Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:116-DB
Serial No.01
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.26/2024
Date of CAV
:
Date of pronouncement :
17.02.2025
27.02.2025
Shri Adelbert Nongrum, Member Meghalaya Legislative Assembly, S/o (L)
Starwell Sunn, R/o Jaiaw Lansonalane, Shillong, East Khasi Hills,
Meghalaya.
….. Appellant
Vs.
The Speaker, Meghalaya Legislative Assembly.
Coram:
..... Respondent
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellant
: Mr. P. Yobin, Adv with
Ms. B. Ramsiej, Adv
For the Respondent
: Mr. A. Kumar, Advocate General with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
F
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Note: For proper public information and transparency, any media
reporting this judgment is directed to mention the
composition of the bench by name of judges, while reporting
this judgment/order.
2025:MLHC:116-DB
JUDGMENT
(Delivered by the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice)
This is an appeal by a member of the Meghalaya Legislative
Assembly (MLA) (“the appellant”). On 15th February, 2024, he presented a
Special Motion before the Speaker which was disallowed by him under Rule
130A of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business of the Legislature.
The subject-matter of the Special Motion was a part of the CAG
report on the social and economic sectors for the year ending 31st March,
2022. It deprecated an expenditure of Rs.156.14 crore made by the
government company, Meghalaya Power Distribution Corporation Limited
(MePDCL) in awarding contracts under the Saubhagya scheme. The scheme
was conceived by the Central government but its implementation was with
the State government through the project implementing agency, Saubhagya.
The fund was Central. The State government, in turn, implemented the
scheme through MePDCL a body corporate controlled by it.
By a terse letter dated 19th February, 2024, the Commissioner and
Secretary of the Assembly informed the appellant that the Special Motion
had been “disallowed” by the Speaker as it was under consideration by the
Public Accounts Committee. We do not know why in the body of the letter a
reference was made to the Chief Minister as if the information was derived
2025:MLHC:116-DB
from him. Whether the report was considered by the Public Accounts
Committee or not ought to have been within the knowledge of the Speaker.
Learned counsel for the appellant uses this reference to the Chief
Minister to attack the bonafides of the Speaker, submitting that the Speaker
was acting on the dictates of the Chief Minister.
We do not think so. It appears that quite unnecessarily, he sought
confirmation of this information from the Chief Minister which was
provided to him.
The appellant filed the instant writ petition [WP (C) No.99 of
2024] in this Court, feeling aggrieved by the decision of the Speaker
reflected in the letter dated 19th February, 2024. According to him, his
request, for the Special Motion presented by him to be tabled, ought to have
been acceded to and the Motion deliberated upon in the House. There was,
according to him an infringement of his right as member of the legislative
assembly, by the Speaker. The Court should exercise its writ jurisdiction to
compel the Speaker to table the Motion, it was contended.
The writ petition was heard extensively by a learned single judge
of this Court. Two principal grounds were made out before his lordship.
2025:MLHC:116-DB
The first was that under Article 212 of the Constitution of India,
the Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction had no jurisdiction to adjudicate
this dispute arising in the Legislative Assembly between a member of the
Meghalaya Legislative Assembly and the Speaker. Alternatively, it was
argued that there was no illegality or irregularity in the decision of the
Speaker, as the Special Motion could only be tabled after examination of it
by the Public Accounts Committee of the Assembly was completed. As such,
the alleged grievance of the writ petitioner was premature.
First, let me deal with the point of jurisdiction. Before anything
else, the question which has to be decided by this Court is whether it has
jurisdiction to decide this writ petition and the appeal connected with it.
Article 212 of the Constitution of India is based on the high constitutional
principle of separation of powers of the three organs of the governmentexecutive, legislature and judiciary and complete autonomy of the
Legislature in the conduct of its proceedings. Article 212 is in the following
terms:
“212. Courts not to inquire into proceedings of the
Legislature.–(1) The validity of any proceedings in the Legislature
of a State shall not be called in question on the ground of any
alleged irregularity of procedure.
2025:MLHC:116-DB
(2) No officer or member of the Legislature of a State in whom
powers are vested by or under this Constitution for regulating
procedure or the conduct of business, or for maintaining order, in
the Legislature shall be subject to the jurisdiction of any court in
respect of the exercise by him of those powers.”
Learned Advocate General Mr. Kumar cited a number of
authorities of the Supreme Court on the subject which I propose to discuss
now.
The first case is Ramdas Athawale (5) v. Union of India & ors
reported in (2010) 4 SCC 1, where the Supreme Court held as follows:
“30. A plain reading of Article 122 makes it abundantly clear that
the validity of any proceeding in Parliament shall not be called in
question on the ground of any irregularity of procedure. ….. The
dispute raised essentially centres around the question as to whether
the Speaker’s direction to resume sitting of the Lok Sabha which
was adjourned sine die on 23-12-2003 is proper?
31.…...Whether the resumed sitting on 29-1-2004 was to be treated
as the second part of the fourteenth session as directed by the
Speaker is essentially a matter relating purely to the procedure of
Parliament. The validity of the proceedings and business transacted
in the House after resumption of its sittings cannot be tested and
gone into by this Court in a proceeding under Article 32 of the
Constitution of India.
38. Under Article 122(2), the decision of the Speaker in whom
powers are vested to regulate the procedure and the conduct of
business is final and binding on every Member of the House. The
validity of the Speaker’s decision adjourning the House sine die on
23-12-2003 and latter direction to resume its sittings cannot be
inquired into on the ground of any irregularity of procedure. …..”
2025:MLHC:116-DB
The ratio in Ramdas was followed by the Supreme Court in Satish
Chandra v. Speaker, Lok Sabha & ors reported in (2014) 2 SCC 178 and in
State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab & anr
reported in (2024) 1 SCC 384. Learned judge ruled that the Court did not
have jurisdiction but went on to observe that there was nothing irregular in
the decision of the Speaker to reject the Special Motion. The findings are a
little contradictory in the sense that when an opinion is expressed that the
Court lacks jurisdiction, it would not embark on evaluation of the merits of
the case and come to a decision. But it may not be as incongruous as it
appears to be because of the special circumstances discussed below which
constituted the cause of action in the writ.
It is a constitutional principle of high value and vintage that the
high prerogative power of the High Court to issue writs is not intended to be
taken away by any provision of the Constitution unless such exclusionary
provision is expressly made.
Article 212 of the Constitution presupposes legal and regular
proceedings in the Legislature. If that be the case, then the procedure in
conducting the proceeding by the Speaker cannot be questioned in any Court
2025:MLHC:116-DB
of law. This is for the reason that the Legislature, under the doctrine of
separation of powers, is given the autonomy to conduct its own proceedings.
If the proceedings are unconstitutional or illegal or wholly beyond
the competence of the legislature, then the legislature steps out of the
protection of Article 212 and the High Court, in the exercise of its writ
jurisdiction, has the power to adjudge null and void the proceedings as well
as all the illegal procedures followed to implement it.
Now, if the case here was that a valid motion was not being tabled
by the Speaker, then in that case the Speaker was acting unconstitutionally
and de hors the jurisdiction and power conferred on him. The Court would
have jurisdiction to declare the act as unconstitutional and direct him to place
the Motion before the House.
In this case, the Motion is premature as the audit report under the
Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Meghalaya Legislative
Assembly has to be placed before the Committee of Public Accounts, for its
examination under Rule 241 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of
Business of the Meghalaya Legislative Assembly. It is empowered to do so
under Article 151(2) of the Constitution which says that the report of the
Comptroller and Auditor-General of India relating to the accounts of the State
2025:MLHC:116-DB
shall be submitted to the Governor who shall cause them to be laid before the
legislature of the State. It is to be read with Article 208 of the Constitution
vesting power in the legislature to make rules for regulating its procedure and
conduct of its business.
Hence, there is nothing unconstitutional or illegal in the
functioning of the Speaker which would invite interference by the Court.
Article 212 comes in the way of the Court adjudging the merits of the
procedure followed by it. Once the auditor’s report is examined by the Public
Accounts Committee, it would certainly give a fresh cause of action to the
appellant to present a new special motion, if he is so advised.
With the above observations, we affirm the impugned judgment
and order and dispose of the appeal accordingly.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
27.02.2025
“Lam DR-PS”
LAMPHRANG KHARCHANDY
Date: 2025.02.27 15:07:15
PST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review