Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL REVISION APPLICATION (AGAINST ORDER PASSED BY
SUBORDINATE COURT) NO. 3105 of 2026
==========================================================
ADILKHAN SALIMKHAN BELIM
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. FAIZAN I SAMA(22021) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR. ROHAN RAVAL, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 28/10/2026
ORAL ORDER
Draft amendment stands allowed.
1.
By way of this revision application under Section 438 read
with Section 442 of the BNSS, 2023, the applicant has prayed to
quash and set aside the order dated 04.08.2026 passed by the
learned Sessions Judge, Valsad, below Exhibit-6 in Sessions
Case No. 8 of 2026, rejecting the discharge application preferred
by the applicant under Section 227 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973, and has further prayed to discharge the
applicant from the offence punishable under Section 304 of the
IPC
in
connection
with
FIR
No.11200019220956/2022,
registered at Dungri Police Station, District Valsad, dated
13.07.2022.
2.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order passed by
the learned Sessions Judge, Valsad, in Sessions Case No. 8 of
2026, below Exhibit 6, wherein the application moved by the
present applicant, invoking the provisions of Section 227 of the
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
Code of Criminal Procedure, corresponding to Section 250 of the
BNSS, 2023, was rejected, the applicant has sought discharge
from the
array of accused in connection with FIR No.
11200019220956/ 2022 registered at Dungri Police Station,
District Valsad, dated 13.07.2022.
3.
Learned advocate for the applicant submitted that the FIR,
the statements and allegations contained therein, and the
material collected during the course of the investigation does not
disclose the ingredients of the offence punishable under Section
304 of the IPC. It is further submitted that there was no
intention on the part of the applicant in the incident in question
and, therefore, the invocation of the provisions of Section 304 of
the IPC is nothing but a mere assertion without any substance.
It is further submitted that there was no enmity between the
parties in connection with the present accusations and,
therefore, the invocation of Section 304 of the IPC is nothing but
a mere addition to establish the gravity and severity of the
offence in question. Concluding his submissions, the learned
advocate submitted that, at the most, the offence under Section
304A of the IPC can be said to have been made out.
4.
Per contra, the learned APP, Mr. Rohan Raval, submitted
and defended the impugned order, contending that the same had
been passed after duly considering all the contentions raised by
the applicant herein, which were based solely on assumptions
and presumptions and were in the nature of a defence. He
further submitted that the defence of the accused cannot be
considered while dealing with an application seeking discharge
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
from the array of accused. He further submitted that, even upon
considering the statements and allegations, as well as the
panchnama drawn at the scene of the offence and the other
material placed for consideration, there appears to be ample
material to frame charges against the accused for the alleged
offence. He further submitted that it is a case of sheer rashness
and negligence, wherein the present applicant is alleged to have
hit the motorcycle from behind, resulting in the deaths of three
persons. Therefore, he submitted that there appears to be
sufficient material to frame the charges and requested that the
application be rejected.
5.
Having heard the learned advocates for the parties and
considered the conclusion arrived at by the learned Sessions
Judge, this Court is required to consider and confine its
reasoning to the invocation of the provisions of Section 227 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure, which pertain to the discharge
of the accused from the array of accused in respect of the
statements and allegations made against them.
6.
It is required to be placed on record that, while exercising
jurisdiction and dealing with an application seeking discharge of
the accused from the array of accused, only the material placed
for consideration by the prosecution is to be looked into, and no
defence is to be considered. Thus, the entire burden, even
otherwise, lies on the applicant to seek and pray for discharge
from the array of accused.
7.
However, the learned advocate for the applicant is not in a
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
position to point out any such material, either from the chargesheet or from the police investigation papers, that would
constrain this Court to consider the request for discharge. On
the contrary, the material collected by the Investigating Officer
during the course of the investigation, which culminated in the
submission of the charge-sheet and the registration of the case,
apparently discloses sufficient material and grounds to proceed
against the accused. It is pertinent to note, at this stage, the
relevant portions of the reasoning assigned by the learned
Sessions Judge while relying on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex
Court with regard to the weight to be attached to the material on
record and the circumstances under which the parameters for
invoking the provisions of Section 227 are to be considered. At
the stage of discharge, the Court is not required to weigh the
evidence as if it were conducting a trial. The Hon'ble Supreme
Court in State of Bihar v. Ramesh Singh, (1977) 4 SCC 39,
Union of India v. Prafulla Kumar Samal, (1979) 3 SCC 4,
Sajjan Kumar v. CBI, (2010) 9 SCC 368 and Amit Kapoor v.
Ramesh Chander, (2012) 9 SCC 460 has consistently held that
where the material placed before the Court gives rise to a strong
suspicion regarding the involvement of the accused, the Court
would be justified in framing charge. At the stage of discharge,
the Court is not required to weigh the evidence as if it were
conducting the trial.
8.
Thus, in view of the aforesaid, having considered the sum
and substance of the relevant propositions laid down in the
aforesaid decided cases, the facts of the case at hand, and the
submissions advanced by the learned advocate for the applicant,
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
as opposed by the learned APP, this Court is of the view that
there appears to be sufficient material, at least to give rise to a
strong suspicion regarding the involvement of the accused, and,
therefore, there is proper justification, at least, for framing the
charges. It is also pertinent to note that, while dealing with the
issue of whether the applicant should be discharged from the
array of accused, the Court is not required to weigh the evidence
as if it were conducting a trial.
9.
Thus, the submission advanced by the learned advocate for
the applicant that there was no intention or knowledge on the
part of the applicant while committing the alleged crime cannot
be considered at this stage. There is no case of the prosecution,
as urged, that the incident was intentional, rather, it is a case of
rashness and negligence. Even otherwise, these allegations are
required to be appreciated judicially by leading ocular evidence,
during which the applicant would also have an opportunity to
cross-examine the witnesses and put forth his own case.
10.
The contention that Section 304 of the Indian Penal Code
is not attracted and that the case would fall only under Section
304A IPC also cannot be accepted at this stage. The question
whether the material collected during investigation discloses
merely rash and negligent driving punishable under Section
304A IPC or whether it also discloses the requisite knowledge so
as to attract Section 304 IPC is essentially a matter to be decided
after the parties lead evidence during trial. At this stage, the
Court is only required to ascertain whether there exists sufficient
material to proceed against the accused. A detailed examination
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
of the ingredients of the offence and appreciation of evidence is
beyond the permissible scope of an application under Section
227 of the Code.
11.
More so, while dealing with the application filed under
Section 227 and 239 of the Code which pertains to discharge,
the scope to exercise such jurisdiction is very limited; wherein
the Court has only to confine its reasoning in consonance with
the material placed for consideration as to find out whether the
case for trial has been made or not in such proceedings and the
Court is not expected to hold a mini trial by evaluating the entire
set of evidence. At the time of framing of the charge, the Court
has only to consider the probative value of the evidence on
record and is not expected to go into the merits of the case
rather roots of the case while evaluating the same.
12.
In context to the aforesaid legal aspect, the detailed
application amalgamated in the number of contentions while
weighing the value of the evidence on record; with the plausible
defence set for by the applicant by way of filing the application,
which runs in number of pages is a self- explanatory of the fact
that the entire case requires to be appreciated judiciously;
instead of expecting from the Court to conduct the mini trial, at
the stage of deciding the application seeking discharge from the
array of the accused, which otherwise is not permissible under
the law as there are catena of decisions which restrains the
Court to adhere to the very purpose and object behind provisions
of Section 239 of the Code.
13.
Thus, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that the obligation
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
to discharge the accused under Section 239 of the Code arises
when the Court concerned considers the charge against accused
to be "groundless" and no detailed evaluation of materials or
meticulous
consideration
of
possible
defences
need
be
undertaken at this stage nor any exercise of weighing materials
in golden scales is to be undertaken at this stage and only
consideration at the stage of filing application seeking discharge
under
Section
of
the
Code
is
as
to
whether
the
allegation/charge is “groundless” or not and exercise at this
stage is to be confined to considering police report and
documents to decide whether allegations against accused can be
said to be groundless. Here, In the present case, considering the
police report in the form of charge-sheet, it pirma facie reveals
that no such material is found to be “groundless” to discharge
the petitioner from the alleged offence. Nothing sort of any
material seems to have been shown by the petitioner – accused
from material to show “groundless” charge alleged against him.
14.
It is pertinent to note that very purpose and object of
discharge as enumerated in provisions of Section 239 of the
Code wherein the “mini trial” at the stage of framing of charge is
not permissible; nor the Court is expected to go into the merits of
the case. The Court is only to confined as to whether a prima
facie case is made out or not. As the word enumerated
“groundless” requires a careful and objective consideration of the
question whether a charge against the accused is “groundless” or
whether there is a ground for presuming that he has committed
an offence. Thus, the sum and substance of the word
“groundless” means there must be no grounds for presuming
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
that the accused has committed an offence. However, by
invoking the provisions of Section 239 of the Code, pertains to
discharge, which otherwise may very from case to case, is being
used as an instrument rather a shield to stall the smooth
proceedings of the trial and thereby to create an obstructions so
that the trial could not met with its legitimate fate in time, which
is not permissible in the eye of law.
15.
Thus, in view of the aforesaid law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court, the Court is required to see as to whether a prima
facie case is made out or not and whether the accused is
required to be put to trial or not at the stage of framing of the
charge and / or while deciding discharge application and it is
not permissible to hold a “mini trial”. No defence on merits is to
be considered at the time of framing the charge and / or at the
stage of deciding the discharge application.
16.
Insofar as the scope to exercise the revisional power is
concerned, it cannot be exercised in a routine or casual manner
as the High Court has no authority to appreciate the evidence by
holding a “mini trial” as has been held by the Hon’ble Apex Court
in State Through Deputy Superintendent Of Police (supra) where
the Hon’ble Apex Court after considering the decision in case of
Munna Devi v. State of Rajasthan & Anr., (2001) 9 SCC 631
has held in paragraph No.75 and 76 as under:
“75. In Munna Devi v. State of Rajasthan & Anr.,
(2001) 9 SCC 631,this Court held as under:"3.....The revision power under the Code of Criminal
Procedure cannot be exercised in a routine and casual
manner. While exercising such powers the High Court
has no authority to appreciate the evidence in the
manner as the trial and the appellate courts are
required to do. Revisional powers could be exercised
R/CR.RA/3105/2026
(GJHC240777372026)
ORDER DATED: 28/10/2026
only when it is shown that there is a legal bar against
the continuance of the criminal proceedings or the
framing of charge or the facts as stated in the first
information report even if they are taken at the face
value and accepted in their entirety do not constitute
the offence for which the accused has been charged."
76. Thus, the revisional power cannot be exercised in
a casual or mechanical manner. It can only be
exercised to correct manifest error of law or procedure
which would occasion injustice, if it is not corrected.
The revisional power cannot be equated with appellate
power. A revisional court cannot undertake meticulous
examination of the material on record as it is
undertaken by the trial court or the appellate court.
This power can only be exercised if there is any legal
bar to the continuance of the proceedings or if the facts
as stated in the charge- sheet are taken to be true on
their face value and accepted in their entirety do not
constitute the offence for which the accused has been
charged. It is conferred to check grave error of law or
procedure.”
17.
The learned Court below has succinctly dealt with all the
aspect as agitated by the petitioner-accused while refusing the
discharge application considering the factual as well as the legal
position and this Court is in complete agreement with the said
findings arrived at by the learned Court below denying the
discharge application.
18.
For the foregoing reasons and the reasons recorded by the
learned Court below, therefore, sum and substance is that
defence raised herein seeking discharge, as discussed in
preceding paragraphs cannot be looked upon and in view of the
aforesaid, the present Revision Application stands dismissed.
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
CDP
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review