be dismissed in
limine, as the same involves adjudication of disputed questions of
fact. In paragraph 12 of the counter affidavit filed by the
Respondent-State, the claim of the Petitioner, with respect to his
possession over the land has been disputed. It is further submitted
that the impugned orders have been passed after ample consideration
of both the fact and the law.
9.
The Ld. counsel representing the Respondent-State further
submits that Respondent No. 3, prior to passing the order dated
5.9.2022, had called for an inquiry report from the Additional
Collector, Gumla. In his report, it is categorically recorded that
before vesting of Zamindari, the ex-landlord was dispossessed from
the land forming the subject matter of the instant petition, and as
such, Form M under the Bihar Land Reforms Act, 1950, was not
issued in his favour. Further, the Remarks Column of Register II does
not contain the signature of the competent authority, and as such, the
same is suspicious.
10.
Respondents Nos. 6 to 15 were impleaded as intervenor
Respondents upon their application, upon an interlocutory
application being IA No. 29 of 2024, filed by them. The Ld. Counsel
appearing for Respondent Nos. 6 to 15 claimed that the land forming
the subject matter of the instant petition is used by the villagers for
more than 100 years for various social and religious purposes, such
as stocking their crops, holding melas, etc. They have further
2026:JHHC:17642
contended that a school has been running over a portion of the land
since 1970, and another portion is also used as a playground.
11.
Respondents No. 6 to 15 have also filed a counter-affidavit in
which strong reliance has been placed on an order passed in a case
registered as M. No. 2 of 1980 under Section 145 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973. The said order passed on 26.8.1988
shows that the land was being used by the villagers for common
purposes.
12.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after going
through the records, the following issue is framed for adjudication
of the instant writ petition: Whether instant writ petition can be entertained and the relief sought
by the petitioner be granted ?
13.
This Court is of the view that adjudication of the instant
petition requires looking into certain factual aspects which are hotly
contested by the parties. The Ld. counsel appearing for the Petitioner
has claimed to be in possession of the land upon execution of the
sale deed dated 8.9.2012. He has claimed that he was put into
possession by his predecessors in interest, and since then he has been
in peaceful possession of the land. The factual matrix pertaining to
the Petitioner's possession has, however, been disputed by the
Respondent-State as well as by Respondents Nos 6 to 15.
14.
The records suggest that the Petitioner had purchased the
property by registered sale deed in the year 2012. However, the
application for mutation was filed only in 2018. The Petitioner has
2026:JHHC:17642
not explained this delay of six years in applying for mutation. Apart
from mere averments in the writ petition (which have been denied),
the Petitioner has not brought on record any evidence of the
preceding nature which could clear the cloud with respect to his
possession over the property.
15.
Reference is made to the case of Mahnoor Fatima Imran and
Ors v. Visheshwar Infrastructure Private Limited and Ors. (2025
INSC 646), wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India has held
that in order for a writ petition to be entertainable, clear title and
proven physical possession are must. Similarly, in the case of
Roshina T v. Abdul Aziz KT and Ors (Civil Appeal No. 11759 of
2018), it has been held that issues pertaining to possession entail
adjudicating factual disputes, which require the court to strenuously
examine the evidence.
16.
Such adjudication can be done by a civil court in a civil suit,
but not in a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India.
17.
These judgements are based on the established principle of
law that while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, this court cannot delve into questions of fact
which are hotly contested.
18.
The judgement relied upon by the Petitioner will not apply to
the case at hand, as in the said case the lawful possession over the
property in question was established beyond any doubt.
2026:JHHC:17642
19.
Even otherwise, the orders impugned before this Court seem
to have been passed, taking into consideration the entirety of the
facts and the title antecedent of the land. The orders passed by
Respondent No. 3 and Respondent No. 4 show consideration of
contentions raised by both parties and proper scrutiny of the
available records.
20.
It is established law, the court, in exercise of its extraordinary
jurisdiction, while undertaking judicial review of a decision, cannot;
rather should not, act as a court of appeal. The scope of judicial
review is to see whether the decision impugned before it is vitiated
by an apparent error of law or, on the face of it, is perverse. Powers
of judicial review can be exercised in cases where the decision is so
arbitrary and capricious that no reasonable person could have ever
arrived at it.
21.
In the case at hand, the Petitioner has failed to make out any
such case, and as such, no interference is required.
22.
In light of the above, the Petitioner cannot be granted the relief
as prayed for. However, the Petitioner shall have liberty to avail
appropriate remedy within the legal framework.
23.
The writ petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending I.A. if any,
stands closed. No order as to cost.
(Deepak Roshan, J)
Dated15 /06/2026
Amardeep/
N.A.F.R
Uploaded on
19.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review